Adobe Systems Inc. v. Macromedia Inc.
| Adobe Systems Inc. |
| Macromedia, Inc. |
| 1:2000cv00743 |
| August 10, 2000 |
| US District Court for the District of Delaware |
| Joseph J Farnan |
| Patent |
| 35 U.S.C. § 271 Patent Infringement |
| Both |
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on May 15, 2003. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
Filing 680
ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) that Clerk of the Court to destroy all Court Exhibits and Jury Notes (DI #539, & #590) taken by the jurors throughout the trial. copies to: cnsl. (afb)
|
| Filing 679 LETTER to Mary B. Graham from Clerk re: list of docs. to be returned pursuant to the Court's Ord. on 02/28/03. (afb) |
| Filing 678 LETTER to William J. Wade from Clerk re: docs. returned per DI #675. (afb) |
| Filing 677 LETTER to Clerk from Mary B. Graham claiming a list of sealed docs. filed by Adobe. (afb) |
| Filing 676 LETTER dtd. 3/6/03 from William J. Wade to Clerk's Office on behalf of deft. that deft. plans to claim sealed documents. (ssb) |
|
Filing 675
ORDER DIRECTING RETURN of SEALED DOCUMENTS to the Parties ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) (afb)
|
| Filing 674 Clerk's Taxation of Costs. Re: Pltf.'s Bill of Costs is denied as moot since parties have agreed to bear their own costs. (afb) |
| Final Report to Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks. Exit original(DI #2). (afb) |
| Adobe picked up trial exhibits in response to letter from Court (DI #673). (afb) |
| Macromedia picked up trial exhibits in response to letter from Court (DI #673). (afb) |
| Filing 673 Letter to parties dated 8/7/02 by Courtroom Deputy requesting parties claim trial exhibits by 8/22/02. (rwc) |
| Case closed per DI #672. (rwc) |
|
So Ordered granting [672-1] dismiss/dismissal stipulation with prejudice. (signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr.) Notice to all parties. (rwc)
|
| Filing 672 STIPULATION of dismissal with prejudice pursuant to Rule 41(a)(1) and proposed order. Parties to bear their own cost. (signed by all parties). (rwc) |
| Filing 671 Letter dated 7/24/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, on behalf of Adobe Systems, advising the Court that the parties are negotiating and request a brief continuance to 7/29/02 of the Stay entered on 6/25/02. (rwc) |
| Filing 670 Letter dated 6/25/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade confirming telephone conversation with chambers regarding result of stay issued. (rwc) |
| Filing 669 Letter dated 6/25/02 to parties by Judge Farnan encouraging parties to seek a business solution resolve pending disputes and advising that order [DI #666] cancelling status conference was issued; status report due 7/24/02 re: settlement. (rwc) |
|
Filing 668
ORDER - (1) denying [350-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent; (2) denying [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent; (3) denying [360-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent; (4) denying [363-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues; (5) denying [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents; (6) denying [402-1] cross motion for Summary Judgment on Notice and marking on the '998 and '969 Patents ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 667
ORDER - (1) denying as moot [542-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Willful Infringement and Macromedia's Defenses of Invalidity; (2) denying as moot [545-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Wilfulness; (3) denying as moot [547-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Invalidity of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528; (4) denying as moot [549-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages; (5) denying as moot [577-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. '998, '969 & '443; (6) denying as moot [579-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Willfulness & Damages; (7) denying as moot [581-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Infringement & Willful Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969; (8) denying as moot [583-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Validity of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969; (9) denying as moot [585-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Damages For Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 666
ORDER, terminated status conference set for 6/25/02 , all activity is Stayed pending settlement status report , and set Status Report deadline to 7/24/02 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 665 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc., re: Pltf's 1st set of Document Requests and Interrog., for the Trial on Macromedia's MX products, were served. (rwc) |
| Filing 664 STATUS REPORT dated 6/24/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade in anticipation of 6/25/02 status conference. Filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 663 Appendix to [DI #662] Bill of Cost. Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. Appending [662-1]. (rwc) |
| Filing 662 Bill of costs filed by Adobe Systems Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 661 Declaration of Mary B. Graham in support of [657-1] Adobe's Motion for Attorney's Fees and Other Related Expenses, Enhanced Damages and Interest. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 660 Declaration of Ian N. Feinberg in support of [657-1] Adobe's Motion for Attorney Fees and Other Related Expenses, Enhanced Damages and Interest. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 659 Declaration of Dr. Allen Kretz in support of [657-1] Adobe's Motion for Attorneys Fees and other Related Expenses, Enhanced Damages and Interest. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 658 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of [657-1] motion for Enhanced Damages, Attorney Fees and Other Related Expenses, and Interest - Answer Brief due 7/5/02. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 657 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Enhanced Damages, Attorney Fees and Other Related Expenses, and Interest Answer Brief due 7/5/02 re: [657-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 656 Corrected - Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [653-1] motion for Stay of Execution of Judgment RE: U.S. Patent No. - Answer Brief due 7/2/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 655 Letter dated 6/18/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade on behalf of Deft enclosing Revised Opening Brief [654-1] in Support of Motion to Stay Execution of Judgment. Previous version [654-1] contained typographical errors. (rwc) |
| Filing 654 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [653-1] motion for Stay of Execution of Judgment RE: U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 7/1/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 653 MOTION by Macromedia Inc., with Proposed Order for Stay of Execution of Judgment RE: U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 7/1/02 re: [653-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 652 Letter dated 6/17/02 to Clerk by William J. Wade enclosing original signature page to [DI #635] Declaration. (rwc) |
| Filing 651 Letter dated 6/17/02 to Clerk by William J. Wade enclosing original signature page to [DI #637] Declaration. (rwc) |
| Filing 650 Declaration of Charlene M. Morrow in support of [647-1] Macromedia's Motion for Enhanced Damages and Attorney's Fees. (SEALED) (rwc) |
| Filing 649 Declaration of William J. Wade in support of [647-1] Macromedia's Motion for Enhanced Damages and Attorney's Fees. (SEALED) (rwc) |
| Filing 648 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [647-1] motion for Enhanced Damages and Attorney Fees - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 647 MOTION by Macromedia Inc., with Proposed Order for Enhanced Damages and Attorney Fees Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [647-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 646 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [645-1] motion for Permanent Injunction RE: U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443, 5,151,998 & 5,204,969 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 645 MOTION by Macromedia Inc., with Proposed Order for Permanent Injunction RE: U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443, 5,151,998 & 5,204,969 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [645-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 644 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [643-1] Renewed motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law of Non-Invalidity of Asserted Claims in U.S. Patent No. 5,151,998 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 643 Renewed MOTION by Macromedia Inc., with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law of Non-Invalidity of Asserted Claims in U.S. Patent No. 5,151,998 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [643-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 642 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [641-1] Renewed motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law - Answer Brief due 6/28/02, and [641-2] Renewed motion for New Trial or Remittitur RE: Damages Relating to U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 641 Renewed MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law , or in the alternative, for New Trial or Remittitur RE: Damages Relating to U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [641-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [641-2] motion (rwc) Modified on 06/17/2002 |
| Filing 640 Declaration of of John C. Larosz in support of [638-1] Macromedia's Motion to Amend [614-1] Judgment. (rwc) |
| Filing 639 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [638-1] motion to Amend [614-1] judgment order to include Pre-Injunction Damages, Prejudgment Interest and Post-Judgment Interest U.S. Patent Nos. 5,467,443, 5,151,998, and 5,204,969 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 638 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order to Amend [614-1] judgment order to include Pre-Injunction Damages, Prejudgment Interest and Post-Judgment Interest RE: U.S. Patent Nos. 5,467,443, 5,151,998, and 5,204,969 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [638-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 637 Declaration of Scott Larrimer in support of [633-1] Macromedia's Rule 59(E) Motion RE: Laches & Estoppel. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 636 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: No original signature on [635-1] declaration of Michael J. Sackstedder. (rwc) |
| Filing 635 Declaration of Michael J. Sacksteder in support of Macromedia's [633-1] Rule 59(E) Motion Re: Laches and Estoppel. (rwc) |
| Filing 634 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in support of [633-1] Rule 59(E) motion RE: Laches and Equitable Estoppel - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 633 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order RE: Laches and Equitable Estoppel Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [633-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 632 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its Renewed [631-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law - Answer Brief due 6/28/02, and in support of Renewed [631-2] motion for New Trial RE: Invalidity of U.S. Patent 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 631 Renewed MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law , or for New Trial RE: Invalidity of U.S. Patent 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [631-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [631-2] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 630 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its Renewed [629-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law - Answer Brief due 6/28/02, and in support of, Renewed [629-2] motion for New Trial RE: Willfulness - Answer due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 629 Renewed MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law , or for New Trial RE: Willfulness Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [629-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [629-2] motion (rwc) Modified on 06/17/2002 |
| Filing 628 Appendix to Adobe's Opening Briefs in support of its Motions for Judgment as a Matter of Law, or in the alternative, Motions for New Trial. Appending [627-1] opening brief, [625-1] opening brief, [623-1] opening brief, [621-1] opening brief (rwc) |
| Filing 627 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of [626-1] renewed motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law - Answer Brief due 6/28/02, and in support of [626-2] motion for New Trial on Willfulness and Damages - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 626 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law , or, alternatively, for New Trial on Willfulness and Damages Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [626-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [626-2] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 625 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of [624-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02, and in support of, [624-2] motion for New Trial - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 624 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443 , or in the alternative, Motion for New Trial Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [624-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [624-2] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 623 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc., in support of [622-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the issues of and Invalidity of U.S. Patent Nos. 5,151,998 and 5,204,969 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02,and in support of, Motion [622-2] motion for New Trial - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 622 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the issues of Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patent Nos. 5,151,998 and 5,204,969 , or, in the alternative, Motion for New Trial Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [622-1] motion, Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [622-2] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 621 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc., in support of [620-1] motion for Permanent Injunction to Enjoin Macromedia's Infringement of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 6/28/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 620 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Permanent Injunction to Enjoin Macromedia's Infringement of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [620-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 619 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. to Correct Final Judgment Under FRCP, Rule 60(a), or in the alternative, under FRCP, Rule 59(e) Answer Brief due 6/28/02 re: [619-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 618 REPLY to [607-2] counter claim filed by Macromedia, Inc. Jury Trial Demanded. (rwc) Modified on 06/07/2002 |
| Filing 617 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [585-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Damages For Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (rwc) |
| Filing 616 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [583-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Validity of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (rwc) |
| Filing 615 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [581-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Infringement & Willful Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (rwc) |
| Filing 614 JUDGMENT for Macromedia Inc. against Adobe Systems Inc. for $3,653,198.00 plus costs by Jury Verdict of 5/10/02 (Trial #2) presided by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. (signed by Courtroom Deputy) copies to: cnsl. (rwc) |
| Filing 613 JUDGMENT for Adobe Systems Inc. against Macromedia Inc. for $2,822,280.00 plus costs by jury verdict of 5/2/02, presided by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. (signed by Courtroom Deputy) copies to: cnsl. (rwc) |
| JUDGMENT registered against defendant Macromedia Inc. for $2,822,280.00, (Jury Verdict 5/2/02 - Trial #1). (rwc) |
| JUDGMENT registered against plaintiff Adobe Systems Inc., for Jury Verdict of 5/10/02 (Trial #2) in amount of $3,653,198.00 + $1,262,395.00 = $4,915,593.00 total. (rwc) |
| JUDGMENT for Macromedia Inc. against Adobe Systems Inc. for $1,262,395.00 plus costs resulting from Jury Verdict of 5/10/02 (Trial #2), Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. presiding, copies to: cnsl. (rwc) |
