Plaintiff:	PRINCE R. ELLIS, MICKEY M ELLIS and VERONA E.T. ELLIS
Defendant:	COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, COMPTROLLER PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS, VINCENT QUINN, Principal, ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE OF PENNSYLVANIA COURTS, KIM BERKELEY CLARK, President Judge, HONORABLE MARIE T. VEON, President, JOHN F. DISALLE, President Judge, GEORGE W. WHEELER, President Judge, SUSAN DAVIS, Vice President, DENISE PARISE, Director, Human Resources, MONTGOMERY COUNTY COURTHOUSE, (Orphans' Court Division), HON. MELISSA S. STERLING, MATTHEW V. PIO, Orphans' Court Administrator, RACHEL DEENIS, Judicial Assistant, ASHLEY KODET, Orphans' Courts Administrator, PHILADELPHIA CORPORATION OF THE AGING, ANN DANISH, Director, Care Management, HERBERT SIMONIAN, Regional Sales Director, BRENDA COLLAZO, Executive Director, ALLEN GLICKSMAN, Director of Research and Evaluation, SUSAN STARK, Social Service Coordinator, MEGAN FLANAGAN, Protective Services Supervisor, SHERRELL JENKINS, Services Coordinator, VINCENT MOORE, Services Coordinator, PHILADELPHIA BAR ASSOCIATION, PETER JOHNSON, Executive Vice President and Chief Fiduciary Officer, MARY MEEKSHANK, Executive Director, CATHRYN MILLERWILSON, Executive Director, ANITA SANTOSSINGH, Executive Director, LAVAL MILLERWILSON, Executive Director, JOANNA VISSER ADJOIAN, Co-Director, PHILADELPHIA SCHOOL DISTRICT, DR. TONY WATLINGTON, PH.D, Superintendent, MATTHEW STANSKI, Chief Financial Officer, ELLIOT WEINBAUM, Chief Philanthropy Officer, MAJEEDAH SCOTT, Director, MEREDITH MEHRA, Director & Development & Programming Professional, SOULA SERVELLO, Director of Strategic Planning, GLORIA GRESHAM, Director, LOU BELLARDINE, Chief Talent Officer, ANDREW ROSEN, Deputy, Employee Relations, PHILADELPHIA SCHOOL DISTRICT FUND, DONNA FRISBYGREENWOOD, President and Chief Executive Officer, ED ZIMMERMAN, Chairman of the Board, LAUREN CAWLEY, Grants Manager, JOE KANDRICK, Climate Manager, WILLIAM MITCHELL, Teacher, KRISTIE EDLIN, Board Manager, JERRY JORDAN, Vice President, General, DEE PHILIPS, Vice President Middle Grades, LINDA HARRIS, Assistant to the President, DENISE RODGERS, Vice President, Elementary Schools, WENDY COLEMAN, Associate Secretary/Staff Representative, JACKIE DUBIN, District Staffer, JOSEPH GREENBERG SCHOOL, The School District of Philadelphia, GINA HUBBARD, Principal, ASHANTA AUSTIN, Assistant Principal, EVELYN GRAVES MINISTRY CHURCH, DBA Evelyn Graves Drama Productions Inc, JOHN GRAVES, Dr., CASSANDRA GRAVES, Dr., SHARON FLYHTE, PAMELA ROBINSON, COMMUNITY COLLEGE OF PHILADELPHIA, THOMAS HAWK, Vice President-FIN, EDWARD CROSBEE, Chief Executive Officer, ANNE GRECO, Director of Campaign and Grant Development, MINDY POSOFF, Managing Director, BILL BROMLEY, Director, Information Technology Services, CENTER FOR ADVOCACY THE RIGHTS AND INTEREST OF THE ELDERLY, DIANE MENIO, Executive Director, WHITNEY LINGLE, Executive Director, KATHY CUBIT, Executive, REBECCA NURICK, Project Manager, Pennsylvania SMP, JESSICA