Plaintiff:	Roger Johnson, Richard Elliott, Adrian Lilly, Tracy Esselman, Chelsea Johnson, Alisa Wilson, Patrick Callagan, David Harris, Leona Beyer, Wayne Hatfield, Haley Warren, Doug Callahan, Ruvimbo Nyemba, Deborah Doyle, Sherry Spangenberg, Mary Zureick, Randy Brewer, Dorothy Rose, Lyndon Langford, Jeff Potts, Theresa Helton, Carla Griessman, Shannon Koehler, Edward Thiessen, Dominque Bray, Michael Brophy, JoAnn Young, Candi McKinney, Laura Batsche, Joi Crowe, Brandon Mathis, Patricia Legendre, Jimmy Allen, Edythe Bishop, Michele Keplinger, Brandon Lacinak, Kevin Haggard, Donald Mauntel, Damon Deck, Caela Finnell, Maggie Knauer, Kelly Williams, Danielle Reed, Lonnie Wheeler, Jeremy Brewer, Robert Moore, Haley Payne, Ruthie Sears, Judith Gardner, Rose Koehler, Lynne List, Vicki Buschur, Patricia Shott, Elaine Waxler, Donald Smith, Christopher McCaughey, Kevin Hartness, Carol Pummell, Janet Cornett, Kirstin Weisman, Debbie Moore, Ricky Hounchell, Barbara McClure, Steven Bayliss, Lindsey Bray, Ashley Casey, Nancy Begley, Traci Mathews, Tracy Janson, Karen Crissinger, Angelina Foster, Hiram McCauley, Dorothea Hamilton, Damian Fields, Patrick Willoughby, Anthony Bode, Joann Frazier, Sherri Lynn Allen, Brittany Theilman, Cheryl Wyatt, Delores Scott, Karen Miller, Lennie Fossett, Julie Martin, Troy Wilder, Ashley Walker, Antoinette Benjamin, Tiffany Messerschmidt, Amber Johnson, Jean Fenner, Glenna Shafer, Brenda Conley, Jennifer Myers, Sharon Howard, Holly Reifenberger, Jennifer Hickey, Marcella McDonald, Kimberly Mayer, Daniel Webber, Diane Meyer, Darrell Earls, Carolyn Dotson, Jonathan Brunner, Timothy Hannon, Carrie Crowe, Debra Henderson, Lindsey Walsh, Mackenzie Bender, Karen Taylor, Martha Kibler, Rahmann Nisbett, Greg Graber, Heather Pickett, William Moore, Timothy Marshall, Gail Nordeman, Victoria Landrum, Eddie Stallings, Elsa Ieraci, Ailene Levan, Maurice Grabow, Charlann Shepherd, Billy Wolsing, Gary Neu, Robert Runtz, Sarah Jessee, Derek List, Stefanie Deaton, Ben Thaeler, Erin Greelish, Ronald Schuster, Crystal Garrison, Jack Marcheschi, Angela Buechel, Billy Dugger, Forrest Crowe, Caidan Bailey, Joseph Schimmel, William Dabney, Connie Underwood, Mona Eder, Dawn Leeann Brown, Bryan Powers, Sara Jonas, Kenneth Conger, Kerry McNeal, Melvin James, Tonia McQueary, Ollie Deaton, Douglas Drafts, Katelyn Kauffman, Francene Cook, Cathy Holley, Frieda Aaron, Chris Ebbing, Jennifer Bookman, Denise Bess, Kaitlyn Boggs, Timothy Osborn, Vicky Wilson, Robert Masters, Jason Riley, Kathryn Howell, Kimberly Bates, Michelle Agee, Sandra Couch, Orris Smoote, Nick Benge, Tammy Jones, Ryan Handorf, Terry Beil, Gary Coots, Jacob Feltner, Richard Lozier, Emanuel Wyatt, Patrick Stephenson, Duane Pelfrey, Teresa Worley, Troy Beckelheimer, Robin Schiller, Sara Selm, Tom Meyers, Paula Wilson, Mark Reed, Brooke Vandervort, Derrill Reynolds, Brenda Errgang, Taura Halbert, Jacob Durham, Kathleen Bushelman, Staci Smith, Mary Gerbus, Kevin McDonald, Darlene Sterling, Barbara Couch, Brian Atkins, Lenora Haggard, Kameron McNeal, Tempie Stephenson, Valarie Kopp, Katherine Walls, Marjorie Newman, Dana Conley, Denise Hamilton, Donald Moore, Mike Sand, Deborah Worley, Rebekah Brady, Christine Geralds, Shamiya Ford, Jeffrey Poff, Rhonda Mains, Michael Crail, Asia Shannon, Judy Young, David Hall, Sherri Puckett-Morrissette, Helen Ward, Karen Sisson, David Snider, Robert Densler, Elizabeth Compo, Ronald Rowley, Jetton Wilson, Reba Morgan, Sierra Stratman, Jody Bauer, Priscilla Wittmeyer, Kimberly Jenkins, Sara