Retractable Tech v. Becton Dickinson, et al
Plaintiff: Retractable Technologies, Incorporated
Defendant: Becton Dickinson & Company, Tyco International (US), Incorporated, Tyco Healthcare Group LP, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Incorporated, Premier, Incorporated and Premier Purchasing Partners, L.P.
Petitioner: Presbyterian Hospital of Kaufman, Andrew L Guggenhime and Neoforma Incorporated
Case Number: 5:2001cv00036
Filed: January 29, 2001
Court: US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas
Presiding Judge: David Folsom
Nature of Suit: Anti-Trust
Cause of Action: 28 U.S.C. § 1331 Fed. Question: Anti-trust
Jury Demanded By: y
RSS RSS Track this Docket
Docket Report

This docket was last retrieved on December 27, 2006. A more recent docket listing may be available from PACER.

Date Filed Document Text
December 27, 2006 Opinion or Order Filing 473 ORDER granting #472 Motion for Disbursement of Funds and ORDERED that the Clerk of Court issue a check payable to Retractable Technologies in the amount of $10,000.. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 12/27/2006. (sm, )
December 19, 2006 Filing 472 MOTION for Disbursement of Funds by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Patton, Nicholas)
January 6, 2006 Shipped to FRC on 1/6/06, Accession Number 021-06-0022, Location F-28-031-1-3, Box 14 vol 1, Box15 vol 2-8, Box 16 vol 9-13, Box 17 vol 14-17 of 72. [For internal information only - case is either pending and imaged or closed.] (rml, ) Modified on 1/6/2006 (rml, ). Modified on 11/19/2008 to correct Location number(rml, ).
October 3, 2005 Opinion or Order Filing 471 ORDER granting #469 Joint Motion to Amend/Correct Protective Order. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 10/3/05. (mrm, )
October 3, 2005 Opinion or Order Filing 470 ORDER MODIFYING PROTECTIVE ORDER; granting #468 JOINT Motion to Amend/Correct Protective Order. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 10/3/05. (mrm, )
September 29, 2005 Filing 469 JOINT MOTION to Amend/Correct Unopposed Joint Motion to Modify Protective Order by Dft Becton Dickinson & Company & Pla Retractable. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Carter, William) Modified on 9/29/2005 (sm, ).
September 29, 2005 Filing 468 JOINT MOTION to Amend/Correct Unopposed Joint Motion to Modify Protective Orders by Becton Dickinson & Company, Louisiana Wholesale, Rochester Drug and JM Smith. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Carter, William) Modified on 9/29/2005 (sm, ).
September 21, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 465 ORDER MODIFYING PROTECTIVE ORDER re #461 MOTION Modify Protective Order Plaintiff's Motion for Modification of Protective Order and Emergency Motion for Further Enlargement of Protective Order and for Shortened Response Time on This Motion filed by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated; ORDERED that the Protective Order entered in this case on or about 1/31/02 is modified to add the languange contained in this order as a paragraph "B" under Section IV; IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the deadlines established in the Protective Order, as modified and enlarged by the Order Enlarging Protective Order Deadline dated 8/2/04 are hereby further enlarged up to and including 10/1/04. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 9/21/04. (mrm, )
September 14, 2004 Filing 464 Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge David Folsom : In Chambers Conference held on 9/14/2004. (mrm, )
September 9, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 463 ORDER granting #461 Motion to modify proctective order and enlarge response time ORDERING that any party opposing the motion shall file its responses within three business days from entry of order and deadlines established in protective order of 1/31/2002 are hereby enlarged. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 9/9/2004. (sm, )
September 9, 2004 Filing 462 RESPONSE to Motion re #461 MOTION Modify Protective Order Plaintiff's Motion for Modification of Protective Order and Emergency Motion for Further Enlargement of Protective Order and for Shortened Response Time on This Motion filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(Carter, William)
September 1, 2004 Filing 461 MOTION Modify Protective Order Plaintiff's Motion for Modification of Protective Order and Emergency Motion for Further Enlargement of Protective Order and for Shortened Response Time on This Motion by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order #2)(Patton, Nicholas)
August 2, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 460 ORDER granting #459 Motion to Amend/Correct, granting #459 Motion for Extension of Time to Complete Discovery ORDERING that the deadlines established in protective order of 1/31/2002 are extended for thirty days. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 8/2/2004. (sm, )
July 30, 2004 Filing 459 MOTION to Amend/Correct conflict between #52 Protective Order and subp served 7/29/04, MOTION for Extension of Time for a deadline in the court's protective order by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(rml, )
July 8, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 458 SEALED ORDER granting 457 Sealed Motion . Signed by Judge David Folsom on 7/8/2004. (sm, )
July 8, 2004 Filing 457 SEALED MOTION . (sm, )
July 2, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 456 AGREED STIPULATION of DISMISSAL AND ORDER Dismissing Case with prejudice . Signed by Judge David Folsom on 7/2/2004. (sm, )
July 1, 2004 Filing 455 SEALED SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION to exclude the expert testimony re 378 Sealed Motion by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, )
July 1, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 454 ORDER granting #451 Motion for Leave to File supplemental motion in Excess Pages . Signed by Judge David Folsom on 7/1/2004. (sm, )
June 30, 2004 Filing 453 AMENDED MOTION in Limine by Becton Dickinson & Company. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(mpv, )
June 30, 2004 Filing 452 MOTION in Limine by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(mpv, )
June 30, 2004 Filing 451 UNOPPOSED MOTION for Leave to File Excess Pages in supplemental motion to exclude the expert testimony of Donald R House by Becton Dickinson & Company. (rec'd copy) (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(mpv, )
June 29, 2004 Filing 450 EMERGENCY MOTION/APPLICATION for Order to Show Cause Re Contempt by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(mpv, )
June 29, 2004 ***NOTICE OF DOCKETING ERROR, SEALED DOCUMENT ATTACHED TO ENTRY #449 DELETED. YOU WILL BE UNABLE TO VIEW THIS DOCUMENT*** (mpv, )
June 28, 2004 Filing 449 SEALED SUPPLEMENTAL REPLY to Response to Motion re 365 Sealed Motion to exclude the testimony of Pla's expert Einer Elhauge filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (mpv, )
June 22, 2004 Filing 448 NOTICE Of Subpoena to nonparty Wadley Regional by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated (sm, )
June 21, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 447 ORDER setting further deadlines due to pretrial conference being held Jury Selection set for 7/7/2004 in Ctrm 319 (Texarkana) before Judge David Folsom and each side shall have 1 hour to question the panel. Revised Motions in limine due by 6/30/2004 and each side shall provide a minimum of 48 hrs notice to other side concerning witnesses to be called and each side shall have one hour for their opening statements.. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 6/21/2004. (sm, )
June 18, 2004 Filing 446 SEALED CROSSMOTION to Compel and Brief (SAME AS #445 - 2 Part Pleading) by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, )
June 18, 2004 Filing 445 SEALED RESPONSE to Motion re 441 SEALED MOTION to Compel filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, )
June 18, 2004 Filing 444 Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge David Folsom : Initial Pretrial Conference held on 6/18/2004. (Court Reporter Libby Crawford.) (mrm, )
June 17, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 443 ORDER granting #442 Motion shorten response time to pla motion to compel Response to Motion due by Tuesday, June 22, 2004 at noon and this matter is set for hearing on the following day at 10:00 am.. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 6/17/2004. (sm, )
June 15, 2004 Filing 442 EMERGENCY MOTION to shorten time of response to RTI Emergency motion filed 6/15/2004 by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(sm, )
June 15, 2004 Filing 441 SEALED EMERGENCY MOTION to Compel with Exhibits by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (sm, )
June 14, 2004 Filing 438 SEALED SUPPLEMENTAL REPLY to Response to Motion re 365 Sealed Motion filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, )
June 14, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 437 SEALED ORDER granting 436 Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Reply in Excess Pages . Signed by Judge David Folsom on 6/14/2004. (sm, )
June 11, 2004 Filing 439 NOTICE of court decision denying motion to exclude report of professor Elhauge in case no vc 02-4770 in California by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated (sm, )
June 10, 2004 Filing 436 SEALED Unopposed MOTION for Leave to File supplemental Reply in Excess Pages by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, ) Modified on 6/10/2004 (sm, ). (RECEIVED SEALED sup rply)
June 8, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 435 ORDER setting pretrial conference and on the occasion of this conference the following matters will be addressed (1) jury selection; (2) juror questionnaires; (3) juror notebooks and (4) other pretrial issues but not pending motions will be argued Pretrial Conference set for 6/18/2004 10:00 AM in Ctrm 319 (Texarkana) before Judge David Folsom.. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 6/8/2004. (sm, )
June 2, 2004 Filing 434 RESPONSE to Motion re #432 MOTION for Hearing filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(sm, )
May 17, 2004 Filing 433 SEALED RESPONSE to 429 Response to Motion to exclude Pla's expert by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (mpv, )
May 17, 2004 Filing 432 MOTION with brief in support for Separate Hearing on Injunction after Jury trial by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(mpv, )
May 3, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 431 ORDER granting #430 Motion for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply re 365 Sealed Motion Responses to dfts supplemental memorandum due by 5/17/2004. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 5/3/2004. (sm, )
April 29, 2004 Filing 430 UNOPPOSED MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply to dfts supplemental memorandum to motion to pr by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (Attachments: #1 Text of Proposed Order)(sm, )
April 15, 2004 Filing 429 SEALED Supplemental Memorandum RESPONSE to Motion re 365 Sealed Motion to preclude testimony of pla expert filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm, )
April 2, 2004 Filing 440 SEALED DOCUMENT (sm, )
April 1, 2004 Filing 428 SUPPLEMENTAL SUR-REPLY to Response to Motion re 378 Sealed Motion filed by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (sm, )
March 30, 2004 Filing 427 SUPPLEMENTAL NOTICE of Attorney Appearance of Gregory Casas as additional counsel by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated (sm, )
March 29, 2004 Filing 426 SEALED SUPPLEMENTAL REPLY to Response to Motion re 379 Sealed Motion filed by Becton Dickinson & Company. (sm, )
March 29, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 425 ORDER granting #423 Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Reply in support of motion for sum jgm. Signed by Judge David Folsom on 3/29/2004. (sm, )
March 29, 2004 Filing 424 SEALED MOTION by Retractable Technologies, Incorporated. (sm, )
March 29, 2004 NOTICE from Court regarding 424 SEALED MOTION - WAS DOCKETED INCORRECTLY(sm, ) Modified on 3/29/2004 (sm, ).
