Norman et al v. Essex Property Trust, Inc. et al
| Alexis Norman, Nicolette Cochran and Roes 1 through 100 |
| Essex Property Trust, Inc., Essex Portfolio, L.P., 95360 Residences, L.P., 500 Folsom, L.P., Bayport Serrano Associates, L.P., Belmont Affordable Partners, L.P., BEX FMCA, LLC, BEX II GP, LLC, BEX III GP, LLC, BEX IV GP, LLC, BEX Portfolio, LLC, BEXAEW Esplanade, LP, BEXAEW GP, LLC, BEXAEW Parkside Court, LP, BEXAEW the Havens, LP, BRE-FMCA, LLC, Courtyards At 65TH, L.P., EMC SPE, LLC, Emerald Pointe Apartments, LLC, Essex 500 Folsom, LLC, Essex Anavia, L.P., Essex Bella Villagio, L.P., Essex Bellerive, L.P., Essex Berkeley 4th Street, L.P., Essex Bex III, LLC, Essex Bexaew, LLC, Essex Bluffs, L.P., Essex Briarwood, L.P., Essex Bridgeport, L.P., Essex Buena Vista, LLC, Essex Bunker Hill, L.P., Essex Cadence Gp, L.P., Essex Cadence Owner, L.P., Essex Cal-Wa, L.P., Essex Camarillo Corporation, Essex Camarillo, L.P., Essex Camino Ruiz Apartments, L.P., Essex Canyon Oaks Apartments, L.P., Essex Carlyle, L.P., Essex Catalina, LLC, Essex Chestnut Apartments, L.P., Essex City View, L.P., Essex Cochran, L.P., Essex Columbus, L.P., Essex Dublin GP, L.P., Essex Dublin Owner, L.P., Essex Emeryville GP, L.P., Essex Emeryville Owner, L.P., Essex Esplanade, L.P., Essex Form 15, L.P., Essex Fountain Park Apartments, L.P., Essex Fox Plaza, L.P., Essex Gas Company Lofts, L.P., Essex Gateway Management, LLC, Essex Hamilton, L.P., Essex Haver Hill, L.P., Essex HGA, LLC, Essex Hillcrest Park, L.P., Essex Hillsborough Park, L.P., Essex Hillsdale Garden Apartments, L.P., Essex Huntington Breakers, L.P., Essex Huntington On Edinger, L.P., Essex Jaysac Tasman, L.P., Essex JMS Acquisition, L.P., Essex JV, LLC, Essex Kiely, L.P., Essex Kings Road, L.P., Essex Le Parc, L.P., Essex Lorraine, L.P., Essex Management Corporation, Essex Marbrisa Long Beach, L.P., Essex Marina City Club, L.P., Essex MCC, LLC, Essex Meadowood, L.P., Essex Meridian, LLC, Essex Mirabella Marina Apartments, L.P., Essex Monarch La Brea Apartments, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, LLC, Essex NBN SPE, LLC, Essex Noho Apartments, L.P., Essex Park Catalina, L.P., Essex Pe Lofts, L.P., Essex Pleasanton GP, L.P., Essex Pleasanton Owner, L.P., Essex Regency Escuela, L.P., Essex Rexford, LLC, Essex Riley Square, L.P., Essex San Fernando, L.P., Essex San Ramon Partners L.P., Essex Santee Court, L.P., Essex Skyline, L.P., Essex SPE, LLC, Essex Summerhill Park, L.P., Essex The Commons, L.P., Essex The Pointe, L.P., Essex The Woods, L.P., Essex Tierra Vista, L.P., Essex Tiffany Court, LLC, Essex Toluca Lake, L.P., Essex Township, L.P., Essex Treetops, L.P., Essex Valley Village Magnolia, LLC, Essex Vista Belvedere, L.P., Essex Walnut GP, L.P., Essex Walnut Owner, L.P., Essex Warner Center, L.P., Essex Waterford, L.P., Essex Wesco III, L.P., Essex Wesco IV, LLC, Essex Wesco V, LLC, Essex Wesco, L.P., Essex Wilshire, L.P., Fairhaven Apartment Fund, Ltd., GBR Palma Sorrento LLC, Gr Block B LLC, Gr Block C LLC, Japantown Associates LLC, K-H Properties, Monarch Buena Vista Borrower, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps GP, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps, LLC, New Century Towers, LLC, Newport Beach North LLC, Palm Valley Roll-Up LLC, Pine Grove Apartment Fund, Ltd., PPC Sage Apartments Manager II LLC, PPC Sage LLC, Richmond Essex, L.P., Sac Redwood City Apartments LLC, Santa Clara Square, LLC, Santa Monica Affordable Partners, L.P., SP/P Channel Point, L.L.C., The Oakbrook Company, Valley Park Apartments, Ltd., Villa Angelina Apartment Fund, Ltd., WC Brio Apartments LLC, WCP Serrano, Inc., Wesco GP, LLC, Wesco III Bex, LLC, Wesco III Gp, LLC, Wesco IV, LLC, Western Mountain View II Investors, Western Riviera Investors, Western-Seven Trees Investors and Does 1 through 100 |
