Howard Avenue Station, LLC v. Ortiz et al
Appellant: Howard Avenue Station, LLC
Interested Party: The Dubliner, Inc. and Richard Campion
Appellee: Frank Kane and Thomas Ortiz
Case Number: 8:2020cv02780
Filed: November 24, 2020
Court: US District Court for the Middle District of Florida
Presiding Judge: Charlene Edwards Honeywell
Nature of Suit: Bankruptcy Appeal (801)
Cause of Action: 28 U.S.C. § 0158
Jury Demanded By: None
Docket Report

This docket was last retrieved on September 22, 2022. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.

Date Filed Document Text
January 22, 2021 Opinion or Order Filing 12 MOTION to Consolidate Cases by Howard Avenue Station, LLC. (DeGrave, Heather)
January 11, 2021 Opinion or Order Filing 11 NOTICE of docketing bankruptcy record on appeal advising counsel to comply with Rule 8018. Notice of appeal filed in U.S. District Court on 11/24/2020. (MCB)
January 8, 2021 Opinion or Order Filing 10 BANKRUPTCY RECORD on appeal consisting of items as designated on transmittal Related document: #1 Bankruptcy Notice of Appeal filed by Howard Avenue Station, LLC. (Attachments: #1 2 - Notice_of_Appeal_of_Amended_Final_Judgment_Resolving_Adversary_Proceeding_Doc_242_date, #2 3 - Order_being_Appealed - Amended_Final_Judgment_Resolving_Adversary_Proceeding, #3 4 - Appellant_Designation_of_Contents_for_Inclusion_in_Record_on_Appeal_Filed_by_Heather_A_De, #4 5 - Statement_of_Issues_on_Appeal_Filed_by_Heather_A_DeGrave_on_behalf_of_Plaintiff_Howard_A, #5 6 - Appellee_Designation_of_Contents_for_Inclusion_in_Record_of_Appeal_Filed_by_Eric_D_Jacobs, #6 7 - Public Docket, #7 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000001_Complaint_For_Turnover_of_Property_of_the_Estate_by_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLC_against_The, #8 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000003_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_attached_Exhibit_A_and_Exhibit_B_to_Complaint_for_Turnover_of_Property_of, #9 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000003_Part_2_Exhibit_A_-_Commercial_Lease, #10 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000003_Part_3_Exhibit_B_-_Dubliner_Lease_Agreement, #11 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000017_Part_1_Motion_For_Summary_Judgment_Filed_by_James_W_Elliott_on_behalf_of_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue, #12 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000017_Part_2_Exhibit_A, #13 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000017_Part_3_Exhibit_B, #14 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000020_Answer_to_Complaint_and_Affirmative_Defenses, #15 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000022_Answer_to_Complaint_And_Affirmative_Defenses, #16 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000023_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Affidavit_of_Richard_Campion_in_Opposition_to_Plaintiffs_Motion_for_Summ, #17 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000023_Part_2_Exhibit_Affidavit, #18 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000024_Response_to_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLCs_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_and_Cross, #19 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000027_Answer_to_Counterclaim, #20 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000029_Memorandum_of_Law_in_Response_to_Frank_R_Kanes_Response_to_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Stati, #21 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000032_Reply_to_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLCs_Memorandum_of_Law_in_Response_to_Frank_R, #22 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000037_Order_Granting_Ore_Tenus_Motion_to_Intervene_as_Defendant_by_Frank_R_Kane, #23 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000039_Transcript_Regarding_Hearing_Held_12122012_on_1-Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_by_Plaintiff, #24 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000042_Order_On_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLCs_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_And_Frank_R_Ka, #25 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_1_Affidavit_in_Support_of_Debtors_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_Filed_by_James_W_Elliott_on_b, #26 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_2_Exhibit_A_-_Lease, #27 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_3_Composite_Exhibit_B, #28 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_4_Composite_Exhibit_C, #29 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_5_Exhibit_D, #30 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_6_Exhibit_E, #31 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_7_Exhibit_F, #32 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_8_Exhibit_G, #33 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000045_Part_9_Exhibit_H, #34 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000051_Supplemental_Response_to_Debtors_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_and_Opposition_to_Affidavit, #35 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000052_Notice_of_Filing_Declaration_of_Frank_R_Kane_Filed_by_Kathleen_L_DiSanto_on_behalf_of_Def, #36 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_1_Supplemental_Response_to_and_Memorandum_of_Law_in_Support_of_Debtors_Motion_for_Summary_J, #37 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_2_Exhibit_A, #38 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_3_Composite_Exhibit_B, #39 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_4_Exhibit_C, #40 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_5_Composite_Exhibit_D, #41 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_6_Exhibit_E, #42 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_7_Exhibit_F, #43 