March 26, 2004 Filing 423 UNOPPOSED MOTION for Leave to File supplemental reply in excess of ten pages by Becton Dickinson & Company. (rec reply) (sm, )
February 27, 2004 Filing 422 NOTICE of Attorney Appearance of James Nelson, Paul Schuster and Gregory Casas of Locke Liddell & Sapp law firm by/for Retractable Technologies, Incorporated (sm, )
January 28, 2004 Filing 421 SEALED CORRECTED Supplemental response to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm by plaintiff Retractable Tech with exhibits (sm)
January 28, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 420 ORDER granting [419-1] motion UNOPPOSED SEALED MOTION by RTI for leave to file corrected supplemental response to motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) ccP attys of record 1/28/04 (sm)
January 28, 2004 Filing 419 UNOPPOSED SEALED MOTION by RTI for leave to file corrected supplemental response to motion for sum jgm (sm)
January 27, 2004 Filing 418 SEALED Supplemental response to supplemental motion to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm by plaintiff Retractable Tech without exhibits (exhibits to be filed per order #416 at a later date) (exhibits became apart of #421 the corrected supplemental response) (sm) Modified on 01/29/2004
January 27, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 417 ORDER granting [415-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file supplemental response to dfts motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/27/04 (sm)
January 27, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 416 ORDER granting [414-1] motion for leave to file exhibits to supplemental response to Becton motion for sum jgm on 1/28/04 instead of filing with supplemental response ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/27/04 (sm)
January 26, 2004 Filing 415 UNOPPOSED MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file supplemental response to dfts motion for sum jgm (rec sealed suppl response) (sm)
January 26, 2004 Filing 414 MOTION by Retractable Tech for leave to file exhibits to supplemental response to Becton motion for sum jgm on 1/28/04 instead of filing with supplemental response (sm)
January 23, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 413 ORDER granting [412-1] motion to continue trial to 7/6/04 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/23/04 (sm)
January 23, 2004 Filing 412 MOTION by Retractable Tech to continue trial (sm)
January 23, 2004 Jury trial reset at 7/6/04 before Judge David Folsom per Order #413 (sm)
January 21, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 411 ORDER that the Court hereby allots each side thirty hours to present their case which includes cross-examination, redirect and rebuttal ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/21/04 (sm)
January 16, 2004 Filing 410 JOINT Response by Retractable Tech, Becton Dickinson to [406-1] order (estimate of trial length) (sm)
January 15, 2004 Filing 409 SEALED Supplemental [379-1] motion to SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm for summary judgment by Becton Dickinson (sm)
January 14, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 408 ORDER that dft is ordered to submit the amended motion for sum jgm (#379) by 1/15/04 at 5:00 pm and pla is to respond (if any) by 1/26/04 at 5:00 and pla is advised that while its period for response includes the entire 10 days the Court's trial schedule will not likely permit an extension and dfts reply if any is due by 1/29/04 at 5:00 pm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/14/04 (sm)
January 13, 2004 Filing 407 Transcript of dispositive motions held on 12/11/03 filed . Court Reporter: Libby Crawford ( 76 pages) (sm)
January 6, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 406 ORDER that each side submit an estimate of time required to present their cases including cross examination, redirect and rebuttal to court no later than 1/16/04 at 5:00 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/6/04 (sm)
January 5, 2004 Opinion or Order Filing 405 EX PARTE ORDER granting [403-1] motion SEALED MOTION by pla ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: Finance and Attys of pla 1/6/04 (sm) Modified on 01/06/2004
January 5, 2004 Filing 404 Notice of AMENDED disclosure by Retractable Tech (sm)
December 31, 2003 Filing 403 SEALED MOTION by pla (sm)
December 22, 2003 Filing 402 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to additional evidence of pla in response to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm (sm)
December 22, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 401 SEALED ORDER granting [400-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exceed the page limit to file reply to motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 12/22/03 (sm)
December 19, 2003 Filing 400 SEALED MOTION by Becton to exceed the page limit to file reply to motion for sum jgm (rec sealed reply) (sm)
December 15, 2003 Filing 399 Notice of disclosure of providing deposition designations, motion in limine and exhibit list to dfts by Retractable Tech (sm)
December 12, 2003 Filing 398 Minutes Re: hearing on [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm, [378-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House, [365-1] SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge, [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David by Judge David Folsom on 12/11/03 (Ct rep/ECRO: Libby Crawford) (mrm)
December 11, 2003 Filing 397 SEALED Supplemental response to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm by plaintiff Retractable Tech (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
December 3, 2003 Filing 396 SEALED SUR-Reply by Retractable Tech to dfts reply to response to [378-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
December 1, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 395 ORDER that hearing on dispositive motions and daubert challenges presently set for 12/3/03 at 1:30 pm are rescheduled for 12/11/03 at 10:00 and each side has one hour for argument , Motion hearing set for 10:00 12/11/03 for [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm, [378-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House, [365-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge, [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 12/1/03 (sm)
November 25, 2003 Filing 394 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm with exhibits (sm)
November 25, 2003 Filing 393 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [378-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House (sm)
November 25, 2003 Filing 392 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman (sm)
November 25, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 391 SEALED ORDER granting [388-1] motion SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION to exceed page limit to file reply to pla response to motion to exclude portions of expert testimony of David Egliman ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/25/03 (sm)
November 25, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 390 SEALED ORDER granting [387-1] motion SEALED MOTION to exceed page limit to file a reply to motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/25/03 (sm) Modified on 11/25/2003
November 25, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 389 SEALED ORDER granting [386-1] motion SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION by Becton to exceed page limit to file reply to motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/25/03 (sm)
November 24, 2003 Filing 388 SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION to exceed page limit to file reply to pla response to motion to exclude portions of expert testimony of David Egliman (rec reply) (sm)
November 24, 2003 Filing 387 SEALED MOTION to exceed page limit to file a reply to motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House (rec reply) (sm)
November 24, 2003 Filing 386 SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION by Becton to exceed page limit to file reply to motion for sum jgm (rec reply) (sm) Modified on 11/24/2003
November 24, 2003 Filing 385 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [365-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
November 24, 2003 Filing 384 SEALED Response by Retractable Tech to [378-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House (FILED UNDER SEAL) with exhibit A (sm)
November 24, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 383 ORDER granting [374-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file response to dfts motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/24/03 (sm)
November 20, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 382 ORDER granting [381-1] motion to withdraw [364-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the expert testimony of Manuel Velasquez ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 11/20/03 (mpv)
November 19, 2003 Filing 381 UNOPPOSED MOTION by Becton Dickinson to withdraw [364-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the expert testimony of Manuel Velasquez (sm)
November 10, 2003 Filing 380 SEALED Response by Retractable Tech to [379-1] motion SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm (sm)
November 10, 2003 Filing 379 SEALED MOTION and Brief by Becton for sum jgm with 3 volumes of exhibits (sm)
November 10, 2003 Filing 378 SEALED MOTION by Dft Beccton to exclude the expert testimony of Donald House with Exhibits (sm)
November 10, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 377 ORDER granting [367-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file motion to exclude Donald House, granting [361-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file a motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/10/03 (sm)
November 7, 2003 Filing 376 SEALED Response by Retractable Tech to [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman WITH EXHIBITS (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
November 7, 2003 Filing 375 SEALED Response by Retractable Tech to [365-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge (FILED UNDER SEAL) with exhibits (sm) Modified on 11/07/2003
November 7, 2003 Filing 374 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file response to dfts motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House (rec response) (sm)
November 6, 2003 Filing 373 Fax noticing receipt of document # 372 to attorney Stuart M Reynolds Jr for movant Neoforma Inc., Joseph J Frank for defendant Becton Dickinson, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 11/5/03 varied times. (mrm)
November 5, 2003 Filing 372 Notice of Hearing: Motion hearing on Dispositive motions and any Daubert Challenges, reset for 1:30 12/3/03 for [365-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge, reset for 1:30 12/3/03 for [364-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the expert testimony of Manuel Velasquez, reset for 1:30 12/3/03 for [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman sent to pty attys of record (mrm)
October 27, 2003 Filing 371 Certificate of Designation of Witness list filed by Becton Dickinson (sm)
October 24, 2003 Filing 370 AMENDED Trial Witness list filed by Retractable Tech (sm)
October 15, 2003 Filing 369 Fax noticing receipt of Order #368 to attorney Stuart M Reynolds Jr for movant Neoforma Inc., David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 10/15/03 various times. (mpv)
October 14, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 368 ORDER resetting hearing on Dispositive Motions and any Daubert Challenges , Motion hearing reset for 10:00 11/25/03 for [365-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge, reset for 11/25/03 for [364-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the expert testimony of Manuel Velasquez, reset for 10:00 11/25/03 for [363-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 10/15/03 (mpv)
October 8, 2003 Filing 367 MOTION by Becton Dickinson to exceed page limitation to file motion to exclude Donald House (rec sealed motion) (sm)
October 8, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 366 ORDER granting [362-1] motion SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION by Becton for extension of time to file motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 10/8/03 (sm)
October 6, 2003 Filing 365 SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the testimony of pla expert Einer Elhauge with exhibits (sm)
October 6, 2003 Filing 364 SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude the expert testimony of Manuel Velasquez WITHDRAWN PER ORDER #382 (sm) Modified on 11/20/2003
October 6, 2003 Filing 363 SEALED MOTION by Becton to exclude portions of the expert testimony of David Egilman with exhibits (sm)
October 6, 2003 Filing 362 SEALED UNOPPOSED MOTION by Becton for extension of time to file motion to exclude expert testimony of Donald House (sm)
