Kirschbaum v. Reliant Energy Inc
Brad Kirschbaum, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated |
Raymond Royer |
American Association of Retired Persons, National Employment Lawyers Association and Elaine L. Chao, Secretary, Department of Labor |
Reliant Energy, Incorporated, T. Milton Honea, Milton Carroll, John T. Cater, Richard E. Balzhiser, James A. Baker, III, Benefits Committee of Reliant Energy, David M. McClanahan, Mary P. Ricciardello, Gary Whitlock, Lee Hogan, Waters S. Davis, IV, Steve Schaeffer and Tom Standish |
06-20157 |
March 3, 2006 |
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit |
Securities, Commodities, Exchange |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on May 21, 2008. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
Record on appeal returned to USDC. SEALED: 1 box Electronic ROA Recycled:[Y/N] Y . [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 05/21/2008 03:55 PM] |
Record on appeal returned to 5CCA. Volumes: 38 SEALED: 1 box [06-20157] Case Management ddl satisfied. (Jd) [Entered: 05/21/2008 03:55 PM] |
Mandate issued. Approved BOC Issued (Y/N)?: Y [06-20157] Mandate pull date satisfied. (SBS) [Entered: 05/19/2008 08:31 AM] |
Bill of costs filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish. Sufficient [Y/N]: Y . [6018444-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 05/01/2008 02:32 PM] |
Opinion filed. Issd in T form? Y Mandate pull date is 5/16/08. [06-20157] (RMF) [Entered: 04/25/2008 02:51 PM] |
Judgment entered and filed. [06-20157] (RMF) [Entered: 04/25/2008 02:54 PM] |
Response/opposition filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish to R28(j) letter filed 6/17/07 [ # 5777261-1 ] by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Raymond Royer Sufficient [Y/N]: y [6007726-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 04/17/2008 11:51 AM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [6003359-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 04/11/2008 01:16 PM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish. [5968048-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 02/25/2008 11:37 AM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5968422-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 02/25/2008 03:38 PM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5933705-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 01/09/2008 12:52 PM] |
Filing letter of Amicus Curiae Elaine Chao dated 10/3/07 referencing 9th Circuit Case 06-15013 (Phelps v Calpine) Sufficient [Y/N]: y [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 10/04/2007 01:02 PM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5860378-1] [06-20157] (Jd) [Entered: 10/01/2007 01:51 PM] |
Oral argument heard. Case argued by Robert A Izard for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, James Edward Maloney for Appellee Tom Standish, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Reliant Energy Inc Elizabeth Hopkins for Amicus Curiae Elaine Chao [06-20157] (PFT) [Entered: 10/01/2007 10:21 AM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5858805-1] [06-20157] (PFT) [Entered: 09/28/2007 10:15 AM] |
Response/opposition filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish to FRAP 28(j) [ # 5858805-1 ] by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Raymond Royer Date of COS: 09/28/07 Sufficient [Y/N]: y [5859526-1] [06-20157] (PFT) [Entered: 09/28/2007 03:42 PM] |
COURT Order filed granting unopposed motion to participate in oral argument [ # 5845590-1 ] Copies e-mailed to counsel. [06-20157] (GAM) [Entered: 09/14/2007 02:46 PM] |
Unopposed motion filed by Amicus Curiae Elaine Chao to participate in oral argument on time ceded by Appellants [5845590-1] Date of COS: 09/07/07 Sufficient [Y/N]: y [06-20157] (PFT) [Entered: 09/12/2007 09:25 AM] |
Case calendared for oral argument. [06-20157] (PFT) [Entered: 08/21/2007 03:59 PM] |
Case tentatively calendared for oral argument Week of: 10/01/07. [06-20157] (GAM) [Entered: 07/31/2007 09:56 AM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish. [5780159-1] [06-20157] (CNF) [Entered: 06/20/2007 12:07 PM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5777261-1] [06-20157] (CNF) [Entered: 06/18/2007 01:21 PM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [5670825-1] [06-20157] (CNF) [Entered: 02/07/2007 11:58 AM] |
Supplemental authorities (FRAP 28(j)) filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish. (SEND TO SCREENING JUDGE AND PANEL) [5667075-1] [06-20157] (CNF) [Entered: 02/02/2007 04:09 PM] |
Record on appeal filed. Vol(s) of Electronic Pleadings: 35 Vol(s) of Electronic Transcripts: 3 SEALED: box (sealed docs.- 33, 97, 101, 110-112, 115, 153, 154, 169-171, 173, 174, 177-181) [06-20157] ROA ddl satisfied. (CNF) [Entered: 02/02/2007 11:22 AM] |
Record requested from district court. [06-20157] ROA due on 12/7/06. (SBS) [Entered: 11/22/2006 03:11 PM] |
Reply brief filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [5611460-1] [06-20157] Reply Brief ddl satisfied. , (SBS) [Entered: 11/22/2006 03:09 PM] |
The attorney Marissa M Tirona for Natl Empl Lawr Assn not participating in case. [06-20157] (JMW) [Entered: 11/16/2006 09:53 AM] |
CLERK Order filed granting unopposed motion to extend time to file Reply Brief [ # 5574664-1 ] Reply Brief ddl updated to 11/16/06 for Raymond Royer, for Brad Kirschbaum. Copies to all counsel. [06-20157] (CNF) [Entered: 10/16/2006 04:04 PM] |
Unopposed motion filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer to extend time to file reply brief until 11/16/06 [5574664-1] Date of COS: 9/19/06 Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [06-20157] (JMW) [Entered: 10/11/2006 10:33 AM] |
