Noel v. Ford Motor Company
| Exius Noel, Beatrice Noel, Patrick Chery, Esther Joseph Noel and Mathieu Noel |
| Ford Motor Company |
| 6:2011cv00370 |
| March 10, 2011 |
| US District Court for the Middle District of Florida |
| Orlando Office |
| Osceola |
| John Antoon |
| David A Baker |
| Motor Vehicle Prod. Liability |
| 28 U.S.C. § 1332 Diversity-Auto Negligence |
| Both |
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on May 22, 2013. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| FEES paid by All Defendants (Jury costs $546.62 receipt number ORL-25519) per #97 Order. (LMM) |
Filing 100
ORDER dismissing case and directing the Clerk of the Court to close this file. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 5/22/2013. (BRS)
|
| FEES paid by All Plaintiffs (Jury Costs $546.62 receipt number ORL-25502) re #97 Order. (LMM) |
| Filing 99 NOTICE of compliance re #97 Order Regarding Jury Costs by Beatrice Noel, Esther Joseph Noel, Exius Noel, Mathieu Noel (Bright, David) |
| Filing 98 NOTICE of compliance re #97 Order Regarding Jury Costs by Ford Motor Company (Croftchik, Todd) |
|
Filing 97
ORDER that the parties are assessed jury costs in the amount of $1,093.24 which is to be divided equally between the plaintiffs and the defendant. The parties have 14 days from the date of this order to deposit these funds into the Registry of this Court. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 5/14/2013. CTP (DJD)
|
| Filing 96 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge David A. Baker: SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE held on 5/13/2013. CASE SETTLED. (digital) (HSL) |
|
Filing 95
ORDER denying #57 Ford Motor Company's motion in limine as to Plaintiffs' Trial Exhibits 261, 262, & 263. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 5/7/2013. (EK)
|
| Filing 94 NOTICE to counsel of filing of OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT. The parties have seven (7) calendar days to file with the court a Notice of Intent to Request Redaction of this transcript. If no such Notice is filed, the transcript may be made remotely electronically available to the public without redaction after 90 calendar days. Any party needing a copy of the transcript to review for redaction purposes may purchase a copy from the court reporter or view the document at the clerk's office public terminal. Court Reporter: Amie First (ARF) |
| Filing 93 TRANSCRIPT of Final Pretrial Conference held on 4-29-13 before Judge John Antoon, II. Court Reporter Amie R. First, RPR, CRR, AmieFirst.CourtReporter@gmail.com. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER or purchased through the Court Reporter. Redaction Request due 5/28/2013, Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 6/6/2013, Release of Transcript Restriction set for 8/5/2013. (ARF) |
|
Filing 92
ORDER Granting 90 Motion to Substitute Party. Plaintiffs Esther Joseph Noel and Mathieu Noel, as the Co-Personal Representatives of the Estate of Paulette Noel, Deceased shall be substituted in place of Exius Noel, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paulette Noel, Deceased. The Clerk is directed to amend the style of this case to reflect the substitution. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 5/3/2013. (DJD)
|
|
Filing 91
ORDER denying without prejudice #88 Motion for Tiffany Alexander to withdraw pro has vice admission. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 5/2/2013. (LAK)
|
| Filing 88 MOTION to Withdraw 43 Order on motion to appear pro hac vice of Tiffany Alexander by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 90 ORE TENUS MOTION to Substitute Party plaintiffs and to amend style of case by Patrick Chery, Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel - Court Grants Motion and will enter separate order. (DJD) |
| Filing 89 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Judge John Antoon II: FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE held on 4/29/2013. Court hears argument on motions in limine and objections to exhibits. Trial to commence Monday, May 13, 2013 at 9:00 a.m. - estimated at 10 days. Court Reporter: Amie First (DJD) |
|
Filing 87
ORDER granting in part and denying in part #57 Omnibus Motion in Limine filed by Ford Motor Company. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/26/2013. (EK)
|
| Filing 86 NOTICE of Appearance by Jeffrey A. Cohen on behalf of Ford Motor Company (Cohen, Jeffrey) |
| Filing 85 NOTICE of filing re #84 Exhibit List by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel (Bright, David) Modified on 4/24/2013 (MAL). |