October 6, 2003 Filing 361 MOTION by Becton Dickinson to exceed page limitation to file a motion for sum jgm (rec sum jgm) (sm)
September 17, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 360 SEALED ORDER granting [343-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton Dickinson to compel pla to produce documents within 20 days from date of entry of this order ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 9/18/03 FILED UNDER SEAL (sm) Modified on 09/18/2003
August 25, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 359 ORDER granting [358-1] motion to modify [355-1] order ORDERING that Dft Becton is granted up to 9/8/03 to produce the documents addressed in courts order #355 and FURTHER ORDERED that Becton will produce all documents which have been located and shall produce the Rule 30b6 witness regarding Block Teurmo, Block Terumo II and Project East for deposition ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 8/26/03 (sm)
July 29, 2003 Filing 358 MOTION by Becton Dickinson to modify [355-1] order (sm)
July 21, 2003 Filing 357 SEALED Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [343-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton Dickinson to compel pla to produce documents (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
July 14, 2003 Filing 356 SEALED Response by Retractable Tech to [343-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Becton Dickinson to compel pla to produce documents (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
July 9, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 355 ORDER granting [234-1] motion SEALED MOTION by pla to compel deposition testimony against dft Becton ORDERING that dft produce within 30 days of entry of this order documents and one 30bwitness to the extent it has not already done so ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 7/9/03 (sm)
July 9, 2003 Filing 354 Application by Becton Dickinson for Joseph J Frank to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
July 9, 2003 Terminated document #331 per #333 order (sm)
July 9, 2003 PHV Filing Fee paid by atty Joseph Frank; PHV FILING FEE $25.00 RECEIPT # 78701 (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 353 Application by Becton Dickinson for Steven Herzog to be admitted pro hace vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 352 Application by Becton Dickinson for Sidney Rosdeitcher to be admitted pro hace vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 351 Application by Becton Dickinson for Christopher Giampapa to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 350 Application by Becton Dickinson for Patricia Ronan to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 349 Application by Becton Dickinson for Catherine Montjar to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 348 Application by Becton Dickinson for Jennifer Lyons to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 347 Application by Becton Dickinson for Eric Stone to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 346 Application by Becton Dickinson for Jacqueline Rubin to be admitted pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 345 Application by Becton Dickinson for Robert Atkins appearing pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 Filing 344 Application by Becton Dickinson for Leslie G. Fagen appearing pro hac vice (sm)
June 27, 2003 PHV Filing Fee paid by atty Herzog, Rosdeitcher, Giampapa, Ronan, Lyons, Rubin, Stone, Montjar, Atkins, Fagen; PHV FILING FEE $ 25.00 ea ($250.00) RECEIPT # 98688 (sm)
June 24, 2003 Filing 343 SEALED MOTION by Becton Dickinson to compel pla to produce documents (sm)
June 3, 2003 Filing 342 Designation of expert witnesses filed by defendant Becton Dickinson (rml)
June 3, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 341 SEALED ORDER granting [340-1] motion SEALED MOTION ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) (rml)
June 2, 2003 Filing 340 SEALED MOTION (rml)
May 27, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 339 SEALED DOCUMENT (ORDER signed by Judge Folsom) (sm)
May 22, 2003 Filing 338 SEALED DOCUMENT (sm)
May 13, 2003 Filing 337 SEALED DOCUMENT (signed by Judge Folsom) (sm)
May 13, 2003 Filing 336 SEALED DOCUMENT (sm)
May 7, 2003 Filing 335 SEALED DOCUMENT (signed by Judge Folsom) (sm)
May 7, 2003 Filing 334 SEALED DOCUMENT (sm)
May 6, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 333 THIRD AMENDED Docket Control Order resetting Identify trial witnesses by 10/24/03 for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech Expert witness list by 6/2/03 for Becton Dickinson ; Deadline for filing of all motions 10/6/03 for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 1/26/04 for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Jury selection begins at 10:00 2/3/04 Jury instructions due by 1/26/04 for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Final pretrial conference at 10:00 2/2/04 for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 5/7/03 (sm)
May 2, 2003 Filing 332 Response by Retractable Tech to [331-1] motion to amend [229-1] Scheduling order (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 331 MOTION by Becton Dickinson to amend [229-1] Scheduling order (sm)
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 330 ORDER granting [329-1] motion SEALED MOTION by Pla and Premier ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record and Finance 4/29/03 (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 329 SEALED MOTION by Pla and Premier (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 328 SEALED DOCUMENT by pla and dft Premier Inc and Premier Purchasing (sm)
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 327 ORDER granting [326-1] dismiss/dismissal stipulation, dismissing party defendant Premier Purchasing, defendant Premier, Inc with prejudice ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 4/29/03 FILED UNDER SEAL (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 326 JOINT Stipulation of dismissal between pla and Dft Premier Inca and Premier Purchasing (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 325 ORDER granting [324-1] motion SEALED MOTION by pla and Dft VHA ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record, Finance Div 4/29/03 (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 324 SEALED MOTION by pla and Dft VHA (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 323 SEALED DOCUMENT by pla and dft VHA and Novation) (sm) Modified on 04/29/2003
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 322 ORDER granting [321-1] dismiss/dismissal stipulation, dismissing party defendant VHA, Inc., defendant Novation, L.L.C. with prejudice ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) FILED UNDER SEAL cc: attys of record 4/29/03 (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 321 JOINT Stipulation of dismissal between pla and Dfts Novation and VHA (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 320 SEALED DOCUMENT by pla and dft Tyco Intl and TYco Healthcare(sm) Modified on 04/29/2003
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 319 STIPULATED ORDER granting [318-1] dismiss/dismissal stipulation, dismissing party defendant Tyco Healthcare, defendant Tyco Intl with prejudice ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) FILED UNDER SEAL cc: attys of record 2/29/03 (sm)
April 29, 2003 Filing 318 JOINT Stipulation of dismissal between pla and Dft Tyco (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
April 29, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 317 ORDER granting [316-1] motion JOINT SEALED MOTION by pla and Tyco ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 4/29/03 (FILED UNDER SEAL) cc: attys of record and Finance (sm) Modified on 04/29/2003
April 25, 2003 Filing 316 JOINT SEALED MOTION by pla and Tyco (sm) Modified on 04/29/2003
April 21, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 315 ORDER denying [310-1] supplemental motion to unseal court order, denying [310-2] supplemental motion for sanctions against Becton Dickinson ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 4/21/03 (sm)
April 16, 2003 Filing 314 Reply by Retractable Tech to response to [310-2] supplemental motion for sanctions against Becton Dickinson (mpv)
April 11, 2003 Filing 313 SEALED DOCUMENT (mpv)
April 10, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 312 ORDER denying AS MOOT [294-1] motion for reconsideration of [280-1] order ruling on Pla's emergency motion to compel production of documents from Premier, Inc., Premier Purchasing Partners, LP, and Dr Kirk Hanson, in light of recently obtained discovery evidence, denying [292-1] motion to compel discovery from RTI Director Michael Gruber with exhibits ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 4/10/03 (sm)
March 24, 2003 Filing 310 Supplemental [309-1] motion for reconsideration of trial date to unseal court order , and for sanctions against Becton Dickinson by Retractable Tech (mpv)
March 24, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 311 ORDER denying [309-1] motion for reconsideration of trial date and the courts February 2004 docket ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/24/03 (sm)
March 19, 2003 Filing 309 MOTION by Retractable Tech for reconsideration of trial date (sm)
March 18, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 308 ORDER granting [307-1] motion for permission to disclose trial setting and FURTHER ORDERED that dft Becton is authorized to disclose the final pretrial conference and jury selection dates by this courts order (#305) ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/18/03 (sm)
March 10, 2003 Filing 307 MOTION by Becton Dickinson for permission to disclose trial setting (sm)
March 7, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 306 ORDER that #305 order be SEALED ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/10/03 (sm)
March 6, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 305 ORDER resetting trial dates, reset pretrial conference for 10:00 2/2/04 before Judge David Folsom , reset jury selection for 2/3/04 before Judge David Folsom ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/6/03 FILED UNDER SEAL per #306 order (sm) Modified on 03/24/2003
March 3, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 304 ORDER, RE: #300 for hearing to be held 3/4/03 at 2:00 pm MARSHALL, TX and the court directs the parties and counsel previously ordered to appear in Marshall to appear in Texarkana, TX at 2:00 pm on 3/4/03 instead of Marshall ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/3/03 (sm)
February 27, 2003 Filing 303 SEALED DOCUMENT (Transcript) (sm)
February 26, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 302 ORDER that Dkt Nos 299, 300 and 301 be SEALED ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 2/26/03 (sm)
February 26, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 301 ORDER denying WITHOUT PREJUDICE subject to refiling in the event settlemetn negotiations do not produce a final agreement [202-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Tyco Intl and Tyco Healthcare, denying [201-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of VHA Inc, denying [200-1] motion to strike Affirmative Defenses of Novation, denying [199-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Premier Inc and Premier Purchasing, denying [198-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Becton Dickinson & Co ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 2/26/03 (FILED UNDER SEAL per #302) (sm) Modified on 02/26/2003
February 26, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 300 ORDER for counsel for RTI and Becton to appear before court in Marshall at 2:00 pm on 3/4/03, for hearing ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 2/26/03 (FILED UNDER SEAL PER #302) (sm) Modified on 03/03/2003
February 26, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 299 ORDER denying without prejudice subject to refiling if parties do not conclude settlement negotiations with an agreement [273-1] motion for partial summary judgment , denying [57-1] motion for summary judgment (reentered on docket per #247 order vacating #166 order) ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 2/26/03 (FILED UNDER SEAL PER #302) (sm) Modified on 02/26/2003
February 20, 2003 Filing 298 SEALED DOCUMENT minutes hearing held on 2/20/03 (mrm)
February 20, 2003 Filing 297 SEALED DOCUMENT (Transcript) (sm)
February 18, 2003 Filing 296 Trial Witness list filed by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. (mpv)
February 18, 2003 Filing 295 Trial Witness list filed by Retractable Tech (mpv)
February 18, 2003 Filing 294 Emergency MOTION by Retractable Tech for reconsideration of [280-1] order ruling on Pla's emergency motion to compel production of documents from Premier, Inc., Premier Purchasing Partners, LP, and Dr Kirk Hanson, in light of recently obtained discovery evidence (mpv)
February 18, 2003 Filing 293 Witness list filed by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (mrm)
