Tash Hepting, et al v. AT&T Corporation, et al
| In re: NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY TELECOMMUNICATIONS RECORDS LITIGATION |
| TASH HEPTING, GREGORY HICKS, ERIK KNUTZEN and CAROLYN JEWEL, on behalf of themselves and all other similarly situated |
| AT&T CORPORATION and AT&T, INC. |
| UNITED STATES OF AMERICA |
| LAW PROFESSORS |
| 09-16676 |
| August 7, 2009 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit |
| Other Civil Rights |
Opinions
We have the following opinions for this case:
| Description |
|---|
 Hepting, et al. v. AT&T Corp., et al.
|
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on December 29, 2011. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| Filing 86 Terminated John Rogovin for Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16677, Verizon Wireless Services, LLC, Verizon and MCI Worldcom Advanced Networks, LLC in 09-16691, Verizon Florida, Inc. and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16707 and MCI, LLC in 09-16712, Kalea Seitz Clark for Verizon Maryland, Inc. in 09-16683 [7489649] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LC) |
| Filing 85 Received 7 paper copies of Supplemental reply brief [63] filed by Tash Hepting in 09-16676. Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Ray Anderson in 09-16720, and James Joll in 09-16723. [7483259] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 84 Added attorney Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T, Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16698 Eric Dean McArthur for New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. AT&T, Inc. AT&T Operations Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16702 Eric Dean McArthur for Cingular Wireless AT&T, Inc., in case 09-16686 Eric Dean McArthur for Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. AT&T Corp. AT&T, in case 09-16704 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Communications of California AT&T Corp., in case 09-16684 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corporation AT&T, Inc., in case 09-16676 Eric Dean McArthur for Cingular Wireless LLC Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. AT&T Corp. AT&T, in case 09-16707 Eric Dean McArthur for Cingular Wireless LLC, in case 09-16687 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc. SBC Long Distance, LLC, in case 09-16708 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16697 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. Cingular Wireless, LLC AT&T Corp. AT&T Communications, Inc., in case 09-16688 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16709 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16690 Eric Dean McArthur for Cingular Wireless LLC Bell South Corporation, in case 09-16719 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. Cingular Wireless, LLC AT&T Communications of California, Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16691 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corp. AT&T Communications, Inc., in case 09-16692 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16717 Eric Dean McArthur for Illinois Bell Telephone Co. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16713 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corporation AT&T Inc. Bellsouth Corporation, in case 09-16720 Eric Dean McArthur for BellSouth Corp. AT&T Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16723 Eric Dean McArthur for Pacific Bell Telephone Company AT&T Communications of California, Inc. AT&T Inc. SBC Long Distance, LLC AT&T Corp., in case 09-16710 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corporation, in case 09-16701 Eric Dean McArthur for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16700. [7475025] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 83 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Eric D. McArthur for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, Appellees AT&T, Inc. and Cingular Wireless in 09-16686, Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16688, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC and Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc. and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc. and Bellsouth Corporation in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc. and BellSouth Corp. in 09-16723. Date of service: 09/15/2010. [7474999] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (EDM) |
| Filing 82 Terminated Thomas P. Walsh for USA in 09-16713. [7474843] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 81 Received Attorney Thomas P. Walsh for Appellee USA in 09-16713 letter dated 09/14/2010 re: withdrawal of counsel from appeals. No service. (Counsel reminded to file documents correctly pursuant to 9th Cir. R. 25-2. Also see 9th Cir. R. 25-3.1.) [7474831] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 80 Received 7 paper copies of Joint Reply brief [71] filed by all Plaintiffs-Appellants. [7472656] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 79 Filed clerk order: The supplemental reply brief [63] submitted by Tash Hepting in 09-16676, Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Ray Anderson in 09-16720, James Joll in 09-16723 is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a tan cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. Court records indicate that 55 attorneys participating in these appeals have not registered for the Court’s Appellate Electronic Case Files ("ECF") system. Use of the ECF system is mandatory for all attorneys unless the Court grants a request to be exempted from the requirement. See 9th Cir. R. 25-5. All attorneys participating in these appeals who have not already registered for the Court’s ECF system are directed to do so within 7 days from the filing of this order. Information about electronic filing and the ECF system may be found on the Court's website. [7467450] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 78 Filed clerk order: The joint reply brief [71] submitted by All Plaintiffs-Appellants is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a gray cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7467367] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 77 Filed order (Appellate Commissioner) The opposed motion to file an overlength reply brief is granted. The opposed motion to vacate the June 16, 2010 order is granted in part. The provision of the order relieving co-counsel remains in place. The remaining provisions of the order are vacated. The motion to file a supplemental reply brief is granted. The opposed motion to file public and redacted versions of the supplemental answering brief are referred to the merits panel for resolution. The redacted version of the brief shall be provisionally maintained under seal and in camera pending the panel’s resolution of the motion. (Pro Mo) [7467241] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (KKW) |