HARTFIELD, Volunteer Coordinator-Long Term Care Ombudsman, ESQ. KAREN C. BUCK, Executive, LOUIS COLBERT, Vice President, SENIORLAW CENTER, MICHELE F. COHEN, Attorney, ROSEANNE MILANES, Attorney, MEAGHAN SHIRK, Attorney, JEFFREY GEROME, Administrative Coordinator, VALERIE SNOW, Attorney, KERSEY CUNNINGHAM, Senior Legal Advocate, COMMUNITY LEGAL SERVICES INC, LIBARDO CLAVIJO, Chief Financial Officer, GEOFF CROCKER, Chief Technology Officer, MICHAEL D. LIPUMA, President, AARON HUBER, Vice President, Information Systems, CAITLIN NAGEL, Director of Advancement and Communications, JONATHAN STEIN, of Counsel, PAMELA WALZ, Supervising Attorney, LYDIA GOTTESFEED, Managing Attorney, HAVEN BEHAVIORAL HEALTHCARE INC, BRUCE E. MCDONOUGH, SABER HEALTHCARE GROUP, CHESTNUT NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER LLC, DENISE MARIOTTI, Chief Human Resources Officer, ROY ROSIN, Chief Innovation Officer, REBECCA WILSON LERARIO, President, TERRI GIANCATERINO, Director, Faculty Affairs, Department of Medicine, AMY ZLYSTRA, Associate Executive Director Call Center, MICHAEL DONATO, Director, Finance Rad One, SPRINGFIELD REHABILITATION, WILLIAM MURPHY, Principal, SUSAN ARSCHT, RNC, BSN, MS, Director of Nursing, MAXINE SHUSMAN, OTR, L. Director of Rehabilitation, ROBERT SHUSMAN, Medical Director, MICHELLE RUSSO, M.A., CCC, NHA Administrator, PREMIER HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT LLC, FLORA REZNIK, CFO, BARAK BAVER, Principal, KANSAS SWAIN, Principal, RICHARD STRACKE, Collections Specialist, KATHLEEN MCNAMARA, Associate Director of Human Resources, DAVID LEVI, Accounts Payable Coordinator, BRANDYWINE NEUROPSYCHOLOGY ASSOCIATES, PH.D. GEORGE LEDAKIS, Psychologist/Neuropsychologist Principal Owner, PSY.D. MICHELLE PAYNE, Psychologist/Neuropsychologist, PSY.D. DANIEL KENNEDY, Licensed Psychologist/Pediatric Neuropsychologist, ADR OPTIONS INC, MAGGY CARNEY, Chairman (President), THOMAS B. RUTTER, Esq., Former Chairman, GENIEVE TOLL, Controller, THOMAS A. WALLITSCH, Arbitrator, MICHAEL CARNEY, Chief Executive Officer, ARTHUR W. HANKIN, Attorney, B A SENIOR SERVICES LLC, BRUCE ATWINE, Custodian of records, KEVIN MAHONEY, CEO, University of Pennsylvania Health System, VASAN KESAVAN, President, THOMAS G. SCRIVEN, Managing Director, IRA WINSTON, Chief Infrastructure Officer, SHERRYL KUHLMAN, Managing Director, DANIEL COSTANTINO, Chief Information Security Officer, PRESBYTERIAN MEDICAL CENTER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA HEALTH SYSTEM, ANTHONY ZUMPANO, Chief Financial Officer, MICHAEL POSENCHEG, Chief Medical Officer, DANIELLE BECKER, Neurology Resident, TOM WATSON, Operation Resident, JOANNE RESNIC, Director, Quality Patient Safety, PENN MEDICINE NEUROLOGY, PMUC, DR. SWATHI VIJAYARGHABEN, MD, MERCY HOSPITAL OF PHILADELPHIA, DBA Penn Medicine, DBA Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, JACKIE QUAY, Principal, MARYANNE SNYDER, NURSE LINDA MACMILLAN, Certified Medical Coder, GREGORY TERRILL, Security Supervisor, ARLENE ROBERTS, Volunteer Services Manager, SARAH