Richard Blumenthal, et al v. Donald Trump
Amy Klobuchar, Jeff Merkley, Cory A. Booker, Ron Wyden, Richard J. Durbin, Eric Swalwell, Chris Murphy, Patrick J. Leahy, Zoe Lofgren, Ted Deutch, Steve Cohen, Kamala D. Harris, Tim Kaine, Sheila Jackson Lee, Chris Van Hollen, Jerrold Nadler, James E. Clyburn, Michael F. Bennet, Sheldon Whitehouse, Henry C. Hank Johnson, Brian Schatz, Ted Lieu, Karen Bass, David N. Cicilline, Tom Carper, Edward J. Markey, Tammy Duckworth, Elizabeth Warren, Bernard Sanders, Kirsten E. Gillibrand, Benjamin L. Cardin, Patty Murray, Mazie K. Hirono, Hakeem Jeffries, Christopher A. Coons, Richard Blumenthal, Catherine Cortez Masto, Linda T. Sanchez, Jamie Raskin, Maria Cantwell, Steny H. Hoyer, Tom Udall, Martin Heinrich, Nancy Pelosi, Jack Reed and Cedric L. Richmond |
Donald J. Trump, in his official capacity as President of the United States of America |
Leonard I. Garth, Judge, Scholar, Rutgers Law School, Frank Greenberg, Tom Harkin, (D-IA), Karole Green, Professor of Law, Washington University in St. Louis School of Law, Cary Coglianese, Lee Hamilton, (D-IN), Frank Edmund Deale, Svetlana Wachtell, Professor of Constitutional Law and Civil Liberties, New York University School of Law, Madeleine K. Albright, Wendy Parmet, Matthews University Distinguished Professor of Law and Professor of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University School of Law, Peter Smith, (R-VT), Richard A. Horvitz, Andrew Rothman, Associate Professor of Law, Rutgers Law School, Seth Davis, Brian Wolfman, Lawrence Ashe, Professor of Law, Georgia State University College of Law, Marilyn Glynn, Former OGE Acting Director and General Counsel (career), Joseph Solomon, Distinguished Professor, New York Law School, Christoph Henkel, Professor of Law, Mississippi College School of Law, Matthew D. Adler, Jed Shugerman, Legal historian and Professor, Prem Kumar, Paul R. Verkuil, Senior Fellow at the Center for American Progress and President Emeritus of the College of William & Mary, Mary-Beth Moylan, Associate Dean for Academic Affairs and Experiential Learning, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, Jack Rakove, Legal historian and Professor, Richard Heppner, Assistant Professor, Duquesne University School of Law, Herbert M. Wachtell, Professor of Constitutional Law and Civil Liberties, New York University School of Law, Jesse Egbert, Professor, Clark D. Cunningham, Professor, John F. Kerry, Bathsheba N. Crocker, Laurence H. Tribe, Lumen Mulligan, Research Professor of Law, University of Kansas School of Law, Barbara Boxer, (D-CA), George Miller, (D-CA), Dick Zimmer, (R-NJ), Michael Darr Barnes, (D-MD), Jesse Herbert Choper, Distinguished Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley School of Law, Mark Udall, (D-CO), Simon Stern, Legal historian and Professor, Niskanen Center, Joan E. Steinman, Suzy George, Jonathan S. Masur, James Gray Pope, Distinguished Professor of Law & Sidney Reitman Scholar, Rutgers Law School, Richard Thomas, Former Associate General Counsel, OGE; Former Ethics Counsel, Department of Health & Human Services, Bernice J. Greenberg, Seth Barrett Tillman, Scholar, Gautham Rao, Legal historian and Professor, Edward B. Shils, Trevor Potter, Mark Rahdert, Professor of Law, Temple University James E. Beasley School of Law, Michael C. Dorf, Bob Carr, (D-MI), Maxwell Stearns, Venable, Baetjer & Howard Professor of Law, University of Maryland Carey School of Law, John Mikhail, Legal historian and Professor, Jeffrey Prescott, Lawrence Reynolds, Former Assistant General Counsel for the Department of Housing & Urban Development with responsibility for ethics (career; also served at the Department of Labor in career ethics capacity), Chuck Hagel, James B. Steinberg, William Luneberg, Professor of Law, Emeritus, University of Pittsburgh School of Law, Joan E. Steinman, University Distinguished Professor Emerita, Chicago-Kent College of Law, Wendy Sherman, Trip Rothschild, Former Associate General Counsel at the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Donald B. Ayer, Daniel Feldman, Brad Miller, (D-NC), Gary Hart, (D-CO), Diana