Plaintiff:	United States of America ex rel., State of California ex rel., State of Colorado ex rel., State of Delaware ex rel., State of Florida ex rel., State of Georgia ex rel., State of Illinois ex rel., State of Indiana ex rel., State of Iowa ex rel., State of Louisiana ex rel., State of Maryland ex rel., State of Minnesota ex rel., State of Nevada ex rel., State of New Jersey ex rel., State of New Mexico ex rel., State of North Carolina ex rel., State of Oklahoma ex rel., State of Rhode Island ex rel., State of Tennessee ex rel., State of Texas ex rel., State of Virginia ex rel., State of Washington ex rel., Terri Nix, District of Columbia ex rel. and State of Louisiana Medical Assistance Programs ex rel.
Defendant:	United Biologics, LLC doing business as United Allergy Services formerly known as United Allergy Labs, United Allergy Labs, Decatur Pediatric Group, P.A., Preston Ridge Pediatric Associates, PC, Bi-County Gwinnett Pediatrics, P.C., Neil R. Nickelsen, D.O., The Columbus Clinic, P.C., Pediatric Associates of Lawrenceville, LLC, Georgia Medical Associates, P.C., Family Health Care Center, Inc., Wayne Family Practice Associates, P.C., Family Practitioners of Glynn, P.C., Internal Medicine Associates of Waycross, P.C., Peter Wrobel, M.D., Valdosta Family Medicine Associates, P.C., Blackshear Family Practice, P.C., Georgia Medical Treatment Center, North Georgia Internal Medicine, P.C., Douglas Pediatrics Associates, P.C., East Cobb Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, P.C., Kennesaw Pediatrics, P.C., Dunwoody Village Clinic, P.C., Cartersville Pediatrics Associates, P.C., North Fulton Internal Medicine Group, P.C., Pediatric Associates, P.C., Pediatric Associates of Johns Creek, P.C., North Whiteville Urgent Care and Family Practice, PA, Holly Ridge Healthcare, PA, Northside Urgent Care, Inc., ABC Pediatrics of Dunn, PA, Family Wellness Clinic, P.A., Eastover Family Care, P.C., Eastern Carolina Medical Center, P.C., Pelican Family Medicine, P.A., Palladium Primary Care, PA, Friendly Urgent Care, Inc., Caromed Inc., Carolina Family Medicine & Urgent Care, P.A., Spear Clinic, P.A., Eagle Medical Center, PC, Triad Internal Medicine Associates, P.A., Freedom Medial Clinic & Urgent Care, P.A., Anson Pediatrics, P.C., Bland Clinic, P.A., Gaffney Health Services, P.A., Immanuel Family Practice, P.A., Carolina Internal Medicine Associates, P.A., Roxboro Family Medicine & Immediate Care, P.C., NC Pediatric Associates, PLLC, Cary Family Practice & Walk-In Clinic, P.C., North State Medical Center, P.A., Holly Springs Pediatrics, PLLC, Capital Physicians Group, PA, Durham Family Medicine, PA, Medaccess Urgent Care, PLLC, Alliance Family Health Group, LLC, North Raleigh Pediatric Group, P.A., Waverly Primary Care, PLLC, Hickory Family Practice Associates, P.A., Lamond Family Medicine, PLLC, Hazelwood Family Medicine, PLLC, WNC Hypertension & Wellness Center, Family Care of Fairview, P.A., Kingsport Primary Care, P.C., Fairbrook Medical Clinic, P.A., Rainbow Pediatrics, P.A., Biltmore Family Medicine, PLLC, Piedmont Family Practice, LLC, Families First Family Medicine, PC, Eastside Medical Clinic, PA, Internal Medicine & Diagnostics Group, LLC, Gateway Family Medicine of Travelers Rest, P.A., Premier Clinics, P.A., Oaktree Medical Centre, P.C., The Family Practice, Poinsett Family Practice, Piedmont Medical of S.C., LLC, Global Family Medicine, LLC, Gaffney Family Physicians, Inc., Lakeview Urgent Care & Family Clinic, Inc., Southeastern Medical Clinic Grays Creek, Raeford Family Care Center, LLC, Allergy Clinics of North Carolina, P.C., Carolina Urgent & Family Care, P.A., Cape Fear Family Medical Care, P.A., West Primary Care, Inc., Trinity Urgent Care & Family Practice, LLC, Dillon