In Re: Tremont Securities Law
John D. Case, Yale M. Fishman 1998 Insurance Trust, Individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated and derivatively on behalf of the nominal defendant, John Dennis, Lawrence J. Rothschild and Family Swimmers Limited Partnership |
Select Spectrum Partners, LLC, Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company, Tremont Market Neutral Fund Limited, Tremont Opportunity Fund Limited, New York Life Insurance and Annuity Corporation, Tremont Strategic Insurance Fund LP, Tremont Market Neutral Fund II, L.P., Tremont Opportunity Fund II, L.P., Rye Select Broad Market Insurance Fund LP, MassMutual Holdings LLC, Rye Select Broad Market Prime Fund, L.P., KPMG, Austin Capital Safe Harbor ERISA Dedicated Fund, Ltd., Tremont (Bermuda) Limited, Rye Select Broad Market Insurance Portfolio LDC, Argus International Life Bermuda Limited, New York Life Insurance Company, Tremont Arbitrage Fund Ireland, SSCFund Services, Tremont Group Holdings, Inc., SSCTechnologies Holdings, Inc., Tremont Capital Management Inc., BNY Alternative Investment Services, Inc., Rye Select Broad Market XL Fund, Gary Busel, Rye Investment Management, Bank of New York Mellon Corporation, Timothy Birney, Rye Select Broad Market Fund, L.P., Tremont Arbitrage Fund, L.P., Tremont International Insurance Limited, Ronald Pearson, Tremont Partners, Inc., Oppenheimer Acquisition Corporation, Austin Safe Harbor Master Account, G.P., Massmutual Holding LLC, Ernst & Young LLP, AGH and Mark Santero |
Stuart Pologe, Spectrum Select L.P., Ron Ward, Rye Select Broad Market Fund, Tremont Market Neutral Fund, Harry Hodges, Rye Select Broad Market XL Fund, L.P., Susan Hammond, FutureSelect Prime Advisor II, LLC, Jim Mitchell, Lynn O. Keeshan, Oppenheimerfunds, Inc., FutureSelect Portfolio Management, Incorporated, Robert Schulman, Rye Select Broad Market Portfolio Limited, Rupert Allan, Austin Capital Management GP Corporation, Sandra L. Manzke, Austin Capital Management Limited, Rye Select Broad Market XL Portfolio Limited and Steven Thomas Clayton |
John Johnson, Tremont Opportunity Fund III, L.P., Paul Zamrowski, Stella RuggianoTrust, West Trust, Madelyn Haines, William J. Millard Trust, Philadelphia Financial Life Assurance Company, Tremont International Insurance Fund, L.P., George P. Turner and Bindler Living Trust |
Security Life of Denver Insurance Company, Paul Funk, Nicholas P Kardasis IRA, Daniel Jackson, Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Sola Ltd., Geoffrey Rabie Credit Shelter Trust, Ronald Ward, NPV Positive Corporation, John F. Keane, Jr., Ronald Gallatin, Stephen Calabrese, Calco Painting, Incorporated, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, RCW Group, Inc., Stuart Levey, Delaware Life Insurance Company, Neal J. Polan, Jean-Marc Chouraqui, Arthur E. Lange, Individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Chateau Fiduciaire S.A., The International Dad Trust, Deborah Levey, AIG Life Insurance Company, Pacific Life Insurance Company, Arthur M. Brainson, Joanne Brenda Rabie Credit Shelter Trust, Richard A. Scherr, Group Defined Pension Plan & Trust, Nationwide Life Insurance Company, Antonio Calabrese, Solus Recovery Fund II Master LP, Dianne Ward, Solus Recovery LH Fund LP, John Patience, Individually and as Trustee for The John Patience Trust, dated June 23, 1993, Yvette Finkelstein, Ultra Master Ltd., BMIS Funding I, LLC, Levey Fishman Trust, Stuart Levey, Trustee, Harriet Rutter Klein Revocable Trust, Pruco Life Insurance Company, Arthur Simons, Lakeview Investments, LP, Metropolitan Life Assurance Company, 2001 Frederick Dematteis Revocable Trust, John Hancock Life Insurance Company, (U.S.A.), M. Kenneth Witover, Cummins Incorporated, as the authorized representative of the Cummins, Inc. Grantor Trust dated September 10, 2007, as amended, Matthew L. Klein Irrevocable Family Trust, Arthur C. Lange, Individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Judith Ludwig, Halcyon Loan Trading Fund LLC, Tremont Insurance Plaintiffs' Litigation Trust, Solus Core Opportunities Master Fund Ltd., Joseph Ludwig and Dematteis FLP Assets, LLC |
