Charles Robbins v. Gerber Products Company et al
Plaintiff: Charles Robbins
Defendant: Gerber Products Company, Gerber Products Company doing business as Nestle Nuitrition doing business as Nestle Infant Nutrition doing business as Nestle Nutrition North America and Nurture, Inc. doing business as Happy Family Brands doing business as Happy Family Organics
Case Number: CAC/2:21-CV-01457
Filed: February 17, 2021
Court: Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation
Presiding Judge: James V Selna
Nature of Suit: Other
RSS RSS Track this Docket
Docket Report

This docket was last retrieved on June 7, 2021. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.

Date Filed Document Text
April 15, 2021 Opinion or Order Filing 26 HEARING ORDER re: pldg. ( #1 in MDL No. 2997) - SECTION A (DESIGNATED FOR ORAL ARGUMENT) PANEL HEARING set for 5/27/2021 in Washington, DC font>. Notices of Presentation or Waiver of Oral Argument due on or before 5/3/2021.#Notice of Presentation or Waiver of Oral Argument form (JPML form 9) can be downloaded from our website.Signed by Judge Karen K. Caldwell, Chair, PANEL ON MULTIDISTRICT LITIGATION, on 4/15/2021. Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (RH)
April 13, 2021 Filing 25 RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION -- (re: pldg. ( #1 in MDL No. 2997) ) Filed by Defendants Beech-Nut Nutrition Company, #et al.Gerber Products Company, Nurture, Inc., The Hain Celestial Gr oup, Inc., Plum, PBC, CAMPBELL SOUP COMPANY, Sprout Foods, Inc. #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D, #5 Exhibit E, #6 Exhibit F, #7 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Panos, Dean)
April 13, 2021 Filing 24 RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION -- (re: pldg. ( #1 in MDL No. 2997) ) Filed by Plaintiffs Ashley Allen, #et al.Emily Baccari, Jeremy Cantor, Kaitlynn Carson, Amber Caudill, Neisha Daniels , Jillian Geffken, Hannah Grandt, Dominick Grossi, Anthony Harrison, Christina Holland, Heather Hyden, Heather McCormick, Haley Sams, Vito Scarola, ASHLEY ALLEN, EMILY BACCARI, JEREMY CANTOR, KAITLYNN CARSON, AMBER CAUDILL, NEISHA DANIELS, FELICIA DYKES, JILLIAN GEFFKEN, JESSICA GOODPASTURE, HANNAH GRANDT, DOMINICK GROSSI, GALENA GUTIERREZ, ANTHONY HARRISON, CHRISTINA HOLLAND, HEATHER HYDEN, MERCEDES JONES, LISA LOSIEWICZ, HEATHER MCCORMICK, TERRIE MCDONALD, HALEY SAMS, VITO SCAROLA, BAYLEE SCHAEFER, NATALIA STOROSHKO, ARIANE THOMAS, Emily Baccari, Dominick Grossi, Heather Hyden, Haley Sams, Vito Scarola, EMILY BACCARI, JILLIAN GEFFKEN, HEATHER HYDEN, MERCEDES JONES #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Bloch, Steven)
April 13, 2021 Filing 23 RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION -- (re: pldg. ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) ) Filed by Plaintiffs Riley Bucci, #et al.Kelsey Gross, Jenna Johnson, Abbey Johnston, Elaine Lake, Stevie McCartin, Courtney Nemmers, Jessica Scott, Tracy Tankard, Mallory VanDyke, Lauren Smith #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (French-Hodson, Ruth Anne)
April 8, 2021 Filing 22 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (CORRECTED) re: pldg.( 66 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Steven L. Bloch on behalf of Plaintiffs EMILY BACCARI, #et al.JILLIAN GEFFKEN, HEATHER HYDEN, MERCEDES JONES #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Schedule of Actions Corrected, #2 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Bloch, Steven) Modified on 4/8/2021 (LH). EDITED EVENT NAME AND MDL LINK
April 6, 2021 Filing 21 INTERESTED PARTY RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION -- (re: pldg. ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) ) Filed by Plaintiffs Andrea Kelly, Cole Millican (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service re Response in Partial Support) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Frank, Cody) Modified on 4/7/2021 (LH). EDITED EVENT NAME
April 6, 2021 Filing 20 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. ( #73 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Plaintiffs Kendra Anderson, Marla Micks -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Sheehan, Spencer)
