Plaintiff / Appellant:	GARY VICTOR DUBIN, individually and on behalf of all Hawaii attorneys similarly situated, DBA Dubin Law Offices, CHRISTIE ADAMS, TORU AKEHI, GWEN ALEJO-HERRING, GLORIA ALMENDARES, JERIS YUKIO AMAZAKI, DEBRA ANAGRAN, DIRK APAO, JERRY BADUA, JULIA BADUA, LIAO LUCY BAMBOO, MIA BAN, ROMAN BAPTISTE, CHARLES BASS, LAURIE BASS, AGRIPINO PASCUA BONILLA, RUTH ROJAS BONILLA, SHERILYN MAY ROJAS BONILLA, KANOA ROSS BRISTOL, DONNA BROOKS, DAVID R. BROWN, REYNALDO CABUDOL, CHRISTY CARRICO, PHINEAS CASADY, JOYCE CHANDLER, WILLIAM CHANDLER, JENNIFER CHAPMAN, LUIS C. CHAVEZ, STEPHEN CHEIKES, MERVIN HALFRED NAEA CHING, LUCIA CHING, SUTAH CHIRAYUNON, SEUNG CHOI, BRETT CHRISTIANSEN, AH MEI CHUN, HUGH JOHN COFLIN, JANET COFLIN, RUSSEL COLE, PAUL COLLINS, WATOSHNA LYNN COMPTON, GEORGE COSTA, GREGORY CLYDE SOUZA CRAVALHO, TONI NOELANI CRAVALHO, ROGER CUNDALL, ERIC LEE DAVIES, WILLIAM DAVIS, VANDETTA DAVIS, YUKIKO HAYASHI DAY, PAIGE DE PONTE, FATIMA DUNCAN, CAROLINA CABUDOL EALA, EDWIN PAET EALA, DAVID WENDELL ELLIS, LORI LYNN ELLIS, JANICE ELLISON, SCOTT ELLISON, NELIE BANIAGA ESCALANTE, NORBERTO RAMELB ESCALANTE, ELENA FEDOROVA, AKIKO FERGERSTROM, JUSTIN FERGERSTROM, JOHN J. FREEPARTNER III, LISA MARIE FREEPARTNER, MICHAEL J. FUCHS, IRENE SAJOR GANO, ROYD ALLEN GANO, EDNA GANTT, LEAH GILLESPIE, ELIZABETH GILLETTE, DAVID GOODWIN, MALIA GRACE, ANTONIO GRAFILO, NELIA GRAFILO, HOWARD GREENBERG, KENNETH HAGMANN, MICHAEL JON HAMMER, DARRYL HASHIDA, SEAN HAYWORTH, NICOLE FLORES HOSAKA, TOD HOSAKA, CHRISTIAN JENSEN, DAVID KAPLAN, DONALD KARLEEN, BEATA KARPUSIEWICZ, YVONNE M. KEAHI, JAROSLAW KARPUSIEWICZ, KEITH KIMI, OTELIAH KIND, KORY KLEIN, MARY KNUDSEN, ELEANA U. KOAKOU, LENORE LANNON, STEPHEN LAUDIG, Esquire, MALLORY ASPILI LONGBOY, SHARI ARAKAWA LONGBOY, FRANK JAMES LYON, ERIC MADER, AMY KATHLEEN MAHER, MICHAEL CHARLES MAHER, GWEN MARCANTONIO, ARMAND MARIBOHO, DARLA MARIBOHO, JENNIFER MARTIN, MARYELLEN MARKLEY, LAURA MARQUES, CHANELLE LEOLA MATTOS, JOSEPH KEAOULA MATTOS, WILLIAM MCTHEWSON, EMILOU N.A. MIKAMI, RICKEY R. MIKAMI, TROY MIZUKAMI, JONNAVEN JO MONALIM, MISTY MARIE MONALIM, ROBERT-GAVIN MOORE, TERESA MOORE, THOMAS MORTON, TERRY LYNNE OHARA MOSELEY, YVONNE NIELSEN, AILYN T. OUNYOUNG, SAMRIT OUNYOUNG, DAVID L. OWLES, RAQUEL PACHECO, JOHN PERREIRA, ROSE PERREIRA, MICHAEL PIERCE, MARIO PORTILLO, EBONI PRENTICE, ROSARIO RAMOS, LURLINE RAPOZA, MERRILLYN M. J. L. RAPOZA, JOHN RIDDEL, Jr., JEANETTE ROSEHILL, MARCUS ROSEHILL, RAY J. RUDDY, MICHELE COLLEEN RUNDGREN, TODD RUNDGREN, JO RUSSO, KELLY KALANIKAPULAHAO SAMPAIO, RICHARD MILIKONA SAMPAIO, Jr., JOHN SAVAGE, RONALD SCHRANZ, JOHN SHIGEMURA, JASON SIEGFRIED, MELEANA SMITH, JODY SOLBACH, ELIZABETH SPECTOR, DANIEL JOSEPH SPENCE, EILEEN EVELYN STEPHENSON, CONNIE SWIERSKI, BONNIE SWINK, JACK SWINK, EVELYN TAKENAKA, NADINE K. TAMAYOSE, REID