Maxon Hyundai Mazda et al v. Carfax, Inc.
Plaintiff: Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, R &J Nissan LLC, Barry's Auto Center, Inc., R&J Nissan, LLC, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., E.M. Rinehart Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, Best Auto Outlet, Inc., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, Dutchess Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Tamaroff Motors, Inc., J.O. Stevenson, Inc., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, B.C.T. Imports Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, BTLS, Inc., Heinrich Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, M & S of Pawling, Inc., Towson Automotive, Inc., Galesburg Nissan Corp., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Auto LLC, Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Rine Motors Inc., Subaru World of Newton, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Salerno Duane Inc., Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Manfredi Chevrolet, RB Automotive Group Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., Acton Toyota of Littleton, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Team Precision Auto LLC, Habberstad Nissan, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, Toyota World of Lakewood, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., City Motors LLC, Frangie Motors Inc., Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Dijos Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., NYLSI Inc., Sutton Ford Inc., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, William T. Pritchard, Inc,, ADA Motors Inc., Schumacher Automotive, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Brentlinger Enterprises, Cape Hy, Inc., Lyford Motors LLC, Rallye Automotive LLC, James Toyota, Nissan World of Springfield, Bayside Chrysler, Rockville Cars, LLC, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Schumacher Auto Group, JBA Automotive LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Tirrico Inc., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Smithtown Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Price Simms Ford, LLC, J.O.S., Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Nissan World of Denville, Salerno * Duane Infiniti, Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Merrimac Motors, Inc., Manfredi Motors Inc., DGM, L.L.C., Hanford Toyota, Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Elk Grove Kia, Balise JRN, Inc., County Line Carriage Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Nissan sales Corp., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Mack Auto Imports Inc., Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Sutton Ford Lincoln and Stevenson Cars, Inc.
Case Number: 1:2013cv02680
Filed: April 23, 2013
Court: US District Court for the Southern District of New York
Office: Foley Square Office
County: New York
Presiding Judge: Ronald L Ellis
Referring Judge: Alison J Nathan
Nature of Suit: Anti-Trust
Cause of Action: 15 U.S.C. § 1 Antitrust Litigation (Monopolizing Trade)
Jury Demanded By: Plaintiff
RSS RSS Track this Docket
Docket Report

This docket was last retrieved on May 23, 2022. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.

Date Filed Document Text
May 23, 2022 Opinion or Order Filing 203 SEALED MATERIALS DISPOSED: Document(s) 196 were destroyed since the filing party did not retrieve the material(s) within 30 days of the date indicated. The sealed record(s) were destroyed on 05/23/2022..(jus)
May 23, 2022 Opinion or Order Filing 202 SEALED MATERIALS DISPOSED: Document(s) 53 and 100 were destroyed since the filing party did not retrieve the material(s) within 30 days of the date indicated. The sealed record(s) were destroyed on 05/23/2022..(jus)
April 22, 2022 Opinion or Order Filing 201 NOTICE TO ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE SEALED MATERIAL: Notice to the attorney of record for the filing party to retrieve sealed document number 196 within thirty (30) days, or the Court will dispose of them. Sealed Records Retrieval due by 5/23/2022. .(jus)
April 22, 2022 Opinion or Order Filing 200 NOTICE TO ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE SEALED MATERIAL: Notice to the attorney of record for the filing party to retrieve sealed document number 53 and 100 within thirty (30) days, or the Court will dispose of them. Sealed Records Retrieval due by 5/23/2022. .(jus)
July 17, 2018 Opinion or Order Filing 199 TAXATION OF COSTS: as to #198 Bill of Costs Notice of Taxation. Costs are taxed on July 17, 2018 in favor of Carfax, Inc. against Maxon Hyundai Mazda, et al., in the amount of $9,266.60. Done on Submission, no objections filed.(dt)
July 17, 2018 Opinion or Order Minute Entry Bill of Costs: Done on submission 7/17/2018, no objections filed. (dt)
June 29, 2018 Opinion or Order Filing 198 BILL OF COSTS NOTICE OF TAXATION to recover costs against All Plaintiffs. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. The Clerk may tax costs 14 days after this filing. Objections to Bill of Costs due by 7/13/2018 (Attachments: #1 Affidavit)(Cooper, James)
June 25, 2018 Opinion or Order Filing 197 MANDATE of USCA (Certified Copy) as to #170 Notice of Appeal filed by MAXON HYUNDAI MAZDA, ET AL. USCA Case Number 16-3717-cv. UPON DUE CONSIDERATION, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED that the judgment entered on September 30, 2016, is AFFIRMED.. Catherine O'Hagan Wolfe, Clerk USCA for the Second Circuit. Issued As Mandate: 06/25/2018. (nd)
October 31, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 196 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault.(rz)
October 30, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 195 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Eric L. Cramer dated 07/15/2016 re: Reply Expert Report of Hal J. Singer, Ph.D.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Reply Expert Report of Hal J. Singer, Ph.D. dated July 15, 2016)(Warlick, Sarah)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 194 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Defendant Carfax, Inc.'s Reply in Support of its Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Reply to Plaintiffs' Rule 56.1 Response to Defendant's Rule 56.1 Statement of Facts, Reply Expert Report of Professor Robert Willig, Ph.D., Declaration of Joe Koenig, and Transmittal Declaration of Sarah Warlick, together with attached exhibits served on Attorneys for Plaintiffs on 06/24/16. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 193 REPLY Expert Report of Robert Willig. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2)(Cooper, James)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 192 DECLARATION of Sarah E. Warlick in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 326, #2 Exhibit 327, #3 Exhibit 328, #4 Exhibit 329, #5 Exhibit 330, #6 Exhibit 331, #7 Exhibit 332, #8 Exhibit 333, #9 Exhibit 334, #10 Exhibit 335, #11 Exhibit 336, #12 Exhibit 337, #13 Exhibit 338, #14 Exhibit 339, #15 Exhibit 340, #16 Exhibit 341, #17 Exhibit 342, #18 Exhibit 343, #19 Exhibit 344, #20 Exhibit 345, #21 Exhibit 346, #22 Exhibit 347, #23 Exhibit 348, #24 Exhibit 349, #25 Exhibit 350, #26 Exhibit 351, #27 Exhibit 352, #28 Exhibit 353, #29 Exhibit 354, #30 Exhibit 355, #31 Exhibit 356, #32 Exhibit 357, #33 Exhibit 358)(Warlick, Sarah)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 191 DECLARATION of Joe Koenig in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 190 COUNTER STATEMENT TO Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 189 REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment . . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 188 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Plaintiffs' Brief in Opposition to Carfax's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Plaintiffs' Rule 56.1 Response to Defendant's Statement of Material Facts As to Which There Is No Genuine Issue to Be Tried ("Plaintiffs' Rule 56.1 Response"), Expert Report of Hal J. Singer, Ph.D., and the Declaration of Jeffrey Kabacinski in Support of Plaintiffs' Rule 56.1 Response, together with attached exhibits served on Attorneys for Defendant on 05/13/2016. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Warlick, Sarah)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 187 RESPONSE Expert Report of Hal J. Singer, Ph.D. (filed on behalf of Plaintiffs). Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Warlick, Sarah)
October 29, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 186 DECLARATION of Jeffrey Kabacinski in Support re: #185 Counter Statement to Rule 56.1. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 171, #2 Exhibit 172, #3 Exhibit 173, #4 Exhibit 174, #5 Exhibit 175, #6 Exhibit 176, #7 Exhibit 177, #8 Exhibit 178, #9 Exhibit 179, #10 Exhibit 180, #11 Exhibit 181, #12 Exhibit 182, #13 Exhibit 183, #14 Exhibit 184, #15 Exhibit 185, #16 Exhibit 186, #17 Exhibit 187, #18 Exhibit 188, #19 Exhibit 189, #20 Exhibit 190, #21 Exhibit 191, #22 Exhibit 192a, #23 Exhibit 192b, #24 Exhibit 193, #25 Exhibit 194, #26 Exhibit 195, #27 Exhibit 196, #28 Exhibit 197, #29 Exhibit 198, #30 Exhibit 199, #31 Exhibit 200, #32 Exhibit 201, #33 Exhibit 202, #34 Exhibit 203, #35 Exhibit 204, #36 Exhibit 205, #37 Exhibit 206, #38 Exhibit 207, #39 Exhibit 208, #40 Exhibit 209, #41 Exhibit 210, #42 Exhibit 211, #43 Exhibit 212, #44 Exhibit 213, #45 Exhibit 214, #46 Exhibit 215, #47 Exhibit 216, #48 Exhibit 217, #49 Exhibit 218, #50 Exhibit 219, #51 Exhibit 220, #52 Exhibit 221, #53 Exhibit 222, #54 Exhibit 223, #55 Exhibit 224, #56 Exhibit 225, #57 Exhibit 226, #58 Exhibit 227, #59 Exhibit 228, #60 Exhibit 229, #61 Exhibit 230, #62 Exhibit 231, #63 Exhibit 232, #64 Exhibit 233, #65 Exhibit 234, #66 Exhibit 235, #67 Exhibit 236, #68 Exhibit 237, #69 Exhibit 238, #70 Exhibit 239, #71 Exhibit 240, #72 Exhibit 241, #73 Exhibit 242, #74 Exhibit 243, #75 Exhibit 244, #76 Exhibit 245, #77 Exhibit 246, #78 Exhibit 247, #79 Exhibit 248, #80 Exhibit 249, #81 Exhibit 250, #82 Exhibit 251, #83 Exhibit 252, #84 Exhibit 253, #85 Exhibit 254, #86 Exhibit 255, #87 Exhibit 256, #88 Exhibit 257, #89 Exhibit 258, #90 Exhibit 259, #91 Exhibit 260, #92 Exhibit 261, #93 Exhibit 262, #94 Exhibit 263, #95 Exhibit 264, #96 Exhibit 265, #97 Exhibit 266, #98 Exhibit 267, #99 Exhibit 268, #100 Exhibit 269, #101 Exhibit 270, #102 Exhibit 271, #103 Exhibit 272, #104 Exhibit 273, #105 Exhibit 274, #106 Exhibit 275, #107 Exhibit 276, #108 Exhibit 277, #109 Exhibit 278, #110 Exhibit 279, #111 Exhibit 280, #112 Exhibit 281, #113 Exhibit 282, #114 Exhibit 283, #115 Exhibit 284, #116 Exhibit 285, #117 Exhibit 286, #118 Exhibit 287, #119 Exhibit 288, #120 Exhibit 289, #121 Exhibit 290, #122 Exhibit 291, #123 Exhibit 292, #124 Exhibit 293, #125 Exhibit 294, #126 Exhibit 295, #127 Exhibit 296, #128 Exhibit 297, #129 Exhibit 298, #130 Exhibit 299, #131 Exhibit 300, #132 Exhibit 301, #133 Exhibit 302, #134 Exhibit 303, #135 Exhibit 304, #136 Exhibit 305, #137 Exhibit 306, #138 Exhibit 307, #139 Exhibit 308, #140 Exhibit 309, #141 Exhibit 310, #142 Exhibit 311, #143 Exhibit 312, #144 Exhibit 313, #145 Exhibit 314, #146 Exhibit 315, #147 Exhibit 316, #148 Exhibit 317a, #149 Exhibit 317b, #150 Exhibit 318, #151 Exhibit 319, #152 Exhibit 320, #153 Exhibit 321, #154 Exhibit 322, #155 Exhibit 323, #156 Exhibit 324, #157 Exhibit 325)(Warlick, Sarah)
October 28, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 185 COUNTER STATEMENT TO #179 Rule 56.1 Statement. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Warlick, Sarah)
October 28, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 184 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment . [Filed by Plaintiffs]. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Warlick, Sarah)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 183 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Defendant Carfax, Inc.s Memorandum of Law in Support of the Motion For Partial Summary Judgment, Statement of Material Facts as to Which There Is No Genuine Issue to be Tried, Expert Report of Professor Robert Willig Ph.D., Declaration of Joe Koenig, and Transmittal Declaration of Sarah Warlick, with exhibits served on Attorneys for Plaintiffs on 02/26/2016. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 182 RESPONSE Expert Report of Robert Willig. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3)(Cooper, James)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 181 DECLARATION of Sarah E. Warlick in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10, #11 Exhibit 11, #12 Exhibit 12, #13 Exhibit 13, #14 Exhibit 14, #15 Exhibit 15, #16 Exhibit 16, #17 Exhibit 17, #18 Exhibit 18, #19 Exhibit 19, #20 Exhibit 20, #21 Exhibit 21, #22 Exhibit 22, #23 Exhibit 23, #24 Exhibit 24, #25 Exhibit 25, #26 Exhibit 26, #27 Exhibit 27, #28 Exhibit 28, #29 Exhibit 29, #30 Exhibit 30, #31 Exhibit 31, #32 Exhibit 32, #33 Exhibit 33, #34 Exhibit 34, #35 Exhibit 35, #36 Exhibit 36, #37 Exhibit 37, #38 Exhibit 38, #39 Exhibit 39, #40 Exhibit 40, #41 Exhibit 41, #42 Exhibit 42, #43 Exhibit 43, #44 Exhibit 44, #45 Exhibit 45, #46 Exhibit 46, #47 Exhibit 47, #48 Exhibit 48, #49 Exhibit 49, #50 Exhibit 50, #51 Exhibit 51, #52 Exhibit 52, #53 Exhibit 53, #54 Exhibit 54, #55 Exhibit 55, #56 Exhibit 56, #57 Exhibit 57, #58 Exhibit 58, #59 Exhibit 59, #60 Exhibit 60, #61 Exhibit 61, #62 Exhibit 62, #63 Exhibit 63, #64 Exhibit 64, #65 Exhibit 65, #66 Exhibit 66, #67 Exhibit 67, #68 Exhibit 68, #69 Exhibit 69, #70 Exhibit 70, #71 Exhibit 71, #72 Exhibit 72, #73 Exhibit 73, #74 Exhibit 74, #75 Exhibit 75, #76 Exhibit 76, #77 Exhibit 77, #78 Exhibit 78, #79 Exhibit 79, #80 Exhibit 80, #81 Exhibit 81, #82 Exhibit 82, #83 Exhibit 83, #84 Exhibit 84, #85 Exhibit 85, #86 Exhibit 86, #87 Exhibit 87, #88 Exhibit 88, #89 Exhibit 89, #90 Exhibit 90, #91 Exhibit 91, #92 Exhibit 92, #93 Exhibit 93, #94 Exhibit 94, #95 Exhibit 95, #96 Exhibit 96, #97 Exhibit 97, #98 Exhibit 98, #99 Exhibit 99, #100 Exhibit 100, #101 Exhibit 101, #102 Exhibit 102, #103 Exhibit 103, #104 Exhibit 104, #105 Exhibit 105, #106 Exhibit 106, #107 Exhibit 107, #108 Exhibit 108, #109 Exhibit 109, #110 Exhibit 110, #111 Exhibit 111, #112 Exhibit 112a, #113 Exhibit 112b, #114 Exhibit 113, #115 Exhibit 114, #116 Exhibit 115, #117 Exhibit 116, #118 Exhibit 117, #119 Exhibit 118, #120 Exhibit 119, #121 Exhibit 120, #122 Exhibit 121, #123 Exhibit 122, #124 Exhibit 123, #125 Exhibit 124, #126 Exhibit 125, #127 Exhibit 126, #128 Exhibit 127, #129 Exhibit 128, #130 Exhibit 129, #131 Exhibit 130, #132 Exhibit 131, #133 Exhibit 132, #134 Exhibit 133, #135 Exhibit 134, #136 Exhibit 135, #137 Exhibit 136, #138 Exhibit 137, #139 Exhibit 138, #140 Exhibit 139, #141 Exhibit 140, #142 Exhibit 141, #143 Exhibit 142, #144 Exhibit 143, #145 Exhibit 144, #146 Exhibit 145, #147 Exhibit 146, #148 Exhibit 147, #149 Exhibit 148, #150 Exhibit 149, #151 Exhibit 150, #152 Exhibit 151, #153 Exhibit 152, #154 Exhibit 153, #155 Exhibit 154, #156 Exhibit 155, #157 Exhibit 156, #158 Exhibit 157, #159 Exhibit 158, #160 Exhibit 159, #161 Exhibit 160, #162 Exhibit 161, #163 Exhibit 162, #164 Exhibit 163, #165 Exhibit 164, #166 Exhibit 165, #167 Exhibit 166, #168 Exhibit 167, #169 Exhibit 168, #170 Exhibit 169, #171 Exhibit 170)(Warlick, Sarah)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 180 DECLARATION of Joe Koenig in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Cooper, James)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 179 RULE 56.1 STATEMENT. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 27, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 178 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment . . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 10, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 177 ORDER. The Court hereby grants Carfax's redaction and sealing requests. Within three weeks of the publication of this Order, Carfax is ordered to (1) file under seal all sealed documents, as well as unredacted versions of all redacted documents; and (2) file on the public docket redacted versions of all redacted documents, as well as unredacted versions of any other documents that may not previously have been publicly filed because they were the subject of earlier (ultimately withdrawn) sealing or redaction requests. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/6/2017) (rjm)
October 10, 2017 Opinion or Order Transmission to Sealed Records Clerk. Transmitted re: #177 Order to the Sealed Records Clerk for the sealing or unsealing of document or case. (rjm)
April 6, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 176 ORDER of USCA (Certified Copy) as to #170 Notice of Appeal. USCA Case Number 16-3717. The parties in the above-referenced case have filed a stipulation withdrawing this appeal pursuant to Local Rule 42.1. The stipulation is hereby "So Ordered". Catherine O'Hagan Wolfe, Clerk USCA for the Second Circuit. Certified: 04/6/2017. (nd)
