Plaintiff:	PAUL MARZOLO, as proposed Administrator of the Estate of Christine Marzolo, deceased, MATTIE MOORE, ROMANA HAYNES, CAREFIRST INC, a Maryland Corporation and its wholly-owned subsidiaries Carefirst of Maryland, Inc., a Maryland Corporation, Willse & Associates, Inc., a Maryland Corporation, CFS Health Group Inc., a Maryland Corporation, Delmarva Health Plan, Inc., EMMA CLARK, CAROLYN C TAYLOR, AMY S JAMES, BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF MINNESOTA, a Minnesota Corporation and a subsidiary of Aware Integrated Inc., and its wholly-owned subsidiary Comprehensive Care Services, Inc., a Minnesota Corporation, First Plan of Minnesota, a Minnesota Corporation, Atri, MELISSA L VICE, LONNIE J PAYNE, BRYAN WAMPOLE, LISA CHRIST, LISA HARPER, MONICA S GANN, CHARLES WHITE, ROBIN BUNDOFF, DEBBIE SULLIVAN, AVRILL C ARONSON, MORRIS TOWNSEND, TRACY LEWIS, PATRICIA L BROCKMAN, RICHARD A CROSBY, JR., SHARON K EMMONS, LULA MARIA HARPER LOTT, ANN E LARKIN, CARL HENRY, RANDALL J VEYS, induvidually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, VIVIAN S MEEKS, SANDRA FRENCH, as proposed Administratrix of the Estate of William J. French, Jr., deceased, CATHERINE L BROWN, PAULETTE HAMILTON, DEBORAH K FISH, EDWARD JORDAN, CLAIBORNE COLLIER, SR., VINCENT W LUDACKA, STEVEN MICHIELSEN, SYLVIA LONGINO, ROSEMARY SMITH, as surviving spouse and as successor in interest of plaintiff's decedent Leo Francis Smith, AARON SIMS, DEBBIE R HIERS, DOROTHY KERN, ARTHUR REILLY, KATHY YOUNG, VANNILA BENNETT, DEXTER WILLIAMS, TAYLOR WILLIAMS, CHARLES NORTHCUTT, JOHN JAROSZ, as Administrator Ad Prosequendum of the Estate of Maria Jarosz, deceased, SHIRLEY TORRY MARTIN, JOYCE WATSON, MARTHA MCINTEE-NELSON, MELISSA AMATO, DALE WAYNE HENDERSON, JAQUELINE J SAMUELS, individually an as parent of Gina M. Bell, deceased, LILIA FELICI, DENNIS WOLOSONOWICH, JOAN CRAFT, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, JOSEPH O WASHINGTON, III, VANESSA SCOTT, CARLOS FONSECA, AUTHERINE MIDDLETON, LINDA RICHEY, CURTIS DURDEN, JR., MICHAEL JAMES BELONGIE, individually and as an heir to Lauren D. Belongie, STEPHEN BROOK, MARK MINISQUERO, KENNETH ANTHONY GREEN, JUDY WHITE, ROBERT D GANGI, HAROLD J MCPHERSON, individually and on behalf of other Tamera L. McPherson, KENNETH GROSS, LILLIE CANNON, CASSANDRA KNOX, GARRY P CLEMONS, BERNARD STRICKLAND, ROY CARROL, DEXTER P WIGFALL, LATONYA A JEFFERS, KENNETH M KNAUFF, MARY J ANDERSON, CRAIG G REAVES, DOROTHY LOTT, CAROLE WERNER, SARAH SHIELDS, ROBERT L SMALL, BRADY L WILLIAMS, DEBRA NEAL, BETTIE A NEWSON, PATRICIA PETERSON, MARSHALL DILLON, WARREN NANCY, MARSHA HOLLOWAY, STEVEN KAIL, MARIANNE SMOLUCHA, on behalf of herself and as parent and natural guardian of minor plaintiffs, Laura Smolucha and Maria Smolucha, JEFFREY WILKIN, GREGORY RETZER, DELORIES POWELL, SANDRA M LOGAN, LESA CARPENTER, GROUP HEALTH SERVICES OF OKLAHOMA INC, an Oklahoma Corporation and its wholly-owned subsidiary Group Health Maintenance Organization, Inc., d/b/a BlueClinics HMO, an Oklahoma Corporation d/b/a Blue Cross Blue Shield of Oklahoma, PATTI PAULSEN, as