Family Medicine, P.A., Mid State Health Associates, Inc., Prime Medical Group, P.C., Lunceford Family Health Center, P.C., Memphis Primary Care Specialists, LLC, Main Street Medical Associates, The Center for Adult Medicine, P.A., Summit Medical Arts Associates, LLC, Ear, Nose & Throat Specialists of Morristown, Heritage Family Medicine, Gigliotti Family Medicine, Stafford Medical, P.A., Woodbury Pediatrics, Sicklerville Internal Medicine, Atrium Pediatrics, Pediatric & Adult Medicine, Premier Wellness Internal Medicine, LLC, Sunset Road Medical Associates, P.A., Family Medicine Associates Williamstown, Family Medicine Associates Vineland, Cherry Hill Pediatrics, Family Medicine Mt. Laurel, Lerch & Amato Pediatrics, Medford Station, Heights Primary Care, Family Practice Associates at Washington, P.A., Berlin Medical Associates at Winslow, Aroesty ENT, White Rose Family Practice, LLC, Ear Nose Throat Associates of Central Pennsylvania, LLP, Family Practice Associates of Western PA, P.C., Internists of Central Pennsylvania, Ltd., Martha L. Moore, M.D., Genesis Medical Associates, Inc., Cura Family Medicine, P.C., Southern Cove Medical Associates, Inc., P.C., Harleysville Medical Associates, P.C., Steinbaum Levine Associates, LLC, Pediatric Arts, Aygen Pediatrics & Adult Care, Mark Kress & Associates, Montvill Practice Associates, P.A., Burwell Family Medicine, P.C., Village at Newtown Medical Center, P.C., Scotch Plains Pediatrics, Injury Care Center, LLC, Madeleine C. Weiser, Southhampton Medical Center, Family Health Associates, LLC, Rosemary A. Bates, Pediatric Healthcare Associates, P.A., Manuel Griego, Jr., Drs. Kaplan & Akins, P.A., Rockwall Pediatrics, Steven G. Bander, Larry K. Stubblefield, Patient Focus Medical Practice, P.A., Forest Lane Pediatrics, LLC, KHI Medical Solutions, Inc., Salma Mazhar, North Dallas Ent Group, P.A., Les T. Sandknop, Pediatric Associates of North Texas, McKinney Family Healthcare, LP, Frisco Urgent Care and Clinics, North Country Family Practice, P.A., Huguley Medical Associates, Joy Obokhare, MD, Mid County Medical Group, P.A., Dekalb Physicians Clinic, PLLC, Olie Garrison, MD, Ault McInnis, PLLC, Tyler Internal Med Assn, Newton Family Clinic PA, Healthcare Express, LLP, MD2 Urgentcare Clinic, Valley Medical Clinic, LLC, El Paso Pediatric Associates, PA, Westwind Pediatric Clinic, Sun City Medical Practice, PA, Cancer Radiation & Specialty Clinics of El Paso, PA, The Doctors In, Carla J. Cole, North Texas Family Practice Assoc., Vital Family Practice Center, Offices of Family Medicine, PLLC, David W. Carlson, Village Medical Center, Karen K. King, Our Family Doctor, P.A., Forest Medical Care, P.A., Priority Health Center, LLC, Mahmood B. Panjwani, All Care Family & Urgent Care Clinics, PA, Farida Valliani, Brehm Medical Center, Paul S. Worrell, Joyce M. Shotwell, Medi Clinic, Mark Heaver, Jeffrey D. Rettig, Martin G. Mcelya, Rebecca D. Butler, M.D., PLLC, Dallas Comprehensive Medical Care, PLLC, Julie L. Reihsen, George L. Eastman III, M.D. & Associates, Thompson Family Medicine, The Family Doctors, P.A., West Plano Pediatrics, P.A., Doctors of Internal Medicine, P.A., Plano Pediatrics, P.A., Piga Primary Care Associates, LLC, Precision Family Medicine, P.A., Care United Medical Centers of America, LLP, J. Gregory McCray, Akirkhan N. Daya, Family Practice Associates, LLC, Granbury Family Medclinic, P.A., Patrick W. Hisel, Dublin Family Medicine, Schmidt Medical Center, P.A., S. Howard Dickey, C. Brooks Smith, M.D. & Associates, Kare Family Clinic, P.A., D. Blayne Laws, Ellis County Medical Associates, P.A., Burroughs Medical Clinic, P.A., Emmanuel E. Sackey, Wise Family Practice, Clinics of North Texas, LLP, Radu Ciubuc, Odessa Consultants, PLLC, El Paso Oncology