Valles et al v. Pima County et al
Ismat Awdish, Reuben Grinstein, Armando Valles, John Harris, Basseem Challangoe, Halla Awdish, Jorge Alvarez, Hadeel Areny, TDI International Incorporated, Patricia Harris, Jane N Engs, Ramon Escoboza, Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Mark Arellano, Luke Awdish, Felicia Escoboza, Sandra Teran, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, Javier Teran, Deborah Grendahl, Stuart R Engs, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein and Lorena Arellano |
GC Enterprises GP, Manchester Development Corporation LLC, Thomas E Hosack, Roy H. Long Realty Company Incorporated, West Speedway Partners LLC, David H Mason, Unknown Parties, Martin D Collier, M.L. Parkhurst Construction LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol Incorporated, Pima, County of, GC Management, VMDC Investments Incorporated, Richard A Sack, Desert Vista Engineering LLC, Unknown Party and Albert H Gersten, II |
4:2008cv00009 |
January 3, 2008 |
US District Court for the District of Arizona |
Tucson Division Office |
Pima |
Jennifer C Guerin |
Frank R Zapata |
Civil Rights: Other |
42 U.S.C. § 1983 |
Plaintiff |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on February 10, 2015. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
Filing 310 Satisfaction of Mandate re: #303 Notice of Appeal (BAC) |
Filing 309 APPEAL DOCUMENT re: #303 Notice of Appeal. Petition for a writ of certiorari is denied. (BAC) |
Filing 308 MANDATE of USCA as to #303 Notice of Appeal, filed by Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Armando Valles, Mark Arellano, Stuart R Engs, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, Reuben Grinstein, Lorena Arellano, TDI International Incorporated, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Ismat Awdish, Sandra Teran, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl, Basseem Challangoe. AFFIRMED. (Attachments: #1 Memo, #2 NEF)(KAD) |
Filing 307 ORDER of USCA as to #303 Notice of Appeal. Petition for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc is DENIED.(BAC) |
Filing 306 Taxation Judgment in amount of $ 7,210.50 against plaintiffs. Signed by Chief Deputy Clerk Michael O'Brien on 04/18/2011. (BJW) |
Filing 305 TIME SCHEDULE ORDER of USCA as to #303 Notice of Appeal,, filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, Mark Arellano, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, Reuben Grinstein, Lorena Arellano, TDI International Incorporated, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Ismat Awdish, Sandra Teran, Jane N Engs, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl, Basseem Challangoe. (BAC) |
Filing 304 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Case Number 11-15794 for #303 Notice of Appeal. (BAC) |
Filing 303 NOTICE OF APPEAL to 9th Circuit, as to #300 Order Adopting Report and Recommendations, Terminate Motions,, by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. Filing fee received: $ 455.00, receipt number 0970-5116347. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 302 BILL OF COSTS by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1 - Subpoena Service Costs, #2 Exhibit 2 - Interpreter Costs, #3 Exhibit 3 - Deposition Costs)(Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 301 CLERK'S JUDGMENT: Magistrate Judge Guerin's Report and Recommendation (Doc. 295) is accepted and adopted. Plaintiffs' partial motion for summary judgment (Doc. 276) is denied. Pima County's motion for summary judgment (Doc. 279) is granted and this case is dismissed with prejudice. CASE CLOSED. Signed on 3/2/2011. (GCP) |
Filing 300 ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #295 Report and Recommendations. Denying Plaintiff's #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment. Granting Defendant's #279 MOTION for Summary Judgment. This case is dismissed with prejudice. The Clerk of the Court shall enter judgment and close the file in this case. Signed by Senior Judge Frank R Zapata on 3/2/2011. (GCP) |
Filing 299 REPLY TO OBJECTION to #295 Report and Recommendations filed by Pima, County of. (Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 298 OBJECTION TO REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, MarkREPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, MarkREPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, MarkREPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, Mark by Plaintiffs Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit, #2 Exhibit, #3 Appendix)(Hallinan, Joane) Modified on 2/7/2011 (KDT).INCORRECT EVENT SELECTED; THIS ENTRY HAS BEEN MODIFIED FROM OBJECTION TO OBJECTION TO REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS. |
Filing 297 ORDER granting #296 Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Dfts' #294 Motion in Limine. Pla's deadline to respond to Dft's Motion in Limine is extended to ten days following the district court's ruling on the pending Motions for Summary Judgment. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 2/1/2011. (GCP) |
Filing 296 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply to MOTION IN LIMINE by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 295 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS The Magistrate recommemds that the District Court, afer it independent review of the record, enter an order DENYING re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Reem Challangoe, Gregory Vega, Jorge Alvarez, John Harris, Javier Teran, Halla Awdish, Maxine Grinstein, Deborah Grendahl, Hadeel Areny, Stuart R Engs, Armando Valles, Mark Arellano, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, Reuben Grinstein, Lorena Arellano, TDI International Incorporated, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Ismat Awdish, Sandra Teran, Jane N Engs, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl, Basseem Challangoe, GRANTING re #279 MOTION for Summary Judgment filed by Pima, County of. Awarding judgment in favor of Pima County and directing the Clerk of the Court to close the file in this matter. ***SEE ATTACHED PDF ORDER FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.***. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 1/20/2011. (KDT) |
Filing 294 MOTION in Limine re: Scope of Expert Steven Magelli's Testimony by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit Exhibit 2)(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 293 STATEMENT of REPLY to Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment re #292 Reply to Response to Motion,, by Plaintiffs Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 292 REPLY to Response to Motion re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 291 ORDER granting #289 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages; granting #290 Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply re #290 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply. Plaintiff's shall file their Reply on or before 12/1/2010.. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 11/30/2010.(KDT) |