March 31, 2021 Filing 19 SEE CORRECTED PLEADING (re: pldg. ( 78 in MDL No. 2997)) NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( 1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Spencer I Sheehan on behalf of Plaintiffs Lumarie Lopez-Sanchez, #et al.Kendra Anderson, Marla Micks, Kelsey Gancarz, Stephanie Soto #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Sheehan, Spencer) Modified on 4/7/2021 (LH). ADDED NOTATION
March 29, 2021 Filing 18 SEE CORRECTED PLEADING (re: pldg. ( 88 in MDL No. 2997)) NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( 1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Steven L. Bloch on behalf of Plaintiffs Ashley Allen, #et al.Jeremy Cantor, Dominick Grossi, Anthony Harrison, Heather Hyden, Haley Sams, Vito Scarola, ASHLEY ALLEN, JEREMY CANTOR, DOMINICK GROSSI, ANTHONY HARRISON, HEATHER HYDEN, LISA LOSIEWICZ, HALEY SAMS, VITO SCAROLA, Emily Baccari, Dominick Grossi, Heather Hyden, Haley Sams, Vito Scarola, EMILY BACCARI, JILLIAN GEFFKEN, HEATHER HYDEN, MERCEDES JONES #[Suppress List] (Attachments: #1 Schedule of Actions, #2 Proof of Service Amended Certificate of Service to Include Counsel of Record for Defendants Campbell Soup Company and Plum, PBC) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Bloch, Steven) Modified on 4/8/2021 (LH). ADDED NOTATION
March 26, 2021 Filing 17 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (CORRECTED) re: pldg.( 1 in MDL No. 2997), ( 57 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Timothy J. Peter on behalf of Plaintiffs Miranda Fogle, Katesha Smith (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Peter, Timothy) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). EDITED EVENT NAME AND ADDED MDL LINK
March 26, 2021 Filing 16 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. ( 27 in MDL No. 2997), ( #26 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Defendant Gerber Products Company -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Merryman, Bryan) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 26, 2021 Filing 15 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. ( 61 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Defendant Hain Celestial Group, Inc. -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Panos, Dean) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 25, 2021 Filing 14 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. ( 34 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Defendant Nurture, Inc. -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYN/1:21-cv-00271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534 (Agrusa, Angela) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 23, 2021 Filing 13 SEE CORRECTED PLEADING (re: pldg. ( 65 in MDL No. 2997)) NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( 1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Timothy J. Peter on behalf of Plaintiffs Miranda Fogle, Katesha Smith (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997 et al. (Peter, Timothy) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). ADDED NOTATION
March 23, 2021 Filing 12 ***TEXT ONLY ENTRY***MINUTE ORDER (re: pldg. ( #49 in MDL No. 2997) ) -- Motion of: Defendants Nurture, Inc., et al. for Extension of Time to File Response -- GRANTED TO ALL PARTIES. Responses due on or before 4/13/2021. Reply, if any, due on or before 4/20/2021. Signed by Clerk of the Panel John W. Nichols on 3/23/2021. Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, CAN/4:21-cv-00913, CAN/4:21-cv-01113, CAN/4:21-cv-01763, CO/1:21-cv-00500, FLM/6:21-cv-00317, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, ILN/1:21-cv-00835, KS/2:21-cv-02096, MN/0:21-cv-00666, MOW/4:21-cv-00129, NJ/1:21-cv-02417, NJ/1:21-cv-04650, NJ/2:21-cv-01977, NJ/2:21-cv-02516, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NJ/2:21-cv-03402, NJ/2:21-cv-04791, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-00678, NYE/2:21-cv-00758, NYE/2:21-cv-00805, NYE/2:21-cv-00884, NYE/2:21-cv-00938, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYE/2:21-cv-00970, NYE/2:21-cv-01045, NYE/2:21-cv-01062, NYE/2:21-cv-01067, NYE/2:21-cv-01076, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYN/1:21-cv-00133, NYN/1:21-cv-00167, NYN/1:21-cv-00183, NYN/1:21-cv-00186, NYN/1:21-cv-00200, NYN/1:21-cv-00213, NYN/1:21-cv-00227, NYN/1:21-cv-00229, NYN/1:21-cv-00258, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534, VAE/1:21-cv-00269, VAE/1:21-cv-00277, VAE/1:21-cv-00321 (JN)