| Filing 612 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [579-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Willfulness & Damages - Reply Brief due 5/31/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 611 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [577-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patents '998, '969 & '443 - Reply Brief due 5/31/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 610 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [530-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages Patent No. 5,546,528. (rwc) |
| Filing 609 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [547-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Invalidity of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 (rwc) |
| Filing 608 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [532-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Willfulness RE: U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528. (rwc) Modified on 05/24/2002 |
| Filing 607 Pltf's ANSWER to Counterclaims by Deft and Counterclaims for Declaratory Relief of Patent Invalidity [DI #566], filed by Adobe Systems. (rwc) |
|
Filing 606
ORDER, set Status Conference for 2:30 on 6/25/02 re: Deft's product, Flash MX Patent issues ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 605 Letter dated 5/20/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade on behalf of Deft, requesting that trial relating to infringement of Flash MX product be scheduled for late August and that a status conference be set to discuss pretrial matters. (rwc) |
| Filing 604 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc., in opposition to [542-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Willful Infringement and Macromedia's Defenses of Invalidity - Reply Brief due and in opposition to [579-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Willfulness & Damages - Reply Brief due 5/23/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 603 Letter dated 5/16/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, on behalf of Pltf., requesting the Court to schedule a 2 day trial in July 2002, re: infringement of Macromedia's Flash MX. (rwc) |
|
Filing 602
ORDER - Clerk to provide lunch to Jury for 5/10/02, (Trial #2). ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Finance Admin. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 601
ORDER - Clerk to provide lunch for jurors: 5/6/02 to 5/9/02,(Trial #2)( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Finance Admin. (rwc)
|
| Filing 600 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/10/02 (Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 599 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/9/02 (Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 598 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/8/02 (Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 597 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/7/02 (Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 596 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/6/02 (Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 595 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/3/02 (Trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 594 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 5/2/02 (Trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 593 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 4/30/02 (Trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 592 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 4/30/02 (Trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 591 TRIAL TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for dates of 4/29/02 (Trial #1). (rwc) Modified on 05/14/2002 |
| Filing 590 Jury notes filed re: Trial # 2 (5/6/02 - 5/10/02). (rwc) |
| Filing 589 Trial Exhibit list filed by Courtroom Deputy, re: Jury Trial #2 (5/6/02 - 5/10/02). (rwc) |
| Filing 588 JURY VERDICT for Macromedia Inc. (re: Trial #2). (rwc) |
| Filing 587 JURY INSTRUCTIONS (ssb) |
| Filing 586 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [585-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Damages For Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (Answer Brief due 5/24/02) (ssb) |
| Filing 585 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Damages For Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 ; pro. order (ssb) |
| Filing 584 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [583-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Validity of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (Answer Brief due 5/24/02) (ssb) |
| Filing 583 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Validity of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 ; pro. order (ssb) |
| Filing 582 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [581-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Infringement & Willful Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 (Answer Brief due 5/24/02) (ssb) |
| Filing 581 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law re Infringement & Willful Infringement of U.S. Patents '443, '998 & '969 ; pro. order (ssb) |
| Filing 580 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of [579-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Willfulness & Damages (Answer Brief due 5/24/02) (ssb) |
| Filing 579 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Willfulness & Damages (ssb) |
| Filing 578 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of [577-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patents '998, '969 & '443 (Answer Brief due 5/24/02) (ssb) |
| Filing 577 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Judgment as a Matter of Law on the Issues of Noninfringement and Invalidity of U.S. Patents '998, '969 & '443 (ssb) |
| Filing 576 LETTER dtd. 5/10/02 from William J. Wade to the Court listing modifications Macromedia requests be made to the special verdict form and jury instructions. (ssb) |
| Filing 575 LETTER dtd. 5/10/02 from Mary B. Graham to the Court listing trial exhibits Adobe offers into evidence. (ssb) |
| Jury trial held, (Day 5. Trial #2). Judge Farnan presiding. (rwc) |
| Filing 574 REPLY BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. IN SUPPORT OF [549-1] Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages (ssb) |
| Filing 573 REPLY BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. IN SUPPORT OF [545-1] Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Willfulness (ssb) |
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J.) - 4th day (2nd trial) (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
| Filing 572 LETTER dtd. 5/9/02 from Mary B. Graham to the Court regarding Adobe's issues/changes with respect to the jury instructions. (ssb) |
| Filing 571 LETTER dtd. 5/9/02 from William J. Wade to the Court on behalf of Macromedia requesting that trial exhibits PX 540, PX 562 & PX 422 be admitted into evidenece. (ssb) |
| Filing 570 LETTER dtd. 5/8/02 from William J. Wade to the Court encl. Macromedia's pro. special verdict form & interrogs. to the jury together with a disk. (ssb) |
| Filing 569 LETTER dtd. 5/8/02 from William J. Wade to the Court on behalf of Macromedia regarding the following trial matters: (1) testimony of Adrian Freed; (2) testimony of Dr. Phillips; & (3) Macromedia's videos & screen captures of products in operation should be admitted in evidence. (ssb) |
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J) - 3rd day (2nd trial) (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
|
Filing 568
ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) that lunch be furnished for 7 jurors & 1 CSO on 5/2/02 (copies to: financial clerk) (ssb)
|
|
Filing 567
ORDER denying pltf's [478-1] letter motion and permitting deft. to assert infringement of the '443, '998 and '969 Patents under the doctrine of equivalents ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (ssb)
|
| Filing 566 ANSWER to 2nd Amended Complaint by Macromedia Inc. and COUNTERCLAIMS w/ jury demand (ssb) |
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J.) - 2nd day (2nd trial) (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
|
So Ordered granting [561-1] motion for Edward H. Sikorski, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (ssb)
|
| Filing 565 JOINT STIPULATION Re: Damages Base in connection with the Trial on the '443, '998 & '969 Patents (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 564 LETTER dtd. 5/6/02 from William J. Wade to the Court on behalf of deft. listing evidence relating to the testimony of Dr. Phillips that has been excluded. (ssb) |
| Filing 563 LETTER dtd. 5/6/02 from Mary B. Graham on behalf of pltf. listing matters needing to be addressed by the Court. (ssb) |
| Filing 562 LETTER dtd. 5/6/02 from Mary B. Graham to the Court on behalf of pltf. requesting that deft's expert, Dr. Feiner, not be permitted to testify on matters not subject to his report. (ssb) |
| Filing 561 MOTION w/pro. order by Adobe Systems Inc. for Edward H. Sikorski, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice (ssb) |
|
Filing 560
TRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) as follows: 5/6/02 9:00 - 5:00; 5/7/02 12:30 - 6:00; 5/8/02 9:00 - 5:00; 5/9/02 9:00 - 5:00 (copies to: cnsl.) (ssb)
|
|
Filing 559
AMENDED ORDER ( signed on 5/3/02 by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) that the date of claim construction Order (D.I. 554) is amended to read "May 3, 2002." (Copies to: cnsl.) (ssb)
|
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J.) - 1st day (2nd trial) (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
| Filing 558 LETTER dtd. 5/3/02 from William J. Wade to the Court on behalf of Macromedia concerning claim terms in Court's mem op & order re claim construction. (ssb) |
| Filing 557 LETTER dtd. 5/3/02 from Mary B. Graham to the Court on behalf of Adobe requesting that the Court's mem op & order re claim construction be amended with regard to 8 terms. (ssb) |
|
Filing 556
ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) that the Clerk of the Court furnish lunch for 7 jurors on 4/29/02 through 5/1/02 (copy to: financial clerk) (ssb)
|
|
Filing 555
TRIAL MANAGEMENT ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) allocating 9 hours each to pltf. & deft for opening, direct & cross examinations and argument on evidence issues (SEE ORDER FOR FURTHER DETAILS) copies to: cnsl. (ssb)
|
|
Filing 554
ORDER ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) construing terms & phrases in the '998 & '969 patents (SEE ORDER FOR DETAILS) copies to: cnsl. (ssb)
|
| Filing 553 MEMORANDUM OPINION re claim construction ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. copies to: cnsl. (ssb) Modified on 05/06/2002 |
| Deadline updated: set Telephone Conference (3rd pretrial conference) for 12:30 on 5/3/02 (Calendar Notice) (ssb) |
| Conference held (Farnan, J.) re 2nd trial on Macromedia's patents (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J.) - Day 4 (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service)` (ssb) |
| Filing 552 Trial Exhibit list, filed by Courtroom Deputy. (re: Trial #1, 4/29/02 - 5/2/02). (rwc) |
| Filing 551 JURY VERDICT for Adobe Systems Inc. (re: Trial #1 4/29/02 - 5/2/02). (rwc) |
| Filing 550 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [549-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages - Answer Brief due 5/16/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 549 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages Answer Brief due 5/16/02 re: [549-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 548 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [547-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Invalidity of U.S. Patent 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 5/16/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 547 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Invalidity of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 5/16/02 re: [547-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 546 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [545-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Wilfulness - Answer Brief due 5/16/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 545 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Wilfulness Answer Brief due 5/16/02 re: [545-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 544 Memorandum of Points and Authorities, Filed by Adobe Systems Inc., in support of Adobe's [542-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Willful Infringement and Macromedia's Defenses of Invalidity, as well as Adobe's Opposition to Macromedia's Motions [530-1 & 532-1] on Willful Infringement and Damages - Answer Brief due 5/16/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 543 Proposed Order filed by Adobe Systems Inc. re: Adobe's [542-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law on Willful Infringement and Macromedia's Defenses of Invalidity, as well as proposed order for Adobe's Opposition to Macromedia's Motions [530-1 & 532-1] on Willful Infringement and Damages. (rwc) |
| Filing 542 Adobe Systems Inc.s Opposition to Macromedia's Motions: [532-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Willfulness - Reply Brief due 5/9/02, [530-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages - Reply Brief due 5/9/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 541 Letter dated 5/2/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade, on behalf of Deft., re: (1) Adobe's objections to showing Video Operation oof Go PenPoint System; (2)Adobe's objections to the Microsoft documents, and Objections to Holland Article PX 127. (rwc) |
| Filing 540 Final Jury instructions (Trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 539 Jury notes filed re: Trial # 1 (4/29/02 - 5/2/02). (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Jury trial held (Farnan, J.) - Day 3 (Ct. Rptr. Hawkins Reporting Service) (ssb) |
| Filing 538 Letter dated 5/1/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham on behalf of Pltf., re: correction to proposed Jury Instruction 1.3. (trial #1). (rwc) |
| Filing 537 Letter dated 5/1/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade on behalf of Deft., re: (1) Adobe's objections to Macromedia's exhibits; (2) Objections to Adobe's demonstartive exhibits; (3) Objections to Adobe's trial exhibits; and (4) Objections to Adobe's deposition designations. (rwc) |
| Filing 536 Letter dated 5/1/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham on behalf of Pltf., re; attached Expert Report on Infringement of Flash MX, dated 3/28/02, of Richard L. Phillips. (rwc) |
| Filing 535 Letter dated 5/1/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, on behalf of Pltf., re: update on jury instructions (1st trial). (rwc) |
| Jury trial held (Day 2), Judge Farnan presiding. (Ct Rptr Heather/Jennifer of Hawkins Reporting). (rwc) |
| Filing 534 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade on behalf of Macromedia, re: "beta product." (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 533 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [532-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Willfulness - Answer Brief due 5/14/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 532 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Willfulness Answer Brief due 5/14/02 re: [532-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 531 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [530-1] motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages - Answer Brief due 5/14/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 530 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Judgment as a Matter of Law RE Damages Answer Brief due 5/14/02 re: [530-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 529 Letter dated 4/30/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade, re: evidentiary issues raised outside the presence of the jury. (rwc) |
| Filing 528 TRANSCRIPT (w/3.5 floppy disk) filed by Hawkins Reporting Service re: jury trial for dates of 4/29/02 (for Day 1). (rwc) |
| Deadline updated per calendar notice; set 2nd Jury Trial for 9:00 a.m. on 5/6/02 (rwc) |
|
Filing 527
Trial Scheduling ORDER, for 4/30/02 & 5/1/02.( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Jury trial held,(Day 1). Judge Farnan presiding. (Ct Rptrs: Heather/Dale from Hawkins Reporting Services). (rwc) |
| Filing 526 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade with attached deposition designations for the 4/29/02 trial. (rwc) |
| Filing 525 Letter dated 4/29/02 to Docket Clerk by secretary for William J. Wade enclosing "confidential" envelopes as requested for [DI#'s 523 & 524]. (rwc) |
| Filing 524 Letter dated 4/29/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade, re: Doctrine of Equivalents. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 523 Letter dated 4/29/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 522 Joint STIPULATION with proposed order, Re: Damages Base in Connection with the 4/29/02 Trial of the '528 Patent. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 521 Letter dated 4/29/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, enclosing proposed jury instruction on "Absence of Witness." (rwc) |
