In re: Navy Chaplaincy
| Richard V. Spencer, Secretary of the U.S. Navy, John B. Nowell, Vice Admiral, Chief of Naval Personnel, United States Navy, Secretary of the Navy, Brent W. Scott, Rear Admiral, Chief of Chaplains and Deputy Chief of Chaplains |
| David L. Gibson, William C. Blair, David S. Wilder, Thomas G. Klappert, 06-1696, Joseph E. Dufour, 06-1696, Rafael J. Quiles, Rick P. Bradley, 06-1696, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Jairo Marino, 06-1696, Armando Torralva, 06-1696, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, 06-1696, Frank Klapach, 06-1696, Gregory R. De Marco, Furniss Harkness, Samuel David Kirk, 06-1696, Patrick T. Doney, 06-1696, Richard F. Hamme, 00-0566, George P. Byrum, Jan C. Kohlmann, 06-1696, David Mitchell, 06-1696, Martha Carson, Andrew Calhoun, 06-1696, Richard L. Arnold, John Gordy, 06-1696, Chris Xenakis, 06-1696, Gary Paul Stewart, 06-1696, Frank Johnson, 06-1696, Lloyd Scott, 06-1696, George W. Linzey, Timothy J. Demy, 06-1696, Thomas R. Watson, 06-1696, Larry Farrell, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., 06-1696, James Looby, 06-1696, Denise Y. Merritt, Timothy D. Nall, Robert L. Hendricks, 06-1696, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Lavelle, Alan Garner, 06-1696, Thomas Rush, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., 06-1696, Wilson W. Wineman, 06-1696, Michael A. Wright, Gary Heinke, 06-1696, Mary Helen Spalding, William A. Hatch, Jr., 06-1696, Michael Belt, Daniel E. Roysden, James M. Weibling, Laurence W. Jones, 06-1696, Glenn Thyrion, 06-1696, Barby Earl Wilson and Allen Lancaster, 06-1696 |
| Associated Gospel Churches, John Witherspoon, Chaplaincy of Full Gospel Churches, Robert Duane Purser, Lieutenant Commander, Mark R. Johnston and Robert H. Adair |
| In re: Navy Chaplaincy |
| 19-5206 |
| July 24, 2019 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, D.C. Circuit |
| Other |
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on September 4, 2019. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| NOTICE [1805002] Appellants Will Not File a Dispositive Motion filed by Associated Gospel Churches in 19-5204, Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206 [Service Date: 09/04/2019 ] [19-5204, 19-5206] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 09/04/2019 05:00 PM] |
| REPLY [1804526] filed by Associated Gospel Churches in 19-5204, Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206 to response [ # 1803677-2 ] [Service Date: 09/02/2019 by CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 1921 words. [19-5204, 19-5206] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 09/02/2019 11:56 PM] |
| RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION [1803677] to motion [ # 1803535-2 ] filed by Deputy Chief of Chaplains, John B. Nowell, Brent W. Scott, Secretary of the Navy, Richard V. Spencer and United States Navy in 19-5204, 19-5206 [Service Date: 08/26/2019 by CM/ECF NDA] Length Certification: 499. [19-5204, 19-5206] (Soni, Sushma) [Entered: 08/26/2019 03:00 PM] |
| CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE WITH TYPE-VOLUME LIMITS [1803764] for motion for other relief [ # 1803535-2 ] filed by Associated Gospel Churches in 19-5204, Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206. [19-5204, 19-5206] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 08/26/2019 07:38 PM] |
| CERTIFICATE AS TO PARTIES, RULINGS AND RELATED CASES [1803524] filed by United States Navy, Richard V. Spencer, Secretary of the Navy, Brent W. Scott, John B. Nowell and Deputy Chief of Chaplains in 19-5204, 19-5206 [Service Date: 08/23/2019 ] [19-5204, 19-5206] (Soni, Sushma) [Entered: 08/23/2019 06:41 PM] |
| DOCKETING STATEMENT AND STATEMENT OF ISSUES [1803534] filed by Associated Gospel Churches and Denise Y. Merritt and Daniel E. Roysden in 19-5204, Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206 [Service Date: 08/23/2019 ] [19-5204, 19-5206]--[Edited 08/26/2019 by LMF] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 08/23/2019 11:32 PM] |
| MOTION [1803535] Procedural Motion to Separate Associated Gospel Churches appeal from remaining 54 Navy chaplains filed by Associated Gospel Churches in 19-5204, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Richard L. Arnold, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206 (Service Date: 08/23/2019 by CM/ECF NDA) Length Certification: 7 pages (including Certificateof Service). [19-5204, 19-5206] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 08/23/2019 11:56 PM] |
