Plaintiff:	Zoila Cortez, Carlos Guzman, Andres Mora, William Simpson, Bianey Sinisterra, Zdzislaw Usewicz, Victor Zapata, Voldymyr Khomik, Gustavo Iturralde, Edgar Abarca, Yasmin Abarca, Aly Abdelrehim, Stephen Addeo, Luis Adriano, Emmanual Agostini, Gladys Agudelo, Luis Aguilar, Wilmer Aguinaga, Kevin Ahearn, Raul Alcivar, Carlos Ali, Anthony Alloggio, Brigitte Almanzar, Jorge Almeida, Ana Maria Alvarado, Telma Alvarado, Gloria Alvarez, Juan Alvarez, Maria Alvarez, Rolando Alvarez, Hernando Alvarez-Garcia, Jose Alvarracin, Santiago Alvear, Anthony Amabile, Jr., Melba Amaya, Michael Ambrosecchia, Alberto Andrade, Rossina Angulo, Philip Annunziato, Donald Arana, Magda Arango, Fabio Arbelaez, Desiderio Arboleda, Michael Arendt, Julio Arias, Jhonson Arichabala, Amparro Aristizabal, Dagoberto Aristizabal, Enid Aristizabal, Thomas A. Arlotta, Daniel Arrigo, Betsy Arruda-Loor, Kleber Arteaga, Vilma Aspiazu, Freddy Astudillo, Martha Atehortua, Frank Auditore, Hernando Avenia, Angel Avila, Cesar Avila, Derlim Avila, Richard Avila, Sixto Aviles, Ivan Ayala, Rosa Azcarate, Andrzej Baczkowski, Jason Bailey, Peter Bailon, Reyaad Baksh, Hector Balaguer, Jose Balarezo, Richard Ballerini, Ivan Banda, Miguel Banda, Nestor Banda, Nestor Banda, Jr., Sandra Baquero, Jose Barahona, Virginia Barbosa, Miguel Barona, Sergio Barragan, Raul Barreto, Rodrigo Barros, Sebastiano Basile, Julio Bastidas, Ramiro Bastidas, Ivan Bayas, Scott Bedell, Tadeusz Bedkowski, Sime Begonja, Fanny Bejarano, Wlodzimierz Belkowski, Luis Benitez, Ana Bermeo, Luis Bermeo, Luis Berrezueta, George Berrones, Ana Betancur, Louis Betro, John Bevando, Jan Bierylo, Charles Blandino, Daysy Blandon, Lucy Blandon, Frank Bocchichio, Nicholas P. Bolobanic, Susana Bonifaz, Luis Bonilla, Gladys Bonnen, Andrzej Borkowski, Wiktor Borowiecki, Luz Botero, Jorge Bravo, Richard Brenseke, Lisa Brown, Thomas Bruno, Kenny Bugge, Cruz Bunay, German Ernesto Bunay, Teresa Bunay, Mario Buonviaggio, Leopoldo Burgos, Charles Bustamante, Georgina Cabrera, Kleber Cabrera, Rolendio Cabrera, Hamide Cagatay, Zebiullah Cagatay, Bolivar Caivinagua, Martha Caiza, Collin Calder, Ivan Calero, Maria Rocio Calle, Wilson Calle, Francisco Camino, Flor Campos, Angel Campoverde, Rey Campoverde, Rodrigo Campozano, Consuelo Campuzano, Ana Patricia Cantos, William Cantres, Edison Cardenas, Carlos Cardona, Catterine Cardona, Luz Cardona, Denis Carlin, Michael Carlisi, James Carr, Victor Carrasco, Ramon Carrero, Linda Carrillo, Ronald Carson, Javier Carvajal, Donald Casey, Carlos Castano, Francisco Castillo, Nancy Castillo, Piedad Castillo, Silvia Castillo, Douglas Castle, Gisel Castro, Hector Castro, Lucero Castro, Michael Cavaluzzi, Lidia Ceballos, Carlos Cedeno, Guy Cerbone, Monte Cesta, Rosa Chain, Aida Chalco, Horacio Chalen, Michael Charles, Benjamin Cheesman, Joseph Chiarantano, Nick Chiarello, Maria Chimbay, Walter Chipe, Manuel Chique, Luis Chirinos, Andrzej Chojnowski, Faisal Choudhury, Vincent Ciaramella, Yolanda Cintron, Dermott Clancy, Cecilia Claret, Justina Claret, Sarbelia Coballes, Robert Cochero, Edward Cochran, Anthony Cokley, Felice Colella, Joseph Colombo, Viviana Colorado, Christopher Colucci, John Colucci, John Combos, John Comerford, Ralph Conca, Beatriz Concepcion, David Contessa, Thomas Conway, Freddy Cordero, Howard Corr, Elena Corrales, Francisco Cortes, Jorge Cortez, Lidia Cortijo, Thomas Costello, Martin Coyne, Jose Criollo, Nancy Criollo, James Cronin, Efren Cruz, Zunilda Cruz, Cuervo, David Cuevas, Peter Curley, Peter Cusick, Mieczyslaw Dabrowski, Kevin Dallas, Patrick D'Alliegro, John Daly, Michael Damato, Frank Danetra, Steven Daquila, Robert Darin, Flora Davila, Wilmar Davila, Jimmie Davis, Pyron Davis, Maria De La Cruz, Peter DeAngelis, Gilberto DeJesus, Elsa DeLaCruz, Gloria Delacruz, Isabel DeLeon, Emilsen Delgado, Joseph DeLuca, Louis DeLuccy, Mark DeMauro, Wieslaw Demko, Michael Devito, Fernando Dias, Alba Diaz, Luz Diaz, Ramiro Diaz, Ruth