February 23, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 175 ORDER of USCA (Certified Copy) as to #170 Notice of Appeal filed by Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., 4984 Partners Ltd., 3925 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., 21st Century Auto Group, Cherry Hill Imports, Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Howard Auto Group, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Haldeman Ford, Inc., Curry Automotive LLC, DTC Corp., Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Townsend Bros. Inc., BTLS, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., Bayside Chrysler, Route 23 Honda, Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Hanford Hyundai, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Nissan World of Red Bank, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Merrimac Motors, Inc., Next Motors Corporation, Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, County Line Carriage Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Williamson Cadillac Company, Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Salerno Duane Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Chrysler of Culpeper, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Habberstad BMW of Huntington, AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Renton Hyundai, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Elk Grove Toyota, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, Magic City Motor Corp., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Sutton Ford Inc., Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., Nissan World of Denville, Life Quality BMW, Rine Motors Inc., Chevrolet of Jersey City, Santilli Enterprises Inc., Scap Auto Group, R &J Nissan LLC, Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, City Motors LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Northtown Lexus, Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Autoworld Kia, Open Road of Mendham, LLC, DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Star Toyota, Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Chilson Corner Motors, Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Sawdran LLC, Brentlinger Enterprises, Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Krusemark Automotive, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Rockville Cars, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Manfredi Auto LLC, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Reydel Volkswagen, Inc., Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Nissan World of Springfield, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., Burien Nissan, Stevenson Cars, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Gault Volkswagen, Concours Motors Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, Garcia Imports, Inc., Sutton Ford Lincoln, Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, W.S. Healey Chevrolet Buick, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Henry Valencia Inc., Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Curry Motor Cars, LLC, Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Tirrico Inc., Bronx Ford, Inc., Thirteen Twenty LLC, Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., M & S of Pawling, Inc., Paul Miller Performance LLC, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Hampton Imports LLC, Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc., Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Mack Auto Import Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, Yonkers Auto Outlet, King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Universal Global Inc., Brentlineger Enterprises, Miller Motor Car Corp., N & H Motors, Inc., B.C.T. Imports Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, Schaller, Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Car Pros Renton, D & C Chevrolet Co., Northtown Toyota Scion, Balise N, LLC, Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Waco Dodge, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, Bartow Ford Company, R&J Nissan, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, FOC Inc., Martin Swanty Kia, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Nissan sales Corp., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Paul Miller AWD LLC, Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Price Simms, Inc., Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Staretz LLC, Toyota World of Lakewood, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Imports Service Center, Inc., Joseph H of D LLC, LCJ Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Price Cars SR LLC, Community Honda, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, Dutchess Cars, LLC, Beck Automotive Group, Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Sussex County Imports LLC, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Wayne Motors, Inc., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Rensselaer Auto Plaza, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., Star Nissan, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, Paul Miller Inc., Tamaroff Motors, Inc., Kia Tacoma, Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Jaguar of Great Neck, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Bob Bell Ford, Great Neck Suzuki, Poquoson Motors, Inc., James Toyota, Denville Nissan Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Curry Imports Inc., FSW, Inc., Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Balise V., Inc, Biener Auto Group, Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., City World Motors, LLC, Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Thomas Subaru, Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Team Precision Auto LLC, NYLSI Inc., Schumacher Auto Group, Farrell Motors, Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Offlease4less, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., R & M Marketing Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Lash Auto Group LLC, DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Nissan of Fontana Inc., Northtown Hyundai Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Hoehn Infiniti, Lyford Motors LLC, Champaign Motors Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, United Galaxy Inc., Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., ADA Motors Inc., R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, NextMotors Corporation, Outten Automotive, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., Dijos Inc., BFC 3 LLC, Curry Auto LLC, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., Stevenson & Associates, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Clay Chevrolet Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Sawyer Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Galesburg Nissan Corp., Western Motors, Inc., White Plains Chrysler Jeep, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., J.O. Stevenson, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, Phoenix Motor Company, Perrine Auto Group, Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Adjess Motors LLC, DGM, L.L.C., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Biener Audi, Thomas Dodge Corp., Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Ralph Automotive Inc., Route 59 Automobile LLC, Archer Kia, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., Timco, WR Thomas Inc., Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Parsons Buick Company, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Balise Subaru Inc., Tenafly Auto Mall Inc., Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Norwood Subaru, Inc., Tenafly Kia-Teter
January 26, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 174 ORDER granting #173 Letter Motion for Extension of Time. (Pursuant to the Court's December 12, 2016 Order (Dkt. 171 ), the current deadline to submit these requests is February 1, 2017. With the Court's approval, Carfax would appreciate an extension of time until February 24, 2017.) SO ORDERED. Motions due by 2/24/2017. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 1/26/2017) (ama)
January 25, 2017 Opinion or Order Filing 173 FIRST LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from James L. Cooper dated 1/25/2017. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
December 9, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 172 OPINION AND ORDER. For the foregoing reasons, Carfax's motion for partial summary judgment is GRANTED. The parties shall have one week from the date of this Opinion & Order to meet and confer and submit a joint letter proposing any redactions to the Opinion & Order, along with a justification for why such redactions are appropriate under this circuit's law. See Lugosch v. Pyramid Co. of Onondaga, 435 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2006). Although the Court will publicly docket an order announcing its bottom-line conclusions, it will refrain from publicly docketing this Opinion & Order until it has ruled on the proposed redactions. The Court will do so expeditiously. Upon resolution of any redactions, the Court will close the case in light of the parties' stipulation, see Dkt. No. 151, and representations to the Court, see Tr. of Nov. 23, 2015 Conf. This resolves Docket Nos. 154 and 164. So ordered. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/30/2016) (rjm)
December 9, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 171 ORDER. The Court ORDERS all parties seeking sealing and redaction of materials submitted to the Court for purposes of resolving the motion for summary judgment to jointly resubmit these requests on or before February 1, 2017, consistent with this order. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 12/9/2016) (rjm)
December 9, 2016 Opinion or Order Terminate Transcript Deadlines (rjm)
October 28, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 170 NOTICE OF APPEAL from #169 Order on Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, Order on Motion for Local Rule 37.2 Conference,,,,,,,,. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Cas
October 28, 2016 Opinion or Order Transmission of Notice of Appeal and Certified Copy of Docket Sheet to US Court of Appeals re: #170 Notice of Appeal. (nd)
October 28, 2016 Opinion or Order Appeal Record Sent to USCA (Electronic File). Certified Indexed record on Appeal Electronic Files for #170 Notice of Appeal filed by Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., 4984 Partners Ltd., 3925 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., 21st Century Auto Group, Cherry Hill Imports, Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Howard Auto Group, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Haldeman Ford, Inc., Curry Automotive LLC, DTC Corp., Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Townsend Bros. Inc., BTLS, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., Bayside Chrysler, Route 23 Honda, Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Hanford Hyundai, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Nissan World of Red Bank, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Merrimac Motors, Inc., Next Motors Corporation, Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, County Line Carriage Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Williamson Cadillac Company, Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Salerno Duane Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Chrysler of Culpeper, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Habberstad BMW of Huntington, AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Renton Hyundai, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Elk Grove Toyota, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, Magic City Motor Corp., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Sutton Ford Inc., Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., Nissan World of Denville, Life Quality BMW, Rine Motors Inc., Chevrolet of Jersey City, Santilli Enterprises Inc., Scap Auto Group, R &J Nissan LLC, Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, City Motors LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Northtown Lexus, Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Autoworld Kia, Open Road of Mendham, LLC, DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Star Toyota, Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Chilson Corner Motors, Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Sawdran LLC, Brentlinger Enterprises, Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Krusemark Automotive, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Rockville Cars, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Manfredi Auto LLC, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Reydel Volkswagen, Inc., Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Nissan World of Springfield, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., Burien Nissan, Stevenson Cars, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Gault Volkswagen, Concours Motors Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, Garcia Imports, Inc., Sutton Ford Lincoln, Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, W.S. Healey Chevrolet Buick, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Henry Valencia Inc., Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Curry Motor Cars, LLC, Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Tirrico Inc., Bronx Ford, Inc., Thirteen Twenty LLC, Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., M & S of Pawling, Inc., Paul Miller Performance LLC, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Hampton Imports LLC, Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc., Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Mack Auto Import Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, Yonkers Auto Outlet, King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Universal Global Inc., Brentlineger Enterprises, Miller Motor Car Corp., N & H Motors, Inc., B.C.T. Imports Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, Schaller, Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Car Pros Renton, D & C Chevrolet Co., Northtown Toyota Scion, Balise N, LLC, Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Waco Dodge, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, Bartow Ford Company, R&J Nissan, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, FOC Inc., Martin Swanty Kia, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Nissan sales Corp., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Paul Miller AWD LLC, Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Price Simms, Inc., Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Staretz LLC, Toyota World of Lakewood, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Imports Service Center, Inc., Joseph H of D LLC, LCJ Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Price Cars SR LLC, Community Honda, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, Dutchess Cars, LLC, Beck Automotive Group, Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Sussex County Imports LLC, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Wayne Motors, Inc., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Rensselaer Auto Plaza, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., Star Nissan, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, Paul Miller Inc., Tamaroff Motors, Inc., Kia Tacoma, Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Jaguar of Great Neck, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Bob Bell Ford, Great Neck Suzuki, Poquoson Motors, Inc., James Toyota, Denville Nissan Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Curry Imports Inc., FSW, Inc., Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Balise V., Inc, Biener Auto Group, Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., City World Motors, LLC, Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Thomas Subaru, Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Team Precision Auto LLC, NYLSI Inc., Schumacher Auto Group, Farrell Motors, Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Offlease4less, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., R & M Marketing Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Lash Auto Group LLC, DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Nissan of Fontana Inc., Northtown Hyundai Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Hoehn Infiniti, Lyford Motors LLC, Champaign Motors Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, United Galaxy Inc., Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., ADA Motors Inc., R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, NextMotors Corporation, Outten Automotive, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., Dijos Inc., BFC 3 LLC, Curry Auto LLC, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., Stevenson & Associates, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Clay Chevrolet Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Sawyer Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Galesburg Nissan Corp., Western Motors, Inc., White Plains Chrysler Jeep, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., J.O. Stevenson, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, Phoenix Motor Company, Perrine Auto Group, Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Adjess Motors LLC, DGM, L.L.C., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Biener Audi, Thomas Dodge Corp., Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Ralph Automotive Inc., Route 59 Automobile LLC, Archer Kia, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., Timco, WR Thomas Inc., Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Parsons Buick Company, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Balise Subaru Inc., Tenafly Auto Mall Inc., Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Bergstrom Ford-
September 30, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 169 ORDER granting #154 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; terminating #164 Letter Motion for Local Rule 37.2 Conference. In light of the parties' claims that some of the record before the Court at summary judgment consists of confidential business information that should not be filed on the public docket, the Court has given the parties a week to propose any redactions to the Court's Opinion & Order and to justify those redactions by reference to the Second Circuit's decision in Lugosch v. Pyramid Co. of Onondaga, 435 F. 3d 110 (2d Cir. 2006). After determining which, if any, portions of the Opinion & Order should be redacted, the Court will file the Opinion & Order on the public docket. Once the Opinion & Order is publicly filed, and pursuant to the parties' stipulation in advance of Carfax's motion for partial summary judgment, see Dkt. No. 151, the Court will close the case. This Order, by reference to the temporarily sealed Opinion & Order, resolves Docket NOs. 154 and 164. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/30/2016) (tro) Modified on 10/20/2016 (tro).
