William Kaska, et al v. Oakland County, MI
| EILEEN AJIRI, SAMUEL AJIRI, BRENT ATKINS, EMANUEL BENNEDICT-SMITH, JEFFREY BORIN, SAMANTHA BROWN, KELLY BURT, VERNON CHASE, BERNICE CLARK, RENEE SIMPSON CRIBB, RASHAD CROSBY, BRYAN DANIEL, KEYON DICKERSON, HERBERT GIBBS, GIBBS PROPERTIES, LLC, MARIA GONZALEZ, MARTIN GONZALEZ, DENNIS GROH, KIMBERLY HODGE, NAVARRO HODGE, RICHARD HUTCHINSON, JAMIL A. JAMALEDDINE, BUBBACARR JATTA, KOFI JOHNSON, LARRY JONES, WILLIAM KASKA, NICHELLE KIRKSEY, CORA MCBRIDE, CRYSTAL MCCANN WILLIAMS, MICHELLE MOLOIAN, CAROLYN NICHOLSON, CARL NIHRANZ, TODD PARSONS, CHARLES PERRYMAN, CHERIE PETERSON, ADAM RATCLIFF, GERALD REEVES, LOUIS RODRIGUEZ, DAVID ROLAND, DOROTHY RUSAW, ALVIN SABRI, STEPHANIE SHANAHAN, FRITZ SIBERT, CRYSTAL SMITH, SHARON SMITH, KRISTINA SMITH AVANT MAYS, STEVE SOHL, DARREN ROBERT STERN, CHARMAINE STEWART, ALESIA STRAUGHTER, TIMOTHY SUTHERLAND, DAVID TOWNSEND, NATASHA TUPPER, ROBERT TUPPER, GREG TYLL, ROBERT WALKER, TROWN WILLIAMS, CHERYL WILLIAMS-KEARNEY and STACEY WINDHAM |
| OAKLAND COUNTY, MI |
| 25-1925 |
| October 16, 2025 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit |
| Civil Rights: Other |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on March 31, 2026. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| Filing 26 THIRD BRIEF filed by Attorney Mr. William H. Horton for Appellant Cross-Appellee Oakland County, MI. Certificate of Service: 03/31/2026. [25-1925] (WHH) [Entered: 03/31/2026 02:28 PM] |
| Filing 25 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Name of Counsel: Scott Fenton Smith ; Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Stacey Windham in 25-1925, 25-1972 makes the following disclosure: 1. Is said party a subsidiary or affiliate of a publicly owned corporation? NO 2. Is there a publicly owned corporation, not a party to the appeal, with a financial interest in the outcome? NO Certificate of Service: 03/10/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (SFS) [Entered: 03/10/2026 05:10 PM] |
| Filing 24 SECOND BRIEF filed by Mr. Scott Fenton Smith for Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Stacey Windham in 25-1925, Mr. Scott Fenton Smith for Mr. William Kaska, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Stacey Windham, Ms. Samantha Brown, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Mr. Trown Williams, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Kofi Johnson, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Mr. Larry Jones, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Mr. David Roland, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Nichelle Kirksey, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Brent Atkins, Ms. Crystal Smith, Mr. Robert Tupper, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Keyon Dickerson, Cora McBride, Mr. Todd Parsons, Navarro Hodge, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Bubbacarr Jatta, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Kelly Burt, Mr. Herbert Gibbs and Mr. Charles Perryman in 25-1972. Certificate of Service: 03/10/2026. Argument Request: requested.. [25-1925, 25-1972] (SFS) [Entered: 03/10/2026 05:07 PM] |
| Filing 23 2 DAY EXTENSION: Second brief now due 03/10/2026 [25-1925, 25-1972] (SFS) [Entered: 03/06/2026 08:27 PM] |
| Filing 22 RULING LETTER SENT granting motion to extend time to file brief by 14 days [ # 21 ] filed by Mr. Scott Fenton Smith. in 25-1925, resetting briefing schedule: second brief now due 03/06/2026. third brief now due 04/06/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (VLP) [Entered: 02/17/2026 06:12 AM] |
| Filing 21 MOTION filed by Mr. Scott Fenton Smith for Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Stacey Windham in 25-1925 to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 02/15/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (SFS) [Entered: 02/15/2026 06:34 PM] |
| Filing 20 Mediation Office is no longer involved in this appeal. [25-1925, 25-1972] (MLB) [Entered: 01/29/2026 02:14 PM] |
| Filing 19 RULING LETTER SENT granting motion to extend time to file brief [ # 17 ] by 30 days, filed by Mr. Jonathan Robert Marko. Resetting briefing schedule: second brief now due 02/20/2026; third brief now due 03/23/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (GSA) [Entered: 01/13/2026 02:35 PM] |
