Plaintiff:	ALBERTA BATTS, SETH WALSTON, JR., DON WEBB, FAITH MURPHY, HARVEY TATE, REDEDIETH MORRISSEY, MARTHA JOY MILLER, WALTER GUY ADAMS, DONNIE MESSICK, ISAAC WEBB, PARIS BEST, JOE HERRING, MANDIE KENAN, SALLIE BONEY JOHNSON, WILLIE BURTON, MILDRED KENAN, ADAJIO FAISON, LARRY FAISON, JOE KENAN, CATHY PEARSALL, BETTY COLLIER, MARY KENAN, OLIVIA VANN SMITH, ALLEN T. JOHNSON, ANNIE CARR, GENE PEARSON, JANIE PAYNE, LLOYD BARTON, GLADYS M. WALSTON, MARCUS PETERSON, ANNIE JACOBS, MARGARET WILLIAMS, ERIC HIGH, CARL A. MOYE, ETHEL NEWKIRK, TEVIN NEWKIRK, WARD SCARBOUGH, RICHARD LAVERNE BROWN, NED ROBINSON, JAMES D. HALL, EMMA A. MOYE, RICHARD H. THOMPSON, VIOLA HERRING, NORWOOD PICKETT, ESTELLA WALKER, BETTY JAMES, RAY C. HALL, FRANKEA RASHAWN HALL, WANDA MCGOWAN, GWENDOLYN PICKETT, FOSTINA LISANE COOPER, CLIFFORD NEWKIRK, PAMELA HALL, CARL LEWIS, HOWARD MURPHY, PERRY MILLER, SCOTTY HALL, LEOLA JACOBS, TRACEY SCOTT GODLEY, WILLIAM ROBINSON, VIVIAN FAISON, ALONZO KELLY, JR., JENNIE DAVIS, THURMAN MCAURTHOR JUDGE and JAMES MONTGOMERY, SR.
Plaintiff / Appellee:	HATTIE TUCKER, RAQUAN SCARBOROUGH, LILLIE WAYMON, ANDREW LEE BROWN, RANDY ALLEN DAVIS, Executor of the Estate of Jennie Stancil Davis, ELAINE CARLTON, LOIS STEWART BANKS, HELEN C. DOBSON, BRENDA ATKINSON, COLLINS LOPEZ, ANNIE HARPER, KANDACE BLANKS, KENTREL DAVIS, CELESTINE BROWN SMITH, MAYA JUDGE, ELAINE FAISON HUNT, FOSTINA JONES, HERMETTA JUDGE, VICTOR RAYA, ARCHIE WRIGHT, JR., EUNICE ANDERSON, QUINTIN LEE GODLEY, Administrator of the Estate of Tracey S. Godley, ALEX SHARPLESS, IOLA PICKETT HALL, ETHEL DAVIS, KIMBERLY CARR, JAMES ALFRED HENRY, ANTHONY CARLTON, MARGARET GRETA NICHOLSON, CHARLES HERRING, BOBBY JAMES WYCKOFF, SARA LOU BATTS, DAQWAN ROBINSON, LEE ANN WILLIAMS, GEMELL BETHUNE, RUSSELL PICKETT, ETHEL BEST, ROSEMARY BATTS, DORIVAL S. ROCHA, EDNA MURPHY, GORDEN HUMPHREY, GENEVA PICKETT, MICHAEL JOHNSON, WILBERY GARY MURRAY, TAMMAURA MARSHAYE BROWN, LAWRENCE RAWLS, COREY BATTS, JAMES HARPER, JR., JAMES ANTHONY MILLER, DEBORAH GOODMAN TOTTEN, DOROTHY L. HILL, Administratrix of the Estate of Perry Miller, TONY BENNETT, GERALDINE HUMPHREY, EUGENA WARD ELLIS, Administratrix of the Estate of Isaac Shelton Ward, MINNIE BRINSON, ROBERTO MURPHY, DELOIS BETHUNE, BRENDA LEE MURRAY, ROSALIND LEE, JOHN TAYLOR, CARLEEN ROBINSON, Administratrix of the Estate of Ned Robinson, GEORGE F. WILLIAMS, ELISA