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_8_Exhibit_G, #44 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_9_Composite_Exhibit_H, #45 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_10_Exhibit_I, #46 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_11_Composite_Exhibit_J, #47 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_12_Exhibit_K, #48 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_13_Exhibit_L, #49 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_14_Composite_Exhibit_M, #50 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_15_Exhibit_N, #51 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_16_Exhibit_O, #52 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_17_Exhibit_P_Part_1, #53 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_17_Exhibit_P_Part_2, #54 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_17_Exhibit_P_Part_3, #55 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000055_Part_18_Exhibit_P, #56 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000059_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_and_Request_to_Take_Judicial_Notice_Filed_by_Peter_Jackie_Muchunas_on_beh, #57 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000059_Part_2_Transcript_Pages_1_thru_56, #58 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000059_Part_3_Transcript_Pages_57_thru_112, #59 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000059_Part_4_Transcript_Pages_113_thru_169, #60 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000064_Affidavit_of_Jack_M_Greene, #61 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000065_Affidavit_of_Tommy_Ortiz_Authenticating_Filed_by_Peter_Jackie_Muchunas_on_behalf_of_Plaint, #62 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000066_Affidavit_of_W_Bart_Meacham_Filed_by_Peter_Jackie_Muchunas_on_behalf_of_Plaintiff_Howard, #63 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_and_Request_to_Take_Judicial_Notice_as_to_the_Deposition_of_Thomas_Ortiz, #64 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_2_Transcript_-_Deposition_of_Thomas_Ortiz, #65 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_3_Exhibit_A_-_70209_E-mal, #66 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_4_Exhibit_B_-_Memorandum_of_Understanding, #67 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_5_Exhibit_C_-_71609_E-mail, #68 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_6_Exhibit_D_-_72009_E-mail, #69 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_7_Exhibit_E-_Termination_of_Master_Lease, #70 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_8_Exhibit_F_-_Commercial_Lease, #71 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000067_Part_9_Exhibit_G_-_Description_of_Premises, #72 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_1_Amended_Notice_of_Filing_and_Request_to_Take_Judicial_Notice_Filed_by_Peter_Jackie_Muchun, #73 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_2_Certified_Dubliner_Complaint, #74 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_3_Certified_Defendants_Answer_to_Dubliner_Complaint, #75 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_4_Certified_Dubliners_Answer_to_Counter-Claims, #76 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_5_Certified_Partial_Final_Judgment, #77 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000068_Part_6_Certified_Final_Judgment, #78 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000069_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_and_Request_to_Take_Judicial_Notice_as_to_the_Exhibit_L_Filed_by_Peter, #79 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000069_Part_2_Certified_Complaint_for_Eviction_and_Damages_by_Frank_R_Kane, #80 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000070_Notice_of_Filing_Certified_Copy_of_Commercial_Lease_Filed_by_Kathleen_L_DiSanto_on_behalf, #81 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000071_Notice_of_Filing_Affidavit_of_William_J_Podolsky_III_Filed_by_Kathleen_L_DiSanto_on_beha, #82 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000072_Notice_of_Filing_Supplemental_Declaration_of_Frank_R_Kane_in_Support_of_Frank_R_Kanes_R, #83 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000073_Declaration_re_of_Jack_Greene_Filed_by_Kathleen_L_DiSanto_on_behalf_of_Counter-Claimant_F, #84 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000075_Motion_to_Supplement_the_Record_in_Accordance_with_Federal_Rule_of_Evidence_106_Filed_by_K, #85 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000081_Order_Granting_Motion_to_Supplement_the_Record_in_Accordance_with_Federal_Rule_of_Evidence, #86 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000083_Transcript_Regarding_Hearing_Held_3262013_on_1_-_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_by_Plaintif, #87 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000084_Transcript_Regarding_Hearing_Held_3292013_on_1_-_Continued_Hearing_on_Motion_for_Summary, #88 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000089_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Supplemental_Affidavit_of_Richard_Campion_in_Opposition_to_Howard_Avenue, #89 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000089_Part_2_Affidavit, #90 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000093_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_attached_Supplemental_Affidavit_of_Jack_M_Greene_Filed_by_Richard_J_McIn, #91 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000093_Part_2_Supplemental_Affidavit_of_Jack_M_Greene, #92 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000094_Supplemental_Memorandum_of_Law_in_Support_of_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLCs_Motion, #93 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000098_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Designation_of_Portion_of_Transcript, #94 