Plaintiff / Appellant:	MARK BOLLHARDT, CHARLES HARTWIG, MORRIS SMITH, PETER CIULLO, CHRISTOPHER L. BALTZ, JOHN SOLTESZ, PAUL BENSOUSSAN, TRAVIS LEE BURFORD, CHARLES SPANIER, JAMES FLURRY, RONALD SCHWIER, JOHN KIMBRELL, JOE SPAGNUOLO, RICK E. PRICE, WILLIAM CRISTOPHER SNYDER, RUSSELL DAVIDSON, RICHARD WILLINGHAM, WILLIAM TISSAIR, RALPH GRAY, JAMES AYERSMAN, GARY BREWER, DEVIN POURCIAU, on behalf of Bobby Pourciau, deceased, STEVEN SMITH, MARK SNIDER, ROY ROGER FAIRCLOTH, DAVID BRADLEY, RONALD WIZIMIRSKI, WILLIAM RANDALL TYLER, CLAUDE WAYNE BREWER, CLAIR FLETCHER, NOEL PHILP, WILLIAM HARGRAVES, SHAINDELL GRAHAM, Individually and as successor in interest to decedent, Morton Graham, ROBERT WHITE, GLEN COCHRAN, RAYMOND M. HUMPHRIES, PERRY WARD, STEPHEN E. SPRADLEY, SCOTT FISHER, ELLEN P. O'NEILL, PAUL GILLESPIE, ENOS LAWSON, CHARLES BOTHELL, EUGENE RUTKOWSKI, BRIAN M. WHITE, PAUL FERRARA, MICHAEL LAKICH, PETER LEONARD, LAWRENCE MOSER, STEPHEN L. FLEMING, KEVIN MURPHY, RON OHLSEN, KENDAL D. MCDANIEL, TIMOTHY M. TAYLOR, GERALD F. GREY, DANIEL SMYTH, MARSHALL WHITE, FRED VIGNALI, STEPHEN CROSSLAND, DONNIE STEARNS, DONALD HUNT, FRANKLIN MILLER, ARMON CLOSE, PAUL O'MALLEY, JOHN M. CHRISTENSEN, EDWARD STEVENS, JOHN LEE WATSON, JAMES CHOATE, CLAUDE LINLEY, ROBERT D. BATTELLINE, STEPHEN ALLEN, TIMOTHY BARTH, RICHARD VASSAR, THOMAS BERNSEN, TERRY HOPKINS, JOHN GILLUM, JOHNNY MOSSES, RICHARD L. DESALVO, DAVID WORTHEN, JOE HOLLEY, C. H. DUNIGAN, on behalf of Mark Dun, LARRY RAY GODDARD, WILLIAM PRESTON, MARION E. JONES, JAMES DOTSON, DONALD WILKERSON, TONY D. BROWN, JAMES WAYNE HALL, JAMES NUTTALL, RUTH SMITH, ARTHUR S. ANDERSEN, MICHELE COVERT, JESUS MORENO, SANDRA K. COYLE, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Lester H. Coyle, Deceased, ALONZO A. MUNOZ, PAUL OSTERGARD, DENNIS BJORGE, RICHARD SIDOROWICZ, SHELIA PRATER, MICHAEL HAVENS, THOMAS QUINN, GERALD DUNCAN, ROY C. MENTZER, FARRELL PATTERSON, CHARLES EVANS, Jr., deceased, DALLAS A. SCOTT, WALTER SAMUEL SCHYTTE, RANDY MAYER, KURT W. DICKENSON, SCOTT R. FISHER, BERNARD MCDERMOTT, WILLIAM WILLIAMS, LAURA TOCKMAN, JULIA IRENE GARFIELD, JOHN A. ZORBAS, HYMAN B. HOROWITZ, JAMES BOSTIAN, ARNOLD GARBUTT, LESTER DAY, STAN COSGROVE, JORGE RINCON, THOMAS OFE, WILLIAM KELLY, RAYMOND L. ROSE, RICHARD JEWELL, JOHN DUNN, ARTHUR CHATEAU, NORMAN CUPP, WILLIAM YOUNG, JAMES SMETHERS, LENNART ANDERSON, FRANKLIN DAVIS, GARY C. GALANTE, ROBERT JAMES PHILLIPS, WILLIAM BARNARD, WENDY DAVIS, individually, and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of M. David Davis on behalf of the Estate of M. David Davis, Deceased, JAMES MORO, GARY CARLSON, EDWIN KELLY, DALE CRABTREE, GAIL CARNEY, individually and on behalf of the Estate of Jan Carney, REGINA MITTLER, VAN CALVIN FLEMING III, MELVIN ISRAELSON, STEVEN COHEN, JOHN HENRY, GARY GIAMPAPA, RICHARD PONTO, JERRY JONES, NEWBURN PHIPPS, MICHAEL