August 26, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 168 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment . . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
August 26, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 167 SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF re: #166 Order,, . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Range Rove
August 17, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 166 ORDER. On August 10, 2016, the Second Circuit issued a decision in MacDermid Printing Solutions LLC v. Cortron Corp., No. 15-589,2016 WL 4204795 (2d Cir. Aug. 10, 2016), that addressed the standard for evaluating claims brought under Section 1 of the Sherman Act that are subject to the "rule of reason." Id. at *5. If any party believes that decision bears on the pending summary judgment motion in this case, it may submit a brief of no more than five pages addressing the decision by August 26, 2016. So ordered. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 8/17/2016) (rjm)
July 29, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 165 SUPPLEMENTAL RULE 7.1 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Identifying Corporate Parent IHS Markit Ltd. for Carfax, Inc.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
July 14, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 164 LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from ERIC L. CRAMER dated July 8, 2016. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Au
July 13, 2016 Opinion or Order ***NOTICE TO ATTORNEY TO RE-FILE DOCUMENT - EVENT TYPE ERROR. Notice to Attorney Eric L. Cramer to RE-FILE Document #162 LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from ERIC L. CRAMER dated July 8, 2016. Use the event type Letter found under the event list Other Documents. (db)
July 12, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 163 LETTER RESPONSE to Motion addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from James L. Cooper dated July 12, 2016 re: #162 LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from ERIC L. CRAMER dated July 8, 2016. . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
July 8, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 162 FILING ERROR - WRONG EVENT TYPE SELECTED FROM MENU - LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from ERIC L. CRAMER dated July 8, 2016. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Met
June 16, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 161 ORDER granting #160 Letter Motion for Extension of Time: So ordered. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 6/16/2016) (tn)
June 13, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 160 JOINT LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from All Parties dated 06/13/2016. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
May 2, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 159 ORDER granting #158 Letter Motion for Extension of Time. Plaintiffs' Opposition and Supporting Evidence: May 13, 2016 (Brief limited to 35 pages); Defendant's Reply: June 24, 2016 (Brief limited to 15 pages). SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 5/02/2016) (ama)
May 2, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 158 LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from David A. Langer dated May 2, 2016. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-
May 2, 2016 Opinion or Order Set/Reset Deadlines: Responses due by 5/13/2016 Replies due by 6/24/2016. (ama)
April 5, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 157 ORDER. On February 26, 2016, Defendant filed a motion for partial summary judgment currently pending before the Court. Dkt. No. 154. Pursuant to the Court's Individual Rule 4.A, Defendant submitted a letter to the Court via email requesting permission to file its submission under seal and/or with redactions. In the letter, Defendant states that the parties jointly request permission to meet and confer after briefing is concluded in this matter, and to jointly propose a set of redactions for the publicly-filed versions of all documents associated with the partial summary judgment briefing. The parties' request is granted. Joint letters and proposed redactions shall be submitted to the Court no later than June 27, 2016. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 4/5/2016) (rjm)
April 5, 2016 Opinion or Order Transmission to Sealed Records Clerk. Transmitted re: #157 Order to the Sealed Records Clerk for the sealing or unsealing of document or case. (rjm)
March 30, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 156 ORDER granting #155 Letter Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery. Deposition of Defendant's Expert: April 21, 2016; Plaintiffs' Opposition and Supporting Evidence: (Brief limited to 35 pages): May 6, 2016; Defendant's Reply: (Brief limited to 15 pages): June 17, 2016. SO ORDERED. Deposition due by 4/21/2016. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 3/30/2016) (ama)
March 30, 2016 Opinion or Order Set/Reset Deadlines: Responses due by 5/6/2016 Replies due by 6/17/2016. (ama)
March 29, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 155 LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from David A. Langer dated March 29, 2016. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Managemen
February 26, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 154 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. Responses due by 4/22/2016(Cooper, James)
February 25, 2016 Opinion or Order Filing 153 STIPULATION AND ORDER REGARDING EXPERT DISCOVERY. The parties stipulate to the following regarding the scope of expert discovery in the above-captioned matter ("Litigation"): At the times provided by the Court or by subsequent stipulation of the parties as approved by the Court, including the Court-approved schedule set forth in the parties' December 1, 2015 joint letter (see Dkt. Nos. 151, 152), for the service of written expert reports or the conduct of expert depositions, the parties shall make all disclosures required by Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, as modified, clarified or limited by this Stipulation and Order, and depositions of experts under Rule 26(b)(4) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure shall occur, and as further set forth in this Stipulation and Order Regarding Expert Discovery. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 2/25/2016) (rjm)
December 10, 2015 Opinion or Order Telephone Conference set for 1/5/2016 at 11:00 AM before Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis. On the day of the conference, the parties will jointly place a telephone call to the chambers of Judge Ronald L. Ellis, at 212-805-0563. Upon receipt of this order, if you need further information, direct inquiries to Rupa Shah, 212-805-0242. (rsh)
December 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Set/Reset Deadlines: Fact Discovery due by 3/28/2016. (cf)
December 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 152 ORDER re: #151 Letter filed by Carfax, Inc., #123 JOINT LETTER MOTION to Adjourn Conference to allow Parties to Submit Proposal Arising From Mediation addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from all parties dated October 6, 2015, filed by Carfax, Inc., #146 Letter filed by Carfax, Inc. In light of the forgoing, it is hereby ORDERED that the schedule set out in the December 1, 2015, joint letter is adopted. Carfax's motion for partial summary judgment will be due on or before February 26, 2016. Plaintiff's opposition will be due April 22, 2016, and Carfax's reply will be due May 20, 2016.( Motions due by 2/26/2016., Responses due by 4/22/2016, Replies due by 5/20/2016.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 12/4/2015) (cf)
December 1, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 151 JOINT LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from James L. Cooper dated December 1, 2015 re: Joint Proposal. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
November 24, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 150 ORDER terminating #78 Letter Motion for Local Rule 37.2 Conference. (HEREBY ORDERED by Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis)(Text Only Order) (Ellis, Ronald)
November 23, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 149 STIPULATION AND ORDER TO AMEND STIPULATED CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER: It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the undersigned parties, subject to approval and entry by the Court, that, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c)(1) (G), paragraph 11 of the Parties December 9, 2104 Stipulated Confidentiality Order (Dkt. 68), shall be amended as further set forth in this order. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 11/23/2015) (lmb)
November 23, 2015 Opinion or Order Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Alison J. Nathan: Status Conference held on 11/23/2015. See transcript for details. (Court Reporter Carol Ganley) (snu)
November 3, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 148 SCHEDULING ORDER: There is a Case Management Conference scheduled for Friday, November 13, 2015 at 2:00 p.m. The Court hereby adjourns and re-schedule the conference for Monday, November 23, 2015 at 2:00 p.m. (Conference set for 11/23/2015 at 02:00 PM before Judge Alison J. Nathan). (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 11/3/2015) (rjm)
October 30, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 147 ORDER: On October 15, 2015, the Court received a request from Defendant Carfax, Inc., to redact portions of the transcript of the initial pretrial conference held before Judge Ellis on April 6, 2015. Carfax asks the Court to redact those parts of the transcript that discuss a document designated as confidential under the Stipulated Confidentiality Agreement approved by this Court on December 9, 2014. The Court has reviewed the proposed redactions and has determined that Carfax's request to redact the transcript must be DENIED. (As further set forth in this Order.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/30/2015) (kko)
October 23, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 146 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from James L. Cooper dated 10/23/2015 re: Joint Letter addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from All Parties dated October 23, 2015. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
October 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 145 ORDER. On April 13, 2015, and October 16, 2015, the Court received motions and supporting affidavits from Sara E. Farber and Leah Threatte Bojnowski (respectively) requesting permission to withdraw their appearances as counsel for Defendant Carfax, Inc. These motions are hereby GRANTED. This resolves Dkt. Nos. 80 and 134. Granting #80 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. Attorney Sara Elizabeth Farber terminated; Granting #134 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney. Attorney Leah Threatte Bojnowski terminated. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/20/2015) (rjm)
October 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 144 ORDER. It is ORDERED that both parties' objections to Judge Ellis's ruling are dismissed without prejudice. This resolves Dkt. No. 137. So ordered. Terminating #137 Motion to Compel. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/20/2015) (rjm)
October 19, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 143 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from David A. Langer dated October 19, 2015 re: Response to October 8, 2015 Order (Dkt. No. 126). Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management,
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 142 RESPONSE re: #113 Objection (non-motion) . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Range
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 141 Objection re: #108 Memorandum & Opinion,, . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Rang
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 140 REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #137 MOTION to Compel Carfax, Inc. to Produce Documents and Responses to Interrogatories Dating from the Beginning of the Alleged Anticompetitive Exclusive Dealing Scheme . . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Mana
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 139 DECLARATION of Jeffrey Kabacinski in Opposition re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action .. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc.
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 138 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action . . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli A
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 137 MOTION to Compel Carfax, Inc. to Produce Documents and Responses to Interrogatories Dating from the Beginning of the Alleged Anticompetitive Exclusive Dealing Scheme . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Hon
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 136 ORDER. It is hereby ORDERED that Plaintiffs have until October 21, 2015, to comply with the Court's October 8, 2015, order. If they fail to do so, the Court will deem the filings docketed on ECF as of October 21, 2015, to be the complete record in this case up to that date. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/16/2015) (rjm)
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 135 DECLARATION of Leah Threatte Bojnowski in Support re: #134 MOTION for Leah Threatte Bojnowski to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc... Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Bojnowski, Leah)
October 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 134 MOTION for Leah Threatte Bojnowski to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Bojnowski, Leah)
October 15, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 133 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Kenneth L. Chernof dated 10-15-2015 re: response to Oct. 8 Order. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
October 14, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 132 ORDER granting #127 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney; granting #129 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney: On October 13, 2015, the Court received motions and supporting affidavits from Christopher M. Mason and Annica Paula Margareta Bianco requesting permission to withdraw their appearance as counsel for Defendant Catfax, Inc. These motions are hereby GRANTED. Attorney Annica Paula Margareta Bianco and Christopher May Mason terminated. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/14/2015) (tn)
October 14, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 131 JOINT LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from James L. Cooper dated 10-14-2015 re: joint letter pursuant to the Court's October 7, 2015 order. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
October 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 130 DECLARATION of Annica Paula Margareta Bianco in Support re: #129 MOTION for Annica Paula Margareta Bianco to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc... Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Bianco, Annica)
October 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 129 MOTION for Annica Paula Margareta Bianco to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Bianco, Annica)
October 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 128 DECLARATION of Christopher M. Mason in Support re: #127 MOTION for Christopher Mason to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc... Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
October 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 127 MOTION for Christopher Mason to Withdraw as Attorney for Defendant Carfax, Inc.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
October 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 126 ORDER. All requests to redact documents pursuant to Rule 4.A of the Court's Individual Practices currently pending before the Court are hereby granted. By October 15, 2015, both parties are ordered (1) to file on ECF the approved redacted versions of all briefing and exhibits previously submitted to the Court via email pursuant to Rule 4.A (this includes briefing and exhibits submitted to Magistrate Judge Ellis), and (2) to file a status letter indicating that no outstanding briefing or exhibits remain unfiled. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/8/2015) (rjm)
October 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Transmission to Sealed Records Clerk. Transmitted re: #126 Order to the Sealed Records Clerk for the sealing or unsealing of document or case. (rjm)
October 7, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 125 ORDER. On October 6, 2015, the parties filed a joint letter requesting permission to submit a joint proposal setting out a process for limited discovery leading to an expedited motion for partial summary judgment by Defendant Carfax. The Court appreciates and encourages the parties' efforts to come to a mutually agreeable proposal for an efficient resolution of the case. The parties' request is therefore GRANTED. The parties are instructed to submit their joint proposal by October 23, 2015. The status conference scheduled for October 9, 2015, is adjourned to November 13, 2015, at 2:00pm. The October 7, 2015, deadline for filing a status report is adjourned sine die, and as further specified in this Order. It is therefore ORDERED that by October 14, 2015, the parties shall submit to the Court a joint letter indicating whether they continue to seek immediate resolution of their objections to Judge Ellis's July 24, 2015, discovery order (Dkt. No. 108), or whether they wish to withdraw their objections. If the parties withdraw their objections, they will do so without prejudice to refiling them after the resolution of their proposal due October 23, 2015. Granting #123 JOINT LETTER MOTION to Adjourn Conference to Allow Parties to Submit Proposal Arising From Mediation addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from All Parties dated October 6, 2015. Document filed by Carfax, Inc. (Status Conference set for 11/13/2015 at 02:00 PM before Judge Alison J. Nathan). The following deadline(s) was terminated: Case Management Conference. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/7/2015) (rjm).
