Bruce Fulmer v. Scott Klein, et al
Scott W. Klein, Thomas S. Rogers, John J. Mueller, Paul E. Weaver, Donald B. Reed, Billy Mundy, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Steven Gaberich, Georgia Scaife, Andrew Coticchio, Employee Benefits Committee, William Gist, Katherine J. Harless, Stephen L. Robertson, Clifford Wilson, Samuel D. Jones and Jerry V. Elliot |
Randy Kopp, Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated |
16-11590 |
November 7, 2016 |
U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit |
Other |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on July 19, 2018. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
MANDATE ISSUED. Mandate issue date satisfied. [16-11590] (CAS) [Entered: 07/19/2018 11:53 AM] |
JUDGMENT ENTERED AND FILED. [16-11590] (EAB) [Entered: 06/27/2018 02:20 PM] |
PUBLISHED OPINION FILED. [16-11590 Affirmed] Judge: PEH, Judge: EHJ, Judge: JEG. Mandate issue date is 07/19/2018 [16-11590] (EAB) [Entered: 06/27/2018 02:15 PM] |
COSTS TAXED AGAINST: Each party bear its own costs. [16-11590] (EAB) [Entered: 06/27/2018 02:26 PM] |
SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (FRAP 28j) FILED by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson Date of Service: 02/12/2018 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 02/12/2018 01:57 PM] |
ATTORNEY NOT PARTICIPATING. Jeremy Feigenbaum is designated as inactive in this case. Reason:counsel is no longer with firm. [16-11590] (SDH) [Entered: 01/18/2018 03:46 PM] |
COURT ORDER granting motion for leave to file a post-argument letter filed by Appellees Employee Benefits Committee, John Does 1-20, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Mr. Paul E. Weaver, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. William Gist, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. Clifford Wilson, Mr. Billy Mundy and Human Resources Committee [ # 8655476-2 ] [16-11590] (SDH) [Entered: 12/11/2017 01:02 PM] |
LETTER filed by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson for post-argument. [16-11590] (SDH) [Entered: 12/11/2017 01:21 PM] |
UNOPPOSED MOTION filed by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson for leave to file document [8655476-2]. Date of service: 12/08/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Feigenbaum, Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 12/08/2017 06:59 AM] |
DOCUMENT RECEIVED - NO ACTION TAKEN. No action will be taken at this time on the post argument letter received from Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp because party must seek leave of court to file [16-11590] (ABT) [Entered: 12/07/2017 03:04 PM] |
ORAL ARGUMENT HEARD before Judges Higginbotham, Jones, Graves. Arguing Person Information Updated for: Christopher Landau arguing for Appellee Andrew Coticchio, Appellee Jerry V. Elliot, Appellee Employee Benefits Committee, Appellee Steven Gaberich, Appellee William Gist, Appellee Katherine J. Harless, Appellee Human Resources Committee, Appellee John Does 1-20, Appellee Samuel D. Jones, Appellee Scott W. Klein, Appellee John J. Mueller, Appellee Billy Mundy, Appellee Donald B. Reed, Appellee Stephen L. Robertson, Appellee Thomas S. Rogers, Appellee Georgia Scaife, Appellee Paul E. Weaver; Arguing Person Information Updated for: Ronald Mann arguing for Appellant Randy Kopp [16-11590] (SME) [Entered: 12/04/2017 10:36 AM] |
SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (FRAP 28j) FILED by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson Date of Service: 11/21/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Feigenbaum, Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 11/21/2017 11:23 AM] |
RESPONSE filed by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson to the 28j letter filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp in 16-11590 [ # 8630278-2 ] Date of Service: 11/06/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Feigenbaum, Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 11/06/2017 05:04 PM] |
SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITIES (FRAP 28j) FILED by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp Date of Service: 11/03/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Feigenbaum, Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Ronald Mann ) [Entered: 11/03/2017 08:53 AM] |
CASE CALENDARED for oral argument on Monday, 12/04/2017 in New Orleans in the En Banc Courtroom -- AM session. In accordance with our policy, lead counsel only will receive via email at a later date a copy of the court's docket and an acknowledgment form. All other counsel of record should monitor the court's website for the posting of the oral argument calendars.. [16-11590] (SME) [Entered: 10/24/2017 01:14 PM] |
CASE TENTATIVELY calendared for oral argument for the week of 12/04/2017. [16-11590] (GAM) [Entered: 09/30/2017 01:10 PM] |
Paper copies of appellant reply brief filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp in 16-11590 received. Paper copies match electronic version of document? Yes # of Copies Provided: 7. Paper Copies of Brief due deadline satisfied. [16-11590] (MRW) [Entered: 05/11/2017 12:24 PM] |
APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF FILED # of Copies Provided: 0 Reply Brief deadline satisfied. Paper Copies of Brief due on 05/09/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp. [16-11590] REVIEWED AND/OR EDITED - The original text prior to review appeared as follows: APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF FILED by Mr. Randy Kopp. Date of service: 04/28/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Feigenbaum, Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Thomas James McKenna ) [Entered: 04/28/2017 03:43 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM FILED by Attorney(s) Jeremy M. Feigenbaum for party(s) Appellee Georgia Scaife Appellee Steven Gaberich Appellee Katherine J. Harless Appellee Stephen L. Robertson Appellee Thomas S. Rogers Appellee Samuel D. Jones Appellee Employee Benefits Committee Appellee John Does 1-20 Appellee Scott W. Klein Appellee Paul E. Weaver Appellee Clifford Wilson Appellee Andrew Coticchio Appellee Donald B. Reed Appellee Human Resources Committee Appellee William Gist Appellee John J. Mueller Appellee Jerry V. Elliot Appellee Billy Mundy, in case 16-11590 [16-11590] (LCA) [Entered: 04/27/2017 02:10 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM Counsel for Defendants-Appellees Scott W. Klein et al. for the court's review. Lead Counsel? No. [16-11590] (Jeremy M. Feigenbaum ) [Entered: 04/26/2017 01:40 PM] |
Paper copies of appellee brief filed by Appellees Employee Benefits Committee, John Does 1-20, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Mr. Paul E. Weaver, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. William Gist, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. Clifford Wilson, Mr. Billy Mundy and Human Resources Committee in 16-11590 received. Paper copies match electronic version of document? Yes # of Copies Provided: 7. Paper Copies of Brief due deadline satisfied. [16-11590] (MRW) [Entered: 04/25/2017 12:13 PM] |
APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED # of Copies Provided: 0 E/Res's Brief deadline satisfied. Paper Copies of Brief due on 04/24/2017 for Appellees Andrew Coticchio, Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Steven Gaberich, William Gist, Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Samuel D. Jones, Scott W. Klein, John J. Mueller, Billy Mundy, Donald B. Reed, Stephen L. Robertson, Thomas S. Rogers, Georgia Scaife, Paul E. Weaver and Clifford Wilson.. Reply Brief due on 04/28/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp [16-11590] REVIEWED AND/OR EDITED - The original text prior to review appeared as follows: APPELLEE'S BRIEF FILED by Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson. Date of service: 04/14/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 04/14/2017 04:10 PM] |