Filing 290 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 289 MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages to Reply to Response to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 288 REPLY to Response to Motion re #279 MOTION for Summary Judgment filed by Pima, County of. (Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 287 RESPONSE re #277 Statement,,, of Facts in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment by Defendant Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit TOC, Exhibits 1-19)(Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 286 RESPONSE to Motion re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Pima, County of. (Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 285 AFFIDAVIT in Support re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment IN SUPPORT OF OUR RESPONSE TO COUNTY'S MSJ filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit, #2 Exhibit, #3 Exhibit, #4 Exhibit, #5 Exhibit, #6 Exhibit, #7 Exhibit, #8 Exhibit, #9 Exhibit, #10 Exhibit, #11 Exhibit, #12 Exhibit, #13 Exhibit, #14 Exhibit, #15 Exhibit, #16 Exhibit, #17 Exhibit, #18 Exhibit, #19 Exhibit, #20 Exhibit, #21 Appendix)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 284 RESPONSE to Motion re #279 MOTION for Summary Judgment, #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 283 ORDER granting #281 Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages. IT IS ORDERED that Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment and Plaintiff's Resppnse thereto may exceed the 17-page limit; the parties briefs shall not exceed 30 pages in length.. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 10/21/2010.(KDT) |
Filing 282 NOTICE of Appearance by Andrew Lawrence Flagg on behalf of Pima, County of (Flagg, Andrew) |
Filing 281 MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages for Motion for Summary Judgment by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 280 STATEMENT of of Facts in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment re #279 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Defendant Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 279 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Index, Exhibits 1 -10, #2 Exhibit Exhibits 11-13, #3 Exhibit Exhibits 14-20, #4 Exhibit Exhibits 21-30, #5 Exhibit Exhibits 31-43)(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 278 LODGED Proposed Order Re: Motion for Partial Summary Judgment re: #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or Amend is granted. Filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 277 STATEMENT of Separate Statement of Facts re #276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment by Plaintiffs Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D, #5 Exhibit E, #6 Exhibit F, #7 Exhibit G, #8 Exhibit H, #9 Exhibit I, #10 Exhibit J, #11 Exhibit K, #12 Exhibit L, #13 Exhibit M, #14 Exhibit N, #15 Exhibit O, #16 Exhibit P)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 276 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies Incorporated, TDI International Incorporated, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) Modified on 10/18/2010 NOT TEXT SEARCHABLE (KDT). |
Filing 274 ORDER granting #273 Stipulation ; Dispositive motions shall be filed on or before 10/18/2010; Proposed Joint Pretrial Order on or before 11/18/2010.. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 8/9/2010. (JKM) |
Filing 275 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin: Status Conference held on 8/9/2010. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(BHA) |
Filing 273 STIPULATION by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 272 Upon the telephonic request of the parties, IT IS ORDERED setting a status conference for 8/9/2010 at 03:00 PM in Courtroom 3C, 405 West Congress Street, Tucson, AZ 85701 before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Parties are to appear in person. Ordered by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. (JCG)(This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.) |
Filing 271 Notice re Service by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega 9th Supplemental Disclosure Statement (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 270 STATUS REPORT JOINT SETTLEMENT by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, Pima, County of, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 269 NOTICE of Deposition of Tim McCann, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 268 Notice re Service by Pima, County of Notice of Service of Defendant Pima County's Fifth Supplemental Disclosure Statement (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 267 NOTICE of Deposition of Tim Robertson, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 266 NOTICE of Deposition of Ismat and Halla Awdish, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 265 SUPPLEMENT of Supplemental Notice of Non-Party at Fault Supplemental Notice of Non-Party at Fault by Defendant Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 264 NOTICE of Deposition of Herb Sudduth, filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 263 ORDER granting #262 Motion for Extension of Time of Discovery Deadlines. Discovery due by 7/9/2010. Dispositive motions due by 8/9/2010. Proposed Pretrial Order due by 9/9/2010.. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 6/8/2010.(KDT) |
Filing 262 Joint MOTION for Extension of Time Discovery Deadlines by Pima, County of. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order Order re Extension of Discovery Deadlines)(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 261 NOTICE of Deposition of Hadeel Areny, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 260 NOTICE of Deposition of John and Patricia Harris, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 259 NOTICE of Deposition of Gregory Vega, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 258 NOTICE OF WAIVER OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE by L Anthony Fines and William G Walker, counsel for Defendants Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, David H. Mason, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC (Walker, William) |
Filing 257 NOTICE of Deposition of Carmine DeBonis, filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 256 NOTICE of Deposition of Stuart Engs and Jane Engs, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 255 NOTICE of Deposition of Reuben Grinstein and Maxine Grinstein, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 254 NOTICE of Deposition of Basseem Challangoe and Reem Challangoe, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 253 NOTICE of Deposition of Sandra Teran and Javier Teran, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 252 NOTICE of Deposition of James Mitchell, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 251 NOTICE of Deposition of Charles Huckleberry, filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 250 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 249 ORDER granting #235 Motion to Quash. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/13/10.(SMBE) |
Filing 248 Notice re Notice of Service of Defendant Pima County's Fourth Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Pima, County of Pima (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 247 Notice re Notice of Service by Pima, County of Defendant Pima County's Second Supplemental Response to Plaintiff's First Request for Production (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 246 RESPONSE to Motion re #235 Proposed MOTION to Quash Subpeona of Armando Valles filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 245 NOTICE of Deposition of Armando Valles, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 244 NOTICE of Deposition of Karen DeJean, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 243 NOTICE of Deposition of Marvin and Deborah Grendahl, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 242 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of James Mitchell (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 241 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of Ramon and Felicia Escoboza (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 240 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of Armando Valles (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 239 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of Jorge Alvarez (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 238 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Pima, County of Mark and Lorena Arellano (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 237 NOTICE of Deposition of Deborah Marchbanks, filed by All Plaintiffs. (Ganson, Norris) |