| 3:2023cv00348 |
| February 22, 2023 |
| US District Court for the Southern District of California |
| Michael S Berg |
| Todd W Robinson |
| Rent Lease & Ejectment |
| 28 U.S.C. ยง 1441 bc Removal- Breach of Contract |
| Both |
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on May 2, 2023. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
Filing 9
ORDER (1) Remanding Action to the Superior Court of California, County of San Diego; and (2) Denying as Moot Plaintiffs' Motion for Remand (ECF Nos. #6 , #8 ). Signed by Judge Todd W. Robinson on 05/02/2023. (cxl1)
|
| Filing 8 NOTICE Stipulation Remanding Case to State Court by 500 Folsom, L.P., 95360 Residences, L.P., BEX FMCA, LLC, BEX II GP, LLC, BEX III GP, LLC, BEX IV GP, LLC, BEX Portfolio, LLC, BEXAEW Esplanade, LP, BEXAEW GP, LLC, BEXAEW Parkside Court, LP, BEXAEW the Havens, LP, BRE-FMCA, LLC, Belmont Affordable Partners, L.P., Courtyards At 65TH, L.P., EMC SPE, LLC, Emerald Pointe Apartments, LLC, Essex 500 Folsom, LLC, Essex Anavia, L.P., Essex Bella Villagio, L.P., Essex Bellerive, L.P., Essex Berkeley 4th Street, L.P., Essex Bex III, LLC, Essex Bexaew, LLC, Essex Bluffs, L.P., Essex Briarwood, L.P., Essex Bridgeport, L.P., Essex Buena Vista, LLC, Essex Bunker Hill, L.P., Essex Cadence Gp, L.P., Essex Cadence Owner, L.P., Essex Cal-Wa, L.P., Essex Camarillo Corporation, Essex Camarillo, L.P., Essex Camino Ruiz Apartments, L.P., Essex Canyon Oaks Apartments, L.P., Essex Carlyle, L.P., Essex Catalina, LLC, Essex Chestnut Apartments, L.P., Essex City View, L.P., Essex Cochran, L.P., Essex Columbus, L.P., Essex Dublin GP, L.P., Essex Dublin Owner, L.P., Essex Emeryville GP, L.P., Essex Emeryville Owner, L.P., Essex Esplanade, L.P., Essex Form 15, L.P., Essex Fountain Park Apartments, L.P., Essex Fox Plaza, L.P., Essex Gas Company Lofts, L.P., Essex Gateway Management, LLC, Essex HGA, LLC, Essex Hamilton, L.P., Essex Haver Hill, L.P., Essex Hillcrest Park, L.P., Essex Hillsborough Park, L.P., Essex Hillsdale Garden Apartments, L.P., Essex Huntington Breakers, L.P., Essex Huntington On Edinger, L.P., Essex JMS Acquisition, L.P., Essex JV, LLC, Essex Jaysac Tasman, L.P., Essex Kiely, L.P., Essex Kings Road, L.P., Essex Le Parc, L.P., Essex Lorraine, L.P., Essex MCC, LLC, Essex Management Corporation, Essex Marbrisa Long Beach, L.P., Essex Marina City Club, L.P., Essex Meadowood, L.P., Essex Meridian, LLC, Essex Mirabella Marina Apartments, L.P., Essex Monarch La Brea Apartments, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, LLC, Essex NBN SPE, LLC, Essex Noho Apartments, L.P., Essex Park Catalina, L.P., Essex Pe Lofts, L.P., Essex Pleasanton GP, L.P., Essex Pleasanton Owner, L.P., Essex Portfolio, L.P., Essex Property Trust, Inc., Essex Regency Escuela, L.P., Essex Rexford, LLC, Essex Riley Square, L.P., Essex SPE, LLC, Essex San Fernando, L.P., Essex San Ramon Partners L.P., Essex Santee Court, L.P., Essex Skyline, L.P., Essex Summerhill Park, L.P., Essex The Commons, L.P., Essex The Pointe, L.P., Essex The Woods, L.P., Essex Tierra Vista, L.P., Essex Tiffany Court, LLC, Essex Toluca Lake, L.P., Essex Township, L.P., Essex Treetops, L.P., Essex Valley Village Magnolia, LLC, Essex Vista Belvedere, L.P., Essex Walnut GP, L.P., Essex Walnut Owner, L.P., Essex Warner Center, L.P., Essex Waterford, L.P., Essex Wesco III, L.P., Essex Wesco IV, LLC, Essex Wesco V, LLC, Essex Wesco, L.P., Essex Wilshire, L.P., Fairhaven Apartment Fund, Ltd., GBR Palma Sorrento LLC, Gr Block B LLC, Gr Block C LLC, Japantown Associates LLC, K-H Properties, Monarch Buena Vista Borrower, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps GP, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps, LLC, New Century Towers, LLC, Newport Beach North LLC, PPC Sage Apartments Manager II LLC, PPC Sage LLC, Palm Valley Roll-Up LLC, Pine Grove Apartment Fund, Ltd., Richmond Essex, L.P., Sac Redwood City Apartments LLC, Santa Clara Square, LLC, Santa Monica Affordable Partners, L.P., The Oakbrook Company, Valley Park Apartments, Ltd., Villa Angelina Apartment Fund, Ltd., WC Brio Apartments LLC, Wesco GP, LLC, Wesco III Bex, LLC, Wesco III Gp, LLC, Wesco IV, LLC(A Delaware Limited Liability Company), Western Mountain View II Investors, Western Riviera Investors, Western-Seven Trees Investors (Rackers, Mark) (cxl1). |