Administratix of the Estate of Frederic L. Paulsen, deceased, HOLLY NEWBERRY, individually and as personal administrator of the Estate od Stephen Phillip Newberry, deceased, ANA MEDERO, DELLAPINO BALLARD, SEAN SELF, TOMMY D JAMES, ALASKA ELECTRICAL PENSION FUND, on behalf of itself and others similarly situated, INTERNATIONAL UNION OF OPERATING ENGINEERS, LOCAL NO. 68 WELFARE FUND, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, MARY J KESTNER, MARK TURNER, MELISSA W BARKLEY, DIANNE IRENE HOOD, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated, BARBARA A KNOWLTON, TOMMY HARDY, JARRELL M BEARDEN, HILDA BONNER, individually and as Personal Administrator of the Estate of Edwin L. Bonner, Jr., deceased, JAMES HOPE, TERESSER BASS, FRANKLIN MCCONNELL, SHAWAND HICKS, KATHY PHILLIPS, VELMA JOHNSON, WILLIAM MONTGOMERY, RE'SHEDIA YOUNG, ERESTIA THOMAS, LINDA MURRAY, DONNIE L STATOM, RONALD RUSSELL, IRENE BARLOW, KAILA NICOLE JONES, as Administrator of the Estate of Winona Adkerson and Edward Douglas Adkerson, TERESA E TEATER, BARBARA M STRAWITZ, NANCY HENRY, MARTHA THOMAS, TERESA DRINKWINE, individually and as Trustee for the next of kin of Micahel Drinkwine, decedent, JODIE YOUNG, ALFRED MORABITO, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, RODGER T PEARSON, THOMAS HARVEY, JAMES JEFFCOAT, ZOLA M HARTFIELD, MARQUITTIA MCCOY, DEBORA L ISAACS, MARIE A BARBER, CHARLES BROWN, ROBERT PETERSON, ANNETTE WHITE, ROSALIA SUMAIT, HERMAN WARD, CHARLES HAYNES, JR., MARIE GIVENS, GARY GURVEY, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, SYDNEY L WILLIAMS, KIMBERLY S MCKENZIE, HELEN MEEKS, MARK HEAD, CHRISTY POE SPEARS, as Administratrix of the Estate of Romona Joyce Shears, deceased, DONNA SIMS, EASTGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY, STEVEN BELBRUNO, SHIRLEY POPULIS, DELLA WASHINGTON, TOMMIE ODUM, MARY A LUEKER, ELIZABETH PETERSON, ROBERT JOHNSON, DEBORAH VALENTINE, LEROY ANDERSON, CYNTHIA K MYERS, DAMON CARTER, DAVID A DAY, SHIRLY LEVIN, FRED REISS, THEODORE POPULIS, JACQUELINE POOLE, FRANCES BOUIE, ZINA R MCCUE, BOBBY WOODS, ALLISON D DUKES, ROBERT N ST HILAIRE, RYAN WHITE, an infant, by and through his next friend, Sheri Ullrich, successor in interest of plaintiff's decedent, Scott Edward White, JOY M SHAW, DONALD E MILLIGAN, JR., DORIAN TAYLOR, JACQUELINE K MANNING, LORRAINE KOPA, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, SHIRLEY DRENNAN, SANDRA LIENDECKER, individually and as Guardian ad Litem for J.L. a minor child; C.L. a minor child, and T.L. a minor child, SHANAN FEYER, individually and as widow for the use and benefit of herself and next of kin of Cayce Feyer, deceased, DEIDRE R RODRIGUEZ, DEBRA ESPEY, MERCELINO SUMAIT, NOLAN WILLIAMS, SHANETTA LACY, MERRIE E BEAVERS, EDGAR J WATSON, JAINE SMITH, TATIKA JERNIGAN-WILSON, HERMAN C SEGLE, TAYLOR SLOAN, JAMES BUNDOFF, MELISSA S RATZ, ROBERT F WILSON, TIMOTHY L JACKSON, BILLIE HARKINS, ASSURANT PLAINTIFFS, STEVEN ALEXANDER, WELLCHOICE INC, a Delaware Corporation and its wholly-owned subsidiary Empire Healthchoice Assurance, Inc., a New York