|
Filing 520
ORDER - granting in part, denying in part [391-1] motion in Limine 1-9: (1) Adobe's Motion No. 1 - Broz's Statement is GRANTED; (2) Adobe's Motion No.2 - Anticompetitive Reasons is GRANTED; (3) Adobe's Motion No. 3 - Johnston's Resignation is GRANTED; (4) Adobe's Motion No. 4 - Adobe's Delay is DENIED; (5) Adobe's Motion No. 5 - Claims of Infringement of the '597 Patent is GRANTED; (6) Adobe's Motion No. 6 - Adobe's Cease and Desist Letter is GRANTED; (7) Adobe's Motion No. 7 - Adobe's Website is DENIED; (8) Adobe's Motion No. 8 - Excel 5.0 and IBM Application is DENIED; and (9) Adobe's Motion No. 9 - Expert Testimony as to Legal Standards is GRANTED. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 519
ORDER (1) denying [336-1] Macromedia's Letter Motion Seeking Foreign Sales; (2) denying as moot,[390-2] Adobe's corresponding Motion in Limine to exclude such evidence; and (3) denying as moot,[500-1] Adobe's Further Motions in Limine for the '528 Trial to Preclude Belated Evidence Offered by Macromedia its Expert Dr. Foley ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 518
ORDER - (1) denying [370-1] motion in limine to exclude improper opinion testimony by fact witnesses and uncorroborated fact testimony regarding the prior art; (2) granting as moot, [372-1] motion Limine to exclude evidence not timely disclosed; (3) denying [374-1] motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony Of Richard Phillips; (4) granting [376-1] motion in Limine to Exclude evidence that is irrelevant under Rule 401 and/or unduly prejudicial, confusing or misleading under Rule 403; (5) granting [378-1] motion in Limine to Exclude Expert and supporting evidence not disclosed in Adobe Systems, Inc.'s expert reports; (6) denying [380-1] motion in Limine To exclude evidence of Adobe's late-obtained opinion letters; (7) denying [382-1] motion in Limine To exclude hearsay ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 517
Trial Management ORDER - (1)The Parties are alloted 7.5 hrs each; (2) Pltf shall present its prima facie case, Deft shall present its defense; (3) Examination of witnesses will be conducted in accordance with FRCP 611(a); (4) Courtroom demeanor, (see Order for details). ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 516 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [500-1] motion in Limine for the '528 Trial to Preclude Belated Evidence Offered by Macromedia and its Expert Dr. Foley (rwc) |
| Filing 515 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, advising the Court that Deft is allegedly making another product that literally infringes the claims of the '528 patent-Dreamweaver MX. Pltf requests to add product to list of accused products for trial. (rwc) |
| Filing 514 Amendments from the File History of Patent No. 5,204,969. Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 513 Amendments from the File History of Patent No. 5,467,443. Filed by Adobe Systems, Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 512 Amendments from the File History of No. 5,151,998. Filed by Adobe Systems, Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 511 Charts Summarizing Amendments to the File Histories of Macromedia Patents in Suit, U.S. Patent Nos. '443, '998 & '969. Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 510 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham advising the Court that Plaintiff is enclosing 3 charts for filing summarizing the prosecution history and cited amendments for the '998, '969 & '443 patents. (rwc) |
| Filing 509 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by William Wade enclosing copies of [DI #486 & 484] along with 3.5 floppy disk for 5/6/02 trial. (rwc) |
| Filing 508 Letter dated 4/26/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham on behalf of Pltf, re: Macromedia's letter dated 4/24/02 raises new issue that notice of alleged infringement and date for accrual of damages for '998/'969 patents is not March 1997. Pltf asserts the operative date of May 28, 1999. as alleged (rwc) |
|
Filing 507
MEMORANDUM ORDER denying [343-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 506 Appendix of Documentary Evidence in Support of Macromedia, Inc.'s Opposition/Answer Brief in Opposition to Adobe's Further Motions in Limine. Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [505-1] answer brief (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 505 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [500-1] motion in Limine for the '528 Trial to Preclude Belated Evidence Offered by Macromedia and its Expert Dr. Foley - Reply Brief due 5/2/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 504 Letter dated 4/25/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, on behalf of Pltf., enclosing 3/5 floppy disk requested by chambers for revising Jury Instructions. (rwc) |
| Filing 503 TRANSCRIPT filed by Hawkins Reporting Service for Pretrial Conference held on 4/24/02 at 1:30 p.m. (Ct Rptr Heather/Hawkins). (rwc) |
| 2nd Pre-trial conference held before Judge Farnan. Motions for Summary Judgment and Laches will be denied, Memorandum Orders to issue. Oral trial management instructions provided to counsel. (rwc) Modified on 04/26/2002 |
| Filing 502 Letter dated 4/24/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade representing Deft's. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 501 Letter dated 4/24/02 to Clerk by Mary B. Graham representing Pltf., enclosing 2 envelopes for sealing [DI #500] Further Motions in Limine. (rwc) |
| Filing 500 MOTION - Adobe's Further Motions (with attachments A-F) in Limine for the '528 Trial to Preclude Belated Evidence Offered by Macromedia and its Expert Dr. Foley filed by Adobe Systems, Inc. Answer Brief due 5/8/02 re: [500-1] motion (SEALED). (rwc) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 499 Macromedia's Proposed Changes to the Joint Proposed Jury instructions for the '528 Patent, filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 498 Macromedia's Preliminary Proposed Jury instructions with Respect to the '528 Patent (with 3.5 floppy disk attached), filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 497 Letter dated 4/24/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade enclosing revised sets of Macromedia's Proposed Jury Instructions with proposed changes, and 3.5 floppy disk. (rwc) |
| Filing 496 Letter dated 4/24/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, advising the Court that Tab A of [DI #485] does not contain latest objections by Adobe. Adobe proposes, rather than replacing Tab A, that which is being called proposed Adobe instructions in Tab A, should be considered only as alternatives. (rwc) |
| Filing 495 Letter dated 4/23/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, enclosing Figure 9 of the '443 patent, and discussing issue of labeling for Figure 9. (rwc) |
| Filing 494 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT filed by Adobe Systems Inc. amending [15-1] amended complaint, [1-1] complaint, (as granted during 4/3/02 Scheduling Conference, amending prayer for relief re: attorney fees and deleting allegations as to '597 patent). (Answer to 2nd Amended complaint due 5/3/02 for Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 493 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [422-1] motion for Attorney Fees and Costs incurred in defending pltf's infringement claim on '597 patent (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 492 Appendix of Documentary Evidence in support of [DI #491] Macromedia's Revised Brief in support of its Claim Construction for U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443. Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [491-1] reply brief (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 491 Revised Reply Brief filed in support of Macromedia's Claim Construction for U.S. Patent No. 5,467,443. Filed by Macromedia Inc. (Revising [DI #'s 243 & 470]). (rwc) |
| Filing 490 Letter dated 4/19/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade in response to Adobe's opening letter memorandum of 4/16/02 re: application of Doctrine of Equivalents to '443, '998, and '969 patents. (with attached Exhibits A-E). (rwc) |
| Filing 489 Joint Proposed Jury instructions for the '528 Trial, filed by Adobe Systems Inc., Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 488 Proposed Preliminary Jury instructions for the First Trial ('528 Patent), filed jointly by Adobe Systems Inc., Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 487 Letter dated 4/19/02 to Clerk by William J. Wade requesting substitution of signature page to Declaration [DI #481] of Eric Wittman. (substitution made). (rwc) |
| Filing 486 Proposed Amended Joint pre-trial order Regarding U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528. Filed by Adobe Systems Inc., Macromedia Inc. (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 485 Proposed Agreed upon and Disputed Preliminary Jury instructions with Objections for Trial Commencing May 6, 2002 (Macromedia Version - Tab A), (Adobe Version - Tab B). Filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 484 Proposed Agreed upon and Disputed Jury instructions with Objections for Trial Commencing May 6, 2002, filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 483 Proposed Joint Amended pre-trial order regarding U.S. Patent Nos. 5,467,443, 5,151,998 & 5,204,969, filed by Adobe Systems Inc., Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 482 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. re: no original signature on [DI #481]. (corrected 4/19/02). (rwc) |
| Filing 481 Declaration of Eric Wittman in support of [480-2] Macromedia's Opposition to Adobe's Motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement of U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528. (rwc) |
| Filing 480 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to Adobe's [472-1] motion for Summary Judgment that Flash MX Infringes U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 - Reply Brief due 4/25/02 (rwc) |
| Filing 479 Plaintiff's Answer Brief in Opposition to [DI #470] Defendant's Revised Claim Construction Brief for the '443 Patent, Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 478 Letter dated 4/17/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham, Esq. (SEALED). (rwc) |
|
Filing 477
ORDER, set 2nd Pretrial Conference for 1:30 p.m. on 4/24/02 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 476 Letter dated 4/16/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade requesting an extension to 4/18/02 for Defendant to file their Reply Brief re: Supplemental Claim Construction in Connection with the '528 patent; and Motion [464-1] for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement of '528 Patent by Flash MX. (rwc) |
| Filing 475 Letter dated 4/16/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham advising the Court that Pltf will not introduce survey evidence that is the subject of Deft's Motion in Limine No. 8; therefore, Pltf will not be filing an Answer Brief. (rwc) |
| Filing 474 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in opposition to [422-1] motion for Attorney Fees and Costs incurred in defending pltf's infringement claim on '597 patent - Reply Brief due 4/22/02). (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 473 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [472-1] motion for Summary Judgment that Flash MX Infringes U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 - Answer Brief due 4/29/02 (SEALED). (rwc) |
| Filing 472 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. for Summary Judgment that Flash MX Infringes U.S. Patent No. 5,546,528 Answer Brief due 4/29/02 re: [472-1] motion (rwc) |
| Filing 471 Proposed Order Re: Macromedia's Revised Claim Construction Briefing, filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 470 Revised Opening Brief in support of Macromedia's Claim Construction for U.S. Patent No.: 5,467,443, revising [DI# 243] Filed by Macromedia Inc. (rwc) |
| Filing 469 Letter dated 4/12/02 to Judge Farnan by Mary B. Graham requesting that Adobe be granted an extension until 4/15/02 to reply to [DI# 461]. (rwc) |
| Filing 468 MEMORANDUM OPINION re: meaning of phrase "set(s) of information" in the '528 patent [DI#467]. (signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc) |
|
Filing 467
ORDER establishing the meaning the phrase "set(s) of information" in the '528 patent, "is a collection of tools or commands used to perform operations on a document."( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
|
Filing 466
ORDER Macromedia shall file revised opening brief in support of its claim construction of '443 patent by 4/12/02; Adobe shall file revised answer brief by 4/16/02; Macromedia shall file a revised reply brief by 4/19/02. Adobe shall file an answer brief to Macromedia's supplemental claim construction brief [DI#461} re: '528 patent by 4/12/02; Macromedia shall file reply brief by 4/16/02. Claim construction is anticipated for 4/22/02 or 4/23/02. The issue of whether Macromedia' Flash MX infringes the '528 patent will be tried separately in June/July 2002. Macromedia's Sur-Reply re: Doctrine of Equivalents in support of its opposition to Adobe's motions for summary judgment of the invalidity and noninfringement of patents: '998, '969 and '443, [DI#456] shall be stricken. Adobe shall file opening letter memorandum re: application of Doctrine of Equivalents to patents: '998, '969 and '443, by 4/16/02; Macromedia shall file reply letter memorandum by 4/19/02. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: cnsl. (rwc)
|
| Filing 464 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringment of '528 Patent by Flash MX and Request for expedited briefing Answer Brief due 4/24/02 re: [464-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 463 CORRECTED Attachment 4 to Appendix to Brief Filed (UNDER SEAL) by Macromedia Inc. (correcting attachment 4 of D.I. 458 appendix) (dlk) Modified on 04/10/2002 |
| Filing 461 Corrected Supplemental Claim Construction Brief by Macromedia Inc. RE: '528 Patent and Brief in support of Motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement, Request for Expedited Briefing. (dlk) |
| Filing 460 CORRECTED(Sur)Reply Brief Filed (UNDER SEAL) by Macromedia Inc. in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent (Correcting D.I. 457) (dlk) |
| Filing 459 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 4/9/02 by William J. Wade,Esq. RE: On 4/8/02 Macromedia filed documents that should have contained color images, but did not. Enclosed are corrected copies to replace those documents. Note that Appendix we are replacing only attachment 4 thereto. (dlk) |
| Filing 465 Letter dated 4/3/02 to Charlene M. Morrow, Esq., from Ilona K. Kniss enclosing erratas for transcripts of Richard Phillips taken on 3/5/02 and 3/6/02. (rwc) |
| Filing 462 Macromedia's Supplemental CORRECTED Consolidated [Proposed] Order RE: Claim Construction (dlk) |
| Filing 458 (UNDER SEAL)Appendix of Documentary Evidence by Macromedia Inc. in Support of Macromedia'a Supplemental Claim Construction Brief RE: '52 patent (D.I. 455) and Brief in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement, Request for Expedited Briefing. (dlk) Modified on 04/10/2002 |
| Filing 457 (SUR)Reply Brief Filed (UNDER SEAL) by Macromedia Inc. in suuport of its [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent (dlk) Modified on 04/10/2002 |
| Filing 456 Sur-Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. RE: Doctrine of Equivalents in support of its opposition to Adobe's [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents, [360-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 455 Macromedia's Supplemental Claim Construction Brief RE: U.S. Patent No. '528 (Supplementing [292-1] brief) and Brief in support of Motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement, Request for Expedited Briefing Inc. (dlk) Modified on 04/10/2002 |
| Filing 454 Letter to the Court dated 4/5/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. (Filed Under Seal) (dlk) |
| Filing 453 Letter to the Court dated 4/5/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Four outstanding discovery issues on which the parties could not agree. (dlk) |
| Filing 452 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's responses and Supplemental Response to Deft's 1st set of interrogs No. 1 (dlk) |
| Filing 451 Re-NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Jeremy Clark on 4/10/02 at 9:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 450 Declaration (SEALED) of Richard L. Phillips in support of Adobe's Opposition Brief(D.I. 305)(D.I. 408) to Macromedia's Claim Construction of Patent '998 and '969(Sound Editing) (dlk) Modified on 04/09/2002 |
