Plaintiff:	KENNETH OSBORN, MICHAEL GRIES, RICHARD CRONE, PINE HURST ACRES, VJW FARM, INC., PETER V. ANDERSON, NORMAN SIGRIST, RON WETZ, GRANT ANNEXSTAD, BRADLEY J. VERMEER and CHARLES A. WELSH
Defendant:	SYNGENTA SEEDS, LLC, FKA Syngenta Seeds, Inc., SYNGENTA CROP PROTECTION AG, SYNGENTA BIOTECHNOLOGY, INC., SYNGENTA AG, SYNGENTA CORPORATION and SYNGENTA CROP PROTECTION, LLC
Appellee:	BYRON STONE, PLLC, TEEL & MARONEY, PLC, ABREO & CARTER, MOLLEUR LAW OFFICE, BRIAN FITZWATER LAW OFFICE, HOLLAND LAW FIRM, LAW OFFICE OF THOMAS A. NOE, III, SHATZMAN & ASSOCIATES, P.C., ELLIS & JUDD LAW OFFICE, LLC, OVERBOE LAW, CALDWELL, BRIERLY, CHALUPA & NUZMAN, PLLC, CLINE WILLIAMS WRIGHT JOHNSON & OLDFATHER, LLP, NELSON, YOUNG, & BRALAND ATTORNEYS AT LAW, GRAY, RITTER, GRAHAM, P.C., JENNA LAIRD LEGER, THE JULIAN C. GOMEZ LAW FIRM, PLLC, LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM ENYART, TOURKOW CRELL ROSENBLATT & JOHNSTON LLP, MCCULLEY MCCLUER PLLC, CLARK LOVE & HUTSON, GP, WALK & MURPHY, PLC, HERITAGE LEGAL GROUP PLLC, CARPENTER & SCHUMACHER, P.C., MORRIS LAING EVANS BROCK & KENNEDY, PHILLIPPI LAW FIRM, LLC, VAN KLEY & WALKER, LLC, RICHARD D. LARSON, P.C., CLARK & CLARK P.C., WATTS GUERRA LLP, MCCLURE, THOMAS & THOMAS, LAW OFFICES OF LEONEL ALEJANDRO PC, DILLON LEGAL GROUP, CHURCH, CHURCH, HITTLE & ANTRIM, JOHNSON LAW GROUP, STUEVE SIEGEL HANSON LLP, BEASLEY, ALLEN, CROW, METHVIN, PORTIS & MILES, P.C., BATTLE & WINN LLP, JOSEPH F. MANAK, Attorney at Law, CONNORS LLP, WESTERVELT, JOHNSON, NICOLL & KELLER, LLC, WALLACE LAW, PENDLEY, BAUDIN & COFFIN, L.L.P., HAWKINS LAW, PC, THE LAW OFFICE OF MARK L EUREK, BRADY PRESTON GRONLUND PC, MAYNES LAW OFFICE, THOMAS P. CALHOUN, III, Attorney at Law, LAW OFFICE OF MIKE CRANE, LLP, JEREMY P. COHEN, LAW OFFICES OF HANS A. BUEHLER, LLC, SORLING NORTHRUP ATTORNEYS, WOJTALEWICZ LAW FIRM, LTD, DANIEL M. HOMOLKA, P.A., ANDERSON, BOTTRELL, SANDEN & THOMPSON, ATLEE HALL, LLP, ANGEL, ISAACSON & TRACY, ATTORNEYS AT LAW, BRENNAN STEIL S.C., DENNEY & BARRETT, PC, ALERDING CASTOR HEWITT LLP, WADLER, PERCHES, HUNDL & KERLICK, WHITE & ALLEN, P.A., MCFARLAND LAW, PC, OKOON HINTERMEISTER, PLLC, THE GIBBS LAW FIRM, GREAK LAW, P.C., PATTON, HOVERSTEN & BERG, P.A., SHAMBERG, WOLF, MCDERMOTT & DEPUE, FELLHEIMER LAW FIRM LTD., BLOOM GATES & WHITELEATHER, LLP, THOMPSON, GARRETT & HINES, RYAN MOORE & COOK, WOODS ROGERS PLC, WORTH LAW FIRM, BRAND & MORELOCK, THE LAW OFFICE OF THOMAS R. FIELDS, P.A., TULLY LAW OFFICE, PC, JOHN M. TOTTEN, P.C., WEEKS & BRUCKER, LTD, GAMBLE & RUSSELL, P.C., FAITH INGLE SMITH LAW FIRM, JUSTIN HILL, PC, DOBBS LEGAL GROUP, RAY, WINTON & KELLEY, PLLC, QUIRK & HUNTER, PC, MOORE, SUSLER, MCNUTT & WRIGLEY, LLC, FORBES LAW GROUP, LLC, BARRACK, RODOS & BACINE, FOREMAN WATSON HOLTREY, LOWE EKLUND WAKEFIELD CO., LPA, HENINGER GARRISON DAVIS, LLC, BRAD MORRIS LAW FIRM, PLLC, TAFT STETTINIUS & HOLLISTER LLP, CRITCHFIELD CRITCHFIELD & JOHSON, LTD., BRIANA DEANE, MAILANDER LAW OFFICE, THE LAW OFFICE OF ROB TULLY PC, HABUSH HABUSH & ROTTIER S.C., VANDERGINST LAW, GARY T. GEE LAW OFFICE, COLE, EASLEY, SCIBA & WILLIAMS, P.C., DAVID R. ADELMAN, DAVIS & CAMPBELL, LLC, KEVIN W. LILES PC, SONENBERG LAW LLC, MILBERG TADLER PHILLIPS GROSSMAN LLP, WRIGHT SCHIMMEL LLC, PLEWS SHADLEY RACHER & BRAUN LLP, BOREN, OLVER AND COFFEY, LLP, CARELLA BYRNE CECCHI OLSTEIN BRODY & AGNELLO, P.C., HUME, SMITH, GEDDES, GREEN & SIMMONS, LLP, W. CALLOWAY HUFFAKER, ZEILINGER LAW OFFICE, REICHERT LAW OFFICE, SCHULTZ LAW, DEBORAH K. SMITH, RILEY-TANIS & ASSOCIATES PLLC, ENGLISH, LUCAS, PRIEST & OWSLEY, LLP, ZIMMERMAN REED, LLP, COOTS, HENKE & WHEELER, RICHARDSON, PATRICK, WESTBROOK & BRICKMAN, LLC, BERNATZ & VAN BEEK, ARNDT BUSWELL & THORN S.C., REICHERT WENNER, P.A., BROCK LAW OFFICES PC LLO, LAMKIN & LAMKIN, P.C., SHAMBERG JOHNSON & BERGMAN, BURNS CRONAUER & BROWN LLP, PHIPPS ANDERSON DEACON, LLP, HENSLEY LEGAL GROUP PC, JOHN L. JERNIGAN, III, Attorney at Law, DARLING & DARLING, KOENIG LAW FIRM, MARTZ & LUCAS, LLC, MAZZANTI LAW OFFICE, PLLC, NATHAN J. NOBLE, P.C., LEE J. LEWIS, WESTERFIELD, JANOUSH & BELL, P.A., GREGG NEAL, CRESS LAW GROUP, PC, JOHN E. TARBURTON, Attorney at Law, BILL J. MILNER LAW OFFICES, LAW OFFICES OF RICHARD HOFFMAN, ROB TULLY LAW FIRM, KITTELSEN, BARRY, WELLINGTON, THOMPSON, & SCHLUESCHE, ATTORNEYS AT LAW, CHARLES HEAR, HAGEN & HAGEN, P.C., JAMES M. PIETZ, Attorney at Law, DREW YOUNG LAW, ALLEN, STEIN & DURBIN, PC, DANIEL QUIGLEY, CONRAD F. CROPSEY, Attorney at