Hauenstein, Junior Monroe, Josh Fogel, Nellie Davis, William Wolder, Karen Johnson, Jacqueline Judkins, Earl Thomas Stamps, Jr., Troy Fite, Veronica Yeakle, Amanda Koch, Crystal Pierce, Evelyn Helton, Penny Brackett, Trey Billing, Stacy John Martin, Debbie Rodriguez, Hannah Zymslo, Luke Holcomb, Jeffrey Hyde, Josh Roy, Melissa Habermehl, Vera Moffitt, Tom Lantry, Patricia Adams, Thomas Atkinson, Phyllis Bechtold, Andrew Carr, Tonya Chisman, Stephen Carmen, Jessica Hastings, Shawnda Benton, Richard Brorein, David Rohling, Robert Mounce, Teresa McMillen, Melissa Braucher, Paul Scholz, Alyssa Flatt, Arlene Fait, Clara Tubbs-Hill, Kathleen Teslcher, Patrick Schmit, Sandra Lemmel, Kristine Dority, Ryan Hensley, Laura Aker, Robert Houghton, Jr., Dawn Wingert, Dirk Hitchcock, Keith Young, Loretta Hon, Theresa Robbinson-Woods, Sandra Roundtree, Kenny Wilson, Courtney Hammons, Joy Cullins, Deon Stigall, Jr., Kathy Hersley, Karen Higginbothan, Vivian Kiefer, Terry Wilson, Lyndsey Middendorf, Robert Campbell, Chelsea Hortman, Patrick Dugan, Lisa Conley, Corrine Zachry, Jordan Vance, Sharon Brice, Antoine Powell, Joseph Davis, Alissa Hightchew, Carol Ross, Andrew Schultz, Heather Slayback, Benjamin Williams, Violet Whalen, Maurine Langford, Stephanie Mueller, Angela Pennington, Mark McMurren, Michelle Noble, Kim Underwood, James Pumpelly, Christina Brashear, Grant McKenney, Jeff Peddicord, Carla Wooten, Adam Hartman, Sandra Dennis, Cathy Beil, David Conger, Clarence Phillips, Donna Good, Francine Ford, Natasha Lainhart, Irene Hyde, Eric Courtney, Nancy Bowman, Jenna McCall, David Fisher, Jordan Ribariu, Kevin Schmit, Amanda Franks, Dana Setters, Kenneth Mahlenkamp, Samantha Hamilton, Katrina Allen, Stacy Fletcher, George Arnold, Rhonda Scott, David Huser, Dillon Jones, Paul Boggs, Tara Brown, Nicholas Battista, David Shempert, Tammy Dale, Bunnavuth Chhun, Michael Cotter, Arletta Bowling, Nicole Baker, Brandon Schoborg, Heather McCann, Dawn Merland, Alyssa Hall, Gerald Botner, Douglas Hayes, Sr., Joshua Ault, Janet Campbell, Hillary Levandofsky, Bert Stidham, Thomas Barth, Amber Work, Jason Romer, Alyssa Jackson, Kayla Burton, Stephanie Hawks, Diana Ashcraft, Minuet Healy, Paul Baker, Samantha Redrow, Deena Borchers, Sydney Jones, John Collins, Kevin Elfers, Cindy Bartlett, Gerald Hammons, Tyler McKnight, Kevin Hunley, Joetta Nafe, Laura Weisbecker, Jessica Cochran, Margie Eversole, Michelle Byar, Harry Reynolds, Kathryn Curley, Robert Wilson, Ryan Miller, Dawn Dunklin, Tammy Hughes, Ali Scully, Denise Helton, Richard Stanfield, Kyra McClendon, Michelle Beavan, Christopher Haynes, Christina Rutter, Christopher Atwood, Tim Moore, Charles Nelson, David Smith, Erma Jean Gilbert, James Cuzzort, Rachel Jones, Paul Wilson, James Albers, Larry Krech, Cory Wright, Todd Ray, Shirley Mains, Dannie Owens, Gordon Rister, Deborah Sturdivant, Brandon Webster, Michael Watkins, Adrienne Thomas, Celeste Hoffman, Billie Jane Moore, Brad Arnold, Katherine Prater, Larry Stephen Hayes, Timothy Byrd, Tammie Little, Wendy Oberlander, Jenny Grimm, Evelyn Young, Tonya Neal, Thomas Augst, Gayle Bachmann, Judy Beck, James McCain, Karen Leger, Joseph Wilder, Jack Buskirk, Karen Feltner, Denise Benge, Michael Hillard, Joe Rutter, Michelle Walters, Beth Leisring, Alex Taylor, Valerie Reeves, John Richardson, Cathleen Weber, Kelly Martin, Kim Schmit, Martha Hutton, Sherry Kidd, Margaret Radenheimer, Vicki Wallace, Brian Thien, Zachary Stacy, Brenda Shell, Stephanie Jobe, Tracey Walsh, Latoya Bradshaw, Deborah Roark, Amanda