Hunter Doster, et al v. Frank Kendall, et al
| HUNTER DOSTER, JASON ANDERSON, MCKENNA COLANTANIO, PAUL CLEMENT, JOE DILLS, BENJAMIN LEIBY, BRETT MARTIN, CONNOR MCCORMICK, HEIDI MOSHER, PETER NORRIS, PATRICK POTTINGER, ALEX RAMSPERGER, BENJAMIN RINALDI, DOUGLAS RUYLE, CHRISTOPHER SCHULDES, EDWARD STAPANON, III, ADAM THERIAULT and DANIEL REINEKE, On behalf of themselves and others similarly situated |
| HON. FRANK KENDALL, In his official capacity as Secretary of the Air Force, LT. GENERAL ROBERT I. MILLER, In his official capacity as Surgeon General of the Air Force, LT. GENERAL MARSHALL B. WEBB, In his official capacity as Commander, Air Education and Training Command, LT. GENERAL RICHARD W. SCOBEE, In his official capacity as Commander, Air Force Reserve Command, LT. GENERAL JAMES C. SLIFE, In his official capacity as Commander, Air Force Special Operations Command and UNITED STATES OF AMERICA |
| TODD ZYWICKI, JEFFREY A. SINGER, M.D., JASON C. SCHNEIDER, JOSEPH F. IRWIN, JAMES FRIEDLEIN, JASON WEAVER, SEAN HICKS, JAMES ARMSTRONG, MICHAEL GAYDESKI, DAVID R. MENDOZA, JAMES WALLS, JOHN MORRIS PRITCHARD, III, CONNOR PENN, ZACHARY WALES, CAMERON DAVIES and FOUNDATION FOR MORAL LAW |
| 22-3702 |
| August 16, 2022 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit |
| Other Statutory Actions |
Opinions
We have the following opinions for this case:
| Description |
|---|
 Doster v. Kendall
|
|
Doster v. Kendall
|
|
Hunter Doster v. Frank Kendall
|
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on October 14, 2022. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
Filing 50
AMICUS BRIEF filed by Cameron Davies, James Armstrong, James Friedlein, Michael Gaydeski, Sean Hicks, Joseph F. Irwin, David R. Mendoza, Connor Penn, John Morris Pritchard, III, Jason C. Schneider, James Walls, Zachary Wales and Jason Weaver , with parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/14/2022. [22-3702] (GCS) [Entered: 10/14/2022 10:43 PM]
|
|
Filing 49
MOTION filed by Mr. Gene C. Schaerr for James Armstrong, Cameron Davies, James Friedlein, Michael Gaydeski, Sean Hicks, Joseph F. Irwin, David R. Mendoza, Connor Penn, John Morris Pritchard, III, Jason C. Schneider, Zachary Wales, James Walls and Jason Weaver for leave to correct the amicus curiae brief. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702] (GCS) [Entered: 10/14/2022 10:29 PM]
|
|
Filing 48
Errata to Brief for 13 United States Marines as Amici Curiae Supporting Appellees and Affirmance filed 10/11/2022 by Mr. Gene C. Schaerr for James Armstrong, Cameron Davies, James Friedlein, Michael Gaydeski, Sean Hicks, Joseph F. Irwin, David R. Mendoza, Connor Penn, John Morris Pritchard, III, Jason C. Schneider, Zachary Wales, James Walls and Jason Weaver. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702] (GCS) [Entered: 10/14/2022 10:22 PM]
|
|
Filing 47
REPLY BRIEF filed by Attorney Mr. Casen Ross for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 10/14/2022 04:56 PM]
|
|
Filing 46
AMICUS BRIEF filed by John Eidsmoe, Foundation for Moral Law , without parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/14/2022. [22-3702] (JAE) [Entered: 10/14/2022 03:57 PM]
|
|
Filing 45
MOTION to file AMICUS BRIEF filed by John Eidsmoe for Foundation for Moral Law. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702] (JAE) [Entered: 10/14/2022 03:47 PM]
|
|
Filing 44
***DOCUMENT LOCKED- COUNSEL INSTRUCTED TO REFILE MOTION AS A SEPARATE ENTRY FROM THE AMICUS BRIEF**** AMICUS BRIEF filed by John Eidsmoe, Foundation for Moral Law , without parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/14/2022. [22-3702]--[Edited 10/14/2022 by VLP] (JAE) [Entered: 10/14/2022 03:42 PM]
|
|
Filing 43
AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Foundation for Moral Law by John Eidsmoe. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702] (JAE) [Entered: 10/14/2022 03:18 PM]
