Patricia Adams, et al v. The Medical Protective Company, Inc., et al
| PATRICIA ADAMS, MACKENZIE BENDER, REBEKAH BRADY, GLORIA GREENE, RITA HOUNCHELL, ROBERT HOUGHTON, SR., TAMMY MANN, SHARON L. HOWARD, as Administrator of the Estate, obo Paul Marksberry, HEATHER MCCANN, LYNDSEY MIDDENDORF, TERESA NICHOLS, CRYSTAL PIERCE, DEBORAH WORLEY, as the Executrix of the Estate, obo Fay Rosebery, MICHAEL SANDER, DANA SETTERS, DAVID SHEMPERT, RICHARD STANFIELD, SIERRA STRATMAN, KATHERINE WALLS, VERONICA YEAKLE, PATRICK STEPHENSON, MICHELLE AGEE, CHRISTOPHER SCOTT ATWOOD, MICHELLE BEAVAN, KAITLYN BOGGS, ARLETTA BOWLING, TARA BROWN, CHRISTOPHER CLARK, DANA CONLEY, ERIC COURTNEY, KRISTINE DORITY, CHRISTINE GERALDS, LENORA HAGGARD, SAMANTHA HAMILTON, JENNIFER HICKEY, KAREN JOHNSON, JOAN JONES, TAMMY JONES, AMANDA KOCH, MICHAEL KOELBLIN, NATASHA LAINHART, KYRA MCCLENDON, THOMAS MEYERS, ROBERT MOUNCE, JENNIFER MYERS, TONYA NEAL, SHERRI PUCKETT, MARY RAVENSCRAFT, DERRILL REYNOLDS, EDDIE STALLINGS, RYAN TANNER, LAURA WEISBECKER, KIRSTIN WEISMAN, CHERYL WYATT, MARY ZUREICK, FRIEDA AARON, JAMES ALBERS, KATRINA ALLEN, SHERRI LYNN ALLEN, REBECCA APPLEGATE, GEORGE ARNOLD, BRIAN ATKINS, THOMAS ATKINSON, JONATHAN ATWELL, THOMAS AUGST, GAYLE BACHMANN, CAIDAN BAILEY, PAUL BAKER, JENNIFER BALLINGER, THOMAS BARTH, CINDY BARTLETT, LAURA BATSCHE, NICHOLAS BATTISTA, JODY BAUER, JOSEPH BAUMGARDNER, PHYLLIS BECHTOLD, JUDY BECK, NANCY BEGLEY, TERRY BEIL, DENISE BENGE, NICK BENGE, WILLIAM BENTON, DENISE BESS, LEONA BEYER, EDYTHE BISHOP, JENNIFER BOOKMAN, PATRICIA BOONE, DEENA BORCHERS, DORIS BOTNER, NANCY BOWMAN, PENNY BRACKETT, LATOYA BRADSHAW, CHRISTINA BRASHEAR, MELISSA BRAUCHER, LINDSEY BRAY, SHARON BRICE, CALVIN BROWN, JONATHAN BRUNNER, VICKI BUSCHUR, KATHLEEN BUSHELMAN, BRENDA BUTLER, DOUG CALLAHAN, JANET CAMPBELL, ROBERT CAMPBELL, RENECIA CHERRY, TONYA CHISMAN, JENA CLARK, TERRY COLLINS, ELIZABETH COMPO, DAVID CONGER, KENNETH CONGER, BRENDA CONLEY, LISA CONLEY, FRANCENE COOK, MICHAEL COOK, GARY L. COOTS, JANET CORNETT, KRISTA COX, MICHAEL CRAIL, KAREN CRISSINGER, JOI CROWE, AMBER CROXSON, WILLIAM DABNEY, TAMMY DALE, JOSEPH DAVIS, RALPH DAWSON, OLLIE DEATON, STEFANIE DEATON, DAMON DECK, SANDRA DENNIS, CAROLYN DOTSON, BRENDA ERRGANG, TRACY ESSELMAN, MARGIE EVERSOLE, ARLENE FAIT, LINDA FAVARON, CAELA FINNELL, MARK R. FITZPATRICK, FRANCINE FORD, LENNIE FOSSETT, AMANDA FRANKS, AMY FULLER, JUDITH GARDNER, ERMA GILBERT, SARA GODBY, CHRISTINE GOLDSTEIN, GREG GRABER, MAURICE GRABOW, ERIN GREELISH, ROBBIE GREGORY, SUSAN GRIFFIN, JENNY GRIMM, MELISSA HABERMEHL, LYNN HALEY, RUHAMA HALL, DOROTHEA HAMILTON, COURTNEY HAMMONS, TIMOTHY HANNON, KEVIN HARTNESS, JESSICA HASTINGS, DOUGLAS HAYES, DENISE HELTON, EVELYN HELTON, THERESA HELTON, DEBRA HENDERSON, KELLY HENNESSY, BARBARA HENSLEY, RYAN HENSLEY, KAREN HIGGINBOTHAN, MICHAEL HILLARD, DIRK HITCHCOCK, CELESTE HOFFMAN, LORETTA HON, CHELSEA HORTMAN, RICKY HOUNCHELL, KATHRYN HOWELL, TAMMY HUGHES, CAROLYN HURSONG, GEORGE HUTCHINSON, MARTHA HUTTON, JEFFREY HYDE, ELSA IERACI, ALYSSA JACKSON, CHELSEA JOHNSON, ROGER JOHNSON, RACHEL JONES, JACQUELINE JUDKINS, KATELYN KAUFFMAN, THOMAS KELLISON, MICHELLE KEPLINGER, MARTHA