| Filing 84 Exhibit List Pursuant to Court's Minute Entry Doc. 78 by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel.. (Bright, David) |
| Filing 83 NOTICE of filing re #82 Exhibit List by Ford Motor Company (Croftchik, Todd) Modified on 4/24/2013 (MAL). |
| Filing 82 Exhibit List by Ford Motor Company.. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 81 TRIAL CALENDAR for trial term May 2013 - Jury Trial set for 5/13/2013 at 09:00 AM in Orlando Courtroom 6 B before Judge John Antoon II. CTP (DJD) |
|
Filing 80
ORDER allowing laptop computers, cellular telephones and tablet computers into Courtroom No. 6B for use at trial commencing on Monday, May 13, 2013. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/23/2013. CTP (DJD)
|
| Filing 79 NOTICE of hearing: Jury Trial set for date certain on 5/13/2013 at 09:00 AM in Orlando Courtroom 6 B before Judge John Antoon II. CTP (DJD) |
|
Filing 77
ORDER granting in part and denying in part #56 Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/19/2013. (EK)
|
| Filing 78 Minute Entry. Proceedings held before Judge John Antoon II: Granting #71 Motion to allow electronic equipment; Granting #72 Motion to allow electronic equipment - Separate orders to be entered. Denying #73 Motion to Strike trial brief; Granting #75 Motion for Leave to File trial brief; TELEPHONE STATUS CONFERENCE held on 4/18/2013. Court addresses parties' numerous exhibits and objections thereto. Court to rule on Motions in Limine prior to the pretrial conference so objections will be narrowed. Parties agree to two exhibit lists (A list will consist of anticipated exhibits to be admitted) (B list will consist of exhibits possibly to be admitted). Court sets trial for date certain on Monday, May 13, 2013 at 9:00 a.m. Counsel for Pltf: David Bright; Counsel for Deft: Gregory Schuck and Todd Croftchik. Start time: 3:45 p.m; End time: 4:00 p.m. Court Reporter: Amie First (DJD) |
| Filing 76 Exhibit List Amended by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel.. (Bright, David) |
| Filing 75 MOTION for leave to file trial brief re [62, 63 and 64] and RESPONSE to Motion re #73 Amended MOTION to Strike #63 Trial Brief, #62 Trial Brief, #64 Response to motion filed by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Bright, David) Modified on 4/18/2013 (MAL). |
|
Filing 74
ENDORSED ORDER granting #70 Joint Motion for Leave to Amend Plaintiffs' Exhibit List to include Exhibit 449; Plaintiffs shall file the Amended Exhibit List as a separate docket entry within five (5) days from the date of this Order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/17/2013. (BRS)
|
| Filing 73 Amended MOTION to Strike #63 Trial Brief, #62 Trial Brief, #64 Response to motion by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 72 Joint MOTION to allow electronic equipment, specifically Tablet Computers, Lap Top Computers, and/or Cellular Telephones, etc for Trial by All Parties. (Bright, David) Modified on 4/16/2013 (LMM). |
| Filing 71 Joint MOTION to allow electronic equipment, specifically Tablet Computers, Lap Top Computers, and/or Cellular Telephones at Final Pretrial Conference on April 29, 2013 by All Parties. (Bright, David) Modified on 4/16/2013 (LMM). |
| ***PRO HAC VICE FEES paid and Special Admission Attorney Certification Form filed by attorney Jennifer H. Reid, appearing on behalf of Ford Motor Company (Filing fee $10 receipt number Orl-24654.) Related document: #66 MOTION for Jennifer H. Reid to appear pro hac vice. (CH) |
| Filing 70 Joint MOTION for leave to file to Amend Plaintiffs' Exhibit List by All Plaintiffs. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order)(Bright, David) Modified on 4/16/2013 (LMM). |
|
Filing 69
ENDORSED ORDER granting #66 motion to appear pro hac vice. Provided, all counsel shall register for and use the electronic filing system as adopted by the Court. After this Order, the Clerk will no longer send copies of docket entries by U.S. Mail to counsel in this case. Appearance and participation by more than one attorney at any hearing or trial is subject to the discretion of the presiding judge. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 4/15/2013. (Baker, David)
|
|
Filing 68
ENDORSED ORDER denying without prejudice for failure to comply with Local Rule 3.01(g) #67 Motion to Strike. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 4/15/2013. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 67 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Untimely Court Filings by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 66 MOTION for Jennifer H. Reid to appear pro hac vice by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