MUHLENBERG, Supervisor, Theraputic Recreation, DR. DANIEL JONES, M.D. (Father's Doctor from 2000-2012), PENN MEDICINE, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, DR. VICTOR L. CARPINELLO, M.D., Urology, OAK STREET HEALTH INC, SHANEE ODUM, Owner, BRIAN CLEM, Chief Operating Officer, ERICA FRANK, Vice President, Public Relations, KELLI CONLEY, Corporate Office Manager, ANN FARRELL, Regional Vice President, KRISTEN STUBBS, Regional Vice President, CODY WEAVER, Behavioral Health Specialist, AMANDA HYDE, Senior Human Resources Business Partner, VALERIE WEISS, Primary Care Physician, WILLIAM DENNIS, Senior Outreach Executive, DR. DEWYN SERGEANT, M.D., LINDSEY ELLEN REHL, R.N., C.R.N.P., GREGORY DAVIS, President and Chief Executive Officer, MADELINE BELL, President and Chief Executive Officer, SOPHIA HOLDER, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, DOUGLAS HOCK, Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, LOUIS TROILO, Vice President FIN, SAGE MYERS, Medical Director of Emergency Preparedness, THE CHILDRENS HOSPITAL OF PHILADELPHIA PRACTICE ASSOCIATION, THE CHILDRENS HOSPITAL OF PHILADELPHIA, DR. CAMILLUS L. WITZLEBEN, M.D., Director, DR. WAYNE FRANKLIN, Medical Group C Pediatrician, DR. ANDREW ADESMAN, M.D., Senior Fellow Division of Child Development & Rehabilitation, MAXINE FIELD, PH.D., Certified School Psychologist, MAUREEN A. FEE, M.D., Clinical Attending, DR. RANDALL T. DRAIN, M.D., THE CONSORTIUM INC, Honorable John F. White Jr. President and CEO, HON. JOHN M. YOUNGE, Chairman of the Board, ERIC SILVERMAN, Chief Financial Officer, MARK BERRY, Director, Charles Breeze Supports Coordinator, UNITED STEELWORKERS OF AMERICA, International Union, THOMAS M. CONWAY, International President, ALTON BERAY, President, GARY BONE, President, B. CHAPMAN, President, BERRY CHRISTENSON, President, DENNIS CZAJKA, President, UNITED STEELWORKERS DISTRICT 10 LOCAL 286 WELFARE TRUST FUND, JIMMIE T. NOLAN, International Rep., MARIO TATOM, Vice President, MICHAEL CONNELL, Business Agent, CARLO SIMONE, JR., President, LINDSAY PATTERSON, Business Agent, KATHY CONNELL, Pension (Payroll Management), NEWMAN & COMPANY INC, BERNARD NEWMAN, Chairman, DAVID NEWMAN, Vice President & General Manager, JESSICA NEWMAN, Owner, BERNICE ROCKHILL, Human Resources Executive, LYNNE FERMAN, Board of Directors, TREASURER STACY GARRITY, LYNN SHEFFER, Principal, BRIAN T. LYMAN, Chief Accounting Officer, URI MONSON, Secretary, DIANA FISHLOCK, Deputy Communications Director, MICHAEL MATSKO, Director, WILLIAM WHITMAN, Information Technology Generalist, RACHEL LEVIN, Secretary, JOSEPH WASIAK, Assistant Executive Director, RUST MEGHAN, Forensic Social Worker, KRISTEN RODACK, Director, PAUL SIENKIEWICZ, Project Manager, PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL, BUREAU OF PROFESSIONAL & OCCUPATIONAL AFFAIRS, Legal Office - Prosecution Division, PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION, ERIC HAGARTY, State Superintendent of Schools, MATTHEW STERN, Assistant Superintendent, CAROLYN ANGELO, Executive Director, MONIQUE