Filing 236 Notice re ERRATA by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega re #235 Proposed MOTION to Quash Subpeona of Armando Valles NOTICE OF ERRATA (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 235 Proposed MOTION to Quash Subpeona of Armando Valles by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 234 Notice re of Service by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega 8th Supplemental Disclosure Statement (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 233 NOTICE of Deposition of James Mitchell, filed by Pima, County of. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 232 ORDER denying #205 Motion to Strike. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 4/27/2010.(JKM) |
Filing 231 NOTICE of Deposition of James Mitchell, filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 230 NOTICE of Deposition of Jorge Alvarez, filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 229 NOTICE of Deposition of Mark and Lorena Arellano, filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 228 NOTICE of Deposition of Armando Valles, filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 227 NOTICE of Deposition of Ramon and Felicia Escoboza, filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 226 Notice re Service by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega 7th Supplemental Disclosure Statement (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 225 Notice re Service by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 224 STATUS REPORT JOINT SETTLEMENT by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, Pima County, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 223 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Third Disclosure Statement Re: Expert Witnesses by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 222 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Supplemental Responses to Pltf's Request for Production by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 221 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Supplemental Responses to Pltf's Request for Non-Uniform Interrogatories by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 220 Notice re Notice of Service of Plaintiffs' 5th Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega by Joane Hallinan, Esq. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 219 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Responses to Plaintiffs' Request for Non-Uniform Interrogatories by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 218 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Response to Plaintiffs' Request for Production by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 216 Notice re of Service of Pima County's Responses to Plaintiffs' Request for Admissions by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 217 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin: Status Conference held on 3/15/2010. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(JKM) |
Filing 215 IT IS ORDERED setting a status conference on discovery issues for 3/15/2010 at 09:40 AM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Parties to appear telephonically with the court initiating the call. Ordered by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. (JCG)(This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no PDF document associated with this entry.) |
Filing 214 Notice re of Service of Plaintiffs' 4th Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 213 Notice re of Service of Pima County's 2nd Supplement Disclosure Statement by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 212 REPLY to Response to Motion re #205 MOTION to Strike re Motion To Strike Notice of Non-Party at Fault filed by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 211 RESPONSE in Opposition re #205 MOTION to Strike re Motion To Strike Notice of Non-Party at Fault filed by Pima County. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit A-1, #3 Exhibit A-2, #4 Exhibit B, #5 Exhibit C)(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 210 Notice re Notice of Service of 3rd Supplemental Disclosure by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 209 Notice re Notice of Service of 1st RFP by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 208 Notice re NOtice of Service of 1st RFA by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 207 Notice re Notice of Service of 1st NUI by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 206 NOTICE of Change of Address by Joane E Hallinan (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 205 MOTION to Strike re Motion To Strike Notice of Non-Party at Fault by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 204 Notice re Notice of Errata by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 203 Notice re Notice of Service of Responses to RFA by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 202 Notice re Notice of Service of NUI by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 201 Notice re Notice of Service of RFP by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 200 Notice re of Non-Party at Fault by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 199 Notice re Notice of Service of 2nd Supplemental Disclosure by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 198 Notice re of Service of Pima County's First Supp. Disclosure Statement by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 197 Notice re of Service of 2nd Set of Interrogatories by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 196 Notice re of Service of 1st Req. for Admissions by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 195 Notice re of Service of 2nd Request for Production by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 194 ORDER granting #193 Motion for Extension of Time to Extend Expert Witness Disclosure Deadlines. ***********SEE ATTACHED PDF FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION.*****. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 12/23/09.(KDT, ) |
Filing 193 MOTION for Extension of Time Extension of Time by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega. (Attachments: #1 Proposed Order Re: Stipulated Motion to Extend Expert Witness Deadline)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 192 Notice re Notice of Service of 1st Supplemental Disclosure Statement by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 191 Notice re Notice of Service of Response to Request for Production by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 190 Notice re Notice of Service of Response to Interrogatories by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 189 Notice re Service of Pima County's First Interrogatories to Plaintiffs by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 188 Notice re of Pima County's First Request for Production by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 187 Notice re Notice of Service of Initial Disclosure by Jorge Alvarez, Lorena Arellano, Mark Arellano, Hadeel Areny, Halla Awdish, Ismat Awdish, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Jane N Engs, Stuart R Engs, Felicia Escoboza, Ramon Escoboza, Deborah Grendahl, Marvin Grendahl, Maxine Grinstein, Reuben Grinstein, John Harris, Patricia Harris, T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., TDI International, Inc., Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, Armando Valles, Gregory Vega (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 186 SCHEDULING ORDER: Discovery due by 6/9/2010. Dispositive motions due by 7/9/2010. Proposed Pretrial Order due by 8/9/2010. Joint Settlement Status Report due by 1/8/2010 and every 90 days thereafter. **SEE ATTACHED PDF FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION**. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 9/16/09. (LSI, ) |