March 23, 2021 Filing 11 MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE RESPONSE re: pldg. ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Angela Christine Agrusa on behalf of Defendant Nurture, Inc Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534 (Agrusa, Angela) Modified on 3/25/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 22, 2021 Filing 10 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT re: pldg. ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) -- Identifying Corporate Parent Danone S.A. for Nurture, Inc. Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534 (Agrusa, Angela) Modified on 3/23/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 22, 2021 Filing 9 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( #15 in MDL No. 2997), ( 12 in MDL No. 2997), ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Angela Christine Agrusa on behalf of Defendant Nurture, Inc. Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534 (Agrusa, Angela) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 19, 2021 Filing 8 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT re: pldg. ( 1 in MDL No. 2997) -- Identifying Corporate Parent Nestle S.A., Corporate Parent Nestle Holdings, Inc. for Gerber Products Company (Attachments: #1 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, MN/0:21-cv-00666, NJ/2:21-cv-01977, NJ/2:21-cv-02516, NJ/2:21-cv-03402, NJ/2:21-cv-04791, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, VAE/1:21-cv-00269 (Merryman, Bryan) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 19, 2021 Filing 7 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( #15 in MDL No. 2997), ( #21 in MDL No. 2997), ( 12 in MDL No. 2997), ( 1 in MDL No. 2997), ( #16 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Bryan A Merryman on behalf of Defendant Gerber Products Company (Attachments: #1 Schedule of Actions, #2 Proof of Service) Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/3:21-cv-01600, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, KS/2:21-cv-02096, MN/0:21-cv-00666, NJ/2:21-cv-01977, NJ/2:21-cv-02516, NJ/2:21-cv-03402, NJ/2:21-cv-04791, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/1:21-cv-01287, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, VAE/1:21-cv-00269 (Merryman, Bryan) Modified on 3/29/2021 (LH). REMOVED DUPLICATE PARTIES
March 16, 2021 Filing 6 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. (5 in CAC/2:21-cv-01457, #10 in MDL No. 2997, 5 in NYE/2:21-cv-00944, 5 in NYN/1:21-cv-00229) Filed by Plaintiffs Charles Robbins, #et al.Mic hael Motherway, Leiba Baumgarten #[Suppress List] -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYN/1:21-cv-00229 (Sultzer, Jason)
March 11, 2021 Filing 5 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE (AMENDED) re: pldg. (4 in CAC/2:21-cv-01457, #8 in MDL No. 2997, 4 in NYE/2:21-cv-00944, 4 in NYN/1:21-cv-00229) Filed by Plaintiffs Charles Robbins, #et al.Mich ael Motherway, Leiba Baumgarten #[Suppress List] -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYN/1:21-cv-00229 (Sultzer, Jason)
March 10, 2021 Filing 4 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE re: pldg. ( #5 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Plaintiffs Charles Robbins, #et al.Michael Motherway, Leiba Baumgarten #[Suppress List] -- Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:2 1-cv-01457, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYN/1:21-cv-00229 (Sultzer, Jason)
March 9, 2021 Filing 3 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE re: pldg.( #1 in MDL No. 2997) Filed by Jason Sultzer on behalf of Plaintiffs Charles Robbins, #et al.Michael Motherway, Leiba Baumgarten #[Suppress List] Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYN/1:21-cv-00229 (Sultzer, Jason)