MICHAELS, CLIFFORD HIGDON, KENNETH DARNELL, JACQUELINE PATENAUDE, his wife, THOMAS KRUEPER, JOHN DELGADO, JAN OWEN, MICHAEL ROMANO, FLOYD ZORDEL, TIMOTHY BRUNGARD, JAMES BOSWELL, PAUL PARKER, WILLIAM WINANT, ANTHONY WAYNE ALLRED, BRIEN LOUGHEED, as representative of the Estate of Hugh Lougheed, JAMES L. GUTHRIE, RONALD W. WHEELER, JOHN GOETZ, JERRY SPARKS, STEVEN GIFFORD, WENDY DENNSTEDT, TED BAGWELL, JAMES WALLNER, GARY SUPPER, CAROLYN A. CROXFORD, TOMMY RAYNER, BART PRICE, JOHN JOSEPH JOHNSON, THOMAS A. BAILOR, JOHN R. CLIFTON, NAMON L. HART, STEVE DURHAM, RICHARD LUTZ, RONALD A. RAINES, LINDA HOOVER, ROY C. LUSCH, BEN STOUT, FRANK HUNTER, Sr., DIANNE PARISH, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Rex Parish, MELISSA A. SPIESMAN, as personal representative of the Estate of Allen H. Kanovsky, Deceased, DARRELL HOPPE, Sr., TERRY BIEDERMAN, JOYCE HELM, BARBARA A. ERICHSEN, Individually and as Special Administrator of the Estate of Richard J. Erichsen, Deceased, CATHERINE DAVIS, individually and on behalf of the estate of Frank Fielding Davis, deceased, JERRY O. SMITH, MICHAEL S. ARLOW, TIMOTHY D. KING, JAMES S. COOK, TIMOTHY J. MELINE, HARRIS A. BRANAMAN, MIKE FAUCHA, MICHAEL DELONG, an anticipated representative of the Estate of John DeLong, EDWARD CALLACI, MARK ADAMS, THOMAS J. BROWN, MICHAEL BRENNOCK, JACKIE ATKINS, BRIAN P. PATENAUDE, IRIS CRUPPER, DOUGLAS HARPER, GARRY EISCH, WAYNE DOUGLAS TOTH, ROGER DALE PRESSLEY, JESSIE NEWELL, TERRELL HARPER, LARRY SEIDLER, JOSEPH F. OGDEN, ROY ADAMS, WILLIAM GOMBA, JOE MONTALVO, JERRY L. OATES, WILLIAM CHEVALIER, GREGORY KUNCE, DAVID COYNE, GREGORY H. TILLER, KIM KNIGHTON, JOSEPH GUILLOT, BRUCE GARBER, BARRY MILLIGAN, AUBREY ALLEN, Executor of the Estate of Jeffrey R. Allen, RICK MILLER, DAVID SANBORN, GEORGE RIPPS, DENNIS YOUNGER, MARK WELLS, EARL FAIRBANKS, NICOLE LUNATO, as surviving natural daughter and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert R. Lunato, CARL JOHNSON, JAMES LONG, Esquire, LARRY NABORS, CLINTON WESTRING, JERRY MAY, MARTIN CAULEY, CHARLOTTE DICKINSON, Individually and on behalf of the Estate of Terry L. Dickinson, Deceased, JUNIUS CONWAY, CHARLES IHLE, ROBERT PIONTEK, JAMES F. DAVENPORT, KAREN WRIGHT, individually and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Leon Wright deceased, and on behalf of the estate of Leon Wright, deceased, JOHN F. HENRY, JOHN METCALF, DONALD MCCAAY, WILLARD HOFFMAN, STEPHEN AYLWARD, GREGORY P. URBANSKI, MICHAEL ATKOCAITIS, KENNETH PARKER, LARRY MADDUX, Sr., JOEL HORRELL, JAMES DINKINS, FLORIAN TIEGS, Sr., BILLY JOE MARKHAM, Jr., GREG FREEMAN, ROBERT M. TINDALL, JOHN PETERSON, DANA DANCER, ISAAC COCKFIELD, JAMES BERGHERR, PHILIP BADER, FREDERICK ADDISON, TAMMY LECLAIR, Spouse, RANDY A. JUMPER, DRAKE S. REID, THOMAS ADKINS, RONNIE RENFORE, LYLE MCCORISON, RONNIE L. MOUNTS, CHARLES CORN, JOHN