Diaz, Castrenze DiCarlo, Pancri Diez, Anthony Dimino, John Dipalo, Leo DiRubbo, Nicholas DiRubbo, Zbigniew Dobronski, Patrick Dolan, Frank Dolce, David Dominguez, Francisco Dominguez, Margarita Dominguez, Tailor Dominguez, Christopher Donnelly, Michael Donovan, Clara Dota, Glenn Dowd, Edward Doyle, Jesse Drake, Bogdan Drozd, Dominik Drozdz, Oswald Drysdale, Inerva Duarte, Luz Duche, Angel Duchitanga, Rosalino Duchitanga, Maria Duque, Elvia Dutan, Lucila Dutan, Tomasz Dybus, Carl Dyer, Cirilo Encalada, Jorge Encalada, Marco Encalada, Mark Engelbrecht, Joseph Eramo, Robert Espinal, Hernando Espinosa, Nancy Espinosa-Cardenas, Adolfo Espinoza, Carlos Espinoza, Harold Estrada, Anna Estrella, Robert Fairweather, Blanca Falcones, William Fallon, Manuel Fares, Bradley Fassett, Christian Febrillet, Gladys Feliciano, Wilson Feliciano, Marcial Feliu, Delio Feliz, Sandra Fernandez, Kenneth Ferraro, Washington Ferruzola, Piotr Fiedziukiewicz, Tom Finnerty, Gregory Fisco, Joseph Fiumano, Patrick Flaherty, Danilsa Flores, James Flynn, Donald Foley, Patricia Fox, Charles Francis, Lucelly Franco, Dzile Frangu, Nathaniel Frazier, Flavio Freire, Janina Frelas, Lazaro Fuentes, Manuel Fuertes, Juan Galarce, Carmen Gallego, Isma Gallego, Rebeca Gallegos, Victor Gallegos, Walter Gallegos, Wilson Gallegos, Kevin Fitzpatrick, Talia Flores, Herman Franco, Luis Franco, Deloris Frierson, Harald Gabrielsen, Cruz Galiano, Norberto Gallardo, Diana Galli, Cori Gallo, Edgar Galvis, Wieslaw Gandurski, Carlos Garcia, Enrique Garcia, Fredy Garcia, Jose Garcia, Joseph Garcia, Ladislao Garcia, Sixta Garcia, Viviana Garcia, Leonard Gawin, Manes Geneus, Samuel Giamo, Claudia Gil, Margarita Gil, Dennis Gimblet, Alberto Giraldo, Deycer Giraldo, Edir Giraldo, Hitier Giraldo, Leslie Glenn, Gildardo Gomez, Ruben Gomez, Gisselle Gonzalez, Juan Gonzalez, Roberta Gonzalez, Edward Gora, Malgorzata Grabowska, Abdon Grageda, John Greaney, Chris Greco, Slawomir Gryszkiewicz, Jorge Gualotuna, Arthur Gudeon, Joseph Guercio, Francisco Guerrero, Rodolfo Guevara, Cesar Guiracocha, Richard Gullo, David Guszick, Rafael Gutierrez, Armando Guzman, Salma Guzman, Brian Hanberry, Chris Harmon, Michele Harris, Michael Hartberger, Michael Hartnett, Roger Haughton, Dick Hernandez, Jaime Hernandez, Luis Hernandez, Robert Hernandez, Rosario Hernandez, Tercida Hernandez, Jose Herrera, James Higgins, Christopher Hinckson, David Hobbs, Thomas Hogan, Richard Hovell, Angel Hualpa, Maria Huerta, Julio Hurtado, Kenneth Hutter, Carlton Hylton, Diomedes Ibanez, Nury Ibanez, Edgar Idrovo, Jeffrey Imsho, Henry Infantas, Jorge Inga, Thomas Irwin, Maritza Isabel, Wladyslaw Iwanczyk, Janusz Jakubowski, Julio Jalil, Leslie James, Mary James, Marina Jara, Freddy Jaramillo, Jonas Jaramillo, Rogerio Jarrin, Lawrence Jaszcar, Rodrigo Jimbo, Francisco Jimenez, Jose Jimenez, Alan Johnson, Charles Johnson, Christopher Johnson, James Jones, Pierra Jones, Tony Jones, Jan Jozefowicz, Henryk Jozwiak, Osman Juarez, Philip Jude, Teresa Jurado, Charles Kaczorowski, Jozef Kaczynski, Boris Kagan, Bozena Kajewska-Pielarz, Slawomir Karpinski, Janusz Karpiuk, Marian Karus, Andrzej Kasina, John Kear, John Kearney, Ronald Kerney, Yasha Khaimov, Donald Killeen, Kenneth Kinsey, Andrzej Kiryk, John G. Kissane, Anna Knurzynska, Daniel Kochanski, Wieslaw Kolodziejczyk, Antoni Konopka, Michal Kopcza, Helga Kopperl, Andrzej Korzep, Igor Kosiv, Edward Kosowski, Adam Kowalczyk, Thomas Kucer, Yosef Kudman, Douglas Kuhn, Antoni Kurak, Boguslaw Kwasniak, Michael Labate, Troy Lagner, John Laios, Eva Lamboy, Antoni Lampart, Keith Landau, Karl Lanfrit, Mark Lanigan, Emerita Lara, Nick LaSala, Carlos Lascano, Andrzej Lasica, Leszek Lech, Fabio Lecoche, Horacio Ledesma, Ines Leon, Jose Leon, Segundo Leon, David Lerich, Alan Letz, Stephen Lewis, Leonard Lewis, Sr., Carmelo Linea, Manuel Lituma, Thomas LoBasso, Jose Loja, John Lombardi, Francisco Londono, Liliana Londono, Agustin Lopez, Antonio Lopez, Francis