October 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 124 NOTICE of Intent to Request Redaction for specific portions of the Transcript of the April 16, 2015 initial conference. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
October 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 123 JOINT LETTER MOTION to Adjourn Conference to Allow Parties to Submit Proposal Arising From Mediation addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from All Parties dated October 6, 2015. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Chernof, Kenneth)
October 5, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 122 ORDER: that by October 7, 2015 the parties shall meet and confer and submit a joint letter to the Court. The joint letter shall: 1) Include a statement confirming that all Stage 1 discovery has been completed (the parties should not assume that the Court will grant any extensions); 2) Include a statement regarding the status of any settlement discussions and whether the parties would like a referral to the Magistrate Judge or the Court-annexed Mediation Program for settlement discussions; 3) Include a statement regarding whether any party intends to move for summary judgment on or before the deadline specified in the CMP; and 4) If no party intends to move for summary judgment, propose (a) a deadline for the submission of a joint final pre-trial order pursuant to Rule 5.A of the undersigned's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, and (b) potential trial dates. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/5/2015) (tn)
September 29, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 121 NOTICE OF FILING OF OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT Notice is hereby given that an official transcript of a Initial Pretrial Conference proceeding held on 04/16/2015 has been filed by the court reporter/transcriber in the above-captioned matter. The parties have seven (7) calendar days to file with the court a Notice of Intent to Request Redaction of this transcript. If no such Notice is filed, the transcript may be made remotely electronically available to the public without redaction after 90 calendar days...(ca)
September 29, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 120 TRANSCRIPT of Proceedings re: Initial Pretrial Conference held on 4/16/2015 before Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis. Court Reporter/Transcriber: Mary Greco, (518) 581-8973. Transcript may be viewed at the court public terminal or purchased through the Court Reporter/Transcriber before the deadline for Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER. Redaction Request due 10/23/2015. Redacted Transcript Deadline set for 11/2/2015. Release of Transcript Restriction set for 12/31/2015.(ca)
September 21, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 119 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by James L Cooper on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. New Address: Arnold & Porter LLP, 601 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC, USA 20001, (202) 942-5000. (Cooper, James)
September 21, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 118 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Kenneth L. Chernof on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. New Address: Arnold & Porter LLP, 601 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC, USA 20001, (202) 942-5000. (Chernof, Kenneth)
September 21, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 117 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Sarah Warlick on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. New Address: Arnold & Porter LLP, 601 Massachusetts Avenue NW, Washington, DC, USA 20001, (202) 942-5000. (Warlick, Sarah)
August 18, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 116 REPLY in Support of Carfax's Objections to the Magistrate's Ruling on Carfax's Motion to Compel. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
August 17, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 115 REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #114 Response . Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive
August 14, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 114 RESPONSE to Plaintiffs' Objections to the Magistrate Judge's July 24, 2015 Order. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
August 11, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 113 Objection re: #108 Memorandum & Opinion,, . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A)(Cooper, James)
August 11, 2015 Opinion or Order ***NOTICE TO ATTORNEY TO RE-FILE DOCUMENT - EVENT TYPE ERROR. Notice to Attorney James L Cooper to RE-FILE Document #112 MOTION Objections to Magistrate's Order on Motion to Compel re: #108 Memorandum & Opinion,, . Use the event type Objection (non-motion) found under the event list Other Answers. (db)
August 7, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 112 FILING ERROR - WRONG EVENT TYPE SELECTED FROM MENU - MOTION Objections to Magistrate's Order on Motion to Compel re: #108 Memorandum & Opinion,, . Document filed by Carfax, Inc. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Exhibit A)(Cooper, James) Modified on 8/11/2015 (db).
July 29, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 111 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Ryan McEwan on behalf of Maxon Hyundai Mazda. New Address: Joseph Saveri Law Firm, Inc., 555 Montgomery Street, Suite 1210, San Francisco, California, USA 94111, (415) 500-6800. (McEwan, Ryan)
July 29, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 110 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Joshua Davis on behalf of Maxon Auto Enterprises. New Address: Joseph Saveri Law Firm, Inc., 555 Montgomery Street, Suite 1210, San Francisco, California, USA 94111, (415) 500-6800. (Davis, Joshua)
July 29, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 109 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Joseph Richard Saveri on behalf of Maxon Hyundai Mazda. New Address: Joseph Saveri Law Firm, Inc., 555 Montgomery Street, Suite 1210, San Francisco, California, USA 94111, (415) 500-6800. (Saveri, Joseph)
July 24, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 108 MEMORANDUM OPINION & ORDER #105706 re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action filed by Carfax, Inc. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that: 1) Defendant Carfax's Motion to Compel is DENIED. 2) Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel is GRANTED IN PART. Carfax must produce documents relating to its decision to use exclusivity provisions in its agreements, underlying negotiations and communications, and documents analyzing the effects of those agreements, from January 1, 2006, to the present. (As further set forth in this Order.) (Signed by Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis on 7/24/2015) (kko) Modified on 7/28/2015 (soh).
June 25, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 107 STIPULATION AND ORDER TO EXTEND THE SCHEDULING ORDER DATES BY NINETY DAYS. All Parties to this litigation respectfully submit this Stipulation and proposed Order to modify the Civil Case Management Plan and Scheduling Order (the "CMP") approved Oct. 31, 2014 [ECF No. 64j, as follows: The deadline for completing "Stage 1," as provided in CMP Appendix A, page 3, is extended from June 30, 2015 until September 30, 2015. The deadline for completing at least one full mediation session (see CMP Appendix A, page 1) remains July 30, 2015. The deadline for substantially completing the depositions of 50 or fewer selected Plaintiffs, as provided in CMP Appendix A, page 3, is extended from March 31, 2016 until June 30, 2016. The deadline for substantially completing the remaining depositions of Defendant, as provided in CMP Appendix A, page 3, is extended from March 31, 2016 until June 30, 2016. The deadline for substantially completing the depositions of third party fact witnesses, including former employees of a party, as provided in CMP Appendix A, page 3, is extended from March 31, 2016 until June 30, 2016, and as further set forth in this Stipulation and Order. In addition to the above, the conference set for July 10, 2015 is ADJOURNED to October 9, 2015 at 10:30 a.m. The Court is unlikely to grant any further extensions or adjournments. So ordered. (Deposition due by 6/30/2016.), (Case Management Conference set for 10/9/2015 at 10:30 AM before Judge Alison J. Nathan.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 6/25/2015) (rjm)
June 5, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 106 ORDER granting #105 Motion for Sarah E. Warlick to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
June 4, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 105 MOTION for Sarah E. Warlick to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10995973. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Certificates of Good Standing, #2 Text of Proposed Order)(Warlick, Sarah)
June 4, 2015 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #105 MOTION for Sarah E. Warlick to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10995973. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (sdi)
May 27, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 104 REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action . . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Cooper, James)
May 27, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 103 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from David A. Langer dated May 27, 2015 re: Plaintiffs Reply in Support of Motion to Compel. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Managem
May 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 102 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from David A. Langer dated 05/20/2015 re: Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant Carfax, Inc.'s Motion to Compel Discovery from Plaintiffs with Respect to Carfax's First Requests for Production of Documents. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Aut
May 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 101 OPPOSITION BRIEF re: #93 Notice (Other),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Cooper, James)
May 11, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 100 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault.(nm)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 99 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action . . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 98 DECLARATION of Annica Sunner Bianco in Support re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents, #2 Exhibit B Plaintiffs' Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents, #3 Exhibit C Carfax, Inc.'s Letter Motion dated March 19, 2015, #4 Exhibit D Plaintiffs' Response to Carfax, Inc.'s Letter Motion dated March 24, 2015, #5 Exhibit E Plaintiffs' Letter Motion for Pre-Motion Discovery Conference dated April 9, 2015, #6 Exhibit F Carfax, Inc.'s Response to Plaintiffs' April 9, 2015 Letter dated April 15, 2015, #7 Exhibit G Joint Letter addressed to the Court dated April 24, 2015 regarding follow up to April 16, 2015 Conference)(Mason, Christopher)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 97 DECLARATION of Dr. John Hayes in Support re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A letter dated February 27, 2015, #2 Exhibit B filed under seal, #3 Exhibit C filed under seal, #4 Exhibit D filed under seal, #5 Exhibit E filed under seal, #6 Exhibit F "NIADA" 2010 Used Car Industry Report, Part 1, #7 Exhibit F "NIADA" 2010 Used Car Industry Report, Part 2)(Mason, Christopher)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 96 DECLARATION of Julie A. Ortmeier in Support re: #95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A copy of an advertisement or solicitation, #2 Exhibit B copy of an advertisement or solicitation, #3 Exhibit C copy of an advertisement or solicitation)(Mason, Christopher)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 95 MOTION to Compel Plaintiffs to produce the requested discovery in this action . Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 94 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Annica Sunner Bianco dated May 8, 2015 re: Defendant's Motion to Compel Discovery. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Sunner, Annica)
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 93 NOTICE of Motion to Compel re: #92 Letter,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus,
May 8, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 92 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from DAVID A. LANGER dated May 8, 2015 re: Motion to Compel. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Grou
May 5, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 91 ORDER granting #89 Motion for James L. Cooper to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
May 5, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 90 ORDER granting #88 Motion for Kenneth L. Chernof to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
May 4, 2015 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #89 MOTION for James L. Cooper to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10879469. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (wb)
May 1, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 89 MOTION for James L. Cooper to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10879469. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A- District of Columbia Cert of Good Standing, #2 Text of Proposed Order)(Cooper, James)
May 1, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 88 MOTION for Kenneth L. Chernof to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10879379. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A- CA Cert of Good Standing, #2 Exhibit B- District of Columbia Cert of Good Standing, #3 Exhibit C- MD Court of Appeals Cert of Good Standing, #4 Text of Proposed Order)(Chernof, Kenneth)
May 1, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 87 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Susan Lee Shin on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. (Shin, Susan)
May 1, 2015 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #88 MOTION for Kenneth L. Chernof to Appear Pro Hac Vice . Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-10879379. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (wb)
April 29, 2015 Opinion or Order ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Christopher Mason dated 4/24/2015 re: joint letter. ENDORSEMENT: GRANTED. The following changes will take effect regarding page limits: no more than 8 pages for Plaintiffs' brief on their one issue; no more than 15 pages for Carfax's brief on their 2 issues. Response by Plaintiffs no more than 10 pages and a response by Carfax of no more than 7 pages; and any reply by the moving party in each instance shall be no more than 5 pages. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis on 4/29/2015) (Ellis, Ronald)
April 24, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 86 JOINT LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Christopher M. Mason dated April 24, 2015 re: Amended Procedure with respect to Joint Letter Filed on April 24, 2015 (DKT # 85). Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
April 24, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 85 JOINT LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Christopher M. Mason dated April 24, 2015 re: Joint Letter Follow Up to April 16, 2015 Conference. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
April 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 84 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Leah Threatte Bojnowski on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. (Bojnowski, Leah)
April 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 83 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Steven H Blatt on behalf of Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Rensselaer Auto Plaza, Inc., Renton Hyundai, Reydel Volkswagen, Inc., Richard Lundgren Inc., Rine Motors Inc., Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Robert Chevrolet Inc., Rockville Cars, LLC, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Route 23 Honda, Route 59 Automobile LLC, SI Safe Auto, L.L.C., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Saco Auto Holdings- HN LLC, Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC, Salerno Duane Infiniti, Salerno Duane Inc., Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Santilli Enterprises Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Sawdran LLC, Sawyer Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Scap Auto Group, Schaller, Inc., Schumacher Auto Group, Schumacher Automotive, Scotia Motors, Inc., Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Smithtown Toyota, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Star Nissan, Star Toyota, Staretz LLC, Stevenson & Associates, Inc., Stevenson Cars, Inc., Stingray Chevrolet Bartlow, LLC, Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, Stoler Gold Coast, Inc., Stoler of Westbury, Inc., Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Chilson Subaru, Subaru World of Newton, Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Sudbay Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Sunrise Auto Mall Inc., Sussex County Imports LLC, Sutton Ford Inc., Sutton Ford Lincoln, Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Tamaroff Motors, Inc., Tarrytown Honda, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., Team Precision Auto LLC, Tenafly Auto Mall Inc., Tenafly Kia-Teterboro CJDR, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., The Dorschel Group, The Symposium Group, LLC, Thirteen Twenty LLC, Thomas Dodge Corp., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., Thomas Subaru, Timco, Tims Truck Capital & Auto Sales Inc., Tirrico Inc., Townsend Bros. Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., Towson Automotive, Inc., James Toyota, Toyota World of Lakewood, Toyota World of Newton, Transit LLC, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc., United Galaxy Inc., Universal Global Inc., Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Victory Lane Imports Inc., Victory Lane Imports, Inc., W.S. Healey Chevrolet Buick, Inc., WR Thomas Inc., Waco Dodge, Inc., Wayne Motors, Inc., Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Western Motors, Inc., White Plains Chrysler Jeep, William T. Pritchard, Inc,, Williamson Cadillac Company, Yellowstone Country Motors, Yonkers Auto Outlet, Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc.. (Blatt, Steven)
April 16, 2015 Opinion or Order Minute entry for proceedings held before Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis: Initial Pretrial Conference held on 4/16/2015 at 10:30 a.m. Parties must e-file a list of discovery disputes via ECF by 4/24/2015. (rsh)
April 15, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 82 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Christopher M. Mason dated April 15, 2015 re: Response to Plaintiffs' April 9, 2015 Letter (Dkt. 78). Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
April 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 81 DECLARATION of Sara E. Farber in Support re: #80 MOTION for Sara E. Farber to Withdraw as Attorney .. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Farber, Sara)
April 13, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 80 MOTION for Sara E. Farber to Withdraw as Attorney . Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Farber, Sara)
April 10, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 79 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Annica Paula Margareta Sunner on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. (Sunner, Annica)
April 9, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 78 LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference PRE-MOTION DISCOVERY CONFERENCE LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Eric L. Cramer dated April 9, 2015. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro
April 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Initial Conference set for 4/16/2015 at 10:30 AM in Courtroom 11C, 500 Pearl Street, New York, NY 10007 before Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis. (rsh)
April 6, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 77 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Eric L. Cramer dated April 6, 2015 re: Request for Continuance of Conference Scheduled for April 9, 2015. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda,
April 6, 2015 Opinion or Order ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Eric L. Cramer dated 4/6/2015 re: alternate date for initial conference. ENDORSEMENT: GRANTED. (Signed by Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis on 4/6/2015) (Ellis, Ronald).
