Adler, et al v. Northside Hospital, et al
Saul M. Adler |
James Jose, William Keyes, Kenneth Kupke and Margaret Moore |
Gates, Moore and Company |
Madeleine del Portillo and Adler Neonatology Group, P.C. |
Northside Hospital, Inc., Neonatology Associates, P.C., Patrick Spafford and Wendy Troyer |
1:2003cv01433 |
May 22, 2003 |
US District Court for the Northern District of Georgia |
Clarence Cooper |
Anti-Trust |
15 U.S.C. § 26 Suit for injunctive relief re violation antitrust laws |
Plaintiff |
Docket Report
This docket was last retrieved on December 17, 2004. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.
Document Text |
---|
![]() |
Filing 89 STIPULATION of Dismissal with prejudice pursuant to FRCP 41.a.1.ii by all parties and aprvd by dep clerk. (vs) |
Civil Case Terminated. (vs) |
Submission of #79 MOTION for Protective Order, submitted to District Judge Clarence Cooper. (vs) |
Submission of 75 Motion to Stay, 82 MOTION to Compel, 83 Response in Opposition to Motion, 76 Motion for Partial Summary Judgmen, Motion for Hearing, Motion for Hearing, 80 MOTION Rule 56(f), 81 MOTION for Extension of Time to respond to dft Northside's pending motions, submitted to District Judge Clarence Cooper. (vs) |
![]() |
Submission of #70 Motion for Protective Order, #84 Response in Opposition to Motion, #86 Reply Brief, #71 Motion to Stay, submitted to District Judge Clarence Cooper. (vs) |
Filing 87 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of discovery materials by Neonatology dfts. (vs) |
Filing 86 REPLY BRIEF filed by Neonatology dfts re #70 Motion for Protective Order. (vs) |
Filing 85 NOTICE Of hearing by Plaintiffs. (vs) |
Filing 83 RESPONSE in Opposition filed by Plaintiffs re 75 dft Northside Hospital Inc.'s Motion to Stay discovery. (vs) |
Filing 84 RESPONSE in Opposition filed by Saul M. Adler, Adler Neonatology Group, P.C., Madeleine del Portillo re #70 Motion for Protective Order. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1#2 Exhibit 2)(vs) |
Filing 82 MOTION to Compel with Brief In Support by Neonatology dfts (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) |
Filing 81 MOTION for Extension of Time to respond to dft Northside's pending motions with Brief In Support by Saul M. Adler, Adler Neonatology Group, P.C. (FILED UNDER SEAL). (vs) |
Filing 80 Emergency MOTION for Rule 56(f) with Brief In Support by Saul M. Adler, Adler Neonatology Group, P.C..(FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) |
Filing 79 MOTION for Protective Order by Movant (Third Party) Gates, Moore and Company. (Attachments: #1 memo in support)(vs) |
Filing 78 OBJECTION to subpoena to L. Michael Fleischman and motion to quash with supporting memo. by Neonatology Associates, P.C.. (vs) |
MOTION to Quash subpoena with Brief In Support filed within objection document #78 by Neonatology Associates, P.C.. (vs) |
Filing 77 Certificate of service of discovery responses and interrogatories as to plaintiff (vs) |
Filing 76 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital for partial summary judgment , and, in the alternative for preliminary evidentiary hearing on the issue of immunity with memo of law in support and stmt of material facts with volumn I - III of exhibits. (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) |
Filing 75 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital to stay discovery, except discovery related to plas' discrimination claim with brief in support. (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) |
Filing 74 Certificate of service of discovery papers as to defendant Northside Hospital (vs) |
Filing 73 Request by defendant Northside Hospital for oral argument (vs) |
Filing 72 Certificate of service of responses to plas' first set of requests for production of documents as to Neonatology defendants (vs) |
Filing 71 MOTION by Neonatology defendants to stay discovery with brief in support. (vs) |
Filing 70 MOTION by Neonatology defendants for protective order with brief in support. (vs) |
Filing 69 Certificate of service of responses to initial disclosure as to defendant Northside Hospital (vs) |
Filing 68 ANSWERS TO INITIAL DISCLOSURES by Neonatology defendants (vs) |
Filing 67 Certificate of service of third production request to plas as to defendant Neonatology Associat (vs) |
Filing 66 Certificate of service of discoery materials as to Neonatology defendants (vs) |
Filing 65 Certificate of service of discovery materials as to plaintiff (vs) |
Filing 64 Notice of request for production stmts by Neonatology Dfts. (vs) |
Filing 63 Certificate of service as to plaintiffs re: Drs. Jim Jose and Pat Spafford's First Interrogatories and Production Request to Plas, Dr. Keyes' Interrogatories Concerning Counterclaim, and Neonatology Assoc. and Dr. Wendy Troyer's Request for Admissions, Interrogatories, and Production Request to Saul M. Adler. (jdb) |
Filing 62 Notice of discovery plan by Neonatology defendants. (vs) |
Filing 61 ANSWER by Adler Neonatology Gr, Madeleine del Portillo, Saul M. Adler to counterclaim [57-2] (redacted paragraphs 3-14 and 18 FILED UNDER SEAL). (vs) |