2005 Tomchin Family Charitable Trust, KPMG LLP and Phoenix Lake Partners, L.P. |
19-967 |
April 11, 2019 |
U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit |
Other |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on May 14, 2019. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
Filing 80 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [ # 75 ], on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 05/14/2019 by CM/ECF.[2562989][80] [19-967] [Entered: 05/14/2019 09:18 AM] |
Filing 78 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [ # 75 ], on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 05/14/2019 by CM/ECF.[2562937][78] [19-967] [Entered: 05/14/2019 08:47 AM] |
Filing 77 ATTORNEY, Jonathan David Berg, for Cummins Incorporated and John Patience, TERMINATED.[2562936] [19-967] [Entered: 05/14/2019 08:46 AM] |
Filing 75 OPPOSITION TO MOTION, [ # 68 ], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED. Service date 05/13/2019 by CM/ECF. [2562879] [19-967] [Entered: 05/13/2019 06:32 PM] |
Filing 70 CURED DEFECTIVE REPLY TO OPPOSITION2562028-2], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED.[2562190] [19-967] [Entered: 05/13/2019 10:54 AM] |
Filing 69 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, reply brief[66], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED.[2562189] [19-967] [Entered: 05/13/2019 10:54 AM] |
Filing 68 MOTION, for leave to respond, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 05/13/2019 by CM/ECF. [2562105] [19-967] [Entered: 05/13/2019 10:02 AM] |
Filing 67 REPLY TO OPPOSITION [ # 49 ], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED. Service date 05/13/2019 by CM/ECF.[2562028][67] [19-967] [Entered: 05/13/2019 09:29 AM] |
Filing 66 REPLY BRIEF, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED. Service date 05/10/2019 by CM/ECF. [2561575] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 03:55 PM] |
Filing 65 CURED DEFECTIVE NOTICES OF APPEARANCE [ # 63 ], [ # 62 ], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED.[2561194] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 12:18 PM] |
Filing 64 ATTORNEYS, Robert N. Cappucci, Sean Michael Riegert for Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP Arthur C. Lange Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan Neal J. Polan Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust NPV Positive Corporation Daniel Jackson Arthur E. Lange, in case 19-967 , [ # 63 ], [ # 62 ], ADDED.[2561193] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 12:17 PM] |
Filing 63 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED. Service date 05/10/2019 by CM/ECF. [2560924] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 10:38 AM] |
Filing 62 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED. Service date 05/10/2019 by CM/ECF. [2560913] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 10:31 AM] |
Filing 61 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENTS, notice of appearance[58], [57], on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED.[2560866] [19-967] [Entered: 05/10/2019 10:08 AM] |
Filing 58 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED. Service date 05/09/2019 by CM/ECF. [2560123] [19-967] [Entered: 05/09/2019 01:33 PM] |
Filing 57 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED. Service date 05/09/2019 by CM/ECF. [2560101] [19-967] [Entered: 05/09/2019 01:14 PM] |
Filing 49 OPPOSITION TO MOTION, to dismiss [ # 48 ], on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 05/06/2019 by CM/ECF. [2555882] [19-967] [Entered: 05/06/2019 08:36 AM] |
Filing 48 MOTION, to dismiss, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED. Service date 05/03/2019 by CM/ECF. [2555831] [19-967] [Entered: 05/03/2019 06:15 PM] |
Filing 47 LETTER, on behalf of Appellee Cummins Incorporated and John Patience, in re: withdrawing counsel, RECEIVED. Service date 05/03/2019 by CM/ECF.[2555297] [19-967]--[Edited 05/06/2019 by JW] [Entered: 05/03/2019 01:08 PM] |
Filing 46 CURED DEFECTIVE ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE[ # 45 ], on behalf of Appellee Arthur M. Brainson and Group Defined Pension Plan & Trust, FILED.[2555092] [19-967] [Entered: 05/03/2019 11:35 AM] |