Filing 185 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin: Scheduling Conference held on 9/9/2009. FORMAL ORDER TO FOLLOW. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(BHA, ) |
Filing 184 ORDERED: Scheduling Conference set for 9/9/2009 02:00 PM in Courtroom 3C, 405 West Congress Street, Tucson, AZ 85701 before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 8/19/09. (JEMB, ) |
Filing 183 CLERK'S JUDGMENT: Dfts motions to dismiss [149, 137, 151] are granted. Dfts Parkhurst, Sack, Long Realty, and Mason are dismissed from this action without prejudice. Report & Recommendation #172 as to dfts Hosack and Desert Vista Engineering is accepted and adopted. As such, dfts Hosack and Desert Vista Engineering are dismissed from this action without prejudice. Motion for summary judgment #152 is denied as moot. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 7/28/09. (BAC, ) |
Filing 182 ORDER: Report & Recommendation as to dfts Parkhurst, Mason, Sack, and Long Realty #173 is accepted and adopted; dfts motions to dismiss [149, 137, 151] are granted. Dfts Parkhurst, Sack, Long Realty, and Mason are dismissed without prejudice & Clerk of the Court shall enter judgment accordingly. Report & Recommendation #172 is accepted and adopted and dfts and Hosack and Desert Vista Engineering are dismissed without prejudice; Clerk of the Court shall enter judgment accordingly. Motion for summary judgment #152 is denied as moot. This case referred back to Magistrate Judge Guerin for all pretrial proceedings & report and recommendation. All future filings in this case shall be designated: CV 08-9-TUC-FRZ(JCG). Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 7/28/09.(BAC, ) |
Filing 181 NOTICE of Appearance by Norris L Ganson on behalf of all plaintiffs (Ganson, Norris) |
Filing 180 OBJECTION to #172 Report and Recommendations filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 179 OBJECTION by Defendant M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Baldwin, Howard) DOCUMENT NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH LRCiv 7.1(c), ATTORNEY NOTICED. Modified on 6/1/2009 (SSU, ). |
Filing 178 OBJECTION to #173 Report and Recommendations filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 177 OBJECTION to #173 Report and Recommendations filed by David Mason. (Fines, L) Modified on 5/29/2009 (DNO, TO CORRECT FILER). |
Filing 176 ORDER denying #156 Motion for Hearing on Motion; denying #158 Motion for Hearing on Motion. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/8/09.(KMF, ) |
Filing 175 ORDER granting #174 Motion to Continue, all parties objections to R&R & Amended R&R due 5/29/09. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 5/8/09.(KMF, ) |
Filing 174 MOTION to Continue Deadlines for Objections to Report & Recommendation and Amended Report & Recommendation by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Pima County, Gregory Vega, David H. Mason, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 173 AMENDED REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION of #171 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION re #151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason, #149 MOTION to Dismiss Party M. L. Parkhurst Construction, L.L.C., #137 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction Non-Compliance. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/7/09. (KMF, ) |
Filing 172 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION re #152 Third Party MOTION for Summary Judgment on All Counts : Recommend granting; written objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/6/09. (KMF, ) |
Filing 171 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION re #151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason, #149 MOTION to Dismiss Party M. L. Parkhurst Construction, L.L.C., #137 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction Non-Compliance with Rule 9 (b) : Recommend granting motions; written objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/6/06. (KMF, ) |
Filing 170 Notice re Updated Supplemental Authority by David H. Mason re #169 Other Notice (Fines, L) |
Filing 169 Notice re Supplemental Authority by David H. Mason re #151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason (Fines, L) |
Filing 168 STATEMENT of Controverting Statemetn as to Defendants Supplement Statement of Facts re #167 Statement by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 167 STATEMENT of Statement of Facts by Defendants Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC. (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 166 REPLY to Response to Motion re #152 Third Party MOTION for Summary Judgment on All Counts filed by Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC. (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 165 REPLY in Support re #151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason filed by David H. Mason. (Fines, L) |
Filing 164 RESPONSE re #153 MOTION for Summary Judgment Supporting Statement of Facts by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 163 RESPONSE in Opposition re #152 Third Party MOTION for Summary Judgment on All Counts filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 162 SUPPLEMENT of Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant Mason's Motion to Dismiss 3rd Amended Complaint re #160 Response to Motion,, by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 161 REPLY to Response to Motion re #149 MOTION to Dismiss Party M. L. Parkhurst Construction, L.L.C. filed by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 160 RESPONSE to Motion re #151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 159 REPLY to Response to Motion re #137 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction Non-Compliance with Rule 9 (b) filed by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 158 MOTION for Hearing on Motion re Motion for Summary Judgment by Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC. (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 157 RESPONSE in Opposition re #149 MOTION to Dismiss Party M. L. Parkhurst Construction, L.L.C. filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 156 MOTION for Hearing on Motion re Motion to dismiss Request for Oral Argument on Motion to Dismiss by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 155 MOTION re: Request for Oral Argument on Motion to Dismiss Complaint by Defendant David H. Mason. (Fines, L) Modified EVENT on 1/7/2009 FROM REQUEST TO MTN FOR HRG ON MTN (KMF, ). |
Filing 154 ORDER all previously entered pretrial ddls stayed pending resolution of pending motions. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 12/5/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 153 Statement of facts in support of MOTION for Summary Judgment Supporting Statement of Facts by Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC. (Eckel, Neal) Modified on 1/14/2009 INCORRECT EVENT SELECTED. This entry has been modified from Motion to Statement(PAB, ). |
Filing 152 Third Party MOTION for Summary Judgment on All Counts by Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC. (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 151 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction, MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason by David H. Mason. (Fines, L) |