Sclar, Professor of Law and Allan Axelrod Scholar, Rutgers Law School, John P. Wilson, Leslie Wilcox, Former Associate General Counsel for OGE (career), and principal author of the Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch (5 CFR Part 2635), Philip Sharp, (D-IN), Earl B. Shurtz, Research Professor of Law, University of Kansas School of Law, Republican Women for Progress, Heather A. Higginbottom, Tom Coleman, (R-MO), Perry Dane, Professor of Law, Rutgers Law School, J. W. Verret, Jim Leach, (R-IA), Robert S. Stevens, Matt Olsen, Jon D. Michaels, Professor of Law, University of California, Los Angeles School of Law, Dan Fox, Former Office of Government Ethics (OGE) General Counsel and Acting Director (career; also served at the Department of Defense in career legal capacity), Harvey Wilcox, Former Navy Deputy General Counsel (career) and Designated Agency Ethics Official, Steve Bartlett, (R-TX), Karl Manheim, Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, Sandra Rierson, Associate Professor of Law, Thomas Jefferson School of Law, Thomas Green, Professor of Law, Washington University in St. Louis School of Law, Judicial Education Project, Henry A. Waxman, (D-CA), Vikram Singh, Amy Comstock Rick, Former Director of the OGE; former Associate Counsel to President Clinton for ethics (originally career ethics official at Department of Education), Charles Doskow, Dean Emeritus & Professor of Law, University of La Verne Collegeof Law, Erwin Chemerinsky, Dean, University of California, Berkeley School of Law, Matthew I. Hall, Associate Professor of Law, University of Georgia School of Law, Arthur Wolf, Professor of Law and Director, Institute for Legislative and Governmental Affairs, Western New England University School of Law, Edward Purcell, Distinguished Professor, New York Law School, Harold H. Bruff, Rosenbaum Professor of Law Emeritus at the University of Colorado School of Law, Mickey Edwards, (R-OK), Joshua A. Geltzer, Bob Inglis, (R-SC), Helen Hershkoff, Professor of Constitutional Law and Civil Liberties, New York University School of Law, Bruce Andrews, Christopher Shays, (R-CT), Kathy Ashe, Jeff Bingaman, (D-NM), Gregory P. Magarian, Professor of Law, Washington University in St. Louis School of Law, Ronald Chen, University Professor, Distinguished Professor of Law, Rutgers Law School, Karen Kucik, Former ethics official for DOJ, Department of Commerce, and Department of Health & Human Services (career), William Burns, Antony Blinken, Frank Edmund Deale, Associate Professor of Law, City University of New York School of Law, Peter L. Strauss, Betts Professor of Law Emeritus at Columbia Law School, Peter M. Shane, Jacob E. Davis Chair and Jacob E. Davis II in Law at the Ohio State Universitys Moritz College of Law, James C. OBrien, Heather Elliott, Alumni, Class of '36 Professor of Law, University of Alabama School of Law, Jonathan Finer, Aziz Zahirul Huq, Eric J. Segall, Professor of Law, Georgia State University College of Law, Daniel Farber, John F. Preis, Donald L. Doernberg, Professor of Law, Emeritus, Pace University School of Law, and Adjunct Professor of Law, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, Eric P. Schwartz, Daniel Benjamin, Antony J. Blinken, William J. Burns, Joshua Alexander Geltzer and James C. O'Brien |
19-5237 |
September 5, 2019 |
U.S. Court of Appeals, D.C. Circuit |
Other Civil Rights |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on October 13, 2020. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
LETTER [1866238] received from the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the United States notifying this court of the following activity in case No. 20-5: The petition for writ of certiorari was denied on 10/13/2020. [19-5237] [Entered: 10/14/2020 02:44 PM] |
LETTER [1866236] received from the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the United States notifying this court of the following activity in the case before it: A petition for writ of certiorari was filed and placed on the docket on 07/09/2020 as No. 20-5. [19-5237] [Entered: 10/14/2020 02:43 PM] |