April 2, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 76 INTERNET CITATION NOTE: Material from decision with Internet citation re: #59 Order on Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages, Order on Motion to Dismiss. (vf)
April 1, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 75 LETTER addressed to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis from Eric L. Cramer dated April 1, 2015 re: Request For Alternate Conference Date. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./
March 27, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 74 ORDER re: #69 Letter Motion for Local Rule 37.2 Conference on Discovery Issues. This action has been referred to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis for GENERAL PRETRIAL. A CONFERENCE WILL BE HELD IN THIS CASE BY THE JUDGE ON APRIL 9, 2015, AT 11:00 A.M. IN COURTROOM 11C, 500 PEARL STREET. (Pretrial Conference set for 4/9/2015 at 11:00 AM before Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis). (Signed by Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis on 3/27/2015) (kko)
March 25, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 73 ORDER OF REFERENCE TO A MAGISTRATE JUDGE: Order that case be referred to the Clerk of Court for assignment to a Magistrate Judge for General Pretrial (includes scheduling, discovery, non-dispositive pretrial motions, and settlement). Referred to Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 3/25/2015) (kgo)
March 24, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 72 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Eric L. Cramer dated 3-24-2015 re: Discovery Dispute. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County
March 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 71 ORDER granting #70 Letter Motion for Extension of Time to File Responsive Letter to Carfax's Letter Motion. Plaintiffs' request for a one-day extension is GRANTED. Response shall be due on March 24, 2015. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 3/20/2015) (kl)
March 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 70 FIRST LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time to File Responsive Letter to Carfax's Letter Motion addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Ryan J. McEwan dated 03/20/2015. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Hon
March 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Filing 69 LETTER MOTION for Local Rule 37.2 Conference on Discovery Issues addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Christopher M. Mason dated March 19, 2015. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A-Defendant's First Interrogatories to All Plaintiffs, #2 Exhibit B-Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents to All Plaintiffs, #3 Exhibit C-Plaintiffs' Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Interrogatories, #4 Exhibit D-Plaintiffs' Responses and Objections to Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents)(Mason, Christopher)
March 20, 2015 Opinion or Order Set/Reset Deadlines: Responses due by 3/24/2015. (kl)
December 9, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 68 STIPULATED CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER...regarding procedures to be followed that shall govern the handling of confidential material... (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 12/9/2014) (lmb)
December 3, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 67 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Plaintiffs' Initial Disclosures served on Christopher M. Mason and Fredric C. Nelson for Nixon Peabody, LLP on December 1, 2014. Service was made by First Class Mail and Email. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc
December 3, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 66 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Defendant Carfax, Inc.'s Rule 26(a) Initial Disclosures served on Joseph R. Saveri, Esq. and Ryan J. McEwan, Esq. of the Joseph Saveri Law Firm; Leonard A. Bellavia, Esq. and Steven H. Blatt, Esq. of Bellavia Blatt & Crossett, PC; and Eric L. Cramer, Esq. and David A. Langer, Esq. of Berger & Montague, P.C. on 12/1/2014. Service was made by regular first class mail and e-mail. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Farber, Sara)
December 1, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 65 JOINT MOTION for Confidentiality Proposed Stipulated Confidentiality Order. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive
October 31, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 64 CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN AND SCHEDULING ORDER: This Civil Case Management Plan (the "Plan") is submitted by the parties in accordance with Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(f)(3). All parties do not consent to conducting all further proceedings before a United States Magistrate Judge, including motions and trial pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 636(c). This case is to be tried to a jury. Deposition due by 3/31/2016. Case Management Conference set for 7/10/2015 at 11:00 AM before Judge Alison J. Nathan. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/31/2014) (ama)
October 31, 2014 Opinion or Order Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge Alison J. Nathan: Initial Pretrial Conference held on 10/31/2014. (snu)
October 30, 2014 Opinion or Order **REMINDER & TIME CHANGE** There is an Initial Pretrial Conference scheduled for Friday, October 31, 2014 at 11:00 AM in Courtroom 906 of the Thurgood Marshall United States Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, New York, New York before the Honorable Alison J. Nathan, U.S.D.J. (snu)
October 24, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 63 JOINT LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Joint Parties dated 10/24/2014 re: Civil Case Management Plan and Scheduling Order. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rall
October 24, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 62 INITIAL REPORT OF PARTIES BEFORE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Rensselaer Auto Plaza, Inc., Renton Hyundai, Reydel Volkswagen, Inc., Richard Lundgren Inc., Rine Motors Inc., Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Robert Chevrolet Inc., Rockville Cars, LLC, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Route 59 Automobile LLC, SI Safe Auto, L.L.C., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Saco Auto Holdings- HN LLC, Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC, Salerno Duane Infiniti, Salerno Duane Inc., Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Santilli Enterprises Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Sawdran LLC, Sawyer Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Scap Auto Group, Schaller, Inc., Schumacher Auto Group, Schumacher Automotive, Scotia Motors, Inc., Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Smithtown Toyota, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Staretz LLC, Stevenson & Associates, Inc., Stevenson Cars, I
October 14, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 61 ANSWER to #56 Amended Complaint,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
October 6, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 60 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Eric L. Cramer dated October 6, 2014 re: Docket No. 58. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Carfax, Inc., Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto
September 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 59 REDACTED MEMORANDUM & ORDER denying #9 Letter Motion for Leave to File Excess Pages; denying #10 Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part #29 Motion to Dismiss. For the foregoing reasons, Defendant's motion to dismiss is GRANTED with respect to Plaintiffs' claim under Clayton Act 3, and DENIED in all other respects. This resolves Dkt. No. 29. Docket Nos. 9 and 10 are administratively denied as moot. A separate Order scheduling an Initial Pre-Trial Conference will follow. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/29/2014) (lmb)
September 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 58 ORDER: Consistent with its earlier indication and in light of the extent to which the sealed documents were relied upon in the Court's September 29, 2014 Memorandum and Order, the Court will now revisit the question whether the documents at issue should remain under seal. The parties shall reply in separate letters by October 6, 2014 as further set forth in this order. If the parties do not reply by October 6, 2014, the Court promptly will file an unredacted version of its September 29,2014 Memorandum and Order and unseal the documents that were subject to the provisional orders. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/29/2014) (lmb)
September 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 57 NOTICE OF INITIAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE: Initial Conference set for 10/31/2014 at 11:15 AM in Courtroom 906, 40 Centre Street, New York, NY 10007 before Judge Alison J. Nathan as further set forth in this order. Parties ordered to submit via ECF proposed case management plan and joint letter seven days before conference. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/29/2014) (lmb)
June 3, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 56 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT amending #8 Amended Complaint,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, against Carfax, Inc. with JURY DEMAND.Document filed by Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Nissan World of Red Bank, Manfredi Motors Inc., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, BTLS, Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Western Motors, Inc., Bronx Ford, Inc., Route 59 Automobile LLC, Bayside Chrysler, Hanford Toyota, Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., 3925 Partners Ltd., William T. Pritchard, Inc,, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Northtown Toyota Scion, Beaver Motors, Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., JMK Auto Sales Inc., Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Townsend Bros. Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Burien Nissan, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Toyota World of Lakewood, Archer Dodge Inc., Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, John O. Stevenson, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Chilson Corner Motors, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Thirteen Twenty LLC, Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, WR Thomas Inc., Curry Cars LLC, Poquoson Motors, Inc., Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, County Line Buick Nissan, Life Quality BMW, Paul Miller GT Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., United Galaxy Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Carson Automotive Inc., Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, City World Motors, LLC, Kia Tacoma, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Hanford Hyundai, Cherry Hill Imports, King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Timco, Healey Automotive L.L.C., Corvettes of Florida, Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Gault Toyota, Brentlinger Enterprises, Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Tenafly Kia-Teterboro CJDR, Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Hoehn Company, Inc., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Biener Auto Group, Sutton Ford Lincoln, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Offlease4less, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Nissan of Fontana Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Heinrich Chevrolet, Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Nissan World LLC, Williamson Cadillac Company, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Rockville Cars, LLC, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Bob Bell Ford, Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Elk Grove Kia, Durand Chevrolet, Route 23 Honda, Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Balise FOW, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, JMK East L.L.C., Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Chevrolet of Jersey City, Concours Motors Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Prime Infiniti Inc., James Toyota, Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Sunrise Auto Mall Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, FSW, Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Balise V., Inc, White Plains Chrysler Jeep, Automotive Avenues, LLC, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Brentlineger Enterprises, Sutton Ford Inc., Moore Family of Dealership, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Star Toyota, Martin Swanty Kia, Mack Auto Imports Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Hyundai, Archer Kia, Joseph T of D Co., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Krusemark Automotive, Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Haldeman Nissan Inc., Harden Motor Car Corp., Nissan World of Denville, Cape Hy, Inc., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Joseph Northland Motors Inc., BFC 3 LLC, Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, J.O.S., Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Cardinal Honda, Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., N & H Motors, Inc., Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Tirrico Inc., Autoworld Kia, Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Dijos Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, The Dorschel Group, M.T. Imports Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., 21st Century Auto Group, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., M & S of Pawling, Inc., Scap Auto Group, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Lyle's Auto LLC, Staretz LLC, A & H Motors Inc., LCJ Inc., FOC Inc., Balise T, LLC, Joseph T of C, Co., Parsons Buick Company, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Fairfield Motors Inc., Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, BLS, Inc., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Richard Lundgren Inc., Gault Auto Sport BMW, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Clay Corporation, Curry Auto LLC, DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Sudbay Chrysler Dodge, Inc., DGM, L.L.C., Toyota World of Newton, Car Pros Renton, Sussex County Imports LLC, Stevenson & Associates, Inc., GAE, LLC, City Motors LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Saco Auto Holdings- HN LLC, Yellowstone Country Motors, Tamaroff Motors, Inc., County Line Carriage Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Price Cars SR LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Jaguar of Great Neck, Stoler of Westbury, Inc., Lash Auto Group LLC, Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Salerno Duane Infiniti, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Northtown Lexus, Perrine Auto Group, Lyford Motors LLC, Donohoo Auto, LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., R & M Marketing Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Classic Autoplex Galveston, Schumacher Auto Group, Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Outten Automotive, Inc., Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Linear Motors LLC, ADA Motors Inc., Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Universal Global Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., 4984 Partners Ltd., McGrath Nissan Inc., Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Manfredi Auto LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Subaru World of Newton, Chrysler of Culpeper, Victory Lane Imports, Inc., Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Renton Hyundai, Burien Chevrolet Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Next Motors Corporation, Biener Audi, Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Towson Automotive, Inc., Joseph Chevrolet Company, Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Henry Valencia Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Schumacher Automotive, Denville Nissan Inc., Great Neck Suzuki, Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., Norwood Subaru, Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Gault Volkswagen, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Team Precision Auto LLC, Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Curry Imports Inc., Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Wayne Motors, Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, Multi Subaru LLC, Star Nissan, Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., Imports & More, Inc., Rine Motors Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Stingray Chevrolet Bartlow, LLC, Waco Dodge, Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Stoler Gold Coast, Inc., Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, HB Chevrolet, Ralph Automotive Inc., Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Nissan sales Corp., Tims Truck Capital & Auto Sales Inc., Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Space Coast Auto Group Inc., The Symposium Group, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Transit LLC, Curry Motor Cars, LLC, L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Nissan World of Dartmouth, Coliseum Lincoln Mercur
June 2, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 55 REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #29 MOTION to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint. . Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Farber, Sara)
May 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 54 ORDER: Pursuant to Rule 3.D of this Court's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, the Defendant is hereby ordered to submit two courtesy copies of all motion papers, marked as such, to Chambers. All courtesy copies should be three-hole punched, tabbed, and placed in binders. Parties submitting courtesy copies of motion papers containing approved redactions must do so in accordance with Rule 4.A. The Parties are also reminded of the Court's Order dated May 21,2014 (Dkt. No. 51) directing the Parties to file promptly redacted copies of the Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint and Defendant's Reply Brief in Support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 5/29/2014) (ajs)
May 22, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 53 SEALED DOCUMENT placed in vault.(rz)
May 21, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 52 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Sara Elizabeth Farber on behalf of Carfax, Inc.. (Farber, Sara)
May 21, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 51 ORDER: Consistent with the Court's January 29, 2014, order, the Court provisionally grants the request to file under seal Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint and Defendant's reply brief in support of Defendants' Motion to Dismiss. Defendants shall promptly file redacted copies of these documents and the Court will file the originals under seal. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 5/21/2014) (ajs)
April 11, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 50 ORDER: The Court has not yet received the proposed redactions to the reply brief submitted in this matter that Defendant's counsel indicated would be forthcoming. Any such proposed redactions shall be submitted no later than April 18, 2014. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 4/11/2014) (ajs)
February 13, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 49 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS by Joseph Richard Saveri on behalf of All Plaintiffs. New Address: Joseph Saveri Law Firm, Inc., 505 Montgomery Street, Suite 625, San Francisco, CA, 94111, 415-500-6800. (Saveri, Joseph)
February 10, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 48 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Opposition re: #29 MOTION to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint. Redacted for Public Filing. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-
February 5, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 47 ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from David A. Langer dated 1/31/2014 re: Pursuant to Paragraph 4.A of your Honor's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, please find enclosed a copy of Plaintiffs' Brief In Opposition to Carfax's Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Amended Complaint (the "Brief"), and the accompanying Declaration of David A. Langer, in the above-captioned matter. Because the Brief discusses materials that Defendant has requested be filed under seal, it contains proposed redactions that are marked with yellow highlighting. Also enclosed, in accordance with Paragraph 4.A, is a partial, loose leaf set of only those pages of the Brief containing the proposed redactions. Plaintiffs are concurrently filing via email to Chambers a .pdf copy of the enclosed Brief. ENDORSEMENT: Consistent with the Court's 1/29 order, Plaintiffs shall promptly ECF file the redacted documents and the Court will provisionally file the originals under seal. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 2/5/2014) (djc) Modified on 2/5/2014 (djc). Modified on 2/6/2014 (djc).