Letter filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer giving authorization for us to file the motion for extension of time to file reply brief rec'd 9/20/06. [5574652-1] [06-20157] (JMW) [Entered: 10/11/2006 10:23 AM] |
Appellee's Brief filed by Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish. Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [5573916-1] [06-20157] E/Res's Brief ddl satisfied. Reply Brief due on 10/23/06 for Raymond Royer, for Brad Kirschbaum. (SBS) [Entered: 10/10/2006 11:40 AM] |
Appearance form filed by Elizabeth Hopkins for Amicus Curiae Elaine Chao. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) Sufficient Brief ddl satisfied. (CNF) [Entered: 10/02/2006 10:13 AM] |
Appearance form filed by John G Emerson for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 09/22/2006 04:09 PM] |
Phone extension confirmed for Appellee Reliant Energy Inc, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Tom Standish for filing appelees' brief. Extension granted to and including 10/6/06. [06-20157] E/Res's Brief ddl updated to 10/6/06 for Tom Standish, for Steve Schaeffer, for Waters S Davis, for Lee Hogan, for Gary Whitlock, for Mary P Ricciardello, for David M McClanahan, for Bnft Com of Reliant, for James A Baker, for Richard E Balzhiser, for John T Cater, for Milton Carroll, for T Milton Honea, for Reliant Energy Inc. (SDH) [Entered: 08/29/2006 10:26 AM] |
Appearance form filed by Jeffrey G Lewis for Amicus Curiae Natl Empl Lawr Assn. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 09/06/2006 10:37 AM] |
Amicus curiae brief filed by Amicus Curiae Elaine Chao Consent included in brief? [Y/NA] NA Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [5534293-1] [06-20157] Sufficient Brief due on 9/5/06 for Elaine Chao. APPEARANCE FORM REQUESTED FROM ATTY HOPKINS VIA E-MAIL. (SBS) [Entered: 08/24/2006 11:48 AM] |
Appearance form filed by Mary Ellen Signorille for Amicus Curiae AARP. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) Sufficient Brief ddl satisfied. (CNF) [Entered: 08/23/2006 12:11 PM] |
Amicus curiae brief filed by Amicus Curiae AARP, Amicus Curiae Natl Empl Lawr Assn Consent included in brief? [Y/NA] NA Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [5530556-1] [06-20157] Sufficient Brief due on 8/31/06 for Natl Empl Lawr Assn, for AARP. APPEARANCE FORM RECEIVED FROM ATTY SIGNORILLE - BEING PROCESSED. APPEARANCE FORM REQUESTED FROM ATTY'S LEWIS AND TIRONA VIA E-MAIL. (SBS) [Entered: 08/21/2006 03:18 PM] |
Record excerpts filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y [06-20157] (SBS) [Entered: 08/10/2006 04:01 PM] |
Appellant's Brief filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. Disk Provided [Y/N]: Y Sufficient [Y/N]: Y [5522384-1] [06-20157] A/Pet's Brief ddl satisfied. E/Res's Brief due on 9/7/06 for Tom Standish, for Steve Schaeffer, for Waters S Davis, for Lee Hogan, for Gary Whitlock, for Mary P Ricciardello, for David M McClanahan, for Bnft Com of Reliant, for James A Baker, for Richard E Balzhiser, for John T Cater, for Milton Carroll, for T Milton Honea, for Reliant Energy Inc. (SBS) [Entered: 08/10/2006 03:57 PM] |
Briefing notice issued. [06-20157] A/Pet's Brief due on 8/9/06 for Raymond Royer, for Brad Kirschbaum. (SEP) [Entered: 06/30/2006 03:21 PM] |
Notice received from District Court, ROA certified. Electronic Pleadings: y Electronic Transcripts: y [06-20157] Certified ROA due ddl satisfied. (SEP) [Entered: 06/30/2006 03:21 PM] |
Appearance form filed by Aaron Michael Streett for Appellee Tom Standish, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Reliant Energy Inc. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 04/20/2006 09:57 AM] |
Appearance form filed by Maria Wyckoff Boyce for Appellee Tom Standish, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Reliant Energy Inc. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 04/20/2006 09:27 AM] |
Appearance form filed by David Keith Isaak for Appellee Tom Standish, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Reliant Energy Inc. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 04/10/2006 10:26 AM] |
Appearance form filed by Eric Lee Palmquist for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 03/28/2006 02:06 PM] |
Appearance form filed by Robert A Izard for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 03/28/2006 02:05 PM] |
Appearance form filed by James Edward Maloney for Appellee Tom Standish, Appellee Steve Schaeffer, Appellee Waters S Davis, Appellee Lee Hogan, Appellee Gary Whitlock, Appellee Mary P Ricciardello, Appellee David M McClanahan, Appellee Bnft Com of Reliant, Appellee James A Baker, Appellee Richard E Balzhiser, Appellee John T Cater, Appellee Milton Carroll, Appellee T Milton Honea, Appellee Reliant Energy Inc. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 03/27/2006 03:52 PM] |
Appearance form filed by Gina M Tufaro for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 03/20/2006 02:30 PM] |
Appearance form filed by Paul O Paradis for Appellant Raymond Royer, Appellant Brad Kirschbaum. [06-20157] ( No. of forms filed: 1) (CNF) [Entered: 03/20/2006 02:31 PM] |
Notice received 2/24/06 from Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer that transcript is already on file in clerk's office [06-20157] Transcript Order ddl satisfied. Notice of Certified ROA due on 3/28/06. (JMW) [Entered: 03/13/2006 10:07 AM] |
Private civil federal case docketed. NOA filed by Appellant Brad Kirschbaum, Appellant Raymond Royer. [06-20157] (SDH) [Entered: 03/03/2006 02:56 PM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.