Filing 60 ANSWER by Adler Neonatology Gr, Madeleine del Portillo, Saul M. Adler to counterclaim [58-2] . (vs) |
Filing 59 ANSWER by Northside Hospital to second amended complaint [56-1] and COUNTERCLAIM against Adler Neonatology Gr, Madeleine del Portillo, Saul M. Adler (vs) |
Filing 58 ANSWER to Second Amended Cmp by Neonatology Associat, James Jose, William Keyes, Kenneth Kupke, Margaret Moore, Patrick Spafford, Wendy Troyer to complaint [56-1] and Compulsory COUNTERCLAIM against Adler Neonatology Gr, Madeleine del Portillo, Saul M. Adler (ORIGNAL FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) Modified on 04/30/2004 |
Filing 57 ANSWER by Northside Hospital to Second Amended complaint [56-1] and COUNTERCLAIM against Adler Neonatology Gr, Madeleine del Portillo, Saul M. Adler Discovery ends 9/27/04 (FILED UNDER SEAL) (vs) Modified on 04/30/2004 |
Filing 56 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT by plaintiff; jury demand (redacted portions filed under seal) (vs) |
![]() |
Filing 54 TRANSCRIPT filed RE: for dates of March 23, 2004 Court Reporter: Therese J. Vesel, R.D.R. (kac) |
Steno notes of proceedings held 03/23/04 before Judge Clarence Cooper , by Court Reporter Therese Vesel. (ldp) |
Filing 53 Redacted portions of original 5/22/03, cmp by plaintiff filed under seal pursuant to Order dated 3/22/04. (vs) |
Filing 52 REDACTED COMPLAINT (original filed 5/22/03), filed with redacted portions filed under seal pursuant to Order dated 3/22/04. (vs) Modified on 04/14/2004 |
Filing 51 AMENDED COMPLAINT by plaintiff ( non-redacted original filed under seal ) (vs) |
![]() |
Filing 49 Stipulation that pla may file an amended cmp by 4/13/04; dft may answer or otherwise respond to amended cmp by 4/30/04. (to CC) (vs) |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Filing 46 Motion HEARING held before Judge Clarence Cooper [13-1] motion to dismiss counts I, II, and XIII of the complaint. Court entered order. (vs) |
![]() |
Filing 43 Supplemental Brief by defendant Northside Hospital re motions to seal and public rights of acress to confidential information. (vs) |
Filing 42 Supplemental Memo by plaintiff regarding public access to court files. (vs) |
SUBMITTED to Judge Clarence Cooper on [12-1] motion to dismiss antitrust claims in first and second causes of action, [34-1] response, [39-1] reply brief (vs) |
![]() |
Filing 40 Reply brief to [12-1] motion to dismiss antitrust claims in first and second causes of action by defendant Neonatology Associat . (vs) |
Filing 39 Reply brief to [13-1] motion to dismiss counts I, II, and XIII of the complaint by defendant Northside Hospital . (vs) |
SUBMITTED to Judge Clarence Cooper on [20-1] motion to adopt Northside Hospital's motion to dismiss counts I and II of the complaint and response thereto, [14-1] motion for oral argument, [13-1] motion to dismiss counts I, II, and XIII of the complaint, [11-1] motion to strike peer review material information contained within [1-1] complaint, [10-1] motion for an order permitting pleadings and evidence containing confidential peer review information to be filed under seal, [9-1] motion to file certain portions of the complaint herein under seal, [7-1] motion to strike portions of [1-1] complaint, and [7-2] motion to dismiss the complaint with leave to replead pursuant to Rule 15(a). (FILE IN CHAMBERS) (slc) |
Filing 38 CONSENT MOTION to extend time thru 08/15/03 within which defendants may file reply briefs to [12-1] motion to dismiss antitrust claims in first and second causes of action . (to CC) (slc) |
Filing 37 Memorandum by plaintiffs in opposition to [13-1] motion to dismiss counts I, and II, of the complaint. (slc) |
Filing 36 Reply brief in support of [10-1] motion for an order permitting pleadings and evidence containing confidential peer review information to be filed under seal and in support of [9-1] motion to file certain portions of the complaint herein under seal by defendant Northside Hospital. (slc) |
![]() |
Filing 34 Memorandum of law by plaintiffs in response to [12-1] motion to dismiss antitrust claims in first and second causes of action. (slc) |
Filing 33 AMENDED Certificate of interested persons. (to judge) (slc) |
Filing 32 AMENDED Preliminary Report and Discovery Schedule. (to judge) (slc) |
![]() |
Filing 30 Certificate of interested persons by plaintiff and defendant Northside Hospital. (to judge) (slc) |
Filing 29 Preliminary Report and Discovery Schedule by plaintiff and defendant Northside Hospital. (to judge) (slc) |
Filing 28 Response by defendant Northside Hospital to [5-1] motion to strike averments about mediation contained within the [1-1] complaint. (slc) |
Filing 27 Reply brief in support of [11-1] motion to strike peer review material information contained within [1-1] complaint by Neonatology Associates defendants. (slc) |
Filing 26 Reply brief in support of [7-1] motion to strike portions of [1-1] complaint, or [7-2] motion to dismiss the complaint with leave to replead pursuant to Rule 15(a) by Neonatology Associates defendants. (slc) |