February 13, 2003 Filing 292 MOTION by Novation, L.L.C. to compel discovery from RTI Director Michael Gruber with exhibits (sm)
February 10, 2003 Filing 291 Notice of service of first amended designation of experts by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (sm)
February 7, 2003 Filing 290 Minutes Re: Hearing by Judge David Folsom - sealed (Ct rep/ECRO: Libby Crawford) (rml)
February 7, 2003 Filing 289 Expert Witness list filed by VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc (sm)
January 31, 2003 Filing 288 Answer to pla third amended complaint by Becton Dickinson (sm) Modified on 02/05/2003
January 30, 2003 Filing 287 Reply by VHA, Inc. to response to [273-1] motion for partial summary judgment with exhibits and declarations (exh and declarations not scanned due to voluminus) (sm)
January 30, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 286 ORDER granting [285-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file reply in support of motion ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) (rml)
January 29, 2003 Filing 285 MOTION by VHA, Inc. to exceed page limitation to file reply in support of motion (rec reply) (sm)
January 24, 2003 Filing 284 Answer to Third Amended Complaint by Novation, L.L.C. (mpv)
January 24, 2003 Filing 283 Answer to Third Amended Complaint by VHA, Inc. (mpv)
January 24, 2003 Filing 282 Answer to Third Amended Complaint by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (mpv)
January 24, 2003 Filing 281 Answer to Third Amended Complaint by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (mpv)
January 23, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 280 ORDER granting in part (requests 7,14, & 15), denying in part (requests 9, 11, 10, 12, 13 & 8) [265-1] motion to compel production of documents from Premier, Premier Purchasing and Dr Kirk Hanson with exhibits ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) (mpv)
January 21, 2003 Filing 279 Response by Retractable Tech to [273-1] motion for partial summary judgment with exhibits (exhibits not scanned due to voluminus) (sm)
January 21, 2003 Filing 278 Notice of serving disclosure of expert witnesses and expert reports to dfts by Retractable Tech (sm)
January 17, 2003 Filing 277 THIRD Amended complaint by Retractable Tech , (Answer due 1/27/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson ) amending [50-1] amended complaint (sm)
January 15, 2003 Opinion or Order Filing 276 ORDER granting [275-1] motion to extend time to respond to VHA motion for partial sum jgm, Response to motion reset to 1/21/03 for [273-1] motion for partial summary judgment ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/15/03 (sm)
January 15, 2003 Filing 275 AGREED MOTION by Retractable Tech to extend time to respond to VHA motion for partial sum jgm (sm)
January 9, 2003 Filing 274 Notice of supplemental disclosure by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (sm)
December 27, 2002 Filing 273 MOTION and memorandum of law by VHA, Inc. for partial summary judgment with exhibits and declarations (exh and declarations not scanned due to voluminus) (sm)
December 18, 2002 Filing 272 Response by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to [265-1] motion to compel production of documents from Premier, Premier Purchasing and Dr Kirk Hanson with exhibits (sm)
December 17, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 271 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [254-1] motion to compel complaint documents against dft Becton ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/17/02 (sm)
December 17, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 270 ORDER denying [261-1] motion for protective order, granting [257-1] motion to compel discovery ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/17/02 (sm)
December 16, 2002 Filing 269 Notice of amended disclosure by Becton Dickinson (sm)
December 16, 2002 Filing 268 Response by Becton Dickinson to [254-1] motion to compel complaint documents against dft Becton (sm)
December 16, 2002 Terminated document #214 per #259 (sm)
December 13, 2002 Filing 267 Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [257-1] motion to compel discovery (sm)
December 13, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 266 ORDER granting [264-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file reply to motion to compel ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 12/13/02 (sm)
December 12, 2002 Filing 265 EMERGENCY MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel production of documents from Premier, Premier Purchasing and Dr Kirk Hanson with exhibits (sm)
December 11, 2002 Filing 264 MOTION by Becton Dickinson to exceed page limitation to file reply to motion to compel (rec reply) (sm)
December 11, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 263 ORDER denying [230-1] motion to compel VHA & Novation LLC to produce ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/11/02 (rml)
December 9, 2002 Filing 262 Reply/SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE BRIEF by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to response to [57-1] motion for summary judgment (reentered on docket per #247 order vacating #166 order) (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm)
December 6, 2002 Filing 261 CROSSMOTION by Retractable Tech for protective order (sm)
December 6, 2002 Filing 261 Response by Retractable Tech to [257-1] motion to compel discovery (sm)
December 6, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 260 ORDER denying without prejudice [172-1] motion for protective order to prevent RTI from taking depositions of eleven Novation employees and from obtaining related document discovery ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/6/02 (sm)
December 5, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 259 ORDER denying WITHOUT PREJUDICE to REFILING in the event RTI seeks discovery from Guggenhime and Neoforma [213-1] motion for protective order, denying [213-2] motion to quash ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/6/02 (sm)
December 2, 2002 Filing 258 SUPPLEMENTAL Response by Retractable Tech to [57-1] RENEWED motion for summary judgment (reentered on docket per #247 order vacating #166 order) (FILED UNDER SEAL) (sm) Modified on 12/10/2002
December 2, 2002 Filing 257 EMERGENCY MOTION by Becton Dickinson to compel discovery (sm)
December 2, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 256 ORDER granting [251-1] motion To increase the time allowed for dfts depositions and FURTHER ORDERED that expert witnesses are exempted from overall time limit for dft depositions and dfts may examine each of pal expert witnesses for a total of 14 hours and that the overall time limit for dft depositions of fact witnesses is extended by 125 hours ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline Craven ) cc: attys of record 12/3/02 (sm)
November 27, 2002 Filing 255 Reply by Novation, L.L.C. to response to [251-1] motion To increase the time allowed for dfts depositions (sm)
November 27, 2002 Filing 254 EMERGENCY MOTION to Compel by Retractable Tech to compel complaint documents against dft Becton (sm)
November 27, 2002 Filing 253 Request for hearing by Retractable Tech on motion (sm)
November 25, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 252 ORDER granting request for expedited consideration to shorten response time and reset deadline for pla to respond , Response to motion reset to 1:00 11/26/02 for [251-1] motion To increase the time allowed for dfts depositions ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 11/25/02 (sm)
November 21, 2002 Filing 251 EMERGENCY MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. To increase the time allowed for dfts depositions (sm) Modified on 11/25/2002
November 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 250 ORDER denying AS MOOT [204-1] motion for protective order regarding deposition discovery on Becton's strategy with respect to Med-Design technology or med-design's profit projections, granting in part, denying in part [190-1] motion to compel against Dft Becton Dickinson & Company and FURTHER ORDERING that Becton supplement its privilege log with Bates numbers within 20 days from date of entry of this order ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 11/21/02 (sm) Modified on 11/25/2002
November 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 249 ORDER denying AS MOOT [236-1] motion for reconsideration/clarification of discovery orders, denying [236-2] motion and/or to compel production against dft Becton with exhibits, granting in part, denying in part [235-1] motion to compel pla to produce documents on the issues identified in court's September 19th order and ORDERING that Novation shall notify the court in writing of the status of motion for a protective order (#172) within 10 days from date of entry of this order and FURTHER ORDERED that RTI shall notify court in writing of status of nonparties Andrew Guggenhime and Neoforma's motion for protective order (#213) within ten days from date of entry of this order ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 11/20/02 (sm) Modified on 11/25/2002
November 19, 2002 Filing 248 Notice of amended disclosure by Retractable Tech (sm) Modified on 11/25/2002
November 19, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 247 ORDER, vacating [166-1] order in part and specifically vacates the order only to the extent it addressed dfts motion for sum jgm #57-2 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/20/02 (sm)
November 18, 2002 Filing 246 Reply by Retractable Tech to response to [234-1] motion SEALED MOTION by pla to compel deposition testimony against dft Becton (sm)
November 15, 2002 Filing 245 Notice of disclosure/discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
November 15, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 244 ORDER granting [243-1] motion requesting court to rule on merits of Tyco's motion for summary judgment ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 11/18/02 (sm)
November 13, 2002 Filing 243 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare requesting court to rule on merits of Tyco's motion for summary judgment (sealed)
November 12, 2002 Filing 242 Response by Becton Dickinson to [234-1] motion SEALED MOTION by pla to compel deposition testimony against dft Becton (mpv)
November 5, 2002 Filing 241 Response by Novation, L.L.C. to [236-1] motion for reconsideration/clarification of discovery orders (sm)
November 5, 2002 Filing 240 Response Opposition by Becton Dickinson to [236-1] motion for reconsideration/clarification of discovery orders (sm)
November 5, 2002 Filing 239 Response by Retractable Tech to [235-1] motion to compel pla to produce documents on the issues identified in court's September 19th order (sm)
November 4, 2002 Filing 238 Response by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to [236-1] motion for reconsideration/clarification of discovery orders, [236-2] motion and/or to compel production against dft Becton with exhibits (sm)
November 1, 2002 Filing 237 Response by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to [230-1] motion to compel VHA & Novation LLC to produce with exhibits (sm)
October 30, 2002 Filing 236 MOTION by Retractable Tech for reconsideration/clarification of discovery orders , and/or to compel production against dft Becton with exhibits (sm) Modified on 10/31/2002
October 30, 2002 Filing 235 MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to compel pla to produce documents on the issues identified in court's September 19th order (sm)
October 25, 2002 Filing 234 SEALED MOTION by pla to compel deposition testimony against dft Becton (sm) Modified on 10/25/2002
October 24, 2002 Filing 233 Letter from Becton Dickinson to court (sm)
October 23, 2002 Filing 232 Letter Brief from Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. (RE: Hearing) (sm)
October 22, 2002 Terminated document #112 per judge's instructions (sm)
October 21, 2002 Filing 231 Letter from Retractable Tech concerning hearing (sm)
October 18, 2002 Filing 230 Motion by Retractable Tech to compel VHA & Novation LLC to produce (rml)
October 15, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 229 Second Amended Docket Control Order resetting Amend pleadings by 1/17/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Identify trial witnesses by 2/18/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech Expert witness list by 2/7/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, 2/13/03 for Retractable Tech ; Deadline for filing of all motions 2/28/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 3/25/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Jury selection begins at 4/8/03 Jury instructions due by 3/25/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Final pretrial conference at 10:00 3/27/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech; Completion of factual discovery by 1/10/03 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 10/16/02 (sm)