Corporation, d/b/a Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield and Empire Blue Cross, and its wholly-owned subsidiaries, ARNOLD O'BRYAN, JR., as Administrator of the Estate of Joan Marie Hester O'Bryan, CAROL REOTT, GLORIA HARRISON, SYLVIA G HYMAN, MARIO LASPINA, FELISHA CARPENTER, PAUL H GOLDEN, SHARON PEREZ, ELIZABETH MARIE KINGHT, GUARD INSURANCE COMPANY, PRODUCT LIABILITY PLAINTIFFS LIASON COUNSEL, LOUIS M WEGER, TAMMYLEE WILLOZ, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated, KELLY DELEON, SCOTT BENNETT, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Alan Bennett, deceased, WELLCHOICE INSURANCE OF NEW JERSEY INC, a New Jersey Corporation and a wholly-owned subsidiary of Empire Healthchoice Assurance, Inc., a New York Corporation, KENNETH L BRAMLETT, LARRY A SHELLEY, as personal representative of the Estate of Nancy K. Shelley, deceased, ANNE D BRUCE, TAMMY DODSON, JAMES HUNTER, CARLA JONES, BRENDA STRADDECK, THOMAS C HENSON, BENJAMIN JONATHAN CRONE, individually and as successors in interest to the Estate of Rick Arthur Crone, DONNA M PITZER, DORIS TOY, CHRISTINE M DOZIER, JENNIFER MECIJA, SHERRIAL GILBOW, KEITH COLEMAN, EMMA B CHRISTINA, FREDDIE HARRIS, LOVELL JONES-COLEMAN, SUSAN L BRAZELL, JOHN W SURLOCK, LYNETTE KAY GEORGE, LEISA EADDY, JO HELEN BOLER, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated, NORGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY, CATHERINE DUVALL, BETTY DEES, SCOTT ALAN WATSON, CARMEN L BOLTON, SONYA LEWIS, SIDNEY BROWN, as proposed administrator of the Estate of Judith A. Brown, deceased, GERALD SMITH, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, MANUEL SUMAIT, JR., LINDA B SHEARER, as Executrix of the Estate of Hartley Parker Shearer also known as Hartley Parker Shearer, DAVID W FAUGHT, ISIAH E MITCHELL, SR., DEBRA ANN JOHNSON, O.C. WILLIAMS, SR., DIANN LEE, DEBRA F LEGER, MEMEBERS OF THE CLASS PLAINTIFFS STEERING COMMITTEE, Pure Sales and Marketing, MARY J PICKETT, TEINA M SHAFFER, LASHONDA SKINNER, BRANDY MORGAN, SANDERS WILLIAMS, JR., KELLY STRICKLAND, ALGINA SIZEMORE, as Administratrix of the Estate of Douglas Lyle Sizemore, deceased, SONYA M GALLOWAY, ROBERT J MOSES, DARYL K NAKAMURA, ANDRE LASHALL DIXON, RONALD BULGER, SR., as Administratrix of the Estate of Susan Bulger, deceased, LINDA HALL, MACATHERINE JEFFERSON, SUSAN BROOK, SALLIE RIPPY, CLAUDIA LANG, on behalf of herself and all ohers, CAROLYN HOLLAWAY, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, DENA PINA, MARLENE K MCINTYRE, HOWARD ELLIS, ANDREW SMITH, CHRISTINE GAMBARDELLO, KELLY R STRICKLAND, JONANNE KEEGAN, JARVIS L RICHBERG, PAMELA ELLIS, TOMMY MILLS, SANDRA LYNN MESSER, as Administratrix of the Estate of Michael L. Malcom, JOANNA BENTLEY, MELVIN HARRIS, CHARLES K SMITH, MONICA L SAENZ, NANCY COLEMAN, ADAM SUMAIT, BULAR D TAYLOR, ELIZA SUMAIT, individually and as successors in interest to the Estate of Manuel Sumait, JESSIE BROWN, ELAINE LUCILLE EDWARDS, STEPHEN BRODSKY, FALISHA KNIGHT, WANDA F NICHOLS, FRANK SMITH, JR., ALYSIA ASHLEY, SANDRA GAUDIO, ELLAWEISE LACY, PATRICIA MCBEATH, CLIFF CHAMPAGNE, PAMELA