|
Filing 7
ORDER (1) Vacating Hearing Date and Briefing Schedule for Defendants' #3 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim and Motion to Strike, and (2) Setting Briefing Schedule re Plaintiffs' #6 MOTION to Remand to State Court. In the interest of judicial efficiency, the Court VACATES the hearing date and 4 ORDER Setting Briefing Schedule on Defendants' #3 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim and Motion to Strike pending resolution of Plaintiffs' #6 MOTION to Remand to State Court, which is noticed for a hearing on 6/1/2023 at 01:30 PM in Courtroom 3A before the Honorable Todd W. Robinson. Pursuant to Section III.B.2 of the undersigned's Standing Order for Civil Cases, Defendants SHALL FILE their opposition(s) to Plaintiffs' MOTION to Remand to State Court on or before 4/27/2023, and Plaintiffs MAY FILE their optional reply, if any, in support of their MOTION to Remand to State Court on or before 5/11/2023. As noted in Section III.A.2 of the undersigned's Standing Order for Civil Cases, "[a]n opposing party's failure timely to file an opposition to any motion may be construed as consent to the granting of the motion pursuant to Civil Local Rule 7.1(f)(3)(c)." Signed by Judge Todd W. Robinson on 3/24/2023. (no document attached) (sxd)
|
| Filing 6 MOTION to Remand to State Court by Nicolette Cochran, Alexis Norman. (Attachments: #1 Memo of Points and Authorities in support of Motion for Remand, #2 Request for Judicial Notice in support of Motion for Remand, #3 Declaration of Matthew H. Aguirre in support of Motion for Remand)(Aguirre, Matthew) (cxl1). |
| Filing 5 NOTICE of Appearance by Matthew H. Aguirre on behalf of Nicolette Cochran, Alexis Norman (Aguirre, Matthew)Attorney Matthew H. Aguirre added to party Nicolette Cochran(pty:pla), Attorney Matthew H. Aguirre added to party Alexis Norman(pty:pla) (cxl1). |
|
Filing 4
ORDER Setting Briefing Schedule. Presently before the Court is the Essex-related Defendants' #3 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim and Motion to Strike, which is noticed for a hearing on 6/1/2023 at 1:30 PM in Courtroom 3A before the Honorable Todd W. Robinson. Plaintiffs SHALL FILE their opposition on or before 4/6/2023, and the Essex-Related Defendants MAY FILE their optional reply, if any, on or before 5/4/2023. As noted in Section III.A.2 of the undersigned's Standing Order for Civil Cases, "[a]n opposing party's failure timely to file an opposition to any motion may be construed as consent to the granting of the motion pursuant to Civil Local Rule 7.1(f)(3)(c)." Signed by Judge Todd W. Robinson on 3/1/2023. (no document attached) (sxd)
|
| Filing 3 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim and Motion to Strike by 500 Folsom, L.P., 95360 Residences, L.P., BEX FMCA, LLC, BEX II GP, LLC, BEX III GP, LLC, BEX IV GP, LLC, BEX Portfolio, LLC, BEXAEW Esplanade, LP, BEXAEW GP, LLC, BEXAEW Parkside Court, LP, BEXAEW the Havens, LP, BRE-FMCA, LLC, Belmont Affordable Partners, L.P., Courtyards At 65TH, L.P., EMC SPE, LLC, Emerald Pointe Apartments, LLC, Essex 500 Folsom, LLC, Essex Anavia, L.P., Essex Bella Villagio, L.P., Essex Bellerive, L.P., Essex Berkeley 4th Street, L.P., Essex Bex III, LLC, Essex