KIBLER, DEBORAH KIDD, SHERRY KIDD, VIVIAN KIEFER, CHARLOTTE KING, ROSE KOEHLER, SHANNON KOEHLER, VALARIE KOPP, LARRY KRECH, VICTORIA LANDRUM, KAREN LEGER, SANDRA LEMMEL, AILENE LEVAN, LYNNE LIST, TAMMIE LITTLE, TAMALA LOVETTE, KENNETH MAHLENKAMP, VICKY MAINS, MARSHA MARTIN, STACY JOHN MARTIN, ROBERT MASTERS, TRACI MATHEWS, ALAN MATTHEWS, KIMBERLY MAYER, DEREK MAYFIELD, JENNA MCCALL, KEVIN MCDONALD, WHITNEY MCKENZIE, TERESA MCMILLEN, MARK MCMURREN, KAMERON MCNEAL, KERRY MCNEAL, TONIA MCQUEARY, TIFFANY MEADOWS, DAWN MERLAND, RANDALL METCALF, DIANE MEYER, KAREN MILLER, RYAN MILLER, VERA MOFFITT, BILLIE JANE MOORE, DONALD MOORE, ROBERT MOORE, TIM MOORE, MARJORIE NEWMAN, MICHELLE NOBLE, RUVIMBO NYEMBA, TIMOTHY OSBORN, DANNIE OWENS, HALEY PAYNE, JEFF PEDDICORD, DUANE PELFREY, CLARENCE PHILLIPS, JEFFREY POFF, SHEILA POGUE-KRABACHER, BRYAN POWERS, KATHERINE PRATER, CAROL PUMMELL, SANDRA RADEKE, DANIELLE REED, TONI ASH, Executrix of the Estate of Shirley Mains, JOANN FRAZIER, CHERYL MARIE POTTS, as the Executrix of the Estate on behalf of Jeffrey Potts, DAWN LEE ANN BROWN, DOMINIQUE BRAY, RANDALL BREWER and HILARY LEVANDOFSKY |
| THE MEDICAL PROTECTIVE COMPANY, MEDPRO GROUP INC., fka Medical Protective Corporation, TIMOTHY KENESEY and ROBERT IGNASIAK |
| 25-3930 |
| November 24, 2025 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit |
| Contract: Insurance |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on April 27, 2026. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| Filing 22 RESPONSE in opposition filed regarding a motion, [ # 21 ]; previously filed by Mr. Richard Dennis Porotsky, Jr. for The Medical Protective Company, MedPro Group Inc., Timothy Kenesey and Robert Ignasiak. Response from Attorney Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Certificate of Service: 04/27/2026. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 04/27/2026 12:47 PM] |
| Filing 21 MOTION filed by Mr. Richard Dennis Porotsky, Jr. for Robert Ignasiak, Timothy Kenesey, MedPro Group Inc. and The Medical Protective Company to file sur-reply brief. Certificate of Service: 04/22/2026. [25-3930]--[Edited 04/22/2026 by RO] (RDP) [Entered: 04/22/2026 03:00 PM] |
| Filing 20 REPLY BRIEF filed by Attorney Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Certificate of Service: 04/16/2026. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 04/16/2026 10:09 AM] |
| Filing 19 ***LOCKED - please refile without documents that are part of the district court's electronic record*** REPLY BRIEF filed by Attorney Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Certificate of Service: 04/15/2026. [25-3930]--[Edited 04/15/2026 by RO] (AJS) [Entered: 04/15/2026 02:20 PM] |
| Filing 18 APPELLEE BRIEF filed by Mr. Richard Dennis Porotsky, Jr. for Robert Ignasiak, Timothy Kenesey, MedPro Group Inc. and The Medical Protective Company. Certificate of Service: 03/26/2026. Argument Request: not requested. [25-3930] (RDP) [Entered: 03/26/2026 04:27 PM] |
| Filing 17 RULING LETTER SENT granting motion to extend time to file brief [ # 16 ] filed by Mr. Richard Dennis Porotsky, Jr. 7day extension of time granted. Resetting briefing schedule: appellee brief now due 03/27/2026. (RO) [Entered: 03/17/2026 09:07 AM] |