Lopez, Jamie Lopez, Milton Lopez, Wilber Lopez, Andrea Lora, Nicholas Lorusso, Steve Lovergine, Henry Lozano, Ligia Luengas, Esad Lukac, Rolando Luna, Edward Luster, Thomas Lynch, Pedro Macias, Vernon Mack, Thomas Madden, Thomas Maher, Robert Mahoney, Vitaliy Maksymets, Darwin Maldonado, Felix Maldonado, Mariana Maldonado, Joseph Malvino, Ron Mancini, Luz Manco, Carmine Mandragona, Salvatore Marchese, Diego Marin, Walter Marin, Christopher Martin, Craig Martin, Garrett Martin, Joffre Martinez, Manuel Martinez, Kevin Martz, Margarita Mattei, Mark Maupin, Julio Cesar Mayorga Gonzalez, John Mazarese, Juan Mazlymian, Antoni Mazur, James McCann, Sean McDermott, Brian McKenna, Jim McLoughlin, Dennis McMahon, Michael McNair, William McNulty, Salvador Medrano, Trinidad Medrano, Hilario Mejia, Maria Melendez, Richard Meltz, Edgar Mendez, Juan Mendez, Gustavo Mendoza, Luis Meneses, Carlos Merchan, Wojciech Michalik, Damon Michalopoulos, Joseph Mills, Richard Miranda, Susana Miranda, Ubaldo Misaico, Bruce Mogg, Jeffrey Mohlenbrok, Rosa Molina, Robert Mollahan, Frank Molloy, Leidis Montero, Angel Monzant, Eugenio Mora, Fabio Morales, Segundo Morales, Tatiana Morales, LeRoy Moran, Luis Moran, Como Mordente, Consuelo Moreno, Jorge Moreno, John Moretti, Lawrence Morgan, Salvatore Moscato, Linder Mosquera, Joe Moya, Jacek Mrozek, Richard Mulhern, Esperanza Munoz, Janeth Munoz, Glenn Murray, Adolfo Naranjo, Angel Naranjo, Leonardo Naranjo, Luis Naranjo, Walter Naranjo, Mieczyslaw Nartowicz, Carlos Narvaez, Julia Narvaez, Miguel Naula, Dalia Nauta, Geronimo Navarro, Oscar Negrete, Herbert Negron, Timothy Nevins, Jose Nicola, William Noesges, Miryam Noguera, Richard Nolan, Carlos Nunez, Divina Nunez, David Nussbaum, Michael O'Brien, Orlando Ocampo, Gustavo Ochoa, Sean O'Connell, Edward O'Connor, Michael O'Leary, Pilar Olivo, Wilson Olivo, Steven Olsen, Arkadiusz Olszewski, Alexander O'Neal, Michael O'Neil, Iris Zimmerman, Richard Wright, Marian Wronkowski, Krzysztof Zalewski, Ramon Zambrana, Guy Zammit, Cristobal Yamasqui, Matilde Yamasqui, Dennis Yarczower, Carlos Zamora, Jairo Zamora, Santos Zapil, William Ziegelmeier, Juan Zurita, Tadeusz Foremska, Richard Racioppi, Alex Anthony Sanchez, Rafael Valdez, Manuel Checo, Dorota Markut, Roman Markut, Jose Bello, Bozena Kurkowski, Janus Kurkowski, Ludmila Khomik, Monica Arce, Miguel Zanabria, Ryszard Krysiuk, Viasta Krysiuk, Columbina Estrella, Leonardo Estrella, Marco Fernandez, Richard Aalbue, John Abatz, Carmelo Acevedo, Byron Acosta, Julian Acosta, Rene Adorno, Maria Agudelo, Claudio Agudo, Miguel Alfaro Lobo, Pedro Alfonso, Enrique Ali, John Antiaris, Ignacio Arbelaez, Arturo Arias, Gloria Arias, Enrique Arrieta, Ivan Ascencio, Angel Asmal, Carlos Asmal, Wilmer Astudillo, Daniel Austin, Edgar Avila, Luis Avila, Mauricio Avila, Nolberto Avila, Victor Azubike, Fabiola Baez, Vanessa Ballesteros, Stalin Barcco-Wong, Arturo Barrero, Mercedes Barriga, Hector Barroso, Linda Battle, Vincente Benavidez, Joseph Benbow, Anita Bermudez, Hector Betancourt, Roman Bikowski, Jacek Bogacki, Yuly Botero, Hava Bracic, Eric Braverman, Johnathan Buckley, Hector Buestan, Carlos Bunay, Flor Bunay, Hugo Cabrera, Marbin Cabrera, Oswaldo Cabrera, Wilson Cabrera, Manuel Caguana, Segundo Caguana, Juan Caivinagua, Lucy Cali, Elva Calle, Gil Calle, Jose Calle, Russell Cannon, Mauricio Carchi, Fausto Carpio, Jose Carpio, Hernan Carrasco, Neil Carroll, Scott Carville, Antonio Castillo, Isabel Castrillon, Maria Castro, Teresita Cayetano, Armando Ceron, Wilson Chaca, Joel Chalco, Maria Chauca, Carlos Chavez, Edizon Chavez, Maria Chique, Pawel Choinski, William Chun, Maria del Pilar Cifuentes, Angel Cobos, Asdrubal Coello, Antonio Collazos, Freddy Conforme, William Cook, Hector Cordova, David Cornier, Jose Coronel, Manuel Cosme, Patricia Cubas, Carmen Cubero, Francisco Cuellar, Rosa Culcay, Andrew Cullimore, Anthony Cuomo, Leonor Datil, Maria DeJesus, Belkis Delacruz, Ofelia DeLaCruz, Luciano