Paper copies of record excerpts filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp in 16-11590 received. Paper copies match electronic version of document? Yes. # of Copies Provided: 4. Paper Copies of Record Excerpts due deadline satisfied. [16-11590] (RLL) [Entered: 02/24/2017 09:00 AM] |
Paper copies of appellant brief filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp in 16-11590 received. Paper copies match electronic version of document? Yes. # of Copies Provided: 7. Paper Copies of Brief due deadline satisfied. [16-11590] (RLL) [Entered: 02/24/2017 09:00 AM] |
CLERK ORDER granting motion to extend time to file appellee's brief filed by Appellees Employee Benefits Committee, John Does 1-20, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Mr. Paul E. Weaver, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. William Gist, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. Clifford Wilson, Mr. Billy Mundy and Human Resources Committee [ # 8429399-2 ] Appellee's Brief due on 04/14/2017 for Appellees Andrew Coticchio, Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Steven Gaberich, William Gist, Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Samuel D. Jones, Scott W. Klein, John J. Mueller, Billy Mundy, Donald B. Reed, Stephen L. Robertson, Thomas S. Rogers, Georgia Scaife, Paul E. Weaver and Clifford Wilson [16-11590] (PAC) [Entered: 02/17/2017 01:15 PM] |
UNOPPOSED MOTION filed by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson to extend time to file brief of appellee until 04/14/2017 at 11:59 pm [8429399-2]. Date of service: 02/17/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Gillespie, Kelly, Landau [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 02/17/2017 01:04 PM] |
EXTENSION RECEIVED for Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson. Extension Granted in Part to and including 03/30/2017. Reason: Lacking Substantial Reason(s). E/Res's Brief deadline updated to 03/30/2017 for Appellees Andrew Coticchio, Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Steven Gaberich, William Gist, Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Samuel D. Jones, Scott W. Klein, John J. Mueller, Billy Mundy, Donald B. Reed, Stephen L. Robertson, Thomas S. Rogers, Georgia Scaife, Paul E. Weaver and Clifford Wilson [16-11590] (PAC) [Entered: 02/16/2017 04:25 PM] |
UNOPPOSED LEVEL 1 EXTENSION REQUESTED by Appellees Mr. Andrew Coticchio, Mr. Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Mr. Steven Gaberich, Mr. William Gist, Ms. Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Mr. Samuel D. Jones, Mr. Scott W. Klein, Mr. John J. Mueller, Mr. Billy Mundy, Mr. Donald B. Reed, Mr. Stephen L. Robertson, Mr. Thomas S. Rogers, Ms. Georgia Scaife, Mr. Paul E. Weaver and Mr. Clifford Wilson for filing Defendants-Appellees Brief until 04/14/2017 at 11:59 pm. [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 02/15/2017 10:30 AM] |
APPEARANCE FORM Christopher Landau for the court's review. Lead Counsel? Yes.. THE IMAGE FOR THIS FILING WILL NOT BE VIEWABLE AS IT CONTAINS SENSITIVE INFORMATION. [16-11590] (Christopher Landau ) [Entered: 02/14/2017 04:11 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM FILED by Attorney(s) Christopher Landau for party(s) Appellee Georgia Scaife Appellee Steven Gaberich Appellee Katherine J. Harless Appellee Stephen L. Robertson Appellee Thomas S. Rogers Appellee Samuel D. Jones Appellee Employee Benefits Committee Appellee John Does 1-20 Appellee Scott W. Klein Appellee Paul E. Weaver Appellee Clifford Wilson Appellee Andrew Coticchio Appellee Donald B. Reed Appellee Human Resources Committee Appellee William Gist Appellee John J. Mueller Appellee Jerry V. Elliot Appellee Billy Mundy, in case 16-11590 [16-11590] (PAC) [Entered: 02/14/2017 04:25 PM] |