HESTER, Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joan Scarbough, TONGA BONEY, IVAN DANYELL WILLIAMS, JAMES WILLOUGHBY, SR., EDDIE RAY HALL, EDITH SAUNDERS, LOUISE VERNELL MONROE, Administratrix of the Estate of Billie Monroe, AVERY ADRAYLE WILLIS, JR., ROSALYN MOORE, JEREMIAH MATHEWSON, GREGORY BRINSON, DEBORAH J. MCGEE, IRIS HIGH, GERTIE JACOBS, THURNELL BECTON, Executor of the Estate of Viola Christine Herring, JAMES ATKINSON, ANTONIO KEVIN MCKOY, LITTLE DAVIS, JERRY BONEY, EDWARD MONROE, JOANNE KING, KIRON NEWTON, WILMA HALL, WILLIAM MATHIS, CAROLYN ADAMS, RAEFORD BATTS, TALLEY SAUNDERS, JOYCE MESSICK, RICHARD BLOW, CHERYL FLOWERS, JIMMY CARR, RETHA PICKETT, JAMES DAVIS, SR., MARY TATUM, JOYCE MURPHY, Administrator of the Estate of Howard Lee Murphy, RONALD MATTHEWS, VONNIE WILLIAMS, HARRY EDWARD KENAN, Co-Administrator of the Estate of Mildred Kenan, LOTTIE FOWLER, KIM NEWTON, ERNESTINE SAVAGE, DENNIS BURTON, SANDRA KEMP, Administrator of the Estate of Charles Monroe, ALLEN A. JOHNSON, LINDA GIRLEY, PATRICIA MONTGOMERY, EVELYN BONEY JAMES, JACQUELINE DAVIS, COUNCIL GLASPIE, ANNIE HAYES, ANNIE DORIS JOHNSON, as Administratrix of the Estate of Allen Thomas Johnson, SARAH ANN PICKETT, BELVERIA ANN WEBB, LITTLE WORRELL, JAMES WHITLEY, JR., JARMAR TREMAINE MONROE, SAMUEL DEVON MONROE, BRIAN PICKETT, ANGELA HIGH, LINNILL FARLAND, SR., MARGARET STEWART ADAMS, SHEILA MURPHY, CASANDRA MONROE MURCHISON, SALISA BEST, RITA MONROE, PHYLLIS WRIGHT, CYNTHIA HIGH, QUEENIE ELIZABETH ROSE, SHARON ROBINSON, JERRY MCCLARIN, SR., JESSIE LISANE, JR., GREGORY PETERSON, BARBARA MCKOY JAMISON, SUSAN WEBB, Administratrix of the Estate of Don Webb, SHIRLEY TEMPLE KELLY, MYRON JUDGE, LORETTA MILLER, Administrator of the Estate of Rededieth M. Morrisey, TERRY TERRELLE WILLIAMS, FREDERICK PICKETT, TRACY SHAMEKA CROMARTIE, WILMA DIANA JARMAN EVANS, ANNIE HERRING, JERRY SLOAN, MELVIN LASHLEY, DIANE ARTIS, JULAINE BENNERMAN, CAROLYN ANN GLASPER, DAISY WILLIAMS, MAXINE SPENCER, ADELE WHITEHEAD JONES, PAMELA KAYE MCMILLON, DELOIS LEWIS, MARY E. ADAMS, EDWARD INGRAM, LAKECHIA TURNER, WOODY GILLIS, As Executor of the Estate of Gwendolyn Gail Pickett, JEFFERY LANIER, CARTHA WILLIAMS, ARTIS HALL, LINDA WILLIAMS, LUKE DAVIS, MICHAEL SCARBOUGH, Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joan Scarbough, Executor of the Estate of Ward Scarbough, MICHELLE GARNER, FRANCIS CHERYL HALL, DARLENE FOWLER MAYNOR, TERRA KENAN, PERCY