Plaintiff:	Daria Janina Wszolkowska, As Administrator of the Estate of Dariusz Wszolkowski, Monica Arce, Marek Socha, Tina L. Jones, in her capacity as the Administratrix of the Estate of James Jones, Deceased, Malgorzata Kuca, in her capacity as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Franciszek Zugaj, Deceased, Alexandra Burnett, in her capacity as Personal Representative of teh Estate of Juan Zurita, Deceased, Marco Fernandez, Elizabieta Kosousku, in their capacity as the Co-Administratrices of the Estate of Edward Kosowski, Deceased, Marcin Matuszewski, Administrator of the Estate of Marolia Matuszewski, Waldemar Ropel, Maria Puello, Tadeusz Foremska, Nicholas DiRubbo, in his capacity as Personal Representative of the Estate of Leo Dirubbo, Deceased, Robert Sienkiewicz, Miguel Zanabria, Napoli Shkolnik PLLC, Ludmila Khomik, Genowefa Kaleta-Lech, Wife of Decedent, Adam Marian Ginter, As the Administrator of the Estate of Janusz Ginter, America Peralta, Spuose of the Decedent Guido Peralta and Administratrix of the Estate, Voldymyr Khomik, Luis Hernando Alvarez, Son of the Decedent and Administrator of the Estate, Alex Anthony Sanchez, Dennis Vanfechtmann, Administrator of the Estate of Edward Vanfechtmann*, Gustavo Iturralde, Bozena Kurkowski, Tadeusz Kowalewski, Administrator Barbara NIewojt, Mayra Amaro Venegas, Elaine Mesa, in her capacity as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Monte Cesta, Deceased, Leonardo Estrella, Roseann Shubert Cimino, Administratrix of the Estate of Anthony Shubert, Deceased, Lucyna Foremska, Viasta Krysiuk, Columbina Estrella, Lois M. Rosenblatt, Public Administrator of Queens County, Gabriela Perez, Personal Representative of the Estate of Edgar Avila, Waldyslaw Kwasnik, Ryszard Krysiuk, Various plaintiffs represented by Oshman & Mirisola, LLP, Dorota Markut, Public Administrator of King County, Administrator of the Estate of Leonard Lewis, Sr., Deceased, Barbara Akus, in their capcity as the Co-Administratrices of the Estate of Edward Kosowski, Deceased, Maria Moreno, Janus Kurkowski, Jose Bello, Richard Racioppi, Edelmira Feliz, as the surviving spouse of Delio Feliz, Richard Buckheit, Public Administrator of Kings County, Rafael Valdez, Ninfra DeVito, Administratrix of the Estate of Michael DeVito, Deceased, Manuel Checo, Various plaintiffs represented by Cannata/Grochow, Noel Lorenzo, as Administrator of the Estate of Carmen Padilla, Deceased, Edward S. Mollahan, as Co-Executor of the Estate of Robert Mollahan, Deceased, Jasmin April Hernandez, Daughter and Administratrix of the Decendent's Estate and Roman Markut
Defendant:	The Bank of New York, Ann Taylor Stores Corporation, Weston Solutions, Inc., Cunningham Duct Cleaning Co., Inc., Lehman Brothers Inc., 110 Church LLC, Brown Harris Stevens Commercial Services, L.L.C., New York City Industrial Development Corporation, ATTORNEY Hillman Enviornmental Group, LLC., WFP Tower B Co., The One Liberty Plaza Condominium, Condo #1178, Brown Brothers Harriman & Co., Indoor Air Professionals, Inc., Brookfield Properties, LLC, Structure Tone Inc., Law Engineering P.C., Envirotech Clean Air, Inc., Verizon New York Inc., District Council 37, AFSCME, AFL-CIO, Lionshead Development LLC., Related Companies, L.P., 75 Broad LLC, McClier Corporation, St. John's University, Deutsche Bank, Mayore Estates LLC, Nomura Securities International, Inc., JP Morgan Chase, Board of Managers of the 120 Broadway Condominium, Condo #871, 80 Lafayette Associates, LLC, 120 Broadway Properties LLC, Deutsche Bank Trust Corporation, Nomura Holding America, Inc., WFP Tower A Co. L.P., WFP One Liberty Plaza, Co. GP., Corp.,, New York University Real Estate Corporation, Hudson Towers Housing Co., Inc., New York City School Construction Authority, Crown Properties, Inc., Bovis Lend Lease, Inc., Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas, Tribeca North End L.L.C., One Wall Street Corporation, B.R. Fries & Associates, Inc., Century 21, Inc., One Liberty Plaza, Plaza Construction Corp., 150 Broadway Corp., Mayore Estates LLC and 80 Lafayette Associates LLC, G.P. Corp., A.J. Goldstein, WFP Tower D Co., Century 21 Department Stores LLC, Brookfield Financial Properties, LP, City of New York, 120 Broadway, LLC, WFP Tower D Holding Co. L.L.P., 100 Church, LLC, Verizon Communications Inc., 120 Broadway Condominium (CONDO #871), New Liberty Plaza L.P., WFP Tower A Co., Kasco Restoration Services Co., World Financial Properties, L.P., WFP Tower D Co. L.P., 127 John Street Realty LLC, AT&T Wireless Services, Inc., WFP Tower D Holding I B.P. Corp., 150 Broadway N.Y. Associates L.P., Bankers Trust Corporation, Blue Millenium Realty LLC, New York City Department of Education, The Board of Managers of the One Liberty Plaza Condominium, Condo #1178, One Broadway, LLC, BFP Tower C. Co., LLC, Kenyon & Kenyon, FGP 90 West Street, Inc., American Stock Exchange Realty Associates, LLC, Ambient Group, Inc., Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., Structure Tone Global Services, Inc., Alan Kasman, DBA Kasco, Lefrak Organization, Inc., Logan LLC, Structure Tone, (UK), Inc., Grubb & Ellis Management Services, Inc., Tully Industries, Inc., New York University, The American Stock Exchange, GPS Environmental Consultants, Inc., The American Stock Exchange, L.L.C., Capital Properties, Inc., Sakele Brothers L.L.C., Broadway West Street Associates LP, Tully Construction Co., Inc., American Stock Exchange Clearing LLC, 120 Broadway Holdings, LLC, Lehman Commercial Paper Inc., 53 Park Place LLC., One Wall Street Holdings, LLC., Crown 61 Associates L.P., WFP Tower B Co., G.P. Corp., AMEC Construction Management, Inc., American Express Bank, Ltd., The Bank of New York, Inc., BFP One Liberty Plaza Co. LLC., New York City Economic Development Corporation, Indoor Environmental Technology, Inc., National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc., BFP Tower C MM LLC, Crown Broadway, LLC, Murray Hill Properties, WFP Tower D Holding Co. II L.P., WFP Retail Co. G.P. Corp., Blackmon-Mooring-Steamatic Catastophe, Inc., DBA BMS CAT, Zar Realty Management Corp., Stoner and Company, Inc., American Express Company, American Express Travel Related Services Company, Inc., CDL New York LLC, 222 Broadway, LLC, Turner Construction Company, Brookfield Partners, LP, General RE Services Corp., New York City Industrial Development Agency, New Water Street Corporation, WFP One Liberty Plaza Co., L.P., Brookfield Properties Holdings, Inc., Rockrose Development Corporation, TosCorp, Inc., WFP Tower A. Co. G.P. Corp., TRC Engineers, Inc., Trinity Centre LLC, Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc., Silverstein Properties, Inc., WFP Tower B Co. LP, Logany LLC., Crown 61 Corp., City University of New York, The Bank of New York Trust Company, N.A., WFP Retail Co. LP., Verizon Properties Inc., WFP Tower B Holding Co. LP, Hillman Environmental Group, LLC, 715 Realty Co., Bailey N.Y. Associates, Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance Group, PLC, Brookfield Properties Corporation, Tucker Anthony, Inc., The Bank of New York Company, Inc., Cammeby's Management Company, LLC, Capital Properties NY LLC i/s/h/a/ Capital Properties, Inc., B.C.R.E. 90 West Street, LLC, Cushman & Wakefield, Inc., Columbia Casualty Company, Db Private Clients Corporation, State Street Bank and Trust Company, as owner Trustee of ZSF/Office NY Trust, Survivair Respirators, Inc., Deutsche Bank Trust Company, MCI, Inc., Dynaserv Industries, Inc., MSDW 140 Broadway Property, L.L.C., 60 Hudson Owner, LLC, Applied Environmental, Inc., Bristol Environmental, Inc., Royal Environmental, Inc., 250 Broadway Associates, Related BPC Associates, Inc., Senex Greenwich Realty Associates, LLC, Contaminant Control, Inc., Two Broadway LLC, Borough of Manhattan Community College, Seven Hanover Associates, LLC, 100 Wall Company LLC, Black