March 9, 2021 Filing 2 ***TEXT ONLY NOTICE***NOTICE OF FILING AND PUBLICATION OF BRIEFING SCHEDULE re: pldg. ( #1 in MDL No. 2997) BRIEFING SCHEDULE IS SET AS FOLLOWS:< br< Notices of Appearance due on or before 3/23/2021. Corporate Disclosure Statements due on or before 3/23/2021. Responses due on or before 3/30/2021. Reply, if any, due on or before 4/6/2021. In their briefs, the parties should address what steps they have taken to pursue alternatives to centralization (including, but not limited to, engaging in informal coordination of discovery and scheduling, and seeking Section 1404 transfer of one or more of the subject cases). #Appearance forms (JPML form 18) and #Corporate Disclosure forms can be downloaded from our website. Important: A Corporate Disclosure Form, if required, must be filed, even if one has previously been filed in this MDL.Please visit the #CM/ECF Filing Guidelines < Forms page of our website for additional information.Signed by Clerk of the Panel John W. Nichols on 3/9/2021. Associated Cases: MDL No. 2997, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/4:21-cv-00913, CAN/4:21-cv-01113, CO/1:21-cv-00500, FLM/6:21-cv-00317, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, ILN/1:21-cv-00835, KS/2:21-cv-02096, MOW/4:21-cv-00129, NJ/1:21-cv-02417, NJ/2:21-cv-01977, NJ/2:21-cv-02516, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NJ/2:21-cv-03402, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/2:21-cv-00678, NYE/2:21-cv-00758, NYE/2:21-cv-00805, NYE/2:21-cv-00884, NYE/2:21-cv-00938, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYE/2:21-cv-00970, NYE/2:21-cv-01045, NYE/2:21-cv-01062, NYE/2:21-cv-01067, NYE/2:21-cv-01076, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYN/1:21-cv-00133, NYN/1:21-cv-00167, NYN/1:21-cv-00183, NYN/1:21-cv-00186, NYN/1:21-cv-00200, NYN/1:21-cv-00213, NYN/1:21-cv-00227, NYN/1:21-cv-00229, NYN/1:21-cv-00258, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534, VAE/1:21-cv-00269, VAE/1:21-cv-00277 (DP)
March 9, 2021 Filing 1 MDL Number 2997 Assigned -- MOTION FOR TRANSFER ACCEPTED FOR FILING re: pldg. ( #1 in Pending No. 19) Associated Cases: Pending No. 19, CAC/2:21-cv-01457, CAN/4:21-cv-00913, CAN/4:21- cv-01113, CO/1:21-cv-00500, FLM/6:21-cv-00317, ILN/1:21-cv-00719, ILN/1:21-cv-00835, KS/2:21-cv-02096, MOW/4:21-cv-00129, NJ/1:21-cv-02417, NJ/2:21-cv-01977, NJ/2:21-cv-02516, NJ/2:21-cv-02531, NJ/2:21-cv-03402, NYE/1:21-cv-00870, NYE/2:21-cv-00678, NYE/2:21-cv-00758, NYE/2:21-cv-00805, NYE/2:21-cv-00884, NYE/2:21-cv-00938, NYE/2:21-cv-00944, NYE/2:21-cv-00970, NYE/2:21-cv-01045, NYE/2:21-cv-01062, NYE/2:21-cv-01067, NYE/2:21-cv-01076, NYE/2:21-cv-01118, NYN/1:21-cv-00133, NYN/1:21-cv-00167, NYN/1:21-cv-00183, NYN/1:21-cv-00186, NYN/1:21-cv-00200, NYN/1:21-cv-00213, NYN/1:21-cv-00227, NYN/1:21-cv-00229, NYN/1:21-cv-00258, NYS/1:21-cv-01217, NYS/1:21-cv-01271, NYS/1:21-cv-01473, NYS/1:21-cv-01882, NYS/7:21-cv-01534, VAE/1:21-cv-00269, VAE/1:21-cv-00277 (DP)

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

Search for this case: Charles Robbins v. Gerber Products Company et al
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Charles Robbins
Represented By: Michael R. Reese
Represented By: Thomas S Alch
Represented By: Joseph Lipari
Represented By: Jason Sultzer
Represented By: David R. Shoop
Represented By: Daniel H. Markowitz
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Gerber Products Company
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Gerber Products Company doing business as Nestle Nuitrition doing business as Nestle Infant Nutrition doing business as Nestle Nutrition North America
Represented By: Catherine S Simonsen
Represented By: Bryan A Merryman
Represented By: Gerber Products Company
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Nurture, Inc. doing business as Happy Family Brands doing business as Happy Family Organics
Represented By: Angela Christine Agrusa
Represented By: George J. Gigounas
Represented By: Nurture, Inc.
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?