and Internal Medicine, P.A., Jorge Ortiz, St. Jude International Cancer Associates, Primary Healthcare Physicians, Eastside Family Care Center, Physicians Healthcare Associates, LC, Shylesh Ganta, Permian Women's Center, P.A., Family Medicine & Skin Care Center, El Paso Integrated Physicians Group, P.A., Re Medical Associates, PA, Complete Care Midland, Community Medical Clinic, Angelina Farella, NW Cypress Pediatrics and Family Medicine, PLLC, SJMC Physician Services, Occupational and Family Medicine of South Texas, Avanta Health Professionals, PA, A Brighter Tomorrow Pediatrics, Deirdre McMullen, Sugarland Med-Ped Clinic, JK Family Clinic, Pisharodi Surgicals, Inc., Oaks Family Practice Center, P.A., L. Kin Szeto, 1960 Family Practice, P.A., Clear Lake Family Physicians, PLLC, RGV Preventative Care Inc., Quantum Physicians, PA, Jacinto Medical Group, PA, Family Medical Care, P.A., John M. Young, Manon E. Childers, III, Amarillo Family Physicians Clinic, P.A., Sangtae Caleb Kim, Fletcher & O'Grady Pediatric Associates, Ricky A. Siewert, Total Care Health, PA, Panhandle Family Care, LLC, Samuel A. Hare, M.D., North Hills Family Medicine, PA, Internal Medicine Center of Fort Worth, Basanti Vrushab, M.D., PLLC, Texas Familicare Medical Group, PLLC, Durbin Family Practice, P.A., Old Town Medical Center, Bluffington Family Medicine, PLLC, Healthcare Associates of Irving, PLLC, Kathryn Pifer, Maxhealth Medical Associates, P.A., Winter Park Family Practice, LLC, The Pediatric Center, Natchitoches Medical Specialists, LLC, Gilbert Medical Center, PLLC, Seminole Medical Clinic, LLP, Urgent Care of Atoka, PC, Noel R. Williams, Aquilo Health Company, PC, Regional Family Medicine, PA, Ouachita Valley Family Clinic, PA, BHFC Warren, Southern Medical Group, LLC, Benton Family Clinic, PA, Lake Village Clinic, PA, SAMA Health Care Services, PA, Complete Family Medicine, LLC, Axtell Clinic, PA, Lakepoint Family Physicians, PA, Harrisonville Family Medicine, Inc., Lakeside Physicians Group, Arkansas Central Primary Care, PLLC doing business as Jacksonville Medical Clinic, Hillcrest Family Practice, PC, Milestone Family Medicine, PC, Nadal Pediatrics, P.A., Oklahoma City Gynecology and Obstetrics, LLC, John Doe Medical Practices, Berlin Medical Associates, Endocrinology Institute of Texas, Bill Burke, Cody L. Mihills, Ear, Nose, & Throat Care, P.A., Walter Leon, Oak Cliff Family Healthcare, PA, Pediatrics of Dallas, Dunn & Chadwick Family Medicine, Alpha Medical Center, Harry Hernandez, Toepperwein Family Practice, P.A., Tanya R. Grun, Carl Erickson, Howard H. Galarneau, Jr., David A. Ramos, Elms Creek Family & Urgent Care Clinic, Dan Freeland, San Antonio Internal Medicine Physicians, PLLC, Robert G. Bass, Jr., Pleasanton Medical Center, Ltd, Vital Life Wellness Center, Hormazd Sanjana, Aspen Creek Medical Associates, P.C., Front Range Primary Care Partners, LLC, Brim Healthcare of Colorado, LLC, Airport Clinic, Inc., Atlanta Medical and Aesthetic Center, Inc., Atlanta Ropheka Medical Center, PC, Atlanta Women's Specialty Group II, LLC, Brian C. Griner, M.D., LLC, Brian K. Nadolne, M.D., P.C., Community Care, MD, PC, Cumming Pediatric Group, P.C., DeKalb Medical Center, Inc., East Metro Internal Medicine, L.L.C., Greater Atlanta Family Healthcare, LLC, Just for Women, LLC, Life Cycle Pediatrics, LLC, New Millennium Obstetrics and Gynecology, LLC, Physicians Family Medicine of Canton, LLC, Physicians Family Medicine, LLC, Quality Medical Management Services, LLC, Real Health Medical, LLC, Rolf W. Meinhold, M.D., P.C., Shamil, P.C., Smokerise Family Medical Association, P.C., Sy Med,LLC, Urgent Care Xpress, L.L.C., Woodstock Family and Urgent Care, Deerpath Primary Care, S.C., Family Medicine Specialists, S.C., Mirshed