SHIELDS, BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF ALABAMA, JENNIFER NAPOLI-BRANSON, SHARON BURKE, ANDY WAMPOLE, DAISY WILLIAMS, MONICA RIDGEWAY, KELLY A TILLEY, MARY K PERRY, KEVIN W CLARK, CASSANDRA JAMES, DAVID HARTSELL, WILLIAM WEBB, GREGORY SUBER, WILLIE G BREWSTER, JANNIE LUCAS, MARTIN FONSECA, LESLIE NEILSON, SHERMAN D ROBINSON, PATRICIA ANN RHODES, GERALD DEMERS, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, TIMOTHY BRIDGES, individually and on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, EUGENE SMITH, INEZ FINSCHER, ALAN M HUBERMAN, LINDA RIZZO, individually and on behalf of others similarly situated, MEICKI BAKER, JENNIFER FUNDERBURG, ERNIE BROOKS, RICHARD WOOLUM, FRANK HOOVER, STACEY DOUGLAS, JESSICA WHITTEN, SHIRLEY ANN WALTERS, LORE J CAILOR, GLINDA JEAN FORD, JERRY STAGG, LEOTIS C WILLIAMS, EARNESTINE PARKER, SHARON COX, SHERRY K LIGON, MARY LAWSON, MEHMET KILIE, EVA POTTS, BARBARA M PFAFF-MELANI, THELMA JUANITA MOSLEY, as Administratrix of the Estate of Harold McDonald Mosley, deceased, ANNIE GATEWOOD, BETTY L STILTMAN, BOBBIE MAGGETT, DORIS J SMITH, ODESSA GRISSOM, PAUL VERZONE, DOROTHY E SMITH, JERRY PRICE, DAVID W PETTIT, DAMETRIA IGBONAGWAM, individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Alesha Brown, deceased, SHELIA AGEE, KATHERINE FARRIS, DOROTHY BECKWORTH, KATHLEEN B SMALLS, CAROLE WILLIAMS, MARIYLN BLACKWELL, TURWANDA V SHAKOOR, DAN HUFFMAN, as proposed Administrator of the Estate of Candy Lynn Huffman, deceased, KAREN J GREER, MAGNOLIA THOMAS, LOUIS E TUNBLIN, ROSE JONES, JIMMY DARLING, DONNA M PIERCE, RONNIE SMITH, MUNICIPAL WORKERS COMPENSATION FUND INC, PAMELA CALVERT, RICKY E SMITH, DEBRA MULL, individually and on behalf of her minor son, Brandon Laiche, and on behalf of other similarly situated, ROBERT BECKWORTH, DEXTER K LEE, ALLIED SERVICES DIVISION WELFARE FUND, on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated, JACK C. REEVES, JR., DARRIN P MARLOW, JASON MORROW, ALICE HAIRFIELD, EZELL SUMMERS, VERA COLLEY, individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Robert Colley deceased, JENNIFER FLANDERS, MICHAEL MENDOZA, GREGORY HASSLET, AMANDA MARIE DIANA, STEPHANIE A LOWE, ANNIE D BLEVINS, individually on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, CONNIE B COOK, JACQUELINE SANDERS, DOYLE HARRISON, ELMENIA JOHNSON, individually and as tutor for Cameron Johnson & Lauryn Johnson, EUGENE J FAY, RAMAL WILLIAMS, JOY N BOYER, KRYSTIE DANE, individually and as personal representative of the Estate of Decedant, FRANCES GLENN, DANIEL NEWBERRY, individually and as personal administartor of the Estate of Stephen Phillip Newberry, deceased, MARILYN LEWIS, KAISER FOUNDATION HOSPITALS, DEBRA JOHNSON ALSBERGE, as personal representative of the Estate of Richard Alsberge, deceased, JANA STEPHENS, ALBERT ACTION, JULIE K BAKLE, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, JEFFREY B DRAIN, JANICE W LEE, CLAUDETTE GREER, BAUDA VL SUTTON, ROSEMARY SMITH, MICHELLE L MOATS, JOE BLAYLOCK, MARK ALLEN PRINCE, PAMELA WOOLUM, SANDRA D MCMAHON-LOUGH, DORIS SLOAN, RAMONA