| Filing 76 Filed (ECF) Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723 reply to response (). Date of service: 07/26/2010. [7418235] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SES) |
| Filing 75 Filed (ECF) Appellee USA reply to response (). Date of service: 07/16/2010. [7407433]--[COURT UPDATE: spread entry to consolidated case numbers: [09−16676, 09−16677, 09−16679, 09−16682, 09−16683, 09−16684, 09−16685, 09−16686, 09−16687, 09−16688, 09−16690, 09−16691, 09−16692, 09−16693, 09−16694, 09−16696, 09−16697, 09−16698, 09−16700, 09−16701, 09−16702, 09−16704, 09−16706, 09−16707, 09−16708, 09−16709, 09−16710, 09−16712, 09−16713, 09−16717, 09−16719, 09−16720, 09−16723] 07/16/2010 by MS] (TMB) |
| Filing 74 Filed (ECF) Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16677 response supporting motion (,motion to file oversized brief). Date of service: 07/12/2010. [7401935] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (CC) |
| Filing 73 Filed (ECF) Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723 response opposing motion (,motion for miscellaneous relief (to be used only if no other relief applies)). Date of service: 07/07/2010. [7396762] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SES) |
| Filing 72 Filed (ECF) Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16677, Appellee Sprint Nextel Corporation in 09-16679, 09-16682, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Maryland, Inc. in 09-16683, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, 09-16685, Appellees AT&T, Inc., Cingular Wireless and Verizon in 09-16686, Appellees Cingular Wireless LLC, Nextel West Corp. and Verizon in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company, Inc., MCI Communications Services, Inc., Nextel West Corp., Spring Spectrum L.P., Sprint Communications Company, L.P. and Verizon in 09-16688, Appellees AT&T Corp., MCI Communications Services, Inc. and Verizon in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company Incorporated, Nextel West Corp., Spring Spectrum L.P., Sprint Communcations Company L.P. and Verizon in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Verizon and Verizon Global Networks, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees Verizon, Verizon Communications, Inc. and Verizon Northwest, Inc. in 09-16706, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Cingular Wireless LLC, Verizon, Verizon Communications Inc. and Verizon Florida, Inc. in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc., SBC Long Distance, LLC and Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees MCI, LLC and Verizon in 09-16712, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation, Cingular Wireless LLC and Sprint Nextel Corporation in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc., Bellsouth Corporation, Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., BellSouth Corp., Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16723 response opposing motion (,motion to file oversized brief). Date of service: 07/07/2010. [7395262] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (MK) |
| Filing 71 Submitted (ECF) Reply brief for review and filed Motion to file oversized brief. Submitted by Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16677. Date of service: 07/01/2010. [7392015] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE; attached the certificate of service. 07/02/2010 by MS] (CC) |
| Filing 70 Terminated Ronald Paltin Schiller for Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16694 [7374911] [09-16694, 09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SC) |
| Filing 69 Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:CB): The motion to file a supplemental reply brief is denied. The clerk notes that the motion for leave to file a supplemental brief made no request for that relief. The Government’s motion to file redacted and sealed versions of the brief is granted. The motion to file a late response to the Government’s motion is granted. Ronald P. Schiller’s motion to withdraw as co-counsel for Verizon is granted. [7374896] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SC) |
| Filing 68 Received 7 paper copies of Answering brief [66] filed by USA. [7347196] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 67 Filed clerk order: The answering brief [66] submitted by USA is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a red cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7343343] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 66 Submitted (ECF) Answering brief for review. Submitted by Appellee USA. Date of service: 05/19/2010. [7343245]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread entry to consolidated cases 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723. 05/19/2010 by MA] (TMB) |
| Filing 65 Filed (ECF) Appellant Tina Herron in 09-16704, Appellant Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Appellant Ray Anderson in 09-16720, Appellant James Joll in 09-16723 Motion to file a late brief. Date of service: 05/06/2010. [7327925] [09-16676, 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread docket text to rest of consolidated cases, 09-16707, 09-16692, 09-16690, 09-16708, 09-16691, 09-16710, 09-16709, 09-16688, 09-16712, 09-16687, 09-16713, 09-16686, 09-16717, 09-16685, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16682, 09-16693, 09-16679, 09-16677, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16700, 09-16698, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16706. 05/06/2010 by RY ] (SES) |