Filing 45 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellee Arthur M. Brainson and Group Defined Pension Plan & Trust, FILED. Service date 05/03/2019 by CM/ECF.[2555004] [19-967] [Entered: 05/03/2019 11:03 AM] |
Filing 44 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, acknowledgment and notice of appearance[38], on behalf of Appellee Arthur M. Brainson, FILED.[2554825] [19-967] [Entered: 05/03/2019 09:46 AM] |
Filing 43 SO-ORDERED SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, setting Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski Brief due date as 07/02/2019. Joint Appendix due date as 07/02/2019, FILED.[2553705] [19-967]--[Edited 05/02/2019 by JW] [Entered: 05/02/2019 10:47 AM] |
Filing 40 LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, informing Court of proposed due date 07/02/2019, RECEIVED. Service date 05/02/2019 by CM/ECF.[2553445] [19-967] [Entered: 05/02/2019 07:57 AM] |
Filing 38 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellee Arthur M. Brainson, FILED. Service date 05/01/2019 by CM/ECF.[2553065] [19-967] [Entered: 05/01/2019 03:05 PM] |
Filing 37 NOTICE, to Appellee 2001 Frederick Dematteis Revocable Trust, AIG Life Insurance Company, Rupert Allan, Austin Capital Management GP Corporation, Austin Capital Management Limited, Austin Capital Management Limited, BMIS Funding I, LLC, Arthur M. Brainson, Antonio Calabrese, Stephen Calabrese, Calco Painting, Incorporated, Chateau Fiduciaire S.A., Jean-Marc Chouraqui, Steven Thomas Clayton, Cummins Incorporated, Delaware Life Insurance Company, Dematteis FLP Assets, LLC, Yvette Finkelstein, Paul Funk, FutureSelect Portfolio Management, Incorporated, FutureSelect Prime Advisor II, LLC, Ronald Gallatin, Geoffrey Rabie Credit Shelter Trust, Group Defined Pension Plan & Trust, Halcyon Loan Trading Fund LLC, Susan Hammond, Harriet Rutter Klein Revocable Trust, Harry Hodges, Joanne Brenda Rabie Credit Shelter Trust, John Hancock Life Insurance Company, Nicholas P Kardasis IRA, John F. Keane, Jr., Lynn O. Keeshan, Lakeview Investments, LP, Deborah Levey, Stuart Levey, Levey Fishman Trust, Stuart Levey, Trustee, Joseph Ludwig, Judith Ludwig, Sandra L. Manzke, Matthew L. Klein Irrevocable Family Trust, Metropolitan Life Assurance Company, Jim Mitchell, Nationwide Life Insurance Company, New York Life Insurance and Annuity Corporation, Oppenheimerfunds, Inc., Pacific Life Insurance Company, John Patience, Philadelphia Financial Life Assurance Company, Stuart Pologe, Pruco Life Insurance Company, RCW Group, Inc., Rye Select Broad Market Fund, Rye Select Broad Market Fund, L.P., Rye Select Broad Market Portfolio Limited, Rye Select Broad Market Prime Fund, L.P., Rye Select Broad Market XL Fund, L.P., Rye Select Broad Market XL Portfolio Limited, Richard A. Scherr, Robert Schulman, Security Life of Denver Insurance Company, Arthur Simons, Sola Ltd., Solus Core Opportunities Master Fund Ltd., Solus Recovery Fund II Master LP, Solus Recovery LH Fund LP, Spectrum Select L.P., The International Dad Trust, Tremont Insurance Plaintiffs' Litigation Trust, Tremont Market Neutral Fund, Ultra Master Ltd., Dianne Ward, Ron Ward, Ronald Ward and M. Kenneth Witover , for failure to file an appearance, SENT.[2552562] [19-967] [Entered: 05/01/2019 10:39 AM] |
Filing 35 NEW CASE MANAGER, Jason Wang, ASSIGNED.[2551739] [19-967] [Entered: 04/30/2019 02:19 PM] |
Filing 31 ATTORNEY, Arthur Nealon for Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP Arthur C. Lange Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan Neal J. Polan Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust NPV Positive Corporation Daniel Jackson Arthur E. Lange, in case 19-967, [ # 28 ], ADDED.[2549309] [19-967] [Entered: 04/26/2019 12:16 PM] |
Filing 29 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 04/25/2019 by CM/ECF.[2548874] [19-967] [Entered: 04/25/2019 09:44 PM] |
Filing 28 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Arthur E. Lange, Arthur C. Lange, Neal J. Polan, NPV Positive Corporation, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan and Daniel Jackson, FILED. Service date 04/25/2019 by CM/ECF. [2548869] [19-967] [Entered: 04/25/2019 07:57 PM] |