Delorbe, Rosa Diez, Gina Dominguez, Joseph Douso, John Dowling, Stanislaw Drozdz, Manuel Duchitanga, Maria Duchitanga, Blanca Duque, Flor Duque, Ana Duran, Willie Easterling, Luis Encalada, Enny Espinosa, Alex Espinoza, Carlos Fajardo, Frank Felicetti, Aldo Feliciano, Juan Gallo, Rosa Gandia, Jesus Garces, Segundo Garces, Fernando Garcia, Isabel Garcia, Jorge Garcia, Lizeth Garcia, Luis Garcia, Sonia Garcia, Peter Gaspar, Blanca Gavidia, Michael Gibson, Jose Gomez, Luis Gomez, Gabriel Gonzalez, John Gonzalez, Joseph Granata, Graziano, Rosa Gualpa, Enrique Guaman, Jose Guartambel, Antonio Guerrero, Julio Guevara, Samuel Guiracocha, Eric Guzman, Felix Guzman, John Harris, Frank Harvey, Jeffrey Hayduk, Gustavo Henao, Enrique Hernandez, Maria Cecilia Hernandez, Nubia Hernandez, William Hightower, Peter Hunce, Neil Hurley, William Hurtado, Manuel Idrovo, Luis Inga, Ecuador Intriago, Jozef Jablonski, Juan Jara, Manuel Jaramillo, Christopher Jenkins, Carmen Jerez, Alberto Jimenez, Rafael Jimenez, Raul Jimenez, Luis Jordan, Danny Joseph, Urbano Juarez, Egerton Kelly, Mitchell Kessler, Imtiaz Khan, Mechelle King, Joel Klein, Lubomir Kmec, Kazimierz Kukacki, Ana Lascano, Annette Leary, Carlos Lenis, Cesar Leon, Thomas Leonard, Ivonne Leroux, Jerry Liguori, Diego Lituma, Hilda Llerena, Pascual Llibri, Maria Lluguay, Raul Loja, Wilmo Loja, Adriana Londono, Gloria Londono, Adolfo Lopez, Angel Lopez, Luz Adriana Lopez, Oswaldo Lopez, Ricardo Lopez, Rolando Lopez, Nubia Losada, Tyrone Lott, Fernando Lucero, Veronica Macas, Douglas Marcillo, John Marcos, Virgilio Marmolejo, Gloria Marrero, Donna Marshall, Richard E. Martin, Roberto Martinez, Anthony Martucci, Derrick McBean, Michael McPartland, Diego Medina, Rosa Medina, Alberto Melo, Enrique Mendoza, Luis Mesa, Timothy Moeller, Luz Montalvo, Otto Montenegro, Hamilton Montero, Sandra Montoya, Edward Moore, Edwin Morales, Xiomar Morales, Wilson Moran, Sandra Moreno, Simon Morocho, Javier Munoz, Michael Murphy, Rosa Narvaez, Segundo Naula, Aurea Negron, Rodolfo Nieto, Victor Nino, David Niskanen, Joseph Nolan, Sean O Neill, Janneth Ocampo, Christopher Ortiz, Maria Ortiz, Rosa Ortiz, Wilson Ortiz, Emil Onzo, Walter Oquendo, Julio Ordonez, Aurellio Orellana, Cristobal Orellana, Edgar Orellana, Haidee Orozco, Rafael Orozco, Edgar Ortega, Mariana Ortega, Sandra Ortega, Alicia Osorio, Wladyslaw Ostrzycki, Blanca Oyervide, Jaime Ozoria, Maximo Pachay, Jose Pacheco Lobo, Miguel Pacho, Wojciech Paciorkowski, Carmen Padilla, Nayibe Padredin, Miguel Paduani, Krzysztof Pajak, Rosa Palaguachi, Michael Pallotto, Patricia Palma, Henry Palomeque, Camilo Palomino, Frank Pangallo, Czeslaw Pankiewicz, Nicholas Papazissis, Philip Pappalardo, Kleber Paredes, Valentin Paredes, Walberto Paredes, Felix Parra, Leydi Parra, Frank Pasqua, Zoila Pastuizaca, Michael Paternostro, Reina Paucar, Grecia Pazmino, Albert Peduto, Inez Pelaez, Rolando Pelaez, Alexander Pena, Gabriel Pena, Jorge Pena, Luis Pena, Marianna Pena, Michael Pena, Luis Penafiel, Robert Pepe, Joseph Pepe, Jr., Guido Peralta, Jose Peralta, Zaida Perea, Jacqueline Perez, Otilia Perez, David Perez- Zapata, Maribel Perez-Sanchez, Kazimierz Perkowski, LaDerrick Perry, Slawomir Peski, Stephen Peters, Julio Pichu, Hanna Pieczynska, Clifford Pierrot, Jan Pietraszkiewicz, John Pigott, Luis Pillco, Napoleon Pina, Freddy Pineda, Hernan Pineda, Carlos Pinela, Katherine Pinkney, Fernando Pino, Luis Pinos, David Pinto, Zbigniew Plucinski, Jose Polo, Pedro Ponce, David Pope, Piotr Porowski, Raul Porras, Michael Power, Juan Manuel Prada, Maria Prada, Victor Prado, Bruce Prescod, Gladys Pretel-Vega, Andrzej Prus, Andrej Prusak, Elsa Puma, Maria Puma, Pietro Puma, Manuel Pumacuri, Dan Purcell, Jan Pyziak, Scott Quinlan, Natalia Quintanilla, Efrain Quintero, Jesus Quizhpi, Nelly Quizhpi, Segundo Quizhpi, Mark Rafaniello, James Ragnetti, Joseph Raimondi, Freddy Ramirez, Harold Ramirez, Michael Ramirez, Orlando Ramirez, Ramiro