SUMAIT, JOANNA O'SULLIVAN, TEAMSTERS HEALTH & WELFARE FUND OF PHILADELPHIA AND VICINITY, WILLIE R THAMES, JANET HARGETT, FLORENCE Y SEAGRAVES, DARLENE STAMPLEY, VIRGIL L ANDERSON, BETTY CARTER, individually and on behalf of her mother and next friend Maurine Featherstone, and on behalf of others similarly situated, WILLIAM J REED, CYNTHIA ULETT LYNCH, BARBARA MCANNALLY, individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Van McAnally, deceased, SHERRY PASTINE, JOSE ARTEMIO FONSECA, KIMBERLY A CAMPBELL-DEAN, DARLENE OWENS, as Personal Representative of Estate of Joseph Frank Owens, deceased, SHARON L COBURN, DANIEL JOHNSON, ELROY L JOHNSON, MIDWEST HEALTH PLAN INC, MICKEY LIVINGSTON, BETTY THURMOND, DONALD A HILDEBRAND, JR., BRYAN E BURNETT, EDNA N ROBERSON, MARTHA NORMAN, RITA BROOKS, MEMYE CRESWILL, PATTI LONG, as surviving child of Plaintiff's decedent, Shirley Y. Sylvester and as proposed Administratrix of the estate of Shirley Y. Sylvester, deceased, RUFUS HENDON, JANICE VINYARD, REBECCA A PRINCE, PATRICIA L HUNTER, EVELYN HOLT, CHRIS LOGAN, CARYL A TAYLOR, CLIFFORD ECKENRODE, JEANNE RAMSEY, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, THOMAS VORHOLT, THERESA MILLIGAN, JIMMIE K WILLIAMS, LESTINE ROGERS, JOY DODSON, COLEEN M CRAIG, EVIA HOLMES, AARON P. BAKER, WARREN NANCE, MARY ASHFORD, FRIEDA BURROUGHS, as Executor of the Estate of Emory M. Burroughs, deceased, RUTH SMITH, individually and as widow fro the use and benefit of herself and next of kin of Rich Smith, deceased, MICHAEL LEU, as Administrator of the Estate of Pamela Leu, deceased, EARL RICHARD COOK, GULF DISTRIBUTING HOLDINGS LLC, ROBERT D ANGEL, DONALD CAMPBELL LOCKHART, LILLIE BEATRICE LEGGETT EVANS, BRENDA THOMPSON, PATRICIA ANN WHITE, MINNIE CAMPBELL, BRENDA CUNNINGHAM, Administrator of the Estate of Charles Cunningham and individually and on behalf of the heirs at law of Charles Cunningham, deceased Estate of Charles Cunningham, RACHEL A HASH, JASON M MITCHELL, GARY L LYMAN, as personal representative of the Estate of Joshua James Lyman, deceased, FREDDIE B LYTLE, MARY P DORSEY, individually and as Administrator of the Estate of James Dorsey, PETER VERAAS, DEBRA R SMITH, DONALD WALKER, deceased, COORDINATED PLAINTIFFS, EDWARD C THIBODEAU, RODNEY E PLANT, ANNE ELLIS, JOYCE REACH, HARRY LEWIS, OLLIE JOHNSON, RICKA LEAH WESTFALL, OSCAR MCGEE, as Administrator of the Estate of Pearlie Faye McGee, deceased, SHELLY M TARVAN, AMY WENDORF, MARY ARMBRUSTER, CARL STEVERSON, JESSIE ALLEN, NICOLE Y CAMPBELL, FAITH RENEE FORD, DOROTHY TOLLIVER, SHIRLEY DOLGOFF, JIMMIE BARBEE, ANN MONSUE, as Administratix of the Estate of Clyde Monsue, deceased, MICHAEL J MOSCATO, JAMES H WHITEHOUSE, JR., as Co-Administrator Ad Prosequendum of the Estate of James H. Whitehouse, Jr., deceased, JOHN DEES, REBECCA GROVES, on behalf of herself and all other similarly situated in the State of Ohio, VATHANA S CHHIV, LOWEY DANNENBERG BEMPORAD & SELINGER, P.C., MARY COOPER, CATHY STRICKLAND, SHANNA G ERICSSON-HARKNESS, AUDREY BERRY, KENNETH C SMITH, JUDITH J BROWNE, as surviving spouse and as successor in interest