| Filing 64 Filed (ECF) Appellant Tina Herron in 09-16704, Appellant Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Appellant Ray Anderson in 09-16720, Appellant James Joll in 09-16723 Motion to file supplemental brief. Date of service: 05/06/2010. [7327561] [09-16676, 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread docket text to rest of consolidated cases, 09-16707, 09-16692, 09-16690, 09-16708, 09-16691, 09-16710, 09-16709, 09-16688, 09-16712, 09-16687, 09-16713, 09-16686, 09-16717, 09-16685, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16682, 09-16693, 09-16679, 09-16677, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16700, 09-16698, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16706. 05/06/2010 by RY] (SES) |
| Filing 63 Submitted (ECF) Reply brief for review. Submitted by Appellant Tina Herron in 09-16704, Appellant Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Appellant Ray Anderson in 09-16720, Appellant James Joll in 09-16723. Date of service: 05/03/2010. [7323345] [09-16676, 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread brief to consolidated cases. 05/06/2010 by MA] (SES) |
| Filing 62 Received 7 paper copies of Supplemental brief [58] filed by AT&T Defendants-Appellees. [7309536] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 61 Received 7 paper copies of Supplemental brief [56] filed by USA. [7309488] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 60 Filed clerk order: The supplemental brief (public version) [56] submitted by USA is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a tan cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7306916] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 59 Filed clerk order: The supplemental brief [58] submitted by AT&T defendants-appellees is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a tan cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7306757] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 58 Submitted (ECF) Supplemental brief for review. Submitted by Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, Appellees AT&T, Inc. and Cingular Wireless in 09-16686, Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC and Indiana Bell Telephone Company, Inc. in 09-16688, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC and Indiana Bell Telephone Company Incorporated in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC and Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc., SBC Long Distance, LLC and Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc. and Bellsouth Corporation in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc. and BellSouth Corp. in 09-16723. Date of service: 04/19/2010. [7306698] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (MK) |
| Filing 57 Filed (ECF) Appellee USA Motion for miscellaneous relief [motion for leave to file public and sealed versions of supplemetal brief]. Date of service: 04/19/2010. [7306035] (TMB) |
| Filing 56 Submitted (ECF) Supplemental brief for review. Submitted by - National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation and Appellee USA. Date of service: 04/19/2010. [7306002]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread filing to consolidated cases. 04/19/2010 by MA] (TMB) |
| Filing 55 Received 7 paper copies of Supplemental Opening brief [53] filed by Tina Herron in 09-16704, Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Ray Anderson in 09-16720, James Joll in 09-16723. [7282065] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 54 Filed clerk order: The supplemental opening brief [53] submitted by Tina Herron in 09-16704, Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Ray Anderson in 09-16720, James Joll in 09-16723 is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a tan cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7274013] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 53 Submitted (ECF) Supplemental brief for review. Submitted by Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723. Date of service: 03/18/2010. [7271400] [09-16676, 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE: Replaced document with searchable version, removed excerpts, spread entry to consolidated cases. 03/22/2010 by MA] (SES) |
| Filing 52 Added attorney Kevin Murray Fong for AT&T Corporation AT&T, Inc., in case 09-16676. [7270657] (MT) |
| Filing 51 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Kevin M. Fong for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc.. Date of service: 03/17/2010. [7270029]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread docket text to consolidated cases. 03/17/2010 by RY] (KMF) |
| Filing 50 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Bruce A. Ericson for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc.. Date of service: 03/17/2010. [7270002]--[COURT UPDATE: Spread text to consolidated cases. 03/17/2010 by RY] (BAE) |
| Filing 49 Received 7 paper copies of Amicus brief [46] filed by Law Professors. [7241334] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 48 Filed clerk order: The amicus brief [46] submitted by Law Professors is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a green cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7238381] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (GLS) |
| Filing 47 Entered appearance of Amicus Curiae Law Professors. [7235271] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 46 Submitted (ECF) Amicus brief for review and filed Motion to become amicus curiae. Submitted by Law Professors. Date of service: 02/17/2010. [7235235] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723]--[COURT UPDATE: corrected docket text. 02/17/2010 by MA] (STK) |
| Filing 45 Received 7 paper copies of Joint Answering brief [41] filed by Telecommunications Carrier Defendants-Appellees. [7234308] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 44 Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:GSS): The district court docket reflects that the docketing fee was paid on July 31, 2009. Therefore, the joint opening brief filed on December 8, 2009 shall be filed in No. 09-16683 as well as in the other consolidated cases. Appellants Joll, et al., Anderson, et al., Herron, et al., and Lebow, et al.’s opposed motion to file a supplemental opening brief is granted. The appellees shall also be given an opportunity to file a supplemental answering brief. The supplemental briefs for the appellants and the appellees shall not exceed 2,800 words. The appellants’ supplemental opening brief is due March 18, 2010. The appellees’ supplemental answering brief is due April 19, 2010. The answering brief submitted by appellees AT&T Corporationand AT&T, Inc., et al. was filed on February 10, 2010. The court sua sponte extends the due date for the answering briefs for the government and remaining appellees’ to May 19, 2010. The reply brief(s) are due July 1, 2010. The government appellee’s motion for an extension of time to file the answering brief is denied as moot. The appellants’ motion for an extension of time to file the reply brief(s) is denied as moot. [7230135] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SC) |