Law, BORING & BORING, PC, MARK A. ROEDER, BARADA LAW OFFICES, LLC, COTTON, BOLTON, HOYCHICK & DOUGHTY, LLP, SCHWARZ LAW OFFICE, BROOKS & OLSON, TERRIE HARMAN, Attorney at Law, PAUL LLP, RHOADES MCKEE PC, CLINE FARRELL CHRISTIE & LEE, P.C., STINSON LEONARD STREET LLP, RICHARD RUSSELL, Attorney at Law, JOHNSON & MOCK, PC LLO, JEFFERSON & BREWER, LLP, GRIFFIN DIETRICH & ELLIOT, LLC, WINSTEIN, KAVENSKY & CUNNINGHAM, LLC, TUCKER & TUCKER, P.C., MEADOR & CRUMP, P.A., STRITTMATTER LAW FIRM, WILLIS & WILLIS, MALONEY & CAMPOLO, CUSTY LAW FIRM, LLC, FEARER, NYE, & CHADWICK, MCNEELY STEPHENSON, HARE, WYNN, NEWELL & NEWTON, BLAKEMAN & SCHROCK, LTD, KRUML LAW OFFICE, P.C., MUSKE, MUSKE, SUHRHOFF LTD, KELLEY LAW FIRM, PC, BIRD, JACOBSEN & STEVENS, PC, MICHAEL ASHAR, OUDERKIRK LAW FIRM, BOSE MCKINNEY & EVANS LLP, BROYLES KIGHT & RICAFORT, PC, MAURO ARCHER AND ASSOCIATES PLLC, BARRETT WYLIE, LLC, FRUNDT & JOHNSON, LTD., BROWN, DEPREZ & JOHNSON, P.A., JASON SCHUTTE, KOEPKE & HILTABRAND ATTORNEY AT LAW, LAURIE S. WARD, W. DEAN BELK, JR., Attorney at Law, THE MCQUADES CO. LPA, STONE LAW OFFICE, P.L.L.C., RICCOLO, SEMELROTH, & HENNINGSEN, P.C., HART BELL, LLC, BRADFORD LAW FIRM, MORGAN & MEYERS, PLC, HAJJAR PETERS, LLP, JEFF LINK, ROBERTS LAW OFFICE, ALLEN WELLMAN MCNEW HARVEY, LLP, LAW OFFICE OF HAMMELL & MURPHY PLLP, JAMES & LARSON LAW, JAMES LAW, P.C., DEWALD DEAVER, P.C., BENJAMIN MARSHALL & ASSOCIATES, AARON D. HOVAN, Attorney at Law, EMERSON POYNTER LLP, MICHAEL J. GALANIS, IRVIN L. MASCHING, SNEED LANG PC, LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL MILLER, LAW OFFICE OF GREGORY E. TONORE, MICHAEL GROSS, CHARLES E. CRONAUER & ASSOCIATES, DELZER LAW OFFICE, DUNK LAW FIRM, PLLC, MILTNER LAW FIRM, LLC, PEN COSBY, KUHLMAN & LUCAS, LLC, THE WINKIE LAW FIRM, LLC, KIZER, BONDS, HUGHES & BOWEN, PLLC, GEORGE M. BISHOP, KNUTH LAW OFFICE, SEVER STOREY, TUCKER LAW PRACTICE, BARBARA J. SIMMONS, WAGSTAFF & CARTMELL, LLP, MEIER, BRAGICICH & MOORE LLP, WOOD & RUE, PLLP, LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER H. POYNOR, ALEX KOENIGS, BATTS, BATTS & BELL, LLP, PATTERSON COMER, TROYER & GOOD, PC, OBEAR, OVERHOLSER, HUFFER & RIDER, LLC, MORRISSEY, MORRISSEY & DALLUGE, THE CANTLIN LAW FIRM, SHERMAN