of plaintiff's decedant, Gerald William Browne, JOE N BLAKE, CAROLYN DAVIS, LORI L MOCCI, DALLAS MAE LUTZ, JAMES MORROW, JR., JAMES G DAVENPORT, MEMBERS OF THE PLAINTIFFS NON-CLASS STEERING COMMITTEE, JACQUELYN POSEY, MICHAEL TRIM, ANDRIA RENEE BLACKWELL, ELOISE WILLIAMS, HELEN WINE, LAPERIAL MELVIN, MICHELE C GRAYSON, WILLIAM S MOORE, EXCELLUS HEALTH PLAN INC, A New York Corporation and its wholly-owned subsidiary Excellus Benefit Services Inc., a New York Corporation., Federated Mutual Insurance Company, a Minnesota Mutual Company, Health Care Service Corporation, an Illinois Mut, LARRY W DAUERNHEIM, JENNIFER DE LA GARZA, APRIL DAVIS, GERARD GAUDIO, GRACE SANUTTI, SUSAN ROBY, SHIRLEY MOWDY, as surviving spouse of Diller R. Mowdy, Sr., deceased, NICOLETTE CRONE, BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN, and its wholly-owned subsidiary, Blue Care Network, Inc., a Michigan Corporation, LOUISA SMITH, GWENNA J BYRUM-HILL, ROSA SMITH, KAREN M CHANCELLOR, DAVID D WEATHERFORD, WILBUR C CONYERS, KEVIN KEEGAN, LINDA BARKER, JAMIE FENELON, as proposed Administratix of the Estate of Beth Moore, deceased, GEORGIA L BAKER, ANGELA BLOUNT, RUBY SMITH, KIM E SCOTT, FRANK VERCILLIO, JR., NICHOLAS CLARK, SULEMA SALINAS, MOHAMMAD MUSTAFA, AMGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY, LEONARD OLSEN, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, JAMES DOYLE, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, JEFFREY MECIJA, CAROL A VORHOLT, JANICE PRIMER, LINDA A WHITEHOUSE, as Co-Administrator and Co-Administrator Ad Prosequendum of the Estate of James H. Whitehouse, CARLENE THOMAS, TRUSTMARK INSURANCE COMPANY, a Delaware Corporation, EARVIN N SMITH, BRIDGETTE SHIELDS, RICHARDSON PERDUE, JOSEPH CASCIO, JOSE GARCIA, ALABAMA FOREST PRODUCTS INDUSTRY WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION SELF-INSURER'S FUND, on behalf of itself and a class if similarly situated persons, firms, corporations, individuals, or entities, ERIK NEWBERRY, GREGORY LINN EVERETT, JIMMY SAYLES, GEORGE B LEMACKS, LANNY GEORGE, as surviving spouse plaintiff's decedent, DEANNA LISA PUTNAM, LAURA COACH BROWN, ANTHONY CHARLES MANFREDI, AVA MITCHELL, BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF FLORIDA, a Florida Corporation and its wholly owned subsidiary, Health Inc., a Florida Corporation, EDNEATHA WHITE, KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLAN, INC., LESLIE LUTTRELL, SUE BECKUM, JAY DIGIACOMO, EARLY COX, KIMM J DAVIS, CLARENCE HARRIS, MARALYN MONTGOMERY, as surviving spouse of plaintiff's decedent, Robert H. Montgomery and as proposed Administratrix of the Estate of Robert H. Montgomery, deceased, JASON STADLER, EMMA HOWARD, ANNIE EDWARDS, MARILYN BENNETT, individually and as successor in interest to the Estate of Alan Bennett, deceased, SERBOYA DELOTTA, GEORGIA M FLUDD, LARRY VAIL, WESTGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY, JUDY MORRIS, BONNIE A VOLEK, DAWN M LIBBY, NANCY TODD, on behalf of themselves amd all persons similarly situated, MITZI PURSEY, as personal representative of the Estate of bryan