Davis et al v. Banks et al
| Yvonne Davis, Maria Hildago, Abundio Sanchez, Maria Navarro-Carillo, Jose Garzon, Claudia Rivas, Andrea Phillips, Paul Hinton, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Ceferino Paulino, Kelly Tobuck, Rosa Zayas, Edwin Zayas, Janice Torres, Abdon Lopez and Cynthia Ramos |
| David C Banks and New York City Department of Education |
| 1:2022cv08184 |
| September 24, 2022 |
| US District Court for the Southern District of New York |
| Jesse M Furman |
| Civil Rights: Education |
| 20 U.S.C. § 1400 IDEA: Individuals With Disabilities Education Act (short title) |
| None |
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on September 28, 2023. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
Filing 20
FIRST LETTER MOTION for Extension of Time to File status letter on consent addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Min Kyung Cho dated November 22, 2022. Document filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education..(Cho, Min Kyung)
|
|
Filing 19
MEMO ENDORSEMENT on re: #18 Letter filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education. ENDORSEMENT: Unless and until the Court orders otherwise, briefing on the motion for preliminary injunction shall continue to be held in abeyance and Defendants shall submit another status letter by November 28, 2022. Defendants shall answer or otherwise respond to the Complaint by December 12, 2022. SO ORDERED. David C Banks answer due 12/12/2022; New York City Department of Education answer due 12/12/2022. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 10/28/2022) (kv)
|
|
Filing 18
LETTER addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Min Kyung Cho dated October 27, 2022 re: status. Document filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education..(Cho, Min Kyung)
|
|
Filing 17
MEMO ENDORSEMENT on re: #16 Letter filed by Paul Hinton, Edwin Zayas, Jose Garzon, Ceferino Paulino, Rosa Zayas, Abdon Lopez, Andrea Phillips, Abundio Sanchez, Maria Hildago, Claudia Rivas, Cynthia Ramos, Janice Torres, Yvonne Davis, Maria Navarro-Carillo, Rosa Elba de Paulino, Kelly Tobuck. ENDORSEMENT: Defendants shall submit another status letter no later than October 27, 2022. In the meantime, briefing on the preliminary injunction motion shall continue to be held in abeyance. SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 10/12/2022) (jca)
|
|
Filing 16
LETTER addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Rory J. Bellantoni dated 10/7/2022 re: response to Defendants' status report. Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually)..(Bellantoni, Rory)
|
|
Filing 15
ORDER re: #14 Status Report filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education: Plaintiffs shall file any response to the DOE's letter by Tuesday, October 11, 2022. (HEREBY ORDERED by Judge Jesse M. Furman) (Text Only Order) (Furman, Jesse)
|
|
Filing 14
STATUS REPORT. Document filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education..(Cho, Min Kyung)
|
|
Filing 13
ORDER granting #11 Letter Motion for Leave to File Document. Defendant shall submit a status letter no later than October 6, 2022. In the absence of confirmation in that letter that payment has been made -- or will be imminently made -- the Court will schedule a conference and/or set a briefing schedule, likely on an expedited schedule. In the meantime, briefing on the preliminary injunction motion shall be held in abeyance. The Clerk of Court is directed to terminate ECF No. 11. SO ORDERED.. (Signed by Judge Jesse M. Furman on 9/28/2022) (rro)
|
|
Filing 12
LETTER addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Rory J. Bellantoni dated September 28, 2022 re: Response to Defendants' Letter of September 27. Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually)..(Bellantoni, Rory)
|
|
Filing 11
LETTER MOTION for Leave to File a status letter in the event the Court does not deny Plaintiffs' application for preliminary injunctive relief addressed to Judge Jesse M. Furman from Min Kyung Cho dated September 27, 2022. Document filed by David C Banks, New York City Department of Education..(Cho, Min Kyung)
|
|
Filing 10
COMPLAINT against David C Banks, New York City Department of Education. Document filed by Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Jose Garzon(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Maria Hildago(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.)..(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
***NOTICE TO ATTORNEY REGARDING DEFICIENT PLEADING. Notice to Attorney Ashleigh C Rousseau to RE-FILE Document No. #4 Complaint,,,,,,. The filing is deficient for the following reason(s): not all the filers were selected for the pleading (Maria Hildago). Re-file the pleading using the event type Complaint found under the event list Complaints and Other Initiating Documents - attach the correct signed PDF - select the individually named filer/filers - select the individually named party/parties the pleading is against. (pc)
|
|
***NOTICE TO COURT REGARDING PROPOSED ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE WITH EMERGENCY RELIEF. Document No. #7 Proposed Order to Show Cause With Emergency Relief,,,,,, was reviewed and approved as to form. (nd)
|
|
Filing 9
MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: #8 Declaration in Support,,,,,, #7 Proposed Order to Show Cause With Emergency Relief,,,,,, . Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually)..(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
Filing 8
DECLARATION of Ashleigh C. Rousseau in Support re: #7 Proposed Order to Show Cause With Emergency Relief,,,,,,. Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10).(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
Filing 7
PROPOSED ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE WITH EMERGENCY RELIEF. Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually). Related Document Number: #4 ..(Rousseau, Ashleigh) Proposed Order to Show Cause to be reviewed by Clerk's Office staff.