L. TAMAYOSE, KARRI TESHIMA, CLOVER THEDE, DYLAN THEDE, LANA M. TOLEAFAO, SAUMANI LOPI TOLEAFOA, BRUCE ROBERT TRAVIS, ELISE TRAVIS, DARREN TSUCHIYA, LANCE TSUCHIYA, MALIA OLIVAS TSUCHIYA, ANTHONY TUCKER, GLADYS TUPULUA, HEDY UDARBE, RUSTICO UDARBE, VALERIE UYEDA, EDWARD VALLEJO, JON VAN CLEAVE, PATRICK VERHAGEN, STEPHEN WARD, DONAVAN WEBB, VALERIE WOODS, LERMA YAMASHITA, JACK YOUNG and NANCY PATSY YOUNG, individually and on behalf of all clients of Hawaii attorneys similarly situated
Defendant / Appellee:	SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF HAWAII, in its legislative rule-making capacity and in its judicial capacity, THE HONORABLE MARK E. RECKENWALD, in his official capacity while serving as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii, THE HONORABLE PAULA A. NAKAYAMA, in her official capacity while serving as Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii, THE HONORABLE SABRINA S. MCKENNA, in her official capacity while serving as Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii, THE HONORABLE MICHAEL D. WILSON, in his official capacity while serving as Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii, THE HONORABLE KATHERINE S. LEONARD, in her official capacity while serving as appointed substitute Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of Hawaii, OFFICE OF DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL OF THE HAWAII SUPREME COURT, in its individual capacity as a non-agency Special Master, DISCIPLINARY BOARD OF THE HAWAII SUPREME COURT, in its individual capacity as a non-agency Special Master, LAWYERS' FUND FOR CLIENT PROTECTION OF THE HAWAII SUPREME COURT, in its individual capacity as a non-agency Special Master, BRADLEY R TAMM, in his individual capacity while serving under color of law as both the Chief Disciplinary Counsel of the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Hawaii Supreme Court and Fund Administrator of the Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection of, CLIFFORD L. NAKEA, in his individual capacity while serving under color of law as Chairperson of the Disciplinary Board of the Hawaii Supreme Court, ROY F. HUGHES, in his individual capacity while serving under color of law as a Hearing Officer of the Disciplinary Board of the Hawaii Supreme Court, CHARLENE M. NORRIS, in her individual capacity while serving under color of law as Senior Disciplinary Counsel of the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Hawaii Supreme Court and ANDREA R. SINK, in her individual capacity while serving under color of law as an Investigator of the the Office of Disciplinary Counsel of the Hawaii Supreme Court
Case Number:	21-16863
Filed:	November 4, 2021
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Other Civil Rights

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.