| Filing 43 Filed (ECF) Appellant Tash Hepting in 09-16676 Motion to extend time to file Opening brief until 04/01/2010. Date of service: 02/10/2010. [7227989] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 42 Filed clerk order: The joint answering brief [41] submitted by the Telecommunications Carrier Defendants-Appellees is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a red cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7227835] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 41 Submitted (ECF) Answering brief for review. Submitted by Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16677, Appellee Sprint Nextel Corporation in 09-16679, 09-16682, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Maryland, Inc. in 09-16683, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, 09-16685, Appellees AT&T, Inc., Cingular Wireless and Verizon in 09-16686, Appellees Cingular Wireless LLC, Nextel West Corp. and Verizon in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company, Inc., MCI Communications Services, Inc., Nextel West Corp., Spring Spectrum L.P., Sprint Communications Company, L.P. and Verizon in 09-16688, Appellees AT&T Corp., MCI Communications Services, Inc. and Verizon in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company Incorporated, Nextel West Corp., Spring Spectrum L.P., Sprint Communcations Company L.P. and Verizon in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Verizon and Verizon Global Networks, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees Verizon, Verizon Communications, Inc. and Verizon Northwest, Inc. in 09-16706, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Cingular Wireless LLC, Verizon, Verizon Communications Inc. and Verizon Florida, Inc. in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc., SBC Long Distance, LLC and Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees MCI, LLC and Verizon in 09-16712, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation, Cingular Wireless LLC and Sprint Nextel Corporation in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc., Bellsouth Corporation, Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., BellSouth Corp., Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16723. Date of service: 02/10/2010. [7227624] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (MK) |
| Filing 40 Filed (ECF) Appellant Tina Herron in 09-16704, Appellant Steven Lebow in 09-16719, Appellant Ray Anderson in 09-16720, Appellant James Joll in 09-16723 Correspondence: Circuit Rule 25-2 letter on Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Brief.. Date of service: 02/10/2010 [7227156] [09-16704, 09-16676, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SES) |
| Filing 39 Filed (ECF) Appellee USA in 09-16676 Unopposed Motion to extend time to file Answering brief until 02/17/2010 at 12:00 am. Date of service: 02/09/2010. [7225536] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (TMB) |
| Filing 38 Added attorneys Bradford Allan Berenson and Eric Shumsky. [7185886] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 37 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Eric A. Shumsky for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, Appellees AT&T, Inc. and Cingular Wireless in 09-16686, Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16688, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC and Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc. and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc. and Bellsouth Corporation in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc. and BellSouth Corp. in 09-16723. Date of service: 01/07/2010. [7185640] [09-16676, 09-16684, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (ES) |
| Filing 36 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Bradford A. Berenson for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, Appellees AT&T, Inc. and Cingular Wireless in 09-16686, Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16688, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. and Cingular Wireless, LLC in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC and Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc. and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc. and Bellsouth Corporation in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc. and BellSouth Corp. in 09-16723. Date of service: 01/07/2010. [7185631] [09-16676, 09-16684, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (BAB) |
| Filing 35 Filed (ECF) Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723 reply to response (Motion (ECF Filing) ,Motion (ECF Filing) motion to file supplemental brief, Response to Motion (ECF Filing) , Response to Motion (ECF Filing) ). Date of service: 12/22/2009. [7173507] [09-16704, 09-16676, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SES) |
| Filing 34 Filed (ECF) Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. and Verizon Global Networks, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc., Bellsouth Corporation and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., BellSouth Corp. and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16723 response opposing motion (Motion (ECF Filing) ,Motion (ECF Filing) motion to file supplemental brief). Date of service: 12/16/2009. [7166879] [09-16704, 09-16676, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (MK) |
| Filing 33 Filed (ECF) Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723 Motion to file supplemental brief. Date of service: 12/15/2009. [7165358] [09-16704, 09-16676, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SES) |
| Filing 32 Received 7 paper copies of Joint Opening brief [28] filed by all Plaintiffs-Appellants except in case no. 09-16683. [7163100] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SD) |