Filing 150 ANSWER to #136 Amended Complaint,, by Pima County.(Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 149 MOTION to Dismiss Party M. L. Parkhurst Construction, L.L.C. by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit, #2 Exhibit)(Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 148 ANSWER to #136 Amended Complaint,, by Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC.(Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 147 RESPONSE to Motion re #137 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction Non-Compliance with Rule 9 (b) filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 146 ORDER pursuant to #140 Stipulation For Extension of Time To Answer Complaint : Thomas E. Hosack & Desert Vista Engineering, LLC answer due 11/28/2008. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 11/18/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 145 ORDER pursuant to #143 Stipulation For Extension of Time To Answer Third Amended Complaint : David H. Mason answer due 11/28/2008. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 11/18/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 144 ERRATA to document 139 by Defendant M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 143 STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT re #136 Amended Complaint,, by David H. Mason. (Fines, L) |
Filing 142 ORDER pursuant to #139 Stipulation, M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC answer to Third Amended Complaint due 11/28/2008. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 11/12/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 141 ORDER pursuant to #138 Stipulation For Extension of Time To Answer Third Amended Complaint, Pima County answer due 11/28/2008. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 11/12/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 140 STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT by Thomas E. Hosack. (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 139 STIPULATION by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC. (Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 138 STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT (THIRD AMENDED) by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 137 MOTION to Dismiss Case for Lack of Jurisdiction Non-Compliance with Rule 9 (b) by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 136 AMENDED COMPLAINT (3RD) against all defendants;Jury Demand, filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D, #5 Exhibit E, #6 Exhibit F, #7 Exhibit G, #8 Exhibit H, #9 Exhibit I, #10 Exhibit J)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 135 ORDER granting #134 Motion for Extension of Time, all ddls re order #133 continued for 40 days. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 9/17/08.(KMF, ) |
Filing 134 MOTION for Extension of Time of all deadlines for forty (40) days (Partial Stipulation) by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Pima County, Gregory Vega, M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC, Javier Teran, Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc., Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 133 ORDER finding as moot #52 Motion to Dismiss Case; finding as moot #67 Motion to Dismiss Party; finding as moot #97 Report and Recommendations; finding as moot #98 Report and Recommendations; finding as moot #112 Motion to Dismiss Party. FURTHER ORDERED Pla's have leave to file Third Amended Complaint by 9/19/08; Dft's shall file any new motions to dismiss no later than 10/6/08; Responses to motions to dismiss are due 15 days from the filing of the motions; Replies to responses are due 10 days from the filing of the responses. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 9/8/08.**SEE ATTACHED PDF FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION**(JEMB, ) |
Filing 132 REPLY to Response to Motion re #112 MOTION to Dismiss Party Richard Sack and Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. For Lack of Jurisdiction filed by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 131 JUDGMENT on Attorney Fees of $5482 & costs of $215 in favor of Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC against Armando Valles, et al. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 8/29/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 130 ORDER adopting Report and Recommendations re #90 & #101 granting #66 Motion to Dismiss Case; granting #69 Motion for Sanctions; West & the Villas are dismissed w/o prejudice & are awarded $5482 in attys' fees & $215 in costs; Clk Crt to enter jgm. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 8/29/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 129 RESPONSE in Opposition re #112 MOTION to Dismiss Party Richard Sack and Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. For Lack of Jurisdiction filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 128 ORDER pursuant to #125 Stipulation : all pending pretrial ddls stayed until R&R #97 ruling. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 8/8/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 127 Second AMENDED COMPLAINT against Pima County, David H. Mason, M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC, Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc., Jury Demand, filed by Armando Valles, et al. Party Company C; Company D; Company E; Jane Does; John Does; GC Enterprises GP; Albert H. Gersten, II; Manchester Development Corporation, LLC; VMDC Investments, Inc.; Martin D Collier and Company B terminated.(KMF, ) Modified date on 8/11/2008 (KMF, ). |
Filing 126 ORDER granting #119 Motion to file second amended complaint, Clk Crt to file lodged doc #120 . Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 8/8/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 125 STIPULATION TO STAY PENDING PRETRIAL DEADLINES by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 124 ORDER, pursuant to #123 Stipulation, all pending ddls stayed until R&R ruling. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 8/6/08. See attached pdf for complete information(KMF, ) |
Filing 123 STIPULATION to Stay Pending Pretrial Deadlines by West Speedway Partners, LLC, David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Walker, William) |
Filing 122 Notice re Service of Plaintiffs' Initial Disclosure Statement by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 121 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl re #120 Lodged Proposed Document,, #119 MOTION to Amend/Correct re Amended Complaint with proposed 2nd Amended Complaint compared to Amended Complaint attached (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 120 LODGED Proposed 2nd Amended Complaint re: #119 MOTION to Amend/Correct re Amended Complaint with proposed 2nd Amended Complaint compared to Amended Complaint attached. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or Amend is granted. Filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 119 MOTION to Amend/Correct re Amended Complaint with proposed 2nd Amended Complaint compared to Amended Complaint attached by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 118 Notice re Filing Initial Disclosure Statement by Thomas E. Hosack (Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 117 Notice re service of initial disclosure by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC (Baldwin, Howard) |
Filing 116 Notice re Initial Disclosure by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 115 RESPONSE re #111 Objection to Report and Recommendations,, by Defendants David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC. (Fines, L) |
Filing 114 RESPONSE to Motion re #97 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Pima CountyREPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Pima County Response to Plaintiff's Objection filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 113 ORDER 5/29/08 subpoena to CIC quashed; granting #95 CIC's obj to subpoena; denying as moot #94 Motion to modify. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 7/17/08.(KMF, ) |