| Filing 449 Letter dated 4/3/02 to Judge Farnan by William J. Wade, advising the Court that excepts from the deposition of Richard I. Phillips submitted on 3/27/02 to replace the rough transcript of [DI#414] do not match those submitted on 3/18/02 [DI#389]. The corrected pages are attached as [DI#449 Exhibit A SEALED]. (rwc) |
| Pre-trial conference held 4/3/02 (Farnan,J) Ct. Rptr-Carol, Hawkins Reporting. Ct. Reserves decision on the summary judgment motions until briefing is completed. There will be 2 separate trials(re:claim construction) with 2 juries in succession. (dlk) |
| Filing 448 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [360-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent. (SEALED). (rwc) Modified on 04/09/2002 |
| Filing 447 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents. (rwc) |
| Filing 446 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [363-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues, and [402-2] cross-motion for Summary Judgment on Notice and Marking on the '998 and '969 patents.(rwc) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 445 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Jeremy Clark on 4/10/02 at 9:00 a.m. (rwc) |
| Filing 444 DECLARATION of Michael J. Sacksteder in support of D.I. 440 (ssb) |
| Filing 443 APPENDIX to Reply Briefs Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [440-1], [441-1] and [442-1] reply briefs (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 442 REPLY BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in supp. of [343-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 441 REPLY BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in supp. of [350-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent (ssb) |
| Filing 440 REPLY Filed by Macromedia Inc. to pltf's pro. untimely oppos. to deft's [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent (ssb) |
| Filing 439 DECLARATION of Virginia K. DeMarchi in supp. of D.I. 438 (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 438 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. in supp. of [437-1] Motion in Limine No. 8 To Exclude Survey Evidence; Answer Brief due 4/15/02 (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 437 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. in Limine No. 8 To Exclude Survey Evidence ; Pro. order; Answer Brief due 4/15/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 436 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent; Reply Brief due 4/8/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 435 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [378-1] motion in Limine No. 5 to exclude expert opinions and supporting evidence not disclosed in pltf's expert reports; Reply Brief due 4/8/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 434 RESPONSE Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [374-1] motion in Limine No. 3 to exclude testimony of Richard Phillips; Reply Brief due 4/8/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 433 Jury instructions - agreed upon & disputed with objections (ssb) |
| Filing 432 PRO. JOINT PRETRIAL ORDER (ssb) |
| Filing 431 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [382-1] motion in Limine No. 7 to exclude hearsay evidence; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 430 RESPONSE Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [380-1] motion in Limine No. 6 to exclude evidence of pltf's late-obtained opinion letters; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 429 DECLARATION of Adrian Freed in support of pltf's oppos. to deft's motion in limine No. 4 (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 428 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [376-1] motion in Limine No. 4 to exclude evidence under Rule 401 and/or 403; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 427 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [372-1] motion in Limine No 2 to exclude evidence not timely disclosed in discovery; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 426 OPPOSITION Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to deft's [370-1] motion in Limine No. 1 to preclude testimony by pltf's lay witnesses; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 425 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. pursuant to 35 U.S.C. Section 282 (ssb) |
| Filing 424 APPENDIX to Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [423-1] opening brief (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 423 OPENING BRIEF Filed by Macromedia Inc. to [422-1] motion for Attorney Fees and Costs incurred in defending pltf's infringement claim on '597 patent; Answer Brief due 4/12/02 (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 422 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Attorney Fees and Costs incurred in defending pltf's infringement claim on '597 patent ; Answer Brief due 4/12/02 (ssb) |
| Filing 421 DECLARATION of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Deft's oppositions to Pltf's motions in liminie (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 420 OPPOSITION Filed by Macromedia Inc. to Pltf's [391-1] motion in Limine to exclude evidence under 35 U.S.C. Sec. 271(f); Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 419 APPENDIX to Opposition Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [418-1] opposition (SEALED) (ssb) |
| Filing 418 OPPOSITION Filed by Macromedia Inc. to Pltf's [391-1] motion in Limine 1-9; Reply Brief due 4/5/02 (SEALED) (ssb) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [407-1] stipulation and order dismissing claim and counterclaim regarding U. S. Patent no. '597 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 417 Letter to the Court dated 3/27/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. (UNDER SEAL) (dlk) |
| Filing 416 Letter to the Court dated 3/27/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed Original signature page to the Declaration of James D.Foley, Ph.D. in Support of Deft's Motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of Patent '528 (dlk) |
| Filing 415 Letter to the Court dated 3/27/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: original signature pages to Declarations of Virginia DeMarchi, Dr. Curtis Roads, and Professor Steven K. Feiner in Support of Macromedia's Opposition to Adobe's Motions for Summary Judgment. (dlk) |
| Filing 414 Letter to the Court dated 3/27/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached excerpts from transcript deposition of Richard Phillips for the Court's consideration. (dlk) |
| Filing 413 Declaration of Adrian Freed(SEALED) in support of Adobe's opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment on Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent (dlk) Modified on 03/28/2002 |
| Filing 412 Answer Brief Filed (SEALED) by Adobe Systems Inc. opposing [350-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent - Reply Brief due 4/2/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 411 Appendix to Declaration of Dr. Richard L. Phillips Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. and in support of Adobe's [409-1] answer brief (dlk) |
| Filing 410 Declaration of Richard L. Phillips in support of Adobe's answering brief opposing summary judgment of invalidity of '528 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 409 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. opposing [343-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent - Reply Brief due 4/2/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 408 Corrected Opposition Filed(SEALED) by Macromedia Inc. to Adobe's [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents(Correcting D.I. 401) - Reply Brief due 4/2/02 (dlk) Modified on 03/28/2002 |
| Filing 407 STIPULATION with proposed order that Parties agree that Adobe's Claim for infringement of the '597 Patent against Macromedia's Flash products, versions Flash 4.0 and 5.0, is hereby dismissed with prejudice. Macromedia's counterclaim that the '597 Patent be judged invalid, unenforceable, and/or not infringed is hereby dismissed with prejudice, but with no surrender of any right to contest the validity, enforceability or non-infringement of the '597 Patent in any subsequent action. (dlk) |
| Filing 406 Letter(SEALED) to the Court by Mary B. Graham, Esq. (dlk) |
| Filing 402 CROSS MOTION (UNDER SEAL) by Macromedia Inc. for Summary Judgment on Notice and marking on the '998 and '969 Patents Opening brief due 4/8/02 re: [363-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues (dlk) |
| Filing 405 Declaration (SEALED) of Linda Grant in support of Deft's Opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment on Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues. (dlk) |
| Filing 404 Declaration of David Simmons in Support of Deft's Opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment on Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues (dlk) |
| Filing 403 Declaration of Norman K. Meyrowitz in support of Deft's Opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment on Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement issues (dlk) |
| Filing 402 Answer Brief Filed(SEALED) by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [363-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues - Reply Brief due 4/1/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 401 Answer Brief Filed(SEALED) by Macromedia Inc. in Opposition to [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents - Reply Brief due 4/1/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 400 Declaration (SEALED)of Professor Steven K. Feiner in support of Deft's Opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity and Non-Infringement of '443 patent. (dlk) |
| Filing 399 Declaration Volume 2 (SEALED)of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Macromedia, Inc.'s Opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment (dlk) |
| Filing 398 Declaration Volume 1 (SEALED) of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Deft's opposition to Pltf's Motion for Summary Judgment (dlk) |
| Filing 397 Declaration (SEALED)of Dr. Curtis Roads in support of Macromedia's Opposition to Adobe's Motions for Summary Judgment (dlk) |
| Filing 396 Answer Brief Filed (SEALED) by Macromedia Inc. in Opposition to [360-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent - Reply Brief due 4/1/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 395 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's 2ns supplemental response to Deft's 1st set of Interrogs No. 14. (dlk) |
| Filing 394 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and 10th Supp. Responses to Pltf's 1st set of Interrogs Nos. 16 and 23; and Deft's 3rd Supp. Responses to Pltf's 3rd Set of Interrogs Nos. 35 and 55. (dlk) |
| Filing 393 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Notice of Deposition of Charles Geschke and Daniel Brown (dlk) |
| Filing 392 Letter to the Court dated 3/19/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed is the original executed signature page to the Declaration of Virginia DeMarchi filed 3/15/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 391 MOTIONS (SEALED) by Adobe Systems Inc. in Limine 1-9; Answer Brief due 4/1/02 re: [391-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/05/2002 |
| Filing 390 MEMORANDUM by Adobe Systems Inc. in opposition to [336-1] Letter Motion of 3/1/02 seeking Foreign Sales Allegedly Relevant under 35 U.S.C. 271(f) and Adobe's Corresponding Motion in Limine to Exclude such evidence (dlk) Modified on 03/20/2002 |
| Filing 389 Letter to the Court dated 3/18/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: submits excerpt from the deposition testimony of Richard L. Phillips, Adobe's technical expert, which was not available at the time of briefing, for the Court's consideration in connection with claim construction. (dlk) |
| Filing 388 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D.I. 387 (dlk) |
| Filing 387 Declaration of Virginia K. Demarchi insupport of Macromedia's Motions in Limine Nos. 1-7- Notice of deficiency sent-no original signature (dlk) |
| Filing 386 Appendix Volume 3 (SEALED) to Briefs Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [383-1] opening brief, [381-1] opening brief, [379-1] opening brief, [377-1] opening brief, [375-1] opening brief, [373-1] opening brief, [371-1] opening brief (dlk) |
| Filing 385 Appendix Volume 2 (SEALED) to Briefs Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [383-1] opening brief, [381-1] opening brief, [379-1] opening brief, [377-1] opening brief, [375-1] opening brief, [373-1] opening brief, [371-1] opening brief (dlk) |
| Filing 384 Appendix Volume 1 (SEALED)of Documentary Evidence to Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [383-1] opening brief, [381-1] opening brief, [379-1] opening brief, [377-1] opening brief, [375-1] opening brief, [373-1] opening brief, [371-1] opening brief (dlk) Modified on 03/19/2002 |
| Filing 383 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [382-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 382 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine To exclude hearsay evidence Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re: [382-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 381 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [380-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 380 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine To exclude evidence of Adobe's late-obtained opinion letters Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re: [380-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 379 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [378-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 378 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine to Exclude Expert opinions and supporting evidence not disclosed in Adobe Systems, Inc.'s expert reports Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re [378-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 377 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [376-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 376 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine to Exclude evidence that is irrelevant under Rule 401 and/or unduly prejudicial, confusing or misleading under Rule 403 Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re: [376-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 375 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [374-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) Modified on 03/19/2002 |
| Filing 374 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine to Exclude Testimony Of Richard Phillips Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re: [374-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 373 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [372-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) Modified on 03/19/2002 |
| Filing 372 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine to exclude evidence not timely disclosed in discovery Answer Brief Due 3/29/02 re: [372-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 371 Opening Brief(SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [370-1] motion in Limine - Answer Brief due 3/29/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 370 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order in Limine to exclude improper opinion testimony by fact witnesses and uncorroborated fact testimony regarding the prior art Answer Brief due 3/29/02 re: [370-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 04/24/2002 |
| Filing 369 Letter to Clerk of the Court dated 3/15/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed is the original executed signture page to the Declaration of Darryl M. Woo(D.I. 353) (dlk) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [339-1] motion for Heather N. Mewes to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 368 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and 3rd Supplemental Response to Pltf's Interrog No. 23 (dlk) |
| Filing 367 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's Responses and Supplemental Response to Deft's 1st set of Interrogs Nos. 1 & 16; and Pltf's Supplemental Response to Deft's 4th set of Interrogs No. 51. (dlk) |
| Filing 366 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of its [365-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents - Answer Brief due 3/26/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 365 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '998 and '969 patents Answer Brief due 3/26/02 re: [365-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 364 Opening Brief (SEALED) Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of its [363-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues - Answer Brief due 3/26/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 363 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Summary Judgment of Certain Laches, Damages and Willful Infringement Issues Answer Brief due 3/26/02 re: [363-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 362 Declaration(SEALED) of Dr. Richard L. Phillips in support of Adobe's Motion for Summary Judgment (dlk) |