SCHIEFFER, DAVID SILCOX, THOMAS SMITH, LOUIS STERLING II, HARRY JOHNSON, BING LEE BOWER, JERRY MARTIN, Esquire, FREDERICK W. LIPPERT, Jr., MARK R. SUITS, ROBERT RINTZ, KEVIN GORCZYNSKI, as personal representative of the Estate of Robert J. Gorczynski, Deceased, GERALD PICCINI, DAVID GROS, SCOTT GRATTO, PAUL SHEPHERD, LINDA STEWART, individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Ricky Lee Stewart, MICHAEL GILL, MARTIN SOULIERE, BAXTER L. HANNAH, STEPHEN MILLER, EUGENE THEEL, RICHARD GRAHAM, WILLIAM WILCOX, IRWIN ERIC LIVINGSTON, JOHN O'NEILL, THOMAS CHURCH, ROBERT SYLVESTER, MICHAEL COOPER, LAWRENCE S. SHIFFLETT, ROBERT BLAU, CHARLES COLEMAN, RONALD G. PETERSON, DANIELLE SCHOENROCK, EDGAR RAY, STEPHANIE GALE TRULL, RICHARD O'BRIEN, WILLIAM SEALS, LARRY RAFFERTY, JASON MITCHINER, JODY FYFE, LEE WEISS, DANIEL G. AHEARN, SALLY MARKLE, individually and as executor of the Estatte of Richard Markle, DAN KIRK, CHARLES WILLIX, GERALD SAGE, DAVID R. SINN, JOHN W. REESE, SUE MATTHEWS, individually and on behalf of the heirs and estate of Robin Matthews, Deceased, DONALD ALLEN PETERSON, JOSEPH BASTOW, JAMES T. BLACK, WANDA MOTES, individually and as personal representative of the Estate of William Motes, TONY CLIFTON, MICHAEL L. PIERSOL, DAVID R. ANKNEY, ARTURO SIERRA, RONALD CALHOUN, ROBERT MARTIN, EUGENE C. HENDRICKSON, AVEDIS TAJERIAN, JOHN CLARKE, JAMES FORRESTER, JOHNNY BOOSE, CURTIS TATE, JOHN DAVIS, KEVIN FRANCE, JOSEPH S. POPOVEC, MICHAEL J. LECLAIR, Individually, DAVID OGDEN, AUBURN HOPPER, Jr., BETTY WELLS, EDWARD RAY, SCOTT WINFREY, CATHYLEE KJELLSTRAND-GRANUCCI, Individually and On Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Lawrence Granucci, and On Behalf of the Estate of Lawrence Granucci, deceased, BYRON RICKETTS, RONNIE DICKERSON, ROBERT E. HAKE, THOMAS WATTS, RICKY NANCE, DELBERT SMITH, THOMAS HUFF, WILLIAM LOUIS ROTH, JAMES BEELER, WILLIAM ECKHOFF, ROBERT J. GRIJALVA, LYNDA MONROE, TERRY WIYRICK, DANIEL HARRISON, JEFFREY MARTIN, JERRY L. JOHNSON, WALTER NICHOLS, ROBERT HICKS, Individually and on behalf of the Estate of Raymond G. Hicks, LINDA L. GRISAFI, Individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Vincent J. Grisafi, Jr., Deceased, DAVID LAMIE, RICHARD J. LABOURDETTE, ERNEST MIKE CROSS, JOSEPH FEELEY, GAREY MATTHEWS, DELMER LUNDE, LINWOOD RICHARDSON, GAREY HOLIFIELD, MARK BOLLARO, ORRIN HART, BYRON T. NELSON, as Administrator of the Estate of Gary E. Udell, Deceased, JAMES NOSTRANT, JOHN A. WENDLING, WILLIAM NORMAN, Esquire, VERNON D. WARE, Jr., GLENN ROBINSON, MARK SAUL, BENJAMIN MOORE, Sr., MELODY TURNER, Individually and On Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Charles Turner, deceased, and On Behalf the Estate of Charles Turner, deceased., MARK DEPALMA, DUANE DEVERICK, STEVEN REYNOLDS, CHARLES WEST, FLOYD MOFFATT, DANIEL TIETZ, RICHARD SPRINTHALL, Jr., ALTON DOAN, ANTHONY