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000098_Part_2_Excerpt_-_page_84_line_5_to_page_86_line_17, #95 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000099_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Designation_of_Portion_of_Transcript, #96 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000099_Part_2_Excerpt_-_page_84_line_5_to_page_86_line_17, #97 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000100_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Designation_of_Portion_of_Transcript, #98 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000100_Part_2_Excerpt_-_page_17_line_2_to_page_18_line_16, #99 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000100_Part_3_Excerpt_-_page_26_lines_1-12, #100 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000100_Part_4_Excerpt_-_page_70_line_16_to_page_71_line_7, #101 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000100_Part_5_Excerpt_-_page_101_line_6_to_page_102_line_3, #102 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000101_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Designations_of_Reformation_Trial_Testimony_of_William_J_Podolsky_in_Sup, #103 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000101_Part_2_Exhibit_A, #104 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000101_Part_3_Exhibit_B, #105 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000105_Transcript_Regarding_Hearing_Held_12-17-13_on_Status_Conference_to_Announce_Ruling_on_Moti, #106 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000111_Renewed_Motion_For_Summary_Judgment_on_Collateral_Estoppel_Grounds_Filed_by_Eric_D_Jacobs, #107 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000119_Part_1_Opposition_to_Defendant_Frank_R_Kanes_Renewed_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_on_Collateral, #108 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000119_Part_2_Exhibit_A, #109 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000121_Reply_Frank_R_Kanes_Reply_to_Plaintiff_Howard_Avenue_Station_LLCs_Response_in_Opposit, #110 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000123_Transcript_Regarding_Hearing_Held_62014_on_Renewed_Motion_for_Summary_Judgment_on_Collat, #111 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000126_Notice_of_Filing_Supplemental_Authority_Filed_by_Eric_D_Jacobs_on_behalf_of_Defendant_Fran, #112 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000128_Part_1_Notice_of_Filing_Certified_Court_Record_for_Case_No_07-CA-006072_Filed_by_John_R_Hightow, #113 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000128_Part_2_Exhibit_Court_Record_for_Case_No_07-CA-006072_Part_1, #114 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000128_Part_2_Exhibit_Court_Record_for_Case_No_07-CA-006072_Part_2, #115 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000128_Part_2_Exhibit_Court_Record_for_Case_No_07-CA-006072_Part_3, #116 8-12-ap-00935_Docket_000128_Part_2_Exhibit_Court_Record_f
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 9 CERTIFICATE of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement re #3 Interested persons order by Howard Avenue Station, LLC. (DeGrave, Heather)
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 8 NOTICE of pendency of related cases of Howard Avenue Station, LLC per Local Rule 1.04(d) by Howard Avenue Station, LLC. Related case(s): yes (DeGrave, Heather)
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 7 CERTIFICATE of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement re #3 Interested persons order by The Dubliner, Inc. (Busch, Wendolyn) Modified text on 12/9/2020 (MCB).
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 6 NOTICE of pendency of related cases re #2 Related case order and track 1 notice per Local Rule 1.04(d) by The Dubliner, Inc. Related case(s): yes (Busch, Wendolyn) Modified text on 12/9/2020 (MCB).
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 5 CERTIFICATE of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement re #3 Interested persons order by Frank Kane. (Jacobs, Eric)
December 9, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 4 NOTICE of pendency of related cases per Local Rule 1.04(d) by Frank Kane. Related case(s): Yes (Jacobs, Eric)
November 25, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 3 INTERESTED PERSONS ORDER. Certificate of interested persons and corporate disclosure statement due by 12/9/2020. Signed by Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell on 11/25/2020. (BGS)
November 25, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 2 RELATED CASE ORDER AND NOTICE of designation under Local Rule 3.05 - track 1. Notice of pendency of other actions due by 12/9/2020. Signed by Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell on 11/25/2020. (BGS)
November 24, 2020 Opinion or Order Filing 1 BANKRUPTCY notice of appeal by Howard Avenue Station, LLC. Bankruptcy Court case number 8:12-bk-08821-CPM. Filed in Bankruptcy Court on 11/20/2020. (Attachments: #1 Bankruptcy Court's Transmittal)(MCB)

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the Florida Middle District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

Search for this case: Howard Avenue Station, LLC v. Ortiz et al
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Appellant: Howard Avenue Station, LLC
Represented By: Stuart Jay Levine
Represented By: Heather A. DeGrave
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Interested party: The Dubliner, Inc.
Represented By: Wendolyn S. Busch
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Interested party: Richard Campion
Represented By: Wendolyn S. Busch
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Appellee: Frank Kane
Represented By: Eric David Jacobs
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Appellee: Thomas Ortiz
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?