Filing 112 MOTION to Dismiss Party Richard Sack and Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. For Lack of Jurisdiction by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 111 OBJECTION to #98 Report and Recommendations Re: Defendants Mason and Manchester filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 110 NOTICE of Appearance by Joane E Hallinan on behalf of all plaintiffs (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 109 Notice re Errata by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl re #106 Objection to Report and Recommendations, (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 108 ORDER written ojections to Court presiding over the case due 7/16/08. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 7/7/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 107 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #106 Objection to Report and Recommendations, Certificate of Mailing of Objection to Hon. Frank R. Zapata by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 106 OBJECTION to #97 Report and Recommendations filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 105 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #104 Response in Opposition to Motion,, Certificate of Mailing to Capitol Indemnity by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 104 RESPONSE in Opposition re #94 MOTION for to Modify Plaintiff's Subpoena Re Extending Deadline to Respond filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 102 SCHEDULING ORDER: Discovery due by 12/30/2008. Dispositive motions due by 1/23/2009. Joint Proposed Pretrial Order due by 2/24/2009. Joint Settlement Status Report due by 9/24/2008 & every 90 days thereafter. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/25/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 101 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #99 Stipulation of attys' fees & costs; written objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/25/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 100 STIPULATION re #99 Stipulation Proposed Order by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Fines, L) |
Filing 103 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C. Guerin: Scheduling Conference held on 6/24/2008. Formal Scheduling Order to follow. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(SSG) |
Filing 99 STIPULATION re #93 Order, for Attorneys' Fees by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Fines, L) |
Filing 98 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #67 MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason and Manchester Development; objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/24/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 97 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Pima County; written objections due w/in 10 days using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/24/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 96 RESPONSE re #90 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC, #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLCREPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC, #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A & B)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 95 OBJECTION to Subpoena by Objector Capitol Indemnity Corporation. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1)(Mann, Jay) |
Filing 94 MOTION for to Modify Plaintiff's Subpoena Re Extending Deadline to Respond by Capitol Indemnity Corporation. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1-2)(Mann, Jay) |
Filing 93 ORDER re #90 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs & #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC; Ordered West & the Villas to file request for attys' fees w/in 14 days of the date of this order; West & the Villas are excused from participation in the scheduling conference set for 6/24/08. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/10/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 92 Notice re of Errata by David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC re #91 Reply in Support of Motion (Fines, L) |
Filing 91 REPLY in Support re #67 MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason and Manchester Development filed by David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC. (Fines, L) |
Filing 90 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs & #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC; written objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-FRZ. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 6/6/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 89 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin: taking under advisement #52 Motion to Dismiss Case; Motion Hearing held on 6/5/2008 re #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Pima County. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(BHA, ) |
Filing 88 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin: taking under advisement #66 Motion to Dismiss Case; taking under advisement #69 Motion for Sanctions; Motion Hearing held on 6/5/2008 re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC, #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, West Speedway Partners, LLC. (Court Reporter COURTSMART.)(BHA, ) |
Filing 87 NOTICE of Appearance by Thomas Weaver, Jr on behalf of Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 86 RESPONSE to Motion re #67 MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason and Manchester Development filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A-B, #2 Exhibit C-G)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 85 ORDER, Hearing set as to #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case : Motion Hearing set for 6/5/2008 at 04:00PM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/15/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 84 ORDER, Hearing set on #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs, #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case : Motion Hearing set for 6/5/2008 at 03:00PM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/14/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 83 Notice re Compliance with Order dated May 9, 2008 by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl re #78 Order, (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 82 REPLY to Response to Motion re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs filed by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Fines, L) |
Filing 81 REPLY to Response to Motion re #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Fines, L) |
Filing 80 ORDER granting #58 Motion to Produce. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/8/08.(KMF, ) |
Filing 79 ORDER re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. & #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc.: Motion Hearing set for 5/28/2008 at 03:30PM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/8/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 78 ORDER plas provide courtesy copies of amended cmp & all responses to dfts' motions to dismiss to Judge Guerin's Chambers w/in 5 days; parties to comply w/ Local Rules. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/8/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 77 ORDER SETTING SCHEDULING CONFERENCE: Scheduling conference set for 6/24/08 at 3:30 pm before Magistrate Judge Guerin. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 5/8/08. (KMF, ) Modified on 5/19/2008 (BAR, to change text from scheduling order to order setting scheduling conference). |
Filing 76 NOTICE of Appearance by William G Walker on behalf of West Speedway Partners, LLC, David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc (Walker, William) |