HOFFMAN & HIPP, LC, CORNELL LAW OFFICE, MARCH, MCMILLAN, DEJOODE & DUVALL, P.C., LEO BOOTHE, SPENCER GILLAND, THE STROM LAW FIRM, LLC, HECKER LAW GROUP, PLC, CARABIN & SHAW, P.C., HEINISCH & LOVEGROVE LAW OFFICE, PC LLP, HEHNER & ASSOCIATES, LLC, NORMAN PALOUCEK & HERMAN, FAFINSKI MARK & JOHNSON, P.A., GORDON & ASSOCIATES, P.C., JEFFREY A. BOGGESS, P.C., WELD, RILEY, PRENN & RICCI S.C., BAKER, BODWELL, APPEL ATTORNEYS AT LAW, FERRER, POIROT & WANSBROUGH, LANGDON & EMISON ATTORNEYS AT LAW, BARRETT, EASTERDAY, CUNNINGHAM & ESELGROTH, LLP, BRAU LAW OFFICE, BOHRER BRADY LLC, SATTERLEY AND KELLEY, PLLC, MORNING LAW OFFICE LLC, COPLEY ROTH & WILSON, LLC, CHARNETSKI, LACINA & CLOWER, LLP, CAUGHEY, LEGNER & FREEHILL ATTORNEYS AT LAW, LUNDBERG LAW FIRM PLC, JANZEN AGRICULTURAL LAW, LLC, MYERS HOCKEMEYER & MCNAGNY LLP, FITZGERALD LAW P.A., STOERZBACH LAW OFFICE, P.C., RANDLE & SAMMONS, P.C., THE POPPE LAW FIRM, KC COHEN, LAWYER, PC, KEATON & KEATON PC, WILLIAM THOMAS, Attorney at Law, LAW OFFICES OF JAMES S. ROGERS, GUSTAFSON GLUEK, PLLC, STOCKARD, JOHNSTON, & BROWN, P.C, HAMPTON & ROYCE, L.C., MERCHO CAUGHEY & DELAY, SLAVEN LAW GROUP, EMERICK, DIGGINS & ZABONA P.C., THE LAW OFFICES OF TIMOTHY L. LAPOINTE, P.C., KIRK LAW FIRM, SOPER LEDDIN LAW FIRM, PC, GRAYBILL & WITCHER, LLP, MICHAEL SMITH LAW, SIMON HERBERT & MCCLELLAND, LLP, SMITH GARDNER SLUSKY LAZER POHREN & ROGERS LLP, NKA Smith Slusky Law, MITCHELL C. CHANEY, CLENDENING JOHNSON & BOHRER, P.C., BARBER, SEGATTO, HOFFEE, WILKE, & CATE, WILLADSEN & NEAL LLC, GELLHAUS & GELLHAUS, P. C., WOLF ARDIS, P.C., PATRICK A. ELWARD, FISHERBROYLES, LLP, ESPE LAW PLLC, KATZ & KORIN, P.C., SAEED & LITTLE, LLP, WHITMAN, BABER, & SIEGEL, REILING TEDER & SCHRIER, LLC, WALLER JORGENSON WARZYNSKI, PLLC, WAYNE J. LENNINGTON, KRUSE & DAKIN LLP, VAUGHAN LAW FIRM, P.C., KOVARIK, ELLISON & MATHIS, P.C., NKA Ellison Kovarik & Turman Law Firm PC, LIND JENSEN SULLIVAN & PETERSON P.A., KEULER, KELLY HUTCHINS & BLANKENSHIP, LLP, CALL & GENTRY LAW GROUP, PAGEL & WEIKUM, PLLP, WADLER PERCHES HUNDL & KERLICK, WOODARD LAW PC., DURRETT, ARKEMA, GERSON & GILL, P.C., ORLANS, P.C., DEBORAH SMITH MCCLURE, P.C., SCHIRGER, KIRK, MCDOUGALL & WINZELER, P.C., HOSTETTER & ASSOCIATES, SWAIM LAW