Medical Center, S.C., Northwest Medical Associates, S.C., Robin Snead, M.D., S.C., Acadiana Family Practice Associates, LLP, Agape Ear, Nose, and Throat Clinic, APMC, Allen L. Spires, LLC, Baton Rouge General Physicians Medical Group, LLC, Baton Rouge General Physicians, Inc., Chaudhry Clinic, LLC, Billy A. May, Jr, MD APMC, Brian Granger, M.D. APMC, Mirza A. Beg, MD APMC, Yaw Twum-Antwi, M.D., Family Medicine Specialists, LLC, Family Practice Center of Sulphur, LLC, Goodwood Primary Care Clinic, LLC, Jacobs Family Medical Clinic, Inc., Joseph M. Gautreaux, III., M.D. APMC, Kelly L. Cobb, M.D., APMC, Lewis C. Cummings, M.D., APMC, Mayo Medical Clinic, Inc., Optimal Health Out-Patient Clinic, APMC, Pediatric Medical Clinic, Inc., Richard B. Feucht, II, M.D., LLC, Kevin T. Schlamp, M.D., LLC, Slidell Internal Medicine Clinic, LLC, Southern Pediatric Clinic, Inc. APMC, Varnado Family Practice, LLC, Warren J. Degatur, Jr., M.D., APMC, Youngsville Medical Clinic, LLC, Calvary Internal Medicine, PC, Cornelius F. Cathcart, Pediatrics, PA, Kernodle Clinic, Inc., Fayetteville Urgent Care and Family Medicine, PA, First Care Medical Clinic, Inc., Hope Mills Urgent Care and Medical Clinic, P.L.L.C., Physical Medicine and rehabilitation Center, PLLC, Randolph Primary Care, P.A., Randolph Pulmonary & Sleep Clinic, PLLC, Gibbons Family Medicine, P.A., Vickery Family Medicine, PLLC, Roxboro Med Access, PLLC, Southeastern Regional Physician Services, Depersia, Chernoff & Ocasio, P.C., Health Med Associates, P.C., Baker Fore Business Associates, Inc., Charles K. Jones, M.D., D Guin Johnson MD Inc, Dennis E. sandler, M.D., Family Medical and Urgent Care Center, LLC, Fountain Park Family Physicians, Integrative Medical Solutions, PLLC, Kelley Family, LLC, Lisa J. Wasemiller-Smith, M.D., Inc., Mark Oatman, M.D., P.L.L.C., McMahan Family, LLC, Midwest Medical Group, PLLC, Peter Bullock, M.D., P.C., Rodney J. Miles, M.D., Inc., South Moore Medical Clinic, PC, Southern Plains Medical Center, P.C., STATCare Clinics of Green Country, LLC, Oklahoma City Ear, Nose, & Throat Clinic, P.C., Good Health Associates, PLLC, Hamilton Pediatrics, Adam S. Miner, M.D., P.A., Alamo Area Family & Geriatric Medicine Associates, Alvear Family First, P.A., Castle Hills Family Practice, Central Texas Urgent Care, P.A., Clinic Clark Medical Center, Coppell Associates in Family Medicine, P.A., Coppell Clinic, P.A., Corpus Christi Wellness Center, David A. Ray, D.O., P.A., Jon W. Copeland, D.O., P.A., Denise M. Casper, D.O., P.A., Diamond Hill Medical Center, P.A., Doctors Clinic Houston, Doctors Clinic Houston-NW Freeway, Doctors Clinic Houston- North Freeway, Doctors Clinic Houston-Southwest Freeway, Doctors Clinic Houston-Gulf Freeway, Doctors Clinic Houston-East Freeway, Francis M. Gumbel, M.D., P.A., Dr. Mario R. Anzaldua, MD, PA, Wyatt Webb, MD, PA, Family & Senior Medical Clinic, P.A., Family Medicine and Urgent Care, Family Medicine Associates of Stephenville, Family Practice Clinic, Good Shepard Physicain Services, Inc., Gustavo E. Villarreal, M.D., P.A., Gwendolyn Allen MD PA, Jagannath LLC, Jay Chavda M.D., P.A., Jennifer Gwozdz PA, John Garcia, M.D., PA, Jose Perez Cassar MD PA, Kelsom Clinic, P.A., Laredo Family Medicine, P.A., Lawrence A. Alder, M.D., P.A., Lone Star State Dermatology Clinic, PLLC, Medstream Wellness Medical Group LLC, Norberto Alvarez Jr. MD PA, North Central Texas family Medicine, P.A., OM Sakthi, P.A., Pineloch Medical Clinic, P.A., Primary and Diagnostic Medical Centers of Texas P.C., Pulmonary Medicine & Wellness Center, Red Bird Community Health Center, LLC, Rockport Urgent Care Center, PLLC, Stephanie J. Morton, M.D., PLLC, Thomas D. Newell, PLLC, Adult Internal Medicine Sherman, Texas Health Physicians Group, AIM