| Filing 65 JOINT PRETRIAL statement by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel, Patrick Chery and Ford Motor Company (Attachments: #1 Exhibit, #2 Exhibit, #3 Exhibit, #4 Exhibit, #5 Exhibit, #6 Exhibit, #7 Exhibit)(Bright, David) Modified on 4/10/2013 (MAL). |
| Filing 64 RESPONSE to Motion re #57 Omnibus MOTION in limine filed by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel. (Bright, David) |
| Filing 63 TRIAL BRIEF Regarding Admissibility of Evidence of Other Accidents, etc by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel. (Bright, David) |
| Filing 62 TRIAL BRIEF Regarding Non-Preemption of Glazing Claims by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel. (Bright, David) |
| ***PRO HAC VICE FEES paid and Special Admission Attorney Certification Form filed by attorney Gregory L. Schuck, appearing on behalf of Ford Motor Company (Filing fee $10 receipt number ORL-24496.) Related document: #60 MOTION for Gregory L. Schuck to appear pro hac vice. (MAL) |
|
Filing 61
ENDORSED ORDER granting #60 motion to appear pro hac vice. Provided, all counsel shall register for and use the electronic filing system as adopted by the Court. After this Order, the Clerk will no longer send copies of docket entries by U.S. Mail to counsel in this case. Appearance and participation by more than one attorney at any hearing or trial is subject to the discretion of the presiding judge. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 4/8/2013. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 60 MOTION for Gregory L. Schuck to appear pro hac vice by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
| Filing 59 NOTICE of hearing: Final Pretrial Conference set for 4/29/2013 at 09:30 AM in Orlando Courtroom 6 B before Judge John Antoon II. Trial counsel must appear in person at the Final Pretrial Conference. Counsel should be prepared to argue pending motions in limine and any objections to exhibits and witnesses. CTP (DJD) |
| Filing 58 RESPONSE in Opposition re #56 MOTIONS in limine filed by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 57 Omnibus MOTION in limine by Ford Motor Company. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A-G, #2 Exhibit H-I, #3 Exhibit J)(Croftchik, Todd) Modified on 3/4/2013 (JET). |
| Filing 56 MOTIONS in limine by All Plaintiffs. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Bright, David) Modified on 3/4/2013 (JET). |
| Filing 55 NOTICE of Firm Name Change by Ford Motor Company (Croftchik, Todd) Modified on 2/12/2013 (LMM). |
|
Filing 54
ENDORSED ORDER granting #53 Motion to withdraw. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 1/16/2013. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 53 MOTION to withdraw the pro hac vice admission of attorney J. David Byerly, admitted per 47 Order, by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Modified on 1/16/2013 (JET). |
| Filing 52 Amended ANSWER and affirmative defenses with Jury Demand to #22 Amended complaint by Ford Motor Company.(Croftchik, Todd) |
|
Filing 51
ORDER granting #49 Defendant Ford Motor Company's Motion for Leave to Amend Answer and Affirmative Defenses; the Amended Answer and Affirmative Defenses shall be filed as a separate docket entry within seven (7) days from the date of this Order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 12/12/2012. (BRS)
|
|
Filing 50
ORDER denying #48 Motion for leave to file disclosure supplement. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 11/15/2012. (LAK)
|
| Filing 49 MOTION to amend/correct #23 Answer to amended complaint by Ford Motor Company; PROPOSED AMENDED ANSWER ATTACHED. (Croftchik, Todd) Modified on 11/2/2012 (JET). |
| Filing 48 MOTION for leave to file Supplemental Expert Opinions as to Dr. Glenn Ross Caddy by All Plaintiffs. (Didier, Henry) |
|
Filing 47
ENDORSED ORDER granting #46 motion to appear pro hac vice. Provided, all counsel shall register for and use the electronic filing system as adopted by the Court. After this Order, the Clerk will no longer send copies of docket entries by U.S. Mail to counsel in this case. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 8/10/2012. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 46 MOTION for J. David Byerly to appear pro hac vice by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
|
Filing 45
ORDER denying without prejudice #44 motion to appear pro hac vice Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 8/9/2012. (AKJ)
|