ENLOW, RICHARD RASMUSSEN, GREGORY CHIDSEY, GARY SMITH, BRIAN COVERT, ROBERT HARVEY, ROBERT FORSYTHE, RICHARD HARENBERG, GREGORY J. GRANT, WATSON CHARLES ROSS, KEN KANNETT, ORVILLE CHEEK, PATRICK MIDAS, DONALD SHIPMAN, ELDRED LAMBERT, EVERETT JOHNSON, CHESTER WARREN, SAMMY JOYNER, BILLY SMITH, RAYMOND CLARK, SONIA CASTANEDA, Individually and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Orlando Castaneda, and on behalf of the Estate of Orlando Castaneda, Deceased, JOHN KIRBY OVERMAN, NANCY CRIVELLARI, Individually, and On Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of John Crivellari, Deceased, and on Behalf of the Estate of John Crivellari, PIERCE P. RYAN, JEFF JELOSEK, GREGORY MIZIOCH, JOHN LEWIS, VICTOR CARROLL, RANDLE DRESSLER, PAUL CHRISS, HOWARD KOLB, JOSEPH O'NEILL, DEBORAH CASE, as Personal Representative of the estate of Gerald Case, Deceased., MICHAEL SMITH, SJOERD CHASTAIN, DANIEL HARDIN, JOEL TOMLIN, MICHAEL SHOEMAKER, DIANE LINEBERRY, individually and as Representative of the Estate of Harold Wayne Lineberry, DONALD D. WYSE, Individually, and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald Bruce Wyse, HOWARD MURPHY, HAROLD MILLER, JOHN C. MACBETH, JOSEPH KUNDROT, DAVID CRAIG, THOMAS WATERMAN, KIMBERLY HALL, JOHN TOOHEY, MICHAEL S. RIGGS, DANIEL HURTAK, JOHN DRAGON, MARK ROSNER, RALPH TERRELL, AVERY IRVIN, JOHNNY C. SMITH, WILLIAM J. CASSIDY, CHESTER JONES, CHRISTOPHER ALEXANDER, JOE LOUIS POAG, JAYNE NUTT, Individually, and On Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Bobby Nutt, Deceased, and On Behalf of the Estate of Bobby Nutt, LEWIS CRAGG, MILES RESOR, JOE LENNON, FABIAN VELO, Sr., EDMOND NICHOLAS, HERBERT JONES, CALVIN L. JORDAN, PAUL A. LONG, AUTUMN ALLEN, STEVE THOMPSON, KEVIN MULLIGAN, ROBERT SAUNDERS, DARRELL PIERCE, SUZANNE E. PARSONS, individually, and as Executor of the Estate of Charles Leonard Parsons, Deceased, WILLIAM BELLMAN, JAMES CHASE WATSON, JOHN NASCI, ELIZABETH ZELLS, WILLIAM DOVE, ALVIN REED, DONALD EUGENE ANDERSON, JEREMY LANE, REBECCA DOZIER, As Surviving Spouse of David Dozier, CHRISTOPHER MANN, SUSAN MONDAY, Individually and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Kelvin Monday, deceased and on behalf of the Estate of Kelvin Monday, deceased, LUKE THELEN, WILLIAM POSTIY, MICHAEL O. WELLS, Sr., GEORGE MERREN, GREG FERGUSON, JOHN CAMPBELL, JEFF GOEDE, WAYNE JOHNSON, GREGORY FAIRES, RICHARD L. MARGRAF, DAVID BANCK, DIANE LEBLANC, CLARENCE A. SEALS, PATRICK WEBB, ARTHUR ALBERT, EUGENE LIDKE, DONALD FLESHER, CONRAD MUILENBURG, GARY MOTZKO, PAUL PETERSON, NANCY JOHNSON, Individually, and as Representative of the Estate of John Johnson, CHAD HUFFMAN, RONALD LAPORTE, SCOTT GREENAWALT, PETER LEHMAN, GERALD CANCELOSA, CHARLES M. SPEARS, RUSSELL L. KIGHT, MARVIN G. TURNBOUGH II, DAVID SOBELL, BARBARA WILSON, individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald Wilson, deceased, JOHN V. ZELLS, ARTHUR M. MORTENSEN, DENNIS MCDONALD, KELLY SANDLIN,, KENNETH C. STEPHENS, SCOTT F. MCCOLLUM, LEONARD GEE, JOSEPH J. CIANDELLA, WILLIAM SCHOLL, GRANT HAUGE, OSCAR MOLINA, WILLIAM DREW, VORIES KELLEY, BRIAN EVANS, MICHAEL A. BOLES, JOSEPH SHAKER, GARY P. RICKARD, JACK H. OGLESBY, FRANCIS HUGHES, FRANKIE MYERS, BILL HERD, MICHAEL LOZIER, TIM WISENER, DORA KAYE PETERSON, MICHAEL OLSON, JOEL VALME, SAMMY L. MARTINEZ, MICHAEL K. STOREY, ROBERT AWTRY, NICK DEVON FOWLER, KENNETH RANDALL, JEFFREY SCOTT MARTIN, GERALD LYNN, WILLIAM CARPENTER, STEVEN WEST, MELODI EVANS, as Anticipated Representative of Charles Evans Jr., BOBBY NELSON, GREG APEL, ROBERT AYERS, THOMAS GILIBERTI, MICHAEL MCCABE, TED FILZEN, JOHN NESBITT, CARL B. HEDWALL, CLYDE BAILEY, JOHN MOHR, CHARLES ENGFER, BRAD KRYGER, LUTHER PICKERING, VERNON GAINER, MAURY FARRINGTON, JAMES M. PORTER, AUDIE MURPHY, DAVID CHANDLER, KENNETH DECAROLIS, JOEL JONCZYK, BARRY DIEDERICH, JEFFREY M. JONES, Esquire, Attorney, SCOTT HALL, EDWARD W. MATTINGLY, Jr., NATHAN FAGRE, individually and as survivor of James Fagre, deceased, DANIEL THOMAS, DOLORES G. GEORGE, as surviving spouse of Kenneth Eugene George, deceased, SHANE A. PLEMMONS, JIMMIE RHODES, JIMMY TOLE, FRANK ZABLOTNEY, JEFFREY MARKS, DENNIS ANDREWS, MICHAEL HAKSETH, JONAS L. HENDERSON, WILLIAM TAYLOR, THOMAS BOWER, JERRY AKIN, MARTIN BASHAM, ANGELINA JOHNSON, as personal representative and administrator of the estate of Gerald J. Moore, ROBERT W. WILKINS, DENNIS DODGE, RICHARD LEE SCOTT, MIKE T. DAVIS, LYLE MAXEY, BRENT THOMPSON, TERRY RODMAN, AMANDA EMERSON, Individually and as the widow of Robert Emerson, deceased, MICHAEL ROBBINS, MICHAEL WILLIAMS, BONNER SMITH III, RONNIE LEE OSBORNE, JAMES MOATS, PAUL E. CAMPBELL, Jr., DAN RICHARDS, LAURENCE N. BROWN, KENNETH L. MCDANIEL, DELBERT SALYER, WILLIAM L. BAGLEY, Jr., WILLIAM K. BAXLEY, as Administrator of the Estate of Wade H. Baxley, deceased, THOMAS BENNINGTON, DAVID ALAN HORTON, DEXTER KETCHEN, MICHELLE A. UDELL, DOMINIC AQUILANO, TIMOTHY CAREY, BURR J. TRAVIS, JAMES LINDSEY, JAMES DAVIS, KEN EVAN, EUGENE OKERLUND, JOHN SWITALSKI, LARRY PRICE, MARTIN D. MAYER, TERRI BOURQUE, MICHAEL ANTHONY SANEK, WILLIAM O'NEAL, ROBERT CHILDERS, JESSE GREDITOR, CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS, RANDY SNELGROVE, MICHAEL BLAKE, JAMES RUSSELL RAYMICK, CHARLIE OWENS, ROBERT J. GOERLICH, RONALD FUDGE, PAUL OLBERDING, GORDON LIETCH, MICHAEL BALLINGER, JOHN HATCHER, ROBERT LEACH, LARRY CATOE, SHAUN PITTS, NANCY VANNESS, individually, and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiareis of Stephen Vanness, Deceased, and on behalf of the Estate of Stephen Vanness, Deceased, MARK SIEDSCHLAG, MICHAEL DOBRA, TERRY ADAMS, CHARLES CHRISTENSEN, KAY JACOBSON, individually and as Representative of the Estate of Allen