| Filing 361 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of its [360-1] motion for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent - Answer Brief due 3/26/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 360 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Summary Judgment of the Invalidity and Noninfringement of '443 patent Answer Brief due 3/26/02 re: [360-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 359 Letter to the Court dated 3/12/02 by Mary G. Graham, Esq. RE: addressing discovery issues in response to Deft's submission by letter dated 3/1/02 of additional extrinsic evidence. (dlk) |
| Filing 358 Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads in support of Deft's Motion for Summary Judgment of Infringement of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 patent. (dlk) |
| Filing 357 Opening Brief (SEALED) Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent - Answer Brief due 3/25/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 356 PROPOSED ORDER filed by Macromedia Inc. granting [355-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent (dlk) |
| Filing 355 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Summary Judgment of Claims 20 and 22-25 of '998 Patent Answer Brief due 3/25/02 re: [355-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 354 Declaration (SEALED) of Dr. Curtis Roads in support of Deft's Motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 353 Declaration (SEALED) of Darryl M. Woo in support of Deft's Motions for Summary Judgment of Infringement and Non-Anticipation of '998 and '969 patents (dlk) |
| Filing 352 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [350-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent - Answer Brief due 3/25/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 351 PROPOSED ORDER filed by Macromedia Inc. granting [350-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 350 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Summary Judgment of Non-Anticipation of Claims 22-25 of '998 patent and claims 20-23 of '969 patent Answer Brief due 3/25/02 re: [350-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 349 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D. I. 348 Declaration (dlk) |
| Filing 348 Declaration of Michael J. Sacksteder in support of Deft's Motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent. Notice of Deficiency sent-No Original Signature (dlk) |
| Filing 347 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D.I. 346 Declaration (dlk) |
| Filing 346 Declaration of James D. Foley, PH.D. in support of Deft's Motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent. Notice of deficiency sent-No Original Signature (dlk) |
| Filing 345 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [343-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent - Answer Brief due 3/25/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 344 PROPOSED ORDER filed by Macromedia Inc. granting [343-1] motion for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 343 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Summary Judgment of Invalidity of '528 patent Answer Brief due 3/25/02 re: [343-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 342 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and 2nd Supplemental responses to Pltf's Interrog No. 33 (dlk) |
| Filing 341 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections to Pltf's Subpoena to Non-Party Gary Hecker and Gary Hecker's Objections to Pltf's Subpoena. (dlk) |
| Filing 340 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's supplemental Response to Deft's 4th set of Interrogs No. 53 and Pltf's 5th supplemental response to deft's 1st set of Interrogs Nos. 11 & 12. (dlk) |
| Filing 339 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Heather N. Mewes to Appear Pro Hac Vice (dlk) |
| Filing 338 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and 9th supplemental response to Interrog No. 28 of Pltf's 1st set of interrogs. (dlk) |
| Discovery Dispute Teleconference held. (Farnan, J) Ct. Rptr. was present at deposition in California on 3/5/02 during teleconference. (dlk) |
| Filing 337 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Gary Hecker on 3/7/02 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 336 Letter(SEALED) to the Court dated 3/1/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Macromedia's copy of its slide presentation at the 2/21/02 claim construction hearing and additional material for consideration in connection with claim construction. (dlk) |
| Filing 335 Proposed Order filed by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Claim Construction for U.S. Patent Nos. 528,'443,'998 and'969 (dlk) |
| Filing 334 Letter to the Court dated 3/1/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: enclosed Adobe's proposed order regarding claim construction. (dlk) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [332-1] stipulation to amend the date for case dispositive motions to March 11, 2002 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 333 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Objections of Steven Feiner, Ph.D, James Foley, and Curtis Roads' to Pltf's Subpoena Duces Tecum (dlk) |
| Filing 332 STIPULATION with proposed order that Paragraph 5 of the Rule 16 Scheduling Order dated 1/19/01 is amended to change the date for case dispositive motions from 3/1/02 to 3/11/02. (dlk) |
|
Filing 331
ORDER DENYING as moot [218-1] motion for Protective Order; DENYING as moot [212-1] motion to deem admitted and [212-2] motion to Compel; and DENYING [267-1] motion to Compel Discovery ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 330 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of John Jarosz'z Objections to Pltf's Subpoena Duces Tecum. (dlk) |
| Filing 329 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of its [285-1] motion for separate trials (dlk) |
| Filing 328 Corrected NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of John Jarosz'z Objections to Pltf's Subpoena (dlk) |
| Filing 327 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Objections to Def's Subpoena of Richard L. Phillips, and Allan L. Kretz (dlk) |
| Filing 326 Letter to the Court (SEALED) by Mary B. Graham, Esq. (dlk) |
| Filing 325 TRANSCRIPT filed [0-0] Markman hearing for dates of 2/21/02 (Farnan,J) V. Gunning, L. Dibbs Ct. Rptrs. (dlk) |
| Filing 324 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Subpoenaes for Allan L. Kretz, Ph.D and Richard L. Philips, Ph.D. (dlk) |
| Filing 323 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Curtis Roads on 3/8/02 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 322 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of John Jarosz on 2/26/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 321 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of James Foley on 3/7/02 at 9:;30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 320 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Steven K. Feiner on 2/27/02 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Markman Hearing held (Farnan,J) V. Gunning, Ct. Rptr. (dlk) |
| Filing 319 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. Regarding Claim Construction of '528 patent. (dlk) |
| Filing 318 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [285-1] motion for separate trials - Reply Brief due 2/22/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 317 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D.I. 316 (dlk) |
| Filing 316 Reply Declaration of Professor Steven K. Feiner in support of Macromedia's Claim Construction of '443 patent (Notice of deficiency sent-No original signature) (dlk) |
| Filing 315 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D.I. 314 (dlk) |
| Filing 314 Reply Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads in support of Macromedia's Claim Construction of '998 and'969 patents(Notice of deficiency sent-No Original Signature) (dlk) |
| Filing 313 Macromedia's Consolidated Proposed Order RE: Claim Construction (dlk) |
| Filing 312 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of deft's Claim Construction for '443 patent. (dlk) |
| Filing 311 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of Deft's Claim Construction for '998 & '969 Patents (sound editing) (dlk) |
| Filing 310 Letter to the Court dated 2/14/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Adobe is withdrawing its claims of infringement of U.S Patent No. 6,084,597 (dlk) |
| Filing 309 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of its second [267-1] motion to Compel Discovery (dlk) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [288-1] motion for John Allcock, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 308 Declaration of Richard L. Phillips in support of Adobe's Opposition Brief to Macromedia's Claim Construction of '443 patent (dlk) |
| Filing 307 Declaration of Richard L. Phillips in support of Adobe's opposition brief to Macromedia's Claim Construction of '998 and '969 patents (dlk) |
| Filing 306 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to Macromedia's Cliam Construction of '443 patent (auto reblending) (dlk) |
| Filing 304 RE-NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Frank Weyer on 2/7/02 at 9:00 a.m. (dlk) Modified on 02/11/2002 |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [286-1] Stipulation and Protective Order (See Order for details) ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 305 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. to Macromedia's Claim Construction of '998 and '969 patents (sound editing) (dlk) |
| Filing 303 Opening Claims Construction Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. RE: '528 & '597 patents (dlk) |
| Filing 302 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Expert Rebuttal reports of: Professor Steven K. Feiner; James D. Foley, Ph.D.; Dr. Curtis Roads; John C. Jarosz; and Andrew s. Glassner, Ph.D. (dlk) |
| Filing 301 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections to 8th supplemental response to interrogs nos 1,6,13,27 and 28; amended supplemental responses to interrog no. 24; and 2nd supplemental responses to interrog nos. 63, and 64 by Pltf. (dlk) |
| Filing 300 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 2/5/02 RE: original signature page to declarations filed on 2/4/02 to be substituted. (dlk) |
| Filing 299 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 2/5/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Consolidated Brief in suppor of Deft's Claim COnstruction; please sustitute the attached corrected Tables for those filed on 2/4/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 298 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. re: D.I. 297 declaration has no original signature (dlk) |
| Filing 297 Declaration of James D. Foley, Ph.D. filed by Macromedia. (dlk) |
| Filing 296 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: Declaration(D.I. 295) no original signature (dlk) |
| Filing 295 Declaration of Michael J. Sacksteder in support of Macromedia's Consolidated Brief Re: '528 and '597 Patents (dlk) |
| Filing 294 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: D.I. 293 declaration has no original signature (dlk) |
| Filing 293 Declaration of Andrew S. Glassner, Ph.D. filed by Macromedia regarding U.S.Patent No. 6,084,597 (dlk) |
| Filing 292 Consolidated Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of Macromedia's Claim Construction for U.S. Patent Nos. 5,546,528 & 6,084,597. (dlk) |
| Filing 291 Notice of Deficiency from the court to plaintiff Adobe Systems Inc. RE: D.I.290-No original signature. (dlk) |
| Filing 290 Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Macromedia's opposition brief (D.I. 289) (dlk) |
| Filing 289 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [267-1] motion to Compel Discovery - Reply Brief due 2/11/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 288 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for John Allcock, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice (dlk) |
| Filing 287 NOTICE of Subpoena to Frank M. Weyer, Esq. by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition on 2/6/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 286 STIPULATION and Protective Order with proposed order (dlk) |
| Filing 285 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for separate trials Answer Brief due 2/15/02 re: [285-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 284 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/29/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed original executed signature page to the Declaratio of Virginia K. DeMarchi filed under seal on 1/28/02 (dlk) |
| Macromedia retrieved the document reviewed by the Court (dlk) |
| Filing 283 Declaration(SEALED) of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Deft's Reply (D.I.282) (dlk) Modified on 02/01/2002 |
| Filing 282 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [212-1] motion to deem admitted (dlk) |
|
Filing 281
ORDER GRANTING [169-1] motion for Reargument of [158-1] order compelling Macromedia to Produce an Unredacted Copy of Macromedia's Opinion of Counsel Letter relating to '597 patent. After reviewing the Opinion Letter the Court concludes that no further production of the Opinion Letter is required. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 280 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Jon Gay on 2/12/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 279 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of John Alquist on 2/11/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 276 Notice of Deficiency from the court to plaintiff Adobe Systems Inc. RE: D.I. 275 (dlk) Modified on 01/28/2002 |
| Filing 278 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/23/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: enclosed for filing is the Original of the 2nd Declaration of Nicole Dogwill to replace deficient document filed on 1/22/02 (declaration filed under seal) (dlk) |
| Filing 277 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Expert Reports of the following: Professor Steven K. Feiner; James D. Foley, Ph.D; Dr. Curtis Roads; John C. Jarosz; and Andrew S. Glassner, Ph.D. (dlk) |
| Filing 275 Second Declaration of Nicole P. Dogwill relating to the status of Discovery (Sealed) Notice of Deficiency sent-No original signature. (dlk) |
| Filing 274 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/22/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: enclosed 2nd Declaration of Nichole P. Dogwill for filing (dlk) |
| Filing 273 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and 7th supplemental response to Pltf's 1st set of interrogs and Deft's objections and 2nd supplemental responsed to pltf's 3rd set of interrogs. (dlk) |
| Filing 272 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/22/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed original executed signature page to amended declaration of Virginia DeMarchi which was filed on 1/17/02. (dlk) |
| Filed under seal pursuant to the Court's 1/18/02 Order is documents for In Camera Review filed by William J. Wade. (dlk) |
| Filing 271 Letter to the Court dated 1/18/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: joining in Macromedia's request of 1/16/02 for oral argument in connection with its Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order and other pending matters. (dlk) |
| Filing 270 Filed under seal a combined OPENING BRIEF in support of Adobe's second motion to compel discovery and ANSWER BRIEF Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [212-1] motion to deem admitted - Reply Brief due 1/25/02 (dlk) Modified on 01/23/2002 |
| Filing 269 Declaration of Karl Limbach filed under seal relating to the deposition of Dr. Lamoureux (dlk) |
| Filing 268 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/18/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed original executed signature page to the Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi filed on 1/15/02. (dlk) |
| Filing 267 Second MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order to Compel Discovery Answer Brief due 2/1/02 re: [267-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 266 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. on its [218-1] motion for Protective Order (dlk) |
|
Filing 265
ORDER that Macromedia shall produce the opinion of counsel letter relating to U.S. Patent No. 6,084,597 no later than 1/22/02 for in camera Review ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk) Modified on 01/28/2002
|
|
Filing 264
ORDER DENYING [204-1] motion to Amend the Scheduling Order with respect to the Markman Hearing and Trial dates. The parties may agree to a revised schedule for the remaining dates. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
|
Filing 263