| Filing 31 Filed Appellants' excerpts of record in 4 volumes. Served on 12/08/2009. [7158218] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 30 Filed clerk order: The joint opening brief [28] submitted by All Plaintiffs-Appellants except in no. 09-16683 is filed. Within 7 days of the filing of this order, filer is ordered to file 7 copies of the brief in paper format, with a blue cover, accompanied by certification, attached to the end of each copy of the brief, that the brief is identical to the version submitted electronically. [7156390] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (LA) |
| Filing 29 Filed order (Appellate Commissioner) Appellants Hines, et al.’s motion to reinstate No. 09-16706 is granted. The court docket shall be amended to reflect that the docketing fee has been paid by appellants Hines, et al. in No. 09-16706. Case No. 09-16706 is reinstated as a consolidated case with lead No. 09-16676. The appellants’ motion to reconsider the portion of the November 19, 2009 order that establishes the due date of the consolidated reply brief as 14 days after the due date of the consolidated answering brief or the last-served answering brief is granted. The due date for the optional reply briefs or consolidated reply brief is March 25, 2010. ALL THE PARTIES ARE REMINDED THAT THE PROVISIONS OF NINTH CIRCUIT RULE 31-2.2(a), REGARDING TELEPHONIC EXTENSIONS REQUESTS, SHALL NOT APPLY TO THESE CONSOLIDATED CASES. (Pro Mo) [7156364] [09-16706, 09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SC) |
| Filing 28 Submitted (ECF) Opening brief for review. Submitted by Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen in 09-16676, Appellant All Plaintiffs in 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723. Date of service: 12/08/2009. [7156253] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 27 Filed (ECF) Appellant Tash Hepting in 09-16676 motion for reconsideration of non-dispositive Judge Order of 11/19/2009. Date of service: 12/03/2009. [7151166] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 26 Filed clerk order (Deputy Clerk:GSS): The October 20, 2009 joint motion of all plaintiffs and all defendants to modify the briefing schedule in order to coordinate so that the parties may join in a single brief is construed as a stipulated motion for an extension of time to file consolidated briefs pursuant to Ninth Circuit Rule 28-4, and so construed, is granted. The briefing schedule shall is as follows: all the opening briefs or consolidated opening brief are due December 8, 2009; the answering briefs or consolidated answering brief are due February 10, 2010; and the optional reply briefs or consolidated reply brief are due within 14 days after the service of the consolidated answering brief or the last served answering brief. GIVEN THE EXTENDED INTERVAL IN THE BRIEFING SCHEDULE PROVIDED BY THIS ORDER, ANY FURTHER MOTION TO EXTEND THE DUE DATE OF THE OPENING BRIEFS IS STRONGLY DISFAVORED. PURSUANT TO THE FILING OF THIS STIPULATED MOTION UNDER NINTH CIRCUIT RULE 28-4, THE PROVISIONS OF NINTH CIRCUIT RULE 31-.2.2(a), REGARDING TELEPHONIC EXTENSIONS REQUESTS, SHALL NOT APPLY TO THESE CONSOLIDATED CASES. [7138994] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (SC) |
| Filing 25 Added attorney Kevin Stuart Bankston, Kurt Opsahl, and Lee Tien for Tash Hepting, Erik Knutzen, Gregory Hicks, and Carolyn Jewel. [7118214] (RL) |
| Filing 24 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Lee Tien for Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen. Date of service: 11/03/2009. [7118073] (LT) |
| Filing 23 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Kurt Opsahl for Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen. Date of service: 11/03/2009. [7118066] (KO) |
| Filing 22 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Kevin Bankston for Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen. Date of service: 11/03/2009. [7118059] (KSB) |
| Filing 21 Added attorney Thomas E. Moore III for Tash Hepting, in case 09-16676. [7106063] (MT) |
| Filing 20 Added attorney James Samuel Tyre for Tash Hepting, in case 09-16676. [7106060] (MT) |
| Filing 19 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Thomas E. Moore III for Appellant Tash Hepting. Date of service: 10/22/2009. [7105315] (NVE) |
| Filing 18 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of James S. Tyre for Appellant Tash Hepting. Date of service: 10/22/2009. [7105310] (NVE) |
| Filing 16 Filed (ECF) Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen in 09-16676 Joint Motion to extend time to file Opening brief until 12/08/2009, Motion to extend time to file opposition until 02/10/2010, Motion to extend time to file a reply until 03/25/2010. Date of service: 10/20/2009. [7101407] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 17 Case rejected from Circuit Mediation Program. [7102854] [09-16444, 09-16532, 09-16535, 09-16626, 09-16676, 09-16753, 09-16775, 09-16822, 09-16874, 09-16924, 09-16956, 09-16967, 09-16972, 09-16996, 09-17001, 09-17002, 09-17050, 09-17076, 09-17098, 09-35606, 09-35685, 09-35711, 09-35756, 09-35773, 09-55327, 09-55425, 09-55829, 09-55907, 09-55913, 09-55937, 09-56035, 09-56047, 09-56050, 09-56283, 09-56337, 09-56447, 09-56461, 09-60031, 09-72713] (SB) |
| Filing 15 Filed (ECF) Appellants All Plaintiffs and Claudia Mink in 09-16708 Correspondence: Filing Proof of Payment of Filing-Docketing Fee with U.S. District Court. Date of service: 09/15/2009 [7062591] [09-16708, 09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (JRD) |