| ***PRO HAC VICE FEES paid and Special Admission Attorney Certification Form filed by attorney J. David Byerly appearing on behalf of Ford Motor Company (Filing fee $10 receipt number Orl-18970.) Related document: #46 MOTION for J. David Byerly to appear pro hac vice (VEF) Modified on 8/10/2012 (VEF). |
| Filing 44 MOTION for J. David Byerly to appear pro hac vice by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
| ***PRO HAC VICE FEES paid and Special Admission Attorney Certification Form filed by attorney Tiffany M. Alexander appearing on behalf of Ford Motor Company (Filing fee $10 receipt number ORL017638.) Related document: #42 MOTION for Tiffany Alexander to appear pro hac vice (CBH) |
|
Filing 43
ENDORSED ORDER granting #42 motion to appear pro hac vice. Provided, all counsel shall register for and use the electronic filing system as adopted by the Court. After this Order, the Clerk will no longer send copies of docket entries by U.S. Mail to counsel in this case. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 6/11/2012. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 42 MOTION for Tiffany Alexander to appear pro hac vice by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
| Set/reset scheduling order deadlines: Discovery due by 10/26/2012, Dispositive motions due by 11/30/2012, Pretrial statement due by 4/9/2013, All other motions due by 3/1/2013, Jury Trial set for the trial term commencing on 5/1/2013 before Judge John Antoon II (JET) |
|
Filing 41
ORDER granting #40 Second Amended Joint Motion to modify scheduling order; setting forth new deadlines; setting trial term for May, 2013. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 5/24/2012. (BRS)
|
| Filing 40 SECOND AMENDED Joint MOTION to modify Scheduling Order by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) Modified text on 5/24/2012 (PML). |
|
Filing 39
ENDORSED ORDER STRIKING Notices (doc. nos. 33-38). Rule 68 does not authorize filing of unaccepted Offers of Judgment except with respect to costs post judgment. The Clerk is directed to delete these entries from the electronic docket. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 5/1/2012. (Baker, David) (VEF)
|
| Filing 38 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39 |
| Filing 37 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39 |
| Filing 36 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39 |
| Filing 35 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39 |
| Filing 34 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39 |
| Filing 33 STRICKEN and DELETED per Order #39. |
|
Filing 32
ORDER granting #31 Amended Joint Motion to modify the scheduling order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/25/2012. (BRS)
|
| Set/reset scheduling order deadlines: Discovery due by 7/20/2012, Defendant disclosure of expert report due by 6/13/2012, Plaintiff disclosure of expert report due by 5/16/2012 (PML) |
| Filing 31 Joint MOTION to amend/correct #11 Case management and scheduling order by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
|
Filing 30
ORDER denying without prejudice #29 Joint Motion to modify scheduling order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 4/23/2012. (BRS)
|
| Filing 29 Joint MOTION to modify Scheduling Order by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 28 MEDIATION REPORT Hearing held on April 3, 2012 Hearing outcome: Impasse(Siboni, Michael) |
| ***PRO HAC VICE FEES paid and Special Admission Attorney Certification Form filed by Patrick Chery, Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel (Filing fee $10.00 receipt number ORL 12867.) Related document: #26 MOTION for David T. Bright to appear pro hac vice (CBH) |
|
Filing 27
ENDORSED ORDER granting #26 motion to appear pro hac vice. Provided, all counsel shall register for and use the electronic filing system as adopted by the Court. After this Order, the Clerk will no longer send copies of docket entries by U.S. Mail to counsel in this case. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 12/7/2011. (Baker, David)
|
| Filing 26 MOTION for David T. Bright to appear pro hac vice by All Plaintiffs. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit)(Didier, Henry) Motions referred to Magistrate Judge David A. Baker. |
|
Filing 25
ORDER to strike re: 24 Notice of unavailability filed by Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel, Patrick Chery Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 11/23/2011. (BRS)
|
| Filing 24 NOTICE of unavailability of counsel byPatrick Chery, Beatrice Noel, Exius Noel from December 23, 2011 to January 1, 2012. (Didier, Henry) (STRICKEN BY #25 ORDER ON 11/23/2011) (RDO). |