|
|
Filing 42
***DOCUMENT LOCKED- COUNSEL INSTRUCTED TO REFILE AND TO REMOVE ALL ATTACHMENTS*** Errata to Brief for 13 United States Marines as Amici Curiae Supporting Appellees and Affirmance filed 10/11/2022 by Mr. Gene C. Schaerr for James Armstrong, Cameron Davies, James Friedlein, Michael Gaydeski, Sean Hicks, Joseph F. Irwin, David R. Mendoza, Connor Penn, John Morris Pritchard, III, Jason C. Schneider, Zachary Wales, James Walls and Jason Weaver. Certificate of Service: 10/14/2022. [22-3702]--[Edited 10/14/2022 by VLP] (GCS) [Entered: 10/14/2022 03:13 PM]
|
|
Filing 41
AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Jason C. Schneider, Joseph F. Irwin, James Friedlein, Jason Weaver, Sean Hicks, James Armstrong, Michael Gaydeski, David R. Mendoza, James Walls, John Morris Pritchard III, Connor Penn, Zachary Wales, Cameron Davies by Kenneth A. Klukowski. Certificate of Service: 10/11/2022. [22-3702] (KAK) [Entered: 10/11/2022 11:59 PM]
|
|
Filing 40
AMICUS BRIEF filed by Gene C. Schaerr, counsel for Jason C. Schneider, Joseph F. Irwin, James Friedlein, Jason Weaver, Sean Hicks, James Armstrong, Michael Gaydeski, David R. Mendoza, James Walls, John Morris Pritchard III, Connor Penn, Zachary Wales, Cameron Davies , with parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/11/2022. [22-3702] (GCS) [Entered: 10/11/2022 11:55 PM]
|
|
Filing 39
AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Jason C. Schneider, Joseph F. Irwin, James Friedlein, Jason Weaver, Sean Hicks, James Armstrong, Michael Gaydeski, David R. Mendoza, James Walls, John Morris Pritchard III, Connor Penn, Zachary Wales, Cameron Davies by Gene C. Schaerr. Certificate of Service: 10/11/2022. [22-3702] (GCS) [Entered: 10/11/2022 11:44 PM]
|
|
Filing 38
AMICUS BRIEF filed by , with parties' consent. Certificate of Service:10/11/2022. [22-3702] (FRY) [Entered: 10/11/2022 05:06 PM]
|
|
Filing 37
AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Amici Curiae Professor Todd Zywicki and Jeffrey A. Singer, M.D. by Ilya Shapiro. Certificate of Service: 10/10/2022. [22-3702] (IS) [Entered: 10/10/2022 11:38 AM]
|
|
Filing 36
AMICUS APPEARANCE filed for Amici Curiae Professor Todd Zywicki and Jeffrey A. Singer, M.D. by Frederick R. Yarger. Certificate of Service: 10/10/2022. [22-3702] (FRY) [Entered: 10/10/2022 11:36 AM]
|
|
Filing 35
APPELLEE BRIEF filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault. Certificate of Service: 10/07/2022. Argument Request: requested. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 10/07/2022 09:30 PM]
|
|
Filing 34
Argument acknowledgment filed by Attorney Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault. Certificate of Service: 10/07/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 10/07/2022 09:46 AM]
|
|
Filing 33
Argument acknowledgment filed by Attorney Mr. Casen Ross for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 10/06/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 10/06/2022 09:02 PM]
|
|
Filing 32
ORAL ARGUMENT SCHEDULED for 2:00 p.m. (Eastern Time) on Wednesday, October 19, 2022. (LAG) [Entered: 10/04/2022 03:53 PM]
|
|
Filing 31
REPLY filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault regarding motion to supplement record Certificate of Service: 09/28/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 09/28/2022 02:13 PM]
|
|
Filing 30
RESPONSE in opposition filed regarding a motion to supplement certified record, [ # 25 ]; previously filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Hunter Doster, Jason Anderson, McKenna Colantanio, Paul Clement, Joe Dills, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III, Adam Theriault and Daniel Reineke. Response from Attorney Mr. Casen Ross for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 09/26/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 09/26/2022 06:16 PM]
