Defendant:	Adelphia Supply USA, Yudah Neuman, AKA Lenny Neuman, Reuven Sobel, AKA Chaim Sobel, Moses Neuman, Shmuel Lezell, Save Rite Medical.com LLC, Marc Kaplan, Matrix Distributors, Inc., Christopher Benevent, Seth Grumet, Papoutsanis USA, LLC, DBA VIP International-Drogaris, George Drogaris, OSD Capital, Inc., FKA Farnes Enterprises Corporation, Overstockdrugstore.com LLC, DBA SimpleMed Supply, Rick Evenson, Kevin Plumb, Budget Health Corporation, DBA Budget Drugs Pharmacy, John Fandetti, Robert Newmyer, Maria Fandetti, Lori Blue, Anthony Meola, Mark D. Henkin, Dream Cereal Inc., DBA Diabetessupplies4less.com, Douglas Hauck, Berkeley Drugs Inc., Majid Hameed, Eugene Ha, Careway Pharmacy Inc., Anatoliy Fain, Harrico-Galler Drug Corporation, John Gallagher, Haber J&N Inc., DBA The Modern Chemist, Naomi Haber, Jerry Haber, Norstrand Pharmacy, LLC, DBA Vanderveer Pharmacy, Sarathchandra Adusumalli, Hemagiri Gayam, Lev RX Corp, DBA Kiras Pharmacy, Kira Levkouskaya, Eliyahus Pharmacy, Inc., Ilias Mlabasati, Global Care Pharmacy, Inc., D.K.Y. Enterprises, Inc., DBA 8th Avenue Pharmacy, Kim Ping Jim, TGIS Pharmacy, Inc., DBA Sunrise Family Pharmacy, Sajid Javed, Bay Pharmacy Inc., Irene Piker, B & T Marlboro Pharmacy, Inc., Anatoly Gorokhovsky, Larke Drugs, Inc., DBA 110 Pharmacy & Surgical, Prasad Venigalla, La Ruche Pharmacy, Inc., Sunil B. Patel, Estates Pharmacy, Inc., Mohammed Nuruddin, John Doe, 1-10, Novex America, Dennis Cantor, Tri-State Medical Supplies Equip. Corp., Erwin Ganzfried, Mordechai Kritzler, Value Wholesale, Inc., Diane Brown, Medical Discount Services, Inc., Brian Mesika, Darryl Schreiber, Xpress Medical Supplies Corp., DBA Payless Distributors, Mohammed Patel, Zubeda Moti, Muhammad Arif, Saps Drug Wholesale, Inc., Vilas Asmin, Rajesh Amin, Nimesh Amin, Ixthus Medical Supply, Inc., Karl Kunstman, Comply USA Inc., Irany Nir, Ofek Messika, Kimberly Paszkiewicz, Drugplace, Inc., Paul Leight, Kevin Singer, HMF Distributing Inc., Wholesale Diabetic Supplies Inc., Ross Trager, Matthew Frank, Primed Pharmaceuticals LLC, Vincent Mondenado, Matthew Zeigler, NE Medical Supply USA, Inc., Danielle Wayne, Nick Wayne, TAS Medical Supply Company, Inc., Tzvi Sklarz, Product Performance Company, Inc., Jerrold Herman, Stephen Herman, Med-Plus, Inc., Roger Mezhibovsky, Delray Marketing, LLC, Steve Michaels, Diabetic Pharmacy Solutions, LLC, Karl Bucholz, Globe Wanted, Massalah Trading U.S.A. Ltd., Saad Haddad, AKA Sam, Havemeyer Pharmacy Inc., AKA South Second Pharmacy, Michael Bassanell, 6122 Pharmacy, Inc., 86th Street Community Pharmacy, Able Wholesalers of Tennessee, Absolute Freight Services, Advanced Pharmacy LLC, Advanced Scripts Inc., Albert Kritzler, Alpeshkumar Vasani, Amexpo International, LLC, Amin Pharmacy, Inc., An-Noor Pharmacy Inc., Ashraf Awad, Astute Healthcare Limited, DBA e-net solution, Attila Kekesi, Avi Frankman, Bell Apothecary, Inc., Benjamin Walvoord, Jani Bhagvat, Bhanumati Patel, Bisham Singh Ghotra, Bob-Bila Distributors, Inc., Brian Boeshart, Brian Mcclelland, Bridesburg Pharmacy, Carepointe Health Care Corporation, Carl Telander, Casharim Trading, AKA Cashrim, Chaim Greenfield, Chaoying Xuan, Chaya Braish, Childrens Clinic Pharmacy, Christopher Aarons, Clinton Herman, Coolrelic, Inc., Danjal Hansen, Danny Katz, David John Tipp, Deals2000 LLC, DBA Justdiabeticteststrips.com, Dedac Nguyen, Deepak Munshi, Delwar Kahn, Dennis Charles Pay, Desai's Pharmacy Inc., Diptibahen Pateldefe, Discovery Pharmacy Inc., Douglas Parker Rudderham, Dwayne Porter, East Tremont Pharmacy Inc., Eduardo Gil, Edward Connell, Erik Berg, Express Chemist, FCL Health Solutions Ltd., Fifty50 Medical, LLC, G&P Supplies, Inc., Gabecare Direct Rx, Inc., Gary Kagan, George Lynch, AKA Rick, Glendale Prescription Center, Inc., Globalmed Limited, AKA Globalmed Pharmaceutical Wholesaler, Goodlife Pharmacy Inc., Goolam Sheikh, Gregory Peter Santulli, Gregory S. Dixon, Gregory