MEMORANDUM ORDER DENYING [163-1] motion for Reconsideration of [158-1] order ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 262 Amended Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi filed under seal in support of Macromedia's Reply to Adobe's opposition to the Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order. (dlk) Modified on 01/22/2002 |
| Filing 261 Letter to the Court dated 1/17/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed Amended Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi (dlk) |
| Filing 260 Letter to the Court dated 1/17/02 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Pltf's answer to motion to deem requests admitted and compel will be filed on 1/18/02. (vm) |
| Filing 259 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Frank Weyer on 2/6/02 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 258 Letter to the Court dated 1/16/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Defendant's request for oral argument on Motion to Amend Scheduling Order. (vm) |
| Filing 257 Declaration of Virginia K. Demarchi in Support of Macromedia's Reply to Adobe's Opposition to the Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order (D.I. 190). (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vm) |
| Filing 256 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [204-1] motion to Amend the Scheduling Order [190-1] stipulation (FILED UNDER SEAL)(vm) Modified on 01/16/2002 |
| Filing 255 Declaration of Ian Feinberg in Support of Adobe's Opening Brief of Claim Construction of US Patents 5,546,528 and 6,084,597. (vm) |
| Filing 254 Markman Declaration on '528 and '597 Patents by Dr. Richard L. Philips filed by Adobe Systems. (vm) |
| Filing 253 NOTICE of Withdrawal of Appearance of James H. Pooley of Gray Cary Ware & Freidenrich LLP as counsel by Adobe Systems Inc. (vm) |
| Filing 252 Letter to the Clerk of Court dated 1/14/02 by William Wade, Esq. RE: Enclosed original signature pages for Declaration of Steven Feiner and Dr. Curtis Roads. (vm) |
| Filing 251 Proposed Order filed by Macromedia Inc. RE: Claim Construction for US Patent Nos. 5,151,998, 5,204,969 and 5,467,443. (vm) |
| Filing 250 Exhibits to Declaration of Dr. Steven K. Feiner Filed by Macromedia Inc. (vm) |
| Filing 249 Exhibits to Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads (Volume 2 of 2) Filed by Macromedia Inc. (vm) |
| Filing 248 Appendix to Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads (Volume 1 of 2) Filed by Macromedia Inc. (vm) |
| Filing 247 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: Declaration of Steven K. Feiner does not have an original signature. (vm) |
| Filing 246 Declaration of Professor Steven K. Feiner in Support of Macromedia's Claim Construction (Notice of Deficiency) (vm) |
| Filing 245 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads. No original signature on declaration. (vm) |
| Filing 244 Declaration of Dr. Curtis Roads in Support of Macromedia's Claim Construction of US Patents 5,151,998 and 5,204,969. (Notice of Deficiency) (vm) |
| Filing 243 Brief in Support Filed by Macromedia Inc. of its Claim Construction for US Patents 5,151,998, 5,204,969 and 5,467,443. (vm) |
| Filing 242 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. regarding claim construction of its US Patent 6,084,597 with Concatenated Rendering (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vm) |
| Filing 241 Opening Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. regarding claim construction of its US Patent 5,546,528 with tab palettes (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vm) |
| Filing 240 Letter to the Clerk dated 1/14/02 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Original of First Declaration of Nicole Dogwill with original signature. Deficiency corrected. (vm) |
| Filing 239 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. - Declaration of Michelle Mackey lacks original signature. (vm) |
| Filing 238 Declaration of Michelle Mackey in Support of Macromedia's Opposition to Motion for Protective Order (notice of deficiency). (vm) |
| Filing 237 Amended Sixth NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia on 01/11/02 at 3:00 p.m. (vm) |
| Filing 236 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [218-1] in opposition to motion for Protective Order - Reply Brief due 1/18/02 (vm) |
| Filing 235 Fourth NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia on 01/03/02 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 234 NOTICE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's Responses to Dft's Fifth Set of Requests for Production of Documents, Response to Dft's Demand for Entry Upon Adobe's Property for Inspection of Computer File Directory Information, Responses to Dft's Fourth Set of Interrogatories, and Responses to Dft's Second Set of Requests for Admission. (vm) |
| Filing 233 Letter to the Court dated 1/11/02 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Enclosed "under seal" envelopes for Adobe's Opposition to Macromedia's Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order. (vm) |
| Filing 232 Notice of Deficiency from the court to plaintiff Adobe No original signature on First Declaration of Nicole P. Dogwell. (vm) |
| Filing 231 First Declaration of Nicole P. Dogwill relating to the Status of Discovery (in support of Adobe's Opposition to Motion to Amend Scheduling Order) Notice of Deficiency - No original signature. (vm) |
| Filing 230 Letter to the Clerk dated 1/11/02 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Enclosed for filing is First Declaration of Nicole P. Dogwill in support of Dft's Motion to Amend with pdf signature. Original Signature to be filed next week. (vm) |
| Filing 229 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [204-1] motion to Amend the Scheduling Order [190-1] stipulation - Reply Brief due 1/17/02 (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vm) |
| Filing 228 Sixth NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia on 1/11/02 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 227 Fifth NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia on 1/22/02 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 226 NOTICE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. of Notice of Deposition of Michael Hawley. (vm) |
| Filing 225 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. of Plaintiff's 3rd Supplement to its initial disclosures pursuant to rule 26(a)(1). (vm) |
| Filing 224 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and Amended Updated Supplemental Responses to Interrogs Nos. 21 and 24 to 1st set of interrogs and Deft's Objections and Amended Updated Supplemental Response to Interrog no. 31 to 2nd set of Interrogs. (dlk) |
| Filing 223 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Bob Vallone on 1/11/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 222 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Don Hopkins on 1/11/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 221 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Tony Hoeber on 1/11/02 at 1:00 p.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 220 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Dan Fraisl on 1/11/02 at 3:00 p.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 219 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Adobe Systems on 1/11/02 at 9:30 a.m (dlk) |
| Filing 218 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Protective Order Answer Brief due 1/22/02 re: [218-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 217 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Brian Dister on 1/11/02 at 10:00 a.m (dlk) |
| Filing 216 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Pete Santangeli on 1/11/02 at 10:00 a.m (dlk) |
| Filing 215 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Notice of Objection to confidentiality designation (dlk) |
| Filing 214 Letter to the Court dated 1/7/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached is the original Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi to be substituted for the telecopied version which was filed on 1/3/02. (dlk) |
| Filing 213 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [212-1] motion to deem admitted - Answer Brief due 1/17/02, [212-2] motion to Compel - Answer Brief due 1/17/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 212 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order to deem admitted certain of Macromedia's requests for admissions, and to Compel Answer Brief due 1/17/02 re: [212-1] motion, Answer Brief due 1/17/02 re: [212-2] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 211 Declaration of Virginia K. Demarchi filed under seal in support of Macromedia's Motion to Deem Admitted Certain of Macromedia's Requests For Admissions and to Compel further Discovery from Adobe and certification under local rule 7.1.1 7.1.1 (dlk) Modified on 01/04/2002 |
| Filing 210 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 1/3/02 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed for filing declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi with telecopied version of the signature page. Original signature page will be delivered on 1/4/02. (dlk) |
| Filing 209 NOTICE of Service of Pltf's responsed to Deft's 3rd set of requests for production of docs by Adobe Systems Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 208 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 12/26/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached is the original executed affidavit of Darryl M. Woo to substitute for the telecopied version which was filed on 12/21/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 207 AFFIDAVIT of Darryl M. Woo by Macromedia Inc. Re: [204-1] motion to Amend the Scheduling Order [190-1] stipulation (dlk) |
| Filing 206 Appendix to Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [205-1] opening brief (dlk) |
| Filing 205 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [204-1] motion to Amend the Scheduling Order [190-1] stipulation - Answer Brief due 1/4/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 204 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order to Amend the Scheduling Order [190-1] stipulation Answer Brief due 1/4/02 re: [204-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 203 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE pursuant to L.R. 7.1.1 for Adobe's Motion for reconsideration (D.I. 163) to clear defiency(D.I. 164) (dlk) |
| Filing 202 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 12/21/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: notice of deficiency of D.I. 164. Although the issue is moot because Macromedia filed an opposition, enclosed is certificate to correct the deficiency. (dlk) |
| Filing 201 Letter to the Court dated 12/20/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE:Adobe requests that the Court grant Adobe's motion for reconsideration and apply here its ruling in Pitney Bowes, which similarly calls for production of Macromedia's source code in machine readable form. (dlk) |
| Filing 200 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Tom Hale on 1/8/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 199 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Scott Larrimer on 1/7/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 198 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Eric Wittman on 1/8/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 197 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Notice of Deposition of the following: Larry Lozares, Teri Pettit, Dave Lazarony, Paul Asente, Nick Schlott and Steve Warner (dlk) |
|
Filing 196
ORDER DENYING AS MOOT [74-1] motion to Extend Time ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
|
Filing 195
ORDER DENYING [75-1] motion to Compel any documents that discuss Macromedia ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 194 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Macromedia's Demand for Entry Upon Adobe's Property for Inspection of Computer File Directory Information; 2. Macromedia's 4th set of Interrogs to Pltf.; 3. Macromedia's 5th set of request for Production of Docs and things; 4. Macromedia's 2nd set of request for admission to Pltf. (dlk) |
| Filing 193 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's 4th notice of Deposition of Macromedia (dlk) |
| Filing 192 Letter by Barbara Wheeler of Richards, Layton & Finger dated 11/13/01 RE: attached clocked-in copy of NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. with clock-date of 10/15/01. (Originals never received by Court) See docket entry remark of 10/15/01 for details of document (dlk) Modified on 12/10/2001 |
| Filing 191 Letter to the Court dated 12/6/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached original executed signature page to the Declaration of Eulonda Skyles to be substituted for the telecopied version which was filed on 11/16/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 190 STIPULATION with proposed order for extension of Discovery Period to be amended as follows: Fact Discovery dutoff 1/11/02; Opening Markman Brief 1/14/02; Opposing Markman Brief 2/4/02; Markman reply brief 2/15/02; Markman Hearing 2/21/02 at 9:00; Initial expert reports 1/18/02; Expert rebuttal reports 2/1/02; Expert discovery cutoff 2/22/02; Dispositive motions 3/1/02. The pretrial conference and trial dates shall remain as set forth inthe 1/19/01 scheduling order. (dlk) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [190-1] stipulation to extend discovery period ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Deadline updated; reset Discovery deadline to 2/22/02 , and set Markman Hearing for 9:00 2/21/02 per Calendar Notice (dlk) |
| Filing 189 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's supplemental responses to deft's 3rd set of interrogs and 1st set of request for admissions (dlk) |
| Filing 188 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Dennis Griffin on 1/7/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 187 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Doug Benson on 1/4/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 186 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Sho Kuwamoto on 1/2/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 185 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Dan Sadowski on 1/3/02 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 184 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's supplemental responsed to deft's 1st set of interrogs Nos. 1-2,11,12,15,22,& 23 (dlk) |
| Filing 183 Letter to the Court dated 12/4/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: The parties have agreed to the enclosed stipulation and proposed order extending the time for discovery which does not affect the trial date. The parties request a Markman Hrg. date be scheduled between 2/20/02 and 2/22/02 (dlk) |
| Filing 182 Opposition Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [169-1] motion for Reargument of [158-1] order compelling Macromedia to Produce an Unredacted Copy of Macromedia's Opinion of Counsel Letter relating to '597 patent - Reply Brief due 12/10/01 (dlk) |
| Filing 181 Letter to the Court dated 12/3/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE:in response to Adobe filing a reply to its motion for reconsideration; Macromedia believes that the appropriate remedy is for the Court to strike Adobe's 11/30/01 reply letter and not consider it in connection with the motion (dlk) |
| Filing 180 Letter to the Court dated 11/30/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE:response to Macromedia's Opposition to Adobe's Motion for Reconsideration. (dlk) |
| Filing 179 NOTICE of Service by Non-Party Grossman's Objections and Responses to Adobe Systems Doc request accompanying the Notice of Deposition of Gary Grossman (dlk) |
| Filing 178 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Notice of Deposition of Paul George, Notice of Deposition of Mark Hamburg, and Notice of Deposition of Rob Sargent (dlk) |
| Filing 177 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Proof of Service of Supboena issued upon CT Holdings, Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 176 Answer Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. [163-1] motion for Reconsideration of [158-1] order - Reply Brief due 12/3/01 (dlk) |
| Filing 175 SEALED DOCUMENTS filed by Adobe Systems Inc. for In Camera Review pursuant to Paragraph II(4) of the Court's Order of 11/9/01.(not served on Macromedia) (dlk) |
| Filing 174 Letter to the Court dated 11/26/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Pursuant to Paragraph II(4) of the Court's Order of 11/9/01, we are providing the documents ordered to be produced for "in camera" inspection. (dlk) |
| Filing 173 Letter to the Court dated 11/21/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: request that Adobe be permitted to produce for in camera inspection on 11/26/01 the documents that are the subject of Paragraph II(4) of the Court's Order of 11/9/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 172 Letter to the Clerk dated 11/19/01 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Enclosed original signature of Dr. Richard Phillips (D.I. 162). (vm) |