| Filing 16 MOTION filed by Mr. Richard Dennis Porotsky, Jr. for Robert Ignasiak, Timothy Kenesey, MedPro Group Inc. and The Medical Protective Company to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 03/16/2026. [25-3930] (RDP) [Entered: 03/16/2026 04:57 PM] |
| Filing 15 APPELLANT BRIEF filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Certificate of Service: 02/17/2026. Argument Request: requested. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 02/17/2026 02:35 PM] |
| Filing 14 RULING LETTER SENT granting appellants' motion to extend time to file brief [ # 13 ] by 14 days. Resetting briefing schedule: appellant brief now due 02/18/2026; appellee brief now due 03/20/2026. (GSA) [Entered: 02/04/2026 08:42 AM] |
| Filing 13 MOTION filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 02/03/2026. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 02/03/2026 03:34 PM] |
| Filing 12 RULING LETTER SENT granting motion to extend time to file brief [ # 11 ] filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman. 7 day extension of time granted. Resetting briefing schedule: appellant brief now due 02/04/2026; appellee brief now due 03/06/2026. (RO) [Entered: 01/28/2026 02:09 PM] |
| Filing 11 MOTION filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Lee Ann Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl Marie Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 01/27/2026. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 01/27/2026 02:48 PM] |
| Filing 10 RULING LETTER SENT granting motion to extend time to file brief [ # 9 ] filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman. 15 day extension of time granted. Resetting briefing schedule: appellant brief now due 01/28/2026; appellee brief now due 02/27/2026. (RO) [Entered: 01/02/2026 09:28 AM] |
| Filing 9 MOTION filed by Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M. Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick to extend time to file brief. Certificate of Service: 12/30/2025. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 12/30/2025 04:18 PM] |
| Filing 8 APPEARANCE filed for Appellees The Medical Protective Company, MedPro Group Inc., Robert Ignasiak and Timothy Kenesey by Sarah E. Abbott. Certificate of Service: 12/08/2025. [25-3930] (SEA) [Entered: 12/08/2025 03:16 PM] |
| Filing 7 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Name of Counsel: Richard D. Porotsky ; The Medical Protective Company and MedPro Group Inc. makes the following disclosure: 1. Is said party a subsidiary or affiliate of a publicly owned corporation? The Medical Protective Company and MedPro Group Inc. are wholly-owned subsidiaries and/or affiliates of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. 2. Is there a publicly owned corporation, not a party to the appeal, with a financial interest in the outcome? No Certificate of Service: 12/08/2025. [25-3930] (RDP) [Entered: 12/08/2025 12:46 PM] |
| Filing 6 APPEARANCE filed for Appellees MedPro Group Inc., The Medical Protective Company, Timothy Kenesey and Robert Ignasiak by Richard D. Porotsky. Certificate of Service: 12/08/2025. [25-3930] (RDP) [Entered: 12/08/2025 11:52 AM] |