Bexaew, LLC, Essex Bluffs, L.P., Essex Briarwood, L.P., Essex Bridgeport, L.P., Essex Buena Vista, LLC, Essex Bunker Hill, L.P., Essex Cadence Gp, L.P., Essex Cadence Owner, L.P., Essex Cal-Wa, L.P., Essex Camarillo Corporation, Essex Camarillo, L.P., Essex Camino Ruiz Apartments, L.P., Essex Canyon Oaks Apartments, L.P., Essex Carlyle, L.P., Essex Catalina, LLC, Essex Chestnut Apartments, L.P., Essex City View, L.P., Essex Cochran, L.P., Essex Columbus, L.P., Essex Dublin GP, L.P., Essex Dublin Owner, L.P., Essex Emeryville GP, L.P., Essex Emeryville Owner, L.P., Essex Esplanade, L.P., Essex Form 15, L.P., Essex Fountain Park Apartments, L.P., Essex Fox Plaza, L.P., Essex Gas Company Lofts, L.P., Essex Gateway Management, LLC, Essex HGA, LLC, Essex Hamilton, L.P., Essex Haver Hill, L.P., Essex Hillcrest Park, L.P., Essex Hillsborough Park, L.P., Essex Hillsdale Garden Apartments, L.P., Essex Huntington Breakers, L.P., Essex Huntington On Edinger, L.P., Essex JMS Acquisition, L.P., Essex JV, LLC, Essex Jaysac Tasman, L.P., Essex Kiely, L.P., Essex Kings Road, L.P., Essex Le Parc, L.P., Essex Lorraine, L.P., Essex MCC, LLC, Essex Management Corporation, Essex Marbrisa Long Beach, L.P., Essex Marina City Club, L.P., Essex Meadowood, L.P., Essex Meridian, LLC, Essex Mirabella Marina Apartments, L.P., Essex Monarch La Brea Apartments, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, L.P., Essex Monterey Villas, LLC, Essex NBN SPE, LLC, Essex Noho Apartments, L.P., Essex Park Catalina, L.P., Essex Pe Lofts, L.P., Essex Pleasanton GP, L.P., Essex Pleasanton Owner, L.P., Essex Portfolio, L.P., Essex Property Trust, Inc., Essex Regency Escuela, L.P., Essex Rexford, LLC, Essex Riley Square, L.P., Essex SPE, LLC, Essex San Fernando, L.P., Essex San Ramon Partners L.P., Essex Santee Court, L.P., Essex Skyline, L.P., Essex Summerhill Park, L.P., Essex The Commons, L.P., Essex The Pointe, L.P., Essex The Woods, L.P., Essex Tierra Vista, L.P., Essex Tiffany Court, LLC, Essex Toluca Lake, L.P., Essex Township, L.P., Essex Treetops, L.P., Essex Valley Village Magnolia, LLC, Essex Vista Belvedere, L.P., Essex Walnut GP, L.P., Essex Walnut Owner, L.P., Essex Warner Center, L.P., Essex Waterford, L.P., Essex Wesco III, L.P., Essex Wesco IV, LLC, Essex Wesco V, LLC, Essex Wesco, L.P., Essex Wilshire, L.P., Fairhaven Apartment Fund, Ltd., GBR Palma Sorrento LLC, Gr Block B LLC, Gr Block C LLC, Japantown Associates LLC, K-H Properties, Monarch Buena Vista Borrower, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps GP, LLC, Monarch Essex Scripps, LLC, New Century Towers, LLC, Newport Beach North LLC, PPC Sage Apartments Manager II LLC, PPC Sage LLC, Palm Valley Roll-Up LLC, Pine Grove Apartment Fund, Ltd., Richmond Essex, L.P., Sac Redwood City Apartments LLC, Santa Clara Square, LLC, Santa Monica Affordable Partners, L.P., The Oakbrook Company, Valley Park Apartments, Ltd., Villa Angelina Apartment Fund, Ltd., WC Brio Apartments LLC, Wesco GP, LLC, Wesco III Bex, LLC, Wesco III Gp, LLC, Wesco IV, LLC(A Delaware Limited Liability Company), Western Mountain View II Investors, Western Riviera Investors, Western-Seven Trees Investors. (Attachments: #1 Memo of Points and Authorities, #2 Request for Judicial Notice Exhibits A-F)(Rackers, Mark)Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party 500 Folsom, L.P.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party 95360 Residences, L.P.