Diamonds LLC, MCI Communications Corporation, Diversified Environmental Corporation, Rudin Management Co., Inc., Allright Parking Management, Inc., Boston Properties, Inc., LVI Environmental Services, Inc., Specialty Service Contracting, Inc., Tellabs Operations, Inc., 315 Hudson LLC, 90 Church Street Limited Partnership, 30 Broad Street Associates, LLC, 63 Wall Inc., Syska and Hennessy, Comprehensive Environmental Services Co., 176 Broadway Builders Corp., NYSE Euronext, J Hill Associates, Environmental Testing, Inc., Ambassador Construction Co., Inc., 63 Wall Street, Inc., United States Department of Defense, Federal Emergency Management Agency, The Board of Managers of Liberty Terrace Condominium, Port Authority of New York & New Jersey, Morgan Stanley MGMT Capital, Inc., GLO MANAGEMENT, INC., Joseph Martuscello, Nasdaq Stock Market, Incorporated, Bankers Trust Company, Empire State Properties, Inc., 95 Maiden Member L.L.C., 48 Wall LLC, Par Environmental Corporation, Milstein Brothers Real Estate, LLC, Hygienetics Environmental Company, Inc., MCI Communications Services, Inc., Board of Managers of The Hudson View East Condominium, Owner, 88 Greenwich LLC, 120 Greenwich Development Associates, LLC, Nasdaq, Bankers Trust New York Corporation, HMC Capital Resources LLC, Milford Management Corp., 73 Warren Street, LLP, 2 Broadway LLC, Mayore Estates LLC &80 Lafayette Association LLC as Tenants in Common, 22 Cortlandt Street sub floor 1, 2, 3 and floor 1, 2, 3, Belfor USA Group, Inc., Lionshead 110 Development LLC, Eagle One Roofing Contractors, Inc., Liberty View Associates, L.P., 52 Habitat Co., RY Management Co., Inc., Jemb Realty Corp., Abscope Environmental, Inc., JPMorgan Chase & Co., improperly sued herein as J.P. Morgan Chase Corporation, Chase Manhattan Bank, Chase Manhattan Bank Corporation, Chase Manhattan Banking, Chase Manhattan Banking Corporation, Chase Manhattan National Corporation, and Manufacture, RB 52 Co. LLC, 176 Broadway Owners Corp., 114 Liberty Street Associates, Taconic Investment Partners, LLC, Board of Education of the City of New York, The Board of Managers of Liberty House Condominium, Barrington Development Corp., UBS Financial Services, Inc., FKA Swiss Bank Corporation, The Rector, Church-Wardens, and Vestrymen of Trinity Church, in the City of New York, 2 Gold L.L.C., Southbridge Towers, Inc., 230 Central Co., LLC, 130 Cedar Street, William F. Collins, Architect, Marcor Remediation, Inc., ERP Operating Limited Partnership and Equity Residential Properties Management Corp. s/h/a Equity Residential and ERO Operating Unlimited Partnership, Pace University, LVI Services, Inc., Wall Street, LLC, Syms Corp, Edison Parking Management, L.P., ACTA Realty Corp., 20 Broad Street, Hudson View East Condominium, Covino Environmental Associates, Inc., Moody's Holdings, Inc., Norwich Associates, Incorporated, Greenwich Court Condominium Association Corp., Jones Lang LaSalle Services, Inc., 233 Broadway Owners, LLC, 32-42 Broadway Owner LLC, Potomac Abatement, Inc., Related Management Co., L.P., Maiden 80/90 L.L.C., 160 Water Street Associates, Cogswell Realty Group, L.L.C., Mayore Estates LLC, 22 Cortlandt Street sub floors 1, 2, 3 and floors 1, 2, 3, Deutsche Bank DBAB Wall Street, LLC, Cushman & Wakefield 111 Wall, Inc., Tishman Interiors Corporation, Pinnacle Environmental Corporation, American International Realty Corp., Trizechahn Regional Pooling, LLC, Hilton Hotels Corporation, 25 Broadway Office Properties LLC, German American Capital Corporation, Braun Management, Inc. and Daror Associates, LLC, Jones Lang LaSalle Americas, Inc., Environmental Services and Technologies, Inc., Abatement Professionals, 111 Wall Street LLC, Milro Associates, Inc., The Kibel Companies, 10 Gold L.L.C. i/s/h/a 2 Gold L.L.C., Vornado Office Management, LLC, Colliers Abr, Inc., 40 Rector Holdings, LLC, 45 Murray Street Corp., Resnick Water St. Development Co., 33 Rector Street