| Filing 5 BRIEFING LETTER SENT setting briefing schedule: appellant brief due 01/13/2026; appellee brief due 02/12/2026. (RO) [Entered: 12/04/2025 09:43 AM] |
| Filing 4 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Name of Counsel: Alan J. Statman ; Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M. Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick makes the following disclosure: 1. Is said party a subsidiary or affiliate of a publicly owned corporation? No 2. Is there a publicly owned corporation, not a party to the appeal, with a financial interest in the outcome? No Certificate of Service: 12/02/2025. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 12/02/2025 04:06 PM] |
| Filing 3 CIVIL APPEAL STATEMENT OF PARTIES AND ISSUES filed by Attorney Mr. Alan Joel Statman for Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M. Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Is this case a cross-appeal? No ; Has this case or a related one been before this court previously? No ; Please identify the party(ies) the appeal is being taken against: Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M. Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle, Mary Zureick and Robert Ignasiak and Timothy Kenesey ; Issues:. Certificate of Service: 12/02/2025. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 12/02/2025 03:55 PM] |
| Filing 2 APPEARANCE filed for Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominique Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randall Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hilary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M. Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle, Mary Zureick and Appellees Robert Ignasiak, Timothy Kenesey, MedPro Group Inc. and The Medical Protective Company by Alan J. Statman. Certificate of Service: 12/02/2025. [25-3930] (AJS) [Entered: 12/02/2025 03:49 PM] |
| Filing 1 Civil Case Docketed. Notice filed by Appellants Frieda Aaron, Patricia Adams, Michelle Agee, James Albers, Katrina Allen, Sherri Lynn Allen, Rebecca Applegate, George Arnold, Toni Ash, Brian Atkins, Thomas Atkinson, Jonathan Atwell, Christopher Scott Atwood, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Caidan Bailey, Paul Baker, Jennifer Ballinger, Thomas Barth, Cindy Bartlett, Laura Batsche, Nicholas Battista, Jody Bauer, Joseph Baumgardner, Michelle Beavan, Phyllis Bechtold, Judy Beck, Nancy Begley, Terry Beil, Mackenzie Bender, Denise Benge, Nick Benge, William Benton, Denise Bess, Leona Beyer, Edythe Bishop, Kaitlyn Boggs, Jennifer Bookman, Patricia Boone, Deena Borchers, Doris Botner, Arletta Bowling, Nancy Bowman, Penny Brackett, Latoya Bradshaw, Rebekah Brady, Christina Brashear, Melissa Braucher, Dominque Bray, Lindsey Bray, Randy Brewer, Sharon Brice, Calvin Brown, Dawn Brown, Tara Brown, Tara Brown, Jonathan Brunner, Vicki Buschur, Kathleen Bushelman, Brenda Butler, Doug Callahan, Janet Campbell, Robert Campbell, Renecia Cherry, Tonya Chisman, Christopher Clark, Jena Clark, Terry Collins, Elizabeth Compo, David Conger, Kenneth