Ayres, Nancy Pfetsch, Tammy Mann, Kent Reynolds, Susan Griffin, Michael Cook, Kelly Hennessy, Sophia White, Chris Clark, Scott Daniel, Heather Schuster, Lynn Haley, Christine Goldstein, Mary Ravenscraft, Ryan Tackett, Linda Favaron, Timothy Schulze, Marsha Martin, Stephanie Moore, Sheila Pogue-Krabacher, Angela Ferrell, James Brown, Jonathan Atwell, Michael Sander, Vicky Mains, Shannon Wallace, Kimberly Luse, Misty Emerson, Michelle Sizemore, Tamala Lovette, Julie Freeman, Leslie Powers, Deborah Kidd, Lisa Reynolds, Brittany Brewer, Ron Wright, Patricia Boone, Barbara Hensley, Samantha Mink, Tiffany Meadows, Brenda Butler, Carolyn Hersong, William Benton, Jeff Remley, Ralph Dawson, George Hutchinson, Joseph Baumgardner, Timothy Whalen, Jennifer Ballinger, Sandra Radeke, Susan Schock, Laura Kathleen Kranbuhl-McKee, Ruhama Hall, Joan Jones, Carol Wilson, Robbie Gregory, Teresa Nichols, Mike Koelblin, Melissa Cotter, Jacklen Upchurch, Robert Houghton, Sr., Sarra Mueller, Charlotte King, Kelly Engle, Josh Kauffman, Michael Odulana, Doris Botner, Amy Fuller, Ryan Tanner, Todd Green, Regina Wesley, Tom Pritchard, Terry Collins, Derek Mayfield, Katie Lehmkuhl, Randall Metcalf, Chris Scheper, Rebecca Applegate, Kelly Robinson, Gloria Greene, Donna Smallwood, Rita Hounchell, Shandon Simmons, Earl Stamps, Jr., Clara Tubbs-Hills, Josh Ault, Emanuel D. Wyatt, Gary L Coots, Carolyn Hursong, Sherri Allen, Billie Moore, Emma Burlile, Katelyn Kauffman-Houston, Damion Jackson, Jacob Cotter, Kelly Jones, Patrick Calligan, Erma Gilbert, Jodi Behrendt, Debra Moore, Jared Wolfe, Kali Crowe, Emily Haynes, Sherri Cinquina-Listermann, Nodra West, Shirley Webber, Nicholas Langford, Christina Canfield, Alexandra Scully, Harold J Nordeman, Patsy Ervin, Michael Collins, Joel Blair, Douglas Hayes, Dana Edwards, Thomas Meyers, Samantha Curtis-Hamilton, Henry Curry, Martha White-Hutton, Debra Wheeler, Hobert Duane Pelfrey, Steven Schultz, Desiree Peyton, Mark Funk, Glen Botner and Joshua Kauffman
Defendant:	Marguette National Life Insurance Company, Medicaid Coventry Care Coventry Health Care, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Golden Rule Insurance (United Healthcare), AETNA Kentucky, Benovation CAI Insurance Company, Medicaid Buckeye, United Healthcare Services, Inc. (Golden Rule Ins. Co.), GEHA, Passport Health Plan, Blue Cross Blue Shield Florida, Humana Health Plan of Ohio, Inc., Medicaid Caresource, Sedgwick Claims Management Services, Inc., BCBS Illinois Health Care Service Corporation, Community Insurance Company, Blue Cross Blue Sheild New Jersey, Medicaid Passport Health PPH Ohio LLC, BCBS Minnesota BCBSM Inc, Medicaid Kenpac, Centene, BCBS North Carolina, Blue Cross Blue Shield Georgia, MEDBEN, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield Comunity Insurance Company, BCBS West Virginia Highmark, Inc., Custom Design Benefits QI Services, Indiana Comprehensive Health Insurance Association, Anthem BCBS Virginia Anthem, Inc., Kentucky Medicaid, KIGA Kentucky Life And Health Insurance Guaranty Association, Blue Cross Blue Shield Of Tennessee, Inc., Allied Insurance Company of America Corporation Service Company, Cigna Healthcare, Inc., BCBS Kentucky Anthem Insurance Co., Hartford - Disability Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc., BCBS Massachusetts, Amerigroup Corp., Liberty Banker's Life Insurance Company, Veterans Administration, BCBS Texas Health Care Service Corporation, AETNA, Healthspan / Healthspan Preferred, Health Alliance, Buckeye Community