February 5, 2014 Opinion or Order Transmission to Sealed Records Clerk. Transmitted re: #47 Endorsed Letter, to the Sealed Records Clerk for the sealing or unsealing of document or case. (djc)
February 4, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 46 DECLARATION of Julie A. Ortmeier in Support re: #29 MOTION to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit Exhibit D, #5 Exhibit Exhibit E, #6 Exhibit Exhibit F, #7 Exhibit Exhibit G, #8 Exhibit Exhibit H, #9 Exhibit Exhibit I, #10 Exhibit Exhibit J, #11 Exhibit Exhibit K, #12 Exhibit Exhibit L, #13 Exhibit Exhibit M, #14 Exhibit Exhibit N, #15 Exhibit Exhibit O, #16 Exhibit Exhibit P, #17 Exhibit Exhibit Q, #18 Exhibit Exhibit R, #19 Exhibit Exhibit S, #20 Exhibit Exhibit T, #21 Exhibit Exhibit U, #22 Exhibit Exhibit V, #23 Exhibit Exhibit W, #24 Exhibit Exhibit X)(Mason, Christopher)
January 31, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 45 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #29 MOTION to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
January 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 44 ORDER: Therefore, the Court will provisionally grant Defendant's request, file all of the unredacted agreements under seal, and permit the filing, with the requested redactions, of Defendant's moving papers. Defendant shall promptly ECF file the redacted versions of its moving papers, and the Court will file the unredacted originals under seal. The Court will revisit this decision following the resolution of Defendant's motion to dismiss or upon request. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 1/29/2014) (cd)
January 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 43 ORDER granting #40 Motion for Joshua P. Davis to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
January 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 42 ORDER granting #39 Motion for Joseph R. Saveri to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
January 29, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 41 ORDER granting #38 Motion for Ryan J. McEwan to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 40 MOTION for Joshua P. Davis to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Managemen
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 39 MOTION for Joseph R. Saveri to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Manageme
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 38 MOTION for Ryan J. McEwan to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING DEFICIENT MOTION TO APPEAR PRO HAC VICE. Notice regarding Document No. #36 MOTION for Joseph R. Saveri to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283861. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff., #35 MOTION for Ryan J. McEwan to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283848. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff., #37 MOTION for Joshua P. Davis to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283862. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. Certificate of Good Standing Must be issued from Supreme Court of California with a Clerk of Court Signature. Re-file the document as a Corrected Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice and attach a valid Certificate of Good Standing, issued within the past 30 days. (wb)
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #40 MOTION for Joshua P. Davis to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (wb)
January 23, 2014 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #39 MOTION for Joseph R. Saveri to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff., #38 MOTION for Ryan J. McEwan to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (bcu)
January 22, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 37 FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Joshua P. Davis to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283862. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms Ri
January 22, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 36 FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Joseph R. Saveri to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283861. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms R
January 22, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 35 FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Ryan J. McEwan to Appear Pro Hac Vice on Behalf of Plaintiffs. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9283848. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms Riv
January 17, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 34 ORDER granting #31 Motion for David A. Langer to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
January 17, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 33 ORDER granting #30 Motion for Eric L. Cramer to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
January 15, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 32 NOTICE OF APPEARANCE by Daniel John Walker on behalf of 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Rallye Automotive LLC, Ralph Automotive Inc., Range Rove
January 15, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 31 MOTION for David A. Langer to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9263091. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro H
January 15, 2014 Opinion or Order Filing 30 MOTION for Eric L. Cramer to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9262934. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by 21st Century Auto Group, 3925 Partners Ltd., 4984 Partners Ltd., 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., A & H Motors Inc., ADA Motors Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - AC, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Archer Kia, Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Automotive Avenues, LLC, Autoworld Kia, Axelrod Chrysler Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, BFC 3 LLC, BLS, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Balise C, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Balise N, LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise T, LLC, Balise V., Inc, Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Bayside Chrysler, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Beaver Motors, Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Bergstrom Victory Lane, Inc,, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Biener Audi, Biener Auto Group, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Brentlineger Enterprises, Brentlinger Enterprises, Bronx Ford, Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Burien Nissan, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Cape Hy, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Car Pros Renton, Cardinal Honda, Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Carson Automotive Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., Cherry Hill Imports, Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Chilson Corner Motors, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Chrysler of Culpeper, City Motors LLC, City World Motors, LLC, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Clay Corporation, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Community Honda, Concours Motors Inc., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., County Line Buick Nissan, County Line Carriage Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Curry Auto LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Curry Cars LLC, Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Curry Imports Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., DGM, L.L.C., DTC Corp., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Denville Nissan Inc., Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Dijos Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Durand Chevrolet, Durand Toyota-Ford, Dutchess Cars, LLC, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Elk Grove Toyota, Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., FOC Inc., FSW, Inc., Fairfield Motors Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Motors, Inc., Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Frangie Motors Inc., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., GAE, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, Garcia Imports Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Gault Chevrolet, Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Gault Toyota, Gault Volkswagen, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Great Neck Suzuki, Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., HB Chevrolet, Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Hampton Imports LLC, Hanford Hyundai, Hanford Toyota, Harden Motor Car Corp., Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Heinrich Chevrolet, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Henry Valencia Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Howard Auto Group, Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Hummer of Columbus LLC, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Imorts Service Center, Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Imports Service Center, Inc., Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, J.O.S., Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, JMK Auto Sales Inc., JMK East L.L.C., JSBP, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Jaguar of Freeport, Jaguar of Great Neck, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., John O. Stevenson, Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Joseph H of D LLC, Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Joseph T of C, Co., Joseph T of D Co., Martin Swanty Kia, Kia Tacoma, Kim Cesare Auto Sales, Inc., King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Krusemark Automotive, Inc., L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., LCJ Inc., Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Lash Auto Group LLC, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Life Quality BMW, Linear Motors LLC, Lupo LLC, Lyford Motors LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, M & S of Pawling, Inc., M.T. Imports Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Auto LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Manfredi Motors Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Martin Swanty Hyundai, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, McGrath Nissan Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Moore Family of Dealership, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, N & H Motors, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Next Motors Corporation, NextMotors Corporation, Nissan World LLC, Nissan World of Dartmouth, Nissan World of Denville, Nissan World of Red Bank, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Nissan World of Springfield, Nissan of Fontana Inc., Nissan sales Corp., North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., North Shore Chevrolet, Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Northtown Lexus, Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Offlease4less, Ontario Nissan Inc., Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Outten Automotive, Inc., Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Parsons Buick Company, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Paul Miller AWD LLC, Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, Paul Miller GT Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Perrine Auto Group, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Price Cars SR LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, Price Simms, Inc., Prime Infiniti Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, R & M Marketing Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Ho
January 15, 2014 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #31 MOTION for David A. Langer to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9263091. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff., #30 MOTION for Eric L. Cramer to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $ 200.00, receipt number 0208-9262934. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (wb)
December 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 29 MOTION to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. Responses due by 1/31/2014(Mason, Christopher)
November 15, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 28 STIPULATION AND ORDER SETTING BRIEFING SCHEDULE: Defendant currently intends to move to dismiss the 125 page, 600 paragraph Second Amended Complaint. If Defendant does so, the parties stipulate and agree to the following briefing schedule: December 17, 2013: motion, brief, and supporting papers, if any, to be served and, if they contain no material for which a request has been made for filing under seal, filed; January 31, 2014: opposition brief and supporting papers, if any, to be served and, if they contain no material for which a request has been made for filing under seal, filed; February 21, 2014: reply brief and supporting papers, if any, to be served and, if they contain no material for which a request has been made for filing under seal, filed. Consistent with the enlargement of page limits granted on September 18, 2013 with respect to the prior motion to dismiss mooted by the filing of a Second Amended Complaint by Plaintiffs, the parties request, pursuant to Your Honor's Individual Practices in Civil Cases Rule 3(B), an enlargement of the page limits for any briefs to be filed in support, opposition, and reply to a new motion to dismiss of the same 35 pages for the opening and opposition briefs (40 if footnotes are included in typeface of the same size as the text, rather than the smaller size permitted by Local Civil Rule 11.1 (b) of the Local Rules of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York) and 20 pages (25 if footnotes are included in typeface of the same size as the text, rather than the smaller size permitted by Local Ci vii Rule 11.1 (b)) for the reply brief. This Stipulation and Order may be executed in counterparts. Facsimile or electronically transmitted signatures shall be deemed binding as original signatures. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 11/15/2013) (rsh)
October 24, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 27 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT amending #8 Amended Complaint, against Carfax, Inc. with JURY DEMAND.Document filed by Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Manfredi Motors Inc., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, BTLS, Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Western Motors, Inc., Bronx Ford, Inc., Route 59 Automobile LLC, Bayside Chrysler, Hanford Toyota, Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, Classic Buick GMC Ltd., 3925 Partners Ltd., William T. Pritchard, Inc,, Merrimac Motors, Inc., Northtown Toyota Scion, Beaver Motors, Inc., Community Chevrolet Inc., Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., JMK Auto Sales Inc., Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Beck Automotive Group, Townsend Bros. Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Burien Nissan, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Archer Dodge Inc., Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, John O. Stevenson, Inc., Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, Balise Subaru Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, WR Thomas Inc., Curry Cars LLC, Poquoson Motors, Inc., Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, County Line Buick Nissan, Paul Miller GT Inc., Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., United Galaxy Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Price Simms Ford, LLC, D & C Chevrolet Co., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Carson Automotive Inc., Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, City World Motors, LLC, Kia Tacoma, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Hanford Hyundai, King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Timco, Healey Automotive L.L.C., Corvettes of Florida, Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Gault Toyota, Brentlinger Enterprises, Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Hoehn Company, Inc., Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Biener Auto Group, Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Maxon Auto Enterprises, Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Offlease4less, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Nissan of Fontana Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Nissan World LLC, Williamson Cadillac Company, Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Rockville Cars, LLC, J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Bob Bell Ford, Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Elk Grove Kia, Durand Chevrolet, Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Balise FOW, Inc., J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Mazda, BDF Acquisitions of New Mexico, North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, JMK East L.L.C., Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Chevrolet of Jersey City, Concours Motors Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Prime Infiniti Inc., James Toyota, Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Sunrise Auto Mall Inc., AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, FSW, Inc., R &J Nissan LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Balise V., Inc, White Plains Chrysler Jeep, Automotive Avenues, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., Brentlineger Enterprises, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Sutton Ford Inc., Moore Family of Dealership, E.M. Rinehart Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC, Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Archer Kia, Joseph T of D Co., Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Krusemark Automotive, Inc., Camargo Cadillac Company, Haldeman Nissan Inc., Harden Motor Car Corp., Cape Hy, Inc., Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Joseph Northland Motors Inc., BFC 3 LLC, Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Archer Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., J.O.S., Inc., Cardinal Honda, Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., N & H Motors, Inc., Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Tirrico Inc., Autoworld Kia, Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Dijos Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., Pruitt Ford LLC, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., John O'Rion Stevenson, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Phoenix Motor Company, The Dorschel Group, M.T. Imports Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., 21st Century Auto Group, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., M & S of Pawling, Inc., Scap Auto Group, Lyle's Auto LLC, Staretz LLC, A & H Motors Inc., LCJ Inc., FOC Inc., Balise T, LLC, Joseph T of C, Co., Parsons Buick Company, Archer Chrysler Jeep West Inc., Morris Auto Plaza, Inc., Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Fairfield Motors Inc., Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, BLS, Inc., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Richard Lundgren Inc., Gault Auto Sport BMW, Haldeman Ford, Inc., Clay Corporation, Curry Auto LLC, DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Sudbay Chrysler Dodge, Inc., DGM, L.L.C., Car Pros Renton, Sussex County Imports LLC, Stevenson & Associates, Inc., GAE, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Saco Auto Holdings- HN LLC, Yellowstone Country Motors, Tamaroff Motors, Inc., County Line Carriage Inc., Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Price Cars SR LLC, Conklin Cars Salina LLC, Bellavia Buick, Inc., Stoler of Westbury, Inc., Lash Auto Group LLC, Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Salerno Duane Infiniti, J.O. Stevenson, Inc., Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Balise Motor Sales Company, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Northtown Lexus, Lyford Motors LLC, Donohoo Auto, LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., R & M Marketing Inc., Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Classic Autoplex Galveston, Schumacher Auto Group, Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Outten Automotive, Inc., Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Linear Motors LLC, ADA Motors Inc., Fitzgerald Buick, Inc., Thirteen Twenty LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, Universal Global Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., 4984 Partners Ltd., McGrath Nissan Inc., Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Manfredi Auto LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Archer Financial Holdings Inc., Subaru World of Newton, Chrysler of Culpeper, Victory Lane Imports, Inc., Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, Renton Hyundai, Burien Chevrolet Inc., Farrell Motors, Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Fitzgerald Lake Forest Motors, Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Next Motors Corporation, Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Towson Automotive, Inc., Joseph Chevrolet Company, Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Henry Valencia Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Schumacher Automotive, Denville Nissan Inc., Great Neck Suzuki, Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., Norwood Subaru, Inc., Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, Curry Automotive LLC, Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Frederick Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Gault Volkswagen, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Team Precision Auto LLC, Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Acton Toyota of Littleton, Curry Imports Inc., Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Wayne Motors, Inc., Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, Multi Subaru LLC, Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., Imports & More, Inc., Rine Motors Inc., Bartow Ford Company, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Stingray Chevrolet Bartlow, LLC, Waco Dodge, Inc., Crestview Cadillac Corp., Stoler Gold Coast, Inc., Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, HB Chevrolet, Ralph Automotive Inc., Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Nissan sales Corp., Tims Truck Capital & Auto Sales Inc., Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Space Coast Auto Group Inc., The Symposium Group, LLC, Galesburg Nissan Corp., Transit LLC, Curry Motor Cars, LLC, L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, Fitzgerald Toyota Inc., Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Miller Motor Car Corp., Community Honda, Balise JRN, Inc., Alfredo's Foreign Cars, Joseph H of D LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Garcia Motorcars LLC, Rallye Automotive LLC, Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Garcia Imports Inc., Baron Nissan Inc., Northside Ford Truck Sales Inc., Outten Motors, L.L.C., Archer Volkswagen, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., NYLSI Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet, Elk Grove Toyota, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Stevenson Cars, Inc., Imorts Service Center, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., JSBP, Inc., Paul Miller Motors LLC, Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC, Lupo LLC, Scotia Motors, Inc., Price Simms, Inc., Gault Chevrolet
October 24, 2013 Opinion or Order ***NOTE TO ATTORNEY TO E-MAIL PDF. Note to Attorney Leonard A. Bellavia for noncompliance with Section 14.3 of the S.D.N.Y. Electronic Case Filing Rules & Instructions. E-MAIL the PDF for Document 27 Amended Complaint, to: caseopenings@nysd.uscourts.gov. (lmb)
October 7, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 26 MEMO ENDORSEMENT on #24 Letter filed by Maxon Hyundai Mazda re requesting to have until 10/24/2013 to file an Amended Pleading. ( Amended Pleading due by 10/24/2013.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 10/7/2013) (cd)
October 4, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 25 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Christopher M. Mason dated 10/4/13 Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
October 3, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 24 LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Plaintiffs dated October 3, 2013 re: Election to Amend Complaint. Document filed by Maxon Hyundai Mazda.(Blatt, Steven)
September 26, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 23 ORDER: On September 17, 2013, Defendant filed a motion to dismiss in this case. Pursuant to Rule 3.F of this Court's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, on or before October 3, 2013, Plaintiffs must notify the Court and Defendant in writing whether (1) they intend to file an amended pleading and when they will do so or (2) they will rely on the pleading being attacked. If Plaintiffs elect not to amend their complaint, no further opportunities to amend will be granted and the motion to dismiss will proceed in the regular course. If Plaintiffs choose to amend, Defendant may then (a) file an answer; (b) file a new motion to dismiss; or (c) submit a letter stating that it relies on the initially-filed motion to dismiss. Nothing in this Order alters the time to amend, answer or move provided by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure or Local Rules. The initial pretrial conference scheduled for September 27, 2013 is adjourned pending resolution of this motion. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/26/2013) (cd)
September 24, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 22 ORDER granting #21 Motion for Sara E. Farber to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
September 23, 2013 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #21 MOTION for Sara E. Farber to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (bwa)
September 20, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 21 MOTION for Sara E. Farber to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $200.00, receipt number 0208-8894230. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Declaration of Sara Farber, #2 Text of Proposed Order)(Mason, Christopher) Modified on 9/23/2013 (bwa).
