MN Deer Farmers Assoc., et al v. Sarah Strommen, et al
| Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Steven Uchytil, Jamey Blome, Devon Lien, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Renae Blome, Sarah Evans, Jim Simonson, Emily Lien, Melissa Uchytil, Aaron Seitz, Ken Williams, Chase Simonson, Ray Matejcek, Michael Robokoff, Brian Evans, Scott Fier, Deb Houlthaus, Luke Hanson, Scott Salonek, Allen Huju, Andrew C. Whitcomb, Gary Olson, John Holthaus, Kendra Hanson, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Paul Agre, Samantha Uchytil, Stanley Tvedt, Francella Tvedt, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Trudy Graves, Steve Porter, Peggy Porter, Nolan Porter and Dennis Udovich |
| Sarah Strommen, in her official capacity as Commissioner of the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, or her successor, Erica Sawatzke, in her official capacity as Board President of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or her successor, Peggy Anne Hawkins, in her official capacity as Board Vice President of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or her successor, Jessica Koppien-Fox, in her official capacity as a Member of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or her successor, Alex Stade, in his official capacity as Member of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or his successor, Steve Neil, in his official capacity as Member of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or his successor and Brandon Schafer, in his official capacity as Member of Minnesota Board of Animal Health, or his successor |
| 24-2845 |
| September 11, 2024 |
| U.S. Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit |
| Other Civil Rights |
Opinions
We have the following opinions for this case:
| Description |
|---|
 MN Deer Farmers Assoc. v. Strommen
|
Docket Report
RSS Track this Docket
This docket was last retrieved on November 8, 2024. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
| Document Text |
|---|
| MOTION for extension of time to file brief until 01/06/2025, filed by Oliver J. Larson for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Alex Stade and Sarah Strommen and Philip S. Pulitzer for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Alex Stade and Sarah Strommen w/service 11/08/2024. [5455235] [24-2845] (OJL) [Entered: 11/08/2024 03:57 PM] |
| BRIEF FILED - APPELLANT BRIEF filed by Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams, w/service 11/06/2024. Length: 8,687 words. 10 COPIES OF PAPER BRIEFS (WITHOUT THE APPELLATE PDF FOOTER) FROM Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams due 11/12/2024 WITH certificate of service for paper briefs. Brief of Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Alex Stade and Sarah Strommen due on 12/06/2024. [5454128] [24-2845] (HAG) [Entered: 11/06/2024 04:13 PM] |
| APPELLANT brief of Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams submitted for review. The time for filing the subsequent brief (if any) does not begin to run until the brief has been approved and filed. To open/view this brief, you must first login to CM/ECF and then open the document link in your Notice of Docket Activity. Only direct recipients on accounts can open this document. [5453542] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 11/05/2024 12:03 PM] |
| ADDENDUM of APPELLANT FILED by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams, w/service 11/01/2024. [5452628] [24-2845] (HAG) [Entered: 11/01/2024 11:24 AM] |
| Brief deficiency notice sent to counsel, Attorney Erick G. Kaardal for Appellants Gary Olson, Lisa Clark, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Aaron Seitz, Allen Huju, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Deb Houlthaus, John Holthaus, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Jim Simonson, Chase Simonson, Ray Matejcek, Michael Robokoff, Scott Fier, Steven Uchytil, Melissa Uchytil, Andrew C. Whitcomb, Scott Salonek, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Joseph Collins, Ken Williams, Luke Hanson, Kendra Hanson, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Paul Agre, Samantha Uchytil, Stanley Tvedt, Francella Tvedt, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Trudy Graves, Steve Porter, Peggy Porter, Nolan Porter and Dennis Udovich. [5452616] [24-2845] (HAG) [Entered: 11/01/2024 11:09 AM] |
| Addendum of APPELLANT submitted for review by Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams. To open/view this addendum, you must first login to CM/ECF and then open the document link in your Notice of Docket Activity. [5452445] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 10/31/2024 10:10 PM] |