|
|
Filing 29
APPELLANT BRIEF filed by Mr. Casen Ross for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 09/23/2022. Argument Request: requested. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 09/23/2022 06:50 PM]
|
|
Filing 28
APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault by Elizabeth A. Brehm. Certificate of Service: 09/16/2022. [22-3702] (EAB) [Entered: 09/16/2022 12:47 PM]
|
|
Filing 27
APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault by Aaron Siri. Certificate of Service: 09/16/2022. [22-3702] (AS) [Entered: 09/16/2022 12:39 PM]
|
|
Filing 26
ORDER filed:The motion to consolidate [ # 6864076-2 ] [ # 20 ] is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. These appeals will be briefed independently pursuant to the respective briefing schedules already issued. Upon the completion of briefing, these appeals will be submitted to the same panel for consideration on the same date. The decision on the structure of any appellate argument is reserved to the panel. Raymond M. Kethledge, Circuit Judge; John K. Bush, Circuit Judge and Eric E. Murphy, Circuit Judge. [22-3497, 22-3702] (VLP) [Entered: 09/14/2022 03:48 PM]
|
|
Filing 25
MOTION filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault to supplement certified record. Certificate of Service: 09/14/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 09/14/2022 01:15 PM]
|
|
Filing 24
REPLY filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault regarding Reply in support of motion to consolidate Certificate of Service: 09/10/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 09/10/2022 09:44 AM]
|
|
Filing 23
BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting expedited briefing schedule: appellant brief now due 09/23/2022. appellee brief now due 10/07/2022. (VLP) [Entered: 09/09/2022 04:30 PM]
|
|
Filing 22
ORDER filed: The motion for an emergency stay [ # 8 ] is DENIED. The court will expedite the appeal as described in the order. Decision for publication. Raymond M. Kethledge (AUTHORING), John K. Bush, and Eric E. Murphy, Circuit Judges. (CL) [Entered: 09/09/2022 04:20 PM]
|
|
Filing 21
RESPONSE in opposition filed regarding a motion, [ # 20 ]; previously filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Hunter Doster, Jason Anderson, McKenna Colantanio, Paul Clement, Joe Dills, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III, Adam Theriault and Daniel Reineke. Response from Attorney Mr. Casen Ross for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 09/08/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 09/08/2022 01:13 PM]
|
|
Filing 20
MOTION filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault to consolidate cases 22-3497, 22-3702. Certificate of Service: 09/07/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 09/07/2022 02:25 PM]
|
|
Filing 19
TRANSCRIPT ORDER filed - transcript is already on file in the District Court Clerks Office. Filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault. Certificate of Service: 08/31/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 08/31/2022 06:39 PM]
|
|
Filing 18
TRANSCRIPT ORDER filed - transcript is unnecessary for appeal purposes. Filed by Mr. Casen Ross for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb. Certificate of Service: 08/31/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 08/31/2022 09:07 AM]
|
|
Filing 17
NOTICE: The initial transcript order has not been completed. If not completed by 09/06/2022 further action will be taken. (VLP) [Entered: 08/31/2022 09:02 AM]
|
|
Filing 16
CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT filed by Attorney Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault Certificate of Service: 08/29/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 08/29/2022 04:16 PM]