Ramirez, William Ramirez, Dennis Rando, Abdel Rasheed, Eugene Reems, Denis Reen, Lawrence Regula, Andrew Rehorn, John Reilly, Jan Rejment, Roland Renaudin, Paul Renda, Guelmer Rendon, Viviana Rendon, Irving Rengifo, Javier Restrepo, Angel Reyes, Marilan Reyes, David Reynolds, Francisco Reynoso, Joseph Ribeiro, John Ricciardi, Keith Richards, Alejandra Rico, Eric Rieger, Carlos Riera, Maximo Riera, Laura Riggi, Shayla Rivera, Sonia Rivera, Patrizio Rizzi, Bobby Roberts, Blanca Robles, Maria Robles, Teresa Robles, Hugo Rodas, Patricio Rodas, Jorge Rodriguez, Luis Rodriguez, Luz Rodriguez, Manuel Rodriguez, Mercedes Rodriguez, Mirian Rodriguez, Napoleon Rodriguez, Olga Rodriguez, Rosa Rodriguez, Susana Rodriguez, William Rodriguez, Olga Rodriguez-Jomarron, Alfredo Rojas, Angel Rojas, Jaime Rojas, Mario Rojas, Luis Roman, Mieczyslaw Romaniuk, Dennis Romano, Carmen Romero, Cesar Rosales, Carmen Rosario, Richard Ross, Anthony Rotondi, Jerzy Rozpedowski, Glenda Ruales, Segundo Ruales, Anthony Rudder, Casilda Ruffen, Eddie Ruggiero, James Ruggiero, John Ruggiero, Igbalija Rugovac, Arley Ruiz, Rafaela Ruiz, Tejperpab Rupnarain, Thomas Ryan, Donaldo Saavedra, Jorge Saavedra, Galit Sabo-Winer, Donald Sadowy, Blanca Saeteros, Milton Saeteros, Vincenzo Salamone, Maria Salazar, Victor Salazar, Calinda Salgado, Hipolito Salgado, Lorraine Salgado, Angela Salinas, Jan Salwa, Antwi Samuel, Manuel Sanabia, Apolinar Sanchez, Daniel Sanchez, Delta Sanchez, Edilberto Sanchez, Genaro Sanchez, George Sanchez, Javier Sanchez, Jose Sanchez, Juan Sanchez, Liliana Sanchez, Manuel Sanchez, Miyerlay Sanchez, Oscar Sanchez, Rocio Sanchez, Rosa Sanchez, Wilson Sanchez, Gabriel Sandoval, Henry Sandoya, Luis Sanguna, Leonel Sanmartin, Emanuel Santamaria, Hilda Santana, Miquel Santana, Yahira Santana, David Santos, Fernanda Santos, Joanne Santos-Masso, Edwin Sarmiento, Galo Sarmiento, Gerardo Sarmiento, Javier Sarmiento, Jose Sarmiento, Maydi Sarmiento, Pedro Sarmiento, Antonio Sarra, Gertrudis Savage, Robert Schmidt, Steven Schuler, Michaelene Schultz, David Scott, John Seagriff, Maria Segaline, James Seiferheld, Juan Sen, Alfonso Serrano, Angel Serrano, Theresa Serrano, Stanislav Shalomov, Vladimir Shalomov, Ken Shanahan, Steven Shields, Ulysses Shingles, James Short, Anthony Shubert, Martha Sibrian, Andrzej Siemek, Frank Signorile, Daniel Siguachi, Nancy Siguencia, Raul Siguencia, Antonio Silva, Carlos Silva, Enrique Silva, Fredy Silva, Ligia Silva, Luis Simancas, Larry Simes, Zoila Sinchi, George Sinerco, Eugeniusz Skrzeczkowski, Jerzy Slesicki, Janusz Sliwecki, Jeffrey Smith, Maria Solarte, Ignacio Solis, Lucio Solis, Cynthia Sosa, Jaime Sosa, Mayie Soto, Robert Sparano, Zachary Stamatakis, Joe Starace, Andrew Steckler, Maximino Sterling, Jake Stevens, Alex Stroud, Norma Suco, Margaret Sullivan, Jose Sumba, Samuel Sumba, John Sweeney, Konrad Szafranski, Zbigniew Szczepan, Miroslaw Szpanelewski, Edward Szuberla, Edward Szubski, Zbigniew Szynkowski, Janeth Tabares, Ljiljana Tabares, Mauricio Tabares, Bertha Tache, John Taggart, Sara Tallaksen, Pedro Tamayo, Cristhian Tapia, Felicia Taylor, Robert Taylor, Guy Tedaldi, Nicholas Tehan, Rocio Tenempagauy, Wilfrido Tenempaguay, Julia Tenezaca, Manuel Tenezaca, Cesareo Teran, Rocco Testa, Eric Theiss, Kevin Thomas, Jeanne Thorpe, Stephen Tighe, Brendan Tobin, Maribel Tobon, Jorge Toledo, Nelson Toledo, Rosalia Toledo, Victor Toledo, William Toledo, Aracely Toledo Naranjo, Dariusz Tomczyk, Carlos Toral, Flor Torrealba, Aida Torres, Duby Torres, Felix Torres, Javier Torres, Miguel Torres, Pedro Torres, Esperauza Trejos, Consuelo Trujillo, William Trivino, Manuel Tuapante, Jerome Tucker, Clemente Urena, Miguel Urgiles, Esperanza Urquijo, Manuel Uzhca, Miguel Uzhca, John Vaccarella, Rosa Valdez, Wilson Valdez, Aida Valdiulezo-Nieto, Hector Valdiviezo, Carlos Valencia, Gisela Valencia, Yolanda Valencia Gonzalez, John Valenti, Mario Valenzuela, Vincent Vales, Rainel Valladares, Mark