GIRLEY, CAROLYN DAVIS, KATRINA HARVEY, JAMES JACOBS, ANNETTE MCKIVER, SHARADE DAVIS, JOYCE HERRING ROBERTS, REGINA EVERETT, Administrator of the Estate of Walter Guy Adams, MARY LORENA WILLIAMS, TONY ORLANDO HALL, JOYCE MURPHY, DENZEL HERRING, ERVIN M. MURRAY, EDNA WALKER, JAMES D. BOWEN, JR., BETTY JEAN SLOAN, RAYMOND BATTS, CYNTHIA LORETTA DIXON HALL, JAMES ARLANDA PICKETT, PEGGY ARDEAN FENNELL, LINDA EVANS, HARRY MURPHY, LORETTA BYRD, Administrator of the Estate of Lawrence Rawls, PANZYTA KENAN, Co-Administrator of the Estate of Mildred Kenan, LAETITIA LISANE CHELTENHAM, Administratrix of the Estate of Fostina Lisane Cooper, JANNETT BUSH, WILLIE MESSICK, DELPHINE MURRAY WILLIAMS, BRUCE HALL, LUADA PATRICK, Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Louis Robinson, GEORGE ALTON MARTIN, HELEN MCKOY BANKS, JACQUELINE MCCALOP LISANE, DEBBIE MELVIN, JOYCE ANN HARDISON, RUDOLPH ADAMS, JAMES LASHLEY, ANDREW JAMES, Administrator of the Estate of Betty Ann Smith James, JENNIFER HERRING, THURMON MONROE, SR., RACHELLA DOBSON, WOODELL MCGOWAN, Individually and as executor of the estate of Wanda McGowan, NICHOLAS WOODARD, SR., CASSANDRA CHASTEN, ESTATE OF IDA CROMARTIE, EVELYN WOODARD, BRIONNA MCKIVER, PRISCILLA DUNHAM, EMMA LOU KING COLLINS, NOVA WILLIAMS, MINDY PIERCE, TAMMY MONROE, GLENDA BARTON, ANDREW HIGH, BARRY HENRY, DOMINIQUE WOODARD, DANIEL WILLIAMS, JAMES HOLMES, SHARON E. KIRK, ROBERT BETHUNE, MARVIN GAY PICKETT, WILLIAM MURPHY, PEGGY CARR FENNELL, Co-Administratrix of the Estate of Annie Laura Rochelle Carr, TITUS HIGH, GABRIELLA RAYA, ELOUISE ALLEN, BETTY BAKER, KATIE JOYNER, JACQUALINE NEWKIRK, VICTORIA HALL, LAVERNE FULLWOOD, DARIEN JEROME MURPHY, SR., BEN ARTIS, JOHN BAKER, LLOYD DAVIS, RONALD LEE BAKER, APRIL SANTRICE MURRAY, DENNIS MCKIVER, JR., THURMAN MCAURTHOR JUDGE, Individually and as administrator of the Estate of Thurman Judge, CAROLYN HALL, BARBARA GIBBS, PATRICIA MELVIN PRATT, JOHN BANNERMAN, EVANGELINE KENAN, VIRGINIA BOONE, WALTER PICKETT, CAROLYN MATHIS, SHANITA L. HENRY, PANZYTA KENAN, WANDA CARLTON DIXON, RHODA CAMPBELL, JANICE PICKETT, MINNIE MAE PRICE, MARILYN MATTHEWS, MELISSA GLASPIE, GLENN FAISON, JOHN HOCKADAY, JACQUELINE HIGH, JOYCE MCKIVER, SANDRA C. BETHUNE, JOHN LASHLEY, JERRY FENNELL, SR., JESSIE BRINSON, ALMA SHARPLESS, LEDESMOND HIGH, DOUGLAS MATHIS, THELMA JEANETTE WYCKOFF, MARY W. JONES, DAVID MCCLEARY JARMAN, PRECIOUS