|
|
Filing 6
ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF SERVICE Summons and Complaint,,,,, served. David C Banks served on 9/26/2022, answer due 10/17/2022; New York City Department of Education served on 9/26/2022, answer due 10/17/2022. Service was accepted by New York City Law Department. Service was made by email. Document filed by Cynthia Ramos(Individually); Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.); Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.); Edwin Zayas(Individually); Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.); Yvonne Davis(Individually); Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.); Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually); Abdon Lopez(Individually); Paul Hinton(Individually); Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.); Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.); Janice Torres(Individually); Ceferino Paulino(Individually); Andrea Phillips(Individually); Rosa Zayas(Individually); Jose Garzon(Individually); Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.); Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.); Kelly Tobuck(Individually); Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.); Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.); Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.); Abundio Sanchez(Individually); Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.); Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.); Claudia Rivas(Individually); Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.); Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually); Maria Hildago(Individually); Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.); Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.)..(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
Filing 5
ELECTRONIC SUMMONS ISSUED as to David C Banks, New York City Department of Education. (sj)
|
|
Filing 4
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT PLEADING - FILER ERROR - COMPLAINT against David C Banks, New York City Department of Education. Document filed by Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Jose Garzon(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Maria Hildago(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.)..(Rousseau, Ashleigh) Modified on 9/27/2022 (pc).
|
|
***NOTICE TO ATTORNEY REGARDING DEFICIENT PLEADING. Notice to Attorney Ashleigh C Rousseau to RE-FILE Document No. #1 Complaint. The filing is deficient for the following reason(s): not all the filers were selected for the pleading. Re-file the pleading using the event type Complaint found under the event list Complaints and Other Initiating Documents - attach the correct signed PDF - select the individually named filer/filers - select the individually named party/parties the pleading is against. (sj)
|
|
Magistrate Judge Sarah L. Cave is so designated. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section 636(c) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 73(b)(1) parties are notified that they may consent to proceed before a United States Magistrate Judge. Parties who wish to consent may access the necessary form at the following link: #https://nysd.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/2018-06/AO-3.pdf. (sj)
|
|
CASE OPENING INITIAL ASSIGNMENT NOTICE: The above-entitled action is assigned to Judge Jesse M. Furman. Please download and review the Individual Practices of the assigned District Judge, located at #https://nysd.uscourts.gov/judges/district-judges. Attorneys are responsible for providing courtesy copies to judges where their Individual Practices require such. Please download and review the ECF Rules and Instructions, located at #https://nysd.uscourts.gov/rules/ecf-related-instructions..(sj)
|
|
Case Designated ECF. (sj)
|
|
Filing 3
REQUEST FOR ISSUANCE OF SUMMONS as to David C. Banks, in his official capacity as Chancellor of New York City Department of Education and New York City Department of Education, re: #1 Complaint,,,,. Document filed by Yvonne Davis(Individually), Yvonne Davis(as Legal Guardian of O.C.), Jose Garzon(Individually), Jose Garzon(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Hildago(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Maria Hildago(Individually), Paul Hinton(Individually), Paul Hinton(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abdon Lopez(Individually), Abdon Lopez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(as Parent and Natural Guardian of M.G.), Maria Navarro-Carillo(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Janice Torres(Individually), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually)..(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
Filing 2
CIVIL COVER SHEET filed..(Rousseau, Ashleigh)
|
|
Filing 1
FILING ERROR - DEFICIENT PLEADING - FILER ERROR - COMPLAINT against David C Banks, New York City Department of Education. (Filing Fee $ 402.00, Receipt Number ANYSDC-26728879)Document filed by Claudia Rivas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.C.), Cynthia Ramos(Individually), Kelly Tobuck(as Parent and Natural Guardian of K.T.), Edwin Zayas(Individually), Rosa Elba de Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Kelly Tobuck(Individually), Rosa Elba de Paulino(Individually), Rosa Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Andrea Phillips(as Parent and Natural Guardian of S.H.), Abundio Sanchez(Individually), Janice Torres(as Parent and Natural Guardian of A.L.), Edwin Zayas(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.Z.), Janice Torres(Individually), Claudia Rivas(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(Individually), Andrea Phillips(Individually), Rosa Zayas(Individually), Ceferino Paulino(as Parent and Natural Guardian of R.P.), Cynthia Ramos(as Parent and Natural Guardian of W.R.), Abundio Sanchez(as Parent and Natural Guardian of L.S.). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10).(Rousseau, Ashleigh) Modified on 9/26/2022 (sj).
|
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the New York Southern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