October 15, 2002 Filing 228 Fax noticing receipt of #227 to attorney Stuart M Reynolds Jr for movant Neoforma Inc., Scott William MacLaren for movant Presbyterian Hosp., James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Gary A Winters for defendant VHA, Inc., Robert E Bloch for defendant VHA, Inc., Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech, John M O'Quinn for plaintiff Retractable Tech, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 10/15/02 10:03. (lf)
October 15, 2002 Filing 227 Notice of Hearing re: clarification of order #193 entered on 08/23/02 and order #211 entered on 09/19/02 set for 10/24/02 at 1:30 p.m. before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven (cc: attys of record) (lf)
October 11, 2002 Filing 226 Fax noticing receipt of #225 to attorney Stuart M Reynolds Jr for movant Neoforma Inc., Scott William MacLaren for movant Presbyterian Hosp., James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Gary A Winters for defendant VHA, Inc., Robert E Bloch for defendant VHA, Inc., Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech, John M O'Quinn for plaintiff Retractable Tech, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 10/11/02 9:59. (lf)
October 11, 2002 Filing 225 Notice of Hearing: re: Order #211 and Order #219 rest for 10/24/02 at 1:30 before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven (lf)
October 9, 2002 Filing 224 Fax noticing receipt of #223 to attorney Stuart M Reynolds Jr for movant Neoforma Inc., James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech 10/09/02 16:11. (lf)
October 9, 2002 Filing 223 Notice of Hearing: re: Order #211 entered 09/19/02 and Order #193 entered 08/23/02 set before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven on Tuesday, 10/15/02 at 1:30. (cc: attys of record) (lf)
October 8, 2002 Terminated document #88 per #166 order as MOOT per law clerk (sm)
October 4, 2002 Filing 222 Response by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to [199-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Premier Inc and Premier Purchasing (sm)
October 4, 2002 Filing 221 Response by Andrew L Guggenhime, Neoforma Inc. to [214-1] motion to dismiss nonparty Guggenhime and Neoforma's motion for protective order and to quash (sm)
October 3, 2002 Filing 220 Response by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to [200-1] motion to strike Affirmative Defenses of Novation (sm)
October 3, 2002 Filing 219 Response by Becton Dickinson to [198-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Becton Dickinson & Co (sm)
October 2, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 218 ORDER granting [217-1] motion to extend time to respond to pla partial motion to strike defenses of VHA and Novation, Response to motion reset to 5:00 10/3/02 for [201-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of VHA Inc ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 10/2/02 (sm)
September 27, 2002 Filing 217 MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to extend time to respond to pla partial motion to strike defenses of VHA and Novation (sm)
September 27, 2002 Filing 216 Notice of partial withdrawal of motion to compel and Rule 30 deposition notice by Retractable Tech (sm)
September 27, 2002 Filing 215 Response by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to [202-1] motion to strike affirmative defenses of Tyco Intl and Tyco Healthcare (sm)
September 23, 2002 Filing 214 MOTION by Retractable Tech to dismiss nonparty Guggenhime and Neoforma's motion for protective order and to quash (sm)
September 23, 2002 Filing 213 MOTION by Andrew L Guggenhime, Neoforma Inc. for protective order , to quash (sm)
September 23, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 212 PROTECTIVE ORDER granting [208-1] motion for protective order regarding information produced by nonparty Portex Inc. with exhibits ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 9/24/02 (sm)
September 19, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 211 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [183-1] motion for protective order regarding deposition questions of Roni Diaz and Larry Salerno, granting in part, denying in part [173-1] motion for protective order regarding deposition questions of Roni Diaz and Larry Salerno, granting in part, denying in part [167-1] motion to compel answers to deposition questions, granting in part, denying in part [167-2] motion to produce of an unredacted document ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 9/19/02 (sm)
September 19, 2002 Filing 210 Notice of disclosure/certificate of written discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
September 18, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 209 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [196-1] motion to compel interrogatory discovery responses against Dft Becton Dickinson & Co GRANTING the portion of RTI's motion to the extent of interrogatories seeking factual bases and Becton shall supplement its answers with such factual bases within 15 days of entry of this order and DENYING to the exten Interrogatories No 8 and 11 ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 9/18/02 (sm)
September 18, 2002 Filing 208 UNOPPOSED MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. for protective order regarding information produced by nonparty Portex Inc. with exhibits (sm) Modified on 09/18/2002
September 18, 2002 Filing 207 Reply by Retractable Tech to response to [196-1] motion to compel interrogatory discovery responses against Dft Becton Dickinson & Co (sm)
September 12, 2002 Filing 205 Response/Opposition by Becton Dickinson to [196-1] motion to compel interrogatory discovery responses against Dft Becton Dickinson & Co (sm)
September 12, 2002 Filing 204 MOTION by Becton Dickinson for protective order regarding deposition discovery on Becton's strategy with respect to Med-Design technology or med-design's profit projections (sm)
September 11, 2002 Filing 203 Notice of disclosure/certificate of written discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
September 9, 2002 Filing 202 PARTIAL MOTION by Retractable Tech to strike affirmative defenses of Tyco Intl and Tyco Healthcare (sm)
September 9, 2002 Filing 201 PARTIAL MOTION by Retractable Tech to strike affirmative defenses of VHA Inc (sm)
September 9, 2002 Filing 200 PARTIAL MOTION by Retractable Tech to strike Affirmative Defenses of Novation (sm)
September 9, 2002 Filing 199 PARTIAL MOTION by Retractable Tech to strike affirmative defenses of Premier Inc and Premier Purchasing (sm)
September 9, 2002 Filing 198 PARTIAL MOTION by Retractable Tech to strike affirmative defenses of Becton Dickinson & Co (sm)
September 3, 2002 Filing 197 Reply by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to response to [172-1] motion for protective order to prevent RTI from taking depositions of eleven Novation employees and from obtaining related document discovery (sm)
August 27, 2002 Filing 196 MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel interrogatory discovery responses against Dft Becton Dickinson & Co (mpv)
August 27, 2002 Filing 195 Response/opposition by Novation, L.L.C. to [173-1] motion for protective order regarding deposition questions of Roni Diaz and Larry Salerno (mpv)
August 26, 2002 Filing 194 Response by Retractable Tech opposing [172-1] motion for protective order to prevent RTI from taking depositions of eleven Novation employees and from obtaining related document discovery (mpv)
August 23, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 193 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [164-1] motion to compel pla to produce witnesses, granting in part, denying in part [164-2] motion to produce documents ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 8/23/02 (mpv)
August 23, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 192 ORDER denying [189-1] motion for protective order, denying [189-2] motion for shortened response time, denying [189-3] motion for expedited hearing ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 8/23/02 (mpv)
August 22, 2002 Filing 191 Response by Novation, L.L.C. to [189-1] motion for protective order RE: Deposition of Double Dove (mpv)
August 21, 2002 Filing 190 MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel against Dft Becton Dickinson & Company (mpv)
August 21, 2002 Filing 189 MOTION by Retractable Tech for protective order , for shortened response time , and for expedited hearing (mpv)
August 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 188 ORDER granting in part, denying in part [178-1] motion to modify [94-1] Scheduling order, granting [176-1] motion to extend time for expert deadlines for parties for an additional 30 days from their current deadlines of 9/10/02 for Pla and 9/24/02 for Dfts up to and including 10/10/02 for Pla and 10/24/02 for Dfts and that the discovery deadline for the parties shall be extended an additional 30 days from its current deadline of 10/24/02 until 11/25/02. The Court finds good cause exists for extending the current expert report and discovery deadlines for a perios of 30 days. However, the Court declines to continue the trial setting at this time. Judge Folaom has alread moved the trial setting from 9/10/02 to 1/7/03. The Court also feels it is premature to conclude the parties cannot possibly be ready for trial in January. Accordingly, it is hereby ORDERED that the Expert Deadlines for the parties shall be extended an additional 30 days from their current deadlines of 9/10/02 and 9/24/02, respectively, to 10/10/02, and 10/24/02. It is further ORDERED that the Discovery Deadline for the parties shall be extended an additional 30 days from its current deadline of 10/24/02, to 11/25/02. All other relief requested is hereby DENIED at this time. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 8/20/02 (mpv)
August 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 187 ORDER granting [175-1] motion to shorten response time for Dfts' to file a response to Pla's motion to extend the expert and discovery deadlines to 8/23/02, denying [175-2] motion for expedited hearing ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 8/20/02 (mpv)
August 20, 2002 Filing 186 Response by Retractable Tech to [164-1] motion to compel pla to produce witnesses, [164-2] motion to produce documents (mpv)
August 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 185 ORDER granting [174-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file Pla's response to Dfts' rule 37 motion to compel witnesses for deposition and production of documents ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 8/20/02 (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 184 Response by Retractable Tech to [167-1] motion to compel answers to deposition questions, [167-2] motion to produce of an unredacted document (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 183 MOTION by Retractable Tech for protective order regarding deposition questions of Roni Diaz and Larry Salerno (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 182 Answer to second amended complaint by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 181 Answer to second amended complaint by Novation, L.L.C. (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 180 Answer to second amended complaint by VHA, Inc. (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 179 Answer to second amended complaint by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 178 Response by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to [176-1] motion to extend time for expert deadlines for parties for an additional 30 days from their current deadlines of 9/10/02 for Pla and 9/24/02 for Dfts up to and including 10/10/02 for Pla and 10/24/02 for Dfts and that the discovery deadline for the parties shall be extended an additional 30 days from its current deadline of 10/24/02 until 11/25/02 (mpv)
August 19, 2002 Filing 177 Answer to second amended complaint by Becton Dickinson (mpv)
August 16, 2002 Filing 176 MOTION by Retractable Tech to extend time for expert deadlines for parties for an additional 30 days from their current deadlines of 9/10/02 for Pla and 9/24/02 for Dfts up to and including 10/10/02 for Pla and 10/24/02 for Dfts and that the discovery deadline for the parties shall be extended an additional 30 days from its current deadline of 10/24/02 until 11/25/02 (mpv)
August 16, 2002 Filing 175 Unopposed MOTION by Retractable Tech to shorten response time for Dfts' to file a response to Pla's motion to extend the expert and discovery deadlines to 8/23/02 , and for expedited hearing (mpv)
August 16, 2002 Filing 174 Unopposed MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file Pla's response to Dfts' rule 37 motion to compel witnesses for deposition and production of documents (rec'd copy) (mpv)
August 16, 2002 Filing 173 MOTION by Retractable Tech for protective order regarding deposition questions of Roni Diaz and Larry Salerno (mpv)