L. SMITH, LEROY BROADIE, KENNETH CARTER, TIMOTHY MORRISSEY, DWIGHT DELANE DIXON, RACHEL SCARBOROUGH, CLARENCE BANNERMAN, BELINDA DEBORAH BOONE, MEKONNE SHONTE SWANN, LAWANDRA DINAH MCKOY, PHYLLIS MONTE ADAMS, DARLENE JONES, KELLY PEARSON, WILLIE THOMAS WILLIAMS, LAURA PICKETT, JOYCE ANN GLASPIE, LAKESHA T. KELLY, Administrator of the Estate of Alonzo Junior Kelly, SABENA CARTER, JOSEPH DEAN PICKETT, LENORA NICHOLSON, CYRIL HARRINGTON, JAMES HENRY ROSE, ADLENE HERRING, JIMMY WAYMON, JAMES LINWOOD MONTGOMERY, JR., Administrator of the Estate of James Linwood Montgomery, Sr., JONATHAN MATTHEWS, JR., CONNIE NEWTON, WILBERT CARR, FELICIA BANNERMAN, DANIEL I. MILLER, Administrator for the Estate of Perry Miller, GERALDINE BURTON, ANNA MORRISEY, MARY E. UNDERWOOD, ISOLENE SCARBOROUGH, OSHONIA SHERYL MILLER, ALICE HIGH, OLIVIA RAYA, PATRICK H. CROMARTIE, JR., DORIS CHASTEN, RICHARD PRATT, TRUMILLA MCCLARIN, DAISY LLOYD, CHARLES MONROE, MASTER BLANKS, CALVIN MELVIN, Administrator of the Estate of Margaret Marine Williams, DAISY J. FENNELL, AARON SMITH, ANNIE L. MONROE, SUSAN MATHEWSON, CHARLES M. SLADE, JR., Administrator of the Estate of Larry Wayne Smith, Administrator of the Estate of Eric Antonio High, CAROLYN CARR WALKER, Co-Administratrix of the Estate of Annie Laura Rochelle Carr, GREGORY COLLINS HALL, EDNA ALLISON, ROBERT CARTER, FLORA HALL, ANN FRANCES BROWN, ETHEL LEE HALL, ELVIS WILLIAMS, SHATINAH WOODARD, SHIRLYNN BLOW, JERRY C. COLLIER, Executor of the Estate of Bettie C. Collier, JOE TERRANO KELLY, DAVID EARL MURRAY, LOWINELYN MCGEE, ANNJEANETTE GILLIS, As Executor of the Estate of Gwendolyn Gail Pickett, THELMA MATHIS, ELSIE HOCKADAY, GREGORY CARR, VIOLET BRANCH, LENORA HOLMES, SHEENA CROMARTIE, LANNIE FAYE PICKETT, ANNIE RAWLS, DONALD DAVID CARR, CELESTINE BROWN SMITH, Administrator of the Estate of Richard Laverne Brown, JAMES DAVIS, JR., FREEMAN SEALEY, ANTONIO WILLIAMS, SR., JOHN DEE FAISON, LOU FRANCES HERRING, ROSIE WILLOUGHBY, HERBERT MILLER, JOE E. POWELL, JR., PAULINE HILL, JENNIFER MARLENA CROMARTIE, CHARLES WADE, BERNITA FAISON, TERESA LLOYD, ROSA SMITH, DEBORAH MONROE, EDWARD OWENS, KATIE MORRISEY BRUNSON, NICHOLAS BLANKS, NOTIS HOLT, MICHAEL ALLEN, BUDDY JOYNER, OLIVER MURPHY, GEORGE ESTER FENNELL, EMERY P. DALESIO, TIARA MONET FENNELL, BOBBY KING, ROBERT CARR, ANNETTE M. WILLIAMS, ANNIE WASHINGTON, WILLIE JAMES MURCHISON, EDITH PEARSON, Executor of the Estate of