Sargent, Gurpreet Singh, Guy Savia, Hanna Nguyen, Harmanpreet Bal, Hetasveeben Mahendrabhai Vanapariya, Hironori Mitsuishi, Hsiu Sargent, Insight Designs, Inc., Issa Kashou, Jacqueline Herrera, James H. Redecopp, Jason Grama, Jasvir Singh Sohi, Jennifer Herman, Jenny Nguyen, Jiri Svec, Joel Silberstein, John Seal, Johnny K. Chan, Jonathan Nikolas Woods, Joseph Karas, Joyce Mogil, Kenneth Ruiz, Keyur Shah, Kiri Patel, Konie Minga, Konstantinos Polychronopoulos, Krunal Vasani, Kulbir Singh Sohi, Lafayette Drugs, Larry E. Smith, Laurynas Lemesovas, Leonid Beigelman, Leslie Boeshart, Leslie Stewart Jones, Lightbox Medical LLC, Lubna Arshad, Luis Santiago, Luis Soto, M & L Brothers Pharmacy, Inc., Magchop, LLC, Manifest Pharmacy LLC, Manish Mittal, Mark Mogil, Marleny Canete, Maulik Shah, Medex Supply Distributors Inc., Medical Care Supplies Inc., Medical Discount Services, LLC, DBA Medical Whole Sale Supplies, Medworld Supply Inc., FKA SP Dist. Inc., Misar LLC, Mohammad Arshad, Monsur Chowdhury, Moshe Braish, Mujjahid ul Huq, N A & S Drugs, Inc., DBA Falcon Healthmart Drugs, N Hosking & S Duffell, DBA Towers Pharmacy, Nabila Chaudhry, Nachman Neil Feig, Nader Parsian, National Medical Management, Neil J. Hosking, Nessin Ussein, Nigel Huw Bush, Noemi Ruiz, Nouri Fitha, NPR BioMedical Inc., NWHOLESALEDEAL, Inc., Oliver Suess, Oxford Pharmacy, Inc., Paritosh Mazumder, Pat Kekesi, Patricia Herman, Paul Michael Capper, Perfecto H. Hallon, Peter E. Sutulov, Pharma Supply, Inc., Pharmacy Wholesale Services Inc., AKA Professional Pharmacy Wholesale Services Inc., Physician Choice Pharmacy LLC, Power Distribution Enterprises LLC, Pranam Healthcare LLC, DBA San Pedro Pharma Inc., Premier Equipment Solutions, Inc., Product Ltd., Priority Care Pharmacy LLC, AKA Priority Healthcare Corp., Product Trade Services Ltd., Qaiser Chaudhry, QRx Pharmacy and Healthcare Supplies, Inc., DBA QRx2 Pharmacy & Medical Supplies Inc., Raanan Cohen, Raleigh Paolella-Titschinger, Ralph Amato, Ran Lev, Randy Tammara, Rosemary Elizabeth Ann Pay, Sam Zighelboim, Santa Zawaideh, Savoy Medical Products, LLC, Sharine Xuan, Shenay Ussein, Sherwood Prime, Inc., DBA Sherwood Medical Supplies, Shie Greenfield, Shrinathji Rx Inc., DBA Lansdale Rx Pharmacy, Simon R. Duffell, Smartway Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Smartway PW Holdings Ltd., Spyridon Psonis, DBA Parapharmacy Store, Stampmatic, Stephanie Huq, Stephen M. Krause, Steven Tammara, Steven Thuss, Steven W. Laba, Tadas Lemesovas, TDC Pharmaceutical Corporation, Inc., DBA Vital Health Pharmacy, TDP Trading, Inc., Terrific Care LLC, DBA Deanwood Nursing, Thomas Gulik, Thuy Pham, AKA Denis Pham, AKA Huy Pham, Tiffany Riggs, Anthony Kvenvold, Wynne Treanor-Kvenvold, Tori Goldsten, Total Pharmacy Inc., DBA EZ Pharmacy, Trusted Medical Supply LLC, Valley Liquidation Services LLC, DBA VLS, LLC, Vickie Martino, Vinh Huynh, William Semaan, YS Marketing Inc., FKA NuMed Pharma Inc., Yusuf Muse, AKA Yusuf Mohamed, Yuxin Xuie, YX Enterprices Corp, Z Worldwide, Inc., 86 Street Pharmacy, Al Gray, DBA S D'Frog, David Strathy, DBA Bargin Pawn, Ella Sela, DBA Ella's Vision, Jigal Patel, AKA Jignal Patel, Kimberly Stevens, DBA Strips2Cash, Kong Cheung, AKA Kong Carl Cheng Tung, Lehigh Pharmacy & Supplies, Inc., Sayed Raza, AKA Syed Hasan, Mir Darwichzada, Wholesaler Defendants, represented by Goodman & Saperstein, Gottlieb & Janey, and Stern & Schurin, Lori Goldman and E-Pharm Wholesalers, Inc.
Plaintiff / Appellee:	Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Diabetes Care Inc. and Abbott Diabetes Care Sales Corporation
Intervenor:	Jason Yert and Kerr Russell and Weber PLC
Defendant / Appellant:	H&H Wholesale Services, Inc. and Howard Goldman
Case Number:	23-449
Filed:	March 28, 2023
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Nature of Suit:	PROPERTY RIGHTS-Trademark

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.