Jacobson, GEORGE JAMISON, ROBERT CAHILL, NEAL PEISLEY, JAMES SENNELLO, FRANK K. WITT, JAMES B. ADAMS, JIMMY L. ESTEP, GREGG SMITH, GEORGE A. SCHOECK, VICKI NORTHUP, Individually, and on behalf of the wronful death beneficiaries of George Northup, Deceased, and on behalf of the Estate of George Northup, Deceased, RONALD JORDAN, JAMES DICKSON, BRADFORD CROMPTON, ROBERT COLLINS, DAVID DECONCINI, DORN L. SCHMIDT, BILL WEDERTZ, THUC TRINH NGUYEN, Individually, and as Executrix of the Estate of Thang Thuy Nguyen, Deceased, CHARLES A. CROXFORD, MARK D. CALLAHAN, WILLIAM DWIGHT TRULL, BRUCE HALLBERT, CLINTON TRENT, TRACY PURITZ, ADNREA SNYDER, DAVID E. WAGNER, ROBERT MCELWEE, JERRY L. THOMAS, LARRY LEBLANC, NORMAN PRINCE, WARREN SERIGNET, Jr., DON HUX, PAUL J. RILEY, DAN DARR, ROBERT SCOTT, MARK STOUFFER, GARRY LAWRENCE WOLF, Sr., JOSEPH BARNES III, SEAMUS O. CALKINS, FREDERIC BUCK, DAVID B. ANDERSON, DONALD CARSON, JASPER SMITH, HERMAN SMITH, RANDALL STEVEN STOCKTON, STEPHEN ZEBOSKEY, LARRY LOWDER, CHARLES PRUITT, JOHN BRIAN HENDRIX, CAROLYN PINKARD, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Michael Kent Pinkard, and on Behalf of All Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Michael Kent Pinkard, Deceased, JOHN REINWALD, ROBERT TROSTHEIM, STEVEN CUMBERWORTH, JOHN ADAMS, JOSEPH E. MARCIANO, Sr., BOBBY EVANS, ROBERT LEE HEFLER, SAMUEL GREEN, LYLE TOOLE, GEORGE HOUCK, JONATHAN HOLLIBAUGH, HEINZ D. TURNER, EARL HOWARD, JOSEPH SCHEIN, IVAN V. MILLER, JOSEPH PALMERINO, BRUCE MONTGOMERY, PHILIP CLARK, DAVID G. SHELTON, JAMES E. TRAUTMAN, JACK SWINT, DAVID GEORGE, DANIEL EDMONDSON, DONALD WATKINS, RICHARD CHARLES BARCHE, JOHN WORTHYLAKE, CINDY CUSIMANO, CHARLES JOHNS, JOHN R. ULBINSKY, NEIL J. GRANER, HECTOR VANDECAPELLE, JOHN C. WALLACE, JAMES YEX, HENRY QUIGG, STEPHEN CRAIG WEICHERS, EDWARD APRIL, JAMES MORRIS, MATTHEW MCPAYNE, JUDY MCLAWHORN FLEMING, JAMES DAVENPORT, TIMOTHY KESSLER, ANTHONY MIRAGLIA, LARRY WELLMAN, LAWRENCE MORTON, LAWRENCE MULLEN, THOMAS COJOE, MARY YOUNG, individually and as personal representative and executor of the Estate of Alice Kinney, THOMAS ROBERTSON, JOHN HELM, TIMOTHY GALLAGHER, Attorney, DAVID WOODRING, FRANK SHARP, Jr., DANNY KNIGHT, JAMES O'DAY, ROBERT OALMANN, HARRY PENROD, CHARLES WILBOURN, HUGH MCGRAIL, RICHARD LEE EVANS, JAMES V. PATRICK, LORRAINE MAYNARD, KEVIN GRAHAM, EDWARD L. FRAZELLE, HERMAN APFELBAUM, M.D., MICHAEL PERRY BRANNON, ROBERT A. SPRINGER, individually and as Representative of the Estate of Robert E. Springer, ANTHONY LAURIA, CLAVIS BRAWNER, ERNEST J. GARCIA, JAMES W. REEDER, JOHN HAGBERG, DWIGHT MERRICK, TRACY F. PITTS, ROBERT BURNS, WILLIAM HOFFMAN, JOHN J. KOZER III, JOHN HERRICK, HENRI GEIER, RONNIE B. GRIFFITH, TOM HASTINGS, DANIEL REAGAN, THOMAS BACHARACH, KEVIN CONRAD, ARTHUR MCCOY, RONALD WILLOUGHBY, ROBERT F. IRVING, THOMAS KEOUGH, HERMAN J. SMITH, PAUL