MANDATE ISSUED to Clerk, U.S. District Court. [19-5237] [Entered: 03/31/2020 01:36 PM] |
CLERK'S ORDER [1827550] filed withholding issuance of the mandate. [19-5237] [Entered: 02/07/2020 10:04 AM] |
OPINION [1827549] filed PER CURIAM OPINION (Pages: 12). [19-5237] [Entered: 02/07/2020 10:02 AM] |
PER CURIAM JUDGMENT [1827548] filed that the first judgment of the District Court that the Members sustained their burden to show that they have standing to bring their claims be reversed and the case be remanded with instructions to dismiss the complaint; and the second judgment of the District Court that the Members have a cause of action and have stated a claim be vacated as moot, for the reasons in the accompanying opinion . Before Judges: Henderson, Tatel and Griffith. [19-5237] [Entered: 02/07/2020 09:57 AM] |
TRANSCRIPT [1824429] of oral argument [19-5237] [Entered: 01/16/2020 02:58 PM] |
ORAL ARGUMENT HELD before Judges Henderson, Tatel and Griffith. [19-5237] [Entered: 12/09/2019 01:02 PM] |
FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Hashim M. Mooppan, on behalf of Appellant Donald J. Trump (For Internal Use Only: Form is restricted to protect counsel's personal contact information) . [19-5237] (Mooppan, Hashim) [Entered: 12/02/2019 08:10 PM] |
FORM 72 submitted by arguing attorney, Elizabeth B. Wydra, on behalf of Appellees Karen Bass, Michael F. Bennet, Mr. Richard Blumenthal, Cory A. Booker, Maria Cantwell, Benjamin L. Cardin, Tom Carper, Mr. David N. Cicilline, James E. Clyburn, Steve Cohen, Christopher A. Coons, Catherine Cortez Masto, Ted Deutch, Tammy Duckworth, Richard J. Durbin, Kirsten E. Gillibrand, Kamala D. Harris, Martin Heinrich, Mazie K. Hirono, Steny H. Hoyer, Sheila Jackson Lee, Hakeem Jeffries, Henry C. Hank Johnson, Tim Kaine, Amy Klobuchar, Patrick J. Leahy, Ted Lieu, Zoe Lofgren, Edward J. Markey, Jeff Merkley, Chris Murphy, Patty Murray, Jerrold Nadler, Nancy Pelosi, Jamie Raskin, Jack Reed, Cedric L. Richmond, Linda T. Sanchez, Bernard Sanders, Brian Schatz, Eric Swalwell, Tom Udall, Chris Van Hollen, Elizabeth Warren, Mr. Sheldon Whitehouse and Ron Wyden (For Internal Use Only: Form is restricted to protect counsel's personal contact information) . [19-5237] (Wydra, Elizabeth) [Entered: 11/26/2019 01:33 PM] |
PER CURIAM ORDER [1817526] filed allocating oral argument time as follows: Appellant - 15 Minutes, Appellees - 15 Minutes. One counsel per side to argue. Directing parties to file Form 72 notice of arguing attorney by 12/02/2019. [19-5237] [Entered: 11/25/2019 06:00 PM] |
PER CURIAM ORDER [1815232] filed denying motion of Scholar Seth Barrett Tillman and the Judicial Education Project for appointment as amicus curiae in support of appellant, or in the alternative, motion for leave to participate at oral argument [ # 1809824-2 ]. Before Judges: Henderson, Tatel and Griffith. [19-5237] [Entered: 11/12/2019 11:22 AM] |
APPELLANT REPLY BRIEF [1814274] filed by Donald J. Trump [Service Date: 11/05/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,432 words. [19-5237] (Totaro, Martin) [Entered: 11/05/2019 08:03 AM] |
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE [1813420] filed by Jean M. Zachariasiewicz and co-counsel Anthony J. May on behalf of Amici Curiae for Appellee Matthew D. Adler, Cary Coglianese, Seth Davis, Mr. Frank Edmund Deale, Michael C. Dorf, Daniel Farber, Mr. Aziz Zahirul Huq, Jonathan S. Masur, John F. Preis, Joan E. Steinman and Brian Wolfman. [19-5237] (Zachariasiewicz, Jean) [Entered: 10/30/2019 08:48 PM] |
CORRECTED AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813390] filed by Administrative Law, Constitutional Law, and Federal Courts Scholars [Service Date: 10/30/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,168 Words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Zachariasiewicz, Jean) [Entered: 10/30/2019 03:51 PM] |