WILLIAMS, Accountability Director, EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, Washington DC Office, CHARLOTTE A. BURROWS, Chair, UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL, MARLIN PECK, Principal, REGINA CANNON, Certified Nursing Assistant, SANDRA LEPPO, Restorative Aide, MARGARET SMITH, Certified Nursing Assistant, JACQUELINE SCOTT, Director, Rehabilitation, REST HAVEN NURSING HOME INC, CHESTNUT HILL LODGE, AKA Chestnut Hill Lodge Rehabilitation and Skilled Nursing Facility, JOCELYN SAMUELS, Vice Chair, EEOC- Washington DC, KEITH SONDERLING, Commissioner, EEOC- Washington DC, ANDREA R. LUCAS, Commissioner, EEOC- Washington DC, JOSEPH HARDIMAN, Branch Manager, EEOC- Philadelphia, DEBORAH A. KANE, Senior Trial Attorney, STEVEN JESSENHOWARD, JD Candidate and Law and Public Policy Scholar, FREDERICKA WARREN, Records Disclosure Coordinator, SHANON S. LEVIN, Administrative Judge, SYRETTA HALL, Senior Investigator, SPENCER H. LEWIS, JR., District Director, CARLTON M. MADDEN, Director, Office of Federal Operations, KAREN A. TOWNES, EEO-ADR Specialist, XAVIER BECERRA, Secretary U.S. Departrment of Health and Human Services, ANDREA PALM, Deputy Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, DR. TAHIR MANSOOD, Mental Health Doctor in 2003, MCARTHUR ALLEN, Chief Administrative Law, Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals (DMHA), GLEN BRUCE, Chief Technology Officer, MARY MORTENSEN, Chief Medical Officer, ALAN SIM, Chief Data Officer, SHERRI BERGER, Chief Operating Officer, AMENDA COHN, Chief Medical Officer, ABRAHAM LINCOLN, Chief Management Officer, MICHELLE A. HENRY, Attorney General, CHRISTOPHER D. CARUSONE, Manager, JOSEPH J. MAY, Esq., Deputy Attorney General, MICHAEL HALE, Investigation Agent, DONALD GENERALS, President, WILLIAM E. OTTO, Esq., Principal, DR. STEVEN C. LEWIS, D.O., TIMOTHY F. NICHOLSON, President, JOHN POOLE, Vice President, STEVEN LEBER, Registered Dietician, KATE JOHNSON, Social Worker (during Oak Street Health Dad's Rapport), The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Foundation, CYNTHIA REDDY, Medical Records Director, TAMIKA BRISBANE, Director of Nursing, YOUSZEUF AHMED, Regional Business Office Manager, LISA DOZIER, Social Worker, KIMBERLY GRIFFIES-EDWARDS, YOUNGYULL KIM, Vice President, Care Chemicals Sales and Marketing, REBECCA CLARK, Social Worker, MARKIA TURNER, Business Office Manager, TRICIA TRACHUM, Social Worker (Coordinator/Social Worker), TAMIKA BRISBAHE, Facility Coordinator, TYNISHA HERDER-DUNCAN, RN, BS, NHA, ROCHELLE P. WALENSKY, M.D., MPH, CDC Director, PHILADELPHIA FEDERATION OF TEACHERS AMERICAN FEDERATION OF TEACHERS AFL CIO LOCAL 3, JULIANE HOLZ, Victim Advocate, NEQUAVA MATTHEWS, Long Term Care Ombudsman and SENIORLAW CENTER FOR ADVOCACY FOR THE RIGHTS AND INTERESTS OF ELDERS
Case Number:	24-1321
Filed:	February 26, 2024
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Third Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Other Civil Rights

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.