Filing 75 RESPONSE in Opposition re #69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 74 STATEMENT of Facts in support of Plaintiffs' Response to Motion to Dismiss filed by WSP and Villas re #73 Response in Opposition to Motion,, #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 73 RESPONSE in Opposition re #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B (part I), #3 Exhibit B (part II), #4 Exhibit C, #5 Exhibit D)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 72 REPLY to Response to Motion re #66 MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Pima County. (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 71 Notice re Association of Counsel by David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC (Walker, William) |
Filing 70 STATUS REPORT pursuant to the Courts Order dated April 17, 2008 by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 69 MOTION for Sanctions against Plaintiffs by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Fines, L) |
Filing 68 Notice re Notice of Association of Counsel by Pima County (Weaver, Thomas) |
Filing 67 MOTION to Dismiss Party Mason and Manchester Development by David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC. (Fines, L) |
Filing 66 MOTION to Dismiss Case by West Speedway Partners, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit to Motion to Dismiss)(Fines, L) |
Filing 65 Defendants Hosack and Desert Vista Engineering's ANSWER to #33 Amended Complaint, by Thomas E. Hosack.(Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 64 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #33 Amended Complaint, Affidavit of Service upon Defendant Albert Gersten, II by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A & B)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 63 ORDER re #53 Motion to Continue; 4/25/08 scheduling conference vacated; 4/18/08 joint rpt ddl vacated; plas to file rpt w/in 20 days of the filing date of this order; dft objections to the rpt due w/in 10 days of the date rpt is filed. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 4/17/08. See attached pdf for complete information. (KMF, ) |
Filing 62 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #58 MOTION to Produce Documents and 30(b)(6) Deposition of Capitol Indemnity Corporation MOTION to Produce Documents and 30(b)(6) Deposition of Capitol Indemnity Corporation MOTION to Produce Documents and 30(b)(6) Deposition of Capitol Indemnity Corporation Exhibit A to Motion to Produce Documents by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 61 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #33 Amended Complaint, Affidavit of Service of Amended Complaint on Defendant GC Enterprises by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A & B)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 60 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #33 Amended Complaint, Affidavit of Service of Amended Complaint on Defendant VMDC Investments by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A & B)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 59 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #33 Amended Complaint, Affidavit of Service of Amended Complaint on Defendant Martin D. Collier by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A & B)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 58 MOTION to Produce Documents and 30(b)(6) Deposition of Capitol Indemnity Corporation by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order Re: Plaintiff's Motion for Subpoena & 30(b)(6) Deposition)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 57 RESPONSE in Opposition re #52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 56 NOTICE of Attorney Substitution adding Lesley Maura Lukach for Pima County (Lukach, Lesley) Modified on 4/10/2008 to delete duplicate attorney name(BJW, ). |
Filing 55 ANSWER to #33 Amended Complaint, by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC.(KMF, ) |
Filing 54 Lodged Proposed Document re #53 Joint MOTION to Continue the Scheduling Conference currently calendared for April 25, 2008 Proposed Order regarding the Motion to Continue the Scheduling Conference by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl, Defendants Pima County, West Speedway Partners, LLC, David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC, Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 53 Joint MOTION to Continue the Scheduling Conference currently calendared for April 25, 2008 by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Pima County, West Speedway Partners, LLC, Gregory Vega, David H. Mason, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc, M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC, Javier Teran, Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc., Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 52 First MOTION to Dismiss Case by Pima County. (Attachments: #1 Appendix, #2 Exhibit Exhibit 1, #3 Exhibit Exhibit 2, #4 Exhibit Exhibit 3, #5 Exhibit Exhibit 4, #6 Exhibit Exhibit 5)(McDonald, Scott) |
Filing 51 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC served on 3/30/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 50 ORDER Scheduling Conference set for 4/25/2008 09:00 AM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin in her courtroom. (Time & location change.) Joint rpt due 5 business days prior to scheduling conference. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 4/1/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 49 Defendants Thomas Hosack and Desert Vista Engineering's ANSWER to #1 Complaint,,,, by Thomas E. Hosack.(Eckel, Neal) |
Filing 48 ANSWER to #33 Amended Complaint, Defendants by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc..(Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 47 Additional Attachments to Main Document Plaintiff's Request for Clarification by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 46 REQUEST re: Plaintiffs' Request for Clarification by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 42 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. Thomas E. Hosack served on 3/20/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 41 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. Manchester Development Corporation, LLC served on 3/20/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 40 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. Desert Vista Engineering, LLC served on 3/20/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 39 Letter from Loren Bates; Re; Long Realty not being listed on records of the Az Corporation Commission (LMF, ) |
Filing 44 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. David H. Mason served on 3/20/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 45 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. Pima County served on 3/14/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 43 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. Richard A Sack served on 3/14/2008. (CKM, ) |
Filing 38 Party Elects Assignment of Case to District Judge Jurisdiction (LMF, ) |
Filing 37 ORDER referred back to Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin for all pretrial proceedings and Report and Recommendation. Signed by Judge Frank R Zapata on 3/18/08. (LSI, ) |
Filing 36 Minute Order Judge Frank R Zapata added. Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin no longer assigned to case. (LMF, ) |
Filing 35 Party Elects Assignment of Case to District Judge Jurisdiction (LMF, ) |
Filing 34 ORDER adopting Report and Recommendations #29 ; granting plas' request for voluntary dismissal of dfts West Speedway Partners, LLC & The Villas at Hacienda del Sol, Inc #20 , these dfts dismissed w/o prejudice from this action. Signed by Judge David C Bury on 3/13/08.(KMF, ) |
Filing 33 AMENDED COMPLAINT Declaratory releif; gross negligence; violation of due process; promissory estoppel; breach of contract; misrepresentation; fraudulent conveyance; negligence against defendants Pima County et al; Jury Demand, filed by Armando Valles et al(KMF, ) |