CRAIG MABRY, PAULA BOUTON, ROBERT S. KOPS, JIMMIE A. CHRISTENSEN, NORMA S. CHANEY, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Mickey Chaney, Deceased, GEORGE M. BRILL, JOHN REAVIS, WALTER DOWNS, WILLIAM AYERS, LANCE WARREN, ROBERT BRYANT, DOUG JONES, GERALD NEEB, JOSE L. NAVARRO, RICHARD WINSHIP, DOUGLAS HINTON, DENNIS OBADAL, JOEL LIBERTO, DARRELL MEADER, DARREN M. DAUTREUIL, STEPHEN WILLIAMS, HAROLD TROY, KENNETH DEMPICH, PETER HAANEN, PAUL BILARDO, STEPHEN OWENS, JAMES CAMPBELL, DEAN THOMAS, RITA KATHLEEN MARKHAM, THOMAS EDWARD RAY, TAFFORD DESHOTEL, ARNOLD MITTLER, BURL SANDERS, PAUL DORWEILER, LORRAINE REARDON, LAURA A. SEABURY, THOMAS HETTINGER, LEE JAN WADDELL, Individually, and On Behalf of the Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Benny Daniels, Deceased, and On Behalf of the Estate of Benny Daniels, Deceased, JODY L. CARL, DALLAS GRANT, IRVIN BRUNKENHOEFER, JAMES BENNETT, WILLIAM BOGEDAIN, MICHAEL KNOTTS, JIMMIE DALE GERLOFS, ROBERT GRINNELL, Jr., CONNIE COFFMAN, individually, and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Robert Murray, Deceased, and on behalf of the Estate of Robert Murray, Deceased, TIMMY LEE BLANKENSHIP, JOHN POWERS, WILBERT J. COUVILLION, MARK BASS, CONNIE J. SINN, GARALD SHELTON, EDMUND SWAYZE, GREGORY BOWMAN, Esquire, MICHAEL OLIVO, JACQUELINE CHAPLAIN, Individually, and as Administrator of the Estate of Larry Dale Chaplain, Deceased, JAMES W. CROTHERS III, HOWARD EDWARDS, BURTIS DOCKERY, JOHN J. SCHULTZ, PAUL L. KERSMARKI, Sr., DANIEL TAYLOR, BRAD DEAN GORSKI, WILLIAM MADDUX, RICHARD BASSETT, WILLIAM MATTHEWS, PATRICIA POWELL, Individually and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Donald Powell, deceased and on behalf of the Estate of Donald Powell, MARK DIXON, FRANK BURKE, HELENE CHANDLER, JAMES KOLM, PAUL ADLER, RANDY WILEY, EDITH CURTIS, individually and on behalf of the wrongful death beneficiaries of Robert Curtis, deceased and on behalf of the Estate of Robert Curtis, THOMAS HOUGH, HAROLD DALE VALE, JAKE JONES III, NORMA D. PAIR, individually, and as heir of Larry J. Pair, MARY LOU YACKEL, KINGSLEY SUTCH, TED BECK, STEVEN THOMPSON, TROY ESSARY, RICHARD W. LONG, LEWIS KRANTZ, WILLY M. GIBSON, VERNON DANIELS, RICHARD GROSSGOLD, CHARLES DEVERICK, JOHN GRAESSLE, Sr., EARL HUNT, CHARLES CHAMBLISS, MICHAEL HAMILTON, RON ROSENWEIN, WILLIAM BECKER, RICHARD P. CARTER, TOBIN ROUTH, TERRENCE GIVENS, WIL VIGIL, SHARON CHRABRY, Individually, and as Representative of the Estate of Michael Chrabry, CLIFTON SEABURY, LASANDRA YOUNG, individually and as representative of the Estate of James M. Young, CLARK SIMMONS, CHARLES ALTHAFER, DAVID CARTER, SCOTT HANSON, HENRY R. PITTS, RONALD L. SPIERS, DENNIS B. TART, ROBERT SHAWN PEARCY, THOMAS A. WILSON, PAUL OWEN, JAMES CHRISTIAN, TED BARNEY, GEORGE MATTHEWS, CHARLES GIMBY, ARTHUR BUCHANAN, JAMES L. PEGRAM, JAMES