Todd Heath v. Wisconsin Bell, Inc.
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA |
| TODD HEATH |
| WISCONSIN BELL, INCORPORATED |
| USTELECOM - THE BROADBAND ASSOCIATION, CTIA - THE WIRELESS ASSOCIATION and CHAMBER OF COMMERCE OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA |
| 22-1515 |
| March 30, 2022 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit |
| False Claims Act |
Opinions
We have the following opinions for this case:
| Description |
|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on October 5, 2023. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
Filing 69
Paper copies of response to rehearing enbanc brief filed by Appellant Todd Heath. Dist. [69] [7340092] [22-1515] (CAG) [Entered: 10/05/2023 11:59 AM]
|
Filing 68
Filed Response to Petition for Rehearing and Petition for Rehearing Enbanc by Appellant Todd Heath, per order. [68] [7339960] Paper copies due on 10/10/2023 [22-1515] (KRA) [Entered: 10/04/2023 03:49 PM]
|
Filing 67
Submitted response to petition for rehearing enbanc by David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [67] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7339943] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 10/04/2023 02:47 PM]
|
Filing 66
Sent clerk's copy of request to Appellant Todd Heath requesting 30 copies of their Response to the Petition for Rehearing and Petition for Rehearing Enbanc filed by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated on 08/30/2023. Response to Petition for Rehearing due for Appellant Todd Heath by 10/04/2023. [7336815] [22-1515] (MAN) [Entered: 09/20/2023 11:40 AM]
|
Filing 65
Paper copies of brief in support of Petition for Rehearing En Banc filed by Amicus Curiae Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America, dist. [65] [7336200] [22-1515] (LJ) [Entered: 09/18/2023 12:18 PM]
|
Filing 64
Paper copies of brief in support of Petition for Rehearing for Enbanc filed by Amici Curiae CTIA - The Wireless Association and USTelecom - The Broadband Association. DIST. [64] [7336069] [22-1515] (GW) [Entered: 09/18/2023 08:54 AM]
|
Filing 63
Filed brief in support of Petition for Rehearing for Enbanc by Amicus Curiae Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America. Filed per order of 09/14/2023. Paper copies due on 09/18/2023. [63] [7335786] [22-1515] (GW) [Entered: 09/14/2023 04:33 PM]
|
Filing 62
Re-Submitted brief by Christian Sheehan for Amicus Curiae Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America. Leave granted by court order. [62] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7335687] [22-1515] (Sheehan, Christian) [Entered: 09/14/2023 01:50 PM]
|
Filing 61
Filed brief in support of Petition for Rehearing for Enbanc by Amici Curiae CTIA - The Wireless Association and USTelecom - The Broadband Association. Filed per order of 09/14/2023. Paper copies due on 09/18/2023. [61] [7335652] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 09/14/2023 11:42 AM]
|
Filing 60
ORDER re: 1. Motion for Leave to File Brief of USTelecom The Broadband Association & CTIA The Wireless Association as Amici Curiae in Support of Defendant-Appellees Petition for Rehearing En Banc [ # 58 ]. 2. Motion of Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America for Leave to File Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Defendant-Appellees Petition for Rehearing En Banc [ # 59 ]. IT IS ORDERED that USTelecoms motion is GRANTED. The clerk of this court shall file INSTANTER the tendered amicus brief by USTelecom and CTIA. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Chamber of Commerce of the United States of Americas motion is GRANTED to the extent that the Chamber shall submit a compliant amicus brief by 09/18/2023. Specifically, the table of authorities must be listed alphabetically. No other changes will be permitted. LCE [60] [7335651] [22-1515] (MAN) [Entered: 09/14/2023 11:20 AM]
|
Filing 59
Non-Party motion filed by Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America to file Amicus Curiae Brief in Support of Defendant-Appellee's Petition for Rehearing En Banc. [59] [7334079] [22-1515] (Sheehan, Christian) [Entered: 09/06/2023 04:02 PM]
|
Filing 58
Filed Non-Party Motion for Leave to File Brief as Amici Curiae in Support of Defendant-Appellee's Petition for Rehearing En Banc by USTelecom - The Broadband Association & CTIA - The Wireless Association. [7333978] [22-1515] (Angstreich, Scott) [Entered: 09/06/2023 11:31 AM]