Filing 32 ORDER granting #26 Motion for leave to file amended cmp; Clk Crt to file LODGED Proposed Amended Complaint; plas to serve dfts w/ amended cmp. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 3/11/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 31 ORDER Telephonic Scheduling Conference set for 4/25/2008 10:00 AM before Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin's law clerk. Joint rpt due NLT 5 business days bfr the scheduling conference. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 3/7/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 30 ANSWER to #1 Complaint,,,, by Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc..(Aldridge, Lyle) |
Filing 29 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re #20 request for voluntary dismissal of #1 Complaint; written objections due w/in 10 days, using 08cv9-TUC-DCB. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 2/25/08. See attached pdf for complete information(KMF, ) |
Filing 28 ORDER granting #23 STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT, Richard A Sack answer due 3/4/2008; Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. answer due 3/4/2008. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jennifer C Guerin on 2/25/08. (KMF, ) |
Filing 27 LODGED Proposed Order Re: MTN to Amend. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or Amend is granted. Filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 26 LODGED Proposed Amended Complaint. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or Amend is granted. Filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Proposed Amended Complaint)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 24 Corporate Disclosure Statement by Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Rollman, Richard) |
Filing 23 STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc., Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order to Extend Time for Answer by Defendants Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. and Richard A. Sack)(Rollman, Richard) |
Filing 22 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #1 Complaint,,,, Verification of Complaint by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 21 LODGED Proposed Order regarding Voluntary Dismissal Without Prejudice. Document to be filed by Clerk if Motion to Leave to File or Amend is granted. Filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 20 REQUEST re: Voluntary Dismissal without prejudice as to Defendants West Speedway Partners and the Villas at Hacienda Del Sol by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 25 ANSWER to #1 Complaint by M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC.(KMF, ) |
Filing 18 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. West Speedway Partners, LLC served on 1/13/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 17 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Manchester Development Corporation, LLC served on 1/13/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 16 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. David H. Mason served on 1/13/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 15 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Thomas E. Hosack served on 1/12/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 14 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #3 Summons Issued,,, Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint on VMDC by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 13 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #3 Summons Issued,,, Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint on Martin D. Collier by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 12 AFFIDAVIT of Jo Lynn Clapperton re #3 Summons Issued,,, Affidavit of Service of Summons and Complaint on Albert Gersten, II by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 11 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc. served on 1/9/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 10 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc served on 1/10/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 9 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Desert Vista Engineering, LLC served on 1/10/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 8 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #2 Additional Attachments to Main Document,, #5 Additional Attachments to Main Document,, #1 Complaint,,,, Verification of Complaint by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 19 Agreement to Magistrate Judge Jurisdiction. Party agrees to Magistrate Judge Jurisdiction. (LSI, ) |
Filing 7 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC served on 1/9/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 6 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Armando Valles. Richard A Sack served on 1/9/2008. (KMF, ) |
Filing 5 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #1 Complaint,,,, Verifications of Complaint by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart R Engs, Jane N Engs, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Verification of Complaint, #2 Verification of Complaint, #3 Verification of Complaint, #4 Verification of Complaint, #5 Verification of Complaint, #6 Verification of Complaint)(Hallinan, Joane) |
Filing 4 SUMMONS Returned Executed by Plaintiffs. Pima County served on 1/9/2008. (LSI, ) |
Magistrate Election Form Deadline (TO BE MAILED) (LMF, ) |
Filing 3 Summons Issued as to Pima County, West Speedway Partners, LLC, Martin D Collier, David H. Mason, Albert H. Gersten, II, Manchester Development Corporation, LLC, VMDC Investments, Inc., The Villas at Hacienda Del Sol, Inc., M.L. Parkhurst Construction, LLC, Thomas E. Hosack, Desert Vista Engineering, LLC, GC Enterprises GP, Richard A Sack, Roy H. Long Realty Company, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Summons, #2 Summons, #3 Summons, #4 Summons, #5 Summons, #6 Summons, #7 Summons, #8 Summons, #9 Summons, #10 Summons, #11 Summons, #12 Summons, #13 Summons)(JEMB, ). *** IMPORTANT: You must select "Document and stamps" or "Document and comments" on the print screen in order for the court seal to appear on the summons you print. |
Filing 2 Additional Attachments to Main Document re #1 Complaint,,,, Verification of Complaint by Plaintiffs Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart Engs, Jane Eng, Stuart R. and Jane N. Engs Family Trust, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Hadeel Areny Trust, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Hallinan, Joane) |
This case has been assigned to the Honorable Jennifer C. Guerin. All future pleadings or documents should bear the correct case number: CV-08-9-TUC-JCG. (JEMB, ) |
Filing 1 COMPLAINT. Filing fee received: $ 350.00, receipt number 09700000000001639931, filed by Deborah Grendahl, Reuben Grinstein, Maxine Grinstein, Ramon Escoboza, Felicia Escoboza, Stuart Engs, Jane Eng, Basseem Challangoe, Reem Challangoe, Armando Valles, Hadeel Areny, Jorge Alvarez, Mark Arellano, Lorena Arellano, Ismat Awdish, Halla Awdish, Gregory Vega, Javier Teran, Sandra Teran, TDI International, Inc., T.F. Robertson Companies, Inc., John Harris, Patricia Harris, Marvin Grendahl. (Attachments: #1 Civil Cover Sheet, #2 Summons Collier, #3 Summons Hosack, #4 Summons Long, #5 Summons Manchester, #6 Summons Mason, #7 Summons Parkhurst, #8 Summons Pima County, #9 Summons Gersten, #10 Summons GC Enterprises, #11 Summons Sack, #12 Summons Desert Vista, #13 Summons Villas, #14 Summons VMDC, #15 Summons WSP, #16 Exhibit A - Final Plat, #17 Exhibit B - Initial Assurances, #18 Exhibit C - Public Report, #19 Exhibit D - Sub. Assurances, #20 Exhibit E - Purchase Contract, #21 Exhibit F - Performance Bond, #22 Exhibit G - Affidavit of Jim Mitchell, #23 Exhibit H - Request to draw on Bond)(Hallinan, Joane) Modified on 1/7/2008 to delete improperly names parties(PAB, ). |
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the Arizona District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.