Condominium, Department of Small Business Services, Mazal Group LLC, RFG New York Associates, LLC, Resnick 75 Park Place LLC, JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A., CAP, Inc., Continental Casualty Company, The Witkoff Group LLC, District Council 37 Benefits Fund Trust i/s/h/a 37 Benefits Fund Trust, 130 Cedar, Newmark & Company Real Estate, Inc. i/s/h/a Newmark Knight Frank, 20 Broad Street, LLC i/s/h/a 20 Broad St. Co., 80 Lafayette Associates, LLC, 22 Cortlandt Street sub floors 1, 2, 3 and floors 1, 2, 3, TRZ Holdings, LLC, Harris Beach Settlement Administrator for AIG-Related Settlements, AIG American International Realty Corp., Environmental Products and Services, Inc., 1 Whitehall LP, CDL New York LLC i/s/h/a CDL New York LLC Millennium Broadway, Catamount Environmental, Inc., Criterion Laboratories, Inc., Darling Asbestos Disposal Company, Inc., Harrahs Operating Company, Inc., The Related Realty Group, Inc., Marriott Hotel Services, Inc., GB Development Group, Clayton Environmental Consultants, Central Parking System of New York, Inc., Tishman Construction Corporation of Manhattan, Tishman Construction Corporation of New York, Tishman Interiors Corporation, Greystone Properties, General Reinsurance Corp. i/s/h/a General Re Services Corp., BT Private Clients Corporation, Enviroserve, Inc., Milstein Properties Corp., 59 Maiden Lane Associates LLC, MK West Street Company, L.P., 120 Liberty Street, LLC, 160 Water Street, Inc., Jack Resnick & Sons, Inc., District Council 37 of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO, JP Morgan Chase Bank, National Association and Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
Plaintiff / Appellant:	William Rodriguez, Maria Alvarez, Leonardo Naranjo, Juan Caivinagua, Fabio Morales, Andrzej Korzep, Eugenio Mora, Maria Puma, Luis Bermeo, Pedro Viscaino, Nolberto Avila, Hernan Pineda, Freddy Astudillo, Alex Espinoza, Kazimierz Perkowski, Walter Gallegos, Yolanda Cintron, Maria Lluguay, Miquel Santana, Walter Marin, Stanislaw Drozdz, Lawrence Zenteno, Manuel Duchitanga, Isaac Hernandez, Fernanda Santos, Carlos Castano, Sandra McKay, Maria DeJesus, Aldo Feliciano, Segundo Naula, Richard Avila, Segundo Leon, Aida Chalco, Jacek Mrozek, Stephen Tighe, Piedad Castillo, Gil Calle, Felix Parra, Diana Galli, Teresa Bunay, Segundo Villarroel, Edilberto Sanchez, Manuel Lituma, Gloria Alvarez, Johnathan Buckley, Mauricio Tabares, Manuel Chique, Malgorzata Grabowska, Carlos Asmal, Jose Herrera, Manuel Cosme, Santiago Alvear, Jacqueline Perez, Glenn Dowd, Rossina Angulo, Samuel Guiracocha, Simon Morocho, Segundo Morales, Leo DiRubbo, Edir Giraldo, Wilmer Astudillo, Jose Coronel, John Kearney, Andrzej Chojnowski, Bertha Tache, Richard Miranda, Freddy Cordero, Aida Torres, Luis Rodriguez, Flora Davila, Rosalia Vintimilla, Michael Paternostro, Clara Dota, Flor Bunay, Rodrigo Campozano, Consuelo Campuzano, Rodrigo Barros, Bolivar Zamora, Jacek Bogacki, Maria Duchitanga, Lorraine Salgado, Emil Onzo, Lazaro Fuentes, Luis Naranjo, Jose Alvarracin, Norma Suco, Iris Zimmerman, Mario Rojas, Hector Buestan, Nancy Criollo, Julio Bastidas, Angel Duchitanga, James Carr, Maria Salazar, Luis Inga, Julio Villafuerte, Nancy Castillo, Wilson Sanchez, Rebeca Gallegos, Carlos Ali, Juan Sanchez, Rommel Vasquez, Angel Naranjo, Como Mordente, Manuel Pumacuri, Henry Sandoya, Carlos Merchan, Mieczyslaw Dabrowski, Peter Curley, Jose Sanchez, Leydi Parra, Martha Caiza, Raul Siguencia, Jan Wolkowicz, Raul Loja, Wilber Lopez, Segundo Quizhpi, Manuel Fares, Edwin Sarmiento, Bolivar Caivinagua, Jorge Saavedra, Miguel Naula, Betsy Arruda-Loor and John Kear
Not Classified By Court:	WTC Captive Insurance Company, Inc.
Defendant / Appellee:	Battery Park City Authority
Case Number:	19-2934
Filed:	September 11, 2019
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Nature of Suit:	TORTS INJURY-Other Personal

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.