FIRM, PLLC, LOCKRIDGE GRINDAL NAUEN PLLP, CARY, WELCH, HICKMAN & HAWK, LLP, ESTES & KENNEDY LAW OFFICES, PLLC, SEEGER WEISS LLP, WILLIAM F. SMITH, WRIGHT & SCHULTE LLC, KENNETH G. WALSH, Attorney at Law, KRAMER LAW, LLC, GREGORY L. CESHKER, P.C., RICHARD L. COFFMAN, P.C., DBA The Coffman Law Firm, TOM BENSON, CHRIS W. FITZGERALD, Attorney at Law, EDMUND A. WEINHEIMER, JR., P. C., BRENT C. EMBREY, EMERSON SCOTT LLP, HOVLAND & RASMUS, PLLC, CULBERTSON & ALLEN, LLC, VELA LAW OFFICES PLLC, HALL HUDSON, P.C., THE LAW OFFICE OF GEORGE P. ESCOBEDO & ASSOCIATES, THE CAHILL LAW OFFICES, BARRETT MCNAGNY LLP, SCHMITTINGER & RODRIGUEZ, P.A., BOLEN ROBINSON & ELLIS, LLP, MASSIE & QUICK, LLC, SHIMANEK, SHIMANEK, & BOWMAN, LLC, PICKNER LAW OFFICE, SCOTT EMORY POYNTER, QUIGLEY LAW OFFICE, WEXLER WALLACE LLP, HODGE LAW FIRM, WHALEY LAW FIRM, NIDEY ERDAHL TINDAL & FISCHER, PLC, COLE LAW OFFICE, TED B. LYON & ASSOCIATES, P.C., MILLER SCHIRGER LLC, TROTH LAW OFFICE, WASKER DOOR WIMMER & MARCOUILLER, P.C., SCHNELKER, RASSI & MCCONNELL PLC, THRASH LAW FIRM, P.A., MEYER & MEYER LLP, SOUNDING BOARD LEGAL, S.C., DAVE O'BRIEN LAW, EICH, VAN DYKE, WERDAN & STEGER P.C., LAW OFFICE OF BRENT GAINES, COCKERILL & COCKERILL ATTORNEYS AT LAW, THE LAW OFFICE OF SAMUEL W. BEARMAN, L.C., OTTS, MOORE, COALE, GODWIN, STEARNS & DARBY, JOHN R. DELZER, LAW OFFICE OF ADAM CRAWSHAW, HALLETT, HALLETT & NAGEL, PEMBERTON, SORLIE, RUFER, & KERSHNER, PLLP, BIGHAM LAW FIRM, ROTH LAW FIRM, VRIEZELAAR, TIGGES, EDINGTON, BOTTARO, BODEN, & ROSS, L.L.P., CROSS PENNAMPED WOOLSEY & GLAZIER, P.C., WAGNER REESE, LLP, ENDURANCE LAW GROUP PLC, JOHNSON, KRAMER, MULHOLLAND, COCHRANE, DRISCOLL & COCHRANE, P.L.C., SCHWEBEL GOETZ & SIEBEN PA, DENTON & KEULER, LLP, SPEER LAW FIRM, PC, UNDERWOOD LAW FIRM, PC, GRAY REED & MCGRAW LLP, BAKKE NORMAN, S.C., CHAPMAN LAW LLC, BROOKS PIERCE, GRENFELL, SLEDGE AND STEVENS, BUTLER SNOW, LLP, MINER & LEMON, LLP, RAY A. FERGUSON & ASSOCIATES, LTD., DYE SNYDER, LLP, LAW OFFICE OF JEFFREY R. VAUGHAN, P.C., ROBINSON, CURPHEY & OCONNEL, LLC, JAKE W. BROOKS, JOHNSON, MOODY, SCHMIDT & KLEINHUIZEN, P.A., PEMBERTON LAW FIRM, MARTIN, BROWNE, HULL & HARPER PLL, LAW OFFICE OF LESTER WEINSTINE, P.C., WELLER, GREEN, TOUPS & TERRELL, LLP, WICKENS & WICKENS, LLC, RICHARD M. HOLMES, CHESTER LAW OFFICE, BASSFORD REMELE, PA, KEMPTON & RUSSELL, LLC, FLYNN & SULLIVAN PC, RAMMELKAMP BRADNEY, P.C., ANTHONY O'HANLON, P.C., PATTON BROWN LAW, PLLC, JINKS, CROW & DICKSON, P.C., GREEN ESPEL PLLP, SIMMONS HANLY CONROY LLC, KRAFT WALSER LAW OFFICE, PLLP, MILLER PEARSON GLOE BURNS BEATTY & PARRISH, P.L.C., FORDE LAW OFFICES LLP, DOERING & GRISELL, PA, TROUSDALE RYAN, P.C., INGEBRITSON & ASSOCIATES, P.A., WARNER NORCROSS & JUDD, LLP, MIDWEST AG SOLUTIONS LLC, LAW OFFICE OF EZEQUIEL REYNA, JR., BEINE & ROBERTS LAW FIRM, PLC, E. RUDOLPH MCINTYRE, Attorney at Law, THE PRUNEDA LAW FIRM, PLLC, BRETT DUNN PLLC, NATHAN A. EAST, Attorney at Law, WYLAND, HUMPHREY & CLEVENGER LLP, WIL GALLOWAY & ASSOCIATES, PLLC, YIRA LAW OFFICE, LTD, VANDERVOORT CHRIST & FISHER, P.C., FENCHEL, DOSTER & BUCK, PLC, LAW OFFICE OF WILLIAM R. SHIRK, CRYSTAL D. PULLEY, COLVIN, CHANEY, SAENZ & RODRIGUEZ, LLP, MERTES & MERTES, P.C., BOSCHMA LAW OFFICE, CROSS LAW FIRM, LLC, VIRTUS LAW PLLC, GROSBOLL, BECKER, TICE & BARR, WALTERS BENDER STROHBEHN & VAUGHAN, P.C., ADAMS, RIZZI & SWEEN, P.A., TAYLOR & RUHNKE, PC, OSTERBAUER LAW FIRM and STOUT LAW GROUP
Plaintiff / Appellee:	GRAFEL FARMS, LLC, TODD NIEMEYER, LEROY EDLUND, KRUSEMAN FERTILIZER COMPANY, BIEBER FARM, DAVID SCHWANINGER, MIKE DAVAULT, DBA DaVault ArkMo Farms, KAFFENBARGER FARMS, INC., AL-CORN CLEAN FUEL, LLC, FIVE STAR FARMS, DEMMER FARMS, INC., JPPL, INC., BOTTOMS FARMS PARTNERSHIP, D & S GRAIN & CATTLE CO. INC., DAVID DAVAULT, DBA DaVault ArkMo Farms, ROLLING RIDGE RANCH, LLC, CUSTOM FARM SERVICES, LLC, STEVEN A. WENTWORTH, DAVID POLIFKA, CHARLES COBB, CHARLES B. LEX, ROGER WARD, ROBERT NIEMEYER, CE COBB FARMS, TRIPLE BG PARTNERSHIP, NEBCO, INC., DAVID POLIFKA REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST, MARVIN MILLER, BEAVER CREEK FARMS, INC. and BRADLEY DAVAULT, DBA DaVault ArkMo Farms
Appellant:	CLARK MASON ATTORNEYS, SHIELDS LAW GROUP, LLC, JAMES J. THOMPSON, JR., Attorney at Law, PAUL BYRD LAW FIRM, PLLC, AWBREY LAW FIRM and KELLY LAW FIRM, P.A.
Case Number:	21-3111
Filed:	June 23, 2021
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Other

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.