| Filing 23 ANSWER and affirmative defenses with Jury Demand to #22 Amended complaint by Ford Motor Company.(Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 22 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT against All Defendants with Jury Demand filed by All Plaintiffs. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit)(Didier, Henry) Modified text on 11/7/2011 (PML). |
|
Filing 21
ORDER denying as moot #18 Motion to dismiss; granting #20 motion to amend/correct. Plaintiffs counsel shall file the amended pleading as a separate document. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 11/2/2011. (LAK)
|
| Filing 20 Unopposed MOTION to amend/correct #17 Amended complaint by All Plaintiffs. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, 2nd Amended Complaint, #2 Attachment to Complaint)(Didier, Henry) |
| Filing 19 ANSWER and affirmative defenses with Jury Demand to #17 Amended complaint by Ford Motor Company.(IGC) |
| Filing 18 MOTION to dismiss Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint, Answer and Affirmative Defenses and Demand For Jury Trial by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) **E-mailed attorney to file motions separately in the future (IGC).** |
| Filing 17 AMENDED COMPLAINT against Exius Noel with Jury Demand filed by Exius Noel.(Didier, Henry) |
|
Filing 16
ORDER denying as moot #12 motion to amend/correct; granting #13 motion to amend complaint. Plaintiff shall have 5 days to file an amended complaint as a separate document. Signed by Magistrate Judge David A. Baker on 10/13/2011. COPIES SENT. (LAK)
|
| Filing 15 NOTICE of mediation hearing to be held on April 3, 2012 before Michael C. Siboni. (Didier, Henry) |
|
Filing 14
ORDER directing Plaintiff to file the Notice of Mediation within seven (7) days from the date of this Order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 10/5/2011. (BRS)
|
| Filing 13 MOTION to amend/correct Complaint by Exius Noel. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit)(Gillen, Patrick) |
| Filing 12 Unopposed MOTION to amend/correct #7 Answer to complaint by Ford Motor Company. (Hosley, Frank) |
|
Filing 11
CASE MANAGEMENT AND SCHEDULING ORDER: Amended Pleadings due by 9/30/2011, Joinder of Parties due by 9/30/2011, Discovery due by 6/29/2012, Dispositive motions due by 8/1/2012, Pretrial statement due by 12/13/2012, All other motions due by 11/1/2012, Plaintiff disclosure of expert report due by 5/2/2012, Defendant disclosure of expert report due by 5/31/2012, Jury Trial set for the trial term commencing 1/7/2013 in Orlando Courtroom 6 B before Judge John Antoon II. Conduct mediation hearing by 7/13/2012. Lead counsel to coordinate dates. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 9/1/2011. (DJD)
|
| Filing 10 CASE MANAGEMENT REPORT. (Didier, Henry) |
| Filing 9 NOTICE of pendency of related cases re #2 Related case order and notice of designation of track 2 per Local Rule 1.04(d) by Ford Motor Company. Related case(s): No (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 8 Corporate Disclosure Statement by Ford Motor Company. (Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 7 ANSWER and affirmative defenses to #1 Complaint with Jury Demand by Ford Motor Company.(Croftchik, Todd) |
| Filing 6 Summons issued as to Ford Motor Company. (CBH) |
| Filing 5 NOTICE of pendency of related cases re #2 Related case order and notice of designation of track 2 per Local Rule 1.04(d) by Exius Noel. Related case(s): no (Didier, Henry) |
| Filing 4 CERTIFICATE of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement re #3 Interested persons order by Exius Noel. (Didier, Henry) |
|
Filing 3
INTERESTED PERSONS ORDER. Certificate of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement due within 14 days from the date of this order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 3/22/2011. Copies mailed/e-mailed.(DJD)
|
|
Filing 2
RELATED CASE ORDER AND NOTICE of designation under Local Rule 3.05 - track 2. Notice of pendency of other actions due within 14 days from the date of this order. Signed by Judge John Antoon II on 3/22/2011. Copies mailed/e-mailed.(DJD)
|
| Filing 1 COMPLAINT against Ford Motor Company with Jury Demand (Filing fee $ 350 receipt number Orl005622) filed by Exius Noel. (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet)(CBH) Modified on 3/14/2011 (CBH). |
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the Florida Middle District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
