Bruckauf v. Aviles-Ramos
Plaintiff: OLIVER BRUCKAUF, as Parent and Natural Guardian of E.B. and Individually, JANERIS RODRIGUEZ MEJIA, as Parent and Natural Guardian of E.R. and Individually, MAYTINEE BIRD, as Parent and Natural Guardian of H.C. and individually, DONNA CORNETT, as Parent and Natural Guardian of J.B. and Individually, KAMOLPORN LUMMAYOS, as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.L. and Individually, CLAUDIA RIVAS, as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C. and Individually, SANDRA LEE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of V.G. and Individually, MADELINE GRULLON, as Parent and Natural Guardian of C.B. and Individually, MARIA HIDALGO, as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S. and Individually, ADEJUMOKE OGUNLEYE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of D.O. and Individually, ROSA ELBA DE PAULINO, as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P. and Individually, MARTINE THOMAS, as Parents and Natural Guardians of A.T.1 and Individually, SCOTT THOMAS, as Parents and Natural Guardians of A.T.1 and Individually, SHANTEL TALLEY, as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.C. and Individually, MARLENE VASQUEZ, as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.C. and Individually, LINDA LARACHCOHEN, as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.C. and Individually, MARILYN BECKFORD, as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.B. and Individually, PATRICK DONOHUE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.J.D and Individually and CRYSAL CROSLEY, as Parent and Natural Guardian of Z.C. and Individually
Defendant: MELISSA AVILES-RAMOS, in her official capacity as Chancellor of the New York City Department of Education and NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
Case Number: 26-523
Filed: March 6, 2026
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Nature of Suit: Civil Rights
RSS RSS Track this Docket
Docket Report

This docket was last retrieved on April 17, 2026. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.

Date Filed Document Text
April 17, 2026 Filing 54 LETTER, dated 04/17/2026, informing of docket numbers for the Supreme Court matters are 25A1129 and 25A1143, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, RECEIVED. Service date 04/17/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 04/17/2026 01:09 PM] [Edited: 04/20/2026 01:19 PM]
April 9, 2026 Filing 53 LETTER, dated 04/09/2026, informing that a petition under Supreme Court Rule 20; and (2) an application under Supreme Court Rule 22 were filed in the Supreme Court of the United States, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, RECEIVED. Service date 04/09/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 04/09/2026 04:12 PM] [Edited: 04/10/2026 03:55 PM]
April 2, 2026 Filing 52 LETTER, dated 04/02/2026, in reponse to to Appellees' letter (Dkt. 49.l) to advise the Court of a concrete development bearing directly on the pending emergency motion, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, RECEIVED. Service date04/02/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 04/02/2026 03:25 PM] [Edited: 04/03/2026 02:34 PM]
April 1, 2026 Filing 51 ATTORNEY, David J. Markese, for Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, ADDED. [Entered: 04/01/2026 08:55 AM]
March 31, 2026 Filing 50 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL/ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/31/2026 05:55 PM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 49 LETTER, dated 03/30/2026, submitting this response to the Appellant's letters dated 03/29/2026 and 03/30/2026, on behalf of Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, RECEIVED. Service date 03/30/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/30/2026 07:55 PM] [Edited: 04/01/2026 08:33 AM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 48 REPLY TO OPPOSITION, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/30/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/30/2026 06:31 PM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 47 ATTORNEY, Nicole Lancia, for Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, ADDED. [Entered: 03/30/2026 03:26 PM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 46 LETTER, dated 03/30/2026, advsing the Court of two developments that have occured since Appellant's letter of 03/28/2026, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, RECEIVED. Service date 03/30/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/30/2026 02:44 PM] [Edited: 03/30/2026 03:32 PM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 45 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL/ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/30/2026 01:04 PM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 44 MOTION ORDER, denying motion to strike document at docket entry 37. Appellants may file a reply within seven days of this order, by 04/06/2026, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/30/2026 11:29 AM]
March 30, 2026 Filing 43 SO-ORDERED SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, setting Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, Appendix due date as 05/19/2026, Brief due date as 05/19/2026, FILED. [Entered: 03/30/2026 09:30 AM]