Health Plan Solutions, Inc., Aflac, Aetna Health, Inc., Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Florida, Inc., Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association, USF Holland, LLC, Continental Life, Good Samaritan Hospital, Aetna Medicaid Administrators LLC, Golden Rule Insurance Company, Kentucky Insurance Guaranty Association Inc. (KIGA), Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota, Inc., Aetna Better Health of Kentucky Insurance Company, Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Mississippi, A Mutual Insurance Company, FEP Service, Amerigroup Community Care Amerigroup Ohio, Inc., Aetna Better Health, Inc., Anthem Health Plans of Kentucky, Inc., Duke Energy Corporation, Duke Energy, Benefit Recovery Group, Conduent Business Services, LLC, Amerigroup of Ohio, Inc., The Rawlings Company, LLC, United Healthcare Insurance Company, Marquette National Life Insurance, United Health Group Incorporated, Healthplus HP, LLC, Allied Benefits Systems, Inc., Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Healthsmart - Cincinnati, MHBH - The Mail Handler's Benefit Plan, Blue Cross Blue Shield Healthcare Plan of Georgia, Inc., National Government Services, Inc., O'Donnell Schwartz & Anderson, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Alabama, Cigna Health Corporation, Anthem Health Plans of Virginia, Inc., Wellcare Health Insurance Company of Kentucky, Inc., Russell & Oliver, PLLC, Sheakley Unicomp, Inc., Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc., Equian, LLC, Caresource, Medical Benefits Administrators, Inc., Atlas Roofing Corp., Medical Mutual of Ohio, Molina Healthcare of Ohio, Inc., Central States Southeast & Southwest Areas Health & Welfare Fund, Corvel Corporation, John and Jane Does, Health Alliance Midwest, Inc., UMR, Inc., Rawling and Associates, PLLC, NGS American, Government Employees Health Association, Inc. (GEHA), The Christ Hospital, Inc., The Phia Group, LLC, Aetna Better Health of Ohio, Inc., Meridian Roofing Corporation (Atlas Roofing Corporation), The Carl Foundation, Aetna Better Health of Kentucky, Healthspan, Inc., Community Insurance Company doing business as Anthem, UMR, Inc. doing business as United Medical Resources, Healthplus HP, LLC doing business as Empire Bluecross and Blueshield (New York) doing business as Empire Healthchoice HMO, Inc., Health Alliance Midwest, Inc. doing business as Health Alliance, National Government Services, Inc. doing business as Administar C T Corporation System, The Carl Foundation doing business as Health Alliance, United Health Group Incorporated doing business as Optum and Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield doing business as Blue Cross and Blue Shield
Case Number:	1:2018cv00631
Filed:	September 7, 2018
Court:	US District Court for the Southern District of Ohio
Presiding Judge:	Stephanie K Bowman
Referring Judge:	Douglas R Cole
2 Judge:	Susan J Dlott
3 Judge:	Matthew W McFarland
Nature of Suit:	Insurance
Cause of Action:	28 U.S.C. § 1332 Diversity-Insurance Contract
Jury Demanded By:	Plaintiff

Access additional case information on PACER

Use the links below to access additional information about this case on the US Court's PACER system. A subscription to PACER is required.

Access this case on the Ohio Southern District Court's Electronic Court Filings (ECF) System

• Search for Party Aliases
• Associated Cases
• Attorneys
• Case File Location
• Case Summary
• Docket Report
• History/Documents
• Parties
• Related Transactions
• Check Status