Wayne Pursey, deceased, MELISSA JOHNSON, SUSAN MATHEY, CHAD BENNETT, individually and as successor in interest of the Estate of Alan Bennett, deceased, JOHNNY KEYES, TRACEY LYNN ROBICHAUX, DONALD H SCHEIDT, DREW GORDON, NICOLE JUSTINE JAMES, BETH A HOWARD, JOSE MAGDALENO FONSECA, individually and as Representative of the Estate of Maria del Socorro Fonseca, deceased, JOHN STATEN, BRENT D YOUNG, HAYWOOD BROOMFIELD, TROY CHAPPELL, as Administrator of the Estate of Glen Sue Chappell, JOHN W WILHELM, JUDY WHITE, successor in interest of plaintiff's decedant Scott Edward White, ANN SANTOS, DONNA JOYCE ADKINS, KATHLEEN WILSON, individually and as Widow for the use and benefit of herself and next of kin of Robert Wilson, deceased, CHRISTOPHER E WAGONER, DORIS JOHNSON, PEARLIE MADDOX, BARBARA T PAYNE, LENA JOHNSON, BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD OF MASSACHUSETTS, a Massachusetts Corporation, KRISTINA WILSON, ROBIN STERN BRIGGS, as Administratrix of the Estate of Douglas Merrill briggs, deceased, LOIS ADAMS, JOSEPH P GRAHAM, WAYNE ROCHELLE, JAMES E GILMORE, JOSEPHINE JACKSON, ANGELO GAMBARDELLO, H/W, SUSAN JOHNSON, CHARLES D GIRARD, JR., MARY ANN MINERVINO, Administrator of the Estate of Carmine Minervino, LOUISE C WILSON, CORA L CRUMBLE, GUARDIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA, JOHN OWENS, BETH A BELLINO, JANEEN BRIDA, Individually and as Trustee Ad Litem on behalf of all parties entitled by law to damages in the death of Jerome Heffner, Sr., deceased, GARY VARNAM, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, CLARA M EPPS, MARIA ARANDA, ASSURANT HEALTH INC, a Wisconsin Company, JOSHUA M MARTINEZ, CYNTHIA QUIMBY, CHERYL W KIRBY, THIRD PARTY PAYORS, PEGGY ANN COLTON, DAVID HUFF, MAGGIE DORTY, KAY BLAKE, ETHEL M HALL, HELEN MORGAN, JOHNNIE HARGROVE, KEITH EDWARDS, DIANE M VALENTINO, DENISE MCLENDON, LINDA HARVESTON, JAMES MICHAEL BURLESON, JERRY HOLLAWAY, on behalf of himself amd all others similarly situated, CORRINE M FALK, MARTHA MCGEE, individually and on behalf of her mother and next friend Maurine feathermore, and on behalf of others similatly situated, MATTHEW SUMAIT, CARSON BUNCH, LARRY HADDOCK, individually and a widower for the use and benefit of himself and the next of kin of Deborah Haddock, deceased, CHRISTOPHER L HALL, GLENN ARMBRUSTER, EDWARD REOTT, DEBORAH WATSON, MICHAEL L. MALCOLM, deceased, JERRY LOWE, ELIZABETH BLAND, ALTON DILLON, LORETTA V DREHER, BARBARA READUS, LINDA PHIPPS, CHARLOTTE JENKINS, TONY ARMOUR, MONICA ALMEDIA, TOSHA R BEST, LEE ALLAN HALEY, LOTITA MYERS, LESTER C CARR, MEMBERS OF THE PLAINTIFFS PRODUCT LIABILITY STEERING COMMITTEE, Personal Injury and Product Liability, AETNA, INC., JEFFREY FARRIS, DENISE D BOYD, JEFFREY TAGGART, MICHAEL FISHER, LARRY POTTS, ROBERT A DEVORE, BENNIE SPENCER, FAZILA MUSTAFA, JAMES M HARPRING, TONYA R RIDDLE, RUSSELL CEPAS, SEAN HOGGE, ALFORD DARBY, JOHN JAMES, JR., LAURA ALLEN, Administratix of the Estate of the late Daniel Allen, Timothy Bridges, and Alfred Morabito, individually and on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated., GLORIA