CORRECTED AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813357] filed by Niskanen Center, Republican Women for Progress, Donald B. Ayer, Trevor Potter, Mr. Laurence H. Tribe and J. W. Verret [Service Date: 10/30/2019 ] Length of Brief: 3,601 Words. [19-5237] (Wrabley, Colin) [Entered: 10/30/2019 02:09 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813191] filed by Harold H. Bruff, Peter M. Shane, Mr. Peter L. Strauss and Paul R. Verkuil [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 5,170 words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Mapes, Katharine) [Entered: 10/29/2019 05:03 PM] |
NOTICE [1813227] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Matthew D. Adler, Cary Coglianese, Seth Davis, Frank Deale, Michael C. Dorf, Daniel Farber, Aziz Huq, Jonathan S. Masur, John F. Preis, Joan Steinman, Brian Wolfman [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (May, Anthony) [Entered: 10/29/2019 09:25 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813222] filed by John Mikhail, Jack Rakove, Gautham Rao, Jed Shugerman and Simon Stern [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,481 words. [19-5237] (Lai, Erica) [Entered: 10/29/2019 06:59 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813207] filed by Former National Security Officials [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 5,289 words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Koh, Harold) [Entered: 10/29/2019 06:23 PM] |
NOTICE [1813206] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Former National Security Officials [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Koh, Harold) [Entered: 10/29/2019 06:20 PM] |
AMENDED AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813195] filed by Jean Zachariasiewicz [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,168 Words. [19-5237] (Zachariasiewicz, Jean) [Entered: 10/29/2019 05:33 PM] |
CONSENT AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813190] filed by The Niskanen Center, Republican Women for Progress, Donald B. Ayer, Trevor Potter, Laurence Tribe, and J.W. Verret [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 3,601 Words. [19-5237] (Wrabley, Colin) [Entered: 10/29/2019 05:02 PM] |
CONSENT NOTICE [1813186] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by The Niskanen Center, Republican Women for Progress, Donald B. Ayer, Trevor Potter, Laurence Tribe, and J.W. Verret [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Wrabley, Colin) [Entered: 10/29/2019 04:51 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813185] filed by Zachariasiewicz, Jean [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,168 Words. [19-5237] (Zachariasiewicz, Jean) [Entered: 10/29/2019 04:48 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1813121] filed by Former Government Ethics Officers Don Fox, Marilyn Glynn, Karen Kucik, Lawrence D. Reynolds, Amy Comstock Rick, Trip Rothschild, Richard M. Thomas, Harvey Wilcox, Leslie Wilcox [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 5,391 words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Singh, Tejinder) [Entered: 10/29/2019 02:28 PM] |
NOTICE [1813118] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Former Government Ethics Officers Don Fox, Marilyn Glynn, Karen Kucik, Lawrence D. Reynolds, Amy Comstock Rick, Trip Rothschild, Richard M. Thomas, Harvey Wilcox, and Leslie Wilcox [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Singh, Tejinder) [Entered: 10/29/2019 02:22 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1812988] filed by Scholars of Standing, Federal Jurisdiction, and Constitutional Law (listed in Appendix A of Brief) [Service Date: 10/29/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,427 Words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Deutsch, Ruthanne) [Entered: 10/29/2019 09:42 AM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLEE BRIEF [1812974] filed by Bipartisan Former Members of Congress [Service Date: 10/28/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,486 words. [19-5237]]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Dellinger, Walter) [Entered: 10/28/2019 10:06 PM] |
NOTICE [1812973] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Bipartisan Former Members of Congress [Service Date: 10/28/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Dellinger, Walter) [Entered: 10/28/2019 09:41 PM] |