Filing 27 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellee Arthur E. Lange Revocable Trust, Eastham Capital Appreciation Fund LP, Daniel Jackson, Laborers Local 17 Pension Plan, Arthur C. Lange, Arthur E. Lange, NPV Positive Corporation and Neal J. Polan, FILED. Service date 04/25/2019 by CM/ECF.[2548868] [19-967] [Entered: 04/25/2019 07:52 PM] |
Filing 25 FORM D, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 04/25/2019 by CM/ECF.[2547888] [19-967] [Entered: 04/25/2019 09:14 AM] |
Filing 24 FORM C, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. Service date 04/23/2019 by CM/ECF.[2546519] [19-967] [Entered: 04/23/2019 04:33 PM] |
Filing 22 ATTORNEY, Stephanie M. Beige, [ # 21 ], in place of attorney Uri Seth Ottensosser, Jeffrey David Lerner, SUBSTITUTED.[2542838] [19-967] [Entered: 04/18/2019 10:28 AM] |
Filing 21 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL, on behalf of Appellee Arthur M. Brainson, Yvette Finkelstein and Group Defined Pension Plan & Trust, FILED. Service date 04/18/2019 by CM/ECF. [2542822] [19-967] [Entered: 04/18/2019 10:17 AM] |
Filing 18 LETTER, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, regarding keeping the caption the same as prior case number 15-3011, RECEIVED. Service date 04/16/2019 by CM/ECF.[2541358] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 02:44 PM] |
Filing 13 NON-ADMITTED ATTORNEY, Attorney Ralph C. Perry-Miller, Esq. for Appellee The International Dad Trust, orally informed to apply for admission forthwith and submit Addendum A to Notice of Appearance, NOTIFIED.[2541014] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:31 AM] |
Filing 12 NON-ADMITTED ATTORNEY, Attorney Kevin M. Harr, Esq. for Phoenix Lake Partners, L.P. and Appellee Lakeview Investments, LP, orally informed to apply for admission forthwith and submit Addendum A to Notice of Appearance, NOTIFIED.[2541013] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:31 AM] |
Filing 11 NON-ADMITTED ATTORNEY, Attorney Joseph Gleason Minias, Esq. for Appellee Sola Ltd., Solus Core Opportunities Master Fund Ltd., Solus Recovery Fund II Master LP, Solus Recovery LH Fund LP, Ultra Master Ltd. and Halcyon Loan Trading Fund LLC, orally informed to apply for admission forthwith and submit Addendum A to Notice of Appearance, NOTIFIED.[2541012] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:30 AM] |
Filing 10 NON-ADMITTED ATTORNEY, Attorney David Gorvitz, Esq. for Appellee Arthur Simons, Antonio Calabrese, Stephen Calabrese, Calco Painting, Incorporated, Richard A. Scherr, Paul Funk, Joseph Ludwig, Judith Ludwig, Stuart Levey, Deborah Levey, Levey Fishman Trust, Stuart Levey, Trustee, Nicholas P Kardasis IRA and Jean-Marc Chouraqui, orally informed to apply for admission forthwith and submit Addendum A to Notice of Appearance, NOTIFIED.[2541010] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:29 AM] |
Filing 9 ELECTRONIC INDEX, in lieu of record, FILED.[2541004] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:25 AM] |
Filing 5 PAYMENT OF DOCKETING FEE, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, district court receipt # ANYSDC-16669728, FILED.[2540990] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:22 AM] |
Filing 4 DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT, dated 03/18/2019, RECEIVED.[2540988] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:20 AM] |
Filing 3 DISTRICT COURT ORDER, dated 03/15/2019, RECEIVED.[2540986] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:19 AM] |
Filing 2 MAGISTRATE REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION, dated 02/11/2019, RECEIVED.[2540977] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:15 AM] |
Filing 1 NOTICE OF CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Bindler Living Trust, Madelyn Haines, John Johnson, Stella RuggianoTrust, George P. Turner, West Trust, William J. Millard Trust and Paul Zamrowski, FILED. [2540964] [19-967] [Entered: 04/16/2019 11:11 AM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.