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEX FMCA, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEX II GP, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEX III GP, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEX IV GP, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEX Portfolio, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEXAEW Esplanade, LP(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEXAEW GP, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEXAEW Parkside Court, LP(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BEXAEW the Havens, LP(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party BRE-FMCA, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Belmont Affordable Partners, L.P.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Courtyards At 65TH, L.P.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party EMC SPE, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Emerald Pointe Apartments, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Fairhaven Apartment Fund, Ltd.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party GBR Palma Sorrento LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Gr Block B LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Gr Block C LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Japantown Associates LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party K-H Properties(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Monarch Buena Vista Borrower, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party New Century Towers, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Newport Beach North LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party PPC Sage Apartments Manager II LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party PPC Sage LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Palm Valley Roll-Up LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Pine Grove Apartment Fund, Ltd.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Sac Redwood City Apartments LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Santa Clara Square, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Santa Monica Affordable Partners, L.P.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party The Oakbrook Company(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Valley Park Apartments, Ltd.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Villa Angelina Apartment Fund, Ltd.(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party WC Brio Apartments LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Wesco GP, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Wesco III Bex, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Wesco III Gp, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Wesco IV, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Wesco IV, LLC(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Western Mountain View II Investors(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Western Riviera Investors(pty:dft), Attorney Mark G. Rackers added to party Western-Seven Trees Investors(pty:dft) (cxl1). |
| Filing 2 NOTICE of Party With Financial Interest by Essex Camarillo Corporation, Essex Management Corporation, Essex Property Trust, Inc. Identifying Other Affiliate Essex Portfolio, L.P. for Essex Management Corporation; Other Affiliate Essex Management Corporation for Essex Camarillo Corporation ; Other Affiliate State Street Corporation, Other Affiliate BlackRock, Inc., Other Affiliate The Vanguard Group, Inc. for Essex Property Trust, Inc. (maq) |
| Filing 1 NOTICE OF REMOVAL with Jury Demand from Superior Court of California, County of San Diego, case number 37-2022-00038519-CU-NP-CTL. (Filing fee $402 receipt number ACASDC-17606708.), filed by Essex Property Trust, Inc. (Attachments: #1 Civil Cover Sheet, #2 Exhibit A, #3 Exhibit B, #4 Proof of Service)The new case number is 3:23-cv-348-TWR-MSB. Judge Todd W. Robinson and Magistrate Judge Michael S. Berg are assigned to the case.(maq) |
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the California Southern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