|
Filing 57
Paper copies of rehearing enbanc brief filed by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. DIST. [57] [7333399] [22-1515] (CAH) [Entered: 09/01/2023 11:46 AM]
|
Filing 56
Filed Petition for Rehearing and Petition for Rehearing Enbanc by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. Paper copies due on 09/05/2023 [56] [7333069] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 08/31/2023 09:11 AM]
|
Filing 55
Submitted petition for rehearing enbanc by Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [55] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7333038] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgi) [Entered: 08/30/2023 05:24 PM]
|
Filing 54
Order issued GRANTING motion to extend time to file petition for rehearing [ # 53 ]. The appellee shall file any petition for rehearing by 08/30/2023. LCE [54] [7328761] [22-1515] (MAN) [Entered: 08/10/2023 03:34 PM]
|
Filing 53
Motion filed by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated to extend time to file petition for rehearing [53] [7328317] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgi) [Entered: 08/09/2023 08:56 AM]
|
Filing 52
ORDER: Final judgment filed per opinion. With costs: yes. [52] [7326977] [22-1515] (HTP) [Entered: 08/02/2023 11:38 AM]
|
Filing 51
Filed opinion of the court by Judge Hamilton. The judgment of the district court is REVERSED and the case is REMANDED to the district court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. Frank H. Easterbrook, Circuit Judge; David F. Hamilton, Circuit Judge and John Z. Lee, Circuit Judge. [51] [7326970] [22-1515] (HTP) [Entered: 08/02/2023 11:33 AM]
|
Filing 50
Filed Response by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated Attorney Helgi C. Walker to Appellant Todd Heath's Fed. R. App. P. 28(j) Letter. [50][7316743] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgi) [Entered: 06/13/2023 01:48 PM]
|
Filing 49
Filed Appellant Todd Heath Citation of Additional Authority, per Circuit Rule 28(e). [49] [7316123] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 06/09/2023 11:23 AM]
|
Filing 48
ORDER re: Motion to withdraw appearance of counsel. [ # 47 ] The motion is GRANTED. Attorney Robert C. Walters may withdraw from further representation of appellee Wisconsin Bell, Inc. Attorney Helgard C. Walker shall continue to serve as counsel of record for appellee Wisconsin Bell, Inc. CDH [48] [7296482] [22-1515] (CG) [Entered: 03/10/2023 08:52 AM]
|
Filing 47
Attorney motion filed by Attorney Robert C. Walters for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated to withdraw as counsel. [47] [7296298] [22-1515]--[Edited 03/09/2023 by ER - to reflect attorney motion] (Walters, Robert) [Entered: 03/09/2023 12:38 PM]
|
Filing 46
Filed Response by Appellant Todd Heath Attorney David J. Chizewer to Defendant-Appellee Wisconsin Bell's Fed. R. App. P. 28(j) Letter. [46][7292530] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 02/21/2023 02:06 PM]
|
Filing 45
Filed Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated Citation of Additional Authority, per Circuit Rule 28(e). Argument set for: 02/09/2023. [45] [7291909] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 02/16/2023 05:32 PM]
|
Filing 44
Case argued by David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath and Helgard C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [44] [7290274] [22-1515] (KRA) [Entered: 02/09/2023 01:56 PM]
|
Filing 43
Case heard and taken under advisement by panel: Frank H. Easterbrook, Circuit Judge; David F. Hamilton, Circuit Judge and John Z. Lee, Circuit Judge. [43] [7290273] [22-1515] (KRA) [Entered: 02/09/2023 01:55 PM]
|
Filing 42
Argument reset for Thursday, February 9, 2023, at 9:30 a.m. in the Main Courtroom, Room 2721, of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, 219 S. Dearborn Street, Chicago, Illinois. Each side limited to 20 minutes. [42] [7288909] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 02/02/2023 04:32 PM]
|
Filing 41
Received argument confirmation per argument email form for Attorney David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [41] [7288186] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 01/31/2023 11:42 AM]