| Filing 14 Added attorney Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16685 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16686 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16683 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16684 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16687 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16688 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16717 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16713 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16712 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16710 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16698 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16704 Douglas Neal Letter for USA National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation, in case 09-16676 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16694 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16706 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16677 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16707 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16708 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16696 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16679 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16697 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16709 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16690 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16691 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16692 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16693 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16720 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16723 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16701 Douglas Neal Letter for USA, in case 09-16700. [7062191] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 13 Added attorney Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16685 Michael Kellogg for Cingular Wireless AT&T, Inc., in case 09-16686 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Maryland, Inc., in case 09-16683 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Communications of California AT&T Corp., in case 09-16684 Michael Kellogg for Cingular Wireless LLC, in case 09-16687 Michael Kellogg for MCI Communications Services, Inc. AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. Cingular Wireless, LLC AT&T Corp. AT&T Communications, Inc., in case 09-16688 Michael Kellogg for Cingular Wireless LLC Bell South Corporation, in case 09-16719 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16717 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16682 Michael Kellogg for Illinois Bell Telephone Co. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16713 Michael Kellogg for MCI, LLC, in case 09-16712 Michael Kellogg for Pacific Bell Telephone Company AT&T Communications of California, Inc. AT&T Inc. SBC Long Distance, LLC AT&T Corp., in case 09-16710 Michael Kellogg for New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. AT&T, Inc. AT&T Operations Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16702 Michael Kellogg for AT&T, Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16698 Michael Kellogg for Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC Verizon Global Networks, Inc. Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. AT&T Corp. AT&T, in case 09-16704 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Corporation AT&T, Inc., in case 09-16676 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc. Verizon Northwest, Inc., in case 09-16706 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16694 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16677 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications Inc. Cingular Wireless LLC Verizon Florida, Inc. Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc. AT&T Corp. AT&T, in case 09-16707 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16696 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc. SBC Long Distance, LLC, in case 09-16708 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16697 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16709 Michael Kellogg for MCI Communications Services, Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16690 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Teleholdings, Inc. Cingular Wireless, LLC AT&T Communications of California, Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16691 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Corp. AT&T Communications, Inc., in case 09-16692 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc., in case 09-16693 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc. AT&T Corporation AT&T Inc. Bellsouth Corporation, in case 09-16720 Michael Kellogg for Verizon Communications, Inc. BellSouth Corp. AT&T Inc. AT&T Corp., in case 09-16723 Michael Kellogg for AT&T Corp., in case 09-16700. [7062174] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 12 Terminated Richard R. Wiebe for Sean Basinski and All Plaintiffs in 09-16677, Richard D. Suchanek III and All Plaintiffs in 09-16679, Marshall Votta, Jennifer Thomas, Gerard Thibeault, Paul Pothier, Patricia Pothier, Nicole Mirabella, Vincent Matrumalo, Paula Matrumalo, June Matrumalo, Maryann Klaczynski, George Hayek III, Christine Douquette, Rose Deluca, Jenna Caparco, Janice Caparco, Aldo Caparco, Maryann Bouchard, Arthur Bouchard, Sandra Bissitt, Charles F. Bissitt and All Plaintiffs in 09-16682, Kyu Chun Kim, Christopher Bready, Anne Bready, David Beverly Jr., Jenet Artis, Claudis Artis and All Plaintiffs in 09-16683, Curren Warf, Peter Sussman, Robert Scheer, Margaret Russell, Dennis P. Riordan, Sandra Richards, Stephen J. Mather, George Main, Marc Cooper, Tom Campbell, Richard Belzer, American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego/Imperial Counties, American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California, All Plaintiffs and ACLU of Southern California in 09-16684, Edward Gerard de Bonis, Carol Sobel, Dennis P. Riordan, Vincent J. Maniscalco, Robert Jacobson, Rod Gorney, Robert S. Gerstein, American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego/Imperial Counties, American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California and ACLU of Southern California in 09-16685, Alejandro Trombley, Stephen Ternlund, Anatoly Sapoznick, Paul Robilotti, Omar Moreno, Samuel Fisher, Glen Chulsky and All Plaintiffs in 09-16686, A. Joris Watland, William R. Massey, Anakalia Kaluna, Kim Coco Iwamoto, Charmaine Crockett and All Plaintiffs in 09-16687, The Libertarian Party of Indiana, Sean Sheppard, Sam Goldstein Insurance Agency, Inc., Carolyn W. Rader, Tim Peterson, David Kadlec, Healing Arts Center, Sam Goldstein, Gabriel Fileppelli, John Elder, Travis Cross and All Plaintiffs in 09-16688, Rebecca Yowtz, Christopher Yowtz, Joan DuBois and All Plaintiffs in 09-16690, The Libertarian Party of Indiana, Sean Sheppard, Sam Goldstein Insurance Agency, Inc., Carolyn W. Rader, Tim Peterson, David Kadlec, Healing Arts Center, Sam Goldstein, Gabriel Fileppelli, John Elder, Travis Cross and All Plaintiffs in 09-16691, Pat Mahoney and All Plaintiffs in 09-16692, Pamela A. Mahoney and All Plaintiffs in 09-16693, Mark P. Solomon and All