| Filing 171 NOTICE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. of Dft's Objections and Fifth Supplemental Response to Plt's First Set of Interrogatories and Dft's Objections and Supplemental Responses to Plt's Third Set of Interrogatories. (vm) |
| Filing 170 Letter to the Court dated 11/19/01 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Request delay in consideration of Protective Order submitted by Dft. until Court rules on Pltf's Motion for Reconsideration. (vm) |
| Filing 169 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Reargument of [158-1] order compelling Macromedia to Produce an Unredacted Copy of Macromedia's Opinion of Counsel Letter relating to '597 patent Answer Brief due 11/30/01 re: [169-1] motion (vm) |
| Filing 168 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. concerning Declaration of Eulonda G. Skyles (no original signature) (vm) |
| Filing 167 Declaration of Eulonda G. Skyles in Support of Macromedia's Motion for Reargument concerning the Court's 11/9/01 Order compelling Macromedia to produce an unredacted copy of Macromedia's opinion of counsel letter relating to '597 Patent. (Notice of Deficiency) (vm) |
| Filing 166 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of copies of deposition subpoena of Patricia Pane and Notice of Deposition with Subpoena of CompanionLink Software, Inc. and Subpoena issued by USDC for the Norther District of Texas to CT Holdings, Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 165 Letter to the Court dated 11/15/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Deft. will treat Pltf's Motion for reconsideration as a Motion for reargument and will file its answer to the Motion by 11/29/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 164 Notice of Deficiency from the court to plaintiff Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Declaration fo Dr. Phillips and Motion for Reconsideration. (dlk) |
| Filing 163 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Reconsideration of [158-1] order Answer Brief due 11/28/01 re: [163-1] motion (Notice of deficiency-no 7.1.1 notice) (dlk) |
| Filing 162 Declaration of Dr. Richard L. Phillips concerning the Court's decision to require software to be provided only in printed form.(Notice of deficiency-no original signature) (dlk) Modified on 11/15/2001 |
| Filing 161 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Subpoena to UniPress Software and Subpoena to Kevin Johnston with proof of service (dlk) |
| Filing 160 Letter to the Court dated 11/14/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: filing of Motion for reconsideration in connection with the Court's orders of 11/5 and 11/9 to the extent that they deny Adobe's motion to compel production of complete, electronic source code. (dlk) |
| Filing 159 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Proof of Service of Subpoena and Notice of Deposition upon Keith M. Zentner (dlk) |
|
Filing 158
MEMORANDUM ORDER GRANTING IN PART, DENYING IN PART [65-1] motion to Compel Discovery and GRANTING IN PART, DENYING IN PART [75-1] motion to Compel (See Order for details) ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
|
Filing 157
AMENDED ORDER that paragraph a. of D.I. 148 is amended as follows: "Adobe's Motion for Confidentiality Order (d.I. 68) is DENIED and Macromedia's Proposed Protective Order (D.I. 83) is GRANTED." ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 156 Letter to the Court dated 11/9/01 by Jeffrey L. Moyer, Esq. RE: In order to comply with the Court's 11/5/01 Order, Macromedia is submitting the enclosed revised protectie order. Adobe's counsel has not executed the proposed order and has indicated that it does not want the Court to enter a protective order at this time.(Proposed Order Attached) (dlk) Modified on 11/14/2001 |
| Filing 155 Letter to the Court dated 11/9/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Because the Court has ordered the parties to agree to a form of stipulation regarding a protective order, we write to let the Court know that we will be filing a motion for reconsideration and respectfully ask that the Court consider the points contained in this letter prior to entry of an order. (dlk) |
| Filing 154 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's supplemental responses to deft's 1st set of Interrogs No. 1,6-7, 11-12, 1627, 33 and 35 (dlk) |
| Filing 153 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's responses to Deft's 4th set of request for production of docs and response to deft's 3rd set of interrogs and 1st set of requests for admissions (dlk) |
| Filing 152 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deft's Objections and Responses to Pltf's 4th set of interrogs and Responses to Pltf's 1st set of request for admission (nos 1-95) (dlk) |
| Filing 151 NOTICE of Service by non-party of Charles Gottlieb's Objections to Pltf's supplemental subpoena. (dlk) |
| Filing 150 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Objections and 3rd supplemental response to pltf's 1st set of interrogs no.6 (dlk) |
| Filing 149 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Notice of Deposition of David F. Herbstman, David Simons, and Daniel Wilk (dlk) |
|
Filing 148
ORDER DENYING [68-1] motion for Protective Order, GRANTING [83-1] answer brief with proposed Protective Order. The parties shall submit a Stipulated Protective Order consistent with this Memorandum Opinion no later than 11/9/01.( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 147 MEMORANDUM OPINION ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk) |
|
Filing 146
ORDER DENYING [119-1] motion to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order, however, the parties may agree to a new discovery cut-off date. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (dlk)
|
| Filing 145 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Keith M. Zentner on 11/29/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 144 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Gary Grossman on 11/5/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 143 Letter to the Court dated 10/26/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: request that the Court schedule argument on Macromedia, Inc.'s Motion to Amend. (dlk) |
| Filing 142 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 10/26/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached is the original signature page to the Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi (dlk) |
| Filing 141 NOTICE of Service of objections and 2nd supplemental response to 1st set of interrogs. and objections and 4th supplemental response to 1st set of Interrogs(no.21) by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 140 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. RE: Declaration (dlk) |
| Filing 139 Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi in support of Deft's Reply in support of its Motion to amend the scheduling order. (Notice of deficiency sent-no original signature) (dlk) |
| Filing 138 Letter to the Clerk's Office dated 10/25/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: enclosed for filing is the Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi, which contains a telecopied version of the signature page. The Original signature page will be delivered to the Court on Friday, 10/26/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 137 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [119-1] motion to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order (dlk) |
| Filing 136 NOTICE of Lodging of Proof of Service of Subpoena, Notice of Deposition, together with witness fee upon Silicon Graphics, Inc. by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 135 Third NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia, Inc. on 10/31/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 134 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Keith M. Zentner on 11/5/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 133 Second NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia, Inc. on 10/26/01 at 10:00 am. (dlk) |
| Filing 132 MEMORANDUM by Adobe Systems Inc. in opposition to [119-1] motion to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order (dlk) |
| Filing 131 NOTICE of Service of Errata to Josef Sensendorf's Objections and Errata to Michael Lamoureux's Objections by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Notice of Service filed by Macromedia, Inc. of non-Party Loren Hillberg's Objections to Adobe's Subpoena; Non-Party Wayne Veatch's Objections to Adobe's Subpoena; Non-Party Michael Lamoureux's Objections to Adobe's Subpoena; Non-Party Charles Gotlieb's Objections to Adobe's Subpoena; Non-Party Josef Sensendorf's Objections to Adobe's Subpoena; and Non-Party Samuel M. Roberts' Objections to Adobe's Subpoena (See D.I. 192 for details) (dlk) Modified on 12/10/2001 |
| Filing 130 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 129 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of David Mills on 10/16/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 128 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 127 Letter to the Clerk of the Court dated 10/9/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached original executed signature page to the Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi (dlk) |
| Filing 126 NOTICE of Service by Adobe Systems Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 125 Appendix of Documentary Evidence in support of Macromedia, Inc.'s Motion to Amend Filed by Macromedia Inc. Appending [121-1] opening brief (FILED UNDER SEAL) (dlk) |
| Filing 124 Notice of Deficiency from the court to defendant Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 123 Declaration of Virginia K. Demarchi in support of Macromedia, Inc.'s Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order (deficiency notice sent-no original signature) (dlk) |
| Filing 122 Letter to the Court dated 10/5/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: attached for filing is the Declaration of Virginia K. DeMarchi(original signature page will be deliverd 10/9/01) (dlk) |
| Filing 121 Opening Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of its [119-1] motion to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order - Answer Brief due 10/19/01 (dlk) |
| Filing 120 Proposed Order filed by Macromedia Inc. for [119-1] motion to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order (dlk) |
| Filing 119 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. to Amend [32-1] Scheduling order (dlk) |
| Filing 118 Letter to the Court dated 10/4/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: response to Macromedia's letter and supplemental Brief of 9/20/01 relating to protective order and countermotion to compel (dlk) |
| Filing 117 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 116 REVISED NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Kevin Johnston on 11/6/01 at 10:30 a.m. (dlk) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [115-1] motion for Virginia K. DeMarchi, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 115 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Virginia K. DeMarchi, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice (dlk) |
| Filing 114 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Adobe Syustems, Inc. on 10/9/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 113 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Adobe Systems, Inc. on 10/19/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 112 RE-NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Adrian Freed on 10/10/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 111 NOTICE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. of Pltf's Second Supplemental Responses to Dft's First Set of Interrogatories 1,6-7,11-12,16,19-27, and 33. (vm) |
| Filing 110 NOTICE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. of Objections of John Dowdell to Pltf's Subpoena. (vm) |
| Filing 109 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Proof of Service of Subpoena upon VTech Innovations. (vm) |
| Filing 108 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Macromedia on 10/24/01 at 9:30 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 107 Supplemental Brief by Macromedia Inc. in support Deft's request for entry of proposed protective order and of [75-1] motion to Compel (dlk) |
| Filing 106 Letter to the Court dated 9/20/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Macromedia hereby seeks leave to submit attached supplemental Memorandum in support of Macromedia's Countermotion to Compel Discovery from Adobe. (dlk) |
| Filing 105 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Vtech innovations, d/b/a Advanced American Telephones on 10/5/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 104 NOTICE of Service of Objections of John Dowdell to Pltf's Subpoena by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 103 NOTICE of Lodging of Proof of Service of Subpoena and Notice of Deposition together with witness fee upon Motorola, Inc. by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 102 NOTICE of service of Objections of Michael Edmunds to Pltf's Subpoena by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 101 NOTICE of Service of Objections of Non-party Adrian Freed to Deft's notice of deposition and subpoena duces tecum by Adobe Systems Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 100 NOTICE of Service of Pltf's 4th set of Docs and 3rd set of interrogs. by Adobe Systems Inc. (dlk) |
| Deadline updated; reset Discovery deadline to 2/8/02 (dlk) |
|
So Ordered granting [97-1] stipulation that the Rule 16 Scheduling Order be amended to change the following dates: fact discovery cutoff 11/6/01; Markman Hrg.12/12/01 at 1:00 p.m.; Initial expert reports 12/21/01; Expert rebuttal reports 1/11/02; and Expert discovery cutoff 2/8/02 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 99 NOTICE of Service of Deft's 3rd set of Requests for Production of Docs. and Things by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 98 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Adrian Freed on 9/25/01 at 9:30 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 97 STIPULATION with proposed order that the Rule 16 Scheduling Order be Amended to change the following dates: 1. Fact discovery cutoff 11/6/01; 2. Markman Hearing 12/12/01 at 1:00 p.m.; 3. Initial expert reports 12/21/01; 4. Expert rebuttal reports 1/11/02; 5. Expert discovery cutoff 2/8/02; 6. All other dates shall remain as set forth. (dlk) |
| Filing 96 Letter to the Court dated 8/29/01 by Mary B. Graham and William J. Wade RE: enclosed Stipulation extending time for discovery. (dlk) |
| Filing 95 Letter to the Court dated 8/17/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: response to Adobes letter to the Court dated 8/16/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 94 Letter to the Court dated 8/16/01 by Mary B. Graham RE:request that the Rule 16 Conference for 8/30 not be cancelled or request that a hearing be scheduled to resolve outstanding discovery disputes. (dlk) |
| Deadline updated; set Markman Hearing for 1:00 on 12/12/01 per calendar notice. (dlk) |
| Filing 93 NOTICE of Service of Pltf's response to deft's 2nd set of interrogs and pltf's response to deft's 2nd set of request for production of docs by Adobe Systems Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 92 Letter to the Court dated 8/9/01 by William J. Wade,Esq. RE: response to Ms. Graham's letter dated 8/3/01 (dlk) |
| Filing 91 Reply Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in support of [75-1]counter- motion to Compel (dlk) |
| Filing 90 Letter to the Court dated 8/3/01 by Mary B. Graham RE:Macromedia's production of the electronic source code for accused products. Proposed order attached. (dlk) |
| Filing 89 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Motorola on 9/3/01 at 9:30 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 88 Answer Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [75-1] motion to Compel - Reply Brief due 8/9/01 (vm) |
| Filing 87 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. [68-1] motion for Protective Order (vm) |
|
So Ordered granting [86-1] stipulation ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (vm)
|
| Filing 86 STIPULATION with proposed order for extension of time until 8/01/01 for Pltf. to file Reply Brief on Motion for Confidentiality Order and Answering Brief to Dft's Cross-Motion to Compel and Extend Discovery. (vm) |
| Filing 85 Dft's Errata to Its Answer Brief in Opposition to Pltf's Motion to Compel. (vm) |
| Filing 84 Reply Brief Filed by Adobe Systems Inc. in support of Its [75-1] Motion to Compel Contentions and Other Discovery (SEALED) (vm) |
| Filing 83 Letter Brief Filed by Macromedia Inc. in opposition to [68-1] motion for Protective Order - Reply Brief due 7/30/01 (dlk) |