| APPELLANT brief of Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams submitted for review. The time for filing the subsequent brief (if any) does not begin to run until the brief has been approved and filed. To open/view this brief, you must first login to CM/ECF and then open the document link in your Notice of Docket Activity. Only direct recipients on accounts can open this document. [5452444] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 10/31/2024 10:07 PM] |
| CLERK ORDER: The [ # 5443325-2 ] motion for extension of time to file Appellees brief is denied as premature. The denial is without prejudice to the filing of a renewed motion after Appellants brief has been submitted and accepted for filing and a deadline for Appellees brief has been set. [5445968] [24-2845] (HAG) [Entered: 10/15/2024 09:49 AM] |
| MOTION for extension of time to file brief until 01/06/2025, filed by Attorney Philip S. Pulitzer for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Alex Stade and Sarah Strommen w/service 10/04/2024. [5443325] [24-2845] (PSP) [Entered: 10/04/2024 02:06 PM] |
| STATEMENT of issues filed by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams - w/service 09/19/2024. [5437842] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/19/2024 04:22 PM] |
| Certificate of transcript filed by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams. Transcript ordered August 5, 2024. [5437843] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/19/2024 04:24 PM] |
| DESIGNATION of record filed by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams. w/service 09/19/2024 [5437840] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/19/2024 04:21 PM] |
| METHOD of appendix preparation filed by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams - Separate Appendix - w/service 09/19/2024 [5437838] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/19/2024 04:19 PM] |
| CORPORATE disclosure statement filed by Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams. - FOR CAL [5437835] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/19/2024 04:17 PM] |
| APPEARANCE filed by Oliver Larson for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Sarah Strommen and Alex Stade w/service 09/18/2024 [5437118] [24-2845] (OJL) [Entered: 09/18/2024 01:48 PM] |
| APPEARANCE filed by Philip Pulitzer for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Brandon Schafer, Sarah Strommen and Alex Stade w/service 09/18/2024 [5437116] [24-2845] (OJL) [Entered: 09/18/2024 01:44 PM] |
| **LOCKED-COUNSEL TO REFILE INDICATING CORRECT PARTIES BEING REPRESENTED**APPEARANCE filed by Philip Pulitzer for Appellees Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Erica Sawatzke, Alex Stade, Brandon Schafer and Sarah Strommen w/service 09/18/2024 [5436947] [24-2845]--[Edited 09/18/2024 by HAG to lock] (OJL) [Entered: 09/18/2024 09:55 AM] |
| **LOCKED-COUNSEL TO REFILE INDICATING CORRECT PARTIES BEING REPRESENTED** APPEARANCE filed by Oliver J. Larson for Appellees Sarah Strommen, Peggy Anne Hawkins, Jessica Koppien-Fox, Steve Neil, Brandon Schafer, Erica Sawatzke and Alex Stade w/service 09/18/2024 [5436944] [24-2845]--[Edited 09/18/2024 by HAG to lock] (OJL) [Entered: 09/18/2024 09:52 AM] |
| Originating court document filed consisting of docket entries, Memorandum Opinion and Order filed 8/14/2024, Judgment filed 8/15/2024, and Notice of Appeal filed 9/9/2024. [5434302] [24-2845] (CBO) [Entered: 09/11/2024 10:23 AM] |
| APPEARANCE filed by Gregory M. Erickson for Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams w/service 09/11/2024 [5434387] [24-2845] (GME) [Entered: 09/11/2024 11:44 AM] |
| APPEARANCE filed by Erick G. Kaardal for Appellants Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams w/service 09/11/2024 [5434384] [24-2845] (EGK) [Entered: 09/11/2024 11:42 AM] |
| BRIEFING SCHEDULE SET AS FOLLOWS: Transcript due on or before 10/21/2024. Appendix due 10/31/2024. BRIEF APPELLANT, Paul Agre, Jamey Blome, Renae Blome, Jennifer Lynn Boon, Mark Henricus Boon, Nolan Buchner, Stephanie Buchner, Lisa Clark, Joseph Collins, Brian Evans, Sarah Evans, Scott Fier, Trudy Graves, Kendra Hanson, Luke Hanson, John Holthaus, Deb Houlthaus, Allen Huju, Devon Lien, Emily Lien, Ray Matejcek, Minnesota Deer Farmers Association, Gary Olson, Nolan Porter, Peggy Porter, Steve Porter, Michael Robokoff, Scott Salonek, Aaron Seitz, Chase Simonson, Jim Simonson, Francella Tvedt, Stanley Tvedt, Melissa Uchytil, Samantha Uchytil, Steven Uchytil, Dennis Udovich, Mark Volk, Mary Volk, Andrew C. Whitcomb and Ken Williams due 10/31/2024 Appellee brief is due 30 days from the date the court issues the Notice of Docket Activity filing the brief of appellant. [5434313] [24-2845] (CBO) [Entered: 09/11/2024 10:28 AM] |
| Civil case docketed. [5434296] [24-2845] (CBO) [Entered: 09/11/2024 10:16 AM] |
Access additional case information on PACER
Access the Case Summary and Docket Report to access additional information about this case on the U.S. Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