September 20, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 20 ORDER granting #19 Motion for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Alison J. Nathan)(Text Only Order) (Nathan, Alison)
September 20, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 19 MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Declaration of Fredric C. Nelson, #2 Text of Proposed Order)(Mason, Christopher)
September 20, 2013 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING PRO HAC VICE MOTION. Regarding Document No. #19 MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. The document has been reviewed and there are no deficiencies. (bwa)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 18 INITIAL REPORT OF PARTIES BEFORE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 17 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #10 MOTION to Dismiss Amended Complaint.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 16 RULE 7.1 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. Identifying Corporate Parent IHS Inc for Carfax, Inc.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 15 ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Christopher M. Mason dated 9/16/2013 re: Request for permission to file an oversized memorandum of law. ENDORSEMENT: 35, So Ordered. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 9/18/2013) (cd)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 14 FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice Corrected. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Declaration of Fredric C. Nelson, #2 Text of Proposed Order)(Mason, Christopher) Modified on 9/18/2013 (bcu).
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING DEFICIENT MOTION TO APPEAR PRO HAC VICE. Notice regarding Document No. #14 MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice Corrected. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. The filing is deficient for the following reason(s): Missing Certificate of Good Standing. Certificates of Good Standing must be issued from the State Court of California and not from a State Bar Association. Re-file the document as a Corrected Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice and attach a valid Certificate of Good Standing, issued within the past 30 days. (bcu)
September 18, 2013 Opinion or Order >>>NOTICE REGARDING DEFICIENT MOTION TO APPEAR PRO HAC VICE. Notice regarding Document No. #12 MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. The filing is deficient for the following reason(s): Missing Certificate of Good Standing.Missing Proposed Order. Re-file the document as a Corrected Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice, file your declaration and certificate as attachments to the motion and attach a Proposed Order as well. (bwa)
September 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 13 DECLARATION of Fredric C. Nelson in Support re: #12 MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
September 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 12 FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT DOCKET ENTRY - MOTION for Fredric C. Nelson to Appear Pro Hac Vice. Filing fee $200.00, receipt number 208-8881329. Motion and supporting papers to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher) Modified on 9/18/2013 (bwa).
September 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 11 MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #10 MOTION to Dismiss Amended Complaint.. Document filed by Carfax, Inc.. (Mason, Christopher)
September 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 10 MOTION to Dismiss Amended Complaint. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
September 17, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 9 LETTER MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Christopher M. Mason dated September 16, 2013. Document filed by Carfax, Inc..(Mason, Christopher)
August 23, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 8 AMENDED COMPLAINT amending #1 Complaint, against Carfax, Inc. with JURY DEMAND.Document filed by Anderson of Hunt Valley, LLC, Paul Miller Sportscars Inc., Bellavia Buick, Inc., Manfredi Motors Inc., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Stoler of Westbury, Inc., Lash Auto Group LLC, Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Habberstad Volkswagen Inc., Anderson Motors, LLC, Diehl Automotive of Robinson, Inc., BTLS, Inc., Thomas Sales & Service, Inc., Sam Scism Motors, Inc., Len Stoler Inc., Western Motors, Inc., Bronx Ford, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- PA, LLC, Salerno Duane Infiniti, Bergstrom Cadillac Inc., Route 59 Automobile LLC, Hanford Toyota, Stingray Chevrolet, LLC, Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., Port Jeff Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Classic Buick GMC Ltd., 3925 Partners Ltd., Balise Motor Sales Company, William T. Pritchard, Inc,, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., Merrimac Motors, Inc., Northtown Toyota Scion, Northtown Lexus, Habberstad Nissan, Inc., Lyford Motors LLC, Community Chevrolet Inc., Donohoo Auto, LLC, R&J Nissan, LLC, Bergstrom Converters Drive, Inc., JMK Auto Sales Inc., Habberstad Motorsport Inc., Beck Automotive Group, R & M Marketing Inc., Dartmouth Nissan, Inc., Schumacher Auto Group, Classic Autoplex Galveston, Bergstrom Ford- Lincoln of Neenah, Inc., Townsend Bros. Inc., Fleet Lease Network Inc., Burien Nissan, Gerry Wood Automotive LLC, 86th Street Chevrolet, Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet Inc., Joseph Northland Motors Inc., Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Outten Automotive, Inc., DeNooyer Chevrolet, Inc., Treasure Coast Imports, Inc., Shaker Valley Auto & Tire Inc., Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc., Linear Motors LLC, Thirteen Twenty LLC, ADA Motors Inc., Universal Global Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- MW, LLC, Plaintiff Performance Motors LLC, Huntington Jeep Chrysler Inc., Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc., Hoehn Motors Inc., Plaza Motors of Brooklyn, Inc., Garcia Imported Cars, LLC, Bergstrom of the Fox Valley, Inc., Bergstrom Ford of Oshkosh, Inc., McGrath Nissan Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC, 4984 Partners Ltd., Balise Subaru Inc., Sudbay Chevrolet- Buick- Cadillac- GMC, Inc., Cold Brook Auto, Inc., Balise Hy, Inc., Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., Manfredi Auto LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Bob Bell Chevrolet of Bel Air, Inc., Crystal Bay Imports, LTD, Subaru World of Newton, Chrysler of Culpeper, Victory Lane Imports, Inc., Cars Unlimited of Suffolk, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC, Renton Hyundai, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, WR Thomas Inc., Burien Chevrolet Inc., Curry Cars LLC, Farrell Motors, Inc., Poquoson Motors, Inc., Magic City Motor Corp., Garcia's Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, County Line Buick Nissan, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Paul Miller GT Inc., Bob Bell Chevrolet- Nissan, Inc., Next Motors Corporation, Carter Chevrolet Co., Inc., Twin Pine Auto Group, Inc., Sarant Cadillac Corp., Conklin Cars Newton LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Hassett Lincoln- Mercury Sales, Inc., United Galaxy Inc., Towson Automotive, Inc., JBA Automotive LLC, Paul Miller Performance LLC, Joseph Chevrolet Company, Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Tustin Buick GMC Inc., Hyundai of White Plains LLC, Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC, Pleasant Valley Motors Inc., Schumacher Automotive, Port Motors Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Price Simms Ford, LLC, Denville Nissan Inc., Great Neck Suzuki, D & C Chevrolet Co., Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc., AutoBranch South FL, Inc., Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, City World Motors, LLC, Kia Tacoma, Northtown Hyundai Inc., Bergstrom Luxury Imports of the Fox Valley Inc., Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., Hanford Hyundai, King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC, Timco, Norwood Subaru, Inc., Heinrich Chevrolet Corp., Healey Automotive L.L.C., Curry Automotive LLC, Axelrod Pontiac- Buick LLC, Corvettes of Florida, Inc., Martens Chevrolet, Inc., Gault Toyota, Brentlinger Enterprises, Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Open Road of Mendham, LLC, Gault Volkswagen, Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Hoehn Company, Inc., Team Precision Auto LLC, Major World Chevrolet, LLC, Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc., Biener Auto Group, Conklin Fangman Kansas City LLC, Central Avenue Nissan, Inc., Morehead Auto Sales Inc., Howard Wilson Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Baron Auto Maxx, Inc., Joseph Cadillac Saab Subaru LLC, Maxon Auto Enterprises, Curry Imports Inc., Acton Toyota of Littleton, Perrine's Pontiac Inc., Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Offlease4less, Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc., Nissan of Fontana Inc., Wayne Motors, Inc., Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Nissan World of Red Bank, LLC, Grand Prix Jeep Chrysler, LLC, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., Gladding Chevrolet Inc., Joseph Buick GMC Truck Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- TO, LLC, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Multi Subaru LLC, Nissan World LLC, Dick DeVoe- Buick Cadillac Inc., Imports & More, Inc., Greenwich Automotive Enterprises Enterprises, Ltd., Williamson Cadillac Company, Rine Motors Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, LLC, Rockville Cars, LLC, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Stingray Chevrolet Bartlow, LLC, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Waco Dodge, Inc., Bob Bell Ford, Bergstrom Kaukauna, Inc., Car Pros Kia of Tacoma, Crestview Cadillac Corp., Stoler Gold Coast, Inc., Elk Grove Kia, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Ralph Automotive Inc., HB Chevrolet, Durand Chevrolet, Nissan sales Corp., Durand Automotive Group, Inc., Adee Motor Cars, LLC, Rossi Chevrolet Buick GMC, Inc., Space Coast Auto Group Inc., Galesburg Nissan Corp., Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc., Curry Motor Cars, LLC, Balise FOW, Inc., P.A.C. Automotive LLC, L.T. Begnal Motor Company Inc., Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc., Enterprise Motorcars, Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc., North Bay Cadillac Co. Inc., Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Garden City Jeep Chrysler Dodge, LLC, Miller Motor Car Corp., Coliseum Lincoln Mercury, Inc., Balise JRN, Inc., Community Honda, JMK East L.L.C., Joseph H of D LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TY, LLC, Stuart Conklin Buick Inc., Garcia Motorcars LLC, Chevrolet of Jersey City, Concours Motors Inc., Towson Automotive Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, Prime Infiniti Inc., James Toyota, Vera- Williams Investments, Inc., Sunrise Auto Mall Inc., The Dorschel Group, Rallye Automotive LLC, AMR Auto Holdings - HN, LLC, R &J Nissan LLC, Classic Chevrolet Sugar Land, LLC, Land Rover of Parsippany Inc., Clay Nissan of Newtown, Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Inc., Curry Chevrolet Sales & Service Inc., Garcia Imports Inc., B & Z Auto Enterprises LLC, Chilson's Corner Motors of Caddot, LLC, Baron Nissan Inc., Ford of Hyannis, Inc., Jack Ingram Motors, Inc., Balise V., Inc, Outten Motors, L.L.C., White Plains Chrysler Jeep, Automotive Avenues, LLC, Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Inc., Dralle Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., AMR Auto Holdings- MH, LLC, B.C.T. Imports Inc., Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc., Classic Buick GMC of Carrollton, LLC, Arlington Automotive Group, Inc., Freedom Ford, Inc., Brentlineger Enterprises, Huntington Hyundai, Inc., Sutton Ford Inc., Yonkers Auto Outlet, NYLSI Inc., Moore Family of Dealership, Elk Grove Toyota, Jeffrey Automotive Group, Inc., E.M. Rinehart Inc., Levvittown Ford LLC, Bergstrom Cadillac of Green Bay, Inc., Hillside Automall, Inc., Hoehn JLR Inc., Mack Auto Imports Inc., Imorts Service Center, Inc., RB Automotive Group Inc., Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC, Paul Miller Motors LLC, Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead, Lupo LLC, Scotia Motors, Inc., Price Simms, Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Gault Chevrolet Co., Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet- Cadillac- Buick- GMC Truck, Barry's Auto Center, Inc., Joseph T of D Co., Paul Miller Bernardsville LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- TH, LLC, AMR Auto Holdings- KH, LLC, Haldeman Ford of Hightown, LLC, Paul Miller AWD LLC, Camargo Cadillac Company, R. Santilli Automotive Group, Inc., Haldeman Nissan Inc., Harden Motor Car Corp., Robert Chevrolet Inc., Santilli Enterprises Inc., Cape Hy, Inc., Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru, Hempstead Auto Co. Inc., Anderson Automotive Group, Inc., BFC 3 LLC, Cascade Auto Group, Ltd., Multi Chevrolet, Inc., Heritage Jaguar of Freeport Inc., Columbia Automotive Inc., Northtown Mazda KIA, Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Bergstrom Chevrolet of Milwaukee, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Hoehn Buick GMC Cadillac, Inc., Mack Auto Import Inc., Cardinal Honda, Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Clay Chevrolet Inc., Champaign Motors Inc., N & H Motors, Inc., Bergstrom Imports, Inc., Redlands Automotive Services Inc., Tirrico Inc., Autoworld Kia, Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Dijos Inc., Thomas Dodge Corp., Pruitt Ford LLC, Taylor Chrysler Dodge Inc., Ontario Nissan Inc., Classic Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, Inc., Port Motors, Incorporated, Schaller, Inc., Balise N, LLC, Phoenix Motor Company, DTC Corp., M.T. Imports Inc., Mel Rapton Honda, Inc., 21st Century Auto Group, Hummer of Columbus LLC, Paul Conte Cadillac, Inc., Northstar Chevrolet, Inc., M & S of Pawling, Inc., Garcia Imports, Inc., Scap Auto Group, Smithtown Toyota, SI Safe Auto, L.L.C., AMR Auto Holdings- BG LLC, Lyle's Auto LLC, North Shore Chevrolet, Staretz LLC, A & H Motors Inc., LCJ Inc., Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Balise T, LLC, Joseph T of C, Co., Sawdran LLC, Parsons Buick Company, W.S. Healey Chevrolet Buick, Inc., Paul Miller Inc., Riverhead Auto Mall, Ltd., Plaza Oldsmobile, LTD, Dutchess Cars, LLC, Fairfield Motors Inc., Best Auto Outlet, Inc., Garcia Imported Motorcars, LLC, BLS, Inc., Montgomery Chevrolet Company, Bergstrom Chevrolet Cadillac, Inc., Crossroads Ford Lincoln, Inc., Garcia Asia- Pacific Motors LLC, Richard Lundgren Inc., Gault Auto Sport BMW, Lawrence Automotive Inc., Haldeman Ford, Inc., Salerno Duane Inc., Curry Auto LLC, Clay Corporation, DePaula Chevrolet, Inc., Sudbay Chrysler Dodge, Inc., DGM, L.L.C., Car Pros Renton, Sussex County Imports LLC, NextMotors Corporation, GAE, LLC, Adjess Motors LLC, Tenafly Auto Mall Inc., Balise C, LLC, Chilson Subaru, Victory Lane Imports Inc., Saco Aut
July 10, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 7 STIPULATION RE: AMENDMENT OF COMPLAINT AND EXTENSION OF TIME: Plaintiffs will file and serve an Amended Complaint in this action on or before August 23, 2013 naming additional Plaintiffs and adding certain other allegations. The time for Defendant to answer, move, or otherwise plead in response to the current Complaint in this action is hereby extended to and including the date of filing and service of an Amended Complaint. Defendant will answer, move, or otherwise plead in response to the Amended Complaint on or before September 17, 2013. ( Amended Complaint due by 8/23/2013.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 7/10/2013) (cd)
July 4, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 6 ENDORSED LETTER addressed to Judge Alison J. Nathan from Steven H. Blatt dated 7/3/2013 re: Based upon the above, counsel agreed to the stipulation that was filed electronically earlier today in which plaintiffs may amend their complaint by August 23 and defendant may answer or move with respect to such amended complaint by September 17 and that the 7/26/2013 initial conference be adjourned. ENDORSEMENT: So Ordered. The initial pretrial conference previously set for 7/26/2013 is hereby RESET to 9/27/13 at 10:30AM. The parties' joint letter and proposed case management plan is due 9/18/13. Carfax, Inc. answer due 9/17/2013. (Amended Pleadings due by 8/23/2013. Initial Conference reset for 9/27/2013 at 10:30 AM before Judge Alison J. Nathan.) (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 7/4/2013) (cd)