Vanbelle, Edward Vanfechtmann, Gabriel Varela, Edwin Vargas, Michael Vargas, Cecilia Varicelly, Thomas Vario, Camilo Vasquez, Jose Vasquez, Klever Vasquez, Rommel Vasquez, Francisco Vazquez, Kattia Vazquez, Peter Vazquez, Robert Vazquez, Myriam Vega, Severo Vega, Felix Velarde, Rafael Velasco, Fredy Velasquez, Jose Velasquez, Jose Velesaca, Jazmin Velez, Lucrecia Velez, Nelson Velez, Alejandro Vera, Viviana Vergara, Maritza Victoria, Martha Vidal, Martin Viera, Patricia Villa, Virginia Villa, Antonio Villacres, Julio Villafuerte, Walter Villafuerte, Segundo Villarroel, Oswaldo Villavicencio, Patricia Vilomar, John Vinciguerra, Rosalia Vintimilla, Pedro Viscaino, Kodengada Viswamithra, Andrew Vitiello, David Vivar, Jose Vivar, Luis Vivar, Rosa Vivar, Peter Volpe, Jason Voss, Zbigniew Wadolowski, David Wakeen, Kazimierz Walek, Krzysztof Walek, Kevin Walsh, Thomas Walsh, Jr., Robert Waniurski, Mannix Washington, Ancil Watson, Eric Weber, William Weber, Ronald Weeks, Michael Weiser, Linda Whitley-Warren, Frank Whittle, Robert Wibrew, Romuald Wieliczko, Wlodzimierz Wierzbicki, David Wildner, Seweryn Wojciechowski, Jan Wolkowicz, Clarence Wragg, Luis Yumbla, Bolivar Zamora, Aquiles Yaguana, Armando Yamasqui, Maria Yepes, Alcibar Yumbla, Jorge Zelaya, Lawrence Zenteno, Philip Zitano, Vincent Zolfo, Franciszek Zugaj, Rafael Zumba, Victor Zuniga, Leroy Gordon, Lucyna Foremska, Stanislaw Faltynowicz, Ruben Acosta, Vladmir Akoulov, Waldemar Balcer, Joaquin Campuzano, Henryk Ciborowski, Jan Dobrowolski, Marek Glowaty, Eugeniusz Jastrzebowski, Zbigniew Kucharski, Maria Moreno, Irena Perzynaska, Marian Retelski, Dariusz Wszolkowski and Boguslaw Zalewski
Defendant:	Big Apple Wrecking & Construction Corp., Tully Construction Co., Inc., Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, Lockwood, Kessler & Bartlett, Inc., City of New York, Goldstein Associates Consulting Engineers, P.C., Gilsanz Murray Steficek LLP, Silverite Contracting Corporation, Lucius Pitkin, Inc., Leslie E. Robertson Associates, R.L.L.P., FTI Trucking Corporation, Semcor Equipment and Manufacturing Corporation, Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc., Safeway Environmental Corporation, Robert Silman Associates, P.C., Robert L. Gerosa, Inc., PT&L Contracting Corporation, Skanska Koch, Incorporated, New York City School Construction Authority, New York Crane & Equipment Corp., Skidmore Owings and Merrill, L.L.P., Vollmer Associates LLP, Turner/Plaza, A Joint Venture, Tucci Equipment Rental Corp, Pro Safety Services Incorporated, Total Safety Consulting, LLC, Nicholson Construction Company, City University of New York, Rodar Enterprises, Inc., Thornton Tomasetti, Incorporated, Nacirema Industries, Inc., Mueser Rutledge Consulting Engineers, Weidlinger Associates, Consulting Engineers, P.C., Royal GM, Inc., MRA Engineering P.C., Moretrench American Corporation, Wolkow Braker Roofing Corporation, Mazzocchi Wrecking, Inc., WSP Cantor Seinuk, LZA Technology - a division of Thornton Tomasetti, Laquila Construction, Inc., La Strada General Contracting Corporation, J.P. Equipment & Rental Materials, LLC, Hudson Meridian Construction Group LLC, HP Environmental, Inc., Hallen Welding Service, Inc., Francis A. Lee Company, Executive Medical Services, P.C., Ewell W. Finley, P.C., Evergreen Recycling of Corona, En-Tech Corp., Eagle One Roofing Contractors, Inc., E.J. Davies, Inc., DMT Enterprise, Inc., Dakota Demo-Tech, Inc., Cord Contracting Co., Incorporated, Component Assembly Systems, Inc., Canron Construction Corp., C.B. Contracting Corp., Buro Happold Consulting Engineers, P.C., Brer-Four Transportation, Turner Construction Company, A. Russo Wrecking, Inc., Atlantic-Heydt Corporation, Breeze National, Inc., Breeze Carting, Inc., New York City Department of Education, Yonkers Contracting Company, Inc., Yannuzzi & Sons, Inc., SAB Trucking, Inc., Weeks Marine, Inc, Fleet Trucking Inc., Diamond Point Excavating