TELLES, SEAN MCMINN, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, GERALD W BELONGIE, JR., individually as special administrator of the Estate of Lauren D. Belongie, deceased, and as an heir of Lauren D. Belongie, CLENNON C HALL, MARIA GUADALUPE FONSECA, SHERMAN MCDONALD, JR., LORI DURDEN, SALES AND MARKETING PLAINTIFFS, PAULINE HUFF, as Administratrix of the Estate of Rickie Huff, BRYAN A MAY, JOYCE B DUHE, CASSANDRA BENSON, KAMALIHA BREWSTER, JAN FRANK WITYK, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, JOANN WALLS, HARON Y FLOYD, RUBY HOOVER, JOHN LERCH, individually on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, MONICA SMITH, as Administratrix of the Estate of Christopher Smith, deceased, MARTHA ACCETTULLO and BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF MASSACHUSETTS, a Massachusetts Corporation
Defendant:	NOVARTIS PHARMACEUTICALS, JAMES P HALL, GLENMARK GENERICS INC., USA, GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS, LTD., ACTAVIS ELIZABETH INC, THERESA A WILLIAMS, ANDREW W WALLACE, GLENMARK GENERICS, LTD., MELISSA HAMILL, JOHNSON & JOHNSON, G.D. SEARLE, LLC, OKLAHOMA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, ORTHO-MCNEIL-JANSSEN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., PARKE-DAVIS, a division of Warner-Lambert Company, MARY KATRIADAKIS, CLINE DAVIS & MANN INC, HERTZ CORPORATION, D.O. JAMES P. HALL, BJ THOMPSON, IVAX PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., DAINIPPON PHARMACEUTICALS USA CORPORATION, FIDELITY MANAGEMENT & RESEARCH COMPANY, ELAN CORPORATION, PLC, LODEWIJK J.R. DEVINK, FOSTER A DUZAN, MARY LOU LIENERTH, on behalf of herself and all others similarly situated, SUSAN ADAMO, ACTAVIS INC, ECKERD CORPORATION, ELAN PHARMACEUTICALS INC, JOHN BARRETT, DENISE SEASTRUCK, personal representative of the Estate of Dr. Jay Seastruck, M.D., PUREPAC PHARMACEUTICAL, CO., DAVID REYNOLDS LONGMIRE, HENRY A MCKINNELL, JR., BRIAN KRAH, on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated, JOHNSON & JOHNSON PHARMACEUTICAL RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT LLC, JANSSEN ORTHO LLC, FINKELSTEIN & PARTNERS, LLP, TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USA, INC., SANDOZ, INC., ANTHONY WILD, MARCOS A TOVAR, PHILIP J OBIEDZINSKI and ELAN CORPORATION
Petitioner:	RICHARD W DODD, CHRISTINE MANFREDI and HAROLD SPRINKLE
Plaintiff / Appellant:	ASEA/AFSCME LOCAL 52 HEALTH BENEFITS TRUST, LOUISIANA HEALTH SERVICE & INDEMNITY COMPANY, d/b/a Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana and HARDEN MANUFACTURING CORPORATION, individually and on behalf of itself and all others similarly situated
Defendant / Appellee:	WARNER-LAMBERT COMPANY LLC and PFIZER, INC.
Not Classified By Court:	CAROL JANNEY and DARREN MANCUSO
Intervenor:	SUSAN DUDLEY, MARK DUDLEY, IMS HEALTH, INC. and RHONDA GAYLE GOODRIDGE
Case Number:	11-1806
Filed:	October 11, 2011
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, First Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Other Statutory Actions

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.