| Filing 17 MOTION filed by Mr. Jonathan Robert Marko for Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Stacey Windham in 25-1925, Mr. Jonathan Robert Marko for Mr. William Kaska, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Stacey Windham, Ms. Samantha Brown, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Mr. Trown Williams, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Kofi Johnson, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Mr. Larry Jones, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Mr. David Roland, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Nichelle Kirksey, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Brent Atkins, Ms. Crystal Smith, Mr. Robert Tupper, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Keyon Dickerson, Cora McBride, Mr. Todd Parsons, Navarro Hodge, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Bubbacarr Jatta, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Kelly Burt, Mr. Herbert Gibbs and Mr. Charles Perryman in 25-1972 to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 01/13/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (JRM) [Entered: 01/13/2026 12:15 PM] |
| Filing 16 APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Cross-Appellants Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Stacey Windham in 25-1925, 25-1972 by Jonathan R. Marko. Certificate of Service: 01/12/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972]--[Edited 01/12/2026 by GSA] (AJF) [Entered: 01/12/2026 01:50 PM] |
| Filing 15 FIRST BRIEF filed by Mr. William H. Horton for Oakland County, MI in 25-1925, 25-1972. Certificate of Service: 11/17/2025. Argument Request: requested. [25-1925, 25-1972] (WHH) [Entered: 11/17/2025 11:44 AM] |
| Filing 14 BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting briefing schedule: first brief due 12/22/2025; second brief due 01/21/2026; third brief due 02/20/2026. [25-1925, 25-1972] (GSA) [Entered: 11/12/2025 03:59 PM] |
| Filing 13 LOCKED ** ATTACHMENT NOT PERMITTED ** IF FORM IS NEEDED, PLEASE UPLOAD THE FORM PROVIDED ON THE COURT'S WEBSITE ** WHEN REFILING, PLEASE DESELECT CASE NO. 25-1925 ** CIVIL APPEAL STATEMENT OF PARTIES AND ISSUES filed by Attorney Mr. Scott Fenton Smith for Appellees Cross-Appellants Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Stacey Windham in 25-1972. Is this case a cross-appeal? Yes ; Has this case or a related one been before this court previously? No ; Please identify the party(ies) the appeal is being taken against: Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Stacey Windham and Oakland County, MI in 25-1972, 25-1925 ; Issues: 1)Wyser-Pratt Mgmt. Co. 413 F3d.553(6th Cir. 2005) should be overruled or reconsidered as it not-well reasoned and is the only Circuit that applies the case.which serves no purpose except to bar putative Plaintiffs from pursing their claims. 2)Equitable tolling is appropriate in the present case under both Michigan and Federal Law. 3)Wyser-Pratt should be distinguished or not applied when the law is not identical as applied under substantive state and federal law. 4)Wyser-Pratt should not be applied to Michigan putative class actions as it encroaches on substantive Michigan Class Action law. . [25-1972, 25-1925]--[Edited 11/12/2025 by GSA] (SFS) [Entered: 11/10/2025 05:33 PM] |
| Filing 12 APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Cross-Appellants Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Stacey Windham by Scott F. Smith. Certificate of Service: 11/04/2025. [25-1925]--[Edited 11/04/2025 by GSA] (SFS) [Entered: 11/04/2025 01:16 PM] |
| Filing 11 LOCKED ** APPEARANCE FORM NEEDS TO BE FILED IN EACH CASE SEPARATELY ** PLEASE REFILE AND DESELECT CASE NUMBER 25-1972 ** WHEN FILING IN 25-1972, PLEASE DESELECT 25-1925 ** CORPORATE DISCLOSURE MUST BE FILED SEPARATELY FROM APPEARANCE FORM ** PLEASE FILE IN EACH CASE SEPARATELY ** APPEARANCE filed for Appellees Cross-Appellants Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Samuel Ajiri, Mr. Brent Atkins, Mr. Emanuel Bennedict-Smith, Mr. Jeffrey Borin, Ms. Samantha Brown, Kelly Burt, Mr. Vernon Chase, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Renee Simpson Cribb, Mr. Rashad Crosby, Mr. Bryan Daniel, Keyon Dickerson, Gibbs Properties, LLC, Mr. Herbert Gibbs, Ms. Maria Gonzalez, Mr. Martin Gonzalez, Mr. Dennis Groh, Ms. Kimberly Hodge, Navarro Hodge, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Bubbacarr Jatta, Kofi Johnson, Mr. Larry Jones, Mr. William Kaska, Nichelle Kirksey, Cora McBride, Ms. Crystal McCann Williams, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Mr. Carl Nihranz, Mr. Todd Parsons, Mr. Charles Perryman, Ms. Cherie Peterson, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Gerald Reeves, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Mr. David