Filing 25 Amended MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants amending [11-1] motion to strike peer review material information contained within [1-1] complaint . (slc) |
SUBMITTED to Judge Clarence Cooper on [5-1] motion to strike averments about mediation contained within the [1-1] complaint, and [8-1] motion to dismiss the fifth cause of action. (slc) |
Filing 24 CONSOLIDATED Memorandum by plaintiffs in opposition to [11-1] motion to strike peer review material information contained within [1-1] complaint, [10-1] motion for an order permitting pleadings and evidence containing confidential peer review information to be filed under seal, and [9-1] motion to file certain portions of the complaint herein under seal. (slc) |
Filing 23 Response by Neonatology Associates defendants to [9-1] motion to file certain portions of the complaint herein under seal. (slc) |
Filing 22 Reply brief in support of [5-1] motion to strike averments about mediation contained within the [1-1] complaint by Neonatology Associates defendants. (slc) |
Filing 21 Reply brief in support of [8-1] motion to dismiss the fifth cause of action by Neonatology Associates defendants. (slc) |
Filing 20 MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants to adopt Northside Hospital's motion to dismiss counts I and II of the complaint and response thereto with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 19 Memorandum by plaintiffs in opposition to [7-1] motion to strike portions of [1-1] complaint, [7-2] motion to dismiss the complaint with leave to replead pursuant to Rule 15(a). (slc) |
Filing 18 Memorandum by plaintiff in opposition to [5-1] motion to strike averments about mediation contained within the [1-1] complaint. (slc) |
Filing 17 Memorandum by plaintiffs in opposition to [8-1] motion to dismiss the fifth cause of action. (slc) |
Filing 15 Stipulation by parties, extending time within which the parties may hold the Rule 26(f) conference for the week of July 14,2003 . (to CC) (slc) |
Filing 16 Application for admission of Michael R. Bissegger pro hac vice for defendant Neonatology Associates. (to CC) (slc) |
Filing 14 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital for oral argument with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 13 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital to dismiss counts I, II, and XIII of the complaint with brief in support. (***Brief FILED UNDER SEAL***) (slc) Modified on 07/03/2003 |
Filing 12 MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants to dismiss antitrust claims in first and second causes of action with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 11 MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants to strike peer review material information contained within [1-1] complaint with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 10 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital for an order permitting pleadings and evidence containing confidential peer review information to be filed under seal with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 9 MOTION by defendant Northside Hospital to file certain portions of the complaint herein under seal with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 8 MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants to dismiss the fifth cause of action with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 7 MOTION by Neonatology Associates defendants to strike portions of [1-1] complaint , or to dismiss the complaint with leave to replead pursuant to Rule 15(a) with brief in support. (slc) |
Filing 6 Attorney appearance for Neonatology defendants by Anthony Cochran, John Knox Larkins Jr., and John D. Dalbey. (slc) |
Filing 5 MOTION by Neonatology defendants to strike averments about mediation contained within the [1-1] complaint with brief in support. (slc) |
![]() |
Added attorneys for defendant Northside Hospital: James Clifton Rawls, Eric Schroeder, and S. Derek Bauer. (slc) |
Added attorney for defendants Neonatology Associates, James Jose, William Keyes, Kenneth Kupke, Margaret Moore, Patrick Spafford, and Wendy Troyer: Anthony L. Cochran. (slc) |
Filing 3 CONSENT MOTION to extend time thru 06/30/03 within which defendants may respond to [1-1] complaint , and to extend time thru 07/28/03 within which plaintiff may respond to any motions defendants may file under FRCP 12 . (to CC) (slc) |
Filing 2 Acknowledgment of service by defendant Northside Hospital executed 5/23/03. (slc) |
Filing 1 COMPLAINT filed and summons(es) issued. Consent form to proceed before U.S. magistrate and pretrial instructions given to attorney; jury demand FILING FEE $ 150.00 RECEIPT # 505916 (aet) |
Access additional case information on PACER
Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.
Access this case on the Georgia Northern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System
- Search for Party Aliases
- Associated Cases
- Attorneys
- Case File Location
- Case Summary
- Docket Report
- History/Documents
- Parties
- Related Transactions
- Check Status
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.