Corp., Simpson Gumpertz & Heger Incorporated, Diversified Carting, Inc., Peter Scalamandre and Sons, Inc., Berkel & Company, Contractors, Inc., Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellshaft, One Broadway, LLC, Kenyon & Kenyon, Trinity Centre LLC, New York Industrial Development Agency, 715 Realty Co., 127 John Street Realty LLC, Rockrose Development Corporation, New York University Real Estate Corporation, 80 Lafayette Associates, LLC, American Express Bank, Ltd., American Express Company, American Express Travel Related Services Company, Inc., BFP Tower C MM LLC, BFP Tower C. Co., LLC, Blue Millenium Realty LLC, Century 21 Department Stores LLC, Century 21, Inc., Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., Lehman Brothers Inc., Lehman Commercial Paper Inc., Mayore Estates, LLC, Mayore Estates LLC and 80 Lafayette Associates LLC, WFP Retail Co. G.P. Corp., WFP Retail Co. LP., WFP Tower A Co., WFP Tower A. Co. G.P. Corp., G.P. Corp., Sakele Brothers L.L.C., St. John's University, WFP Tower D Co., WFP Tower D Holding Co. L.L.P., WFP Tower D Holding I B.P. Corp., 53 Park Place LLC., Hudson Towers Housing Co., Inc., Lionshead Development LLC., New Liberty Plaza L.P., One Liberty Plaza Condominium, (Condo # 1178), Verizon Properties Inc., One Wall Street Corporation, Structure Tone Inc., District Council 37 of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO, Capital Properties, Inc., Grubb & Ellis Management Services, Inc., Logany LLC., 150 Broadway Corp., AT&T Wireless Services, Inc., Bailey N.Y. Associates, Brown Harris Stevens LLC, GPS Environmental Consultants, Inc., Indoor Air Professionals, Inc., Kasco Restoration Services Co., Broadway West Street Associates LP, JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., Murray Hill Properties, Brown Brothers Harriman & Co., 75 Broad LLC, A.J. Goldstein, 30 Broad Street Associates, LLC, Stoner and Company, Inc., Pace University, Capital Properties NY LLC i/s/h/a/ Capital Properties, Inc., 150 Broadway N.Y. Associates L.P., Vornado Office Management, LLC, 120 Liberty Street, LLC, 111 Wall Street LLC, 230 Central Co., LLC, 63 Wall Inc., Nasdaq, Deutsche Bank DBAB Wall Street, LLC, Bankers Trust Company, Colliers Aba, Inc., Moody's Holdings, Inc., Jemb Realty Corp., 3242 Broadway Owner LLC, American International Realty Corp., Milford Management Corp., The Board of Managers of Liberty Terrace Condominium, Syms Corp, Two Broadway LLC, Marriott Hotel Services, Inc., HMC Capital Resources LLC, MSDW 140 Broadway Property, L.L.C., 88 Greenwich LLC, Black Diamonds LLC, Borough of Manhattan Community College, Department of Small Business Services, 59 Maiden Lane Associates LLC, Mazal Group LLC, 2 Broadway LLC, Braun Management, Inc. and Daror Associates, LLC, ERP Operating Limited Partnership and Equity Residential Properties Management Corp. s/h/a Equity Residential and ERO Operating Unlimited Partnership, Newmark & Company Real Estate, Inc. i/s/h/a Newmark Knight Frank, 20 Broad Street, LLC i/s/h/a 20 Broad St. Co., 130 Cedar Street, Empire State Properties, Inc., NYSE Euronext, Jack Resnick & Sons, Inc., 315 Hudson LLC, Resnick 75 Park Place LLC, Resnick Water St. Development Co., 60 Hudson Owner, LLC, 25 Broadway Office Properties LLC, ACTA Realty Corp., Survivair Respirators, Inc., Joseph Martuscello, 114 Liberty Street Associates, 120 Greenwich Development Associates, LLC, 176 Broadway Builders Corp., 176 Broadway Owners Corp., 250 Broadway Associates, 33 Rector Street Condominium, 45 Murray Street Corp., 48 Wall LLC, AIG American International Realty Corp., Applied Environmental, Inc., CAP, Inc., Contaminant Control, Inc., J.W. Realty Co. LLC, B.R. Fries & Associates, Inc., One Liberty Plaza, Bristol Environmental, Inc., CDL New York LLC i/s/h/a CDL New York LLC Millennium Broadway, Jones Lang LaSalle Americas, Inc., Jones Lang LaSalle Services, Inc., The Board of Managers of Liberty House Condominium, Abatement Professionals, Comprehensive Environmental Services Co. and State Street Bank and Trust Company, as owner Trustee of ZSF/Office NY Trust