|
|
Filing 15
REPLY filed by Mr. Casen Ross for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb regarding EMERGENCY MOTION to stay injunction pending appeal Certificate of Service: 08/26/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 08/26/2022 04:44 PM]
|
|
Filing 14
ORDER filed granting motion exceed page limit [ # 13 ] filed by Mr. Casen Ross.. Entered by order of the court. (VLP) [Entered: 08/26/2022 02:00 PM]
|
|
Filing 13
MOTION filed by Mr. Casen Ross for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb to exceed page limit. Certificate of Service: 08/26/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 08/26/2022 11:44 AM]
|
|
Filing 12
RESPONSE in opposition filed regarding a motion to stay injunction pending appeal, [ # 8 ]; previously filed by Ms. Anna O. Mohan for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Marshall B. Webb, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife and USA. Response from Attorney Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault. Certificate of Service: 08/25/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 08/25/2022 04:30 PM]
|
|
Filing 11
ORDER filed granting motion exceed page limit [ # 10 ] filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest.. Entered by order of the court. (VLP) [Entered: 08/25/2022 04:14 PM]
|
|
Filing 10
MOTION filed by Mr. Christopher David Wiest for Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault to exceed page limit. Certificate of Service: 08/24/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 08/24/2022 04:40 PM]
|
|
Filing 9
LETTER SENT TO ALL PARTIES: The Court requests that a response to the pending motion to stay injunction pending appeal be filed no later than 5:00 P.M. EDT Thursday, August 25, 2022 and that a reply be filed no later than 5:00 P.M. EDT Friday, August 26, 2022. (VLP) [Entered: 08/22/2022 05:13 PM]
|
|
Filing 8
EMERGENCY MOTION filed by Ms. Anna O. Mohan for Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb to stay injunction pending appeal. Certificate of Service: 08/22/2022. [22-3702]--[Edited 08/22/2022 by VLP] (AOM) [Entered: 08/22/2022 12:51 PM]
|
|
Filing 7
APPEARANCE filed for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb by Casen B. Ross. Certificate of Service: 08/21/2022. [22-3702] (CR) [Entered: 08/21/2022 11:24 AM]
|
|
Filing 6
APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault by Wendy Cox. Certificate of Service: 08/17/2022. [22-3702] (WNC) [Entered: 08/17/2022 06:45 PM]
|
|
Filing 5
APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle, Christopher Schuldes, Edward Stapanon, III and Adam Theriault by Thomas B. Bruns. Certificate of Service: 08/17/2022. [22-3702] (TBB) [Entered: 08/17/2022 01:12 PM]
|
|
Filing 4
APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Jason Anderson, Paul Clement, McKenna Colantanio, Joe Dills, Hunter Doster, Benjamin Leiby, Brett Martin, Connor McCormick, Heidi Mosher, Peter Norris, Adam Theriault, Edward Stapanon, III, Patrick Pottinger, Alex Ramsperger, Daniel Reineke, Benjamin Rinaldi, Douglas Ruyle and Christopher Schuldes by Christopher D Wiest. Certificate of Service: 08/17/2022. [22-3702] (CDW) [Entered: 08/17/2022 09:03 AM]
|
|
Filing 3
APPEARANCE filed for Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife, USA and Marshall B. Webb by Anna Mohan. Certificate of Service: 08/17/2022. [22-3702] (AOM) [Entered: 08/17/2022 08:44 AM]
|
|
Filing 2
The case manager for this case is: Virginia Padgett (VLP) [Entered: 08/16/2022 02:21 PM]
|
|
Filing 1
Civil Case Docketed. Notice filed by Appellants Honorable Frank Kendall, Robert I. Miller, Richard W. Scobee, James C. Slife and USA. Transcript needed: y. (VLP) [Entered: 08/16/2022 02:19 PM]
|
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