Mid-Cities, Arlington Medical Clinic, Arlington Premier Health Clinic, Benchmark Family Medical Center Rockwall, Benchmark Family Medicine Rowlett, Beshears Family Healthcare, Carrollton Family Physicians, Cityview Family Physicians, Cornerstone Family Sports Med, David L. Reeve, M.D. & Associates, Denton Internal Medicine Associates, Esiquiel P. Olivarez Jr., D.O., Family Centered Medical Group, Family Medical Center Southwest, Family Medicine Clinic of Sunnyvale, Forney Family Medical, Frances Dilley, M.D., Hoffman Family Practice Associates, Inova Family Physicians, Keller family Healthcare, Kids Docs, Lake Worth Family Medicine, Lakeside Family and Sports Medicine, Launey Family Medical & Surgical Group, Levy Pediatrics Lake Worth, Lewisville Family & Urgent Care, Lifetime Family Medicine, Mansfield Family Clinic, Medical Associates at Willow Park Family Medicine, Medicine Associates of Kaufman, Medicine Associates of North Texas, Paluxy Road Medical Clinic, R.K. Stahlman II, DO, Sharon Kirven, M.D., P.A., Shaw Breeze Pediatrics, Anna Burke, MD, Benbrook Family Practice, Burrows Clinic, Castle Hill Pediatrics, Cheryl Richards, DO, Steven Cohen, Complete Family Clinic, Coppell Family Medical Center, First Family Care Keller, Golden Isles Family Medicine, P.C., Grapevine FamilyPhysicians, Highlands Medical Group, Hogan Medical for Your Family, INOVA Mesquite Family Medicine, INOVA Richardson, J. Harold Acevedo, M.D., P.C. doing business as Augusta Pediatrics, Judy Yates, MD, Leading Edge Medicine, Magnolia Medical Clinic, P.C., Main Street Family Physicians, Mansfield Internal Medicine, Metro Medical, Richard P. Townsend, MD, Sound Internal Medicine, Inc., Synergy Internal Medicine, Tiena Health Frisco, Timothy McGuire, MD, Trinity Marsh Medical Clinic, Uptown Health and Wellness Center of Cedar Hill, LLC, Victory Medical & Family Care, Wee Tots Pediatrics, P.A., Western Center Family Medicine, Windermere Medical Clinic, Canton Ear Nose & Throat Clinic P.C., Chatham Savannah Medical Group, PC, D. Conrad Harper MD, LLC, Family Medicine Specialists, P.C., Intown Primary Care, P.C., Iveta Berzinch, M.D., PC doing business as Pineview Pediatrics, Milton Hall Surgical Associates, LLC, Norcross Pediatrics And Adolescent Medicine Inc., Oconee E.N.T. & Cosmetic Surgery Center, P.C., Pediatrics at Whitlock, P.C., West Augusta Pediatrics, P.C., Bridgewater Medical Group, Broomall Pediatric Associates, Ltd., Children's Healthcare Associates, LP, Clarksville Medical Group, PA, Dallam Hartley County Hospital District, Emporia Medical Associates, P.C., Forty-Third Medical Associates, P.C., Geriatric Specialities of Arizona, P.C., Grace Clinic of Lubbock, Nick Hollis, Helena Liptakova, Morristown Medical Group, NOVA Medical and Urgent Care Center, Inc., A. Reginald Pilcher, Pratt Medical Center, Ltd., Premier Immediate Care of Georgia, P.C., Primary Care Associates, Inc., Rio Grande Medical Group, Ltd., Sherwood Family Medical Center, Larry Smith, America Strader, James Strader, Alexander Paraschos, M.D. and VICTFORCE, INC. doing business as Windermere Medical Clinic
Petitioner:	Bothwell Law Group, P.C., Mike Bothwell and Bothwell Bracker P.C.
Case Number:	1:2014cv01486
Filed:	May 16, 2014
Court:	US District Court for the Northern District of Georgia
Presiding Judge:	Leigh Martin May
Nature of Suit:	Other Statutes: False Claims Act
Cause of Action:	31 U.S.C. § 3729 False Claims Act
Jury Demanded By:	Plaintiff

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the Georgia Northern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

• Search for Party Aliases
• Associated Cases
• Attorneys
• Case File Location
• Case Summary
• Docket Report
• History/Documents
• Parties
• Related Transactions
• Check Status