Roland, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Ms. Stephanie Shanahan, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Kristina Smith Avant Mays, Ms. Crystal Smith, Ms. Sharon Smith, Mr. Steve Sohl, Mr. Darren Robert Stern, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Alesia Straughter, Mr. Timothy Sutherland, Mr. David Townsend, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Mr. Robert Tupper, Mr. Greg Tyll, Mr. Robert Walker, Mr. Trown Williams, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney, Stacey Windham and Appellant Cross-Appellee Oakland County, MI in 25-1925, 25-1972 by Scott F. Smith. Certificate of Service: 10/31/2025. [25-1925, 25-1972]--[Edited 10/31/2025 by GSA] (SFS) [Entered: 10/31/2025 03:01 PM] |
| Filing 10 LOCKED ** APPEARANCE FORM SHOULD ONLY BE FILED IN 25-1972 ** PLEASE DESELECT CASE NO. 25-1925 ** APPEARANCE filed for Appellant Cross-Appellee Oakland County, MI in 25-1972, 25-1925 by John R. Fleming. Certificate of Service: 10/29/2025. [25-1972, 25-1925]--[Edited 10/29/2025 by GSA] (JRF) [Entered: 10/29/2025 11:52 AM] |
| Filing 9 LOCKED ** APPEARANCE FORM SHOULD ONLY BE FILED IN 25-1972 ** PLEASE DESELECT CASE NO. 25-1925 ** APPEARANCE filed for Appellant Cross-Appellee Oakland County, MI in 25-1972, 25-1925 by William H. Horton. Certificate of Service: 10/29/2025. [25-1972, 25-1925]--[Edited 10/29/2025 by GSA] (WHH) [Entered: 10/29/2025 11:49 AM] |
| Filing 8 VIDEO CONFERENCE: The Mediation conference scheduled for 11/17/2025 at 2:00 PM (ET) with John A. Minter will INCLUDE BOTH CA Nos. 25-1925 AND 25-1972. [Please open original notice found on CA No. 25-1925 for important details and deadlines.] [25-1925, 25-1972] (LMR) [Entered: 10/29/2025 10:41 AM] |
| Filing 7 CIVIL APPEAL STATEMENT OF PARTIES AND ISSUES filed by Attorney Mr. William H. Horton for Appellant Oakland County, MI. Is this case a cross-appeal? No ; Has this case or a related one been before this court previously? No ; Please identify the party(ies) the appeal is being taken against: Ms. Samantha Brown, Mr. Louis Rodriguez, Ms. Michelle Moloian, Mr. Trown Williams, Mr. Fritz Sibert, Ms. Eileen Ajiri, Mr. Richard Hutchinson, Ms. Carolyn Nicholson, Jamil A. Jamaleddine, Mr. David Roland, Mr. Alvin Sabri, Nichelle Kirksey, Ms. Charmaine Stewart, Ms. Dorothy Rusaw, Mr. Adam Ratcliff, Mr. Brent Atkins, Ms. Crystal Smith, Mr. Robert Tupper, Ms. Natasha Tupper, Keyon Dickerson, Cora McBride, Navarro Hodge, Bubbacarr Jatta, Ms. Bernice Clark, Ms. Cheryl Williams-Kearney and Kelly Burt ; Issues:. Certificate of Service: 10/21/2025. [25-1925] (WHH) [Entered: 10/21/2025 09:04 AM] |
| Filing 6 APPEARANCE filed for Appellant Oakland County, MI by John R. Fleming. Certificate of Service: 10/20/2025. [25-1925] (JRF) [Entered: 10/20/2025 03:41 PM] |
| Filing 5 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Name of Counsel: William H. Horton ; Oakland County, MI makes the following disclosure: 1. Is said party a subsidiary or affiliate of a publicly owned corporation? No. 2. Is there a publicly owned corporation, not a party to the appeal, with a financial interest in the outcome? No. Certificate of Service: 10/20/2025. [25-1925] (WHH) [Entered: 10/20/2025 03:39 PM] |
| Filing 4 LOCKED ** DOCKET TEXT INDICATES THE PARTY THE APPEAL IS BEING TAKEN AGAINST IS THE APPELLANT ** DOES NOT MATCH ATTACHMENT ** PLEASE REFILE AND LIST THE CORRECT PARTY(IES) THE APPEAL IS BEING TAKEN AGAINST ** CIVIL APPEAL STATEMENT OF PARTIES AND ISSUES filed by Attorney Mr. William H. Horton for Appellant Oakland County, MI. Is this case a cross-appeal? No ; Has this case or a related one been before this court previously? No ; Please identify the party(ies) the appeal is being taken against: Oakland County, MI ; Issues: Appeal the dismissal of the Southfield Plaintiffs without prejudice. . Certificate of Service: 10/20/2025. [25-1925]--[Edited 10/20/2025 by GSA] (WHH) [Entered: 10/20/2025 03:37 PM] |
| Filing 3 APPEARANCE filed for Appellant Oakland County, MI by William H. Horton. Certificate of Service: 10/20/2025. [25-1925] (WHH) [Entered: 10/20/2025 03:33 PM] |
| Filing 2 MEDIATION OFFICE is involved in this appeal. VIDEO CONFERENCE: A Mediation conference has been scheduled for 11/17/2025 at 2:00 PM (ET) with John A. Minter. [Please open notice for important details and deadlines.] (LMR) [Entered: 10/17/2025 01:11 PM] |
| Filing 1 Civil Case Docketed. Notice filed by Appellant Oakland County, MI. Transcript needed: n. (GSA) [Entered: 10/16/2025 11:06 AM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.