August 16, 2002 Filing 172 MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. for protective order to prevent RTI from taking depositions of eleven Novation employees and from obtaining related document discovery (mpv)
August 14, 2002 Filing 171 Notice of disclosure/written discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
August 6, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 170 ORDER denying [162-1] requested, denying [162-1] motion to shorten response time to RUle 37 motion to compel (#64) and pla shall file a response to #64 motion before 8/16/02 ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 8/6/02 (sm)
August 5, 2002 Filing 169 Response by Retractable Tech to [162-1] motion to shorten response time to RUle 37 motion to compel (#64) (sm)
August 5, 2002 Filing 168 Transcript of hearing on motions held 7/18/02 filed . Court Reporter: Libby Crawford ( 68 pages) (sm)
August 2, 2002 Filing 167 MOTION and Brief by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to compel answers to deposition questions , to produce of an unredacted document (sm)
August 2, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 166 Memorandum Opinion and Order denying [57-1] motion to dismiss, denying WITHOUT PREJUDICE [57-2] motion for summary judgment, denying [54-1] motion to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint, denying [53-1] motion to dismiss second amended complaint ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 8/5/02 (sm)
August 2, 2002 Filing 165 Affidavit/Stipulation by Retractable Tech, Becton Dickinson Re: [104-1] motion to compel discovery responses against Becton (sm)
August 2, 2002 Filing 164 MOTION 37 with exhibits by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to compel pla to produce witnesses , to produce documents (exhibits not scanned) (sm) Modified on 08/02/2002
August 2, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 163 ORDER granting [161-1] motion to exceed page limitation motion to compel pla to produce witnesses for depositions ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 8/2/02 (sm)
August 2, 2002 Filing 162 Request for hearing by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp on motion to compel (#64) . (sm) Modified on 08/02/2002
August 2, 2002 Filing 161 MOTION by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to exceed page limitation motion to compel pla to produce witnesses for depositions (rec copy of motion) (sm)
August 2, 2002 Terminated document #104 and #126 due to #165 and order regarding motion to compel against Becton (sm)
August 1, 2002 Filing 160 Affidavit/STIPULATION by Retractable Tech, Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing Re: [110-1] motion to compel discovery responses against Dfts Premier, Inc. and Premier Purchasing Partners LP (sm)
August 1, 2002 Terminated document #110 per #158 order & #160 (sm)
July 31, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 159 ORDER Regarding RTI's Motion to Compel against VHA and Novation ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 7/31/02 (sm)
July 31, 2002 Terminated document #129 per #159 order filed and stipulation ( per law clerk) (sm)
July 30, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 158 ORDER Regarding RTI's Motion to Compel Against Premier, and Premier Purchasing Partners ORDERING that parties submit to Court an agreed stipulation, detailing the agreements reached on remaining issues presented in motion ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 7/30/02 (sm)
July 30, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 157 ORDER Regarding RTI's Motion to Compel against Becton Dickinson ORDERING that portions of pla motion and supplemental motion which have been discussed by Court are DENIED and parties are to submit an agreed stipulation detailing agreements reached on remaining issues ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 7/30/02 (sm)
July 29, 2002 Filing 156 Notice of disclosure/discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
July 29, 2002 Filing 155 Stipulation/Affidavit by Retractable Tech, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. Re: [129-1] motion to compel discovery responses against dfts VHA and Novation (sm)
July 25, 2002 Filing 154 Minutes regarding hotline hrg on dispute as to how much time each side is allowed when taking a 3rd pty deposition by Magistrate Judge Wendell C. Radford (bjc)
July 23, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 153 Hotline Order ORDERING that the time of the deposition be divided equally among the parties prescribed by Local Rule CV 30 and FURTHER ORDERS that the deposition of Ms. Hernandez be allowed to extend beyond 5:00 pm if necessary ( signed by Magistrate Judge Wendell C. Radford ) cc: attys of record (sm)
July 18, 2002 Filing 152 Minutes of Hearing on Motions to Compel #104, #126, #110, #112, #129 held before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven (Libby Crawford, Court Reporter) (lf)
July 18, 2002 Terminated document #86 as moot (resolved by parties) (mpv)
July 17, 2002 Filing 151 Response by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to [110-1] motion to compel discovery responses against Dfts Premier, Inc. and Premier Purchasing Partners LP (mpv)
July 17, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 150 ORDER granting [145-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file response to Pla's motion to compel discovery responses ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 7/18/02 (mpv)
July 16, 2002 Filing 206 Notice of disclosure/Certificate of Written Discovery by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
July 16, 2002 Filing 149 Response by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to [112-1] motion to compel discovery responses against Dfts Tyco International (US) and Tyco Healthcare, LP (mpv)
July 16, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 148 ORDER granting [144-1] motion to exceed page limitation Tyco's response to Pla's motion to compel ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 7/17/02 (mpv)
July 15, 2002 Filing 147 Response by Becton Dickinson to [126-1] supplemental motion to compel (mpv)
July 15, 2002 Filing 146 Response by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to [129-1] motion to compel discovery responses against dfts VHA and Novation (mpv)
July 15, 2002 Filing 145 MOTION by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to exceed page limitation to file response to Pla's motion to compel discovery responses (rec'd copy) (mpv)
July 12, 2002 Filing 144 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to exceed page limitation Tyco's response to Pla's motion to compel (rec'd copy) (mpv)
July 10, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 143 ORDER granting [132-1] motion to further extend time in which to respond to RTI's motion to compel ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) (rml)
July 10, 2002 Filing 142 Transcript of hearing on motion to dismiss and sum jgm held 6/28/02 filed . Court Reporter: Libby Crawford ( 43 pages) (sm)
July 10, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 141 ORDER granting in part[139-1] motion For Relief of order of 7/9/02 compelling production of documents, granting [139-2] motion for protective order to postpone deposition of Sherry Woodcok ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) sent to pty attys of record (mrm)
July 10, 2002 Filing 140 Response by Retractable Tech to [139-1] motion For Relief of order of 7/9/02 compelling production of documents (sm)
July 9, 2002 Filing 139 EMERGENCY MOTION by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. For Relief of order of 7/9/02 compelling production of documents , for protective order to postpone deposition of Sherry Woodcok (sm)
July 9, 2002 Filing 138 Fax noticing receipt of Order #136 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 7/9/02 various times. (mpv)
July 9, 2002 Filing 137 Fax noticing receipt of #135 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Donald M Hunt for plaintiff Retractable Tech, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Scott William MacLaren for movant Presbyterian Hosp., Nick Patton 07/09/02 13:03. (lf)
July 9, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 136 ORDER denying as "moot" [131-1] motion for hearing on pla supplemental motion to compel #130, granting [130-1] supplemental motion to compel. It is further ORDERED that Novation and/or VHA shall produce all documents responsive to the requests outlined in Pla's Supplemental motion to Compel by noon on 7/10/02. ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: faxed to pty attys of record 7/9/02 (mpv)
July 9, 2002 Filing 135 Notice of Hearing:re: Plt's Mtn to Compel #104, #126, #110, #112, #129 set before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven on July 18, 2002 at 1:30 (cc: attys of record) (lf)
July 8, 2002 Filing 134 Notice of disclosure/certificate of written discovery by Premier, Inc (mpv)
July 8, 2002 Filing 129 MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel discovery responses against dfts VHA and Novation (sm)
July 8, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 128 ORDER granting [127-1] motion to exceed page limitation motion to compel discovery responses against dft VHA and Novation ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 7/8/02 (sm)
July 5, 2002 Filing 133 Response by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to [130-1] supplemental motion to compel (sm)
July 3, 2002 Filing 132 Unopposed MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to further extend time in which to respond to RTI's motion to compel (mpv)
July 3, 2002 Filing 131 EMERGENCY MOTION by Retractable Tech for hearing on pla supplemental motion to compel #130 (sm)
July 3, 2002 Filing 130 Supplemental [129-1] motion to compel discovery responses against dfts VHA and Novation to compel by Retractable Tech (sm)
July 3, 2002 Terminated document #113 per law clerk (sm)
June 28, 2002 Filing 127 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation motion to compel discovery responses against dft VHA and Novation (rec motion) (sm)
June 28, 2002 Filing 126 Supplemental [104-1] motion to compel discovery responses against Becton with exhibits (not scanned) to compel by Retractable Tech (sm)
June 28, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 123 ORDER mooting [113-1] motion to shorten time for VHA, Inc and Novation LLP to respond to Pla's fourth request for production by 5:00 pm on 7/8/02 ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) (rml)
June 28, 2002 Filing 122 Minutes Re: hearing on [57-1] motion to dismiss, [54-1] motion to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint, [53-1] motion to dismiss second amended complaint with exhibits 1 & 2 by Judge David Folsom on 6/28/02 (Ct rep/ECRO: Libby Crawford (mrm)
June 27, 2002 Filing 125 SureReply by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to pla response to [57-2] motion for summary judgment (sm)
June 27, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 124 ORDER granting [114-1] motion for leave to file response to RTI's surreply to motion for summary judgment ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 7/1/02 (sm)
June 27, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 121 ORDER granting [120-1] motion to extend time to file a reponse to pla motion to compel ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 6/27/02 (sm)
June 25, 2002 Filing 120 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to extend time to file a reponse to pla motion to compel (sm)
June 25, 2002 Filing 117 Fax noticing receipt of #116 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 06/25/02 13:53. (lf)
June 25, 2002 Filing 116 Notice of Hearing: re: Plt's Mtn to Compel Discovery Responses Against Becton (#104); Plt's Mtn to Compel Discovery Responses Against Defendants Premier, Inc and Premier Purchasing Partners (#110); Plt's Mtn to Compel Discovery Responses Against Dfts Tyco International (US) and Tyco Healthcare, LP (#112) set for Thursday, July 18, 2002 at 1:30 before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven (cc: attys of record) (lf)
June 24, 2002 Filing 119 Reply by Retractable Tech to response to [57-2] motion for summary judgment (mpv)
June 24, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 118 ORDER granting [106-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file surreply to motion for sum jgm of Tyco ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 6/25/02 (mpv)
June 24, 2002 Filing 115 Response by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to [113-1] motion to shorten time for VHA, Inc and Novation LLP to respond to Pla's fourth request for production by 5:00 pm on 7/8/02, [113-2] motion for hearing (mpv)
June 21, 2002 Filing 114 MOTION by Tyco Intl for leave to file response to RTI's surreply to motion for summary judgment (rec'd copy) (mpv)