March 29, 2026 Filing 42 LETTER, dated 03/28/2026 to advise this Court of a motion filed in the District Court on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, RECEIVED. Service date 03/29/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/29/2026 01:39 AM] [Edited: 03/30/2026 10:23 AM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 41 LR 31.2 SCHEDULING NOTIFICATION, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, informing Court of proposed due date 05/19/2026, RECEIVED. Service date 03/27/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/27/2026 06:35 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 40 REPLY TO OPPOSITION, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/27/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/27/2026 06:34 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 39 OPPOSITION, to Motion to strike document, at docket entry 37, on behalf of Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, FILED. Service date 03/27/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/27/2026 04:45 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 38 CURED DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Motion Opposition, at entry 34, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/27/2026 03:06 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 37 MOTION, to strike document, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/27/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/27/2026 02:18 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 36 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Motion Opposition, at docket entry 34, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/27/2026 01:12 PM]
March 27, 2026 Filing 35 CURED DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Reply to Opposition, at entry 25, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/27/2026 10:24 AM]
March 26, 2026 Filing 34 OPPOSITION, to SUR-REPLY on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/26/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/26/2026 05:37 PM] [Edited: 03/27/2026 10:16 AM]
March 26, 2026 Filing 33 REPLY TO OPPOSITION, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/26/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/26/2026 04:55 PM]
March 26, 2026 Filing 32 NEW CASE MANAGER, Brenda Mojica, ASSIGNED. [Entered: 03/26/2026 08:27 AM]
March 24, 2026 Filing 31 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Reply to Opposition, at docket entry 25, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/24/2026 11:05 AM]
March 24, 2026 Filing 30 ATTORNEY, Richard Paul Dearing, for Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, ADDED. [Entered: 03/24/2026 10:52 AM]
March 23, 2026 Filing 29 OPPOSITION, to Motion for injunction, at docket entry 13, on behalf of Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, FILED. Service date 03/23/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/23/2026 02:16 PM] [Edited: 03/24/2026 05:16 PM]
March 23, 2026 Filing 28 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, FILED. Service date 03/23/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/23/2026 01:54 PM]
March 23, 2026 Filing 27 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Melissa Aviles-Ramos, New York City Department of Education, FILED. [Entered: 03/23/2026 10:38 AM] [Edited: 03/24/2026 10:50 AM]
March 20, 2026 Filing 26 PAYMENT OF DOCKETING FEE, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, district court receipt #ANYSDC-32573472., FILED. [Entered: 03/20/2026 06:34 PM]
March 20, 2026 Filing 25 REPLY TO OPPOSITION, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/20/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/20/2026 05:24 PM]
March 16, 2026 Filing 24 CERTIFIED ORDER, dated 03/16/2026, to SDNY-NY, ISSUED. [Entered: 03/16/2026 02:35 PM]
March 16, 2026 Filing 23 MOTION ORDER, referring the motion for injunction to a three-judge motions panel and declining to grant interim relief pending decision by the panel at docket entry 13, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, by BR, FILED. [Entered: 03/16/2026 02:28 PM]
March 16, 2026 Filing 22 ATTORNEY, Devin Slack, for Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, ADDED. [Entered: 03/16/2026 08:03 AM]
March 13, 2026 Filing 21 OPPOSITION, to Motion for injunction, at docket entry 13, on behalf of Appellee Melissa Aviles-Ramos, Appellee New York City Department of Education, FILED. Service date 03/13/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/13/2026 03:53 PM]
March 13, 2026 Filing 20 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Melissa Aviles-Ramos, New York City Department of Education, FILED. [Entered: 03/13/2026 01:29 PM] [Edited: 03/16/2026 08:01 AM]
March 13, 2026 Filing 19 CURED DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Form C, at entry 17, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/13/2026 12:55 PM]
March 13, 2026 Filing 18 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Form C, at docket entry 14, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/13/2026 12:48 PM]
March 12, 2026 Filing 17 FORM C, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/12/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/12/2026 06:03 PM]
March 12, 2026 Filing 16 ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/12/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/12/2026 05:44 PM]
March 12, 2026 Filing 15 FORM D, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/12/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/12/2026 05:42 PM]
March 12, 2026 Filing 14 FORM C, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/12/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/12/2026 05:41 PM]
March 12, 2026 Filing 13 MOTION, for injunction, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/12/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/12/2026 05:40 PM]
March 11, 2026 Filing 12 CURED DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Motion, to file oversized motion, at entry 10, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/11/2026 01:16 PM]