|
Filing 40
Received argument confirmation per argument email form for Attorney Helgard C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [40] [7288173] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 01/31/2023 11:27 AM]
|
Filing 39
Received argument confirmation from David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [39] [7283652] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 01/09/2023 05:00 PM]
|
Filing 38
Received argument confirmation from Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [38] [7283376] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 01/09/2023 09:52 AM]
|
Filing 37
NOTICE: Attorney Mr. Christian R. Larsen for Not Party USA will not be available for oral argument the United States Attorney's Office will not be appearing. [37] [7283365] [22-1515] (Larsen, Christian) [Entered: 01/09/2023 09:25 AM]
|
Filing 36
Argument set for Thursday, February 9, 2023, at 9:30 a.m. in the Main Courtroom, Room 2721, of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, 219 S. Dearborn Street, Chicago, Illinois. Each side limited to 15 minutes. [36] [7282242] [22-1515] (KRA) [Entered: 01/03/2023 01:17 PM]
|
Filing 35
NOTICE: Attorney Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated will not be available for oral argument September 28 to October 4; November 7 to 18; November 28 to December 2; December 5 to 14, 2022; January 3 to 11; January 12 to 25; April 25 to 26; and May 18 to 19, 2023. [35] [7263043] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 09/26/2022 04:07 PM]
|
Filing 34
Paper copies of appellant reply brief filed by Appellant Todd Heath. [34] [7262932] [22-1515] (CAG) [Entered: 09/26/2022 01:54 PM]
|
Filing 33
Appellant's reply brief filed by Appellant Todd Heath. Paper copies due on 09/29/2022. Electronically Transmitted. REMINDER: Hearing notices are mailed shortly before the date of oral argument. Please note that counsel's unavailability for oral argument must be submitted by letter, filed electronically with the Clerk's Office, no later than the filing of the appellant's brief in a criminal case and the filing of an appellee's brief in a civil case. See Cir. R. 34(b)(3). The court's calendar is located at http://www.ca7.uscourts.gov/cal/argcalendar.pdf. Once scheduled, oral argument is rescheduled only in extraordinary circumstances. See Cir. R. 34(b)(4), (e). [33] [7262431] [22-1515] (LJ) [Entered: 09/22/2022 04:08 PM]
|
Filing 32
Submitted appellant reply brief by David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [32] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7262427] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 09/22/2022 04:01 PM]
|
Filing 31
Paper copies of appellee brief filed by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [31] [7255866] [22-1515] (LJ) [Entered: 08/22/2022 11:24 AM]
|
Filing 30
Appellee's brief filed by Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. Paper copies due on 08/25/2022. Electronically Transmitted. REMINDER: Hearing notices are mailed shortly before the date of oral argument. Please note that counsel's unavailability for oral argument must be submitted by letter, filed electronically with the Clerk's Office, no later than the filing of the appellant's brief in a criminal case and the filing of an appellee's brief in a civil case. See Cir. R. 34(b)(3). The court's calendar is located at http://www.ca7.uscourts.gov/cal/argcalendar.pdf. Once scheduled, oral argument is rescheduled only in extraordinary circumstances. See Cir. R. 34(b)(4), (e). [30] [7255571] [22-1515] (KRA) [Entered: 08/19/2022 10:00 AM]
|
Filing 29
Submitted appellee brief by Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [29] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7255489] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 08/18/2022 05:36 PM]
|
Filing 28
NOTICE: Attorney David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath will not be available for oral argument October 11 to November 7, 2022 and January 3 to January 11, 2023. [28] [7255387] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 08/18/2022 01:16 PM]
|
Filing 27
NOTICE: Attorney Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated will not be available for oral argument September 28 to October 4; November 7 to 18; November 28 to December 2; and December 5 to 14, 2022. [27] [7255361] [22-1515] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 08/18/2022 12:00 PM]