Gene Pearson, BILLIE MONROE, WILLIE KEA, JR., FELICIA JOHNSON, DETRIA BATTS, HARRY EDWARD KENAN, LATONYA CARTER, JULIE DAVIS, RANDY DAVIS, ALEXANDRIA MCKOY, JEDIAEL LEAK, ANTHONY ROBINSON, LUCY SIDBERRY, DENNIS BEST, RICKY LEE GRAY, SONDRA MARSHELL MARTIN, LAJUNE JESSUP, ELSIE HERRING, ADLENE HERRING, Administrator of the Estate of Joe Herring, NORWOOD ALDERMAN, MARVIN DEVON MCKOY, TONY FARRIOR, JOHN EVERETT, GEORGE ESTER FENNELL, Administrator of the Estate of Jerry Franklin Fennell, Jr., DANIELLE MARIE HARRINGTON, SHIRLEY WILLIAMS, KAREN MCKIVER, THERESA J. MILLER, Executrix of the Estate of Martha Joy Miller, RICHARD WILLIAMS, SHANNON ADAMS, PERRY PICKETT, EVETT PICKETT, OLLIE BURTON, Personal Representative of the Estate of Willie J. Burton, BRENDA GARNER BING, AARON WESLEY HALL, on his own behalf and as Guardian of Scotty Hall, James Dudley Hall, and Pamela Hall, JAMES ALFRED HENRY, JR., LEMUEL PRICE, MAE MAZYCK, HERMAN STEVEN WILLIAMS, GEORGIA FARLAND, DEBORAH R. WOLFE, LATORIA MARIE JOHNSON, HARRY LEE SMITH, WINFRED DOUGLASS CHASTEN, MANUEL RAYA, RENE MILLER, NYIESHA KIERRA MURCHISON, EDDIE NICHOLSON, KECIA FARRIOR, JACQUELINE G. HILL, DWAYNE BOWEN, LINDSAY COUNCIL HALL, LORRINE ROBINSON, ALMA S. ROCHA, DWIGHT CARR, NATASHA JUDGE, MACKIE BAKER, ERMA JEAN MILES, EDNA ALLISON, Executor of the Estate of Leola Jacobs, BOBBY MONROE, DEBORAH JOHNSON, JIMMIE SAVAGE, GWENDOLYN HIGH, BETTY WILLIAMS, EMMETT HALL, PATRICIA PARKER PICKETT, RITA BONEY BUTLER, CAROLYN MCKOY WRIGHT, JOYCE ROBERTS HERRING, TANNER PIERCE, ROBERT PICKETT, FREDERICK LLOYD, EDYTHE BROWN, CLEVELAND ADOLPH MONROE, ALISA BRINSON, DOROTHY MATHIS, CAROLYN B. CARR, LULAR FRANCIS WILLIAMS, KEVIN PIERCE, MARILYN ALDERMAN, BOBBY FARRON MONROE, JR., MARILYN O. HALL, Co-Administratrix of the Estate of Ray Cornelius Hall, JAMES DOBSON, MARY P. WADE, TAMMY LLOYD, KELLY BEST, EDITH PEARSON, DEBORAH PETERSON, CLARA MILLER, GEORGE PICKETT, TANECHIA LLOYD, DREAMA CARTER, ELVERETT HALL, JUDITH WORRELL, WILLIAM ROBINSON, JR., Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Louis Robinson, DOROTHY JACKSON, ANTWAN HIGH, DAVID CARTER and DAPHNE MCKOY
Defendant / Appellant:	MURPHY-BROWN, LLC
Case Number:	20-1150
Filed:	February 11, 2020
Court:	U.S. Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit
Nature of Suit:	Other

Access additional case information on PACER

Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.