| Filing 82 Letter to the Court dated 7/23/01 by Mary B. Graham RE:rescheduling of Markman Hearing dates (dlk) |
| Filing 81 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Kevin Johnston on 7/26/01 at 9:30 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 80 AFFIDAVIT of Chris M. Howland in Support of Macromedia's Opposition to Adobe's Motion To Compel Contentions and other Discovery of Macromedia & Countermotion to Compel Discovery from Adobe Re: [77-1] answer brief, [75-1] motion to Compel (dlk) |
| Filing 79 Appendix Filed by Macromedia Inc. of Documentary Evidence in Support of Defendant/Counterclaimant Macromedia, Inc.'s Opposition to Adobe Systems, Inc.'s Motion to Compel Contentions and other Discovery of Macromedia and Countermotion to Compel Discovery from Adobe. Volume 2 (FILED UNDER SEAL) Appending [77-1] answer brief (dlk) |
| Filing 78 Appendix Filed by Macromedia of Documentary Evidence in Support of Defendant/Counterclaimant Macromedia, Inc.'s Opposition to Adobe Systems, Inc.'s Motion to Compel Contentions and other Discovery of Macromedia and Countermotion to Compel Discovery from Adobe Inc. Voulume 1 (FILED UNDER SEAL) Appending [77-1] answer brief (dlk) Modified on 07/23/2001 |
| Filing 77 Macromedia's opposition to Adobe's Motion to Compel Contentions and other Discovery of Macromedia & (Memorandum in Support of ) Countermotion to Compel Discovery from Adobe Inc. [65-1] motion to Compel Discovery (dlk) |
| Filing 76 Proposed Order filed by Macromedia Inc. denying Adobe's Motion to Compel Contentions and Other Discovery from Macromedia (dlk) |
| Filing 75 COUNTERMOTION by Macromedia Inc. to Compel Discovery from Adobe Answer Brief due 8/1/01 re: [75-1] motion (dlk) Modified on 07/23/2001 |
| Filing 74 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. for Scheduling Order to Extend Time for Discovery and Postponing Markman Hearing. Answer Brief due 8/1/01 re: [74-1] motion (dlk) |
| Filing 73 NOTICE of Service of Deft's 2nd set of Request for Production of Docs to Pltf. by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 72 NOTICE of Service by Macromedia Inc. of Deposition of Adobe Systems (dlk) |
|
So Ordered granting [69-1] stipulation that the remaining briefs on the Rule 37 Motion by Adobe to Compel Contentions and Other Discovery of Macromedia shall be due as follows: 7/17/01-Deft's answering brief, 7/24/01 Pltf's reply brief ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (dlk)
|
| Filing 71 SECOND REVISED NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Kevin Johnston on 7/26/01 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 70 NOTICE of Lodging by Macromedia Inc. of Affidavit of Service of Subpoena and Notice of Deposition together with $60.30 Witness fee upon Lucent Technologies, Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 69 STIPULATION with proposed order that remaing briefs on the Rule 37 Motion by Adobe to Compel Contentions shall be due as follows: Macromedia's answering brief 7/17/01, Adobe's reply brief 7/24/01. (dlk) |
| Filing 68 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Protective Order to Govern Discovery of Confidential Information (dlk) |
| Filing 67 Letter to the Court dated 7/9/01 by Mary Graham, Esq. RE: Motion for Confidentiality Order to govern discovery of confidential info. (dlk) |
| Filing 66 Declaration of Dr. Richard Phillips in Support of Plt's Motion to Compel Discovery. (vm) |
| Filing 65 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. to Compel Discovery Answer Brief due 7/12/01 re: [65-1] motion (SEALED) (vm) Modified on 07/03/2001 |
| Filing 64 REVISED NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Kevin Johnston on 7/11/01 at 10:oo a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 63 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of Lucent Technologies on 7/30/01 at 9:30 A.M. (dlk) |
| Filing 62 NOTICE of Lodging of Affidavit of Service of Subpoena and Notice of Deposition upon International Business Machines & Affidavit of Service of Subpoena and Notice of Deposition upon AT&T filed by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 61 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc., Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of AT&T Corporation on 7/30/01 at 9:30 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 60 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc., Macromedia Inc. to take deposition of IBM Corporation on 7/31/01 at 9:30 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 59 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Kevin Johnson on 6/28/01 at 10:00 a.m. (vm) |
| Filing 58 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Subpoena, Notice of Depostion of Microsoft Corp., and Witness Fee Check filed by Macromedia Inc. (dlk) |
| Filing 57 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Steven R. Johnson on 7/23/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 56 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Samuel M. Roberts on 7/6/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 55 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of James R. Von Ehr on 7/12/01 at 10:00 A.M. (dlk) |
| Filing 54 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Samantha Seals-Mason on 7/17/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 53 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Kevin F. Crowder on 7/20/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 52 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Steven P. Capps on 7/10/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 51 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Josef Sensendorf on 6/26/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 50 NOTICE by Adobe Systems Inc. to take deposition of Michael P. Lamoureux on 7/3/01 at 10:00 a.m. (dlk) |
| Filing 49 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc., Adobe Systems Inc. First Supplement to Its Initial Disclosures. (vm) |
| Filing 48 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc.'s Responses to Plaintiff's 3rd Set of Document Requests and Macromedia's Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories. (vm) |
| Filing 47 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take 30(b)(6) deposition of Microsoft Corp. on 7/16/01 at 9:30 a.m. (sm) |
| Filing 46 NOTICE by Macromedia Inc. to take 30(b)(6) deposition of Silicon Graphics, Incorporated on 7/9/01 at 9:30 a.m. (sm) |
| Filing 45 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Pltf's 2nd set of interrogs. to dft. & Pltf's 3rd set of document requests. (sm) |
| Filing 44 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Pltf's suppl. responses to dft's 1st set of interrogs. (sm) |
| Filing 43 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. RE: Dft's objections and suppl. response to pltf. & Dft's 1st set of interrogs. (sm) |
| Filing 42 Letter to the Court dated 4/17/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Pltf's response to dft's letter of 4/9/01 regarding the proposed protective order. (sm) |
| Filing 41 Declaration of Gary Grossman RE: "source code" (sm) |
| Filing 40 Letter to the Court dated 4/16/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Dfts' rebuttal to the 4/9/01 letter brief of pltf. concerning the entry of a protective order in this case. (sm) |
| Filing 39 Letter to the Court dated 4/9/01 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Pltf's enclosed proposed protective order. (sm) |
| Filing 38 Letter to the Court dated 4/9/01 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: The parties request they submit letter briefs concerning the entry of a suitable protective order. (sm) |
| Filing 37 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. RE: Dft's responses to pltf's 2nd set of document requests. (sm) |
| Filing 36 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Pltf's 2nd set of document requests. (sm) |
| Filing 35 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Pltf's responses to dft's 1st set of requests for production of documents and things & Pltf's responses to dft's 1st set of interrogs. (sm) |
| Filing 34 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. RE: Dft's responses to pltf's 1st set of document requests and Dft's objections and responses to pltf's 1st set of interrogs. (sm) |
| Filing 33 Steno Notes for 1/19/01 teleconference, B. Gaffigan, rptr. (sm) |
|
Filing 32
RULE 16 SCHEDULING ORDER setting Discovery cutoff 9/28/01 ; Deadline for filing dispositive motions 3/1/02 ; Pretrial conference for 9:00 4/3/02 ; Jury Trial Date Deadline 9:00 4/29/02 ; Proposed Pretrial Order due on 3/31/02 ; A further Rule 16 conference will be held on 8/30/01. The parties shall select 10/11/01 or 10/12/01 for the scheduling of a Markman Hearing at 9:00 a.m. A total of 2 hours is allocated for the hearing. The parties agree that any notice required by Fed. R. Evid. 902, as amended, shall be provided in connection with the parties' pre-trial disclosures. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: counsel (sm)
|
| Tele-conference held (Farnan, J), B. Gaffigan, rptr; The Court will issue a scheduling order. (sm) |
| Deadline updated; set Markman Hearing for 9:00 10/11/01 or 10/12/01 at 9:00 a.m. (SEE Rule 16 Scheduling Order, D.I. 32). (sm) |
| Deadline updated; set Telephone Conference for 12:00 1/19/01 per calendar notice. (sm) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [31-1] motion for Michele Mackey,Esq. and Sean DeBruine, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
| Filing 31 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Michele Mackey,Esq. and Sean DeBruine, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [31-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 30 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. RE: Dft's 1st set of requests for production of documents and things to pltf. & Dft's 1st set of interrogs. to pltf. (sm) |
| Filing 29 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Macromedia Inc. RE: Dft's initial disclosures pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P.26(a)(1). (sm) |
| Filing 28 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Adobe Systems Inc. RE: Pltf's 1st set of document requests; Pltf's 1st set of interrogs. & Pltf's initial disclosures pursuant to Rule 26. (sm) |
| Filing 27 Letter to the Court dated 12/6/00 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Request that the Court hold a telephone conference to address the Markman hearing date. (sm) |
| Filing 26 Letter to the Court dated 12/1/00 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: Enclosed proposed rule 16 scheduling order agreed to by the parties. (sm) |
| Filing 25 REPLY by Macromedia Inc. to [21-1] Adobe Systems Incorporated's counterclaims. (sm) |
| Filing 24 Letter to the Court dated 10/27/00 by William J. Wade, Esq. RE: Confirmation that the Rule 16 Scheduling Conference on 11/22/00 has been moved to 12/6/00 at 12:30 p.m. (sm) |
| Deadline updated; reset Rule 16 Scheduling Conference for 12:30 12/6/00 per calendar notice. (sm) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [23-1] motion for Darryl M. Woo, Esq., Charlene M. Morrow, Esq., Michael Sacksteder, Esq., Lisa M. Arent, Esq., Lorrel A. Birnschein, Esq., Mark W. Born, Esq. and Eulonda G. Skyles, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
| Filing 23 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Darryl M. Woo, Esq., Charlene M. Morrow, Esq., Michael Sacksteder, Esq., Lisa M. Arent, Esq., Lorrel A. Birnschein, Esq., Mark W. Born, Esq. and Eulonda G. Skyles, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [23-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 22 **Terminated attorney Steven J. Balick for Macromedia Inc., Notice of attorney appearance for Macromedia Inc. by William J. Wade (sm) |
| Filing 21 ANSWER by Adobe Systems Inc. to [18-2] counterclaims (sm) |
|
Filing 20
ORDER, reset Rule 16 Scheduling Conference for 9:15 11/22/00 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: Counsel (sm)
|
|
So Ordered GRANTING [17-1] motion for Colette Vogele, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
| Filing 19 Letter to the Court dated 9/27/00 by Mary B. Graham, Esq. RE: The parties suggest putting off the scheduling conference for 2 weeks. (sm) |
| Filing 18 ANSWER to amended complaint and COUNTERCLAIMS by Macromedia Inc.; jury demand against Adobe Systems Inc. (sm) |
| Filing 17 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Colette Vogele, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [17-1] motion (sm) |
|
Filing 16
ORDER set Rule 16 Scheduling Conference for 10:30 9/29/00 ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) copies to: counsel (sm)
|
| Filing 15 FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT by Adobe Systems Inc. , amending [1-1] complaint (sm) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [9-1] motion for M. Elizabeth Day, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [10-1] motion for Richard M. Goldman, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [11-1] motion for William G. Goldman, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [12-1] motion for Ian N. Feinberg, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [13-1] motion for James Pooley, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [14-1] motion for David S. Bloch, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
| Filing 14 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for David S. Bloch, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [14-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 13 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for James Pooley, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [13-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 12 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Ian N. Feinberg, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [12-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 11 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for William G. Goldman, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [11-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 10 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for Richard M. Goldman, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [10-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 9 MOTION by Adobe Systems Inc. with Proposed Order for M. Elizabeth Day, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [9-1] motion (sm) |
|
So Ordered GRANTING [6-1] motion for Nancy K. Raber, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [7-1] motion for Steven S. Cherensky, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice, GRANTING [8-1] motion for Matthew D. Powers, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
|
So Ordered GRANTING [5-1] stipulation reset Answer deadline to 9/29/00 for Macromedia Inc. ( signed by Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. ) Notice to all parties. (sm)
|
| Filing 8 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Matthew D. Powers, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [8-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 7 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Steven S. Cherensky, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [7-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 6 MOTION by Macromedia Inc. with Proposed Order for Nancy K. Raber, Esq. to Appear Pro Hac Vice re: [6-1] motion (sm) |
| Filing 5 STIPULATION with proposed order that the date by which dft. shall respond to the complaint is extended to 9/29/00. (sm) |
| Filing 4 CASE assigned to Judge Joseph J. Farnan Jr. . Notice to all parties. (ntl) |
| Filing 3 RETURN OF SERVICE executed as to Macromedia Inc. 8/10/00 Answer due on 8/30/00 for Macromedia Inc. (kc) |
| Filing 2 Report to Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks. Exit original. RE: 5,546,528 (kc) |
| Filing 1 COMPLAINT filed; Mag consent notice to pltf. FILING FEE $ 150.00 RECEIPT # 129181 (kc) |
| DEMAND for jury trial by Adobe Systems Inc. (kc) |
| SUMMONS(ES) issued for Macromedia Inc. (kc) |
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the Delaware District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
| Search for this case: Adobe Systems Inc. v. Macromedia Inc. | |
|---|---|
| Search News | [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ] |
| Search Web | [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ] |
| Plaintiff: Adobe Systems Inc. | |
| Represented By: | Mary B. Graham |
| Search News | [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ] |
| Search Finance | [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ] |
| Search Web | [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ] |
| Defendant: Macromedia, Inc. | |
| Represented By: | Steven J. Balick |
| Represented By: | William J. Wade |
| Search News | [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ] |
| Search Finance | [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ] |
| Search Web | [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ] |
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