| CERTIFICATE AS TO PARTIES, RULINGS AND RELATED CASES, DEFERRED APPENDIX STATEMENT, UNDERLYING DECISION AND TRANSCRIPT STATUS REPORT [1803511] filed by Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, George P. Byrum, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Larry Farrell, David L. Gibson, Furniss Harkness, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, Denise Y. Merritt, Timothy D. Nall, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Mary Helen Spalding, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Michael A. Wright, All Gibson Plaintiffs and Associated Gospel Churches [Service Date: 08/23/2019 ] [19-5204]--[Edited 08/26/2019 by LMF] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 08/23/2019 04:54 PM] |
| LETTER [1800342] Correct ECM Party/attorney list and Party filer menu to reflect Notice of Appeal filed by Associated Gospel Churches in 19-5204, Richard L. Arnold, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright, Chris Xenakis and Ray A. Bailey in 19-5206 [Service Date: 08/01/2019 ] [19-5204, 19-5206] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 08/01/2019 06:43 PM] |
| ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [1799864] filed by Arthur A. Schulcz Sr. on behalf of Appellants Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis in 19-5206. [19-5206, 19-5204] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 07/30/2019 10:35 PM] |
| ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [1799858] filed by Arthur A. Schulcz Sr. on behalf of Appellant Associated Gospel Churches. [19-5204] (Schulcz, Arthur) [Entered: 07/30/2019 06:03 PM] |
| ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [1799179] filed by Sushma Soni and co-counsel Marleigh Dover on behalf of Appellees Deputy Chief of Chaplains, John B. Nowell, Brent W. Scott, Secretary of the Navy, Richard V. Spencer and United States Navy in 19-5204, 19-5206. [19-5204, 19-5206] (Soni, Sushma) [Entered: 07/25/2019 07:27 PM] |
| NOTICE OF APPEAL [1798854] seeking review of a decision by the U.S. District Court in 1:07-mc-00269-JDB filed by Richard L. Arnold, Ray A. Bailey, Michael Belt, William C. Blair, Rick P. Bradley, George P. Byrum, Andrew Calhoun, Martha Carson, Gregory R. De Marco, Timothy J. Demy, Patrick T. Doney, Joseph E. Dufour, Larry Farrell, Alan Garner, David L. Gibson, John Gordy, Richard F. Hamme, Furniss Harkness, William A. Hatch, Jr., Gary Heinke, Robert L. Hendricks, Frank Johnson, Laurence W. Jones, Samuel David Kirk, Frank Klapach, Thomas G. Klappert, Jan C. Kohlmann, Allen Lancaster, Michael Lavelle, George W. Linzey, James Looby, Jairo Marino, Walker E. Marsh, Jr., Denise Y. Merritt, David Mitchell, Timothy D. Nall, Edith Rene Porter-Stewart, Cynthia Palmer Prince, Rafael J. Quiles, Daniel E. Roysden, Thomas Rush, Lloyd Scott, Mary Helen Spalding, Gary Paul Stewart, Fred A. Thompson, Jr., Glenn Thyrion, Armando Torralva, Thomas R. Watson, James M. Weibling, David S. Wilder, Barby Earl Wilson, Wilson W. Wineman, Michael A. Wright and Chris Xenakis. Appeal assigned USCA Case Number: 19-5206. [19-5206] [Entered: 07/24/2019 04:09 PM] |
| NOTICE [1798861] received from the Clerk of the U.S. District Court of ERRATA to page 3 of Notice of Appeal. [19-5206] [Entered: 07/24/2019 04:27 PM] |
| CLERK'S ORDER [1798897] filed consolidating cases 19-5206 (Consolidation started 07/24/2019) with 19-5204; directing party to file initial submissions: APPELLANT docketing statement due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT certificate as to parties due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT statement of issues due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT underlying decision due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT deferred appendix statement due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT notice of appearance due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT transcript status report due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT procedural motions due 08/23/2019. APPELLANT dispositive motions due 09/09/2019; directing party to file initial submissions: APPELLEE certificate as to parties due 08/23/2019. APPELLEE entry of appearance due 08/23/2019. APPELLEE procedural motions due 08/23/2019. APPELLEE dispositive motions due 09/09/2019 [19-5204, 19-5206] [Entered: 07/24/2019 05:26 PM] |
| US CIVIL CASE docketed. [19-5206] [Entered: 07/24/2019 04:08 PM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