|
Filing 26
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Michael J. Gill for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [26] [7253946] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] [Edited 08/11/2022 by CG to reflect the reinstatement of counsel.] (Gill, Michael) [Entered: 08/10/2022 06:05 PM]
|
Filing 25
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Stephen J. Hammer for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [25] [7253849] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] [25] [7253849] [22-1515]--[Edited 08/10/2022 by HTP to reflect addition of counsel.] (Hammer, Stephen) [Entered: 08/10/2022 12:33 PM]
|
Filing 24
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Ashley E. Johnson for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [24] [7253847] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] [24] [7253847] [22-1515]--[Edited 08/10/2022 by HTP to reflect addition of counsel.] (Johnson, Ashley) [Entered: 08/10/2022 12:31 PM]
|
Filing 23
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Helgi C. Walker for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [23] [7253845] (L-Yes; E-Yes; R-Yes) [22-1515] [23] [7253845] [22-1515]--[Edited 08/10/2022 by HTP to reflect termination and addition of counsel.] (Walker, Helgard) [Entered: 08/10/2022 12:24 PM]
|
Filing 22
ORDER re: Motion to withdraw as counsel for plaintiff/relator-appellant. The motion is GRANTED and attorney Laura J. Lavey may withdraw from further representation of the Plaintiff/Relator-Appellant. The clerk will update the docket accordingly. [ # 21 ] CMD [22] [7246189] [22-1515] (HTP) [Entered: 07/06/2022 08:48 AM]
|
Filing 21
Motion filed by Appellant Todd Heath to withdraw as counsel [21] [7245833] [22-1515] (Lavey, Laura) [Entered: 07/01/2022 05:17 PM]
|
Filing 20
Paper copies of appellant brief filed by Appellant Todd Heath. [20] [7244092] [22-1515] (LJ) [Entered: 06/23/2022 11:38 AM]
|
Filing 19
Appellant's brief filed by Appellant Todd Heath. Paper copies due on 06/28/2022. Electronically Transmitted. REMINDER: Hearing notices are mailed shortly before the date of oral argument. Please note that counsel's unavailability for oral argument must be submitted by letter, filed electronically with the Clerk's Office, no later than the filing of the appellant's brief in a criminal case and the filing of an appellee's brief in a civil case. See Cir. R. 34(b)(3). The court's calendar is located at http://www.ca7.uscourts.gov/cal/argcalendar.pdf. Once scheduled, oral argument is rescheduled only in extraordinary circumstances. See Cir. R. 34(b)(4), (e). [19] [7243726] [22-1515] (LCP) [Entered: 06/22/2022 08:28 AM]
|
Filing 18
Submitted appellant brief by David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [18] NOTE: Access to this entry is limited to counsel of record. Once the document is approved by the court, it will be filed onto the court's docket as a separate entry which will be open to the public. [7243672] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 06/21/2022 04:23 PM]
|
Filing 17
NOTICE: Circuit Rule 46(a) requires lead counsel be admitted to practice within 30 days of the date the appeal/petition was docketed. The rule also requires any attorney wishing to present oral argument to be admitted. Our records indicate as of this date Attorney Laura J. Lavey for Appellant Todd Heath has/have not been admitted to practice in this court. Within 21 days, please file your application for admission by going to: http://www.ca7.uscourts.gov/forms/forms7.htm and choosing the link, "Application for Admission to Practice in the Seventh Circuit". [17] [7234241] [22-1515] (SK) [Entered: 05/05/2022 12:44 PM]
|
Filing 16
ORDER: Pursuant to Circuit Rule 33, briefing will proceed as follows: Appellant's brief due on or before 06/21/2022 for Todd Heath. Appellee's brief due on or before 08/18/2022 for Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. Appellant's reply brief, if any, is due on or before 09/22/2022 for Appellant Todd Heath. RJS [7232069] [22-1515] (FP) [Entered: 04/26/2022 02:37 PM]
|
Filing 15
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Joseph D. Newbold for Appellant Todd Heath. [15] [7231473] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/22/2022 by PS - to reflect the addition of counsel.] (Newbold, Joseph) [Entered: 04/22/2022 01:54 PM]