Defendant / Appellee:	Battery Park City Authority, WFP One Liberty Plaza Co., L.P., World Financial Properties, L.P., Brookfield Financial Properties, Inc., BFP One Liberty Plaza Co. LLC., WFP One Liberty Plaza, Co. GP., Corp.,, Blackmon-Mooring-Steamatic Catastophe, Inc., Hillman Environmental Group, LLC, The Related Realty Group, Inc., Brookfield Properties Corporation, Brookfield Financial Properties, LP, Brookfield Partners, LP, Brookfield Properties, LLC, Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc., WFP Tower B Co., G.P. Corp., WFP Tower B Co., WFP Tower D Co. L.P., WFP Tower D Holding Co. II L.P., Structure Tone Global Services, Inc., Structure Tone, (UK), Inc., Indoor Environmental Technology, Inc., Weston Solutions, Inc., Related Management Co., L.P., Related BPC Associates, Inc., 160 Water St. Inc., 100 Church, LLC, 160 Water Street Associates, Clayton Environmental Consultants, Criterion Laboratories, Inc., LVI Services, Inc., 110 Wall Street LP, 120 Broadway Properties LLC, 120 Broadway Holdings, LLC, 120 Broadway Condominium (CONDO #871), 120 Broadway, LLC, 2 Gold L.L.C., 222 Broadway, LLC, 90 Church Street Limited Partnership, 233 Broadway Owners, LLC, Abscope Environmental, Inc., Ambient Group, Inc., AMEC Construction Management, Inc., AMG Realty Partners, LP, Board of Education of the City of New York, Bankers Trust Corporation, Belfor USA Group, Inc., B.C.R.E. 90 West Street, LLC, Board of Managers of the 120 Broadway Condominium, (CONDO #871), Board of Managers of The Hudson View East Condominium, (Owner), Boston Properties, Inc., Brookfield Properties Holdings, Inc., BT Private Clients Corporation, Citibank, N.A., Central Parking System of New York, Inc., Cogswell Realty Group, L.L.C., Crown Properties, Inc., Deutsche Bank Trust Corporation, Cunningham Duct Cleaning Co., Inc., Deutsche Bank Trust Company, Envirotech Clean Air, Inc., FGP 90 West Street, Inc., G.L.O. Management, Inc., Hilton Hotels Corporation, Hudson View East Condominium, (Owner), New York City Economic Development Corporation, Law Engineering P.C., The Kibel Companies, Liberty View Associates, L.P., Milro Associates, Inc., National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc., New York City Industrial Development Agency, New York University, Nomura Holding America, Inc., Nomura Securities International, Inc., Pinnacle Environmental Corporation, Plaza Construction Corp., Related Companies, L.P., Silverstein Properties, Inc., One Wall Street Holdings, LLC., Rudin Management Co., Inc., RY Management Co., Inc., Syska and Hennessy, Verizon New York Inc., WFP Tower B Co. LP, WFP Tower B Holding Co. LP, Tribeca North End L.L.C., 110 Church LLC, Zar Realty Management Corp., TRC Engineers, Inc., Tishman Interiors Corporation, Tellabs Operations, Inc., Williams F. Collins, Architect, Crown 61 Associates L.P., Crown 61 Corp., Crown Broadway, LLC, 55 Water Street Condominium, Ann Taylor Stores Corporation, JPMorgan Chase & Co., (improperly sued herein as J.P. Morgan Chase Corporation, Chase Manhattan Bank, Chase Manhattan Bank Corporation, Chase Manhattan Banking, Chase Manhattan Banking Corporation, Chase Manhattan National Corporation, and Manufactur, Chicago 4, L.L.C., Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas, Cushman & Wakefield, Inc., General RE Services Corp., Harrahs Operating Company, Inc., Marcor Remediation, Inc., New Water Street Corporation, Bank of New York, Bank of New York Company, Inc., Tribeca Landing L.L.C., UBS Financial Services, Inc., WFP Tower D Holding I G.P. Corp. and LVI Environmental Services, Inc.
Intervenor:	State of New York
Case Number:	15-2487
Filed:	July 9, 2015
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Nature of Suit:	TORTS INJURY-Other Personal

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.