June 21, 2002 Filing 113 EMERGENCY MOTION by Retractable Tech to shorten time for VHA, Inc and Novation LLP to respond to Pla's fourth request for production by 5:00 pm on 7/8/02 , and for hearing (mpv)
June 20, 2002 Filing 112 MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel discovery responses against Dfts Tyco International (US) and Tyco Healthcare, LP (mpv)
June 20, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 111 ORDER granting [102-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file a motion to compel discovery responses against Tyco ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 6/21/02 (mpv)
June 19, 2002 Filing 110 MOTION with exhibits A & B (not scanned) by Retractable Tech to compel discovery responses against Dfts Premier, Inc. and Premier Purchasing Partners LP (mpv) Modified on 06/19/2002
June 19, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 109 ORDER granting [108-1] motion to exceed page limitation motion to compel against Premier, Inc and Premier Purchasing Partners, LP ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: pty attys of record 6/19/02 (mpv) Modified on 06/19/2002
June 18, 2002 Filing 108 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation motion to compel against Premier, Inc and Premier Purchasing Partners, LP (rec'd copy) (mpv)
June 17, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 107 ORDER denying AS MOOT [61-1] motion to compel discovery ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 6/17/02 (sm)
June 14, 2002 Filing 106 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file surreply to motion for sum jgm of Tyco (rec surreply) (sm)
June 14, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 105 ORDERED that all discovery matters in this case shall be REFERRED to the Honorable Caroline M. Craven for decision. ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record, CC 6/14/02 (mpv)
June 12, 2002 Filing 104 MOTION by Retractable Tech to compel discovery responses against Becton with exhibits (not scanned) (sm)
June 12, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 103 ORDER granting [101-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file motion to compel ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 6/13/02 (sm)
June 12, 2002 Filing 102 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file a motion to compel discovery responses against Tyco (rec motion) (sm)
June 11, 2002 Filing 101 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation to file motion to compel (rec motion to compel) (sm)
June 11, 2002 Filing 100 Reply by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to response to [57-2] motion for summary judgment (sm)
June 11, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 99 ORDER granting [98-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file rply to response to motion for sum jgm ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 6/11/02 (sm)
June 7, 2002 Filing 98 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to exceed page limitation to file rply to response to motion for sum jgm (rec reply) (sm)
June 4, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 97 ORDER Extending Time for Tyco to reply to RTI's response to Tyco's motion for sum jgm to 6/7/02 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 6/4/02 (sm)
May 22, 2002 Filing 96 Response by Retractable Tech to [57-2] motion for summary judgment (sm)
May 15, 2002 Filing 95 Reply by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc to response to [86-1] motion to extend time of discovery and trial deadlines (with A-G not scanned) (sm)
May 15, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 94 AMENDED Docket Control Order setting Amend pleadings by 10/8/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech (No leave to file is necessary until after this date ; Identify trial witnesses by 11/21/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, 11/6/02 for Retractable Tech Expert witness list by 9/24/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, 9/10/02 for Retractable Tech ; Deadline for filing of all motions 11/21/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 12/20/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Jury selection begins at 10:00 1/7/03 Jury instructions due by 12/20/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Final pretrial conference at 1/6/03 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 5/15/02 (sm)
May 14, 2002 Filing 93 Fax noticing receipt of #92 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 5/14/02 varied. (sm)
May 14, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 92 ORDER, Motion hearing set for 10:00 6/28/02 for [57-1] motion to dismiss, set for 10:00 6/28/02 for [57-2] motion for summary judgment, [54-1] motion to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint, [53-1] motion to dismiss second amended complaint with exhibits 1 & 2 and each side shall have 30 minutes to present its arguments to the Court ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 5/14/02 (sm)
May 10, 2002 Filing 91 Response by Retractable Tech to [86-1] motion to extend time of discovery and trial deadlines (sm)
April 29, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 90 ORDER granting [88-1] motion to continue deadline to respond to motion, Response to motion reset to 5/22/02 for [57-2] motion for summary judgment ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 4/29/02 (sm)
April 26, 2002 Filing 89 Fax noticing receipt of document # 87 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 4/26/02 varied times. (mrm)
April 26, 2002 Filing 87 Notice of Hearing: reset pretrial conference for 10:00 9/6/02 before Judge David Folsom sent to pty attys of record (mrm)
April 25, 2002 Filing 88 MOTION by Retractable Tech to continue deadline to respond to motion , Response to motion [57-2] motion for summary judgment (sm)
April 24, 2002 Filing 86 JOINT MOTION by all dfts Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to extend time of discovery and trial deadlines (with A-G not scanned) (sm)
April 11, 2002 Filing 85 Reply by Becton Dickinson to response to [54-1] motion to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint (sm)
April 11, 2002 Filing 84 Reply by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. to response to [53-1] motion to dismiss second amended complaint with exhibits 1 & 2 (sm)
April 9, 2002 Filing 83 Reply by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to response to [57-1] motion to dismiss (sm)
April 4, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 82 ORDER granting [79-1] motion to extend time for dfts to file a reply to pla response to dfts motions to dismiss up to and including 4/9/02 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 4/4/02 (mpv)
April 4, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 81 ORDER granting [74-1] supplemental motion to continue, granting [68-1] motion to continue discovery prior to sum jgm ruling Accordingly, it is therefore ORDERED, ADJUDGED, and DECREED that RTI's motion for Continuance is granted, and that RTI shall file a response, if any, to Tyco's motion for summary judgment on or before 4/26/02 ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 4/4/02 (mpv)
April 3, 2002 Tele-conference held before Magistrate Judge Harry W. McKee (er)
March 28, 2002 Filing 80 Fax noticing receipt of #78 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 03/28/02 9:05. (lf)
March 28, 2002 Filing 78 Notice of Hearing: re: Emergency Mtn by Joint Defendants to Compel Discovery (#61) set before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven on 04/05/02 at 1:30 (cc: attys of record) (lf)
March 27, 2002 Filing 79 JOINT MOTION by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to extend time for dfts to filea reply to pla response to dfts motions to dismiss (sm)
March 27, 2002 Filing 77 Response by Retractable Tech to [57-1] motion to dismiss, [54-1] motion to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint, [53-1] motion to dismiss second amended complaint with exhibits 1 & 2 (sm)
March 27, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 76 ORDER granting [75-1] motion to exceed page limitation response to motions to dismiss ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/27/02 (sm)
March 25, 2002 Filing 75 MOTION by Retractable Tech to exceed page limitation response to motions to dismiss (rec response) (sm)
March 22, 2002 Filing 74 Supplemental [68-1] motion to continue discovery prior to sum jgm ruling to continue by Retractable Tech (sm)
March 22, 2002 Filing 73 Expert Witness list filed by Tyco Intl (sm)
March 22, 2002 Filing 72 Expert Witness list filed by Becton Dickinson (sm)
March 22, 2002 Filing 71 Expert Witness list filed by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (sm)
March 22, 2002 Filing 70 Fax noticing receipt of #69 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 03/22/02 8:08. (lf)
March 22, 2002 Filing 69 Notice of Hearing on Emergency Motion by Joint Defendants to Compel Discovery (#61) rescheduled for Friday, March 29, 2002 at 1:30 before U. S. Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven (cc: Attys of record) (lf)
March 20, 2002 Filing 68 Request for expedited ruling by Retractable Tech (sm)
March 20, 2002 Filing 67 Response by Retractable Tech to [61-1] motion to compel discovery with exh A-J (not scanned) (mpv)
March 18, 2002 Filing 66 Fax noticing receipt of #64 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 3/18/02 varied times. (sm)
March 18, 2002 Filing 65 Response by Retractable Tech to [63-1] motion To shorten response time to dfts joint motion to compel discovery and for expedited hearing (sm)
March 18, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 64 ORDER granting [63-1] motion To shorten response time to dfts joint motion to compel discovery and for expedited hearing, Response to motion reset to 10:00 3/20/02 for [61-1] motion to compel discovery with exh A-J (not scanned) , Motion hearing set for 2:00 3/20/02 for [61-1] motion to compel discovery ( signed by Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 3/18/02 (sm)
March 15, 2002 Filing 63 EMERGENCY MOTION by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. To shorten response time to dfts joint motion to compel discovery and for expedited hearing (sm)
March 14, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 62 ORDER referring motion(s): [61-1] motion to compel discovery with exh A-J (not scanned) to Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/14/02 (sm)
March 8, 2002 Filing 61 EMERGENCY MOTION by joint dfts Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to compel discovery with exh A-J (not scanned) (sm)
March 8, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 60 ORDER granting [59-1] motion to exceed page limitation emergency motion to compel ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 3/8/02 (sm)
March 7, 2002 Filing 59 MOTION by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing, Presbyterian Hosp. to exceed page limitation emergency motion to compel (rec motion) (sm)
March 1, 2002 Filing 58 Expert Witness list filed by Retractable Tech (sm)
February 25, 2002 Filing 57 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare for summary judgment (reentered on docket per #247 order vacating #166 order) (sm)
February 25, 2002 Filing 57 MOTION with exhibits 1-5 (not scanned) by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to dismiss , and for summary judgment (mpv)
February 25, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 56 ORDER granting [55-1] motion to exceed page limitation to file Motion to Dismiss and motion for summary judgment ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: pty attys of record 2/26/02 (mpv)
February 22, 2002 Filing 55 MOTION by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to exceed page limitation to file Motion to Dismiss and motion for summary judgment (rec'd copy) (mpv) Modified on 02/22/2002
February 22, 2002 Filing 54 MOTION with memorandum in support by Becton Dickinson to dismiss Plaintiff's second amended complaint (mpv)
February 22, 2002 Filing 53 MOTION with memorandum in support by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to dismiss second amended complaint with exhibits 1 & 2 (mpv)
February 5, 2002 Received letter from atty Alistair B. Dawson regarding the 1/30/02 protective order informing court of an atty Beckworth who was inadvertently included as a party on the order (sm)
January 31, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 52 AGREED PROTECTIVE ORDER ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 1/31/02 (sm)
January 31, 2002 Received Agreed Protective Order and forwarded to Judge Folsom for review/signature (sm)
January 23, 2002 Opinion or Order Filing 51 ORDER granting [45-1] motion to quash subpoena, granting [45-2] motion for protective order FURTHER ORDERING that Presbyterian Hospital shall produce, within 20 days from date of entry of this order, documents responsive to those item numbers which are not the subject of Presbyterian's motion signed by Judge Caroline M. Craven ) cc: attys of record 1/23/02 (sm)