RECORD EXCERPTS FILED. # of Copies Provided: 0 Paper Copies of Record Excerpts due on 02/21/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp. [16-11590] REVIEWED AND/OR EDITED - The original text prior to review appeared as follows: RECORD EXCERPTS FILED by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp. Date of service: 02/13/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Gillespie, Kelly [16-11590] (Thomas James McKenna ) [Entered: 02/13/2017 01:24 PM] |
APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED # of Copies Provided: 0 A/Pet's Brief deadline satisfied. Appellee's Brief due on 03/15/2017 for Appellees Andrew Coticchio, Jerry V. Elliot, Employee Benefits Committee, Steven Gaberich, William Gist, Katherine J. Harless, Human Resources Committee, John Does 1-20, Samuel D. Jones, Scott W. Klein, John J. Mueller, Billy Mundy, Donald B. Reed, Stephen L. Robertson, Thomas S. Rogers, Georgia Scaife, Paul E. Weaver and Clifford Wilson. Paper Copies of Brief due on 02/21/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp. [16-11590] REVIEWED AND/OR EDITED - The original text prior to review appeared as follows: APPELLANT'S BRIEF FILED by Mr. Randy Kopp. Date of service: 02/13/2017 via email - Attorney for Appellants: Claxton, Mann, McKenna; Attorney for Appellees: Gillespie, Kelly [16-11590] (Thomas James McKenna ) [Entered: 02/13/2017 01:21 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM FILED by Attorney(s) Ronald Mann for party(s) Appellant Randy Kopp, in case 16-11590 [16-11590] (SDH) [Entered: 02/10/2017 04:05 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM by Attorney Ronald J. Mann forAppellant Randy Kopp for the court's review. Lead Counsel? No.. THE IMAGE FOR THIS FILING WILL NOT BE VIEWABLE AS IT CONTAINS SENSITIVE INFORMATION. [16-11590] (Ronald Mann ) [Entered: 02/09/2017 11:28 AM] |
UNOPPOSED MOTION to extend time to file brief as appellant until 02/13/2017 [8384581-2]. Date of service: 12/02/2016 [16-11590] REVIEWED AND/OR EDITED - The original text prior to review appeared as follows: UNOPPOSED LEVEL 1 EXTENSION REQUESTED by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp for filing Brief until 02/13/2017. [16-11590] (Thomas James McKenna ) [Entered: 12/20/2016 01:57 PM] |
CLERK ORDER granting motion to extend time to file appellant's brief filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp [ # 8384581-2 ] A/Pet's Brief deadline updated to 02/13/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp [16-11590] (PAC) [Entered: 12/20/2016 03:13 PM] |
APPEARANCE FORM FILED by Attorney Thomas James McKenna for Appellant Randy Kopp in 16-11590 [16-11590] (RSM) [Entered: 12/07/2016 11:29 AM] |
APPEARANCE FORM received from Mr. Thomas James McKenna, Esq. for Mr. Randy Kopp for the court's review. Lead Counsel? Yes.. THE IMAGE FOR THIS FILING WILL NOT BE VIEWABLE AS IT CONTAINS SENSITIVE INFORMATION. [16-11590] (Thomas James McKenna ) [Entered: 12/06/2016 12:12 PM] |
BRIEFING NOTICE ISSUED A/Pet's Brief Due on 01/11/2017 for Appellant Randy Kopp. [16-11590] (MRB) [Entered: 12/02/2016 11:53 AM] |
ELECTRONIC RECORD ON APPEAL FILED. Exhibits on File in District Court? No. Electronic ROA deadline satisfied. [16-11590] (MRB) [Entered: 12/02/2016 11:53 AM] |
ATTORNEY NOT PARTICIPATING. Andrew George Horne is designated as inactive in this case. Reason:as he is no longer with the firm. [16-11590] (NFD) [Entered: 11/16/2016 09:20 AM] |
INITIAL CASE CHECK by Attorney Advisor complete, Action: Case OK to Process. [8356707-2] Initial AA Check Due satisfied. [16-11590] (CNF) [Entered: 11/14/2016 01:19 PM] |
ELECTRONIC RECORD ON APPEAL REQUESTED FROM DISTRICT COURT for 3:09-CV-2354, 3:09-CV-2354. Electronic ROA due on 11/29/2016. [16-11590] (CNF) [Entered: 11/14/2016 01:22 PM] |
PRIVATE CIVIL FEDERAL CASE docketed. NOA filed by Appellant Mr. Randy Kopp [16-11590] (MVM) [Entered: 11/07/2016 03:40 PM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.