Plaintiffs in 09-16694, Rhea Fuller and All Plaintiffs in 09-16696, Shelly D. Souder and All Plaintiffs in 09-16697, Steve Dolberg and All Plaintiffs in 09-16698, Theresa Fortnash and All Plaintiffs in 09-16700, D. Clive Hardy and All Plaintiffs in 09-16701, The Austin Chronicle, Michael Kentor, James C. Harrington, Richard A. Grigg, Louis Black and All Plaintiffs in 09-16702, Brandy Sergi, Tina Herron and All Plaintiffs in 09-16704, Alex Klabacka, Jana Klabacja, Darryl Hines and All Plaintiffs in 09-16706, Kathleen Miller, Laurence Kornblum, Howard Jacobs and All Plaintiffs in 09-16707, Claudia Mink and All Plaintiffs in 09-16708, Richard Roche and All Plaintiffs in 09-16709, Benson B. Roe, Paul Goltz and All Plaintiffs in 09-16710, Elaine Spielfogel-Landis and All Plaintiffs in 09-16712, Quentin Young, Studs Terkel, James D. Montgomery, Gary S. Gerson, Diane C. Geraghty, Barbara Flynn Currie, American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois, Inc. and All Plaintiffs in 09-16713, Herbert Waxman and All Plaintiffs in 09-16717, Jonnie Starkey, Steven Lebow, Meredith Kaltman, Barry Kaltman, Steven Bruning, Cathy Bruning, Brian Bradley and All Plaintiffs in 09-16719, Shane Brink, Kristen Brink, Trudy Bond, Fran Blamer, William Betz, Anthony Bartelemy, John Barrett, Mark Barker, Collin Baber, Ray Anderson and All Plaintiffs in 09-16720 and Ian Walker, James Nurkiewicz, James Joll, Ramon Goggins and All Plaintiffs in 09-16723 [7062074] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 11 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Douglas Neal Letter for - National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation and Appellee USA in 09-16676, Appellee USA in 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16720, 09-16723. Date of service: 09/15/2009. [7061968] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (DNL) |
| Filing 10 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Michael Kerry Kellogg for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16676, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16677, 09-16682, Appellees Verizon and Verizon Maryland, Inc. in 09-16683, Appellees AT&T Communications of California and AT&T Corp. in 09-16684, 09-16685, Appellees AT&T, Inc., Cellco Partnership, Cingular Wireless and Verizon in 09-16686, Appellees Cingular Wireless LLC, Verizon and Verizon Wireless in 09-16687, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company, Inc., MCI Communications Services, Inc., Verizon and Verizon Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16688, Appellees AT&T Corp., MCI Communications Services, Inc., Verizon and Verizon Wireless, LLC in 09-16690, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Teleholdings, Inc., Cingular Wireless, LLC, Indiana Bell Telephone Company Incorporated, MCI Worldcom Advanced Networks, LLC, Verizon and Verizon Wireless Services, LLC in 09-16691, Appellees AT&T Communications, Inc. and AT&T Corp. in 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, Appellees Verizon, Verizon Communications, Inc. and Verizon Wireless, LLC in 09-16696, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T Inc. in 09-16697, Appellees AT&T Corp. and AT&T, Inc. in 09-16698, Appellee AT&T Corp. in 09-16700, Appellee AT&T Corporation in 09-16701, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Operations Inc., AT&T, Inc. and New Cingular Wireless Services, Inc. in 09-16702, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Communication Systems, LLC, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Verizon and Verizon Global Networks, Inc. in 09-16704, Appellees Verizon, Verizon Communications, Inc. and Verizon Northwest, Inc. in 09-16706, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T, Bellsouth Telecommunications, Inc., Cingular Wireless LLC, Verizon, Verizon Communications Inc. and Verizon Florida, Inc. in 09-16707, Appellees AT&T Communications of the Southwest, Inc., SBC Long Distance, LLC and Southwestern Bell Telephone, L.P. in 09-16708, 09-16709, Appellees AT&T Communications of California, Inc., AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., Pacific Bell Telephone Company and SBC Long Distance, LLC in 09-16710, Appellees MCI, LLC and Verizon in 09-16712, Appellees AT&T Corp. and Illinois Bell Telephone Co. in 09-16713, 09-16717, Appellees Bell South Corporation and Cingular Wireless LLC in 09-16719, Appellees AT&T Corporation, AT&T Inc., Bellsouth Corporation, Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16720, Appellees AT&T Corp., AT&T Inc., BellSouth Corp., Verizon and Verizon Communications, Inc. in 09-16723. Date of service: 09/15/2009. [7061315] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (MK) |
| Filing 9 Filed (ECF) Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen in 09-16676 Civil Appeals Docketing Statement (Form 6). Date of service: 09/14/2009. [7061240] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 8 Added attorney Richard R. Wiebe for Carol Sobel Robert S. Gerstein American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego/Imperial Counties Dennis P. Riordan ACLU of Southern California Robert Jacobson American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California Edward Gerard de Bonis Vincent J. Maniscalco Rod Gorney, in case 09-16685 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Omar Moreno Glen Chulsky Alejandro Trombley Paul Robilotti Stephen Ternlund Anatoly Sapoznick Samuel Fisher, in case 09-16686 Richard R. Wiebe for Jenet Artis All Plaintiffs David Beverly Jr. Christopher Bready Kyu Chun Kim Claudis Artis Anne Bready, in case 09-16683 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Marc Cooper Peter Sussman American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego/Imperial Counties Richard Belzer Curren Warf ACLU of Southern California Robert Scheer Stephen J. Mather Sandra Richards Tom Campbell Dennis P. Riordan American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California Margaret Russell George Main, in case 09-16684 Richard R. Wiebe for Charmaine Crockett All Plaintiffs Anakalia Kaluna William R. Massey Kim Coco Iwamoto A. Joris Watland, in case 09-16687 Richard R. Wiebe for Sean Sheppard Sam Goldstein Insurance Agency, Inc. Travis Cross All Plaintiffs Sam Goldstein The Libertarian Party of Indiana Gabriel Fileppelli John Elder Tim Peterson David Kadlec Carolyn W. Rader