NOTICE [1812965] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Scholars of Standing, Federal Jurisdiction, and Constitutional Law [Service Date: 10/28/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Deutsch, Ruthanne) [Entered: 10/28/2019 07:56 PM] |
NOTICE [1812860] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Simon Stern, Gautham Rao, Jack Rakove, John Mikhail and Jed Shugerman [Service Date: 10/28/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/28/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Lai, Erica) [Entered: 10/28/2019 02:41 PM] |
CLERK'S ORDER [1811864] filed scheduling oral argument on Monday, 12/09/2019. [19-5237] [Entered: 10/22/2019 10:20 AM] |
APPELLEE BRIEF [1812039] filed by Karen Bass, Michael F. Bennet, Mr. Richard Blumenthal, Cory A. Booker, Maria Cantwell, Benjamin L. Cardin, Tom Carper, Mr. David N. Cicilline, James E. Clyburn, Steve Cohen, Christopher A. Coons, Catherine Cortez Masto, Ted Deutch, Tammy Duckworth, Richard J. Durbin, Kirsten E. Gillibrand, Kamala D. Harris, Martin Heinrich, Mazie K. Hirono, Steny H. Hoyer, Sheila Jackson Lee, Hakeem Jeffries, Henry C. Hank Johnson, Tim Kaine, Amy Klobuchar, Patrick J. Leahy, Ted Lieu, Zoe Lofgren, Edward J. Markey, Jeff Merkley, Chris Murphy, Patty Murray, Jerrold Nadler, Nancy Pelosi, Jamie Raskin, Jack Reed, Cedric L. Richmond, Linda T. Sanchez, Bernard Sanders, Brian Schatz, Eric Swalwell, Tom Udall, Chris Van Hollen, Elizabeth Warren, Mr. Sheldon Whitehouse and Ron Wyden [Service Date: 10/22/2019 ] Length of Brief: 12,995 words. [19-5237] (Gorod, Brianne) [Entered: 10/22/2019 04:36 PM] |
AMICUS BRIEF [1810059] filed by Clark D. Cunningham and Jesse Egbert [Service Date: 10/08/2019 ] Length of Brief: 6,465 words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/09/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Dinerstein, Robert) [Entered: 10/08/2019 04:32 PM] |
NOTICE [1810058] of intention to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Not Applicable to this Party] filed by Clark D. Cunningham and Jesse Egbert [Service Date: 10/08/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/09/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Dinerstein, Robert) [Entered: 10/08/2019 04:30 PM] |
AMICUS FOR APPELLANT BRIEF [1810043] lodged by Judicial Education Project and Seth Barrett Tillman [Service Date: 10/08/2019 ] Length of Brief: 3,558 words. [19-5237]--[Edited 10/09/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED EVENT FROM FILED TO LODGED] (Ray, Robert) [Entered: 10/08/2019 03:36 PM] |
LETTER [1809979] sent regarding attorney membership to Carrie Severino for Judicial Education Project. Application for Admission due 11/07/2019. [19-5237] [Entered: 10/08/2019 12:21 PM] |
MOTION [1809824] to participate as amicus curiae [Disclosure Listing: Attached] filed by Judicial Education Project and Seth Barrett Tillman [Service Date: 10/07/2019 ] [19-5237]--[Edited 10/08/2019 by DJR--MODIFIED PARTY FILER] (Ray, Robert) [Entered: 10/07/2019 05:56 PM] |
JOINT APPENDIX [1808862] filed by Donald J. Trump. [Volumes: 2] [Service Date: 10/01/2019 ] [19-5237] (Totaro, Martin) [Entered: 10/01/2019 02:15 PM] |
APPELLANT BRIEF [1808858] filed by Donald J. Trump [Service Date: 10/01/2019 ] Length of Brief: 11,469 words. [19-5237] (Totaro, Martin) [Entered: 10/01/2019 02:10 PM] |
CLERK'S ORDER [1805579] filed considering the joint motion to establish briefing schedule [ # 1805324-2 ], setting briefing schedule: APPELLANT Brief due 10/01/2019. APPENDIX due 10/01/2019. APPELLEE Brief due on 10/22/2019. APPELLANT Reply Brief due 11/05/2019 [19-5237] [Entered: 09/09/2019 12:40 PM] |
JOINT UNOPPOSED MOTION [1805324] to establish briefing schedule filed by Donald J. Trump Length Certification: 41. [19-5237] (Revesz, Joshua) [Entered: 09/06/2019 11:44 AM] |
NOTICE OF APPEAL [1805141] seeking review of a decision by the U.S. District Court in 1:17-cv-01154-EGS filed by Donald J. Trump. Appeal assigned USCA Case Number: 19-5237. [19-5237] [Entered: 09/05/2019 01:33 PM] |
US CIVIL CASE docketed. [19-5237] [Entered: 09/05/2019 01:32 PM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.