Conger, Brenda Conley, Dana Conley, Lisa Conley, Francene Cook, Michael Cook, Gary L. Coots, Janet Cornett, Eric Courtney, Krista Cox, Michael Crail, Karen Crissinger, Joi Crowe, Amber Croxson, William Dabney, Tammy Dale, Joseph Davis, Ralph Dawson, Ollie Deaton, Stefanie Deaton, Damon Deck, Sandra Dennis, Kristine Dority, Carolyn Dotson, Brenda Errgang, Tracy Esselman, Margie Eversole, Arlene Fait, Linda Favaron, Caela Finnell, Mark R. Fitzpatrick, Francine Ford, Lennie Fossett, Amanda Franks, Joann Frazier, Amy Fuller, Judith Gardner, Christine Geralds, Erma Gilbert, Sara Godby, Christine Goldstein, Greg Graber, Maurice Grabow, Erin Greelish, Gloria Greene, Robbie Gregory, Susan Griffin, Jenny Grimm, Melissa Habermehl, Lenora Haggard, Lynn Haley, Ruhama Hall, Dorothea Hamilton, Samantha Hamilton, Courtney Hammons, Timothy Hannon, Kevin Hartness, Jessica Hastings, Douglas Hayes, Denise Helton, Evelyn Helton, Theresa Helton, Debra Henderson, Kelly Hennessy, Barbara Hensley, Ryan Hensley, Jennifer Hickey, Karen Higginbothan, Michael Hillard, Dirk Hitchcock, Celeste Hoffman, Loretta Hon, Chelsea Hortman, Robert Houghton, Sr., Ricky Hounchell, Rita Hounchell, Sharon L. Howard, Kathryn Howell, Tammy Hughes, Carolyn Hursong, George Hutchinson, Martha Hutton, Jeffrey Hyde, Jeffrey Hyde, Elsa Ieraci, Alyssa Jackson, Chelsea Johnson, Ms. Karen Johnson, Roger Johnson, Joan Jones, Rachel Jones, Tammy Jones, Jacqueline Judkins, Katelyn Kauffman, Thomas Kellison, Michelle Keplinger, Martha Kibler, Deborah Kidd, Sherry Kidd, Vivian Kiefer, Charlotte King, Amanda Koch, Rose Koehler, Shannon Koehler, Michael Koelblin, Valarie Kopp, Larry Krech, Natasha Lainhart, Victoria Landrum, Karen Leger, Sandra Lemmel, Ailene Levan, Hillary Levandofsky, Lynne List, Tammie Little, Tamala Lovette, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Vicky Mains, Tammy Mann, Marsha Martin, Stacy John Martin, Mr. Robert Masters, Traci Mathews, Alan Matthews, Kimberly Mayer, Derek Mayfield, Jenna McCall, Heather McCann, Kyra McClendon, Kevin McDonald, Whitney McKenzie, Teresa McMillen, Mark McMurren, Kameron McNeal, Kerry McNeal, Tonia McQueary, Tiffany Meadows, Dawn Merland, Randall Metcalf, Diane Meyer, Thomas Meyers, Lyndsey Middendorf, Karen Miller, Ryan Miller, Vera Moffitt, Billie Jane Moore, Donald Moore, Robert Moore, Tim Moore, Robert Mounce, Jennifer Myers, Tonya Neal, Marjorie Newman, Teresa Nichols, Michelle Noble, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Timothy Osborn, Dannie Owens, Haley Payne, Jeff Peddicord, Duane Pelfrey, Clarence Phillips, Crystal Pierce, Jeffrey Poff, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Cheryl M Potts, Bryan Powers, Katherine Prater, Sherri Puckett, Carol Pummell, Sandra Radeke, Mary Ravenscraft, Danielle Reed, Derrill Reynolds, Michael Sander, Dana Setters, David Shempert, Eddie Stallings, Richard Stanfield, Patrick Stephenson, Sierra Stratman, Ryan Tanner, Katherine Walls, Laura Weisbecker, Kirstin Weisman, Deborah Worley, Cheryl Wyatt, Veronica Yeakle and Mary Zureick. Transcript needed: y. (RO) [Entered: 11/24/2025 03:30 PM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.