March 11, 2026 Filing 11 DEFECTIVE DOCUMENT, Motion, at docket entry 9, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Crysal Crosley, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/11/2026 01:14 PM]
March 11, 2026 Filing 10 MOTION, to file oversized motion, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/11/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/11/2026 09:52 AM] [Edited: 03/11/2026 01:10 PM]
March 10, 2026 Filing 9 MOTION, to file oversized brief, on behalf of Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, FILED. Service date 03/10/2026 by ACMS. [Entered: 03/10/2026 05:49 PM]
March 9, 2026 Filing 8 ATTORNEY, Rory Jude Bellantoni, for Appellant Oliver Bruckauf, Appellant Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Appellant Maytinee Bird, Appellant Donna Cornett, Appellant Kamolporn Lummayos, Appellant Claudia Rivas, Appellant Sandra Lee, Appellant Madeline Grullon, Appellant Maria Hidalgo, Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Appellant Rosa Elba de Paulino, Appellant Martine Thomas, Appellant Scott Thomas, Appellant Shantel Talley, Appellant Marlene Vasquez, Appellant Linda LarachCohen, Appellant Marilyn Beckford, Appellant Patrick Donohue, Appellant Crysal Crosley, ADDED. [Entered: 03/09/2026 12:59 PM]
March 9, 2026 Filing 7 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL/ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/09/2026 12:34 PM]
March 9, 2026 Filing 6 ATTORNEY, Amy McCamphill, in place of attorney Steven Banks, SUBSTITUTED. [Entered: 03/09/2026 10:47 AM]
March 9, 2026 Filing 5 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AS SUBSTITUTE COUNSEL/ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, on behalf of Melissa Aviles-Ramos, New York City Department of Education, FILED. [Entered: 03/09/2026 09:52 AM]
March 6, 2026 Filing 4 ELECTRONIC INDEX, in lieu of record, FILED. [Entered: 03/06/2026 05:03 PM]
March 6, 2026 Filing 3 INTERLOCUTORY CIVIL APPEAL, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, OPENED. [Entered: 03/06/2026 01:31 PM]
March 6, 2026 Filing 2 DISTRICT COURT ORDER, dated 03/05/2026, RECEIVED. [Entered: 03/06/2026 01:27 PM]
March 6, 2026 Filing 1 NOTICE OF INTERLOCUTORY CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Adejumoke Ogunleye, Claudia Rivas, Crysal Crosley, Donna Cornett, Janeris Rodriguez Mejia, Kamolporn Lummayos, Linda LarachCohen, Madeline Grullon, Maria Hidalgo, Marilyn Beckford, Marlene Vasquez, Martine Thomas, Maytinee Bird, Oliver Bruckauf, Patrick Donohue, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Sandra Lee, Scott Thomas, Shantel Talley, FILED. [Entered: 03/06/2026 01:26 PM]

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Search for this case: Bruckauf v. Aviles-Ramos
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: OLIVER BRUCKAUF, as Parent and Natural Guardian of E.B. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: JANERIS RODRIGUEZ MEJIA, as Parent and Natural Guardian of E.R. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MAYTINEE BIRD, as Parent and Natural Guardian of H.C. and individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: DONNA CORNETT, as Parent and Natural Guardian of J.B. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: KAMOLPORN LUMMAYOS, as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.L. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: CLAUDIA RIVAS, as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: SANDRA LEE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of V.G. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MADELINE GRULLON, as Parent and Natural Guardian of C.B. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MARIA HIDALGO, as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: ADEJUMOKE OGUNLEYE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of D.O. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: ROSA ELBA DE PAULINO, as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MARTINE THOMAS, as Parents and Natural Guardians of A.T.1 and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: SCOTT THOMAS, as Parents and Natural Guardians of A.T.1 and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: SHANTEL TALLEY, as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.C. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MARLENE VASQUEZ, as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.C. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: LINDA LARACHCOHEN, as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.C. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: MARILYN BECKFORD, as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.B. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: PATRICK DONOHUE, as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.J.D and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: CRYSAL CROSLEY, as Parent and Natural Guardian of Z.C. and Individually
Represented By: Jeffrey Arlen Spinner
Represented By: Rory Jude Bellantoni
Represented By: David Markese
Represented By: Nicole Lancia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: MELISSA AVILES-RAMOS, in her official capacity as Chancellor of the New York City Department of Education
Represented By: Steven Banks
Represented By: Amy McCamphill, ASCOC
Represented By: Devin Slack
Represented By: Richard Paul Dearing
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
Represented By: Steven Banks
Represented By: Amy McCamphill, ASCOC
Represented By: Devin Slack
Represented By: Richard Paul Dearing
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?