Healing Arts Center, in case 09-16688 Richard R. Wiebe for Steven Bruning All Plaintiffs Brian Bradley Steven Lebow Jonnie Starkey Meredith Kaltman Cathy Bruning Barry Kaltman, in case 09-16719 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Herbert Waxman, in case 09-16717 Richard R. Wiebe for Arthur Bouchard Nicole Mirabella Vincent Matrumalo All Plaintiffs Janice Caparco Maryann Klaczynski Jennifer Thomas Rose Deluca Christine Douquette Paula Matrumalo June Matrumalo Gerard Thibeault Sandra Bissitt Jenna Caparco Marshall Votta Maryann Bouchard Patricia Pothier Charles F. Bissitt Aldo Caparco George Hayek III Paul Pothier, in case 09-16682 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Diane C. Geraghty Gary S. Gerson Studs Terkel James D. Montgomery American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois, Inc. Quentin Young Barbara Flynn Currie, in case 09-16713 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Elaine Spielfogel-Landis, in case 09-16712 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Benson B. Roe Paul Goltz, in case 09-16710 Richard R. Wiebe for The Austin Chronicle Richard A. Grigg James C. Harrington All Plaintiffs Louis Black Michael Kentor, in case 09-16702 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Steve Dolberg, in case 09-16698 Richard R. Wiebe for Tina Herron All Plaintiffs Brandy Sergi, in case 09-16704 Richard R. Wiebe for Tash Hepting Erik Knutzen Gregory Hicks Carolyn Jewel, in case 09-16676 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Jana Klabacja Darryl Hines Alex Klabacka, in case 09-16706 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Mark P. Solomon, in case 09-16694 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Kathleen Miller Howard Jacobs Laurence Kornblum, in case 09-16707 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Sean Basinski, in case 09-16677 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Claudia Mink, in case 09-16708 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Rhea Fuller, in case 09-16696 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Shelly D. Souder, in case 09-16697 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Richard D. Suchanek III, in case 09-16679 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Richard Roche, in case 09-16709 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Christopher Yowtz Rebecca Yowtz Joan DuBois, in case 09-16690 Richard R. Wiebe for Sean Sheppard Sam Goldstein Insurance Agency, Inc. Travis Cross All Plaintiffs Sam Goldstein The Libertarian Party of Indiana Gabriel Fileppelli John Elder Tim Peterson David Kadlec Carolyn W. Rader Healing Arts Center, in case 09-16691 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Pat Mahoney, in case 09-16692 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Pamela A. Mahoney, in case 09-16693 Richard R. Wiebe for Shane Brink All Plaintiffs Trudy Bond John Barrett Mark Barker Kristen Brink Fran Blamer William Betz Anthony Bartelemy Collin Baber Ray Anderson, in case 09-16720 Richard R. Wiebe for Ramon Goggins All Plaintiffs James Nurkiewicz Ian Walker James Joll, in case 09-16723 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs D. Clive Hardy, in case 09-16701 Richard R. Wiebe for All Plaintiffs Theresa Fortnash, in case 09-16700. [7060179] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RL) |
| Filing 7 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Richard R. Wiebe for Appellants Tash Hepting, Gregory Hicks, Carolyn Jewel and Erik Knutzen in 09-16676. Date of service: 09/12/2009. [7059603] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (RRW) |
| Filing 6 Added attorney Thomas Mark Bondy for USA. [7043736] (RL) |
| Filing 5 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Thomas M. Bondy for Appellee USA. Date of service: 08/28/2009. [7043615] (TMB) |
| Filing 4 Added attorney Eric Shumsky for AT&T Corporation AT&T, Inc. [7043160] (RL) |
| Filing 3 Filed (ECF) notice of appearance of Eric A. Shumsky for Appellees AT&T Corporation and AT&T, Inc.. Date of service: 08/27/2009. [7043141] (ES) |
| Filing 2 Filed order MOATT: (SNR) The court sua sponte consolidates appeal nos. 09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 09-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723. A review of the district court’s docket reflects that the filing and docketing fees for 31 of these 33 appeals have not been paid. Within 21 days after the date of this order, appellants shall pay to the district court the $455.00 filing and docketing fees for each unpaid appeal and file in this court proof of such payment, or file in this court a motion to proceed in forma pauperis. Failure to pay the fees or to file a motion to proceed in forma pauperis shall result in the automatic dismissal of the appeal by the Clerk for failure to prosecute. See 9th Cir. R. 42-1. The following briefing schedule shall apply to all these appeals: the opening brief and excerpts of record are due November 16, 2009; the answering brief is due December 15, 2009; and the reply brief is due within 14 days after service of the answering brief. All parties on a side are encouraged to join in a single brief to the greatest extent practicable. See 9th Cir. R. 28-4. [7039639] [09-16676, 09-16677, 09-16679, 09-16682, 09-16683, 09-16684, 09-16685, 09-16686, 00-16687, 09-16688, 09-16690, 09-16691, 09-16692, 09-16693, 09-16694, 09-16696, 09-16697, 09-16698, 09-16700, 09-16701, 09-16702, 09-16704, 09-16706, 09-16707, 09-16708, 09-16709, 09-16710, 09-16712, 09-16713, 09-16717, 09-16719, 09-16720, 09-16723] (JS) |
| Filing 1 DOCKETED CAUSE AND ENTERED APPEARANCES OF COUNSEL. SEND CADS: No. The schedule is set as follows: CADS due by Attorney Cindy Cohn due on 07/31/2009. Transcript order for Appellant Tash Hepting, Appellant Gregory Hicks, Appellant Carolyn Jewel and Appellant Erik Knutzen due 08/31/2009. Transcript due for Orig Clerk USDC, San Francisco on 09/29/2009. Certificate of record due 10/06/2009. Appellant Tash Hepting, Appellant Gregory Hicks, Appellant Carolyn Jewel and Appellant Erik Knutzen opening brief due 11/16/2009. Appellee AT&T Corporation, Appellee AT&T, Inc. and Appellee United States of America answering brief due 12/15/2009. Appellant's optional reply brief is due 14 days after service of the answering brief. [7019812] (GR) |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