|
Filing 14
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Ethan A. Hastert for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [14] [7231438] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515][14] [7231438] [22-1515]--[Edited 04/22/2022 by HTP to reflect addition of counsel.] (Hastert, Ethan) [Entered: 04/22/2022 12:08 PM]
|
Filing 13
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Michael J. Gill for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [13] [7231250] (L-Yes; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] (Gill, Michael) [Entered: 04/21/2022 03:11 PM]
|
Filing 12
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Laura J. Lavey for Appellant Todd Heath. [12] [7231015] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] [12] [7231015] [22-1515]--[Edited 04/21/2022 by HTP to reflect addition of counsel.] (Lavey, Laura) [Entered: 04/20/2022 04:32 PM]
|
Filing 11
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Christa Wittenberg for Appellant Todd Heath. [11] [7231014] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] [11] [7231014] [22-1515]--[Edited 04/21/2022 by HTP to reflect addition of counsel.] (Wittenberg, Christa) [Entered: 04/20/2022 04:29 PM]
|
Filing 10
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Douglas P. Dehler for Appellant Todd Heath. [10] [7231011] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515] (Dehler, Douglas) [Entered: 04/20/2022 04:24 PM]
|
Filing 9
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Andrew P. LeGrand for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [9] [7230965] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/20/2022 by PS - to reflect the addition of counsel.] (LeGrand, Andrew) [Entered: 04/20/2022 03:08 PM]
|
Filing 8
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Robert C. Walters for Appellee Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. [8] [7230963] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/20/2022 by PS - to reflect the addition of counsel.] (Walters, Robert) [Entered: 04/20/2022 03:06 PM]
|
Filing 7
Filed Seventh Circuit Transcript Information Sheet by Appellant Todd Heath. [7] [7229553] [22-1515] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 04/13/2022 01:51 PM]
|
Filing 6
Circuit Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement and Appearance filed by Attorney Roger A. Lewis for Appellant Todd Heath. [6] [7227550] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/05/2022 by FP to reflect that atty. Lewis is added to the docket.] (Lewis, Roger) [Entered: 04/05/2022 12:52 PM]
|
Filing 5
Appearance form Disclosure Statement filed by Attorney David J. Chizewer for Appellant Todd Heath. [5] [7227547] (L-Yes; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/05/2022 by FP to reflect that atty. Chizewer is added to the docket.] (Chizewer, David) [Entered: 04/05/2022 12:44 PM]
|
Filing 4
ORDER: Pursuant to Circuit Rule 33, briefing will proceed as follows: Appellant's brief due on or before 05/23/2022 for Todd Heath. Appellee's brief due on or before 06/22/2022 for Wisconsin Bell, Incorporated. Appellant's reply brief, if any, is due on or before 07/13/2022 for Appellant Todd Heath. RJS [7227388] [22-1515]--[Edited 04/05/2022 by CG to reflect correct deadlines.] (CG) [Entered: 04/05/2022 08:59 AM]
|
Filing 3
Notice of Circuit Rule 33 mediation issued. The mediation will be conducted by phone, Friday April 22, 2022 at 9:30 a.m. Central Time. See Notice for further details and requirements. RJS. [3] [7227381] [22-1515] (CG) [Entered: 04/05/2022 08:51 AM]
|
Filing 2
Added Attorney(s) Christian R. Larsen for party(s) Not Party USA, in case 22-1515 per appearance form. Appearance form filed by Attorney Chris R. Larsen for Not Party USA. [2] [7226934] (L-No; E-Yes; R-No) [22-1515]--[Edited 04/01/2022 by AD to reflect the addition of counsel.] (Larsen, Christian) [Entered: 04/01/2022 03:44 PM]
|
Filing 1
U.S. civil case docketed. Fee paid. Docketing statement filed. Transcript information sheet due by 04/13/2022. Appellant's brief due on or before 05/09/2022 for Todd Heath. [1] [7226531] [22-1515] (CG) [Entered: 03/31/2022 12:08 PM]
|
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.