January 18, 2002 Filing 50 SECOND Amended complaint by Retractable Tech , (Answer due 1/28/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson ) amending [2-1] amended complaint (sm)
December 19, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 49 Memorandum Opinion and Order denying [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, denying [4-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, denying [6-1] motion to dismiss and FURTHER ORDERED that pla REPLEAD its complaint within 30 days of this order ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 12/20/01 (sm)
December 6, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 48 ORDER referring motion(s): [45-1] motion to quash subpoena to Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven, [45-2] motion for protective order to Magistrate Judge Caroline M. Craven ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 12/6/01 (sm)
November 15, 2001 Filing 47 Response/Objections by Retractable Tech to Dfts' joint request for permission to enter on land to inspect and for other purposes. (mpv)
November 1, 2001 Filing 46 Notice of Certificate of Written Discovery by Premier, Inc (sm)
November 1, 2001 Filing 45 MOTION by Presbyterian Hospital of Kaufman to quash subpoena , for protective order (sm)
October 5, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 43 AGREED PROTECTIVE ORDER With Respect to Documents Created by Abbott Laboratories ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record via fax per Judge Folsom (sm)
August 21, 2001 Filing 44 Transcript of mgt conf and motion to dismiss held on 8/15/01 filed . Court Reporter: Libby Crawford ( 40 pages) (sm)
August 17, 2001 Filing 42 REVISED Joint atty conference Report filed by plaintiff Retractable Tech, defendant Becton Dickinson, defendant Tyco Intl, defendant Tyco Healthcare, defendant Novation, L.L.C., defendant VHA, Inc., defendant Premier, Inc, defendant Premier Purchasing (sm)
August 15, 2001 Filing 41 Docket Control Order setting Amend pleadings by 5/7/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Identify trial witnesses by 7/16/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, 7/16/01 for Becton Dickinson, 6/28/02 for Retractable Tech Expert witness list by 3/22/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, 3/1/02 for Retractable Tech ; Deadline for filing of all motions 6/28/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Pretrial order to be submitted on or before 8/20/02 for Premier Purchasing, for Premier, Inc, for VHA, Inc., for Novation, L.L.C., for Tyco Healthcare, for Tyco Intl, for Becton Dickinson, for Retractable Tech ; Jury selection begins at 10:00 9/10/02 Jury instructions due by
August 15, 2001 Filing 40 Minutes Re: [0-0] hearing on motion to dismiss first amended complaint, [0-0] Management conference by Judge David Folsom on 8/15/01 (Ct rep/ECRO: Libby) (mrm)
August 15, 2001 Hearing held re: [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint before Judge David Folsom (mrm)
August 15, 2001 MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE held before Judge David Folsom (mrm)
August 1, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 39 ORDER rescheduling a hearing and mgt conference, reset management conference for 10:00 8/15/01 before Judge David Folsom , Motion hearing set for 10:00 8/15/01 for [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, set for 8/15/01 for held for [4-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, set for 8/15/01 for held for [6-1] motion to dismiss and each side is allotted an extra 10 minutes argument on motions to dismiss for a total of 30 each side ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 8/1/01 (sm)
July 27, 2001 Filing 38 Fax noticing receipt of Order #37 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, David J Beck for defendant Becton Dickinson, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, W Mark Lanier for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 7/27/01 15:55. (mpv)
July 27, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 37 ORDER that hrg on motions and mgt conference be RESCHEDULED and hearing will be in Texarkana and each side is allotted 20 minute arguments, reset management conference for 10:00 8/9/01 before Judge David Folsom , Motion hearing set for 10:00 8/9/01 for held for [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, set for 10:00 8/9/01 for [4-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, set for 10:00 8/9/01 for [6-1] motion to dismiss ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 7/27/01 (sm)
July 13, 2001 Filing 36 Notice of attorney appearance for Becton Dickinson by David J Beck (sm)
July 9, 2001 Filing 35 Notice of corporate disclosure by Retractable Tech (sm)
July 6, 2001 Filing 34 Notice of disclosure by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (sm)
July 5, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 33 ORDER granting [27-1] motion to reschedule management conference, reset management conference for 10:00 7/31/01 before Judge David Folsom ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 7/6/01 (sm)
July 3, 2001 Filing 32 Notice of initial disclosure by Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (mpv)
July 2, 2001 Filing 31 Notice of initial disclosure by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. (mpv)
July 2, 2001 Filing 30 Notice of initial disclosure by Becton Dickinson (mpv)
July 2, 2001 Filing 29 Joint Attorney Conference Report filed by plaintiff Retractable Tech, defendant Becton Dickinson, defendant Intl, defendant Tyco Healthcare, defendant Novation, L.L.C., defendant VHA, Inc., defendant Premier, Inc, defendant Premier Purchasing (mpv)
July 2, 2001 Filing 28 Notice of initial disclosure by Retractable Tech (mpv)
June 29, 2001 Filing 27 Unopposed MOTION by Becton Dickinson to reschedule management conference (mpv)
June 19, 2001 Filing 26 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson 6/19/01 2:01. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 25 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare 6/19/01 2:01. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 24 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing 6/19/01 2:01. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 23 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc. 6/19/01 2:02. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 22 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 6/19/01 2:02. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 21 Fax noticing receipt of document # 20 to attorney Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare 6/19/01 2:03. (mrm)
June 19, 2001 Filing 20 Notice of Hearing: Motion hearing set for 10:00 7/31/01 for [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint Sent to pty attys of record (mrm)
June 18, 2001 Filing 19 Notice of corporate disclosure by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. (sm)
June 11, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 18 ORDER granting [15-1] motion for Robert Bloch to appear pro hac vice ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 6/11/01 (sm)
June 11, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 17 ORDER granting [16-1] motion for Gary Winters to appear pro hac vice ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 6/11/01 (sm)
June 7, 2001 Filing 16 Motion by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. for Gary Winters to appear pro hac vice (sm)
June 7, 2001 Filing 15 Motion by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc. for Robert Bloch to appear pro hac vice (sm)
June 7, 2001 PHV Filing Fee paid by atty Winters and Bloch; PHV FILING FEE $ 20 RECEIPT # 95261 (sm)
June 1, 2001 Filing 14 JOINT Reply by Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl to response to [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, [6-1] motion to dismiss (sm)
June 1, 2001 Filing 13 Reply by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to response to [4-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint (sm)
May 15, 2001 Filing 12 Response by Retractable Tech to [8-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, [4-1] motion to dismiss first amended complaint, [6-1] motion to dismiss (sm)
May 10, 2001 Filing 11 Fax noticing receipt of #10 to attorney James Dennis Chambers for defendant Premier Purchasing, Winford L Dunn Jr for defendant VHA, Inc., Damon Young for defendant Tyco Healthcare, John P DeGeeter for defendant Tyco Healthcare, William David Carter Sr for defendant Becton Dickinson, John M O'Quinn for plaintiff Retractable Tech, Nicholas H Patton for plaintiff Retractable Tech 5/10/01 9:39. (sm)
May 9, 2001 Opinion or Order Filing 10 ORDER Setting Civil Actions for Rulte 16 Mgt Conf, set management conference for 10:00 7/9/01 before Judge David Folsom ( signed by Judge David Folsom ) cc: attys of record 5/10/01 (sm)
May 1, 2001 Filing 9 Notice of corporate disclosure by Becton Dickinson (sm)
May 1, 2001 Filing 8 Motion by Becton Dickinson to dismiss first amended complaint . Added attorney William David Carter Sr. (sm)
April 18, 2001 Filing 7 Notice of corporate disclosure by Premier, Inc (sm)
April 12, 2001 Filing 6 Motion by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare to dismiss . Added attorney John P DeGeeter, Damon Young. (sm)
April 12, 2001 Filing 5 Notice of corporate disclosure by Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare (sm)
April 12, 2001 Filing 4 Motion by Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing to dismiss first amended complaint . Added attorney Winford L Dunn Jr, James Dennis Chambers. (sm)
February 26, 2001 Filing 3 Return of service executed as to Novation, L.L.C. via certified mail on 2/14/01 Answer due on 3/6/01 for Novation, L.L.C. (sm)
February 15, 2001 Filing 2 First Amended complaint by Retractable Tech , amending [1-1] complaint (sm)
January 31, 2001 Summons(es) issued for Becton Dickinson, Tyco Intl, Tyco Healthcare, Novation, L.L.C., VHA, Inc., Premier, Inc, Premier Purchasing (mpv)
January 29, 2001 Filing 1 Original Complaint filed with Jury Demand. Cause: 28:1331 Fed. Question: Anti-trust (sm)
January 29, 2001 Filing Fee Paid; FILING FEE $ 150 RECEIPT # 92313 (sm)

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the Texas Eastern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

Search for this case: Retractable Tech v. Becton Dickinson, et al
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Plaintiff: Retractable Technologies, Incorporated
Represented By: Donald M Hunt
Represented By: Nicholas H Patton
Represented By: Gregory J Casas
Represented By: James R Nelson
Represented By: John M O'Quinn
Represented By: Paul Featherstone Schuster
Represented By: W Mark Lanier
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Becton Dickinson & Company
Represented By: Alistair Byrne Dawson
Represented By: William David Carter, Sr
Represented By: Catherine C Montjar
Represented By: Christopher Hyde Giampapa
Represented By: David J Beck
Represented By: Eric Alan Stone
Represented By: Jacqueline P Rubin
Represented By: Jennifer Lyons
Represented By: Joseph J Frank
Represented By: Patricia E Ronan
Represented By: Robert A Atkins
Represented By: Sidney Rosdeitcher
Represented By: Steven C Herzog
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Tyco International (US), Incorporated
Represented By: Damon Michael Young
Represented By: John P DeGeeter
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Tyco Healthcare Group LP
Represented By: Damon Michael Young
Represented By: John P DeGeeter
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Novation, L.L.C.
Represented By: Winford L Dunn, Jr
Represented By: Gary A Winters
Represented By: Robert E Bloch
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: VHA, Incorporated
Represented By: Winford L Dunn, Jr
Represented By: Gary A Winters
Represented By: Robert E Bloch
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Premier, Incorporated
Represented By: James Dennis Chambers
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Defendant: Premier Purchasing Partners, L.P.
Represented By: James Dennis Chambers
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Petitioner: Presbyterian Hospital of Kaufman
Represented By: Scott William MacLaren
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Petitioner: Andrew L Guggenhime
Represented By: Stuart M Reynolds, Jr
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]
Petitioner: Neoforma Incorporated
Represented By: Stuart M Reynolds, Jr
Search News [ Google News | Marketwatch | Wall Street Journal | Financial Times | New York Times ]
Search Finance [ Google Finance | Yahoo Finance | Hoovers | SEC Edgar Filings ]
Search Web [ Unicourt | Justia Dockets | Legal Web | Google | Bing | Yahoo | Ask ]

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?