BELL, LUKE SMITH, CHARLES CUSIMANO, STEVEN GUBICZA, MARTIN MOTT, JANET WINDSOR JONES, HAROLD SCOTT HAMILTON, WILLIAM RAGAN, HARRY BOLLMAN, DAVID COHEN, ROBBIE SUMMERS, LENNARD KORNFELD, KARL MOORE, GALE JOHN CAMPBELL, GERALD K. BROWN, JAMES MULVANEY, WILLIAM GOLDSMITH, DEBORAH JO FLEEMAN, individually and as administratrix of the Estate of Daniel Fleeman, TIMOTHY PERRILLOUX, DELRAY R. STEPHENS, JACK TAYLOR, HUBERT C. SHEFFIELD, ROBERT HARRISON, EDDIE HERNDON, MICHAEL GARDINER, HARVEY ELLENTHAL, JAMES L. BRACHFELD, PHYLLIS SPEARS-TOMES, Individually, and as Representative of the Estate of Jerry Spears, DAVID LEDBETTER, RICHARD HENRY, LARRY SHULTZ, GEORGE FREDERICK MEARCE, STILLMAN ABBOTT, JARRELL YOUNG, PAMELA W. COOTS, individually and as Administrator of the Estate of Kenneth Coots, Deceased, STEVEN W. JOHNSON, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert W. Johnson, Deceased, ROBERT EDWIN JOHNSEN, DOUGLAS JORDAN, RANDALL JOHNSTON, AMADOR HERRARA, HAROLD RUBASH, WILLIAM WEBSTER, WILLIAM R. KNIERIEM, DAVID KNECHT, PHILIP FRESEMAN, ANTHONY CATANIO, MICHAEL PRATER, CHARLES RHODES, DANE TOUSSAINT, KENNY CUTLER, JAMES MYERS, CARL HUDSON, JOHN BEECH, JOHN MASON, GREGORY YOUNG, DAVID MORROW, Attorney, MILO PELTON, KEVEN LOMAX, JAMES MILLIKEN, JACK LIGGETT, M.D., JAMES GOODWIN, GRADY MICHAEL GADDY, GERALD WHITING, JOE CLARK, JIM HACKWORTH, RONALD FOX, VIRGIL KNOEPKE, KENNETH SYBRANT, LESLIE D. SHANNON, ROBERT MONSON, ALLEN LECHTMAN, ELBRIDGE W. LUTHER, PETER M. COX, HARLEY CATLOW, RICHARD LEWIS, STEPHEN TURPEN, LARRY DAY, PAMELA JEAN LEYDON, individually, and as personal representative of the estate of Michael Terrance Wirsching, JAMES CROKEN, ALLAN KARP, KENNETH JANSEN,, Jr., PHILLIP KAHN, MARK VANBREMEN, JOHN WARD, JAMES JONES, RUFUS PATTERSON, DONALD SMITH, ROBERT J. EUBANKS, JAMES PACK, DANIEL O'LEARY, JOHN ROMEO, JAMES NAGLER, Jr., JOSEPH MADONNA, LARRY BARNES, TIMOTHY JEANSONNE, KEVIN LAWLESS, MICHAEL PATRICK, CLIFF ARMSTRONG, DANNY COOK, ROBERT JOHNSON, TIMOTHY SIMPSON, JEFFREY WAYNE MCCAMERON, THOMAS FARWELL, ART CHANDLER, RALPH T. MOTES, Jr., LESLIE SMITH, LOUIS CRISSMAN, BRIAN SAYRS, MICHAEL W. GIOVANDO, ROY RADFORD, DONALD CUNNINGHAM, EDWIN ALDEN FINE, MICHAEL JAMES, LEAMON KNIGHT, THOMAS RIEDERER, WAYNE SIMPSON, GEORGE YOUNG, CHARLES LINER, CECIL LEON HODGENS, ROBERT BARRETT, MARK BEAN, RALPH BURKE, JOSEPH PIACENTILE, RUDY SHUMATE, JOSEPH EARLS, WILLIAM STOCK, CURTIS WEBB, JOHNNY CRONAN, PETER DOSKEY, JOHN JONES, JAMES T. HATFIELD, TIMOTHY TAYLOR and DAVID MORROW
Not Classified By Court:	In re: VIAGRA (SILDENAFIL CITRATE) PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION
Defendant / Appellee:	PFIZER, INC. and ELI LILLY AND COMPANY
Case Number:	20-15894
Filed:	May 8, 2020
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Torts - Personal Injury

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.