May 22, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 5 NOTICE OF INITIAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE: Initial Conference set for Friday, 7/26/2013 at 11:30 AM in Courtroom 906, 40 Centre Street, New York, NY 10007 before Judge Alison J. Nathan. Parties ordered to submit via email proposed case management plan and joint letter nine days before conference, and as further set in this document. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 5/22/2013) (cd)
May 21, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 4 STIPULATION EXTENDING TIME TO ANSWER, MOVE, OR OTHERWISE PLEAD: IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED AND AGREED by and between Plaintiffs and Defendant Carfax, Inc. that Carfax, Inc. answer to the complaint due 7/8/2013. (Signed by Judge Alison J. Nathan on 5/21/2013) (cd)
May 8, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 3 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE. Carfax, Inc. served on 4/30/2013, answer due 5/21/2013. Document filed by Maxon Hyundai Mazda. (Blatt, Steven)
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order ***NOTE TO ATTORNEY TO E-MAIL PDF. Note to Attorney Leonard Anthony Bellavia for noncompliance with Section 14.3 of the S.D.N.Y. Electronic Case Filing Rules & Instructions. E-MAIL the PDF for Document #1 Complaint,,,,,,,,,,,,, to: caseopenings@nysd.uscourts.gov. (mqu)
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 2 STANDING ORDER IN RE PILOT PROJECT REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES FOR COMPLEX CIVIL CASES IN THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK (See M-10-468 Order filed November 1, 2011). This case is hereby designated for inclusion in the Pilot Project Regarding Case Management Techniques for Complex Civil Cases in the Southern District of New York (the Pilot Project), unless the judge to whom this case is assigned determines otherwise. This case is designated for inclusion in the Pilot Project because it is a class action, an MDL action, or is in one of the following Nature of Suit categories: 160, 245, 315, 355, 365, 385, 410, 830, 840, 850, 893, or 950. The presiding judge in a case that does not otherwise qualify for inclusion in the Pilot Project may nevertheless designate the case for inclusion in the Pilot Project by issuing an order directing that the case be included in the Pilot Project. The description of the Pilot Project, including procedures to be followed, is attached to this Order. (Signed by Judge Loretta A. Preska on 10/31/2011) (laq)
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order Filing 1 COMPLAINT against Carfax, Inc.. (Filing Fee $ 350.00, Receipt Number 1065752)Document filed by Northtown Mazda KIA, Northtown Hyundai Subaru, Nissan World of Red Bank, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Metro Honda, Outten Buick-Pontiac, Inc., Bellavia Buick, Inc., Manfredi Motors Inc., Healey Chevrolet, Inc., Jaguar of Great Neck, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura, Cardinal Honda, RCG Realty Management, Inc., Healey Hyundai, Inc., Nissan World of Dartmouth, Miller Motor Car Corp., Salerno Duane Infiniti, JMK East L.L.C., Healey Used Car Outlet L.L.C., Bayside Chrysler, Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc., Durand Toyota-Ford, Route 18 Auto Group L.L.C., Range Rover of Cherry Hill, Schumacher Automotive, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus, James Toyota, Thomas Dodge Corp., Great Neck Suzuki, Sovreign Motor Cars Ltd., The Dorschel Group, Northtown Toyota Scion, Swanty's Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Northtown Lexus, Kia Tacoma, Perrine Auto Group, Arnold Chevrolet, L.L.C., 21st Century Auto Group, Cherry Hill Imports, Timco, Healey Automotive L.L.C., Cherry Hill Mercedes Benz, Outten Motors, L.L.C., JMK Auto Sales Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Countryside North, SI Safe Auto, L.L.C., Habberstad BMW of Huntington, Gault Toyota, Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest, Schumacher Auto Group, Tenafly Kia-Teterboro CJDR, Gault Volkswagen, Townsend Bros. Inc., Burien Nissan, Star Hyundai, L.L.C., Masterz Automotive Intl Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lake Forest N. Frederick, Sutton Ford Lincoln, North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC, Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C., Jaguar of Freeport, Healey Chrysler Dodge Jeep L.L.C., Bob Ciasulli Auto Group - Toyota Universe, Outten Automotive, Inc., W.S. Healey Chevrolet Buick, Inc., Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park, Toyota World of Lakewood, Moore Family of Dealership, NYLSI Inc., Maxon Hyundai Mazda, Offlease4less, Fitzgerald Automall Frederick Baughmans Lane, Fitzgerald Automall Chambersburg, Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab, Heinrich Chevrolet, Star Toyota, Martin Swanty Kia, Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc., Nissan World of Springfield, Manfredi Cadillac Inc., Star Nissan, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis West Street, Gault Auto Sport BMW, Chilson Corner Motors, Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street, Salerno Duane Inc., Outten Chevrolet, Inc., Martin Swanty Hyundai, Metro Chrysler Plymouth Inc., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda of Toms River, Fitzgerald Automall White Flint, DGM, L.L.C., Toyota World of Newton, Subaru World of Newton, Car Pros Renton, Manfredi Chrysler Jeep & Dodge, L.L.C., Harden Motor Car Corp., RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota, Renton Hyundai, Waco Dodge, Inc., Chilson Subaru, RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Honda Universe, WR Thomas Inc., Nissan World of Denville, Crestview Cadillac Corp., Yellowstone Country Motors, Northtown Volvo Porsche Land Rover of Buffalo, Durand Chevrolet, Route 23 Honda, County Line Carriage Inc., Martin Swanty Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Gault Chevrolet, County Line Buick Nissan, Tarrytown Honda, Life Quality BMW, Northtown Chrysler Jeep Dodge, Fitzgerald Automall Countryside, Bill Kolb Jr. Subaru, Inc., Manfredi Chevrolet, Biener Audi.(laq) (msa).
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order SUMMONS ISSUED as to Carfax, Inc.(laq)
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order Case Designated ECF. (laq)
April 23, 2013 Opinion or Order Magistrate Judge Ronald L. Ellis is so designated. (laq)

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the New York Southern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

Search for this case: Maxon Hyundai Mazda et al v. Carfax, Inc.
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Westbury Jeep Chrysler Dodge, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Fitzgerald Toyota Inc.
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Union Pontiac- GMC, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Fitzgerald Automall Annapolis Hudson Street
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: R &J Nissan LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Barry's Auto Center, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: R&J Nissan, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Masterz Automotive Intl Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Infiniti of Cincinnati, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: E.M. Rinehart Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Balise Hy, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Yonkers Auto Outlet
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Habberstad Motorsport Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Infiniti, Nissan, Volkswagen, Saab
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Treasure Coast Imports, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: AMR Auto Holdings- ACII LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Best Auto Outlet, Inc.
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: North Bay Cadillac Buick-GMC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Dutchess Cars, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Garcia Imported Cars, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Tamaroff Motors, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: J.O. Stevenson, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Range Rover of Cherry Hill
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: B.C.T. Imports Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Northtown Mazda KIA
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: BTLS, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Heinrich Chevrolet
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Durand Toyota-Ford
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: M & S of Pawling, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Towson Automotive, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Galesburg Nissan Corp.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Jack Ingram Motors, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Martens Chevrolet, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Port Motors, Incorporated
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Dralle Chevrolet & Buick, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Dick Devoe Buick- Cadillac Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Manfredi Auto LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Bergstrom Buick- GMC Truck, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Fogg's Auto Sales, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Central Avenue Chrysler Jeep Dodge
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Rine Motors Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Subaru World of Newton
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Victory Lane Imports Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Open Road of Mendham, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Huntington Hyundai, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Salerno Duane Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Alfredo's Foreign Cars
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Manfredi Chevrolet
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: RB Automotive Group Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Matthews Kia Mazda Subaru
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Jim Salerno Pontiac Buick GMC Truck, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Acton Toyota of Littleton
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Glalaxy Toyota
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Fitzgerald Automall Lexington Park
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Team Precision Auto LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Habberstad Nissan, Inc.
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: AMR Auto Holdings- HD, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Toyota World of Lakewood
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Enterprise Motorcars, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: City Motors LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Frangie Motors Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Saco Auto Holdings- VW, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Parsons Buick Company
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Dijos Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Landmark Dodge Chrysler Jeep, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Bergstrom Cadillac Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Fleet Lease Network Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: NYLSI Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Sutton Ford Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Saco Auto Holdings- FLMM, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: William T. Pritchard, Inc,
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: ADA Motors Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Schumacher Automotive
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Butler Chrysler Jeep Dodge Inc.
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Brentlinger Enterprises
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Cape Hy, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Lyford Motors LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Rallye Automotive LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: James Toyota
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Nissan World of Springfield
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Bayside Chrysler
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Rockville Cars, LLC
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Ron Bouchards' Auto Sales, Inc.-Acura
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Schumacher Auto Group
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: JBA Automotive LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Gault Auto Sport BMW
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Tirrico Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Montgomery Chevrolet Company
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Bayside Chrysler Jeep, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Smithtown Toyota
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: RCG Realty Management, Inc./Bob Casiulli Auto Group-Tri County Lexus
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Price Simms Ford, LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: J.O.S., Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Durand Automotive Group, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Mercedes Benz of Arrowhead
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Paul Miller Performance LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Sam Scism Motors, Inc.
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Outten Chevrolet, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Healey Ford Lincoln, L.L.C.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Nissan World of Denville
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Salerno * Duane Infiniti
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Bergstrom Premier Motorcars, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Merrimac Motors, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Manfredi Motors Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: DGM, L.L.C.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Hanford Toyota
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Space Coast Auto Group Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Community Chevrolet Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Sarant Cadillac Corp.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Elk Grove Kia
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Balise JRN, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: County Line Carriage Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Howard Auto Group, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: J.O.S. & Associates, Inc. Stevenson Kia
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Teterboro Chrysler Jeep, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Northtown Hyundai Subaru
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Tustin Buick GMC Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Nissan sales Corp.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: King O' Rourke Buick- GMC LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Mack Auto Imports Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Baron Auto Maxx, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Conklin Cars Newton LLC
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Central Avenue Nissan, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: M.T. Imports Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Sutton Ford Lincoln
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Stevenson Cars, Inc.
Represented By: Daniel John Walker
Represented By: David A. Langer
Represented By: Eric L. Cramer
Represented By: Joseph Richard Saveri
Represented By: Joshua Davis
Represented By: Leonard Anthony Bellavia
Represented By: Ryan McEwan
Represented By: Steven H Blatt
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?